Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
FACTS:
Atty. Vicente Raul Almacen filed a Petition to
Surrender the Lawyers Certificate of Title to the
Supreme Court as a sign of his protest as against to
what he call a tribunal peopled by people who are
calloused to our pleas for justice. He also
expressed strong words as against the judiciary
like justice is not only blind, but also deaf and
dumb. . The petition rooted from the case he lost
due to the absence of time and place in his motion in
the trial court. His appeal was dismissed in the Court
of Appeals by reason of jurisprudence. In a petition
for certiorari in the Supreme Court, it was again
dismissed thru a minute resolution. With the
disappointments, he thought of this sacrificial move.
He claimed that this petition to surrender his title is
only in trust, and that he may obtain the title again as
soon as he regained confidence in the justice system.
ISSUE:
Whether or not Atty. Almacen should be given
disciplinary actions for his acts.
HELD:
YES. Indefinite suspension imposed.
RATIO:
It has been pointed out by the Supreme Court that
there is no one to blame but Atty. Almacen himself
because of his negligence. Even if the intentions of
his accusations are so noble, in speaking of the truth
and alleged injustices, so as not to condemn the
sinners but the sin, it has already caused enough
damage and disrepute to the judiciary. Since this
particular case is sui generis in its nature, a number
of foreign and local jurisprudence in analogous cases
were cited as benchmarks and references. Between
disbarment and suspension, the latter was imposed.
Indefinite suspension may only be lifted until further
orders, after Atty. Almacen may be able to prove that
he is again fit to resume the practice of law.
FACTS:
Vicente Raul Almacens Petition to Surrender
Lawyers Certificate of Title, filed on Sept. 26, 1967,
in protest against what he therein asserts is a great
injustice committed against his client by Supreme
Court. He indicts SC, in his own phrase, as a tribual
peopled by men who are calloused to our pleas for
justice, who ignore without reasons their own
applicable decisions and commit culpable violations
of the Constitution with impunity. His clients he
continues, who was deeply aggrieved by this Courts
unjust judgment, has become one of the sacrificial
victims before the altar of hypocrisy.
PALEN