Sie sind auf Seite 1von 45

REPUBLIC OF RWANDA

Ministry of Natural Resources (MINIRENA)

Integrating Climate Change Finance into


SLM Investment Strategies

Rwanda Country
Mapping

Prepared by EcoSecurities Consulting and Best Associated


Consultants (BAC)

Final Version

June 2011

Rwanda Country Mapping

This document has been produced with the financial assistance of the European
Union. The views expressed herein can in no way be taken to reflect the official
opinion of the European Union.

Page 2 of 45

Table of contents
1

Introduction ........................................................................................................ 6
1.1
Background: climate change and land degradation in Rwanda ............................... 6
1.2 Objectives .................................................................................................................... 8

Analysis of the current situation in Rwanda ................................................... 9


2.1
Policies and programmes in place to address climate change and land degradation9
2.2
Current investment flows to climate change mitigation and adaptation projects in the
agriculture, rural and land use sector ................................................................................28
2.3
Identification of opportunities and barriers to funding mitigation and adaptation
projects in Rwanda ...........................................................................................................32

Conclusions and recommendations .............................................................. 36


3.1
How to overcome the implementation barriers of mitigation and adaptation activities
relevant to the AFOLU sector in Rwanda ..........................................................................36
3.2
Where the Government of Rwanda could focus efforts to develop climate change
projects benefiting SLM ....................................................................................................38

References........................................................................................................ 43

Page 3 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

List of Acronyms
ADB/AfDB
AFOLU
BAC
BAD
CDM
DFID
DNA
EDPRS
EC
EICV
FAO
FCD
FONERWA
GHG
GEF
GoR
IDA
IFAD
IMF
ISAR
MINALOC
MINAGRI
MINECOFIN
MINELA
MINIFOM
MININFRA
MINIRENA
MINITERE
NAFA
NAP
NAPA
NGOs
NLC
ODA
OGMR
PRSP
RARDA
RADA
RAP
REMA
RHODA
SLM
SRAP
UN
UNCCD
UNICEF
UNDP

African Development Bank


Agriculture, Forestry and Landuse
Best Associated Consultants
Banque Africaine de Dveloppment
Clean Development Mechanism
Department for International Development
Designated National Authority
Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy
European Commission
Enqute Intgrale sur les Conditions de vie des Mnages
Food and Agriculture Organization
Focus Group Discussion
Fonds National de lEnvironnement au Rwanda
Greenhouse Gases
Global Environmental Facility
Government of Rwanda
International Development Agency
International Fund for Agricultural Development
International Monetary Fund
Institut des Sciences Agronomiques du Rwanda
Ministry of Local Government Community Development and Social
Affairs
Ministry of Agriculture and Animal Resources
Ministry of Economic Planning and Finance
Ministry of Environment and Land
Ministry of Forestry and Mines
Ministry of Infrastructure
Ministry of Natural Resources
Ministry of Lands, Environment, Forestry , Water and Mines
National Forestry Authority
Nation al Action Plan to combat Desertification and Land Degradation
in Rwanda
National Adaptation Programmes of Action
Non Governmental Organizations
National Land Centre
Overseas development assistance
Office de Gologie et Mines du Rwanda
Poverty Reduction Strategy Programme
Rwanda Animal Resources Development Authority
Rwanda Agricultural Development Authority
Regional Action Plan
Rwanda Environment Management Authority
Rwanda Horticulture Development Authority
Sustainable Land Management
Sub- regional Action Programme
United Nations
United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification
United Nations Childrens Fund
United Nations Development Programme
Page 4 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

UNEP
UNFCCC
USAID
USD
WB

United Nations Environment Programme


United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change
United States Agency for International Development
United States Dollars
World Bank

Page 5 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

1 Introduction
The Government of Rwanda ratified the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification
(UNCCD) in October 1998 and is elaborating its National Action Programme to Combat
Desertification (NAP), which has been validated in November 2009. In support of the future
implementation of the NAP/UNCCD, the Global Mechanism of the UNCCD and the United
Nations Development Programme (UNDP) are supporting the Government of Rwanda in the
elaboration of an Integrated Financing Strategy (IFS) for Sustainable Land Management
(SLM) in Rwanda. The IFS aims at identifying and assessing all possible sources of finance
that can strengthen NAP implementation. The present report contributes to this process by
assessing the availability of climate change finance for SLM and NAP implementation.
1.1
Background: climate change and land degradation in Rwanda
Rwanda is a small landlocked mountainous country in Central Africa, bordered by Uganda,
Tanzania, Burundi and the Democratic Republic of Congo. It extends over just 26,338 km2,
and is home to an estimated 9 million people, which makes it the most densely populated
country in Africa. Despite recently enjoying strong economic growth rates (USAID, 2008),
Rwanda ranks 152nd of 169 countries according UNDPs 2010 Human Development report
(UNDP, Human Development Report 2010. The real wealth of nations: pathways to human
development, 2010). Nearly 90% of the population relies on subsistence agriculture and the
majority of the population lives on less than USD 1.25 a day (UNDP, Human Development
Report 2010. The real wealth of nations: pathways to human development, 2010). The four
major causes of poverty in Rwanda bear a direct link with the environment. These have been
identified as follows(Ubudehe Survey,2006).

Causes

% Share of Respondents

Lack of land
Poor soils
Drought/weather
Lack of livestock

49.5
10.9
8.7
6.5

Lack of land, soil infertility and lack of livestock are a direct result of population pressure,
land degradation and soil erosions, and are further exacerbated by changing weather
conditions linked to climatic changes already being observed in the country.
1.1.1

Climate change in Rwanda

Rwanda contributes to 5, 010.4GgCO2e (UNFCCC, Emissions Summary for Rwanda, 2005,


Second National Communication) of global GHG emissions, if greenhouse gas (GHG)
emissions and removals resulting from the forestry sector are not taken into account. The
agriculture sector is the greatest contributor to these emissions (78%), followed by the
energy (17,8%), industrial processes (3%), waste (0.9%) and land use and forestry (0.2%)
sectors. The forestry sector results in a net absorption of 8545 Gg CO2e. Hence, Rwandas
overall contribution to global GHG emissions is negative at 3534.6 Gg CO2e (UNFCCC,
Emissions Summary for Rwanda, 2005, Second National Communication).

Page 6 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Despite not contributing to climate change, Rwanda is already experiencing its adverse
impacts. Average yearly temperatures have increased by 0.9C between 1971 (19.8C) and
2007 (20.7C) (REMA, 2010). Climate-related shocks like drought and flooding are becoming
more regular and are all the more severe as the majority of the population relies on smallscale agriculture and ecosystem services for their livelihoods. The Eastern and South
Eastern regions (Nyagatare, Gatsibo, Bugesera ,Kamonyi and Ruhango Districts) have been
severely affected by prolonged droughts, while the Northern and Western regions (Musanze,
Gakenke, Burera, Nyabihu, Nyaruguru and Gicumbi Districts) have been experiencing
excessive rainfall resulting in erosion, flooding and landslides (Twagiramungu, 2006). These
extreme climate events have had a devastating effect on agricultural productivity. In the 2008
harvests, for instance, the droughts destroyed just-planted seeds and in some cases delayed
planting so much that crops then became highly vulnerable to dry spells late in the season in
a way that affected their productivity (REMA, Rwanda State of Environment and Outlook,
2009).
Rwanda signed the United Nations Framework Convention to Combat Climate Change
(UNFCCC) in 1995 and the Kyoto Protocol in 2004. It ratified the UNFCCC in August 1998
and the Kyoto Protocol in February 2006.
1.1.2 Land degradation in Rwanda
Heavy soil loss is one of the key contributors to land degradation in Rwanda. About half of
Rwandas farm land has shown evidence of modest to severe erosion (REMA, Rwanda State
of Environment and Outlook, 2009). Overall the country is estimated to be losing 1.4 million
tones of soil per year. Soils are exhausted by continuous farming by farmers who have
limited, if any alternatives. Soil loss has a significant impact on the productivity of the land
and can result in farm land turning into waste land. It is estimated that about 40,000 people
every year are food insecure as a direct effect of soil erosion (REMA, Rwanda State of
Environment and Outlook, 2009).
Prevailing agricultural practices on the slopes of the hills and deforestation also result in land
degradation and soil erosion. About 40% of Rwandas land is classified as having a very high
erosion risk with about 37% requiring soil retention measures before cultivation and only
23.4% of the countrys lands not prone to erosion (FAO, Accessed Nov 2010). While it is
recommended that land areas on slopes greater than 5% need erosion control, the reality in
Rwanda is that crops are grown wherever possible, including slopes as steep as 55%. Over
86% of the agricultural land is equipped with anti-erosion techniques, such as protective
grass strips. The province with the highest anti- erosion techniques is Northern Province
leading at around 93.1%, followed by Southern Province at 92.3%, then by the Western
Province at 87.5%, Eastern at 80.06% and Kigali City comes last at 79.8%.
The lack of a human settlement development framework has also resulted in increased land
degradation. Residential areas in urban centres have expanded, with land being poorly
managed resulting in environmental degradation. Domestic and industrial energy demands
have also indirectly contributed to soil erosion and land degradation - much of the countrys
energy requirements are met by crop residues and fuel wood. The use of crop residues limits
the extent to which they can be used to conserve soil moisture and fertility. Deforestation on

Page 7 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

the other hand leads to extensive soil erosion and in some instances floods and landslides
(REMA, Rwanda State of Environment and Outlook, 2009).
Rwanda signed the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification (UNCCD) in June
1995 and ratified it in October 1998. The Convention entered into force in January 1999.
Rwanda has recently prepared its National Action Programme (NAP) under the UNCCD (see
Section 2.1.1). The NAP will form a key part to UNCCD implementation in Rwanda, and, as
explained in more detail in the following chapter, its strong inter-linkages with climate change
make it an even more useful tool towards the sustainable management of natural resources.
1.1.3 Linkages between climate change and land degradation in Rwanda
The correlation between climate change and land degradation in Rwanda is clear. Climate
change threatens marginal lands by increasing the risk of degradation and desertification.
Moreover land degradation, particularly from unsustainable agricultural and land
management practices and deforestation is a major contributor to increased atmospheric
GHG concentrations that are responsible for human-induced climate change. An increase in
extreme weather events, such as droughts and heavy rains, resulting from global warming
leads to further land degradation and this desertification process affects the climate.
A number of areas exist that offer an opportunity for a synergistic approach to tackling
climate change (mitigation and adaptation) and land degradation in Rwanda. These primarily
relate to:
Forestry (e.g. reforestation, avoided deforestation and sustainable forest
management),
Sustainable land management (SLM) and agriculture;
Sustainable rural energy provision, such as through fuel-switching and energy
efficiency at the community level, and the use of biofuels; and
Adaptation through enhancing ecosystem resilience and its capacity to adjust to
changes.
1.2 Objectives
The objectives of this report can be summarized as follows:
 Identify policies and programmes that address climate change and land degradation
in Rwanda;
 Map current investment flows to climate change mitigation and adaptation projects in
the agriculture, rural and land use sector in Rwanda;
 Identify specific opportunities and barriers to funding mitigation and adaptation
projects in Rwanda;
 Analyse how barriers to implementation of mitigation and adaptation activities can be
overcome; and
 Outline specific roles that the GM can play to help increase Rwandas access to
climate change financing.

Page 8 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

2 Analysis of the current situation in Rwanda


2.1

Policies and programmes in place to address climate change and land


degradation

2.1.1 Linkages between NAPA, NAP and EDPRS


National Adaptation Programmes of Action (NAPAs) were established by the Parties to the
UNFCCC when negotiating the adaptation funds. NAPAs provide a process for countries to
identify priority activities that respond to their urgent and immediate needs with regards to
adaptation to climate change. In their NAPAs, countries tend to focus on adaptive capacity to
climate variability. Rwanda published its NAPA in 2006.
National Action Programmes (NAP) are one of the key instruments for the implementation of
the UNCCD. They are developed in the framework of a participatory approach involving the
local communities. Rwanda has elaborated its NAP, which has been validated in November
2009 and is currently at approval stage with the Cabinet (the latest draft NAP has been
referred to in this report).
Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSP) are documents required by the International
Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank before a country can be considered for debt relief
with the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) programme. Poverty reduction papers are
prepared by the member countries through a participatory process involving domestic
stakeholders and external development partners, including the World Bank and IMF. PRSPs
describe the countrys macroeconomic, structural and social policies and programmes over a
three-year or longer period to promote broad-based growth and reduce poverty (IMF, 2010).
Rwanda published its second PRSP, which Rwanda, in agreement with the World Bank,
renamed as Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy (EDPRS), for the
period 2008 2012 in 2007. In the EDPRS, Rwanda has integrated climate change issues,
especially NAPA elements, as key aspects of the programme.
A comparison of Rwandas NAPA, NAP and EDPRS is provided in Table 1.

Page 9 of 45

Table 1: Comparison of Rwandas NAPA, NAP and EDPRS


NAPA

NAP

EDPRS

Guiding

Help Rwanda define urgent and

Contribute to the sustainable

Provide a medium-term framework

principle(s)

immediate adaptation priority activities

management of natural resources for

for achieving Rwandas long-term

to climate change in order to obtain

sustained socio-economic

development goals and

funds from GEF or other donors for

development.

aspirations.

their implementation.
Objectives

Evaluate present vulnerabilities to


climate change considering the

stakeholders and partners to ensure

socio-economic aspects and land

sustainable development and the

use that exacerbate these

rational use of natural resources;

vulnerabilities;

Identify the most vulnerable


groups of population, regions and
sectors;

Reinforce capacities of local

Objectives embodied in three


flagship programmes:

Sustainable Growth for Jobs


and Exports aims to make the

Rehabilitate all areas affected by

Rwandan business

desertification and land

environment the most

degradation;

competitive in the region,

Improve the enforcement of existing

thereby laying the foundations

Determine priority adaptation

laws and formulate new ones to

for strong private sector growth

options and define their profiles;

manage natural resources

in the future;

Select urgent and immediate


activities and projects to be
implemented.

appropriately;

Identify and adopt alternatives to


lessen natural resource
degradation.

Vision 2020 Umurenge aims


to eradicate extreme poverty by
2020;

Governance aims to improve


governance in several areas,
including maintaining peace
and security, strengthening
good relationships with all
countries, promoting unity and
reconciliation among
Rwandans, performing reforms
of the justice system. And

Page 10 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

NAPA

NAP

EDPRS
empowering citizens to
participate and own their social,
political and economic
development in respect of
rights and civil liberties.

Proposed

1. Conservation and protection of

Reinforcement of the political,

priority

lands against erosion and floods at

legislative and institutional

projects/areas

district level in vulnerable regions;

framework to favour environmental

2. Mastering hydro meteorological

protection;

information and early warning

Rational planning and use of land;

systems for control of climate

Sustainable planning and management

change hazards;
3. Realisation of round irrigation
perimeters from water flows in
vulnerable regions;
4. Assistance to districts of
vulnerable regions to plan and
implement conservation measures

of forests;
Rational management of water
resources;
Rational exploitation of mines and
quarries
Improvement in agricultural techniques
and of farming on slopes ;

and water storage;

Reinforcement of the implementation

5. Increase the capacity of

of the national programme for

adaptation of villages imidugudu


in vulnerable regions through
improvement of drinking water and
sanitation and alternative energy
services and promotion of nonagricultural activities;
6. Increase modes of food
distribution and health support to
face extreme climate phenomena;

N/A

grouped housing;
Promotion of sources of energy other
than wood;
Creation of jobs to help the fight
against poverty;
Reinforcement of the recycling
programme for domestic and
industrial waste;
International, regional and sub-regional

Page 11 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

NAPA
7. Preparation and implementation of
woody combustible substitution
national strategy to combat

NAP

EDPRS

cooperation;
Research and system for postevaluation.

deforestation and put a brake on


erosion due to climate change.
Funding

See Table 5

mechanisms

Fonds National pour lEnvironnement


au Rwanda (FONERWA) to be
established
Traditional sources of financing, e.g.

Combination of domestic tax


and non-tax revenues

Grants

External borrowing

GEF, UN organizations, NGOs, and


possibly some of the initiatives
given in Table 5.
Timelines

2007 - 2012

2009 - 2018

2008 - 2012

(project
implementation)
Source: MINITERE, 2006, MINIRENA, 2009, IMF, 2008

While Rwandas NAPA, NAP and EDPRS address different topics and have different priorities, a number of synergies can be
identified, in line with the common overarching objectives of all the three, which is to foster sustainable development in Rwanda.
These synergies include the promotion of off farm activities, support to the integrated water management system, fight against
erosion, promotion of zero grazing, increasing forest cover, effort to reduce wood deficit, developing alternative energy sources,
developing integrated information management system and support to ecosystem rehabilitation. These priorities are intended to
either help Rwandan to mitigate or adapt to effects of climate change. The NAPA, NAP and EDPRS are implemented by national
institutions under different sector policies and strategies, programmes and projects depending on their responsibilities and
mandates. Although sustainable Land Management activities in Rwanda are implemented by a number of ministries and
agencies, the Ministry of Agriculture and Animal Resources (MINAGRI) is the lead institution as it is the one mandated to handle
land issues and is responsible for the provision of strategic orientation and policy formulation in the area of SLM. Major
stakeholders involved in the SLM aspects and their respective roles are summarized in Table 2 below.

Page 12 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Table 2: Mapping of Key Stakeholders and their roles and responsibilities in SLM

Key Stakeholders
MINELA

MINAGRI

MININFRA

MINALOC

MINECOFIN

MINIFOM

REMA
RADA

Role in SLM
Prepare and ensure the follow up and evaluation of policies, strategies for rational exploitation and efficient land
management, Environment, Water Resources and evaluate their implementation
Prepare draft bills and establish norms and practices
Reinforce capacities of decentralised entities in matters of land management, Water Resources and Environment
Initiate, develop and manage suitable programs of transformation and modernization of agriculture and livestock to
ensure food security and to contribute to the national economy
Develop institutional and legal frameworks, national policies, strategies and master plans relating to transport,
energy, habitat and urbanism, meteorology, and water and sanitation subsectors
Initiate, develop and facilitate urban development programmes with a view to providing affordable shelter with due
regard to adequate water and sanitation facilities for the population and promote grouped settlement (Imidugudu)
Sensitization and involvement of decentralized structures and communities in the sustainable land management
Follow up and evaluation of the functioning of decentralised administration units and reinforcement of their
capacities
Coordination of the process of restructuring decentralised administrative units in order to improve their functioning,
synergy and their partnership with other institutions
Contribute to increase living standards of the population and human development within a sustainable
environment
Contribute to promote a fair and flexible labour market that rewards entrepreneurship and risk-taking behaviours
for economic development
Ensure an efficient and equitable tax and benefit system with incentives to work , save and invest in the
development of the country
Contribute to foster deep regional integration through openness to change as well as mobility of goods
Contribute to increase economic productivity, employment opportunities, investment climate, and quality public
investment
Prepare and ensure the follow up and evaluation of policies, strategies for rational exploitation and efficient mines
and forestry management and evaluate their implementation
Prepare draft bills and establish norms and practices
Reinforce capacities of decentralised entities in matters of mines and forestry management
Implement Government environmental policy
Advise the Government on policies, strategies and legislation related to the management of the environment as
well as the implementation of environment related international conventions
Contribute towards the growth of agricultural production through sustainable land and water management and soil
conservation
Implement the national agriculture policy

Page 13 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Key Stakeholders

RARDA

NAFA

NLC
OGMR

ISAR

IRST

Role in SLM
Coordinate farmers activities and those of other agricultural stakeholders
Contribute towards sustainable animal production
Implement the national livestock policy
Coordinate farmers activities and those of other livestock stakeholders
Implement the national Policy on forestry and agro-forestry
Advise the Government on policies, strategies and legislation related to the management of the forestry as well as
the implementation of forestry related international conventions and protection of natural resources such as land,
water and forestry biodiversity
Support organs that are in charge of fighting erosion with the aim of safeguarding forestry
Provides a policy framework for land administration
Offers a legal framework for land tenure security.
Carries out registration and land use planning
Facilitate the establishment of environmental sound norms and standards for mining sector
Implement the national mining policy and strategies
Execute the national agricultural research and promote technologies in crops, livestock, forestry, agroforestry, land
conservation and water management
Coordinate research activities in crop and animal improvement, forestry, agroforestry, land and water
management
Collaborate with national, regional and international agencies with similar mandate.
Research and generating suitable technologies in energy, environment, health society and economy fields hence
contributing to the sustainable development of Rwanda

Source: Adapted from the Official Gazettes of the Republic of Rwanda.

Although the government funds a considerable number of SLM projects, most financing is done by bilateral and multilateral
donors. The major donors to SLM Projects per sector as agreed with the GoR are summarized in Table 3.

Page 14 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Table 3: Donors funding per sector

Agriculture
Bilateral
Multilateral
Canada
EC
Japan
WB
United Kingdom
FAO (UN lead)
United States (US)
WFP
IFAD

Forestry, Land and Environment


Bilateral
Multilateral
Sweden
FAO
Belgium
UNDP (UN lead)
Germany
UNEP
UN HABITAT
WFP

Water and Sanitation


Bilateral
Multilateral
Japan
AfDB
Austria
UN HABITAT
UNICEF (UN lead)
WHO

Source: MINECOFIN, 2010

Page 15 of 45

2.1.2

Climate change mitigation and adaptation initiatives at the international


level relevant to Rwanda
A relatively large number of programs and initiatives exist that Rwanda can tap into to
improve its access to carbon markets. These include initiatives run by several funds, multilateral banks, UN agencies, NGOs and development agencies. Relevant initiatives generally
focus on project financing, policy dialogue and development, capacity building and technical
assistance, in the hope of catalyzing greater involvement in the carbon markets and
contribute to the further mitigation of GHG emissions. Presented below in Table 4 is a
summary of current initiatives and programs relevant to Rwanda with a focus on forestry,
SLM and sustainable rural energy.
Table 4: Summary of initiatives and programs relevant to Rwanda to improve its access to carbon
markets
Initiative

Description

Total size

Sectoral focus

Country focus

ACP-CD4CDM

Project aiming to
enable targeted
countries to fully
participate in the
carbon market
Facility for upfront
project financing and
capacity building

N/A

All sectors
eligible for the
carbon markets

12 African, Caribbean
and Pacific (ACP)
countries, including
Rwanda

2009 - 2011 USD


$7 million.

All sectors
eligible for the
carbon markets

Africa

Partnership for
support on policy,
public dialogue and
technical capacity
Ministerial level
authority for policy
development and
dialogue
Fund for project
financing

USD $15 million

REDD

10 COMIFAC member
1
countries

N/A

10 COMIFAC member
countries

Partnership for
information sharing
and policy dialogue
support for COMIFAC
International
organization
supporting capacity
building, policy
development and
pilot projects
Programme for
capacity building,

N/A

Sustainable
forest
management
and REDD
Forest
management,
community
livelihoods and
reduction in
rates of
deforestation
Sustainable
forest
management
and REDD
Carbon markets,
REDD

African Carbon
Asset
Development
(ACAD) Facility
Agence
Francaise de
Developpment
COMIFAC

Congo Basin
Forest Fund

Congo Basin
Forest
Partnership
GTZ

Norway
International

GBP 100 million

N/A

3 billion NOK /
year

REDD

10 COMIFAC member
countries

10 COMIFAC member
countries

Global

All countries with REDD


potential

COMIFAC member states include: Burundi, Cameroon, Congo, Central African Republic (CAR),
Gabon, Equatorial Guinea, Rwanda, Sao Tome and Principe, the Democratic Republic of Congo
(DRC) and Chad
Page 16 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Initiative

Description

Climate and
Forest Initiative

technical support,
project financing,
policy support and
research
Conservation funding,
policy support,
mapping

USAID - Central
African Regional
Program for the
Environment
(CARPE)
World Bank
BioCarbon Fund

Fund for project


financing

Total size

Sectoral focus

Country focus

N/A

Forest and
biodiversity
protection

Global

Tranche One
USD $53.8
million; Tranche
Two USD $38.1
million. Both
Tranches are
closed to new
fund participation
USD 562.1
pledged

Projects that
sequester or
conserve carbon
in forest and
agroecosystems

Global

REDD, SFM

Based on ODA
eligibility and active
MDB country
programme.
Global

World Bank
Forest
Investment
Program
WWF

Fund for project


financing

NGO focused on
capacity building,
awareness building,
policy development
and pilot projects

N/A

Forest and
biodiversity
protection,
REDD

MDG Carbon
Facility

Innovative means of
harnessing the vast
resources of the
carbon market in
order to bring longterm sustainable
development to a
more diverse share of
developing countries

N/A

Renewable
energy, energy
efficiency,
cleaner energy,
waste to energy,
fugitive emission
reductions

Global, focus on LDCs

Overall, Rwanda has access to nine initiatives and programmes aimed to increase countries
access to carbon markets2. Furthermore, there are a number of governmental and nongovernmental agencies active in Rwanda that have increased access to carbon markets as
part of their agenda. These include the AfD, COMIFAC, GTZ, USAID and WWF. While
access to carbon markets could still be improved, Rwanda is doing relatively well compared
to other African countries in terms of developing carbon project, especially when considering
its rather small geographical size.
Funding specific for adaptation to climate change activities is more recent than mitigation
funding and as such has received less attention than mitigation activities to date. Fewer
funds exist at the international level and therefore fewer opportunities to successfully finance
adaptation activities. Nonetheless, Table 5 provides an overview of initiatives that are
attempting to improve access to adaptation funding and that are relevant to Rwanda.

This may not be an exhaustive list, but certainly covers all major international mitigation funding and
support sources.
Page 17 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Table 5. Summary of adaptation initiatives relevant to Rwanda


GEF Funds

Focus Areas

Volume
pledged

Status

Eligibility

Projects funded
in sub-region

Strategic
Priority for
Adaptation
(SPA)

Biological diversity,
climate change,
international waters,
land degradation

USD
$50m

Non-Annex 1

Rwanda receiving
funding as part of a
region-wide
initiative to
integrate
vulnerability and
adaptation to
climate change into
policy planning

Least
Developed
Countries
Fund
(LDCF)

Supports
implementation of
NAPAs

USD
$180m
(receiving
additional
pledges)

As of May
2008 all
funds have
been
allocated
(21
projects).
Program to
be
evaluated
USD
$36.8m
disbursed
(12
projects).
Open for
project
ideas.

Only NonAnnex 1 LDCs

Rwanda receiving
funding for the
preparation of their
NAPA and for a
project reducing
Vulnerability to
Climate Change by
Establishing Early
Warning and
Disaster
Preparedness
Systems

Special
Climate
Change
Fund
(SCCF)

Water, land
management,
agriculture, health,
infrastructure
development, fragile
ecosystems,
integrated coastal
zone management,
disaster risk
management and
prevention
Adaptation projects
and programs in
developing countries
that are particularly
vulnerable to the
adverse effects of
climate change

USD
$90m

USD
$67.6m
disbursed
(17
projects).
Open for
project
ideas

Non-Annex 1

No projects funded
in Rwanda to date,
but Rwanda is
eligible to apply for
funding under the
SCCF

Expected
to receive
between
USD
$100
500
million by
2012
N/A

Over 5
million
CERs in
holding
account.
Not
operational
yet.
Funded 37
projects in
Africa since
April 2006.
Open for
project
ideas

Non-Annex 1

Only one project


(in Senegal) has
been approved
under the AF Fund
to date, but
Rwanda is eligible
to apply for funding
under the AF.
No projects funded
in Rwanda to date,
but Rwanda is
eligible to apply for
funding under the
CCAA.

Adaptation
Fund (AF)

Climate
Change
Adaptation
in Africa
(CCAA)

Research and
capacity
development
program aims to
significantly improve
the capacity of
African countries to
adapt to climate
change in ways that
benefit the most

Africa

Page 18 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

GEF Funds

Focus Areas

Volume
pledged

Status

Eligibility

Projects funded
in sub-region

USD
$247m
disbursed
so far in
9,500
grants.
Open for
project
ideas
N/A

Countries that
ratified both
the UNFCCC
and CBD

Three climate
change adaptation
projects funded in
Rwanda.

Low and
middle income
countries

Supported three
regional projects
including Rwanda

vulnerable
GEF Small
Grants
Programme
(SGP)

Activities of nongovernmental and


community-based
organizations in
developing countries
in five focal areas
including adaptation

N/A

Global
Facility for
Disaster
Reduction
and
Recovery
(GFDRR)

Improve the ability of


low and middle
income countries to
respond and manage
disaster reduction
and recovery,
including adapting to
climate change

N/A

Overall, Rwanda has access to seven international adaptation initiatives3. Thanks to these
initiatives, Rwanda has so far been able to implement nine adaptation projects, of which four
are regional projects that also include Rwanda, one involved the development of Rwandas
NAPA and the remaining four address specific identified adaptation needs of the country.
Other sources of climate change adaptation funding that may become increasingly important
in the future include:
- Fast Start Fund established in the Copenhagen Accord and which has been adopted
in the Cancun Agreements, (USD 30 Billion from 2010 t0 2012 and USD 100 Billion
from now to 2020);
- Japanese African Adaptation Fund;
- Global Climate change Green Fund established by the UNFCCC COP and the
outcome of Cancun;
- Climate Change Green Fund for Africa established by AfDB.
2.1.3

Climate change mitigation and adaptation initiatives at the national level


in Rwanda

Rwanda has put in place a number of instruments that can be exploited to mitigate and adapt
to the effects of climate change. These instruments are categorized as either legal,
policy/strategy, institutional or programmes/projects.

This may not be an exhaustive list, but it covers all major international adaptation funding sources.
Page 19 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Rwandas legal, policy/ strategy and institutional frameworks as well as


programmes/projects to climate change
Mitigation and Adaptation initiatives to climate change in Rwanda under legal, policy,
strategy and institutional frameworks contain provisions or give orientations that compel
various institutions to implement activities that translate into adaptation and mitigation to
climate change. These frameworks are summarized in Table 46.
Table 6. Summary of key legal, policy and institutional mitigation and adaptation
initiatives to climate change in Rwanda
Initiatives
Legal framework

Policy/strategy
instruments

Nature
Article 49 of Rwandan Constitution obliges both the Government and
Citizens to protect the environment.
The organic law on environment (law No4/2005) aims at protection,
conservation and sustainable management of the environment for welfare
of the population
The Land Law set guidelines that ensure sustainable land management
The Law on forestry protection calls for protection and conservation of
forests and sets punishments for people found destroying the forests.
Rwanda committed itself to the protection of environment internationally by
signing and ratifying International conventions namely the United Nations
Framework Convention on Climate Change, the KYOTO Protocol to the
Framework Convention on Climate change, Convention on persistent
organic pollutants, International Convention on the establishment of
international procedures agreed by states on commercial transactions of
agricultural pesticides and other poisonous products, Convention on the
Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous wastes and their
disposal , International Convention on Biological Diversity and its Habitat,
International Convention on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer,
Biosafety to the Convention of Biological Biodiversity, International
Convention on Wetlands of International importance, especially as water
flow habitats and Convention on International Trade in endangered
species
Both Vision 2020 and Economic Development and Poverty Reduction
Strategy (EDPRS) priorities sustainable development, environment
protection and proper natural resource management through
Reducing the use of wood energy and improving energy efficiency
Promoting soil conservation and restoration of soil fertility
Liming of acid soils to reduce nitrogen emission into the air.
Reducing methane emissions into air through good livestock
practices
Increasing carbon sequestration on farmlands through better
management of residues and rehabilitation of degraded hillside
soils as well as practicing agro forestry.
Conserving critical ecosystems and maintain the functioning of
Page 20 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Institutional
framework
smooth
coordination
environmental
issues/climate
change

for
of

forests and trees in the environment particularly in water catchment


areas.
Encouraging private sector by giving incentives for private
investment
in low carbon project(Low carbon policy,
implementation strategy and guidelines)
Optimum utilization, awareness raising and ensuring populations
participation in environmental activities
Mainstreaming climate change adaptation and mitigation into
national policies and strategies(NAPA has already been
mainstreamed in Economic Development and Poverty Reduction
strategy)
Each of the above areas that facilitate adaptation and mitigation to
effects of climate change has an institution(s) responsible for
coordination, oversight and synergy; REMA-Environment(DNA),
Rwanda Natural Resource Board-Land, Water, Forestry and Mines,
Rwanda Agricultural Board-Agriculture and Livestock , ISAR and
IRST-Research
Within REMA, a directorate for climate change has been created
and is operational

Programmes/Projects
The Government of Rwanda has initiated a number of programmes aimed at helping the
country and its citizens to mitigate and adapt to the effects of climate change. These
programmes/projects are summarized in Table 57 below.
Table 7. Programmes related to mitigation and adaptation to climate change and their
budget in Rwanda
Ministry Responsible

Programmme

Budget (frws)

Source
budget

Ministry of Infrastructure

Diversification of energy sources and

1.674 bn

supply security
Ministry of Environment and

Lands

Land

Planning,

Budget
Management

and

2.03 bn

Administration
Water Resources Management;

1.87bn

Ministry of Agriculture and

Irrigation Development

4.25bn

Animal Resources

Promotion of Research for Development

Soil Conservation and Soil Erosion control;

Forestation, and Reforestation

Development
Budget

0.70 bn
Development

Mines
Ministry

Development
Budget

Ministry of Forestry and

Development

Budget
of

Disaster

Management and Refugees

Risks and Disaster management;

0.08 bn

Recurrent
Budget

Source: REMA, 2010

Page 21 of 45

of

Rwanda Country Mapping

The above programmes have a number of projects that are currently under implementation.
Some of these projects are funded internally by the Government under the Development
Budget while others are financed externally by development partners.
Projects
In addition to putting in place legal, policy, strategy, and institutional instruments as well as
programmes and projects to mitigate and adapt to the effects of climate change, Rwanda has
also commissioned a number of projects. These projects include studies that were conducted
to assess the current status with respect to climate change, such as the first and second
national communications on the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change
(UNFCCC), the National Adaptation Programme of Action and the Study on the Economic
Cost of Climate Change in Rwanda.
Other projects including their budget size and source are summarized in Table 8, 9 and 10.
Table 8: Environmental /Forest /Land Use Projects (Million)
Project Name

Sources of

2007

2008

funding
Detailed

Studies

on

Nyabarongo

Rwanda

167

South Korea

Gestion Intgre des Ressources En Eau

Rwanda

70

DEMP:

Pays Bas

414

Environment

2009/10

Closing

budget 2009

Management

Decentralized

Mini

date

27
282

Management Project Phase I


DEMP: Phase II

UNDP

250

RWANDA
IMCE: Integrated Protection and

IDA

Management Of Critical Ecosystems

IDA/GEF
Rwanda

Restauration de la Biodiversit des Aires

42
441

732

125

1,140

500
80

50

425

98

GEF

570

Projet d'Appui l'Amnagement des

BAD

558

1,175

1,861

Forets

Rwanda

193

158

126

Technical Support to Land Reform In

DFID

393

Rwanda

600

690

1,015

237

244

450

378

Protges

Rwanda
Schma Directeur d'Utilisation des Terres

700

SDUTA
Rainwater Collection and Use

Rehabilitation and Protection of River

BAD

63

FAO

359

Rwanda

25

Rwanda

910

GEF

295

Banks and Lakes Shore


Reinserting

Biodiversity

In

Protected

Areas
Control of Major Rivers (Yanze, Cyunyu,

Rwanda

2013

Page 22 of 45

2010

Rwanda Country Mapping

Project Name

Sources of

2007

2008

funding

Mini

2009/10

Closing

budget 2009

date

Sebeya, Kadahokwa, Rugeramigozi)


Etude de la Nappe Phratique

Rwanda

264

75

Fight Water Hyacinth

Rwanda

216

116

Ground Water Project

LWI

300

700

Rwanda

60

200

Rwanda

875

1,015

2012

Land Management
Programme d'Appui la Reforestation

Belgique

850

2,021

2012

Protected Areas Project

GEF

400

551

2012

Rwanda

200

Rwanda

362

Rehabilitation of Hydrological Stations


National Youth and Environment Project

Rwanda

88

UNDP
Poverty Environment Initiative
Total

UN HABITAT

175

624
958
3,486

3,443

7,287

10, 453

Page 23 of 45

2011

Rwanda Country Mapping

Table 9: Agricultural /Land Use Projects (Million)


Projects

Sources of

2007

2008

funding

Mini budget

2009/10

2009

date

Bugesera Rural Development Project

Luxembourg

816

2,001

Irrigation and hill side protection

Rwanda

400

400,

One Cow Per Family

Rwanda

500

PADAB : Projet D'Appui au Dveloppement

BAD

180

Agricole de Bugesera

Rwanda

Irrigation Master plan

Rwanda

RSSP: Rural Sector Support Project (Phase

IDA

II)

Rwanda

305

FIDA

343

196

273

DIFD

376

95

25

281

FIDA

282

286

159

1,918

Rwanda

110

78

132

32

400

280

2,157

2,477

PAIGELAC:

Project

for

Integrated

management of inland lakes

Closing

223

319

1,199

1,000

1,302

2015

1,540

694

468

2012

117

112

600

180

240

1,042

830

1,032

280
2012

225
2011

Rwanda
Population

PAPSTA: Project for support to

Strategic

Plan for Agriculture Transformation

Gashora Swamp Reclamation

Rwanda

KWAMP: Kirehe Watershed Management

FIDA

Project

Rwanda

500

220

LWH : Land Husbandry Hillside Irrigation and

Rwanda

500

1,875

Water Harvesting
Nasho Irrigation Project
TOTAL

175
4,953

6,924

7,673

12,778

Page 24 of 45

2013

2016

2014

Rwanda Country Mapping

Table 10: Energy Project


2007
Projects

2008

Mini budget

2009/10

Donors
2009

Biomass: Project for substitution of fuel e and wood

Rwanda

300

energy
Expand Meteorological Stations Network (Synoptic,

Rwanda

58

Rwanda

397

Rwanda

332

Agromet, H
Project To Substitute Wood and Wood Coal:
Family Biogaz
Project To Substitute Wood and Wood Coal:
Improved Stoves
Strategic Study On Energy Efficiency

150

150

Rwanda

50

50

Pays Bas

275

100

Rwanda

300

Design and adoption of a Regulatory Framework

GEF

100

800

on Renewable and Substitution Energies

Rwanda

150

100

Project: Substitution Of Wood/ Coal : Household

Pays Bas

277

854

Biogas

Rwanda

301

633

Construction of rain water Collection system on the

Rwanda

Strategic Study/Renewable Energies

GEF

276

public Buildings
District Forests Management (MINALOC)
Total

Rwanda

929
300

787

2,532

2,963

Source: RADA/SLM Project, 2010


The above projects aim at enabling the Rwandese population to adapt to and mitigate the
effects to climate change. The nature and extent of adaptation and mitigation depends of the
project. For example the soil conservation project though radical and progressive terraces
currently under implementation throughout the country has supported farmers to adapt to the
effects of climate change by increasing agricultural production through enabling them to have
enough reservoirs even in case of extreme events such as drought or heavy rains.
Most of the projects listed in the tables above go beyond 2010 and can serve as entry points
for developing other synergistic projects on SLM and climate change. Some of these projects
include: Land husbandry, Hillside irrigation and Water harvesting, One Cow per poor family,
Land Management, Kirehe Community based watershed Management, Support to
reforestation Programme/Programme dappui la Reforestation and Agricultural
Development Support to Bugesera Project (PADAB). Experience shows that the above
projects are likely to go beyond the initial closing dates as most of them are in their first or
pilot phase and there is high potential for financing climate change activities in Rwanda in the
next 5 years.
However, there is need for coordination and creation of synergies for the realisation of
greater impact. When looking at the various projects under implementation, it can be noted
that some activities are duplicated with limited linkages or synergies among them. There is
therefore a need to create a national task force in charge of preparing CC/SLM projects to
Page 25 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

give them more focus and avoid duplication. The task force could develop a coordination
mechanism that describes who does what in order to share information and experience as
well as create synergy among CC/SLM projects. It could also ensure that CC/SLM
stakeholders are supported to elaborate competitive CC/SLM projects to attract potential
donors. During the validation workshop for the present study, which was held from 18 to 20
May 2011, the participants recommended to start with the following projects:
Agroforestry and silvo-pastoral system: This project aims at supporting mitigation
initiatives.The project has been chosen because of land scarcity in Rwanda that would
not allow any meaningful afforestation project. This project is expected to benefit many
farmers because its activities will be carried out in their farms.
Promotion of sustainable crop and animal husbandry techniques: This will support
farmers to adapt to the effects of climate change. Some activities under this project such
as drought resistant crops varieties, soil erosion control, fodder production and
conservation will reduce farmers vulnerability due to effects of climate change.
Figure 1: Radical terracing in Rubaya Sector, Gicumbi District, Northern Province

Photo credit: BAC


Similarly proper livestock management such as zero grazing being taught to farmers in
Rwanda is expected to improve efficient feed utilization hence increasing their capacity to
survive the effects of climate change. It is also expected to reduce accelerating climate
change by decreasing the emission of methane gas into the air.

Page 26 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Figure 2: Zero Grazing in Mukamira Sector, Nyabihu District of Western Province

Photo Credit: BAC


The current efforts to diversify into alternative sources of sufficient energy as well as their
efficient utilisation are aimed at reducing the use of combustible energy hence decreasing
the emission of green house gases into the air and mitigate effects of climate change. The
utilisation of alternative energy source is also expected to reduce burden on forest allowing
them to increase carbon sequestration.
Figure 3: Biogas unit in Nyabihu District and Mini Hydro power station in Burera District respectively

Photo credit: BAC

Photo credit: BAC

Similarly the plantation of forests for regeneration of natural forestry, agro-forestry, biodiesel
forestry as well as high income forestry activities are being implemented in Rwanda to
increase significant quantity of carbon sequestration hence reducing emission of green
gases into the atmosphere.

Page 27 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Figure 4: Reafforestation of in Bugesera District, Eastern Province

Photo Credit: BAC


2.2
Current investment flows to climate change mitigation and adaptation
projects in the agriculture, rural and land use sector
2.2.1

Carbon projects relevant to the agriculture, rural (energy), forestry and land
use sector under development in Rwanda
CDM projects currently under development in Rwanda are summarized in Table 11 below.
Table 11: CDM projects under development in Rwanda

CDM

Rwanda Electrogaz Compact

4472

Fluorescent Lamp (CFL)


distribution Project

EE households

Registered

24,000

At validation

6,000

At validation

6,000

Letter of Non

40,000

Objection

60,000 for the

granted 29 Apr

programme

Lighting

CDM

Rwanda Natural Energy

Solar Solar PV water

5786

Project: Water Treatment

disinfection

Systems for Rural Rwanda


(Shyra and Fawe)

CDM

Rwanda Natural Energy

Solar Solar PV water

5788

Project: Water Treatment

disinfection

Systems for Rural Rwanda


(Mugonero Esepan,
Rwesero, Nyagasambu)
n.a.

D-light rural lighting


programme (PoA)

Renewable energy

http://cdm.unfccc.int/Projects/DB/AENOR1265819671.65/view
http://www.rema.gov.rw/dna/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=72:water-treatmentsystems-for-rural-rwanda-shyira-and-fawe&catid=47:project-listes&Itemid=64
6
http://www.rema.gov.rw/dna/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=74:rwanda-naturalenergy-project-water-treatment-systems-for-rural-rwanda-mugonero-esepan-rweseronyagasambu&catid=47:project-listes&Itemid=64
7
http://www.rema.gov.rw/dna/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=83:d-light-rurallighting-program&catid=47:project-listes&Itemid=64
5

Page 28 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

2010. PDD
writing ongoing
N/A

NURU Design Lighting

Fossil fuel switch (LED

Programme

Conceptual

N/A

Conceptual

55,250

lights charged by a
stationary bicycle)

N/A

Rwanda 19.95MW Small and


Micro Hydro Project Bundle

Hydro

Voluntary carbon projects currently under development in Rwanda are summarized in Table
6 below.
Table 6: Voluntary carbon projects under development in Rwanda

Standard

Project title

Technology used

Status

Emission
reductions
(tCO2e/yr)

Gold
Standard
Plan
Vivo
Tbd

PiSAT Solar K-Light Project


in Rwanda

Solar PV

Listed

4,993

Reforestation

N/A

N/A

Renewable energy,

Conceptual

48,000

10

Clinton Foundation forestry


11

project

Rwanda National Biogas


12

Programme

methane avoidance

http://www.rema.gov.rw/dna/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=80:nuru-designlighting-programme-&catid=47:project-listes&Itemid=64
9
http://www.rema.gov.rw/dna/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=75:rwanda-1995mwsmall-and-micro-hydro-project-bundle&catid=47:project-listes&Itemid=64
10
http://www.viabilityllc.com/pisat-solar-carbon-project.html
11
http://www.rema.gov.rw/dna/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=82:clinton-foundationforestry-project&catid=47:project-listes&Itemid=64
12
http://www.rema.gov.rw/dna/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=77:rwanda-nationalbiogas-programme&catid=47:project-listes&Itemid=64
Page 29 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

2.2.2

Adaptation projects relevant to the agriculture, rural (energy), forestry


and land use sector
A list of adaptation projects being developed and/or implemented in Rwanda at present is
provided in Table 73.
Table 73: Adaptation projects underway in Rwanda

Name

Initiative

Budget

Status

USD 195,000 (GEF

IA approved

under which
funded
Enabling Activities to Facilitate the

LDCF

Preparation of a National
Adaptation Plan of Action (NAPA)

grant)
13

Reducing Vulnerability to Climate

LDCF

USD 3,160,000 (GEF

CEO endorsed

grant) + USD

Change by Establishing Early

3,300,000 (Co-

Warning and Disaster

financing)

Preparedness Systems and Support


for Integrated Watershed
Management in Flood Prone
Areas

14

Projet de construction de 160

GEF Small

citernes d'eau destins la collecte

Grants

des eaux de pluie et la protection

Programme

USD 50,000

Satisfactorily completed

USD 47,290

Satisfactorily completed

USD 24,000

Under execution

de l'environnement dans
l'agglomration de MUSIGASecteur KANOMBE

15

Production of solid fuel briquettes


from municipal waste

16

GEF Small
Grants
Programme

Project de biogaz lcole Stella


Matutina

17

GEF Small
Grants
Programme

13

http://gefonline.org/projectDetailsSQL.cfm?projID=2484
http://gefonline.org/projectDetailsSQL.cfm?projID=3838
15
http://sgp.undp.org/web/projects/13616/projet_de_construction_de_160_citernes_d_eau_destines_a
_la_collecte_des_eaux_de_pluie_et_a_la_protec.html
16
http://sgp.undp.org/web/projects/13636/production_of_solid_fuel_briquettes_from_municipal_waste.
html
17
http://sgp.undp.org/web/projects/14806/project_de_biogaz_a_lecole_stella_matutina.html
14

Page 30 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Name

Initiative

Budget

Status

Under implementation

under which
funded
Integrating vulnerability and

Strategic

USD 1,000,000 (GEF

adaptation to climate change into

Priority on

grant) + USD

sustainable development policy

Adaptation

planning and implementation in

1,265,000 (Cofinancing) (split

18

Southern and Eastern Africa

among five countries,


namely Kenya,
Madagascar,
Mozambique,
Rwanda and
Tanzania)

Pilot project on reducing the


vulnerability of the energy sector to
the impacts of climate change in
Rwanda

19

UNEP, GEF

USD 313,333 (+

and

contributions from the

Government

Government of

of the

Rwanda, tbd)

Under implementation

Netherlands

Source: REMA, 2010


2.2.3

ODA funding or national funding channelled specifically into mitigation


and adaptation activities relevant to the agriculture, rural (energy), forestry
and land use sector
While the proportion of the Rwandan national budget allocated to the environment is still
small (1.15% of overall country budget), it has increased significantly from 2003, when it
constituted less than 0.1% of the overall country budget, at 0.06%. Moving forward, it is
expected that the share of environment, land and forestry will not exceed 1.8% cent of the
total expenditure and not 4.9% in the Capital Development and Productive Sectors
expenditure (REMA, 2009).
In 2005, the overall aid directed to environmental protection in Rwanda constituted only 1%
of the total overseas development assistance (ODA) disbursed in that year. However, due to
its cross-cutting nature, some funds from health (12%), energy (2%), agriculture (4%) and
water and sanitation (3%) may have contributed to environment management.

18

http://www.adaptationlearning.net/project/integrating-vulnerability-and-adaptation-climate-changesustainable-development-policy-plann
19
http://www.iisd.org/pdf/2007/workshop_reducing_vulnerability.pdf
Page 31 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Figure 5: Sectoral distribution of ODA in Rwanda in 2005 (REMA, 2009)

2.3

Identification of opportunities and barriers to funding mitigation and


adaptation projects in Rwanda

2.3.1 Identification of opportunities


Rwanda holds significant opportunities to host GHG mitigation projects. As for adaptation,
there are notable overlaps between carbon market project opportunities, and measures that
help to combat land-degradation and desertification. Opportunities for dual mitigation and
adaptation projects in Rwanda with UNCCD relevance are as follows:

AFOLU - In Rwanda, the key area with mitigation and adaptation potential includes
the entire array of activities that fall under the wider AFOLU category. Activities in this
category offer a high potential for synergies between combating climate change and
land degradation and desertification. Specific opportunities in Rwanda related to the
AFOLU sector include (REMA, 2010):
o Restoring and protecting natural forests;
o Afforestation and reforestation activities (Vision 2020 foresees an increase of
forest cover of up to 30% by 2020, compared to forest cover of 21% today):
 Planting bamboo in protected humid areas;
 Planting eucalyptus on hilly sloped that cannot be used for agriculture;
 Planting Grevilla robusta and other tree species for wood provision.
o Intensification of agroforestry practices;
o Sustainable forest management and conservation.

Rural energy provision is another key area for mainly mitigation activities and for a
synergistic approach between the UNFCCC and UNCCD. Specific opportunities in
Rwanda related to the rural energy sector include (REMA, 2010):
o Increase the share of renewable energy;
o Introduction of efficient charcoal burning and carbonisation;
o Increase use of biogas from 5% to 70% in rural households with access to
electricity, and from 0.5% to 60% in rural households without access to
electricity;
o Replacement of traditional lightbulbs with energy efficient ones;
Page 32 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Introduction of fuel efficient cooking stoves resulting in a reduction of the fuel


wood needed for cooking of in between 50% and 75%.

These activities have been identified as priority areas by a document currently being
prepared by the Rwandan Government (REMA, 2010). An implementation plan still needs to
be disclosed.
2.3.2 Identification of barriers and constraints
It is apparent that despite the numerous options for mitigating GHGs and adapting to climate
change in Rwanda, projects face a range of barriers that prevent both private and public
sector actors from participating within the carbon markets or from seeking adaptation
funding. Barriers and constraints can be summarized as follows:

Mitigation Project Barriers (and the CDM framework):


Limited scope for projects in the land-use sector The land-use sector
(agriculture and forestry) bears a high potential in terms of climate change mitigation
while contributing to sustainable land management in Rwanda. However, markets for
projects in this sector are limited. Avoided deforestation and soil-carbon sequestration
projects have been specifically excluded from the CDM as a project category, while
afforestation and reforestation projects have suffered from complicated
methodological procedures and a limited demand for forestry specific credits due to
the largest active carbon market, the European Union Emission Trading Scheme (EU
ETS), banning the use of forestry credits to meet compliance targets. Despite the
limitation of low greenhouse gas emission levels, Rwanda has taken steps to develop
in a green manner with a target of 90% of energy expected to be from renewable
sources and 246,000 ha of forest allocated for carbon credits thus providing a fertile
environment for many carbon credit eligible projects. So far currently one CDM
project, called the Rwanda Electrogaz Compact Fluorescent Lamp (CFL) distribution
Project, has been registered and numerous others are in the pipeline, especially in
the fields of energy and forestry.

Lack of industrial development The CDM has a strong bias towards large,
industrial, point-source projects with the potential to generate substantial emission
reductions. These projects have proven to be the most profitable and successful of
CDM projects to date largely due to their considerable economies of scale. Despite its
recent economic boom, Rwandas industrial development remains limited, resulting in
limited opportunities to develop CDM projects.

Low grid emission factor 56% of electricity in Rwanda is produced in hydropower


stations, while the remaining is produced through thermal power stations (REMA,
2010). This has resulted in a relatively low national grid emission factor (approx 0.7
tCO2e/MWH (calculated from (REMA, Accessed Nov 2010)) compared to other
countries that use primarily fossil fuels. This means that projects that displace the use
of grid electricity in Rwanda (e.g. energy efficiency, renewables) are credited with
fewer emission reductions than in other countries with dirtier power generation, thus
making the project less viable.

Page 33 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

High transaction costs CDM projects incur substantial upfront development


transaction costs that may be prohibitive for the scale of mitigation projects possible
in Rwanda. High initial transaction costs would need to be covered by a substantial
revenue stream from the sale of carbon credits, which may not always be the case in
Rwanda. Although small-scale projects benefit from reduced eligibility requirements
under the CDM, in reality it has been found that small-scale projects incur similar
overall transaction costs to large-scale projects, making their project viability more
challenging. A lack of initial capital available to cover these transaction costs, from
project developers or local finance institutions, further reduces the potential to
develop these projects under the CDM.

Adaptation Project Barriers


o Information and capacity While the adverse impacts of climate change have been
documented in Rwanda (see for example (REMA, Accessed Nov 2010) and (Ministry
of Lands Environment Forestry Water and Mines, 2006), its manifold impact on the
ecosystems is not yet clear. In order to better determine the challenges of adapting to
climate change, and to allow stakeholders to make educated decisions, information
on climate systems and their variability is required. This uncertainty of climate
change projections and variability makes it difficult to determine the appropriate
adaptation measures (IDS, 2006). Furthermore, while a number of funds and facilities
to sponsor climate change adaptation exist, the level of awareness about their
potential is still low and there is limited know-how about how to apply for the funding
that they make available.
o

Socio-economic country situation Non-climatic stresses associated with the low


development level of Rwanda increase the countrys vulnerability to climate change.
They do so by reducing the countrys resilience and its adaptive capacity because
resources need to be deployed to competing needs (Adger, et al., 2007).

Financial situation - Rwanda is ranked among the least developed countries and as
such is an inherently poor nation. This has meant that historically it has only been
possible to allocate limited funding to the environment (refer to Section 2.2.3). The
Rwandan Government has recognised that environmental degradation is a key
aspect of the countrys low development and vulnerability profile and is supporting
environmental sustainability, however the amount of funding that the Government is
able to allocate to climate change adaptation is still very limited. For climate change
adaptation to be implemented in Rwanda, it will therefore be necessary that sufficient
funds are made available by the developed world.

Channelling adaptation funding Even when funding for adaptation is available,


one of the main barriers is appropriate channelling of the funds to potential projects.
This is a significant problem given the broad spectrum of activities that may be
affected by climate change, as well as the diverse locations and stakeholders
worldwide. Rwanda is in urgent need of accessing adaptation financing. This would
be greatly facilitated by a more straightforward and transparent means of access to
funding sources and through enhanced information and capacity on how to apply for
the funding available from different bodies (many of the adaptation funds currently
Page 34 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

available have come under scrutiny due to a lack of transparency in the way they are
administered and how their funds are disbursed).
o

Harmonisation of adaptation activities


Similar activities within NAPA, NAP and EDPRS priorities should be identified to
create synergies. Promotion of off farm activities, integrated water management
system, zero grazing, fight against erosion, increasing forest cover, make an effort to
reduce wood deficit, develop alternative energy sources, develop integrated
information management system and support ecosystem rehabilitation are common
activities to all the three strategies and should be exploited for the development of
SLM.

Page 35 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

3 Conclusions and recommendations


3.1

How to overcome the implementation barriers of mitigation and adaptation


activities relevant to the AFOLU sector in Rwanda

3.1.1 Overcoming barriers specific to mitigation


Barriers associated with the limited scope for land use sector projects
These can be overcome by GoR negotiating with the AFOLU financing institutions to ensure
that:
 The scope for AFOLU projects in an international climate change agreement is
enlarged to include more land-use type activities;
 The rules and procedures governing the AFOLU sector are simplified;
 Pilot projects are developed for the voluntary market to build experience and learn
lessons that can be applied in the future to projects developed under a compliance
regime.
Barriers associated with the lack of industrial development and the low grid emission
factor
These barriers can be overcome by GoR negotiating in the international climate change
arena to ensure that:
 The CDM is reformed in a way that does not favour industrialtype projects and offers
more scope for small-scale activities;
 CDM reforms address the issue of accounting for emission reductions that displace
off-grid emissions.
High transaction costs barriers can be overcome by Rwanda negotiating in the
international climate change arena to ensure that:
 Further simplified procedures are adopted for small-scale projects, implying lower
transaction costs;
 The Programme of Activities (PoA) a CDM mechanism designed to allow for the
bundling of smaller projects under one umbrella program is further simplified
providing another avenue through which projects in the sub-region can access carbon
finance.
3.1.2 Overcoming barriers specific to adaptation
Information and capacity barriers
It is recommended that
 A centre of excellence for climate change research is established in Rwanda and that
the government engages more actively with the scientific community (nationally and
internationally) to gain better information;
 The information needs of different stakeholders and the best way to communicate
with them is carefully considered when sharing relevant information with them;
 A broad range of stakeholders is involved in climate change policy-making so as to
ensure that climate change adaptation is informed by successful ground-level
experiences in vulnerability reduction. Major stakeholders include MINELA,
MINAGRI, MININFRA MINALOC, MINECOFIN, MINIFOM, REMA, RADA, RARDA,
NAFA, NLC, OGMR and ISAR

Page 36 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

 Although sustainable Land Management activities in Rwanda are implemented by a


number of ministries and agencies, the ministry of Agriculture and Animal Resources
(MINAGRI) is the lead institution as it is the one mandated to handle SLM issues.
This is why it is the one currently supervising SLM project. The ministries are mainly
responsible for policy and strategic orientation and formulation while the agencies
carry out implementation
 A centralized information hub on funding sources for adaptation is developed, and the
capacity of relevant stakeholders on how to apply for adaptation funding is
improved/built through dedicated information/training sessions.
Barriers associated with the socio-economic situation of the country
Overcoming the above barriers requires that
 Climate change facilitation measures are included in a package of positive incentives
to tackle the root of the socio-economic problems that Rwanda faces;
 The discussion on the possibility of linking the need for climate change adaptation
money (in a way, a climate debt that the developed world has with the developing
world) with the larger debt relief debate is taken further.
Financial barriers
The above barriers can be overcome by GoR negotiating in the international climate change
arena to ensure that:
 The funding generated is adequate (i.e. at least in the tens of billions of dollars per
year);
 The funding generated is predictable (i.e. have steady flows of revenues, that can be
estimated in advance);
 The funding generated is additional (i.e. it should come over and above current ODA
commitments) (Decision 1/CP.13. Bali Action Plan, 2007);
 Several of the most promising mechanisms to overcome the present adaptation
funding gap are further developed and deployed (Bapna & McGray, 2008), as it is
unlikely that a single mechanism will be able to meet all these criteria.
Access to adaptation funding barriers to overcome access to adaptation funding
barriers, it is recommended that:
Capacity is built and accurate information is disseminated among adaptation policy
makers and project proponents to empower them to use the mechanisms available as
far as possible.
The following projects Land husbandry, Hillside irrigation and Water harvesting, One
Cow per poor family, Land Management, Kirehe Community based watershed
Management, Support to reforestation Programme/Programme dappui la
Reforestation and Agricultural Development Support to Bugesera Project (PADAB go
beyond 2010 and these can serve as entry point for new projects that link SLMand
Climate Change.

Nationally Appropriate Mitigation Actions (NAMAs) a potential way to finance mitigation and
adaptation in Rwanda post-2012
The Bali Action Plan introduced the concept of nationally appropriate mitigation actions by
developing countries in the context of sustainable development, supported and enabled by
technology, financing and capacity building, in a measurable, reportable and verifiable
Page 37 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

manner.
While an exact definition of what NAMAs are and what they entail is still outstanding, they
can broadly be categorized into three types:
I.
Unilateral NAMAs, which include mitigation actions undertaken by developing
countries on their own;
II.
Supported NAMAs, where mitigation actions in developing countries are supported by
direct climate finance from Annex I countries;
III.
Credited NAMAs, where mitigation actions in developing countries generate credits to
be sold on the carbon markets (e.g. sectoral crediting).
While negotiations on NAMAs are still fairly vague and generalized, making it hard to
understand the concrete implementation issues surround them, NAMAs (particularly
Supported NAMAs and Credited NAMAs) could play a positive role in generating funds for
mitigation activities in Least Developed Countries (LDCs) in general and Rwanda in
particular. NAMAs (Credited NAMAs in particular) could potentially also make a positive
contribution to adaptation as a certain share of proceeds from the NAMA credits could be set
aside to support adaptation (in a similar way to the functioning of the CDM).

3.2

Where the Government of Rwanda could focus efforts to develop climate


change projects benefiting SLM
In order to help develop climate change mitigation and adaptation projects in Rwanda, the
Government of Rwanda could focus on the following:

Support capacity building and awareness raising efforts in Rwanda:


 Support the in-country mapping of AFOLU activities, and conduct a gap analyses to
support the preparation and implementation of concrete capacity building and pilot
activities. This could include assisting with awareness raising campaigns that inform
relevant national UNCCD stakeholders about the outcomes and the relevance of the
negotiations on AFOLU;
 Partner or join forces with donors/development partners with regard to the provision
and implementation of awareness raising, capacity building and technical support
campaigns, including through the provision of co-funding;
 Raise in-country awareness and capacity with other development partners on the
technical aspects and requirements of various adaptation funding sources, including
the Adaptation Fund.

Carefully prepare for negotiations in the international climate change arena:


 Support the political and technical discussions on AFOLU within Rwanda through the
provision of underlying analyses with regards to the potential and options for the best
possible inclusion of AFOLU relevant activities in a post-2012 agreement to allow
Rwanda to benefit from increased climate change financing;
 Gather information on the necessary CDM reforms that will promote Rwandas
access to climate change financing.

Page 38 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Provide technical assistance for the development and implementation of mitigation and
adaptation projects:
 Collaborate with development partners to jointly identify and promote carbon market
opportunities in Rwanda through the provision of technical expertise with regards to
mobilizing resources and raising funding;
 Support the funding of identified project or program opportunities through assistance
with preparing relevant proposals, preparing sales contracts and finding interested
buyers and/or investors;
 In collaboration with other development partners provide technical assistance to
projects and programs in the elaboration of adaptation funding proposals.
 A task force should be established that would be in charge of preparing CC/SLM
projects;
 Efforts should be made by CC/SLM actors to elaborate competitive CC/SLM projects
to attract potential donors;
 Coordination mechanisms describing who is doing what in order to share information
and experience should be established as well as create synergy among CC/SLM
programmes and projects.

Support and encourage decentralised entities and local communities to plan and own
CC/SLM initiatives
 Operationnalise Kigali Declaration on Climate Change by Local Governments
of 27November 2009
 Plan and evaluate climate change initiatives in annual Districts performances
contracts
 Encourage and support local communities to implement climate change
activities at family level.

Page 39 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

The proposed road map for integrating climate change financing into SLM financing in
Rwanda involves carrying out activities as well as a number of studies aimed at creating an
enabling policy environment with respect to climate change in Rwanda. It will also involve a
step by step process leading to the development of two pilot projects (one on adaptation and
another on mitigation) that would provide practical experience that will in future guide the
development of a bigger project on climate change. The road map is as follows
1. Fast truck and lobby for approval of NAP and make it dynamic
2. Carry out a study to streamline institutional framework for effective and efficient
coordination of climate change in Rwanda( formation of a task force, its roles and
responsibilities, its location, involvement of all stakeholders etc)
3. Carry out a study detailing climate change activities, their location and magnitude,
implementation challenges, and determine key priority activities and area of
interventions
4. Identify CC-SLM priorities to start with
5. Development of two pilot projects
Activities

Sub-activities

Responsibl
e
1. Fast truck and lobby for approval of NAP and make it dynamic
1.1 Lobby
1.1.1 Update NAP according to Prime MINERENA
technical
Ministers Office observations
Ministries to take 1.1.2 Develop cabinet paper
NAP for cabinet 1.1.3 Organize NAP technical
discussion
committee meetings
1.2 Organise a
1.2.1 Conept note on the workshop
Rwanda
stakeholders
1.2.2 Identify more stakeholders and National
meeting on their
encourage them and existing ones to Resources
roles in the NAP
participate in the workshop
Board
implementation
(RNRB)

Calendar

Partners

JuneAugust
2011

MINAGRI

September
2011

MINAGRI
MINECOFIN,
Development
partners, Civil
Society
and
Private Sector
2. Study coordination mechanism and communication strategy for SLM-CC activities
2.1 Establish
2.1.1 Develop TORs for the TF
MINIRENA
October
MINAGRI,
taskforce to
2.1.2 Appoint the Task Force
2011
MININFRA,
coordinate and
members
MINECOFIN
provide technical
advice on SLMCC activities
2.2 Conduct a
2.1 Develop TORs for the study
RNRB/TF
November
MINAGRI
study to find a
2.2.Implement the findings of the
2011
single
above study
coordination
mechanism and
communication
strategy that
would hormonise
and coordinate
Page 40 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Activities

Sub-activities

Responsibl
e

Calendar

Partners

SLM-CC issues
2.3 Establish
2.3.1 Identify its composition
RNRB/TF
December
MINAGRI
SLM CC
2.3.2 Define its roles and
2011
MINECOFIN
Platform involving responsibilities
all stakeholders
2.3.3 Organise meetings and
including private
elections of its leaders
sector
3. Study detailed climate change activities (stocktaking), their location and magnitude,
implementation challenges, and determine priority activities and area of interventions
3.1 Identify
3.1.1 Develop TORs for the study
JanuaryMINAGRI
existing CC
3.1.2 Implement the results of the
Feb. 2012
activities and
study
linkage with SLM
and determine
priority activities
CC-SLM and
areas of
intervention
4. Implementation of priorities CC-SLM to start with as pilot activities
4.1 Select 2
4.1.1 Rank priorities
RNRB/TF
February
priorities to start
4.1.2 Select area from which to start
2012
with
based on the most needy
4.1.3 Select best options based on
impact /budget

5. Development of pilot projects and implementation


5.1 Develop
SLM-CC projects

5.2 Negotiation
with the donor
and signature of
financing
agreement
5.3 Beginning of
SLM-CC project
Implementation

5.1.1 Project Concept note


5.1.2 Consultations with stakeholders
5.1.3 Baseline study for the project
5.1.4 Development of the project
document
5.2.1 Meeting with development
partners
5.2.2 Financing agreement
developed and signed

RNRB/TF

MarchMay12

MINIRENA
RNRB/TF

June 2012

5.3.1 Launch of project


5.3.2 Recruit project staff

MINIRENA
RNRB/TF

July 2012

MINAGRI,
MINECOFIN
MININFRA
Development
partners
MINECOFIN,M
INAFFET

MINAGRI,
MINALOC
Districts

At the end of the project impementation and from the experiences and lessons learnt
the Task Force will be transformed into the National Commission to combat
Desertification and Land Degradation as provided for in the NAP implementation
mechanism arrangements.This National Commission to Combat Desrtification and
Land Degradation will built on the Task Forces work and will deal with CCD/NAP
Page 41 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

implementation for SLM and will encourage better integration and synergy between
CCD/SLM and CC activities and financing mechanisms/strategies.

Page 42 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

4 References
Adger, W., Agrawala, S., Mirza, M., Conde, C., OBrien, K., Pulhin, J., et al. (2007).
Assessment of adaptation practices, options, contraints and capacity. In M. Parry, O.
Canziani, J. Palutikof, P. v. Linden, & C. Hanson, Climate Cahange 2007: Impacts,
Adaptation and Vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment
Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (pp. 717-743). Cambridge, UK:
Cambridge University Press.
Bapna, M., & McGray, H. (2008). Financing adaptation: opportunities for innovation and
experimentation. Washington DC: World Resource Institute (WRI).
FAO. (Accessed Nov 2010). Africover. Available at:
http://www.africover.org/system/area.php?place=11 .
IDS. (2006). Overcoming the barriers. Mainstreaming climate change adaptation in
developing countries. Institute for Development Studies (IDS).
International Monetary Fund (IMF), 2008. Rwanda: Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper.
Available at: http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/cr0890.pdf .
International Monetary Fund (IMF), 2010. Povert Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSP).
Available at: http://www.imf.org/external/np/prsp/prsp.asp .
Ministry of Agriculture and animal resources (MINAGRI), 2010. Etude sur lanalyse des
ressources et mcanismes de financement internes, externes et novateurs dans le cadre du
dveloppent de la Stratgie de Financement Intgre pour la Gestion Durable des Terres au
Rwanda, Kigali.
Ministry of Forestry and Mines (MINIFOM), 2010. Elaboration de la stratgie de coordination
et renforcement des synergies entre les conventions de Rio et les autres conventions et
programmes en rapport avec la gestion des ressources naturelles au Rwanda, Kigali.
Ministere des ressources naturelles (MINIRENA), 2009. Plan d'action national de lutte contre
la desertification et la degradation des terres au Rwanda (PAN - LCD). Draft document, not
published.
Ministry of Lands Environment Forestry Water and Mines. (2006). National Adaptation
Programme of Action to Climate Change. NAPA - Rwanda. Available at:
http://unfccc.int/cooperation_support/least_developed_countries_portal/submitted_napas/ite
ms/4585.php.
MINITERE, 2003. National Strategy and Action Plan for the Conservation of Biodiversity in
Rwanda. Ministry of Lands, Resettlement and Environment (MINITERE), Kigali.
MINITERE, 2006. National Adaptation Programmes of Action (NAPA) To Climate Change.
Ministry Of Lands, Environment, Forestry, Water and Mines (MINITERE), Kigali.
Page 43 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

ODI. (2009). Climate Funds Update: Cool Earth Partnership. Available at:
http://www.climatefundsupdate.org/listing/cool-earth-partnership.
REMA. (Accessed Nov 2010). Details for the 2009 Rwanda Grid Emission Factor. Available
at:http://www.rema.gov.rw/dna/index.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_details&gid=24&It
emid= .
REMA. (2010). Evaluation des options d'attenuation des emissions de GES et de
renforcement de puits. Not yet published.
REMA. (2009). Rwanda State of Environment and Outlook. Available at:
http://www.rema.gov.rw/soe/ .
REMA (2006). Economic Analysis Of Natural Resource Management In Rwanda. Rwanda
Environment Management Authority (REMA), Kigali.
REMA (2008). Integrated Management of Critical Ecosystems (IMCE). Rwanda Environment
Management Authority (REMA), Kigali.
ROR (2000). Rwanda Vision 2020. Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning, Republic of
Rwanda (ROR), Kigali.
ROR (2004). Document De Politique Agricole. Ministry of Agriculture and Animal Resources,
Republic of Rwanda (ROR), Kigali.
ROR (2004). National Environmental Policy 2003. Ministry of Lands, Environment, Forestry,
Water and Mines,Republic of Rwanda (ROR), Kigali.
ROR (2004). Politique Nationale des Forts. Ministre des Terres, de la Rinstallation et de la
Protection de lEnvironnement (MINITERE), Kigali.
ROR (2004). Strategic Plan for the Transformation of Agriculture in Rwanda (PSTA I).
Ministry of Agriculture and Animal Resources, Republic of Rwanda (ROR), Kigali.
ROR (2004a). National Land Policy for Rwanda. Ministry of Natural Resources, Republic of
Rwanda (ROR), Kigali.
ROR (2004b). National Human Settlement Policy. Ministry of Infrastructure, Republic of
Rwanda (ROR), Kigali
ROR (2007). Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy, 2008-2012. Ministry of
Finance and Economic Planning, Republic of Rwanda (ROR), Kigali.
ROR (2008). Strategic Plan for the Transformation of Agriculture in Rwanda Phase II (PSTA
II). Final Report. Ministry of Agriculture and Animal Resources, Republic of Rwanda (ROR),
Kigali.
Page 44 of 45

Rwanda Country Mapping

Twagiramungu, F. (2006). Environmental Profile of Rwanda. Kigali, Rwanda: European


Commission.
UNDP. (2010). Human Development Report 2010. The real wealth of nations: pathways to
human development. Available at:
http://hdr.undp.org/en/media/HDR_2010_EN_Complete.pdf .
UNDP and UNEP (2006). Environment and poverty reduction in Rwanda. An Assessment.
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and United Nations Environment
Programme (UNEP), Kigali
UNFCCC. (2007). Decision 1/CP.13. Bali Action Plan. Available at:
http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/2007/cop13/eng/06a01.pdf#page=3.
UNFCCC. (2005). Emissions Summary for Rwanda. Available at:
http://unfccc.int/files/ghg_data/ghg_data_unfccc/ghg_profiles/application/pdf/rwa_ghg_profile
.pdf .
USAID. (2008). Rwanda - Economic Growth Fact Sheet. Available at:
http://www.usaid.gov/rw/our_work/programs/docs/economicgrowth-may2008.pdf.

Page 45 of 45

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen