.

-+
....

'-'

'(;'

:....

=...

("l

4-

~"~

'"

~'

::--......

/\

tl.f~ tt

C1

'\~

f'
.,,~

~ ~

I~);}

rl~

f
I. ~,t,.~~~~'1
~~h

'\

~'1

'*'
~~

J-~~ ~~

~ ~ ~

(~~

\J~
~
~

'

::s-

~ ,J
~ R ~

t"

~,

"'"

,~

<,

~ rs

'"
10 D .r-.~
~.\

It

9'
~
'"

UI
N

9
...
~

t"i

"
170

'\

'~

'-~

~.

~,1

~
""
~

,~

t ~~

~I~

.II'-

~
~

~,\

"}'r 1-

f: }r

'1 ~

'~

~\

:,~

--

,....

1- ~

t" ~

~ ~

~ ~ ~,

~,

fl'

\:It

~'

"

Ci

\)

ft
~

.(\

"\

~J

'S'

~;~\~~f ~

"

;;.

~t
\;
\
~
~~t t ~

ISCAP APPEAL NO. 2012-048, document no. 8

DECLASSIFICATION DATE: July 8, 2015

DECLASSIFIED UNDER AUTHORITY OF THE

INTERAGENCY SECURITY CLASSIFICATION APPEALS PANEL,
E.O. 13526, SECTION 5.3(b)(3)

~
~

(~--..

"

4/4.t'.v-;

>"~

: ./''''''V7~
/h

AX0~'

(~

..~

.; vS ~

#W~

r~

7b >~t./d.t.-)

/k,T~4>./

.. ~J'
;

;7!I:!Jt

/'n-.//"~

-M

~~

~~~4<~

fo..

4.f'~

jJ?~~~

l'~?~~!)

.'

~
.~

:i.~

;,'~

~;

i~

--

~.

.~

..
-

&CAR

-O'>-t

~.

~~.;ra~

J'~'~
..~

17~

.. ~

..

/X;~,~

..

..

~J1I!P'> ~~

~-~~

:'

fl/oIu~ 7>/7'~i~;.

---

,. CwfWAir ~
o...<.I7<.P

-10 c-h _..~

uY ~

~,

>

'.

~r('~--'krV~)'~~

Q~

..

r'>: ..
1Ad

vlL-~~~r~v'jf~k.

IV! ~

. ~91Cv-t'<-

U/Z0

+~7;.~

.<fr~fk~

:'o~,

J'V'1C(j,Y)

AP)}-,

.~ aM(~
;JI1/~
~

U/0 1),

~~.

iJ

4 ~~

~-~?'~~---

~}t ~

e-:

,cc- r

,".

>,-,4,.

,J.

Vt-

~.

&62 ~

... ~

~
..

s=v-

"~
:

!:

~c;,
S~

r8t;/=L/

J7k't

: ~

t:k;.

,\.,

.(.$L

o/01'~

~..J<

... ~
rf-~

-~

c.~:'....,

~'/:~

.
f~

iz;~-

--

~~

~~~?o~)

,71 ~

u91.---

.....

a....4! .~.~.

;~*"'"

8"0~

.~)_

~~

It!)

~.~

Po.('/I;<:

.s~~.
'7't?/

.~~

ft~

I'"Pt~><6
~

v.I' ~~

(~rh.

~~

lSo's/I"<,

.~

~~

"""""
~

J~J.q;II'Prir

~ /~.~

~,L-':T-I

P.vr~";

~yi/ler-

;orrt4.''''~

!f"ff)f>';";~

u.~~

if.?~

I./~~

"f::-::r~~

+tl ~

-'76 ; gy

,i-?~~

.J""~

::

~
'?>1.

~-

j(Adct/.

",L:?,/hv~~
(:7'.

~_

dv ~-

-b'/-l

~J

~~~~~

/VI

9C ~

'7~~'

.~~~

-fo .....
"".-.Arv//'~O/h~r

,A//,d ~

~.~

7<% /,~C-,,

~~~~~~~~~I
.~v0.~

/~

ce(JV

c?7-

I/P?

~~.

10 ~!'~

f,6 -~.

~~~i-J-P~

~'~.

"

Id?

-/-r.~~

.;-~

~~

crt-tn,,:~

A-I(!J'

~,~vIe>

vSeP

'l

';;;~(.)JQ.{/~

..
.,-~

~",c:-d-~Lr'lhJ

a~~t'....

~.~.

~,~",-h~)v~~

~_

#v~/~~'~~~'~~'k--o"i~'__
~

(~

~~

--Z~

-'t9-J'~

/k~

?~~!
~44/!f

~L/

",~

1V/1~

~
/1-

"~
vei'--'

,0 ~ ~

Vf./"/?'?.!J

--4 ~_

~~

->~

,~

C~.A~,,~~~~

~/
,

/f/ qf) //' "

}::::~

,
;

r-

t/>-

)d~~</-

v.l

d-,((jv~

'/ll

AS;'q

7'/ - ~'

~.

gr )'

13526, section 1.4(c) I

vJ"

~,e",

<"~

(~

~')

-8-d~}.

r ~

I R.O.

e:>-..

1~

~(0

I~ (/) i4r~

4~

O~"d

~;

,\-,~.
.;

~?'f~d~-/

;\-c

tk-c. )'

dkP c../
~-.~

~~

A/~'~('~,

A-tf(:;

~,

.A-''"2- J

~-

U/7 .~

W~

(~

cJ-L-.'<7

AQ,

rv,

t'r-t ~

/->:

.uve..~

t:r"V1!5L

.;.~~

~~~

~).$~

~4<{J~

-~

'~f.~

C;;

c..//

.~-

47-- a/24o

/'

0-.~)

1:

.. ~

~.

-I~-~

~,

/r4lQ.'
.....

/11 ~~

,~.

"

/-'F <Sjlt;: v ,IL ~

KP '1~

,~ed';~_

-Y11~/TY~~h,1/

,. ..

..
..... ~.~~

?~S'I~~

!~~tl-t.f<r-

. A,rl(e-t/l//?/ .(~+&

,/.1 ~

fi., ~

..

'-"".J~

~.fA.V,,

i.

.r- ~

l'

!:

I,'v~d~

.~

~.

Jet

~~

~
,'-I

~J',,[,V

IbI~

A c{

A(.;..v.{./;,-/'!
/UJV,

r-

lid~~.
J;

0)

~t~

~ ~

41 ~~A.),/vl

, I~~rl/fe~

v=f

,ftL--/

>.e~

L../~

9/-,/ -

-4/.

,{,~,

::

"

#,'

!:

~
9?~

/h

..~~

.~

17 ~

'-oJ

"

#v

)f4i.;e~ ~

uPL

~Oh-

izl.~

~a-vrL

4.v I~

vott.-e.-

y~~.
(t1~)

-r" ~

fo

&~

I~

fl'>--~.

&&

~'7>~~

~v;'~-A#r

.knrC

/n ~

-h-t;p~

i~

s:v'~r4~#~->..

;:, ~

,
i

:i[("

i.

=:

rz: ~

-hd:ry

~t~.-

""

;.
i

~/

~
Uj'.~

a:

~;>-G-,?~M-:~;r6

~~~,

r :

.!

~(/J'

boa.

..... ~

(~~j

a?-~~

_ .. -

r~/r

p~

iP~ij..:r6

:J~~>~/~'.

1~~

i:

~~G-~.~

~A~

C-<",~"" .. ~.;p
p

~~

'?6~~l

~~

):

-h~~

~~:.

/h

~'7J

~~

d~),,~

L4b'/?,,~

~~~
~
~~/)..~,

~/~

.A~d,-/ ~

~~

d~

~~

~.~

(~.;0~~~?~

~;I"~

~~T~?

::
i

.$'V/M"-

-4-r0 ~
(J 4.dt.

~
~

tve# ~
~~

a: ~

J!/~

t:

tJ'fe;. ~,_

frl'~

~.

.. " ..... ~~.~~~~~

..

d~

p7,'/J

~~

-e-~l ~.~(

>

~
~~~~~~-

5
S~

.9~

~~

4 ae:f?

,::A

~~.~

J'~_

'3

~
;~

5-;"/1 ~

~~:f

C(1.&rr

~.~

c-L~

~,

~~~~~

(//Ji~

..9~/_

~/~'

~~fYc/~-/.--4,h~/J'1

IJ.?

tfi-f~o_

.f-r~.!"

.f.--q(~,f.,-,t

r'h

1k.;7

q/f/)

~/~~I-Cie--C/I&V- ~/

;U"hrt"

':

""lvJ ~

~&?

~~~)--,,~~e;e;e:;;,;;==1
'=7b~1'ci2iJ2>~:::'7_

/yq>'~vc-~,

~
. ~-

(J-

-ss
i_e; U'~L~

~~I

, A'a 4 ~

s/ee-~?<.//~

~-

~~~.~/~_.

r~Ak<-

~~~L::t
ti6-v_~A~~~-

-A% ~.

dLM;

o/';'/.-.-v]~

<f'~

/h~~

ey~

J?~

~!#

c~

~
~r-

fo~A~
~

,;.,

M- ~_
'Y~
~~~-

lo

I'i;

..
::

!I

~Jb ~

~Yl

V.J' ~

d-lu/ ~

US 6-;

r" ,;,'k/'-;-