Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
20
workplace project. Data were collected using standard instruments, chart audit, and interviews.
Results: The Web course provided a standardized and effective
educational experience that enhanced emergency nurses triage
accuracy. The mandatory online tutorial, online discussion, and
workplace project increased the RNs preparation for online
learning, and these educational methods were successful in
transferring triage learning to practice.
Discussion: Web learning can help professionals maintain
competency and support professional practice. Further research is
needed to provide evidence for best practices in E-learning for
RNs. The accuracy of the RNs triage assessment impacts patient
health, hospital accreditation, and funding.
Key words: Online learning; Triage skills; CTAS
fied on an ordinal scale from level I (in need of resuscitation) to level V (nonurgent). Triage training tends to be
informal and focuses on documentation evaluation rather
than triage accuracy.6,7
Two research problems are the need for ongoing standardized training to develop triage skills and access to
timely delivery of educational content. Traditionally,
CTAS training in Canada has been offered as a day-long
workshop. Barriers such as staff shortages, shift work, and
budget constraints have reduced access to the course. In
addition, 1-day workshops have resulted in limited changes
in practice.8 In an effort to improve CTAS training, the
Ontario Hospital Association Change Foundation funded
the development of a 6-week Web-based CTAS workshop.
Learning takes place through text, case studies, and online
discussion moderated by a course facilitator.
The significance to nursing is to determine whether
Web-based learning impacts clinical practice. An extensive literature search of CINAHL (Cumulative Index to
Nursing and Allied Health Literature) and MEDLINE
(1997 to 2010) was conducted. Authors have described
advantages of Web-based learning including convenience, decreased costs, and accessibility for rural learners.9-12 Disadvantages include hardware costs, computer
skills, and the need for self-direction.13,14 Findings from
VOLUME 39 ISSUE 1
January 2013
Rankin et al/RESEARCH
TABLE 1
Overview of CTAS
CTAS level
CTAS descriptor
Level I: Resuscitation
Level II: Emergent
Level V: Nonurgent
January 2013
VOLUME 39 ISSUE 1
DESIGN
WWW.JENONLINE.ORG
21
RESEARCH/Rankin et al
22
VOLUME 39 ISSUE 1
January 2013
Rankin et al/RESEARCH
January 2013
VOLUME 39 ISSUE 1
FIGURE 1
Under- and over-triaging based on E and C group chart audits.
A major finding was that the online CTAS course positively impacted nurses triage skills. The triage accuracy rate
for all nurses was 70%. This figure compares favorably
when measured against previous reports of triage accuracy.36 The overall agreement between the RNs and expert
within 1 triage level was 99.7%, which is also very positive.
This implies that RNs can reliably use the CTAS. The
70% agreement between the expert and RNs provides
further evidence for the work done by other investigators
WWW.JENONLINE.ORG
23
RESEARCH/Rankin et al
regarding the reliability of the CTAS scale.34 It is important to examine the 30% that were incorrectly triaged; of
these, 53% were over-triaged. The majority (71%) of the
over-triaging was done by RNs in the E group. This is a
resource issue and a practice that errs on the side of patient
safety. Triage personnel are typically encouraged to triage
up even if the patient does not clearly present with the
signs and symptoms that match with the higher triage
level. 34 Of greater concern are the patients who were
under-triaged, 83% of whom were triaged by nurses in
the C group. The implications of under-triaging are more
serious: increased patient wait times and poor outcomes if
necessary care is delayed.
Although the hypothesis that a mandatory tutorial,
awarding of marks for online discussion, and a workplace
project would improve nurses satisfaction and enhance
triage accuracy was only partly supported, a great deal
was learned about online learning. The overall OLSI satisfaction rate of 75% with the Web course is consistent with
earlier studies.9,11,30
The finding of no significant difference in nurses
satisfaction with the course was initially surprising. On
closer examination, the reasons for this become clear.
Even without the 25% grade incentive, RNs in the C
group talked online as frequently as those in the E
group. This suggests that if the online discussion is sufficiently interesting, professionals will join voluntarily.
Although the online tutorial was mandatory for RNs in
the E group, all but 2 RNs in the C group chose to do
the tutorial. This means that the 2 groups experiences
ultimately differed only with respect to the workplace project. The finding that nurses who completed the workplace project made significantly fewer errors of clinical
importance (under-triaging) is important and warrants
further study. Moreover, the accuracy of the RNs triage
assessment affects patient safety as well as hospital accreditation. Only 16% (n = 20) had an unsatisfactory experience with the course; the majority of these RNs were
already very experienced with CTAS and were seeking
more in-depth content. In retrospect, they were overqualified for this level of CTAS course. The finding that
nurses increased their computer skills is similar to earlier
studies17,37,38 and suggests that learners may benefit by
taking even relatively short computer courses.
Limitations
24
TABLE 2
Marketing
Provide complete course descriptions to assist learners in
making decisions about course enrollment
Technology
Select well-tested platform with minimal training
Ensure that message management is easy to learn and
facilitates posting and retrieval
Provide platform interface familiar to students
Course design
Provide a tutorial that orientates students to computer
skills required in the course
Provide level tutorial based on learners' computer skills
Provide novices with opportunity to test their skills (eg,
send an attachment)
Make the tutorial available as soon as a student registers
Make the tutorial open and free to anyone visiting
your site
Leave the tutorial online throughout the course
Provide learning and evaluation activities that relate to
clinical practice
Implement workplace project completed individually or
in groups
Provide online opportunity for learners to showcase their
projects
Customize course by adding enriching activities, readings, or optional modules
Provide online discussion forum to enhance learning
and networking
Subdivide large classes into groups of 10 to 12 to keep
online discussion manageable
Develop interesting, practice-based learning activities
Employers
VOLUME 39 ISSUE 1
January 2013
Rankin et al/RESEARCH
Conclusions
January 2013
VOLUME 39 ISSUE 1
13. Ludlow BL, Foshay JD, Brannan SA, Duff MC, Dennison KE. Updating knowledge and skills of practitioners in rural areas: web based model.
Rural Spec Educ Q. 2002;2:33-44.
14. Roschelle J, Pea R. Trajectories from todays WWW to a powerful
educational structure. Educ Res. 1999;28(5):22-5.
15. Phipps R, Merisotis J. Whats the Difference? A Review of Contemporary Research on the Effectiveness of Distance Learning in Higher Education. Washington, DC: Institute for Higher Education Policy;
1999.
WWW.JENONLINE.ORG
25
RESEARCH/Rankin et al
32. Atack L, Rankin J, Then KL. The effectiveness of a six- week online
course in the Canadian Triage and Acuity Scale (CTAS) for emergency
nurses. J Emerg Nurs. 2005;31(5):436-41.
33. Beveridge R, Ducharme J, Janes L, Beaulieu S, Walter S. Reliability of
the Canadian Emergency Department Triage and Acuity Scale: interrater agreement. Ann Emerg Med. 1999;34(2):155-9.
34. Beveridge R, Clarke B, Janes L, Savage B. Canadian Emergency Department Triage and Acuity Scale: implementation and guidelines. CJEM.
1999;1(suppl):S2-S28.
35. Dallaire C, Poitras J, Aubin K, Lavoie A, Moore L, Audet G. Interrater
agreement of Canadian Emergency Department Triage and Acuity Scale
26
VOLUME 39 ISSUE 1
January 2013