Sie sind auf Seite 1von 6

Avoiding Cavitation Damage Extends Pump Life - WaterWorld

1 de 6

http://www.waterworld.com/articles/print/volume-23/issue-10/departmen...

ABOUT | CONTACT | ADVERTISE | SUBSCRIBE

LOGIN OR REGISTER USING


SUBSCRIBE: MAGAZINE l NEWSLETTERS

Home Buyers Guide Drinking Water Wastewater Urban Stormwater Industrial Water Water Utility Mgmt Environmental World Regions Technologies

Home > Avoiding Cavitation Damage Extends Pump Life

by Allan Budris
One way that the Best-of-Class users reduce the Life Cycle Costs of their pump
installations is by selecting pumps and designing pump systems that will avoid
cavitation damage within their pumps. Cavitation damage can drastically
shorten the life of the pump impeller, mechanical seals, bearings and possibly
other pump components. In other words it will reduce the mean-time-betweenfailure (MTBF), which will increase maintenance costs and pump down time.
There has been a lot written on the dangers of pump cavitation damage when
adequate suction pressure (Net Positive Suction Head Available - NPSHA) is
not provided; when pumps are operated at low flow rates (below the start of
suction recirculation); and/or when sufficient straight runs of piping are not
provided upstream of the pump suction. It can require NPSHA values of four
times the published Net Positive Suction Head Required (NPSHR), or more, to
avoid all cavitation in a pump. The start of Suction Recirculation, which occurs
in all centrifugal pumps at some reduced flow rate, can be as high as 85% or
more of the pump best efficiency flow rate (bep). The required minimum straight
length of pipe, up stream of the pump suction, may be as high as 15 times the
pipe diameter or higher.

Report Examines the 'Smart Utility'

However, experienced pump users also know that most smaller pumps do not

22/07/2015 09:11 a. m.

Avoiding Cavitation Damage Extends Pump Life - WaterWorld

2 de 6

http://www.waterworld.com/articles/print/volume-23/issue-10/departmen...

experience cavitation damage, even when operated under these unfavorable


conditions. So the question is, specifically when must pump users take special
precautions to avoid cavitation damage, and the associated increase in
maintenance costs?

FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA

Well, based my extensive experience with several major pump manufacturers, I


was able to developed a method that predicts when pumps are susceptible to
cavitation noise, vibration, and/or damage; and when they are free of these
damaging affects. The method is called Suction Energy, with specific gating
values of Suction Energy identified for different pump types. The amount of
energy in a pumped fluid which flashes into vapor and then collapses back into
a liquid in the high pressure areas of the impeller determines the amount of
noise and/or damage from cavitation.
Suction energy is another term for the liquid momentum in the suction eye of a
pump impeller, which means that it is a function of the mass and velocity of the
liquid in the inlet. Suction energy is defined as:

Click here to enlarge image


Based on the experience of hundreds of centrifugal pumps, the writer was able
to establish the following specific gating values for the start of High Suction
Energy and Very High Suction Energy, for various pump types.

Low Suction Energy


Pumps with levels of suction energy below these values are considered to have
low suction energy. Generally speaking, low suction energy pumps are not
prone to noise, vibration or damage from cavitation or recirculation. However,
there could be detrimental effects on mechanical seals from the air or vapors
which may be liberated from the liquid during the formation of the cavitation
bubbles, under low NPSH margin conditions (below 1.1 - 1.3 NPSH margin
ratio).

High Suction Energy


Pumps with high suction energy and low NPSH margins, especially when
operated in the suction recirculation flow range, may experience noise, vibration
and/or minor cavitation erosion damage with impeller materials that have low
cavitation resistance, such as cast iron. High suction energy starts at about
3,560 rpm in end suction pumps with 6" and larger suction nozzles sizes, and
split case pumps with 8"and larger suction nozzles. At ~1,780 rpm, high suction
energy starts with 10 suction nozzle size end suction pumps, and 12" suction
split case pumps.

22/07/2015 09:11 a. m.

Avoiding Cavitation Damage Extends Pump Life - WaterWorld

3 de 6

http://www.waterworld.com/articles/print/volume-23/issue-10/departmen...

Click here to enlarge image


Very High Suction Energy
Pumps with very high suction energy and low NPSH margins, especially when
operated in the suction recirculation flow range, may experience erosion
damage, even with cavitation resistant materials, such as stainless steel.

NPSH Margin
The NPSHR of a pump does not represent the start of cavitation. It is actually
the NPSHA that will cause the total head to be reduced by 3%, due to flow
blockage from cavitation vapor in the entry of the impeller vanes. It can take
from 1.05 to 2.5 times the NPSHR just to achieve the 100 percent head point,
and typically 4 to 5 times the 3% NPSHR of the pump to totally eliminate
cavitation. The question then becomes, how much NPSH Margin is really
required to minimize cavitation damage, and achieve extended MTBF rates.

Click here to enlarge image


NPSH Margin Reliability Factor
I developed the following graph (figure 1), based on field experience, to provide
a reasonable approximation of the reliability that can be expected with aqueous
liquids, when various NPSH margin ratios are applied to High Suction Energy
pumps of increasing energy levels (Actual Pump Suction Energy divided by the
High Suction Energy gating value for the pump type). These NPSH margin
reliability factors are based on the fact that, above the gating suction energy
values, cavitation becomes more severe. In other words, the greater the suction
energy, the more important it is to suppress the residual cavitation that exists
above the NPSHR, to prevent damage. This reliability factor is only applicable
within the allowable operating flow region, above the start of suction
recirculation. Much higher NPSH margin values are required in the region of

22/07/2015 09:11 a. m.

Avoiding Cavitation Damage Extends Pump Life - WaterWorld

4 de 6

http://www.waterworld.com/articles/print/volume-23/issue-10/departmen...

suction recirculation for high and very high suction energy pump applications.

Click here to enlarge image


Figure 2 can be used to approximate the start of suction recirculation for high
suction energy pumps, in the absence of actual test results. The three curves
show the effect of specific speed on the start of suction recirculation, which
increases with increasing specific speed and suction specific speed.
This new method for predicting cavitation damage in centrifugal pumps, which
has been adopted by the Hydraulic Institute and major pump companies, can
save thousands of dollars in unnecessary maintenance costs.

About the Author:


Allan R. Budris, P.E., is an independent consulting engineer who specializes in
training, failure analysis, troubleshooting, reliability, efficiency audits and
litigation support on pumps and pumping systems. With offices in Washington,
NJ, he can be contacted via e-mail at budrisconsulting@comcast.net.

More WaterWorld Current Issue Articles


More WaterWorld Archives Issue Articles

RELATED ARTICLES

22/07/2015 09:11 a. m.

Avoiding Cavitation Damage Extends Pump Life - WaterWorld

5 de 6

http://www.waterworld.com/articles/print/volume-23/issue-10/departmen...

Visualization software
WERF to launch new groundbreaking studies to advance
energy research
MA Clean Energy Partnership for Water recognized as
'Innovation in Government' finalist
Poseidon Water seeking renewable energy sources for
Huntington Beach desalination project

RELATED PRODUCTS
Jet Aerator
Jet Mixing
Outotec Energy Products

TODAY'S HEADLINES
CA's 'Save Our Water' joins Bay Area Council to release PSA
with Sergio Romo
"Save Our Water," the state of California's official statewide water
conservation education program, in partnership with the Bay Area Council,
has released a new Public Service Announcement featuring San Francisco
Giants star Sergio Romo.

TWDB to consider approving $3.9B for State Water


Implementation Fund for Texas
The Texas Water Development Board will hold a board meeting at the
Stephen F. Austin Building in the city of Austin, Texas, to approve the
inaugural round of funding from the State Water Implementation Fund for
Texas.

EPA announces settlement of CWA violations with Pan AM


Railways
Pan Am Railways has agreed to settle allegations from the Environmental
Protection Agency for Clean Water Act violations at two of its railyards
operating in the cities of Waterville, Maine, and East Deerfield, Mass.

Investment in automation solutions fuels global drives market,


study shows
According to new research conducted by Frost & Sullivan, heightened
investment in automation technologies across end-user industries will propel
the global drives market.

22/07/2015 09:11 a. m.

Avoiding Cavitation Damage Extends Pump Life - WaterWorld

6 de 6

http://www.waterworld.com/articles/print/volume-23/issue-10/departmen...

TOPICS
Drinking Water

RESOURCES
Magazines

ABOUT US
Contact Us

SUPPORT
Register

STAY CONNECTED
Twitter

Wastewater

Webcasts

Advertising

Login

Facebook

Urban Stormwater

White Papers

Subscribe

Forgot Password

Industrial Water

Industry News

About Us

Change Password

Water Utility Management

RSS Feeds

PennWell Events

Site Map

World Regions

Buyer's Guide

PennWell Websites

Environmental

WaterWorldTV Videos

Technologies

Industry Links
Research
Topic Index

2015. PennWell Corporation. All Rights Reserved. PRIVACY POLICY | TERMS AND CONDITIONS

22/07/2015 09:11 a. m.

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen