Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless
you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you
may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use.
Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at
http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=epw.
Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed
page of such transmission.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Economic and Political Weekly is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
Economic and Political Weekly.
http://www.jstor.org
Women's Autonomy and Politics
of Gender in Guyana
The HumanDevelopmentReport,1995 demonstratesthat no countryin the world treatswomen as
well as it does its men. Even so, the HDR ranks Guyanafairly high on its gender-related
indicators.Thispaper is an attemptto analyse the comnplexities
of women's autonomyin Guyana.
MAITREYI DAS
W omen's autonomy is an impor- per cent, and Amerindians or indigenous The research in this paper is prompted
tantcorollary of development in persons account for 6.8 per cent of the total in part by seeking an inquiry into the
the widest sense - of enlarging population. The remaining 15 per cent of dimensions of women's autonomy as a
women's choices and in the attainment of the population is made up of Chinese, 'reality check', given high levels of gender
full personhood [Nussbaum and Glover Portuguese and mixed heritage persons equality as evidenced by the GEM and
1995]. The degree of autonomy thatwomen [PanAmerican Health Organisation1998]. GDI. It is based on participatory field
have is determined by various historical, Women's autonomy in Guyanahas been research in Guyana, as also on analysis of
culturaland economic factors. Thus, in the shaped by its unique history of colonial available sources of national data.
Caribbean,women have greaterautonomy rule, slavery. and indentureship, its eth- The term women's 'autonomy' has
than do women in south Asia (see Human nic composition, its proximity to the US gained currency in development and femi-
Development Report, 1995). The purpose and its small size. The two major political nist literature in preference to women's
of this paper is to analyse the complexity parties, the Afro-Guyanese dominated 'status', which is considered to be more
of women's autonomy in Guyana - a small People's National Congress and the Indo- limited in scope. Thus, women's autonomy
Caribbean country undergoing profound Guyanese dominatedPeople's Progressive has come to denote the independence that
socio-economic transformation.I arguethat Party have been locked in a struggle for women have in their functioning, while
women's autonomy in Guyana is the prod- power in the post-independence decades. women's status denotes women's posi-
uct of several factors, but at the most basic Voting is along ethnic lines and the elec- tion. Autonomy thus takes into account the
level it is shaped by the contradiction tions of 1997 were marked by violence. activities that women engage in and the
between the gender ideology of male The political and economic problems the power that they exercise as a consequence
dominance and the reality of women's country in the last three decades have led of their status, while the status can be
control over their personal and domestic to massive emigration and the flight of the arguedto be a more static concept thatdoes
spheres.This contradictionhas also shaped educated middle class. This scenario has not focus on women's active role in society.
public policy which tries to relegate women also had an effect on the politics of gender Mason (1986:285,1993:21) uses the
to the domestic sphere, when reality at the and on women's solidarity in Guyana. terms 'status' and 'position' to include
micro - the personal, the household and Data on demographic and social indica- autonomy, when she explains that
community - level, does not distinguish tors in Guyana are poor and unreliable. 'women's position here is taken to mean
between public and private spheres. Thus, most UN publications such as the women's control over resources,compared
Guyana (formerly British Guiana) is an State of the World's Children by UNICEF to that of men; the degree of their au-
Anglophone country in South America, or the Human Development Reports by tonomy from men's control; or other as-
which identifies politically, culturally and UNDP have no data for Guyana for many pects of their privilege or oppression that
historically with the Caribbean. It is indicators.However, Guyanaranksreason- arise from society's institutions' (empha-
currently in the process of restructuring ably high on the indices of gender equality sis mine). She further points out that the
its highly indebted economy through a developed by the Human Development concept is an elusive one, but is intrinsic
structural adjustment programme. Its Reports [UNDP 1995]. While on the to the relations of inequality that women
social indicators are at the lower end of HumanDevelopment Index (HDI), Guyana have with men and in their engagement
the Caribbeancontinuum - closer to Haiti ranked 105 out of 174 countries, on the with their environment.
thanto Barbados.Guyanais a post-socialist, GenderRelated Development Index (GDI), Shrijvers (1985, cited in Van der Aa,
post-colonial country, which attained in- it ranked 70th out of 130 countries for 1995:16) has analysed women's autonomy
dependence from British rule in 1966. It which the index was computed. The GDI by economic, political, social-cultural and
has had a period of restricted democracy adjusts the HDI for gender equality in life physical dimensions. Van derAa(1995:17)
in the 1980s. From 1992, since the first expectancy, educational attainment and also points out that the definition of
free elections, democratic trendshave been income. The Gender Empowerment Mea- autonomy can vary by political perspec-
strengthening but the ethnic divisions sure (GEM) is an index of women's par- tive. It can furtherbe analysed at different
between the Afro-Guyanese and the Indo- ticipation in the economic, political and levels - personal or the micro level, and
Guyanese populations have confounded professional spheres. Guyana ranked 25th the organisational or macro level. In ad-
its development objectives. Indo-Guyanese among the 113 countries for which the dition to this, we can look at autonomy at
comprise49.5 percent,Afro-Guyanese35.6 GEM was computed. the theoretical level or at the level of actual
ing control over personal and community Indicatorof Female Status Relationshipto Female Score of Guyanese Women
level resources is not enough to leverage (A) Status (High/Low)
access to or control over public resources. (B) (C)
DemographicIndicators
Ranking Guyana 1 Female minusmale mortalityrates - High
2 Female age at marriage + High
The measurementof women's autonomy 3 Averagehusband-wifeage difference -NA
is an even more daunting task than defin- 4 Parentspreferencesformale children -High
ing it. Mason (1986) has listed a set of Indicators
Kinship-Famiiy
variables that are often used to measure 5 Purdah -(?) High
autonomy. This list takes into the account 6 Levirate -(?) High
the multidimensionality of the concept of 7 Polygyny ? ? - (multiplepartnersand
alternativeconjugal
autonomy, the importance of context- unionscommon)
dependency, the multiple locations of 8 Conjugalfamilyhouseholds + High
gender inequality, and the confounding of 9 Emphasison lineage -(?) High
10 Female propertyinheritance + High
gender and class. These are the pathways 11 Villageexogamy of females - High
to women's autonomy. Table 1 accords 12 Partilocalpost-maritalresidence - High
Guyana a score of high or low on the list 13 Dowry - High
of indicators. 14 Arrangedmarriages - High
15 Cross cousin marriages + NA
We have to emphasise the importance 16 -
Emphasison virginityof brides ?
of contextual and cultural factors in deve- 17 Pre or Post MaritalDoubleStandard - Low
loping indicators to measure women's au- 18 Emphasison women's sexuality,Youthfulness - Low
19 Malerightto divorcewife withouther consent - High
tonomy. Thus, some of Mason's indicators 20 Egalitariannessof husband-wiferelationship + ?
may be more relevant in other contexts, 21 Malefeeding priority -High
notably dowry, levirate and purdah. This 22 Extended-kinsupportforwidowsand divorcees + High
is an inherent pitfall in developing EconomicIndicators
standardised indicators to rank women's 23 Femaleemploymentopportunities + Low
autonomy. Therefore, in order to capture 24 Female labourforce participation + Low
25 Exclusionof women fromextradomestic sphere _ High
the Guyanese context, I have added four 26 Concentrationof women v/s men in informal
indicators that have a bearing on the economic sector Low
autonomy of Caribbean and Guyanese 27 Occupationalsegregationof sexes _Low
women to Mason's original set of 34 28 Sex differencesin wages or earnings _ Low
29 Sex differencesin amountof leisuretime _Low
indicators.These arefemale-headed house- 30 Femaleeducation + High
holds, alternatives to marriage,distinction 31 Female underemploymentor unemploymentrates _ Low
between public and private domains and 32 Women'swork'commitment'(measuredvariously) + ?
female kinship and familial networks. 33 Women'saccess to credit + Low
34 Women'saccess to non-familialsupport + High(?)
These additions to Mason's list are spe-
cific to the Caribbean context, and would IndicatorsGuyanaand the Caribbean
35 Female headed households + High
have little meaning in other cultures. 36 Alternativesto marriage +(?) High?
Headship has provided women greater 37 Distinctionbetween publicand privatedomains _ High
leverage in the management of their lives 38 Female kinshipand familialnetworks + High
and thatof their children [Momsen 1993]. Note: 1 ColumnsA and B in indicators1-34 fromMason(1986). Scoring in ColumnC and indicators35-
This is regarded as an aspect of their 38 author's.
[Thispaperdrawsfromtheexperiencesandinsights
of women in the Guyanese women's movement REVIEW OF INDUSTRY AND MANAGEMENT
- notably, Indra Chandrapal, Andaiye, Janice
Jackson, Jocelyn Dow, Magda Pollard, Pat November 27, 1999
Sheerattan, and innumerable women in
communitiesthat I visited and worked with. An Economic Reforms and Foreign Trade Policies: Case Study
earlierversion has benefited from the comments of Apparel and Machine Tools Industries - Shuji Uchikawa
of VandaRadzig. Carlos Felipe Martinez,UNDP
Guyana,was very supportiveof this researchand Manufacturing
Foreign-Controlled Firms in India:
commented at various stages of this paper.] Long-TermTrends - Suma Athreye
1 Information on women in decision-making Sandeep Kapur
from the Women's Affairs Bureau and The Modern and Indigenous Perceptions in Small Enterprises - Jan Brouwer
Guyana Chronicle, February 16, 1998. Small-Scale Industriesin West Bengal, 1971-97:
References Data Analysis for Study of Growth - Robin Mukherjee
Pranab Kumar Das
Barrow, Christine (1993): 'Small Farm Food Uttam Kumar Bhattacharya
Productionand Gender in Barbados' in Janet
Momsen (ed), Women and Change in the Labour Market under Trade Liberalisationin India:
Caribbean, Ian Randle, Kingston; Indiana Some Issues Concerning Reallocation - Deepika Chakravarty
University Press, Bloomington and
ManagementEducation:A Critical Appraisal - Bernard D'Mello
Indianapolis,James Currey, London.
Besson, Jean (1993): 'Reputation and Respect-
The Review of Industry and Management appearsas a supplementto the last issues
ability Reconsidered:A New Perspective on
Afro-Caribbean Peasant Women' in Janet of February,May and November.
Momsen (ed), Women and Change in the
Caribbean.
For copies write to
CirculationManager
Delph, Y and F Nunes (1997): 'MakingAbortion
LawReformWork- StepsandSlips in Guyana' Economic and Political Weekly
(Parts 1 and 2), ReproductiveHealth Matters,
No 9:66-76.