Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Mass of Hair
(in grams)
100
200
Mass of Cement
(in grams)
3900
3800
Mass of Sand
(in grams)
7000
7000
Force
psi
951.4
1013.79
MPa
6.56
6.99
2. Comparison of the Physical Properties of Cement Tiles with Hair and Cement Tiles
with No Hair
While selecting the ceramic tiles, it is not only necessary to pay attention to the
aesthetic qualities such as style, color, structure, selection of decorative elements within the
framework of the collection, but above all, the technical parameters of the tiles, taking into
consideration the input of work and costs related to maintenance and keeping the tiles clean.
The following tests were conducted by the researchers in order to inform the customers on
what physical and chemical properties should be considered in selecting their tiles.
2.1 Water Absorption. Water absorption testing standards AS4459.3 provides the means to
classify ceramic tiles along with their method of manufacture according to AS 4662 Ceramic tiles Definitions, classification, characteristics and marking. This is important when assessing the
requirements that the ceramic tiles must achieve for them to be are considered the best commercial
quality, otherwise known as first quality.
In this study, five tiles each, one with hair and the other without hair were experimented. To
determine the water absorption of the ceramic tiles the boiling method was used. It involves drying the
tiles out and then boiling them in water for 2 hours followed by cooling to room temperature over a
four hour period. The mass of the tiles are weighed both before and after the water immersion to
determine the percentage of water absorption.
For each tile, calculate the water absorption as a percentage of the dry mass using the
expression:
m2m1
x 100
m1
where: m1= mass of the dry tile; and
m2= mass of the wet tile
The result of the experiment using water absorption was shown in Table 2. It can be seen from
the table that the average water absorption of tiles with hair has a lower value compared with tiles
without hair. In general terms, if the tile has low water absorption, the durability and strength are
increased.
Table 2
Comparison of Water Absorption of Tiles with and without Hair
Trials
1
2
3
4
5
m1
100.23
100.50
100.24
100.18
100.05
100.24
m1
101.50
101.60
101.30
102.20
101.45
101.61
2.1.1 Tile Mass: Accuracy Measurement. Based from Table 3 of the tile mass: accuracy
measurement (International Standards Organization -ISO 10545), the produced tiles with hair (average
water absorption = 0.012) is below the required standard (0.02). Low water absorption restricts the
amount of water that may cause failure. Hence, the produced tile with hair will be better in tile works.
Table 3
Tile Mass: Accuracy of Measurement
SI Number
i
ii
iii
iv
v
Mass of Tiles
(in grams)
0 to 100
101to 500
501 to 1000
1001 to 3000
Above 3000
Accuracy of
Measurement
0.02
0.05
0.25
0.50
1.00
2.1.2 Moisture Rating. Furthermore, water absorption is also measured using ASTM
C373-88 (moisture rating) where tiles are classified according to water absorption percentages. The
results of the experiment show that since the average water absorption was only 0.012, then, the low
water absorption is generally referred to as fully vitrified and impervious, meaning they are viewed by
the consumers as superior products. Table 4 shows ASTM C373-88 for water absorption.
Table 4
ASTM C373-88 for Water Absorption (Moisture Rating)
Impervious
Vitreous
Semi-Vitreous
Tiles exhibiting more than 3.0% but not more than 7.0%.
Non-Vitreous
2.2 Drop Test. This test was conducted in order to determine the hardness of the cement tiles.
Both cement tiles (with hair and with no hair) were dropped. After five trials of dropping the tile, a
slight cracked at the edges resulted for cement tiles with hair. However, the whole cement tile with no
hair cracked vigorously after three trials.
Table 5
Drop Test
Cement Tile
With Hair
With No Hair
Result
Slightly cracked at the edges
Whole tile cracked
2.3 Resistance to Scratches. The relative hardness of tile is an important issue that
should be addressed when selecting a tile. The test is performed by scratching the surface of
the tile with different minerals and subjectively assigning a "MOH's Scale Hardness" number
to the glaze, the softest mineral used is talc ("1" rating), the hardest is a diamond ("10" rating)
as shown in Table 6. When both samples were tested using this scale, the tiles with hair has a
rating of 6 while tiles with no hair has a rating of 5 only. MOH's Scale Hardness values of 5 to
7 are suitable for most residential floor applications. But still, cement tile with hair has a
greater rating than tiles with no hair hence more applicable to be used because the higher the
MOHS rating of a tile, the more resistant it is to wear and scratching (Ames Tile & Stone,
2015).
Table 6
MOHS Hardness Scale
Mineral
Talc
Gypsum
Calcite
Fluorite
Apatite
Feldspar
Quartz
Topaz
Corundu
Example
MOHS
Fingernail scratches it easily
1
Fingernail scratches it
2
Copper penny scratches it
3
Steel knife scratches it easily
4
Steel knife scratches it
5
Steel knife does not scratch it easily, but scratches glass
6
Hardest common mineral, scratches steel and glass easily
7
Harder than any common mineral
8
Scratches topaz
9
m
Diamond
10
2.4 Scoring. Another test conducted to determine the physical property of a tile is
through scoring. The researchers used a conventional glass cutter as their scoring tool. They
found it hard to cut the cement tile with hair unlike the one without hair. But with the use of
straight edge as a guide, the group finally had a good cut.
2.5 Slip Resistance. Slips, trips, and falls constitute the majority of general accidents
inside and outside of some houses. A "slip" occurs when there is too little traction or friction
between the shoe and walking surface. A "trip" occurs when a persons foot contacts an object
in their way or drops to a lower level unexpectedly, causing them to be thrown off-balance. A
trip most often results in a person falling forward, while a slip most often results in the person
falling backward. A "fall" occurs when you are too far off-balance. In order to avoid such
accidents, the researchers produced an unglazed cement tile.
To determine the slip resistance of a tile, friction is needed. Friction is the force that
resists the sliding motion of one surface against another. In the absence of horizontal
dynamometer which is use to get the slip resistance of a tile (ASTM C1028), an experimented
version of determining coefficient of friction was used. To impend motion, a 2 kg-mass was
suspended and passed to a frictionless pulley to a 3kg block resting on a horizontal tile as
shown in Figure 1. The computation of the coefficient of friction of the surface of the tile was
also illustrated. The computed coefficient of friction was 0.67. Based on Table 7 for friction
rating, if coefficient of friction is greater than or equal to six, then the tile is excellent.
However, for cement tile without hair a lesser mass of 1.6 kg was needed in order for the 3 kg
block to impend motion. The computed coefficient of friction was only 0.53 which was rated
as adequate.
Isolating the 2-kg block
W2
Fv = 0; T W1 = 0
T = 2 (9.81) = 19.62 Newtons
T
3k
g
Fv = 0; N W2 = 0
W2 = 3 (9.81) = 29.43 Newtons
2kg
8 x 8 tile
Fh = 0; T F = 0
F = 19.62 Newtons
W1
= F/N = 19.62/29.43
= 0.67
Figure 1
Determination of Coefficient of Friction ()
Table 7
ASTM 1028 Slip Resistance or Friction Rating
Coefficient of Friction
0.60
0.50
0.40
Rating
Excellent
Adequate
Caution is necessary
2.6 Resistance to abrasion. As to abrasion resistance, the cement tile with hair can be
classified as class 3 (heavy residential or light commercial) while the cement tile without hair
was classified only as class one (light residential). Hence, cement tiles without hair are for
light traffic only as can be seen in Table 8 (ASTM C 1027-99).
Table 8
Classification of Tiles According to Abrasion Test
Class Zero
Class One (Light Residential)
3.3 Resistance to Acid. Hydrochloric acid or historically known as muriatic acid was
used in this test. The test specimens were subjected to the action of the test solution and the
researchers visually determined the attack of the acid to the specimens.
Five test specimens were used for both cement tiles, with and without hair. Each test
specimens were dried in the drying oven maintained over 105 C for two hours and then cool
them until they reach room temperature. Test specimens were tested not later than three hours
after they have reached room temperature. It was found out that both samples obtained a class
of LB (V). The result of the test was based on IS0 10545, test on acids and alkalis shown in
Table 9.
Table 9
IS0 10545 Standards
Class
LA(V)
LB(V)
LC(V)
Remarks
No visible effect
Discernable change in appearance
Partial or complete loss of the original surface
CONCLUSIONS
2. To have a more presentable and attractive surface of the tiles, it is recommended that
glaze should be put on the surface or some figure can be drawn to the design of the
surface.
3. Other source of raw materials like clay can be studied to produce cheaper tiles.
REFERENCES
Brebu, M. and Spiridon, I. (2011). Thermal degradation of keratin waste, Journal of
Analytical and Applied Pyrolysis, vol. 91, no. 2, pp. 288295. View at Publisher View at
Google Scholar View at Scopus
Kumar, S., Bhattacharyya, J. K., Vaidya, A. N. T., Chakrabarti, T., Devotta, S. and Akolkar, A.
B. (2009). Assessment of the status of municipal solid waste management in metro cities,
state capitals, class I cities, and class II towns in India: an insight, Waste Management,
vol. 29, no. 2, pp. 883895. View at Publisher View at Google Scholar View at Scopus
Shavelson, R.J. (2004). Editors preface to Lee J. Cronbachs My current thoughts on
coefficient alpha and successor procedures. Educational and Psychological Measurement
64, 389390.
Web
Ames Tile & Stone, 2015. Tech Specs. Retrieved from http://www.amestile.com /section.asp?
pageid=22921.
ASTM F1265-03a(2013), Standard Test Method for Resistance to Impact for Resilient Floor
Tile, ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA, 2013.
Porcelain/Ceramic Test Results. http://www.homedepot.com/catalog/pdfImages/3f/3fdf27b1476e-4df1-b888-a1ce5f57cfe2.pdf.
Standard
Test
Method
for
Determination
of
Resistance
to
Staining
http://www.astm.org/Standards/C1378.htm.
Standard Test Method for Resistance of Ceramic Tile to Chemical Substances.
http://www.astm.org/Standards/C650.htm.