Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Preface
Chapter 1: Introduction
1.1
Background
1.2
How Cells Are Assembled
1.3
Basic Cellular Components
1.4
Tissues
1.5
Tensegrity
1.6
Forces That Hold The Cell Together
1.7
CSK Mechanoreflexes
1.8
Construction of the CSK
1.9
Applications of Cytomechanics
Exercises and Review Questions
References
14
25
33
11
24
32
48
50
70
82
Chapter 8: Micromotors
8.1
Introduction
8.2
Muscular Microstructure
8.3
The Pathway to Contraction
8.4
Generation and Regulation of Force
8.5
Skeletal Muscle Energetics
Appendix: Review of Biomechanical Terminology
Exercises and Review Questions
References
89
68
80
87
101
102
103
110
Appendix
111
9.4
9.5
Propulsive Motors
Comparative Motor Analysis
PREFACE
Cytomechanics studies how cells are influenced by the mechanical stresses and
strains that they experience continually throughout their lives. Cytomechanics
studies these pico-newton and nanometer quantities, to understand and possibly
manipulate the growth, structure and function of cells. This course emphasizes
the processes that drive tissue growth, degeneration, and regeneration, with subtopics including cellular signaling and metabolism, gene mechanics and
expression, and the biomechanical properties of cells and their components.
Projects in modeling cellular structure and behavior are done with Matlab &
Simulink.
An important feature of cell mechanics is mechanotransduction: the process
whereby cells transform mechanical energy into other forms, including chemical,
electrical, and inertial. It is based upon the ability of cells to sense the
mechanical forces always present in their environment and react to them on time
scales ranging from milliseconds to years in order to achieve biological stability at
some level. Mechanotransduction is thus central to cellular structure and
function, tissue maintenance, and ultimately, organismal fate. Understanding it
requires analysis of extremely small forces and deformations at the nanometer
level; this challenge can be met by merging engineering principles with
techniques of modern molecular biology such as immunocytochemistry, optical
imaging, and microfabrication.
Part I (the first 7 chapters) presents the basic structural components, mechanics
and energetics of cells, cellular electrophysiology and techniques for cellular
visualization and mechanical characterization. Part II (the last five chapters)
covers the role of mechanotransduction in complex cell behaviors of signaling,
moving, adhesivity, and growth. Quantitative examples and exercises based on
traditional biomechanics applied to cells are provided. Software, such as Matlab
and Excel will enhance understanding, and specific examples using them are
given. The appendices give formulae and data related to cellular mechanical
properties and the cytoskeleton, along with a brief tutorial on Simulink.
This course packet is a compilation of many textual and research papers, and
includes excerpts from same, cited in the text. Referenced or excerpted articles
are included online in the supplement. The book attempts to introduce the huge
and growing field of cell mechanics, and assumes the reader has background in
basic cell biology, biochemistry, and Physics. While reading each chapter, you
should find the Appendices useful for definitions and formulae. Companion
books in those areas are recommended as reference. For more in-depth texts
please read, The Mechanics of the Cell by David Boar, and Biomechanics by Y.C.
Fung. This book has liberally adapted ideas and material from those two texts, as
well as reviews. Please note that this book will inevitably contain mistakes, so
corrections and comments will be appreciated. Permissions for material from
research articles are pending.
Chapter 1: Introduction
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
(With acknowledgements to Ingber 2008; Eyckmans, Boudou et al. 2011)
1.1 Background
Biological cells are structures that self-assemble from basic components, adapt their
shapes, sizes and strengths to their ongoing needs, and travel to and settle in appropriate
locations using their own renewable energy. Many of these abilities result from a
particular sensory-reflex system possessed by each cell that responds to mechanical
forces within its environment. In fact, in order to properly function and grow, each cell
depends upon continual stress and strain within preferred magnitude ranges. When
force or strain magnitudes are outside the proper range, either too large or too small, cell
function and growth is adversely affected.
This inter-relationship between ambient force and cell function underlies a unique
design whose principles would be highly useful to engineers. Cytomechanics seeks to
uncover those principles using the tools of molecular biology, imaging, biomechanics,
and computer modeling. By analyzing forces and deformations on the pico-newton and
nanometer levels, cytomechanics seeks to explain and possibly manipulate the growth,
structure and function of cells.
A prominent example of the application of cytomechanics is accelerating the growth of
cells and tissues by exposing them to forces from fluid flow in bioreactors. Specifically,
growth of nerves, skin, muscles, bone, and probably all biological tissues can be
stimulated by proper application of forces. Other technology is exploiting the highly
efficient molecular motors found in bacteria to make nano-scale motors.
Although the biological effects of forces are perhaps most evident in the context of
physical activitybreathing, heart pumping, blood flow, and physical exercisesuch
forces also regulate morphogenesis, cell migration, and even cell adhesion to
extracellular matrix. Such forces can regulate a wide variety of biological processes, from
cell proliferation and differentiation to tissue mass homeostasis and complex
inflammatory cascades.
The idea that forces can regulate tissue remodeling and development was articulated
more than a century ago. In 1892, the surgeon and anatomist Julius Wolff postulated
that bone tissue adapts its structure to the mechanical environment based on the
observation that trabeculae matched the principal stress lines in bones caused by daily
physical loading (Wolff, 1892). Although the alignment of trabeculae could have arisen
strictly during prenatal development, he reported this remodeling occurred even after
healing of misaligned fractures. In the same era, mechanical forces were proposed to
shape tissues and organs during embryonic development (Roux, 1895; Thompson, 1917),
but the tools were not available to directly test such ideas experimentally. Nearly a
century passed before these concepts began to captivate the scientific community once
again.
1.2 How Cells Are Assembled
The architecture of biological cells is highly complex, and its elegance can be appreciated
in comparison with that of buildings. Building design must meet certain minimum
standards: (1) a foundation anchoring it to the correct location; (2) sufficient strength to
stand against all expected forces; (3) comfortable internal environment; (4) access
portals for incoming and outgoing traffic; and (5) food and waste processing. Using well-
Chapter 1: Introduction
established formulae from mechanical and civil engineering, the architect can select the
type and sizes of structural components, their arrangement, connections, and all the
functional components needed to satisfy the building standards. Before construction
begins, she knows every line, arc, angle, and load that the building will have.
Architecture of buildings is thus laid out as a clearly understood blueprint.
Architecture of biological cells, on the other hand, is laid out by a blueprint that is not so
clearly understood, in the form of codes on DNA molecules; structurally, cells are
squishy, wiggly, and willful. Nevertheless, cellular architecture not only must satisfy all
the same standards as buildings, it must be self-renewable. Cells solve the mechanical
and civil engineering problems they face in a myriad of elegant ways, using any and every
way to live. In fact, cells have much more intelligence than buildings: they can modify
their structure to meet changing demands and conditions. Cytomechanics seeks to learn
and apply the rules of cellular architecture. While it may never be possible for us to build
cells from scratch, we can expect to learn tricks from them that can help us solve many
technological problems.
1.3
Basic Cellular Components
Basic Plan
The basic plan of all animal cells is the same: they have a lipid membrane, skeleton, and
internal structures. Unlike most components of buildings, however, which are divided
into purely structural or purely functional categories, all cellular components can serve
both categories in elegant ways. The membrane is very weak structurally, but
nevertheless is a barrier wrap and portal to the outside, as well as a smart skin with
sensory and reflex capabilities. Mechanical strength is provided by the cell skeleton, i.e.
cytoskeleton, (CSK), that supports the membrane and maintains cellular shape. The
CSK not only is the backbone and limbs of the cell, it is also a communication network.
Within the gel-like cytosol, internal structures include the nucleus, mitochondria, and
other organelles Together the 3 components, membrane, CSK, and cytosol provide all the
structure and function of the cell.
The Lipid Membrane
All cells are enveloped by a lipid bilayer that is an aggregation of phospholipids, in a
spheroid, separating the cell interior from the exterior environment. Many components
other than lipid exist within the bilayer, and perform various functions, as will be seen in
Chapter 2. Formation of the bilayer in solution is a spontaneous event, driven by
thermal energy, as depicted below in Figure 1.1. Note that the series of time-lapse
photographs show the lipid droplet oscillating in shape, due to thermal fluctuations:
Figure 1.1.
Time-lapse views of lipid vesicle
undergoing thermal fluctuations.
See also:
http://ftp.aip.org/epaps/journ_che
m_phys/E-JCPSA6-119711337/movie1.gif
Chapter 1: Introduction
Actin
Intermediate
.filaments
Microtubules
8
Chapter 1: Introduction
The schematic above shows the epithelial cells connected together by weld-like
connections at the tight junctions, and connecting with the basement membrane by
adhesions, mediate by integrin, and other matrix molecules. Stromal cells can interact
with epithelial cells through mechanical forces applied to the basement membrane that
can regulate nuclear transcription via the Integrin-CSK network.
1.5
Tensegrity (Ingber 2010)
The tensegrity model states that cells, tissues, and other biological structures at smaller
and larger size scales in the hierarchy of life gain their shape stability and their ability to
exhibit integrated mechanical behavior through use of the structural principles of
tensegrity architecture. The term, tensegrity (contraction of tensional integrity) was
first created by the architect R. Buckminster Fuller, who first explored use of this form of
Chapter 1: Introduction
structural stabilization as early as 1927 in his plan for the Wichita Dymaxion house,
which minimized weight by separating compression members from tension members.
To create this cylindrical building, Fuller proposed to set a central mast in the earth as a
vertical compression strut and to suspend from it multiple circular floors (horizontal
wheels) using tension cables. Tensile guy wires that linked the mast to surrounding
anchors in the ground provided the balancing tension necessary to stabilize the entire
structure. Fuller called this special discontinuous-compression, continuous-tension
system, the Tensegrity to emphasize how it differs from conventional architectural
systems (e.g., brick-on-brick type of construction), which depend on continuous
compression for their shape stability. Fullers more formal definition in his treatise,
Synergetics, is Tensegrity describes a structural-relationship principle in which
structural shape is guaranteed by the finitely closed, comprehensively continuous,
tensional behaviors of the system and not by the discontinuous and exclusively local
compressional member behaviors. Note that there is no mention of rigid struts, elastic
strings, tensile filaments, internal vs. external members, or specific molecular
constituents in this definition. In fact, Fuller describes a balloon with non-compressible
gas molecules pushing out against a tensed rubber membrane as analogous to one of his
geodesic domes when viewed at the microstructural level (i.e., the balloon is a porous,
tensed molecular network on the microscale) and explains that both structures are
classic examples of shape stability through tensegrity.
Fuller also described hierarchical tensegrity structures in which individual struts or
tensile elements are themselves tensegrity structures on a smaller scale; key to this
concept is that smaller tensegrity units require external anchors to other tensegrity units
to maintain higher order stability. In fact, he argued that nature utilizes this universal
system of tensile structuring at all size scales and that it provides a way to mechanically
integrate part and whole.
In 1948, Fullers student, Kenneth Snelson, constructed the first stick-and-string
tensegrity sculpture, which thrilled Fuller because it visibly communicated the essence of
this novel form of shape stability to those who could not see it in more complex
structures. Snelsons sculptures contain isolated compression members that are
suspended in midair by interconnections with a continuous tensile network. Some of
these structures require anchorage to the ground to remain stable (e.g., large
cantilevered structures); however, most are entirely self-stabilizing. Similar stick-and
string tensegrity models have been used to visualize tensegrity in cells and other
biological structures for those who cannot easily visualize them. The appearance of
geodesic patterns in biological structures, including viruses, clathrin-coated vesicles, and
actin geodomes in the cytoskeleton of mammalian cells, provides additional visual
evidence of natures use of this form of architecture.
From the above discussion, it is apparent that understanding cell structure starts with a
look at its basic structural plan. At one level, it appears that the basic architecture of the
cell is the same as the geodesic dome, designed by Buckminster Fuller. Geodesic is a
highly efficient building, whose structural elements traverse the shortest distance
required to hold it up. Many non-cellular structures, including viruses, enzymes,
organelles and even small organisms, all exhibit geodesic forms. Stick models of the
structure are shown at left in Figure 1.5, and the CSK of a living cell is shown at right.
10
Chapter 1: Introduction
1.6
Forces that hold the cell together
Tensegrity models can be made from sticks and rubber bands. Their integrity relies on
the tension applied to the sticks by the elastic elements; hence the structure has
tensegrity. In engineering terms, the sticks represent struts, since they sustain
compression and the rubber bands represent ties (or ropes) since they hold tension.
While the geodesic dome has a characteristic spherical shape, many other shapes are
held together by tensegrity, not the least of which is standing bipeds (see below). Your
bones are struts compressed by gravity, while your skeletal muscles act as ropes,
applying tension to maintain posture. Another structure is the loaded bow, shown
below:
Figure 1.6. Biped and bow tensegrity structures.
Bow and Arrow
Compression
Muscle
Tension
mg
Tension
11
Chapter 1: Introduction
hard-wired network of molecular struts and rods that stabilize cell shape. Thus the cell
uses tension rods and compression struts to hold itself together.
In simplest terms, tensegrity structures maintain shape stability within a tensed network
of structural members by incorporating other support elements that resist compression.
The stiffness of the stick-and-string tensegrity structures, and hence their ability to resist
shape distortion, depends on the level of preexisting tension or pre-stress in the
structure before application of an external load. The distinguishing microstructural
feature accounting for this behavior is that, when placed under load, the discrete
structural elements move, changing orientation and spacing relative to one another, until
a new equilibrium configuration is attained. For this reason, a local stress can result in
global structural rearrangements and action at a distance.
To visualize tensegrity at work, think of the human body: it stabilizes its shape by
interconnecting multiple compression-resistant bones with a continuous series of tensile
muscles, tendons, and ligaments, and its stiffness can vary depending on the tone (prestress) in its muscles. If I want to fully extend my hand upward to touch the ceiling, I
have to tense muscles down to my toes, thus producing global structural rearrangements
throughout my body and, eventually, upward extension of my fingers. However, the body
is also multimodular and hierarchical: if I accidentally sever my Achilles tendon, I lose
form control in my ankle module, but I still maintain structural stability in the rest of my
body. Furthermore, every time I breath in, causing the muscles of my neck and chest to
pull out on my lattice of ribs, my lung expands, alveoli open, taught bands of elastin in
the extracellular matrix (ECM) relax, buckled bundles of cross-linked (stiffened) collagen
filaments straighten, basement membranes tighten, and the adherent cells and
cytoskeletal filaments feel the pull; however, nothing breaks and the deformation is
reversible. Tensegrity provides a structural basis to explain all these phenomena.
In the cellular tensegrity model, the stabilizing pre-stress is generated actively by the
cells contractile apparatus and passively by distension through extracellular adhesions,
by osmotic forces acting on the cells surface membrane, and, on a smaller scale, by
forces exerted by molecular filaments extending through chemical polymerization. The
model assumes that the pre-stress is carried by tensile elements in the cytoskeleton,
primarily actin microfilaments and intermediate filaments, and that the cell is both a
hierarchical and multimodular structure. This pre-stress is balanced by interconnected
structural elements that resist being compressed at different size scales, including the
cells external adhesions to the relatively inflexible ECM and internal cytoskeletal
filaments, specifically microtubules that stretch across large regions of the cytoplasm and
cross-linked bundles of cytoskeletal filaments that stabilize specialized microdomains of
the cell surface (e.g., actin microfilaments in filopodia; microtubules in cilia). In this
model, the internal cytoskeleton is surrounded by an elastic sub-membranous
cytoskeleton (e.g., actin-ankyrin-spectrin network) and its associated lipid bilayer, which
may or may not mechanically couple to the internal, tensed microfilament-microtubuleintermediate filament lattice depending on the type of adhesion complex that forms. The
entire cytoskeleton is permeated by the viscous cytosol. Most importantly, this
micromechanical model leads to specific predictions relating to the mechanical role of
distinct cellular and molecular elements in cell shape control.
Contrasting models of cell structure depicts the cell as an elastic cortex that surrounds a
viscous cytoplasm with an elastic nucleus in its center. In engineering terms, this is a
continuum model, and, by definition, it assumes that the load-bearing elements are
12
Chapter 1: Introduction
infinitesimally small relative to the size of the cell. It is essentially the balloon model
considered by Fuller, but in this case all microstructure is ignored. Because they ignore
microstructural features, continuum models cannot provide specific predictions that
relate to the functional contribution of distinct cytoskeletal filaments to cell mechanics.
Furthermore, although these models can provide empirical fits to measured mechanical
properties in cells under specific experimental conditions, they cannot predict how these
properties alter under new challenges to the cell.
How closely does the geodesic model fit the CSK? To test its validity, suppose you hit one
of the struts of the geodesic dome. This would cause the mechanical energy to quickly
travel throughout all the struts, reverberating throughout the structure at the speed of
sound. Does the cell have a corresponding behavior? The answer is yes, since when the
CSK is perturbed at a single site, either by a specific binding event, or experimental
poking, the entire structure feels it, as the energy is dissipated throughout at the speed
of sound.
Next compare dome behavior with another cellular characteristic: shape. Geodesic
domes would quickly collapse if most of its struts were removed; conversely the dome
shape cannot be radically altered by pulling on a few of its struts. Neither of these
features of domes is shared by cells. For example, the normally spherical shape of cells in
culture will persist even after all microtubules are removed either through drugs or gene
knockout. Conversely, cells can flatten when stress is applied to the cell struts by its
ECM, as depicted in Figure 1.7 below. If living cells can remain spherical without most
of its struts, and then change from spherical to flat when stressed, then their behavior
does not closely resemble that of a geodesic dome, and tensegrity must be a more
adaptable concept. In other words, the CSK must have built-in redundancy that is
provided by the microfilament network, and its structure is highly modifiable. In fact,
redundancy of the CSK is to be expected, since its construction can be characterized as
fractal, i.e. structural forms are self-similar at different scales; stated another way, the
network weight and its volume are independent of each other. Thus the simple geodesic
dome model falls short of predicting some cell capabilities.
The ability of
microfilaments to adapt to stress by either stress-stiffening or stress softening will be
further discussed in Chapter 10.
Figure 1.7.
Response of a
single cell to
stress.
1.7
CSK Mechanoreflexes
The CSK apparently can sense the forces applied to it, and adjust its size, strength, and
orientation in order to resist the forces in an efficient manner. When stresses are highly
polarized, such as along the axis of muscles or neurons, filaments of the CSK align
themselves according to principal stress directions, as shown in Figure 1.8 below.
Besides orienting along stress lines, filaments size themselves according to strength
requirements: a conservative architectural practice.
13
Chapter 1: Introduction
1.8
Construction of the CSK
While there are many aspects of cellular architecture remaining to be discussed, lets
consider one more question: how is the CSK constructed? Surely there are blueprints, i.e.
genes, for each of the protein components, and an overall blueprint laying out their 3dimensional arrangement, but how do the ropes and rods connect themselves properly,
in the right amount and orientation to form the fantastic structures seen above? This is a
fundamental problem of biological development. While there is no simple answer, there
are two somewhat competing models or theories that provide at least scenarios of how it
could happen.
One assembly sequence for the CSK could be similar to that of the geodesic dome, with
regular sub-structures such as triangles, being welded one by one into a 3 dimensional
network. Tensegrity would hold the structure together, and would allow it to adapt and
change. The attractive concept that the CSK represents essentially a fullerene structure
was originally proposed by Ingber and subsequently supported by many studies.
While tensegrity and the geodesic dome definitely apply to cells, it is difficult to imagine
how the complex CSK structures seen above assemble and maintain their shape.
Geodesic models significantly change shape or collapse when a single strut or rope is cut,
a behavior that cells do not share. One way cell stability could occur is by percolation
[Forgacs], a process of network formation whereby individual lines grow somewhat
randomly from point to point until sufficient connectivity establishes a network.
A simple example of percolation is the growth of telephone lines linking the East and
West coasts of the U.S. There is no direct line connecting NY with Los Angeles; however,
in the development of lines between intervening cities, eventually a continuous pathway
was formed, and as lines continued to link cities, more and more pathways were formed.
Thus a large number of redundant pathways link the structure end-to-end. Figure 1.9
14
Chapter 1: Introduction
below shows a hypothetical telephone network in the U.S. many years ago. Note that
lines between cities in the Northern sector do link NY with LA. As more cities are
connected, it can be seen that more pathways will connect the 2 coastal cities. Since
removal of a single line from the network can disrupt the continuously connected
pathway from NY to LA, this network has a just critical number of elements for spanning
the distance; it is therefore at its, percolation threshold.
LA
NY
Similarly, Figure 1.10 shows a snapshot of a portion of the Internet web: Do you see any
resemblance to the CSK?
Figure 1.10. A
portion of the
Internet web.
15
Chapter 1: Introduction
and exploitation of biological structures can be highly profitable, since cells require no
patent royalties. The material below can absorb impact energy well, because shocks are
dissipated thoroughly throughout the structure.
The CSK behavior of stress-stiffening has inspired flexible fabrics that get stiffer when
stretched, while maintaining their porosity for critical heat exchange. Development of an
"artificial gill" for oxygen production is underway, using the high surface area and
efficient solid-state catalysis offered by CSK design.
16
Chapter 1: Introduction
Biomimicry of cytomechanical design is advancing many other technologies, including
tissue engineering, wound healing, microtubular nanostructures, bioprocess
optimization, cryogenics mechanoelectrical signaling, tumor therapies, and genetic
regulation. Microtubules serve as perfectly straight templates for fabrication of
nanowires.
With the preceding cursory view of structural principals of the cell (whose mechanical
details are discussed in later chapters, we are now ready to take a closer look. In later
chapters we will ask more probing questions: What other roles does the CSK play? How
does it interact with the nucleus? How is it formed and maintained?
_______________________________________________________
Chapter 1
Exercises and Review Questions
1. Examine Figure 1.1 (and the movie) and explain briefly the events it depicts.
2. What are the general names for structural components that resist compression &
tension? Which cellular components correspond? Compare structural properties
of microtubules, spectrin, and actin filaments, and state a different role for each
of them.
3. List three examples that could represent tensegrity structures. Sketch them and
draw their free body diagrams.
4. State three differences between cellular and building architecture.
5. Demonstrate the percolation threshold of network formation, using
connect_the_dots.m on Sakai. What conditions affect formation of a
spanning network?
6. Examine the Simulink model #1 discussed in class, and make and test your own.
Be sure to document the model and label its components.
References
Eyckmans, J., T. Boudou, et al. (2011). "A Hitchhiker's Guide to Mechanobiology."
Developmental Cell 21(1): 35-47.
More than a century ago, it was proposed that mechanical forces could drive
tissue formation. However, only recently with the advent of enabling biophysical
and molecular technologies are we beginning to understand how individual cells
transduce mechanical force into biochemical signals. In turn, this knowledge of
mechanotransduction at the cellular level is beginning to clarify the role of
mechanics in patterning processes during embryonic development. In this
perspective, we will discuss current mechanotransduction paradigms, along with
the technologies that have shaped the field of mechanobiology.
Ingber, D. E. (2008). "Tensegrity-based mechanosensing from macro to micro."
Progress in Biophysics & Molecular Biology 97(2-3): 163-179.
This article is a Summary of a lecture on cellular rnechanotransduction that was
presented at a symposium on "Cardiac Mechano-Electric Feedback and
Arrhythmias" that convened at Oxford, England in April 2007. Although critical
mechanosensitive molecules and cellular components, such as integrins, stretchactivated ion channels, and cytoskeletal filaments, have been shown to contribute
to the response by which cells convert mechanical signals into a biochemical
17
Chapter 1: Introduction
response, little is known about how they function in the structural context of
living cells, tissues and organs to produce orchestrated changes in cell behavior in
response to stress. Here, studies are reviewed that suggest our bodies use
structural hierarchies (systems within systems) composed of interconnected
extracellular matrix and cytoskeletal networks that span from the macroscale to
the nanoscale to focus stresses on specific mechanotransducer molecules. A key
feature of these networks is that they are in a state of isometric tension (i.e.,
experience a tensile prestress), which ensures that various molecular-scale
mechanochemical transduction mechanisms proceed simultaneously and
produce a concerted response. These features of living architecture are the same
principles that govern tensegrity (tensional integrity) architecture, and
mathematical models based on tensegrity are beginning to provide new and
useful descriptions of living materials, including mammalian cells. This article
reviews how the use of tensegrity at multiple size scales in our bodies guides
mechanical force transfer from the macro to the micro, as well as how it
facilitates conversion of mechanical signals into changes in ion flux, molecular
binding kinetics, signal transduction, gene transcription, cell fate switching and
developmental patterning. (c) 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Ingber, D. E. (2010). "From Cellular Mechanotransduction to Biologically Inspired
Engineering." Annals of Biomedical Engineering 38(3): 1148-1161.
This article is based on a lecture I presented as the recipient of the 2009 Pritzker
Distinguished Lecturer Award at the Biomedical Engineering Society annual
meeting in October 2009. Here, I review more than thirty years of research from
my laboratory, beginning with studies designed to test the theory that cells use
tensegrity (tensional integrity) architecture to stabilize their shape and sense
mechanical signals, which I believed to be critical for control of cell function and
tissue development. Although I was trained as a cell biologist, I found that the
tools I had at my disposal were insufficient to experimentally test these theories,
and thus I ventured into engineering to find critical solutions. This path has been
extremely fruitful as it has led to confirmation of the critical role that physical
forces play in developmental control, as well as how cells sense and respond to
mechanical signals at the molecular level through a process known as cellular
mechanotransduction. Many of the predictions of the cellular tensegrity model
relating to cell mechanical behaviors have been shown to be valid, and this vision
of cell structure led to discovery of the central role that transmembrane adhesion
receptors, such as integrins, and the cytoskeleton play in mechanosensing and
mechanochemical conversion. In addition, these fundamental studies have led to
significant unexpected technology fallout, including development of
micromagnetic actuators for non-invasive control of cellular signaling,
microfluidic systems as therapeutic extracorporeal devices for sepsis therapy, and
new DNA-based nanobiotechnology approaches that permit construction of
artificial tensegrities that mimic properties of living materials for applications in
tissue engineering and regenerative medicine.
18
Proteins
Carbohydrates
Biomembranes
Filaments
Amino Acids
Polymeric
Structural
Components
Sugars
Phospholipids
Peptides
Atoms
Carbon
Oxygen
Hydrogen
Nitrogen
Phosphorous, Sulphur, etc.
Monomeric
Building Blocks
Size and
Complexity
As you can see, our study of cell materials is greatly simplified by the fact that all structural
components are polymers strung together with 3 types of building blocks. The structural
components are mainly proteins, with some carbohydrates. The major categories of cellular
constituents are listed in Table 2.1 below:
Compound
Water
Protein
(Polypeptide)
Lipid (Fat)
Carbohydrate
(Sugars)
Salts
(Electrolytes)
Table 2.1.
Chemical Components of Cells
Fraction in
Relative Size
Polarity of molecule
Cell (%)
of molecule
70-80
Small
Polarized
10-20
Large
Regionally polarized
2-20
1-2
Medium
Medium to large
Non-Polarized
Regionally polarized
Small
Polarized
Note from the table that electrical polarity varies among the molecules. The importance of these
differences to cell mechanics will be appreciated in our study of Energetics in Chapter 6. Note
that lipids are non-polarized, however some amino acids are also non-polarized. Carbohydrates
19
20
70 A
H2O
Hydrophobic core
The phosphate heads are negatively charged, so the outside layers of the phospho-lipid
sandwich quite happily dissolve in water. The core, composed of long hydrocarbon tails, i.e. fatty
acids, behaves oppositely, repelling water and all hydrophilic compounds. Thus the bilayer is
elegantly arranged to exist with both faces in water, allowing the middle to act as a barrier to
movement of water-based materials. Since the membrane separates the cell plasma from the
extra-cellular milieu, it is called the plasma membrane (PM).
An anecdote about the biomembrane is that the first estimate of its thickness is attributed to
Benjamin Franklin. The story goes that he poured a volume of cooking oil into a small pond
until it was entirely covered with oil. He then divided the volume of oil poured by the area of the
pond, finding the thickness was about 30 A. The close correspondence of this number with
present day measurements of lipid monolayers illustrates the power of simple experiments. It
also demonstrates the property of phospholipids to self-assemble into a structure, i.e. a
membrane.
Due to its lipid structure, the cell membrane is non-polar and hydrophobic. Thus the membrane
can sequester charges within the cell, since they cannot penetrate the membrane. It is this
feature that is responsible for the bioelectricity of cells, which will be discussed in Chapter 6.
21
While the PM can be considered part of the CSK, it is relatively weak. It does have measurable
stiffness, however, in shear, compression and bending, as will be seen in Chapter 4. Being
essentially a Newtonian fluid, the bilayer by itself has no tensile strength. To illustrate, look at
Figure 2.4 below, showing 2 vesicles whose walls are pure lipid bilayers. Starting from the
bottom picture, you see the vesicles just touching. The next 2 pictures on top were made as the
vesicle at right is pushed out by pressure from the pipette holding it. Note that the vesicles pass
into each other. This ghost-like behaviour is due to their liquid nature.
3. Vesicles pass
through each other
Figure 2.4.
Vesicle ghosts
2. Pipette pushes
vesicle out
1. Vesicles make
contact
2.3
CSK Components
The structural basis of force transmission in cells is the Cytoskeleton (CSK). In the cytoplasm,
the CSK is a fundamental structure for mediating force transmission (Wang et al., 1993). The
CSK is a highly dynamic cellular scaffolding structure composed of filamentous actin (6 nm in
diameter), intermediate filaments (10 nm), and microtubules (23 nm). These three cytoskeletal
elements are not single proteins, but consist of many monomers able to span large distances
within the cell. Tubulins polymerize to form hollow cylinders known as microtubules and
provide a structure for motor proteins such as kinesins and dyneins to travel between different
cell compartments. Vimentin, keratin, and lamin monomers form intermediate filaments that
connect the nucleus with the endoplasmic reticulum, mitochondria, and Golgi apparatus,
providing structural integrity to the cell. Actin monomers assemble into filamentous actin (Factin) and together with myosin filaments, form the cytoskeletal contractile apparatus. The
actomyosin CSK connects multiple parts of the cell membrane as well as the cell membrane to
the nucleus (Sims et al., 1992).
At the cell membrane, these filaments anchor into clusters of proteins that include focal
adhesions (FAs) which link the CSK through transmembrane integrin receptors with the ECM.
In the extracellular space, the ECM materializes as a mesh of cross-linked proteins and
carbohydrates, and depending on the tissue, can include different constituents including
22
The extracellular matrix (ECM) consists of many filamentous proteins, including collagen,
fibronectin, vimentin, titin and others. The CSK near the membrane is rich in many other
filamentous and small proteins, such as tensin, vinculin, talin, -actinin, etc.
The most
abundant filamentous protein near the plasma membrane is actin. Note that the CSK connects
with ECM via integrin molecules that consist of alpha and beta subunits. These subunits have
ligands for specific receptors on matrix proteins. Integrin thus crosses the plasma membrane
(PM) to serve as the connector. The standard active ligand of integrin is the 3 amino acid
sequence RGD. Circulating cells such as white blood cells and platelets use their integrins as
antennae to locate cells and matrix where their function is needed. Figure 2.6 below
represents an Integrin of a platelet. With its 2 subunits, integrin resemble both in form and
23
The most abundant filament in most cells is filamentous actin (F-actin). Theses microfilaments
are most prominent around cell perimeters, and serve as ropes tying the network of other
proteins together. A notable exception to this cellular dependence on actin for rigidity is the red
blood cell, whose CSK is rich in spectrin. While actin (specifically F-actin) is the main
contractile generator in cells, it can also sustain some compression. Another type and
configuration of actin is globular, or G-actin. Both types exist in cells, as seen below in Figure
2.7, with the F-actin stained green, and the G-actin stained orange (different gray shades if this
is black & white rendering).
Figure 2.7.
Actin in a
fibroblast
Many other proteins link the main filamentous actin to the membrane, including tensin, talin,
and a-actinin, and vinculin, as shown in the cartoon. Although these many proteins, including
Integrin, are not abundant, they play crucial roles in mechanical signaling, as we will see in
subsequent chapters.
Adhesion of cells to the ECM takes place at focal adhesion complexes (FACs), as depicted above.
FACs are mechanical linkages that also serve as signal relay stations between the CSK and ECM.
24
MT
Actin
Figure 2.8. Immunostained cells showing actin in orange and microtubules in green.
The CSK is thus structured as a porous network of struts. This plan is, in fact, no different than
that of all living materials: even bone, the densest material in the body, is composed of geodesic
structures at the meso-scale. The millimeter-size subunits are arranged in a lattice oriented to
maximize strength in the direction of principal stress. Bone, like the CSK, is a strong, shock
absorbing material that distributes mechanical energy to the network, but tends to focus large,
chronic stresses to stronger and thicker support elements.
It should be noted that CSK composition varies from cell to cell, and even region to region
within one cell depending on function as well as developmental state. For example, red cells are
rich in spectrin, but deficient in actin. Muscle cells, in contrast, have very high actin content.
Growing or healing cells may have relatively high actin in their growing portions. Some cells,
25
Table 2.2
Properties of Filaments
Typical
Persistence
Elastic
Diameter (nM) Length p
Modulus
E
(m)
(Gpa)
8
15
2
25
6000
2
10-20
Mass Density
p
(Da/nm)
110
160
1.5
10-300
0.02
0.05
0.002
80
40
0.002
1
4500
1900
The long-range order of the CSK is generated by simple rules for network assembly and
disassembly. In other words, the CSK is a dynamic structure, and static pictures of it just capture
one moment of its ever-changing appearance. Examples are in Figures 2.9 below:
Figure 2.9.
a. Fluorescence micrograph of a
fish keratocyte is shown (with
the nucleus in blue). Motile cells
such as these form branched
actin-filament networks (red) at
their leading edge, and these
branched networks generate
protrusions. Together with
coordinated adhesions to a
surface (indicated by vinculin,
green) and myosin-driven
retraction, the protrusions lead
to directed movement. Scale bar,
15 m.
b. There are three basic steps
involved in the assembly of
protrusive, branched actinfilament networks: filament
elongation; nucleation and
crosslinking of new filaments
from filaments close to the
membrane; and capping of
filaments. Disassembly of the
network involves a separate set
of proteins that severs the
filaments and recycles the
subunits.
26
Cytogel
Gel
H20
Factors
Ca++, pH, heat
27
1.
Goldmann, W.H., Mechanical aspects of cell shape regulation and signaling. Cell
Biology International, 2002. 26(4): p. 313-317.
2.
http://www.bio.unc.edu/courses/2004spring/biol052-006/ch02final.pdf
3.
http://www.science.uwaterloo.ca/~cchieh/cact/applychem/waterbio.html
4.
28
RBC in isotonic
media
RBC in
moderate
hypotonicity
Figure 3.2.b.
Shapes changes in
red blood cells.
RBC in higher
hypotonicity
30
31
Outline of WBC
Microvilli
3.5 Fibroblasts
Fibroblasts serve as a glue holding tissues together and are primary manufacturers of collagen.
Shown below in Figure 3.6 are fibroblasts co-cultured with cardiac myocytes, and stained for
actin. Myocytes are brilliantly stained (white) showing an abundance of actin, while fibroblasts
(left portion) are much darker. Note that the high density of actin sometimes obscures
structural details.
Figure 3.6.
Fibroblasts and
cardiac
myocytes,
stained for actin
32
3.6
Endothelial Cells
Endothelial cells (ECs) are a good example of cytomechanical adaptability. The basic role of
ECs is to line the walls of blood vessels. They are directly exposed to flowing blood, as depicted
schematically and photographically below.
Figure 3.7.
Endothelial
Cells
3.7 Myocytes
The three types of muscle cells: skeletal, heart and smooth, each have different mechanical
structures and behaviors. Myocytes, or muscle cells, are the primary motor cells of the body,
and hence have the highest content of actin. Figure 3.9 below shows a single myocyte that has
been stained for actin. Myocytes tend to elongate to form log-shaped structures.
Figure 3.6
34
Explain how red blood cells can increase volume without increasing their surface area.
Show formulae.
2. What types of forces would be experienced by ECs in their natural state? Draw a sketch
resembling a free body diagram.
3. Describe two types of transduction that a cell can perform.
4. State 2 structural adaptations of RBCs that relate to its function.
5. Compare the way in which red and white cells adapt to different environments in the
blood stream.
6. Expand your Simulink model of gel (from Chapter 2) to include damping. Show the
various degrees of damping, i.e., under, over, etc.
References
35
Bao, G. and S. Suresh (2003). "Cell and molecular mechanics of biological materials." Natural
Materials 2(11): 715-725.
Lee, D. A., et al. (2011). "Stem Cell Mechanobiology." Journal of Cellular Biochemistry 112(1):
1-9.
36
Mechanical Environment
Normal Range
Cell Types
Bone, Cartilage
Arterial
Endothelium
Tendon
Osteocytes, Osteoblasts,
Chondrocytes
Endothelial
Skin
Organ of Corti
Muscle
(Intrafusal)
Muscle
(Extrafusal)
Mesangium
Continuous: 1X - 4X
body weight
Pulsatile: 60-140 mm
Hg;
Up to 560 +- 9
Kg/cm2
0-150 mmHg
100 dB
50-100 lbs
50-100 lbs
120 mm Hg
Tension
Fibroblast
Epidermal, fibroblast
Hair
Nerve/specialized muscle
While we know some of the forces that are applied to cells and tissues, as listed in the table
above, we know much less about how the forces are transmitted throughout the cell.
Quantifying cellular force is difficult because they are distributed among the many complex
structures within, including the cell membrane, cytoplasm, organelles, and especially the
cytoskeleton.
37
Figure 4.1
X
During constant stress, the bar, being deformable, will elongate in the direction of the F vector,
along the X direction and would shorten in the y direction. If the initial length in the X
direction, were Lo, the deformation could be measured as the strain:
x =
L Lo
Lo
The resulting stress-strain curve would typically look like one of the following:
The curve on the right
shows that for low
strains, the behavior is
linear, but begins to
deviate from linearity at
higher strain, reaching
a
maximum
stress
before curving down,
and rupturing. The
curve maximum is the
ultimate tensile stress
(UTS) and the point at
which
the
curve
becomes non-linear is
the elastic or proportional limit. The curve on the left is derived from the one on the right, by
correcting for changes in area during the test. The elastic region of the stress-strain curve
represents the stiffness of the material, defined as Youngs modulus:
Y=
x
x ; which is sometimes called the elastic modulus, E. Stiffness can be measured in both
38
After strain
y
y
(Note that for an elastic material the strain occurs almost instantaneously upon
application of the stress. Also note that to maintain constant stress, y , the applied force must
be reduced if the face area increases, but this would be a negligible change for all practical
situations). The strain in the y direction is:
direction is unconstrained:
y =
x = 0 and, x = y
Now, Consider the case where the x direction is constrained from movement, i.e. transverse
movement is resisted, making:
y
x = 0
x = x E = y E
In other words, to prevent transverse strain, you must push on the object with x. This causes an
added stress to the y direction, due to a tendency to strain:
' y = x = 2 y
and
' y = E 2 y = x
Thus the new stress in the y direction is the original unconstrained stress plus the stress caused
by transverse constraint:
39
y = E y + x
Solving for y we have the biaxial strain equation:
y =
1
( y x )
E
4.5
Types of mechanical loading
Measuring the material properties of engineering materials such as metal, ceramics, and
polymers is a straightforward and well established procedure: specimens are carefully shaped to
fixed geometries, and subjected to forces of various types, while the resulting deformation is
measured. The classical method is to take a small piece of the object under test, place it in an
Instron machine that applies tension, or compression, and torsion or bending forces as shown
below, and measure its deformation until it breaks. This procedure yields parameters such as
).
moduli of elasticity (E) and bending (M), ultimate tensile strength (UTS), and viscosity (
To characterize an entire object by these tests on small pieces it must be assumed that the
material being isotropic in 3 dimensions, i.e., its material properties are equivalent in all
directions and locations.
4.6 Measuring cellular material properties
Material properties of cells are much more complicated than most engineering materials.
Firstly, most cells and their components are highly anisotropic Secondly, material properties are
not constant, and are likely to change during the test procedure. Unlike inanimate objects that
possess static properties, cells behave. Thirdly, cells and their components are generally not
materials, but are structures, whose properties vary depending on the type of force applied.
Despite the complexity and changeability of cell structure, mechanical measurements can yield
important information about cell functions. The challenge of cell mechanical measurement has
been met with many ingenious testing devices. The basic principle of testing is to apply a small
deformation to the specimen while measuring as accurately as possible both the force applied
and the deformation as it evolves over time.
The most straightforward tests involve directly poking the cell with small flexible probes. A
simple tool for applying nano-Newton sized poking forces to cells is the fine-tipped
40
Uniaxial stress, as in Figure 4.3, also causes deformations in the other 2 Cartesian coordinates,
Y and Z, and can be quantified by Poissons ratio:
y = y = x
y
y
41
Figure 4.4
Y
1
0.7
A special case for Poissons ratio is = 0.5, meaning that the material does not change crosssectional area (nor volume) when being deformed. This type of material is called
incompressible. Note that being incompressible does not mean that it is not deformable. While
most engineering materials have = 0.3 or so, the few biological materials that have been tested,
have = 0.5 or greater. Bulk muscle, for example, can have > 1. This can be seen by
contracting your biceps- a very small shortening, i.e. axial compression, can produce a much
larger expansion as the muscle bulges upward. This indicates that muscle volume drastically
increases during contraction. Note that individual muscle fibers have much closer to 0.5, so
that the physical arrangement of the bulk muscle is the cause of the large increase.
Another special case for Poissons
ratio is for a cylinder, as shown
below. For this case, we have
y = y = x
y
y
as before, and
and
so = 1
4
y=
x
E
= . (You finish.)
42
Comparative Mechanical
Properties
Stress
Steel
Figure 4.5
Wood
Bone
Steel Wood Bone
Cells
Strain
Cells
Cellular
pre-stress
Modulus (GPa)
43
Figure 4.7
Note from the continuum model, strain magnitudes are highly anisotropic, and are greatest at
the sites of attachment. Also note, due to the complex shape, it is difficult to calculate Youngs
modulus, but the bulk cellular modulus can be estimated assuming a nominal cross-sectional
area for the cell.
4.8 Estimating Cell Stiffness (adapted from Lee, Knight et al. 2011)
In a recent study, the mechanical properties of MSCs were assessed using micropipette
aspiration in their undifferentiated state and during osteogenic and adipogenic differentiation
[Yu et al., 2010]. The authors report values for instantaneous and equilibrium Youngs moduli
for the undifferentiated cells of approximately 450 and 100 Pa, respectively. These values rise
significantly and progressively during osteogenic differentiation over a 21-day period to reach
values approximately twice that of the undifferentiated cells. These changes are closely
associated with alterations in the cell size and morphology, and with alterations in the
cytoskeleton. Indeed a previous study demonstrated a significant reduction in the modulus of
MSCs following disruption of the actin cytoskeletal organization [Tan et al., 2008]. Embryonic
stem cells have also been studied using micropipette aspiration, with results suggesting a
marked stiffening of the nucleus during differentiation, associated with the nuclear skeletal
component Lamin A/C, which is only expressed in differentiating cells [Pajerowski et al., 2007].
These findings suggest that both embryonic stem cells and MSCs may be more deformable than
their differentiated progeny. This physical plasticity may facilitate the migration of stem cells
through solid tissues to the sites of tissue damage.
44
To find equilibrium
forces:
Fup = Fdown
h
P
Ri
.
Ri
Spherical Stress
A stressed, thin walled
sphere experiences a wall
tension, which in the case
of a cell, is considered,
membrane tension. The
free-body diagram of a
stressed sphere is shown
below.
To find the
membrane tension, T, due
to internal pressure,
a
simple sum of forces will
lead
to
the
LaPlace
equation P = 2T/R
Figure 4.8
Ro
Polymer
Actin
Tubulin
Intermediate
Filaments
Silk
Collagen
filament
Collagen fibril
Elastin
Cellulose Dry
Cellulose Wet
Spectrin
DNA
Typical
Diameter
(nM)
8
25
10-20
Table 3.1
Persistence
Length, p
(
m )
15
6000
Elastic
Modulus, E
(Gpa)
2
2
Mass
Density, p
(Da/nm)
110
160
1.5
10-300
0.02
0.05
0.002
80
40
0.002
1
4500
1900
Note that the 2 major CSK components have equal moduli of 2 GPa, but this is 3 orders of
magnitude greater than spectrin, the major CSK component of RBCs. Since spectrin is much
more dense than either actin or tubulin, this means that its stiffness to weight ratio is very small.
45
Figure 4.9.
Strain > 100%
A qualitative comparison of a highly compliant polymer like elastin with a stiff one like collagen
is shown in Figure 4.10 below. Note that stiffness of both polymers increases drastically at
large strains. Also indicated in the figure, is that the stiffness depends on the strain rate, so that
collagen can behave more like elastin when stretched at an increased rate. This viscous behavior
will be further discussed in Chapter 7.
Figure 4.10
Figure 4.11
46
4.9
Flexural Moduli
Since the polymers that make-up the CSK are bar or rod-like structures (ropes and struts), they
can and do experiences all types of stresses as shown in Figure 4.1. For rods, like polymers,
the most important mechanical mode is bending. Suppose a thin rod of length L is initially
upright at zero temperature, but when warmed is bent under the influence of gravity into a
curvature with radius R:
bend
Figure 4.12
L
R
The rod has bent out of its natural shape, when R = , under conditions of zero temperature
and stress. In this case, we can imagine that the stiffness of the rod determines its curvature,
but it cannot be the same stiffness, Y, describing resistance to uniaxial stress. A new measure of
stiffness is therefore required, the flexural rigidity. For uniform rods, flexural rigidity is:
f = IY
I=
R 4
4
Thus the flexural rigidity is based on Youngs modulus multiplied by the geometric parameter
for rods, the area moment of inertia, I. To determine the amount of deformation of the rod, we
47
E arc = f
L
2R2
In order to derive a useful description of how bent a given rod would be at a given temperature,
Boltzmanns thermal formula, 3/2KT, the average energy per molecule, is needed. For this, a
new parameter is defined, the persistence length, which represents the length over which the
rod will be fairly straight. This length, p , is defined as the magnitude
f/ KT. To better
understand the meaning of p , consider the case when L = p and Earc=KT. In other words,
the bending energy just equals approximately the average energy of one molecule at
temperature T. In this case, we can substitute the conditions:
E arc =
k 2f
= kT = 4.1 pN nm
2 R 2 kT
R=
p
R
p
2
2radians = 81deg rees
Table 4.3
Thus a rod of the persistence length is
curved at 81 degrees when the thermal
energy scale reaches kT. If L << p
then the rod is relatively straight,
otherwise not. Persistence length sets
the scale of thermal fluctuations.
Filaments with contour length >>
p
are highly convoluted and can assume
many configurations.
Persistence
lengths for selected polymers are listed
in Table 4.2.
Formulae related to bending
polymers are listed in Table 4.3:
of
48
Figure 4.13
Figure 4.14
49
The picture at left shows the cell with several beads inside that have been colored from blue to
red, indicating local stiffness.
At right, a close-up of the cell shows records of particle
movement over time. Note that the upper particle traversed a relatively tight area, during the
same time that the lower particle moved over a much wider area. These random motions
indicate how stiffly the beads were trapped within the cytoskeletal network, and hence indicate
local stiffness.
By measuring the mean squared displacement of a particle <Dr2 > over a period of time,
estimate of stiffness can be estimated as
G=
an
D
Dr 2
where G= Youngs modulus, D= diffusion constant of the cytoplasm, and = viscosity of the
cytoplasm .
In the case of active microrheology, magnetic forces are applied and from the resulting
displacements (in and out of phase) of magnetic particles in the system, the frequencydependent susceptibilities are determined. These may be transformed into local moduli for a
more direct comparison with the macroscopically measured moduli.
50
Figure 4.15
P1 =
2 EI
L2
P2 = 4
2 EI
L2
P3 =
4L2
2 EI
Chapter 4
Exercises and Review Questions
1. Estimate an elastic modulus for the RBC in Figure 4.7 . State assumptions.
2. Human hair has a stiffness of 4 X 1010 dynes/cm2 . When axially strained, it undergoes
brittle breaking at a stress of 106 dynes/cm2 (there is no ductility in hair). What is the
radial strain? Assume Poissons ratio is close to that of steel, and hair length similar to
your own. Show assumptions. (Note, hair is cylindrical).
3. Calculate the energy (in terms of KT) required to bend a microtubule, 20 cm long, into a
curve with a 10cm radius? Assume the persistence length to be 2 mm.
4. Now, for the microtubule in #5, calculate the buckling force.
5. Derive Laplace law for a sphere.
6. Model 4:
References
51
52
53
Perhaps the simplest tests involve directly poking the cell, as depicted in Figure 5.1 above. A
simple probe for applying small nano-Newton level poking forces to cells is a fine-tipped micropipet. When the tip bends as it pushes on the cell, the degree of bending indicates at least
qualitatively the cell stiffness. So the probes used are more refined than a hammer, but the
principle is the same: apply a small deformation to the specimen while measuring as accurately
as possible both the force applied and the deformation as it evolves over time.
Mechanically probing single cells and even biomolecules is becoming increasingly sophisticated.
Devices for applying and measuring forces < 1 pN and deformations < 1 nM are available now.
Combining these devices with the latest imaging, molecular biology, and bioinformatics,
including modeling and simulation has led cytomechanists to revolutionize our view of the cell.
These new techniques can illuminate like never before the processes responsible for operation of
cellular machinery, the forces arising from molecular motors and the interactions between cells,
proteins and nucleic acids.
Several methods have been developed to determine the mechanical characteristics of the cell
and to understand how those characteristics change in health and disease. An innovative
apparatus was the cell poker, which was able to measure the stiffness of living cells by
applying an axial strain via a cantilever. This apparatus was also used to demonstrate that
neutrophils may be retained in capillaries in the acute inflammatory response due to an increase
in stiffness caused by chemoattractants.
Another method that has found wide use is atomic force microscopy (AFM). Intrinsic
mechanical properties of the cell have been found by applying continuum mechanics models. .
Mathematical models have also been applied to endothelial cells to understand how force is
transmitted from their apical to basal membranes by combining the AFM with total internal
reflection fluorescence microscopy.
One of the most widely used methods for studying cellular mechanics is the micropipette
aspiration technique. An adaptation of the solution for a punch problem has been used to obtain
mechanical properties of bovine aortic endothelial cells, as well as to compare normal and
osteoarthritic human chondrocytes.
The viscoelastic behavior of cells has also been studied using magnetic bead micro-rheometry.
Creep response and relaxation curves were obtained with this technique by applying tangential
force pulses on magnetic beads fixed to the integrin receptors of the cell membrane, as shown in
section 5.3 below.
The aforementioned testing methodologies can measure cellular structural properties and help
us understand various biological processes, however, there is currently no technique that can
perform stress-controlled indentation testing on single adherent cells. The application of
54
55
Tension or
Compression
Bending
Twisting
56
F1
Type A
F2
P
F1
Type C
F2
Type B
Figure 5.4.
Type A Cell
testing
modes
Bao & Suresh
In addition to the modes of cell contact, variations in the type and timing of stimuli are possible,
as depicted in Figure 5.5 below:
57
Step
Sinusoid
Ramp
Magnitude
TIME
Figure 5.5. Modes (top) and timing protocols (bottom) of force application
Some of the measurement techniques are further described below.
5.5
Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM)
In AFM, a sharp tip at the free end of a flexible cantilever (Figure 5.6) generates a local
deformation on the cell surface. The resulting deflection of the cantilever tip can be calibrated
to estimate the applied force. This is a high-resolution technique that traces the fine structure of
nanometer level objects. The tip can be conjugated with an antibody that binds to the cell
(functionalized) and then it can be used to pull on it with calibrated force.
Pull force
Bond to CSK
Cell surface
The figure at left (above) is a computer model of the mechanical deformation of a cell by the tip
of an AFM cantilever. The model is based on continuum mechanics, and it includes
contributions from the elasticity of the cell membrane as well as the interior of the cell. An
example of the type of image that AFM can produce is shown in Figure 5.7 below:
Figure 5.7.
AFM image of a
living cell. Bar=
5 microns
58
Figure 5.8. An osteosarcoma cell attached between the cantilever of an atomic force
microscope and a surface can exert contractile forces (red arrow) of more than 100 nN
(depicted from left panel to center panel and in a fluorescence micrograph, right panel). Actin
filament structures (white), including contractile stress fibres spanning the upper and lower
surfaces, are generated in the contracting osteosarcoma cell (right). Scale bar, 10 m.
5.6
Magnetic Tweezers
Magnetic beads, a few microns diameter, can be either incorporated into cells, or attached to
specific receptors. An illustration of pulling on a cell with a magnet is shown in Figure 5.9.
B Field
Magnetic
bead
Membrane
In this case, the bead has been incorporated into the cell, and is pulled with an external
magnetic field. Calibrated stretch of the membrane can be thereby done. A more specific force
can be applied to individual molecules using functionalized magnetic beads. These have been
coated with antibodies for specific CSK components such as Integrin. For example, when coated
with fibronectin, the beads will bind to Integrin. When the beads bind, an external magnetic
field can be applied to twist the bead, measuring the response of the CSK portion directly, as
shown in Figure 5.10.
By using a magnet to pull and twist individual molecules on a cell, this technique represents
magnetic tweezers. These magnetic-twisting studies confirmed that mechanical forces are
Figure 5.10. Pulling on CSK
(Wang et al., Science)
59
Micropipet aspiration can be either type A or B (Figure 5.3), depending on conditions. If the
micropipet is tightly sealed to the cell, there is no movement of the main body of cell into the
pipet, and hence only the patch is deformed- this is type A. If there is no seal and no friction
between the cell and the pipet, then the whole cell gets squeezed into the pipet, and it is a type B
stimulus.
Figure 5.11
Aspiration
Negative Pressure
Drawing of Micropipet
Aspiration
Magnified view
of cell patch
showing CSK
60
5.8
Cell Moduli from Pipet Aspiration (Lee et al.)
The micropipette aspiration technique can measure stiffness of an individual cell with a known
aspiration pressure (see Fig. 5.10). The technique has been widely used to determine the
mechanical properties of a variety of cell types including stem cells [Hochmuth, 2000].
Micropipettes, with inner diameters typically between 5 and 15 mm, are used to induce
deformation of the whole cell, or alternatively discrete regions of the cell, depending on the cell
diameter. Moreover, the properties of subcellular components, most notably the nucleus and
cytoskeleton may be investigated. With the control of a hydraulic micromanipulator, the
micropipette is moved into contact with the cell surface and pressures applied and the cell
visualized using bright field or fluorescence microscopy.
Two approaches have been used for performing the aspiration technique. For the incremental
approach, pressure is applied typically in steps up to 5 cmH20 (0.49 kPa), with the equilibrium
cell aspiration length, L, recorded at each pressure. The pipette internal diameter is given by a .
The apparent Youngs modulus may then be determined using a theoretical model [Theret et al.,
1988]. In this model, the cell is assumed to be a homogeneous, elastic half-space material and
the Youngs modulus, E, is therefore given as follows, where () is defined as the wall function
with a typical value of 2.1:
(1)
Here, Youngs modulus can thus be determined from the slope of the linear regression of the
normalized length, L/a, versus the negative suction pressure P.
For the alternative approach, in which pressure is applied in a single step, the following
equation is fitted to the temporal changes in aspiration length measured experimentally (Eq. 2).
This model assumes that the cell behaves as a homogenous linear viscoelastic three-parameter
solid half-space.
(2)
The relaxation time constant t is defined as follows (Eq. 3).
(3)
61
(4)
also possible to determine the apparent equilibrium Youngs model given by:
It should be recognized that although these models benefit from being simple, they neglect
geometrical factors, such as finite cell dimensions, evolution of cell-micropipette contact region
and curvature of the micropipette edges. Thus, other models incorporating these geometric
factors into a computational form have been developed [Haider and Guilak, 2000], which can
also account for the heterogeneity in cellular properties.
5.9
Nuclear Probing
Micropipets can even be used to probe into sub-cellular structures, such as the nucleus as shown
below. This sequence of pictures shows the pipet drawing a single chromosome into the pipet
and gradually pulling it out of the nucleus. This remarkable experiment revealed the surprising,
and still unexplained, phenomenon that all the chromosomes and the nucleoli are connected
together by strings of DNA.
Micropipets have also been used to measure the strength of single chemical bonds that a cell
makes with its matrix. The pipet grabs onto the cell like a leech, and then can pull with a
calibrated force until the bond breaks (Evans). With a manually 0perated micromanipulation
device, the micropipette is moved "like a golf club" to move the beads about 10 micrometers a
second, while monitoring the cell with the video microscope.
Figure 5.14.
Pulling out the
chromosomes
62
Stretch
Tension
Pi
C o
Qm (K w)
Ci =constant
B. Isolated Cell
Stretch
Solutes
Pi
Solutes
C i (t)
Qm (Kw )
Trap
Bead
Actua
tor
Bead
Mesangial
Cell
C i
Mesangial
Cell
C o
Trap Bead
RNA
Magnified
View
Handle
Force
Actuator
Bead
63
Optical tweezers offers several non-contact ways of driving cells. While early optical tweezers
simply trapped and moved particles, it is possible to spin particles or cells at high speeds and
also to orient them in separate traps and then join them together in lock-and-key assemblies. In
a levitation trap the laser beam balances the pull of gravity. To optically trap a particle in
three dimensions it is necessary to exert a longitudinal force in the same direction as the laser
beam and a transverse force at right angles to the beam. The transverse force is created by
having the maximum laser intensity at the center of the beam. If the particle is to the left, say, of
the center of the beam, it will refract more light from the right to the left, rather than vice versa.
The net effect is to transfer momentum to the beam in this direction, so, by Newtons third law,
the particle will experience an equal and opposite force back towards the center of the beam.
In this example the particle is a dielectric sphere. Similarly, if the beam is tightly focused it is
possible for the particle to experience a force that pushes back towards the laser beam. We can
also consider an energetic argument: when a polarizable particle is placed in an electric field, the
net field is reduced. The energy of the system will be a minimum when the particle moves to
wherever the field is highest, which is at the focus. Therefore, potential wells are created by
local maxima in the fields. Depiction of the apparatus for examining red blood cells being
stretched by optical tweezers is shown in Figure 5.17 below:
64
65
66
Substrate topography can be micropatterned so that cells are induced to grow onto tiny elastic
platforms that can be moved to apply or measure force. This is a powerful technique, since the
platforms can be precisely controlled, and can be functionalized with specific cellular matrix
targets. Thus the micropattern can test and perturb cell-matrix interactions in a highly
controlled environment. For example, the strength and behavior of specific focal adhesions can
be studied. The contractile forces generated by cells during locomotion and mitosis can also
been measured with a deformable-substrate method.
Micromechanical systems used for cell mechanics studies broadly fall into two major categories.
The first category comprises hard silicon-based devices that are fabricated using standard IC
manufacturing techniques, whereas the second category comprises systems made of soft
polymers and gels.
Examples of MEMS cell testing systems are shown above. Two configurations are a cluster of
microneedles (Figure 5.21.a and b) or a cantilever beam (Figure 5.21.c). The device in
Figure 5.21.d d can apply mechanical force or deformation at several points on a cell in the
center.
The effect of various MEMS on cellular shape and behavior are shown in Figure 5.22 below.
67
68
6. Model 5: Above
69
References
Bao, G. and S. Suresh (2003). "Cell and molecular mechanics of biological materials." Nat
Mater 2(11): 715-725.
Living cells can sense mechanical forces and convert them into biological responses.
Similarly, biological and biochemical signals are known to influence the abilities of cells
to sense, generate and bear mechanical forces. Studies into the mechanics of single cells,
subcellular components and biological molecules have rapidly evolved during the past
decade with significant implications for biotechnology and human health. This progress
has been facilitated by new capabilities for measuring forces and displacements with
piconewton and nanometre resolutions, respectively, and by improvements in bioimaging. Details of mechanical, chemical and biological interactions in cells remain
elusive. However, the mechanical deformation of proteins and nucleic acids may provide
key insights for understanding the changes in cellular structure, response and function
under force, and offer new opportunities for the diagnosis and treatment of disease. This
review discusses some basic features of the deformation of single cells and biomolecules,
and examines opportunities for further research.
Eyckmans, J., T. Boudou, et al. (2011). "A Hitchhiker's Guide to Mechanobiology."
Developmental Cell 21(1): 35-47.
More than a century ago, it was proposed that mechanical forces could drive tissue
formation. However, only recently with the advent of enabling biophysical and molecular
technologies are we beginning to understand how individual cells transduce mechanical
force into biochemical signals. In turn, this knowledge of mechanotransduction at the
cellular level is beginning to clarify the role of mechanics in patterning processes during
embryonic development. In this perspective, we will discuss current
mechanotransduction paradigms, along with the technologies that have shaped the field
of mechanobiology.
70
At the molecular level, mechanical behavior is statistical, and requires special parameters to
explain it. The Boltzmann distribution provides a simple explanation for the behavior of
molecules exposed to an energy gradient. The energy gradient can be forces applied by
mechanical, electrical, or chemical means. It is based on the probabilistic nature of molecules,
and has widespread applications. The basic formulation is:
F
P1
= e kT
P2
(1)
where P's are the probabilities of states or classes 1 and 2, and DF is free energy.
For example Pi can represent the concentration of particles in 2 separate compartments. Lets
say the energy in the first compartment is F1 and in the second, it is F2, and DF= F2-F1. Since
the particles must either be in compartment 1 or 2, then P1 + P2 =1. So
To illustrate this, take a system whose neutral state (P1=P2= 0.5) is an energy level of 5kT. In
other words, the neutral state is when the system can be in either state with equal probability.
1
P1( x) :=
1+ e
x 5
P2( x) :=
1+ e
( x 5)
1
P1( x)
P2( x)
Figure 6.1
0.5
10
One such system would be the particle distribution on earth surface or in the air. The dotted
line (P2) would represent the likelihood of finding the particle on the surface (for a mass of 0, P2
= 0), and the dark (red) line would represent finding it above the surface. As expected, as mass
of the particle increased, you would find more of it landing on the ground, and less of it in the
air. At some mass, represented by 5kT, there is an equal probability of finding the particle on the
ground or in the air. Many other compartmental situations can be similarly represented.
71
A mechanical behavior that is well described statistically by the Boltzmann relation is the
tendency of polymers to shift from one state to another, depending on energy levels. Examples
of these shifts are the opening and closing of ion channels and the folding and unfolding of
nucleic acids. The latter behavior can be seen in RNA strands that were pulled by optical
tweezers, as shown in Figure 6.2:
Trap
Bead
Trap Bead
RNA
Actuat
or
Magnified
View
Handle
Force
Actuator
Bead
The above set-up shows a strand of RNA held at either end by a binding site on the beads. Note
that the bead size is much larger than the RNA. When the strand is stretched, it behaves as an
ordinary spring at very low and very high levels of tension, but at intermediate ranges, it
exhibited unfolding and re-folding behavior, as depicted in Figure 6.3:
22 nM
As the force is slowly raised above 14 pN, the strand will suddenly unfold and then refold again,
with the unfolded state becoming more frequent as force increases, until it remains permanently
unfolded at a force level above 15 pN. In other words, the probability of unfolding is related to
force, as described by the Boltzmann equation. This behavior is quantified in Figure 6.4.
72
Unfolding upward
Folding downward
Figure 6.4.a. Opening
behavior of RNA at selected
tensions
.
Figure 6.4.b. Fraction of
hairpins folded versus force
This behavior appears to represent a balance between the applied force and the attractive forces
within the RNA fold, including base-pairing, hydration, charge shielding, and Van der Walls.
Thus the fraction of time spent in a state is equivalent to the probability of finding the strand in
that state, and is related to force applied, according to the Boltzmann relationship, where Fo is
the ground energy state, f is applied force, and z is displacement:
Popen =
1+ e
Fo fDz
kT
Within any given time period, T, the probability of being open or unfolded can be calculated as
the fraction of open time:
Popen =
t open
T
73
cm
sec
First the flux of particles per unit time, j, (i.e. number of particles p.u. time) passing a given
point is directly proportional to the concentration gradient, C:
j = D
dC
dx
Ficks 1st
Law
To describe how concentration changes with time, Ficks second law is used:
dC
= DD2 C
dt
where
D2 =
Ficks 2nd
Law
d2
dx 2
A special case of Ficks 2nd law can be set-up to arrive at a simple formula for estimating
diffusion time. This is the case in which an amount of substance is placed in solution at the point
x=0, and its concentration spread with time becomes uniform over x. With these initial and
boundary conditions, Ficks 2nd law is solved analytically as:
C=
1
x2
exp(
)
4pDt
4 Dt
P ( x)dx =
1
2x
exp(
x2
2x 2
)dx
Since concentration of particles is directly related to the probability of finding them in a given
distance dx, C P(x)dx. So equating the 2 formulae yields a simple estimate of the time of
diffusion for a particular solute, given its coefficient, D, as shown below:
Standard estimate of diffusion time. Please note that the
bar over the x is not a negative sign.
The right hand side of the above should read "X bar squared", and represents the spread of
concentration in the x direction. Note that it is analogous to the statistical quantity of variance.
74
Bioelectricity
6.3.a
Internal charge and electrochemical equilibrium
Cells have trapped negative charges in the form of proteins, amino acids, and nucleic acids.
These are charged mostly because of their side groups, in particular carboxyl, that is loses a
proton at neutral pH. For example, alanine is shown below:
PKa = 9
H3N-CH-COO-
pKa= 2.7
CH3
Note that the net charge of theses amphiphilic molecules can be calculated by summing the
charge of each group, using the Henderson-Hasselback equation:
AH A + H +
Kequ =
[ A ][ H + ]
[ AH ]
[ A ]
log( Kequ ) = log
+ log[ H + ]
[ AH ]
[ A ]
log
= pKa pH
[ AH ]
pH pKa +
()
log A
( HA )
- = fractional - charge =
(A )
(A
+ AH
1
- =
1+
1
alog ( pH pKa)
The above equation gives the proportion of negatively charged molecules within the group,
for a given pH. Each side chain has a particular acid-base relationship, with a specific pKa.
A corresponding relationship can be derived for the positively charged (i.e. amino) group.
Cells thus have a trapped negative charge at neutral pH, in the form of big, impermeable
solutes, is the root cause of the electrical potential of all cells. These impermeable solutes
are amino acids, nucleic acids, and other compounds with a tendency to become negatively
charged. To balance the charge, cations that are mobile and permeant through the
75
Eion =
RT [ion]out
ln(
)
zF
[ion]in
and
[+ion][ion]out = [+ion][ion]in
The Nernst potential is the electrical potential that exactly balances the chemical gradient of
mobile ions that balances the trapped negative charge. The Donnan relation is a direct result
of the Nernst. You can see this by noting, if the mobile counterions are K+ and Cl- , the
Nernst potential for each ion must be the same, since at equilibrium there can be only one
potential for the cell. Thus the ions that are freely permeable are those that determine the
cell potential. For most cells these are K+ and Cl-. Note that the Donnan equilibrium applies
only to K and Cl, and not to other ion pairs, that are not freely permeable.
Deriving the Nernst equation comes directly from the Boltzmann relationship, as illustrated
below, using the distribution of particles in the atmosphere as an example:
Deriving the Basic Bioelectric Equation
w.
kT
q.
V
kT
where
So for molar
quantities:
C C o .e
and
z.
V
RT
C = N particles/vol * mass/particle
RT .
z
ln
Co
C
V =
RT C 0
ln( )
zF
Ci
76
Figure 4.5
77
I = NgVp open
Massflux :
I
J=
F
6.4
Energy Storage
The vast majority of cellular energy is stored in the high energy phosphate bond of the ATP
molecule. One ATP molecule is equivalent to 80 pN-nM or 8 N-m/g. Note that the units of
torque and energy are equivalent.
6.5
State Transitions
The RNA unfolding example represents the general process of state transition. The general way
to represent it is:
K21
1
2
K12
With the 2 compartments or states shown, transition rate K21, represents the flow rate of
material from compartment 1 into compartment 2; K12 represents the opposite motion. This is a
2-state, closed system, since no compartment excretes material to the outside or any other
compartment. A closed system is the simplest to deal with, since the mathematics is easy (as will
be seen in the more advanced treatment at the end). Note that for the RNA example, states 1
and 2 could represent the folded and unfolded conditions, and K21 would represent the rate
constant for unfolding, and K12 the rate constant for folding.
We can represent the kinetics of the system as follows:
dX 1
= K 21 X 1 + K 12 X 2
dt
and
(1)
dX 2
= K 21 X 1 K 12 X 2
dt
Or better in matrix notation as the state variable representation:
X 1 a11
= a
X 21
2
a12 X 1
a 22
X2
(2)
78
X = AX
(3)
where it is assumed that X and A are matrices. Note that we are analyzing a system with only 2
compartments, but the above state equation (3) applies to systems with any number of
compartments. So if there were p components, equation (3) would represent:
X i = ai1 X 1 + ai 2 X 2 + ... + a1 p X p
(4)
k12
k
A= 21
k21 k12
Once you check that this is true, you can ask, how can I analyze the system? It should be
apparent that you can solve each differential equation readily using a solver such as Simulink.
You can also solve the entire system by coupling the equations.
You first must understand what X represents. In our case, it represents probability. One way to
look at it is to recognize that the entire two-compartment system can represent many RNA
chains, that can either be in state 1 or state 2. The fraction, or state probability, P1, of being
folded and the probability of being unfolded, P2, are:
P1 =
# folded
# folded + # open
and
P2 =
# open
# folded + # open
79
Kopen = 7 sec-1
Kfold = 1.5 sec-1
6.6
Polymerization
To understand how the CSK and its functional behavior emerges from discrete components, lets
look at the kinetics of polymerization. In Figure 6.7, actin filaments were nucleated from beads
coated with the nucleation-promoting factor ActA (not shown) and were then crosslinked by
fascin inside a unilamellar lipid vesicle
Figure 6.7. Purified proteins
were loaded into a vesicle by a
microfluidic encapsulation
technique that allows the dynamics
of filament assembly to be
observed immediately after
encapsulation.
The micrograph (left) shows
labeled actin filaments (white) that
have polymerized inside the vesicle
and have assembled into a fascincrosslinked network.
The diagram (right) is a schematic
depiction of the actin filament
network present in the inset box of
the micrograph
Polymers are assembled from monomers (captured), and disassembled (released) back into
monomers, generally as a first order system as depicted below:
(capture)
(1)
(release)
dn/dt = -koff
(2)
80
__________________________________________________________________
Chapter 6
Review Questions and Exercises
First Week
1. Using the data shown in Figure 6.6 above, and the ground free energy, Fo = 79 kT, graph
the unfolding probability, using Excel or other program. Put data points from empirical
experiments for the selected forces on your theoretical curve. (Note data represent
numbers obtained from experimental measurements (not calculations); a theoretical
curve is generated by formula).
2. Make a Simulink model of the RNA unfolding kinetics. Your model should be
well documented, according to the following guidelines:
Sub-systems should be used so that the entire model can be fit onto 1 page
and each sub-system can be printed separately, with documentation.
81
Outside Concentration, mM
Inside Concentration, mM
[Na+]
150
144
[K+]
4
[Cl-]
114
[HCO3-] 28
b. What is the transmembrane biopotential?
c. What is the concentration of proteins in the cell? ( assume proteins are the only
solute other than electrolyte, and they have a charge of -1).
d. At what potential (if any) are all ions at equilibrium?
3. Model 6: Make a Simulink model of the RNA unfolding kinetics. Your model
should be well documented, according to the following guidelines:
Sub-systems should be used so that the entire model can be fit onto 1 page
and each sub-system can be printed separately, with documentation.
References
1.
82
83
One of the important phenomena in cell engineering and developmental biology is the
shape of tissue and the cells organization.
environmental conditions, cells can create unique shapes such as flat sheets, selfenclosed monolayers, cysts, or elongated tubes. The more important question is how
these cells interact and how their local interaction causes a global geometrical
distinctive shape for tissues like the heart or kidney. The geometrical interactions and
coordinated adhesion among neighboring cells and between the cells and local
environment are critical for structure and function of epithelial tissue. Any perturbation
of these orchestrated interactions can cause abnormality in behavior and function of
tissue and often lead to initiation of tumor growth and invasion. Another interesting
subject is embryogenesis, when a stem cell with consecutive rapid divisions and
differentiation can create different tissues, wherein the interactions between cells and
environmental biochemical and biomechanical signals have critical, yet nearly unknown
roles. However, in the last two decades, improved experimental techniques and
developments have allowed for more detailed understanding of cell-cell communication
and the cells response to biochemical and biomechanical environmental signals, as
reviewed in Chapter 5. Nevertheless, biological experiments are expensive and depend
on many parameters that are mostly difficult to control and test in isolation.
7.2
Cell Modeling
Mathematical modeling and computational experiments can help explore the behavior
of the individual tissue cells along with investigating their response to environmental
cues. Due to easy isolation in in-silico computational models, incorporating the related
fundamental physical and biological parameters can explain how specific biochemical or
biomechanical parameters may affect the tissue cells and their arrangement. Such a
model can reduce the number of experiments required to obtain meaningful
observations by eliminating unlikely hypothesis while providing a better explanation of
observations. For example, to investigate how individual cells cooperate and contribute
to the overall structure and function of a particular tissue, a proper computational
84
model could define cells as individually deformable shapes, time- and space-dependent
individually regulated cell turnover, and cell-cell and cell-ECM interaction. Many
models have been developed to mimic cell behavior, such as response to external
mechanical and biochemical signals, cell-cell interaction, cell motility, and cell
morphology.
Some models have attempted to mimic collective cell behaviors such as cancer invasion
through the use of continuum and/or discrete approaches where each cell is represented
by a finite element and follows a cellular automata method. Cells can be modeled as
colloidal objects capable of interacting with their environment. In such models, cells are
capable of migrating, growing, dividing, and changing their orientation. In a model
proposed by Galle, Loeffler et al. (2005), the cells move according to the Langevin
dynamics framework and can interact based on a combination of attractive and
repulsive forces. The aim of these models is to replicate the multi-cellular growth
phenomena. By focusing on monolayer culture, Galle et al. have investigated the effect
of key factors on rate and quality of culture growth. They also analyzed the underlying
processes involved in multi-cellular spheroids, intestinal crypts, and other aspects of
developmental biology.
Models can mimic various aspects of cell population, but fail to examine the effects of
cell deformation and morphology on pattern formation and growth processes. Some
models are based on the viscoelasticity of cells, where each cell includes certain elastic
and viscous elements. Such models lend themselves to easy incorporation of the cell-cell
adhesion and repulsion, and various forces acting on individual cells in the cluster. For
example, a 3D deformable cell model with cell adhesion and signaling was developed by
Palsson and colleagues, where each cell is assumed to be ellipsoid shape, with its axis
composed of a combination of springs and viscous elements . This model was used to
investigate the role of cell signaling, cell adhesion, chemotaxis, and coordinated
differentiation in the morphology of a developed organism. Another biomechanical
approach developed by Rejniak and colleagues
viscoelastic objects that can be arranged into tissues of various topologies. This
approach joins elastic cell dynamics with a continuous representation of a viscous
85
incompressible cytoplasm. The model covers many aspects of cellular behavior such as
cell growth, division, apoptosis and polarization. With this model it is possible to
investigate the biomechanical properties of cells and cell-cell interaction, the effects of
the microenvironment on a cellular cluster, and how individual cells work together and
contribute to the structure and function of a particular tissue. An application of this
model is tumor growth .
More recently, Coskun et al. developed a mathematical
86
7.3
The mechanical properties of the cytoskeleton, like elasticity and viscosity, are critical to
the validity of the model. Voigt subunits are effective for modeling a viscoelastic system;
the spring constants of the model are linear approximations to the elasticity of the inner
cell. Additionally, all springs are subjected to a damping force resulting from the
viscosity of the cytoplasm, where linear dashpots approximate the viscosity of the
cytoskeleton (Figure 7.1).
uniformly radial
distributed parts, each of which is represented by a Voigt subunit radiating from the
nucleus (Figure 7.1, blue subunits). Each subunit connects two points of the cell and
nuclear membrane, which are aligned in a radial direction from the center of the
nucleus. The nucleo-skeleton is represented as a viscoelastic model involving an
actomyosin system (Figure 7.1, red subunits). The model also contains N Voigt subunits
in the nucleus ( red subunits). The equation below is the sum of all possible forces on
the cell:
Figure 7.1
Cell Model
87
7.4
V-E analysis assumes that a complex material can be modeled as a purely viscous
material (a dashpot) combined with a purely elastic material (a spring).
It thus
mathematically separates the viscosity of a material from its elasticity. A purely viscous
component is a Newtonian fluid- it has no memory and no elasticity; it cannot deform as
a solid. In cells and tissues, material properties vary from behaving as pure fluids, to
not very pure fluids, to solids, to solid-liquid composites. Despite this diversity, V-E
tools can quantify each of their properties, since the models separate viscosity from
elasticity in a kind of finite element model.
Elastic deformations experienced by structures can be characterized by their particular
stress/strain curves. Examples of such curves for three typical behaviors are shown in
Figure 7.2:
s
e
The above curves represent the stiffness of the structure, as measured by their slopes at
any point. The curve on the left represents rubber-type behaviour, since it is relatively
stiff for small strains, relatively compliant (un-stiff) for intermediate strains, and again
is relatively stiff for high strains. Thus there are 3 separate regions of rubber behaviour,
each of which has a molecular explanation. The middle curve is representative of
standard structural materials. The curve on the right is representative of a purely
Newtonian fluid.
An important factor that has been left out of the above analysis of elasticity is time. It
must be recognized that each curve represents a single point in time ( or as close to a
single point in time as possible). That point in time could represent either an
88
equilibrium or a non-equilibrium situation. The only way to learn the role of timedependent changes in stiffness, is to measure it at a sequence of times following each
stress or strain application. In doing this, you would be measuring viscoelastic
properties. In other words, viscoelasticity can be defined as: stiffness as a function of
time. Materials that have time dependent stress/strain behaviour are called
viscoelastic.
For example, a hydraulic shock absorber is very stiff, when measured very soon after a
displacement, but is not very stiff, later following the displacement. The key point about
a V-E material, therefore, is its time dependent behaviour, in terms of either stress or
strain.
An example of viscoelastic behavior is shown when cartilage is compressed, as in the
experiment by Grodzinski et al. (Figure 7.3):
89
Two distinct phenomena can occur in a VE material: it can creep or it can relax. For
example, play dough, will creep (or flow) from a spherical shape, into a flat puddle,
over the course of several minutes. We could say that a constant force, or stress, of
gravity is acting upon the play dough, and the material creeps slowly. When you pull
suddenly on the material, however, it does not seem to be a liquid, and is rather stiff. So,
again you see that stiffness is relative (not in the Einsteinian sense).
Now, getting to specific ways to characterize V-E materials, there are only a few practical
ways you can do so. Testing properties of anything always requires that you perturb it
in some way, while measuring its response. There are 2 basic mechanical perturbations:
force (stress) or deformation (strain). There are generally 2 ways you can apply these
perturbations: suddenly, or slowly. The sudden method is referred to as a step input
(impulse is also possible but not practical for most material characterizations); the slow
method can take the form of a ramp, sinusoid, or other wave shape. The complete
perturbation matrix and expected material responses looks like this:
Input Shape
Type
Step (sudden)
Ramp (slow)
Stress
Sigmoidal
Strain
Creep:
Voight Complete
Relaxation:
Model
Maxwell model
Ongoing Creep
Ongoing relaxation
The table entries state the type of response to be found for each combination of
perturbation type and shape.
A complex material can be modeled as a purely viscous material combined with a purely
elastic material, thus mathematically separating the viscosity of a material from its
elasticity. A purely viscous component is a Newtonian fluid- it has no memory and no
90
Voigt Model
since s =
and
e+
sC
de/ dt
I = (1/R) V + C dV/dt
____________________________________________________________
______
Chapter 7
Review Questions and Exercises
1. Calculate the time taken for a microtubule to grow from the centrosome of a
typical cell to the cell boundary. How long would it take to shrink to single
heterodimer length if it undergoes rapid depolymerization? Assume: (1) it grows
from the plus end, (2) [M] = 10 uM/L, (3) rate constants as given, (4) a tubulin
heterodimer is 8 nM long.
MW of monomer = 50,000 Daltons; heterodimer is 2X monomer.
91
Tubulin
K+ on
K+ off
K- on
K- on
Monomer in
(uM-S)-
S-1
(uM-S)-1
S-1
solution
Growing
9.3
44
5.3
23
Rapid disassembly
737
915
viscosity is 500 dyne-sec-cm-2 and CSK elasticity is 1000 Pa. You may assume
the cell is cuboidal in shape.
happen immediately after the event, and as time evolves thereafter. What kind of
model could describe the behavior? Draw the model conceptually. What is the
time constant of response? Draw a relevant part of the response, illustrating the
time constant, and be sure to label. What components of the cell does the model
represent? Hint: the initial stress is expressed entirely in the elastic component;
another way to look at it is through the Laplace solution and transform.
3. Recognize the following models and their inputs and outputs: Explain why and
s
e
92
10
4. Model 7. Make a Simulink model of the RNA unfolding kinetics. Your model
Sub-systems should be used so that the entire model can be fit onto 1 page
and each sub-system can be printed separately, with documentation.
Jamali, Y., M. Azimi, et al. (2010). "A Sub-Cellular Viscoelastic Model for Cell
Population Mechanics." Plos One 5(8).
Understanding the biomechanical properties and the effect of biomechanical
force on epithelial cells is key to understanding how epithelial cells form uniquely
shaped structures in two or three-dimensional space. Nevertheless, with the
limitations and challenges posed by biological experiments at this scale, it
becomes advantageous to use mathematical and 'in silico' (computational)
models as an alternate solution. This paper introduces a single-cell-based model
representing the cross section of a typical tissue. Each cell in this model is an
individual unit containing several sub-cellular elements, such as the elastic
plasma membrane, enclosed viscoelastic elements that play the role of
cytoskeleton, and the viscoelastic elements of the cell nucleus. The cell membrane
is divided into segments where each segment (or point) incorporates the cell's
93
11
interaction and communication with other cells and its environment. The model
is capable of simulating how cells cooperate and contribute to the overall
structure and function of a particular tissue; it mimics many aspects of cellular
behavior such as cell growth, division, apoptosis and polarization. The model
allows for investigation of the biomechanical properties of cells, cell-cell
interactions, effect of environment on cellular clusters, and how individual cells
work together and contribute to the structure and function of a particular tissue.
To evaluate the current approach in modeling different topologies of growing
tissues in distinct biochemical conditions of the surrounding media, we model
several key cellular phenomena, namely monolayer cell culture, effects of
adhesion intensity, growth of epithelial cell through interaction with extracellular matrix (ECM), effects of a gap in the ECM, tensegrity and tissue
morphogenesis and formation of hollow epithelial acini. The proposed
computational model enables one to isolate the effects of biomechanical
properties of individual cells and the communication between cells and their
microenvironment while simultaneously allowing for the formation of clusters or
sheets of cells that act together as one complex tissue.
94
Chapter 8: Micromotors
CHAPTER 8: SKELETAL MUSCLE
8.1
Introduction
Cellular motors come in many varieties. The most familiar motor we use every day is our
musculature, which consists of skeletal, cardiac, and smooth muscle, all of which move linearly
i.e., back-and-forth. Other types of motors operate within most of ours cells that transport
things , change cell shape, and move cells around. Most free-living cells, such as bacteria, use
rotary engines. Still other motors are used in cell migration and growth. While there is much
to study about these different motor mechanisms , our task is simplified by the fact that all the
cellular motors use the same fuel: ATP. This chapter will concentrate on the mechanical aspects
of muscle cells, and subsequent chapters will cover rotary and other types of motors.
The 630 bulk skeletal muscles that move joints in the typical human are composed of > 250
million muscle fibers (cells) in the typical human body. Force generation is accomplished by
shortening and/or parallel sliding of two protein filaments: actin and myosin within each fiber.
Muscle contraction is driven by the cycling of cross-bridges, whose unitary length change in the
nanometer range and its pico-Newton force output are fueled by conversion of chemical energy,
stored in the form of adenosine triphosphate (ATP), into a change in myosin protein
configuration. The range of force and length changes of a muscle is determined by factors such
as muscle cross section, fiber angle, tendon attachment, and lever geometry, but also by the
metabolic pathways available for ATP synthesis and by enzymes involved in cross-bridge
cycling. In addition, muscle mechanical activity is affected by the extent of actin and myosin
filament overlap. Force output can be graded by selective recruitment of motor units and/or by
variation of force output from individual units.
The most important points of this chapter are:
1. The mechanism of muscle contraction
2. Force output of muscle
3. Neural control of muscle
8.2
Muscular Microstructure
Skeletal musculature is made up of anatomically distinct units, which are attached to bones (via
tendons) or other muscles (via ligaments) to support specialized movement. In the human, there
are 630 individual muscles, which make up ~40% of total weight of the average body.
Individual muscles are composed of fasciclesassemblies of muscle fibers that are surrounded
by a connective tissue sheath that can span the entire length of a muscle [Fig. 1].
95
Chapter 8: Micromotors
Figure 8.1. The
organization of skeletal
muscle, with
approximate diameters.
Note that the myosin
bundle has many heads
that contact the actin
randomly as the 2
components slide past
each other.
96
Chapter 8: Micromotors
Sarcomere
Myosin head
Sarcomeres contain the sliding filaments, actin and myosin, as shown below.
Figure 8.3. A sarcomere, showing actin filaments sliding over myosin, which is
connected to the Z-discs with titin springs.
97
Chapter 8: Micromotors
The dimensions of typical sarcomeres are shown in Figure 8.4:
Figure 8.4. Actin and Myosin
8.3
The Pathway to Contraction
A. Motor Units
In mammalian muscle each individual fiber is innervated by a single motor neuron. Each motor
neuron may control a range of homotypic fibers (with the number determining the precision of
movement supported). This group of fibers and its controlling neuron is called a motor unit, the
functional unit of muscle contraction. The motor unit (below), is comprised of a single alpha
motor neuron and all the fibers it enervates. This muscle fiber contracts when the action
potential (impulse) of the motor neuron that supplies it reaches a depolarization threshold. The
impulse arrives at the neuromuscular junction, which typically extends over an area of about 0.1
cm2. The depolarization generates an electromagnetic field and the potential is measured as a
voltage. The depolarization, which spreads along the membrane of the muscle, is a muscle
action potential. The motor unit action potential is the spatial and temporal summation of the
individual muscle action potentials for all the fibers of a single motor unit, as shown in Figure
8.5.
Figure 8.5
98
Chapter 8: Micromotors
In this example, there are 4 motor units, each being activated at a different frequency. Their
algebraic sum yields a signal that can be registered at the surface of the bulk muscle. Since the
motor units are spatially separated, this phenomenon is known as spatial summation.
Motor neurons can connect with between 3-2,000 muscle fibers. This large range relates to the
differing functions of muscles. For example, thigh muscles are engaged in forceful, but gross,
movements, such as walking and running. Thigh muscles, i.e., quadriceps, therefore, have
relatively few motor units that each innervates a large number of muscle fibers. Since there are
roughly 300,000 muscle fibers in the quadriceps, and motor units consist of about 1000 fibers,
which translates to about 300 motor neurons controlling the muscle. Other large muscles, such
as the biceps, are similarly innervated. So when the motor neuron fires, a massive twitch of
300 muscle fibers happens. In contrast, muscles controlling fine movements, such as the eye,
have smaller numbers of muscle fibers per motor unit (usually less than 10 fibers per motor
unit), which yields much smaller twitches and hence finer control.
During a typical voluntary muscle contraction the nervous system recruits motor units in a
hierarchical arrangement as motor units with fewer and smaller muscle fibers are activated first,
followed by the motor units with larger muscle fibers. The main determinant of muscle force
output of each motor unit is their frequency of stimulation. The main determinant of the bulk
muscle force is the number of motor units recruited. Thus the biceps theoretically would
produce their maximum force (Maximum voluntary contraction , MVC) when all 300 or so of
their motor units were activating at maximum frequency.
The sequence of action of the power stroke is illustrated in Figure 8.6. In this cartoon, myosin
is assumed to be stationary, while pivoting around its bottom joint. Actin is seen to move to the
right during the power stroke.
Bottom joint
of myosin
Figure 8.6. The power stroke sequence. The myosin head captures ATP, denoted T, which is
then hydrolyzed to ADP, causing a forward rotation of the myosin, which cocks the ratchet.
Next the phosphate is released , causing binding to actin, then the ADP is released, causing the
ratchet to rotate back, in the power stroke.
B. ExcitationContraction Coupling
Contraction is initiated by an electrical impulse [somewhat paradoxically called an action
potential (AP)] of neural origin (i.e., originating in the brain or spinal cord) that reaches all
99
Chapter 8: Micromotors
muscle fibers within a motor unit via the corresponding motor neuron. Subsequent to
neuromuscular transmission, the AP travels along the sarcolemma of each muscle fiber and
proceeds into the t-tubules. The t-tubular electrical signal causes release of Ca++ from the
adjacent SR. Ca binds to the actin filament, displacing the tropomyosin chain to expose the
binding sites for myosin, thereby allowing actin and myosin to interact.
The dependence of force production on Ca is depicted in Figure 8.7.A.
Figure 8.7. (A) Schematic representation of isometric force production (normalized to its
maximum value P ) as a function of cytosolic Ca++ concentration (log scale). (B) Relative
force versus relative velocity (normalized to maximum.).
In the presence of adenosine triphosphate (ATP), the key biological energy storage and transfer
molecule, actin and myosin filaments will slide past each other, driven by cross-bridge cycling
(Figure 6). This causes an increase of force and, if the external load is less than the maximal
force developed by the contractile apparatus, shortening of the sarcomere. In either case, the
mechanical event is known (again, somewhat paradoxically) as a contraction: isometric if
constant length and isotonic if constant force.
The AP-induced increase in [Ca ] is counteracted by re-uptake of Ca into the SR. This also is an
energy-consuming process that requires ATP. In the absence of maintained electrical
stimulation, [Ca ] , therefore, decreases to its resting level, which prevents further formation of
new actin-myosin bonds. A single contraction followed by relaxation is called a twitch.
8.4
Generation and Regulation of Force
A. Temporal Summation of Twitch Tension
A key mechanism controlling force in skeletal muscle is AP frequency of motor units. Since AP is
an electrical pulse that is much shorter than a mechanical muscle twitch, successive APs can
reach the fiber before it has relaxed (i.e., before [Ca ] has returned to its resting value). Restimulation of a fiber under these conditions leads to cumulative amplification of [Ca ] . This
amplification will cause a summation of force (called temporal summation). In the fiber
depicted in Fig. 5, this occurs at stimulation frequencies above 5 Hz. Note that temporal
summation combines with spatial summation, described in section 2.2 and below to produce
smooth muscle forces.
100
Chapter 8: Micromotors
If the interval between APs is less than of the duration of a mechanical twitch ( 10-100 ms,
depending on muscle type and excitability ), the individual twitches will fuse, as seen in Figure
5. When twitches completely fuse, a tetanus resultsa maintained powerful contraction.
During a tetanic contraction, the muscle operates on the plateau region of the force-Ca
relationship [Figure 8.8]. Upon cessation of electrical stimulation (and provided that ATP is
sufficiently abundant), [Ca] is reduced by the reuptake of Ca into the SR and force declines to its
resting value.
B. Force Production
Muscle cross-sectional area provides a good indication of maximum force output. A larger crosssectional area indicates more fibers or fibers with a larger diameter, both of which translate into
larger numbers of parallel myofilaments and, hence, a bigger area for cross-bridge formation.
Maximum contractile strength is about 34 kg per cm2 of muscle cross section (300400 kPa.
This quantity is called Physiological Cross Section Area (PCSA) and is used to estimate clinical
performance of muscles, based on their area. The area of muscles is highly dependent on level
of exercise, and hypertrophy and atrophy are constantly occurring in muscles. Typical PCSA for
Biceps is 23 N/cm2 with 170 ms minimum response time. For triceps it is 13-23 N/cm2, with
100 ms response time.
The table at right summarizes some
important properties of muscle.
The PCSA for each muscle is influenced
by the arrangement of muscle fibers.
When fibers are all parallel,
fiber
direction is parallel to the main axis of
force development, so fascicle length and
muscle length are equal. In contrast,
unipennate fibers run at a pennation
angle(usually between 10 and 30 ) to
the force axis, so fascicle length and
muscle length are unequal. (Bipennate
muscles have fibers that attach to a
101
Chapter 8: Micromotors
tendon in the middle of the muscle and multipennate muscles are those with multiple tendon
attachments and fiber angles.) Whereas unipennate muscles commonly have larger cross
sections, thereby generating larger total forces, the net force, contributed by their individual
fibers is reduced by the cosine of the pennation angle. The total shortening length of pinnate
muscles is reduced by the cosine of the angle. Effective force output and contractile velocity are
further affected by the position of tendon attachments to bones (relative to neighboring joints).
The mechanical gain of the resulting lever systems influences both force output and fine control
of movement.
C. LengthTension Relationship
Force output relates to the number of active cross bridges in each half-sarcomere, which is
dictated by sarcomere length, which directly relates to the amount of overlap between actin and
myosin filaments. The overlap determines the number of cross bridges that may maximally be
formed at any time. Thus the highest active tension can be generated when all myosin heads (at
either end of the myosin molecule) face actin-binding sites (Fig. 9: bc). This is the case when
sarcomere length in skeletal muscle is around 2.02.25
m in h u m an s.
When muscle fibers are stretched beyond this point, the myosin heads near the M-line will no
longer overlap with actin filaments and, therefore, cannot contribute to active force generation
(Fig. 9: d). In the extreme of excessive stretch, at around 3.5
m , actin an
will have no overlap (Fig. 9: e). At this point, cross bridges cannot form and no shortening or
tension may be actively generated. When sarcomere length is less than about 2.0
m ,
interaction of opposite actin filaments disturbs the hexagonal arrangement required for optimal
cross-bridge formation and maximum tension development is reduced [Fig. 9: ab]. At a
sarcomere length of about 1.67
m , m yosin filam en
-lines,
causing a further decrease in active tension generation.
Figure 8.9. Sarcomere
lengthtension
relationships as measured in
a single fiber. A) Piecewise
linear nature of the active
forcelength relationship.
The dashed curve denotes
the forceextension relation
of resting muscle. (B)
Sarcomere structural
interpretation of panel A.
The length of a sarcomere that optimizes force production, is thus in the midregion near 2.25
m (Fig. 9: c) an d pr esettin g m u scles to th is len gth m axim izes for ce output. A comprehensive
analysis of sarcomere length changes found that most muscles operate over a surprisingly
narrow range at 94.5% of L0.
Skeletal muscle is characterized by showing negligible resting (passive) force at sarcomere
lengths less than L0. Above L0, passive force rises quasi-exponentially with sarcomere length
[the dashed curve in Fig. 9(A)]. This behavior is largely attributable to the elastic characteristics
102
Chapter 8: Micromotors
of extracellular components, especially the connective tissue that envelops individual fibers,
fascicles and the whole muscle (Fig. 1).
D. Isotonic ForceVelocity Relationship
As stated earlier, the amount of force generated also depends on the velocity of muscle
shortening. Faster movements will not permit as much force output as those with a lower
velocity. This occurs because the rates of cross-bridge attachment, detachment, and reattachment are chemically limited by the enzymatic activity of the actin-activated myosin
adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase). The number of active cross bridges at any time is, thus,
reduced during fast movements of any given muscle. In addition, there are different myosin
ATPase isoforms, which differentiate various muscle types with their individual characteristic
peak cross-bridge cycling rates .
E. Influence of Strain History
Notwithstanding the success of the sliding-filament theory of muscle contraction, there are two
related phenomena that the above theory is unable to accommodate. Both are functions of strain
history. The first phenomenon is reflected in the generation of additional force (in association
with reduced metabolic energy expenditure) during an eccentric contraction.
If a muscle is stretched during an active contraction, it responds with force in excess of that
predicted from its isometric forcelength relationship. The metabolic consequences of this
behavior were first strikingly demonstrated by use of a pair of back-to-back bicycle ergometers.
A diminutive female, pedaling backward (at constant velocity and with leg musculature
necessarily contracting eccentrically) could readily exhaust an athletic man pedaling forward
(with leg extensor musculature necessarily contracting concentrically).
The above phenomenon is attributed to the ability of skeletal muscle to generate forces in excess
of in the negative velocity region of the forcevelocity relation . At the molecular level, it is
presumed to reflect the behavior of negatively strained cross-bridges, which, under sufficient
strain, may be broken without concomitant hydrolysis of ATP. This results in diminished heat
production , thereby resulting in increased efficiency .
The second phenomenon, also strain-history dependent, confers on muscle a degree of
memory. It is most readily observable on the descending limb of the forcelength relation,
where a component of force enhancement by an eccentric contraction can be exceptionally longlived . This behavior has recently been attributed to the behavior of titin (see Figure 2). Because
titin contains a segment that is able to unfold reversibly, as the muscle is stretched, it has been
implicated as the principle source of energy storage during eccentric contractions.
F. Muscle Tone
Even in the absence of overt activity, muscles have a certain tautness. This is called muscle
tone and arises from low-frequency action potentials generated within the nervous system. The
maintenance of tone (like that of posture) is also an energy consuming process. At rest, muscle
tone accounts for a major portion of baseline energy consumption.
8.5
Skeletal Muscle Energetics
A. Efficiency of Skeletal Muscle
Efficiency is defined as the mechanical power output divided by the metabolic power input. The
peak thermodynamic efficiency of muscle is around 0.4, based on input of the high-energy fuel
ATP. This value drops to about half that level when the cost of conversion of dietary substrates
into high-energy storage compounds is taken into account. This figure further ignores the
103
Chapter 8: Micromotors
anabolic costs of muscle fiber synthesis, maintenance, or repair (normal turnover rates are such
that the contractile protein of active muscle is totally replaced every 24 weeks). Such costs are
usually attributed to resting or basal metabolism.
B. Metabolic Pathways
The obligatory energy substrate that skeletal muscle utilizes is ATP, which, when broken down
into ADP and , releases up to 50 kJ per mole of chemical energy . ATP is needed to fuel crossbridge cycling, but also to pump Ca back into the SR (where one ATP is needed to transport two
Ca ions against their concentration gradient) and to maintain a suitable electrochemical
environment for normal AP propagation.
ATP concentration in skeletal muscle is about 4 mM/L, which is enough to enable contraction
for several seconds or less, since ATP turnover increases linearly with force production . To
maintain contraction and force output beyond such a limited period, ATP must be constantly
replenished. The immediate source of replenishment is creatine phosphate (CrP), which is
present in muscle cells at a concentration of about 20 mMsufficient to sustain another 1020 s
of contraction.
Glucose is the main metabolic source for ATP re-synthesis in muscle; it arises from blood
glucose, muscle glycogen, or liver glycogen. The synthesis of ATP from glucose occurs by two
main pathways: oxidative phosphorylation and glycolysis. As the name suggests, oxidative
phosphorylation requires oxygen (an aerobic process that takes place in the mitochondria),
while glycolysis does not (it takes place anaerobically in the cytoplasm). Aerobic ATP synthesis
is more efficient than anaerobic synthesis, yielding 36 ATP from one molecule of glucose,
compared to only 2 ATP via the glycolytic pathway. Force can be maintained with aerobic ATP
synthesis for an extended period of time, provided that there is an adequate supply of nutrients.
In contrast, contraction based on ATP arising solely from the glycolytic pathway can maintain
maximum force for only around one minute.
Besides its lower relative ATP production, another disadvantage of glycolysis is that it produces
lactic acid (lactate plus H ), which is not efficiently metabolized by skeletal muscle . Excess
production of lactic acid leads to hydrogen ion accumulation within the muscle cell and causes a
reduction in intracellular pH. The pathophysiological consequences of this acidification are still
under investigation. Recent evidence suggests that lactoacidosis may play a less-prominent role
than previously assumed in the impairment of muscle force production upon repetitive
activation (e.g., muscle fatigue). Oxidative phosphorylation, therefore, supports the majority of
sustained locomotor activities, while anaerobic glycolysis is used for activities that require brief
periods of large power output.
C. Fiber Types
Muscle fibers can be categorized by their dominant metabolic pathway for ATP synthesis. There
are three main types (easily identified by their color): slow oxidative fibers, type I (red); fast
oxidative/glycolytic, type IIA (pink); and fast glycolytic, type IIB (white).
The different fiber colors are related to their content of myoglobin, the oxygen store of muscle
cells. Myoglobin, which is red in appearance, is present in particularly high concentration in
slow oxidative fibers (which also contain more mitochondria). Most of these fibers tend to be in
small motor units and are recruited early during muscle activity. Fast glycolytic cells, in
contrast, have very low levels of myoglobin and mitochondria, and large motor unit size. Fast
oxidative/glycolytic fibers have mixed properties.
104
Chapter 8: Micromotors
Fiber types are consistent within a motor unit, but there is usually a mix of types within a given
bulk muscle. An exception to this rule is fish, which have distinct and well-defined bands of
white or red fibers.
To summarize fiber types,
Fibers are a long cylindrical cell with hundreds of nuclei
10-100 mm in diameter
1-30 cm in length
The contractile component is a myofibril
The non-contractile component is endomysium
slow twitch fiber (type I) are red in color because of abundant blood supply and
myoglobin ; they are slower to the peak when contracted and fatigue resistant
fast twitch fiber (type IIB) are pale in color because of less blood supply; they rapidly
peak in force when contracted, but are easy fatigue
intermediate fibers (type IIA) are pink, in between I and II
D. Fatigue
Fatigue (characterized by a decrease of force output) is the consequence of prolonged
contraction. In the exercising human, fatigue can be subdivided into peripheral and central
components . Central fatigue is of neuronal origin, with factors such as decreased motivation,
alertness, or neuronal excitability causing a reduction in AP frequency of motor neurons
(although the extent and detailed mechanisms of these effects are not very well understood).
Peripheral fatigue is caused primarily by biochemical processes within the muscle fiber itself.
Depletion of metabolic substrates (e.g., glycogen) has been shown to reduce muscle-force
production. In addition, accumulation of metabolic by-products (e.g., glycolytic intermediates
and inorganic phosphate), increased osmotic pressure (lacto-acidosis), and elevated muscle
temperature all contribute to peripheral fatigue. Secondary to the above biochemical changes,
there are intrinsic alterations in either cross bridge cycling and/or SR Ca handling (i.e., release
and/or re-uptake) as mechanisms that contribute directly to the reduced force generation in
fatigued muscle.
105
Chapter 8: Micromotors
Sensory responses from a muscle spindle are depicted in Figure 8.11. Note that as the muscle
is stretched, the rate of nerve impulses increases in synchrony. Ia afferents can powerfully
excite the ALPHA MOTOR NEURONS of the muscle containing the spindle. This is the basis of
the classical STRETCH REFLEX in which extension of the muscle (and thus its spindles) cause a
reflex contraction. Golgi tendon organs (not shown) are also involved in reflexes.
Figure 8.11. Sensory output from
a muscle spindle
The gain of these muscle spindle stretch receptors is regulated by the gamma motor neurons,
which activate the intrafusal muscle, causing contraction. This can be understood as automatic
gain control, (AGC) present in many amplifiers. This AGC works by the following mechanism:
the muscle spindle length can be changed in 2 ways: (1) it changes its length in sequence with
the bulk muscle, and (2) it changes its length when the CNS activates the motor neurons,
which contract the intrafusal muscle. In case (1), output of the spindle resembles that of Figure
7. Here, the motor neurons are off, and the sensory gain is maximal. In case (2) the motor
neurons are active, and the intrafusal fiber actively contracts during the stretch and hence its
output is reduced, as shown below in Figure 8. So for a given stretch of the bulk muscle, the
106
Chapter 8: Micromotors
output of the spindle can be reduced. The reason for this control has to do with reflexes, and is
beyond the scope of this chapter.
Figure 8.12. Gain control of a muscle
stretch receptor. In each panel (a to e) ,
the top trace represents afferent neuron
pulses, originating from the sensory
organ , subjected to constant stretch; the
bottom trace represents activation of the
control neuronal influence, similar to
activation of motor neurons. Activation
of causes slowing the rate of sensory
pulses, to a degree proportional to the
magnitude of activation.
E. Summary
In comparison with artificial actuators, muscle surpasses them only in the fuel delivery and
renewability. Muscles are linear actuators that can bend around joints. They are adapted for
intermittent duty and stiffness (compliance) control. Knowledge of Biological force actuators is
crucial to the development of novel actuator technologies. To best mimic the biology, clues
derived from skeletal muscle actuator design should drive the design process.
APPENDIX: REVIEW OF BIOMECHANICAL TERMINOLOGY
Stress-strain Relations in Muscle (from Madden et Al.[1])
Stress is the typical force per cross-sectional area of the actuator material, in this case, muscle.
Peak stress is the maximum force per cross-sectional area that a material is able to maintain
position (also known as blocking stress). Thus force developed by actuators scales linearly with
cross-sectional area (whose surface normal is parallel to the direction in which actuation is
occurring).
Strain represents the displacement normalized by the original material length in the direction
of actuation. Typical strain is the strain that is often used in working devices, whereas peak or
107
Chapter 8: Micromotors
max strain is the maximum strain reported. The peak strain generally cannot be obtained when
operating at peak stress. Strain rate is the average change in strain per unit time during an
actuator stroke. The maximum strain rate is usually observed at high frequencies when strains
are small. Bandwidth is relevant to some actuators, and is the frequency at which strain drops
to half of its low frequency amplitude. Limitations on bandwidth and strain rate can result from
a range of factors including speed of delivery of the input energy, rates of diffusion or heating,
internal dissipation, inertia related effects including speed of sound, and kinetics associated
with the energy transduction method .
Work density is the amount of work generated in one actuator cycle normalized by actuator
volume. It is very important to note that this does not include the volume occupied by
electrolytes, counter electrodes, power supplies, or packaging, unless otherwise stated. These
additional contributions to actuator volume do not always scale linearly with work output and
therefore need to be considered separately. Also it is emphasized that the work density is not
simply the product of peak stress and peak strain. Specific power or power to mass ratio is the
power output per unit mass of actuator material. Typically only the mass of the material itself is
considered. Peak power density can be found from the maximum product of simultaneously
measured stress and strain rate divided by density. Because of the interdependence of load and
rate, peak power is in general less than the product of peak stress and peak strain rate
normalized by density.
Efficiency is the ratio of work generated to input energy expended. Stored electrical energy and
even thermal energy can in principle
be recovered in order to improve efficiency.
Electromechanical coupling in muscle refers to the degree of ratio of electrical activation to
mechanical force output.
.
Elastic modulus is the material stiffness and generally represents the instantaneous value,
before any creep is induced. Note that mammalian muscle stiffness at rest is 40 MPa, but this
value increased 50X during contraction. Each myosin bundle can produce 5.3 pN of force
during its power stroke. There are 100 molecules per actin filament. Each filament has c.s.a. of
1.8 X 10 15 m2 in the relaxed muscle. Cycle life is the number of useful strokes that the material
is known to be able to undergo. Cycle life is often highly strain and stress dependent.
Chapter 8
Review Questions and Exercises
1. How much force does a single myosin-actin bridge attain? How much energy does it take
and how for a single cycle of actin-myosin interaction. ? Calculate the energy efficiency
of skeletal muscle.
2. Describe the different roles of IA and II afferents. State what principles and pathways are
involved.
3. Workshop: With the gamma model, simulate the operation of a muscle spindle subject
to stretch, similar to the traces of Figure 11. Test the effect of gamma motor neuron
activity and compare results to Figure 12. Describe the model, and how it works.
108
Chapter 8: Micromotors
References
1.
Madden, J.D.W., N.A. Vandesteeg, P.A. Anquetil, P.G.A. Madden, A. Takshi, R.Z. Pytel,
S.R. Lafontaine, P.A. Wieringa, and I.W. Hunter, Artificial muscle technology: Physical
principles and naval prospects. Ieee Journal of Oceanic Engineering, 2004. 29(3): p.
706-728.
109
f crit = 2 /
(2)
Figure 9.1
The top plate, area, A, is being dragged over the bottom plate, separated by distance , d,
with fluid of density, , separating them, with force, f, and velocity, Vo. Note that the force (1 &
2) is proportional to the velocity, and inversely proportional to the separation distance.
Drag can be defined as the rate of removal of momentum from a body moving in a fluid.
So, a moving body experiencing a large drag will stop quickly. For example, imagine yourself
110
Now we need to know the relevant Reynolds numbers, that are dependent on object
shape, size and velocity, and on the fluid properties. Reynolds number quantifies the relative
magnitude of inertial and frictional forces in a body moving through a fluid.
Some representative Re numbers, and fluid properties are :
Fluid
Air
Water
Olive Oil
Glycerine
Corn Syrup
1
1000
900
1300
1000
2 X 10-5
0.0009
0.08
1
5
4 X 10-10
8 X 10-10
7 X 10-6
0.0008
0.03
From these data and equation (3) , we can estimate an example: To pull a 5 m cell
(sphere) at a speed of 1 /sec, we can estimate f ~ 10-5 pN , based on a CD = 104 , the media
being plasma, with density near that of water =1000 .
111
Figure 9.4
In summary, the motion of a body depends on the ratio of viscous and inertial effects: Reynolds
number. Re is small for cells, and large for almost all animals. The cellular world is ruled by
friction.
9.2.1 Cell Substrate Interactions
It has been shown that the elasticity of the cellular substrate (characterized by Youngs modulus,
E) in contact with the cell influences the direction of cell migration. This process has been
termed durotaxis. The stiffness of the cellular environment is not only important for cell
migration but also appears to influence the metastatic process of cancer cells in vivo. Therefore,
a mechanistic understanding of how environmental mechanical signals influence cellular
movement and cell dynamics is an important question in cell biophysics.
Mechanical properties of the environment not only influence cell migration but also can
influence many aspects of the cell life cycle. When cells are plated onto a planar substrate, the
morphology and behavior of the cell depends on the stiffness of this substrate. If the substrate is
soft, aggregates of adhesion molecules remain small and transitory. In the opposite limit, when
the substrate is stiff, a clear network of contractile stress fibers (bundles of F actin) develops,
and strong focal adhesions anchoring the cell to the substrate are seen. Substrate stiffness can
also influence the long-term fate of cellular development. It has been shown that differentiation
of mesenchymal stem cells to more specialized cells is influenced by the stiffness of the cellular
substrate. The mechanisms behind this dependence are complex but appear to involve three
basic systems: the actin cytoskeleton, cell-surface adhesions and motor-based contraction.
Indeed, a simplified mechanically-based model showed that when the time scales of adhesion
movement and the cytoskeleton interaction are considered, cells on stiff substrates will form
numerous actin filament bundles with many filaments, while cells on soft substrates will have
fewer bundles with a smaller number of filaments. This stiffness-dependent organization of the
cellular cytoplasm could be an important feature in cellular mechanosensation.
112
It is useful to recognize that cells can move within substrates of pure liquids, semi-solids
and solids. These 3 types of substrates are modeled below. In (A), a pure liquid is represented
as a dashpot, with drag force proportional to viscosity times velocity. Applying force, F, leads to
a gradual acceleration to a constant velocity. In semi-solid (B), an object can be moved by the
force, but will eventually come to rest. In solid (C), the object is trapped, but will oscillate due to
the elasticity of the substrate.
Figure 9.5
9.4
Propulsive motors
The motor we use every day is our skeletal muscle (Chapter 8, which moves linearly i.e., backand-forth. Most free-living cells, such as bacteria, use rotary engines. Most cells contain motors
that crawl or hop. Still other motors are used in cell migration and growth. While there is much
to study about these different motor mechanisms, our task is simplified by the fact that all the
cellular motors use the same fuel: ATP. The several known motor types are outlined below:
9.4.1 Rotary Motors
The f1-ATPase motor is the best-studied rotary motor, and is found in thermophilic bacteria.
The basic plan is shown in the cartoons below. In Figure 9.1, at left, the filament that drives the
motion (the tail of the cell) is attached to the cell membrane with a kind of bearing composed of
proteins.
The f1-ATP-ase motor can either make or break ATP, and hence is reversible . It can generate a
torque of 40 pN-nM. It can perform work of 80 pn-nM (40 * 2p/3) for each 1/3 revolution.
This is equivalent to free energy from ATP hydrolysis.
113
The ATP synthase (top right) not only is natures smallest rotary motor, but also has an
important role in producing most of the chemical energy that aerobic and photosynthetic
organisms need to stay alive. Operation of this motor was studied by using electromagnets to
force it to rotate and generate chemical energy (adenosine triphosphate, ATP). In the process,
the direction of its rotation during ATP synthesis was determined.
ATP synthase is composed of two linked multi-subunit complexes, called F0 and F1. F0 is
embedded in cellular membranes and conducts protons, whereas F1 is a peripheral complex and
contains the catalytic sites. Together they couple the flow of protons down an electrochemical
gradient to the synthesis of ATP from ADP (adenosine diphosphate) and inorganic phosphate.
114
115
Figure
116
Figure 9.6. Forward protrusion in concert with contraction of the rear cell body
overcomes ECM resistive adhesive tractions to allow forward cell migration.
Bacterial pathogens have a cunning way of moving about inside the cells they infect they
harness components of the hosts cytoskeletal machinery, in particular, the protein actin. One
such pathogen, Rickettsia conorii, is transmitted to humans through tick bites, and causes
Mediterranean spotted fever. This bacterium assembles an elaborate tail made of actin
filaments (Figure 9.7) to propel itself through the cytoplasm of the infected host cell and to
invade neighboring cells. Rickettsia tails consist of parallel, unbranched filaments that closely
resemble those present in thread-like cellular filopodia.
Figure 9.7
Figure 9.8
117
As seen in the Figure, there are three modes of linear cellular motion. Characteristics of each
type are shown in the Table.
Figure 9.9
Motor
Step Size
Max Force
Processivity
Mode
A-M
Variable
5 pN
20
None
Hops
Kinesin
8 nm
5 pN
50
Good
Walks
F1ATPase
120
40 pN-nm
~100
Good
Crawls
118
Chapter 9
Review Exercises and Questions
1. The motor protein, kinesin, can generate a force of 6 pN. How fast could it move a
bacterium through a typical cell?.
2. Model the rotary motor of F1 ATPase, showing the behaviors described in class.
119
Appendix
Appendix 1
Numerical Modelling with Simulink
Dimensional Analysis
This is a technique for deriving mathematical descriptions of physical systems,
using educated guessing. The key is using standard letters to describe the 4
fundamental physical dimension, and its corresponding SI unit:
Quantity
Dimension
Units
Length
Mass
Time
Charge
1.1
M
T
Q
(m)
(kg)
(s)
(coul)
Most, if not all, other quantities used in cytomechanics are simple combinations of
these dimensions, such as, velocity = LT-1 , acceleration is
LT-2 , and so on.
As an example of dimensional analysis is finding the period of a simple pendulum,
that we know has units of T. Looking at the pendulum, we see that it is a mass,
dimension M, at the end of a string, dimension L. The only force acting on the
mass is gravity, g, with dimension , LT-2 . So now to derive the formula, we need
to write the dimensional relationship as:
T = f ( M , L, LT 2 )
We can see that there is no way that there is no way that the fundamental
dimension, M, can be transformed into T, so we can eliminate M, and realize that
the period must be independent of mass. So, to get T from L and LT-2 , i.e., g, we
can manipulate them as follows:
L
)
T= f(
LT 2
or, simplifying:
L
T= f(
)
g
Note that there will be other dimensionless parameters, in this case, 2. Other
physical systems may not be so easy to decipher, however, it is always useful to
120
Appendix
check dimensions and units.
Appendix 2
Symbol
Value
Boltzmann constant
1.38 10-23 J/ K
kT ( T = 295K)
Energetic Equivalents
aKT
4.1 pN-nM
4.1 10-21 J
4.1 10-24 erg
2.5 kJ/mole
0.59 kcal/mole
0.025 eV
Average kinetic energy
per molecule = 3/2 KT
Persistence Length p =
Kf/KT
Thermal Voltage = KT/q
Diffusion coefficient =
D=
KT
6r
Particles in gravity =
mgh/KT
Viscosity of water
0.001 Pa-s
P1
= e kT
P2
where P's are the probabilities of states or classes 1 and 2, and F is free energy. For
example Pi can represent the concentration of particles in 2 separate compartments.
121
Appendix
Earc =
fL
2R2
= YI
p =
f
kT
SpecialCase :
when L = p andE arc = kT
E arc =
R=
p
R
f2
2kTR
= kT
p
2
= 2
Hence,
p
L
=
= 2 ...radians = 81
R p / 2
122
Appendix
A.5 Diffusion
Diffusion coefficient indicates how fast particles of radius a can move in
2
cm
P( x )dx =
1
2x
sec
exp(
x2
2x
)dx
x2
1
C=
exp(
)
4Dt
4 Dt
2 Dt = x
So
Water flow
Q m( t ) d t
V c ( t)
V c( 0)
0
Q m K w. A c (
P)
123
Appendix
A.8
K sp =
3 kT
2 Lc p
where
Lc = ContourLengthofthePolymer
p = persistenceLength
Typical
Diameter (nM)
Actin
Tubulin
Intermediate
Filaments
Silk
Collagen
filament
Collagen fibril
Elastin
Cellulose Dry
Cellulose Wet
Spectrin
DNA
8
25
10-20
Persistence
Length p
(m)
15
6000
Elastic
Modulus E
(Gpa)
2
2
Mass Density
p
(Da/nm)
110
160
5
1.5
10-300
0.02
0.05
0.002
80
40
0.002
1
4500
1900
124
Appendix
1 cal=4.186 joules
1 watt = 1joule/sec
1 N=1 Kg-m/sec2
1watt-sec= 1 joule
1 dyne=1 g-cm/sec2
1 atm=1.013 * 106 dynes/cm2
1 atm=76 cm Hg
1 bar=106 dynes/cm2
1 volt = joule/coulomb
1 pound=4.448 N
1 pound/inch2 (1 psi)=6894 N/m2
1 dyne/cm2=0.1 Pa
1 Pa = 1 N/m2
1 dyne/cm2=0.1 N/m2
log RT/F = 58 mV @ 25 C
number
1 molar (M)= 1 mol/L
1 molal= 1 mole(solute)/Kg(solvent)
1 joule=107 ergs
1 Faraday=964800 coulombs/mole
1 joule=1 N-m
Definition
Concentration, outside and inside cell (Moles/Liter);
also refers to curvature C= 1/R, where R= radius.
Diffusion Constant ( cm2/sec)
Dalton- the mass of 1/12 of a C-12 atom
Youngs elastic Modulus (Pa); Also used for energy (J)
Elementary unit of charge
125
Appendix
F
G
G
H
II
J
Ka, Kv
f
M
kb
[M]
M
P
Q,q
R
ree
S
S
T
V
Y
or p
126