Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
SUMMARY
Nonmetric traits are frequently analyzed in
the field of anthropology to measure genetic
relatedness, or biodistance within or between
populations. These studies are performed
under the assumption that nonmetric traits
are inherited genetically. Historically, interpretations of both biological and cultural
change within the Armenian Highlands, have
cited large-scale population movements.
Biological estimates of these changes have traditionally relied upon biodistance estimates,
using odontologic, craniofacial measures of
both deformed and nondeformed skulls. In
order to evaluate whether large-scale prehistoric and historic migrations occurred in the
Armenian Highlands, we examine the biodistance results from nonmetric cranial traits for
19 mortuary samples that represented all time
periods on the Armenian Highlands. None of
the distances between each pair of mortuary
samples examined in this study was significant. These results suggest biological continuity in the populations of Armenia. The biodistance results also suggest endogamy within
inland populations. The broader implications
of these results are also discussed.
134
Corresponding author:
Dr. Anahit Khudaverdyan. Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography, National
Academy of Science, Yerevan 0025, Charents st.15, Republic of Armenia.
Phone: +(374) 077133-254 / +(374) 565-884. E-mail: ankhudaverdyan@gmail.com;
akhudaverdyan@mail.ru
Nonmetric cranial variation in human skeletal remains from the Armenian Highland: microevolutionary relations and an intergroup analysis
ARMENIAN
135
Anahit Y. Khudaverdyan
Nonmetric cranial variation in human skeletal remains from the Armenian Highland: microevolutionary relations and an intergroup analysis
Sample name
Landjik
Date
c. 4000-3000 BC
Researchers
Khudaverdyan, 2009
Black Fortress
c. XIV-XII BC
Khudaverdyan, 2009
Nerkin Getashen I
c. XV BC
Movsesyan,1990
Artik
c. XV/XIV-XI BC
Movsesyan,1990
I period
Sarukhan
c. XI-IX/ VIII BC
Movsesyan,1990
Nerkin Getashen II
c. XIII-XII BC
Movsesyan,1990
c. IX-VIII BC
Movsesyan,1990
Arcvakar
c. XI-IX/ VIII BC
Movsesyan,1990
10
Akunk
c. XI-IX/ VIII BC
Movsesyan,1990
11
Karashamb
c. XI-IX/ VIII BC
Movsesyan,1990
12
Karmir
c. XI-IX/ VIII BC
Movsesyan,1990
13
Lchashen
c. 3000 - 2000 BC
Movsesyan,1990
14
Shushi
c. 3000- 2000BC
Movsesyan,1990
15
II period
16
I period
17
II period
18
Karchakhpyur-Shirakavan
c. 1 BC AD 3
Movsesyan,1990
19
c. 1 BC AD 3
20
c. 1 BC AD 3
21
Bingel Dag
20 century
137
Anahit Y. Khudaverdyan
Table 2. A complete list of nonmetric traits analyzed and the methods used to score them.
138
Trait
Sutura metopica
Scoring Method
absent, complete
Foramen supraorbitale
presence/absence
Foramen parietale
Os bregmaticum
presence/absence
Os epiptericum
presence/absence
Os apicis lambdae
presence/absence
Os asterii
presence/absence
presence/absence
presence/absence
presence/absence
presence/absence
partial formation
absent, 1, 2, more than 2 (the lesser palatine foramina lie on both sides of the posterior border of
the hard palate, immediately posterior to the greater palatine foramen)
Cribra orbitale
presence/absence
Os zygomaticum bipartitum
presence/absence
Tuberculum praecondylare
Torus palatinus
presence/absence
Nonmetric cranial variation in human skeletal remains from the Armenian Highland: microevolutionary relations and an intergroup analysis
Table 3. Number of affected and observed crania, and their dichotomized trait frequencies by mortuary sample for 24 nonmetric cranial traits
used in biodistance analysis*.
Traits
Bronze
Akunk
Lchashen
period
II
period
period
II
period
II
A/
A/
A/
A/
A/
1 Sutura metopica
21.2/
54
12.3/
259
19.47/
36
4.35/
28
2 Foramen supraorbital
54.5/
54
45.1/
222
36.11/
36
27.27/
3 Cribra orbitale
48.4/
59
16.4/
235
11.11/
36
9.09/
4 Foramen infraorbitale
acces.
19.8/
65
9.71/
245
11.11/
36
4.76/
5 Os zygomaticum bip.
13.92/
67
11.3/
251
2.78/
36
2.8/
60
1.9/
259
2.78/
67
10.4/
229
6 Os bregmaticum
A/
A/
A/
13.49/ 126
17.8/
58
6.67/
30
12.3/
88
225
22
44.00/ 125
44.95/
82
40.7/
27
42.9/ 108
38
22
8.00/
125
27.3/
76
8.33/
24
17.9/ 100
105
21
8.80/
125
38.2/
50
5.0/
20
21.6/
70
97
1.19/
21
6.50/
123
39.6/
52
5.56/
18
22.6/
70
46
36
1.08/
23
0.22/
125
1.93/
52
0.83/
30
1.38/
82
10
2.78/
36
4.35/
23
3.22/
125
10.1/
113
3.45/
29
6.8/
142
25
8 Os epiptericum
35.9/
67
23.4/
220
17.14/
35
4.76/
21
20.00/ 120
20.2/
57
21.74/
23
21.0/
80
163
9 Ossicula suturae
squamosae
18.7/
66
6.2/
228
2.78/
36
4.35/
23
3.34/
120
18.5/
89
0.92/
27
9.8/
116
15
10 Os asterii
18.9/
65
7.8/
239
8.33/
36
1.08/
23
6.50/
123
10.9/
46
3.44/
29
7.2/
75
132
11 Foramen parietale
56.4/
58 53.97/ 236
47.22/
36
34.78/
23
43.65/ 126
54.5/
80
46.42/
29
50.5/ 109
387
12 Os apicis lambdae
15.6/
66
12.7/
234
2.78/
36
8.69/
23
4.84/
124
10.0/
50
10.71/
28
10.4/
78
62
65
3.97/
250
0.69/
36
1.08/
23
0.81/
124
5.4/
92
0.83/
29
3.2/
101
14 Ossa suturae
lambdodeae
48.8/
68
40.6/
253
22.22/
36
47.82/
23
25.60/ 125
58.7/
101
28.58/
28
43.7/ 129
341
15 Foramen mastoideum
absent
57.6/
65 42.98/ 255
37.14/
36
21.40/
23
34.92/ 126
65.8/
73
28.57/
28
47.2/
92
294
16 Foramen mastoideum
exsutural
29.6/
64
23.7/
252
17.14/
35
30.43/
23
34.92/ 126
33.6/
87
28.57/
28
31.1/ 115
248
17 Canalis condylaris
intermed.
62.3/
60
61.4/
228
53.33/
30
44.44/
18
63.93/ 122
61.5/
45
46.66/
15
54.1/
60
697
18 Canalis hypoglossi
bipartite
25.5/
60
27.6/
227
23.33/
30
33.33/
18
22.13/ 122
37.5/
24
46.66/
15
42.1/
39
333
19 Tuberculum
praecondylare
21.1/
60
8.9/
250
3.33/
30
5.55/
18
5.73/
122
27.3/
22
6.67/
15
16.99/ 37
85
20 Foramen spinosum
bipertitum
30.5/
64
9.3/
227
11.42/
35
4.54/
22
8.06/
122
40.0/
25
25.92/
17
32.96/ 42
62
21 Torus palatinus
39.6/
62
22.7/
233
15.15/
33
16.67/
18
14.63/ 124
40.9/
89
1.47/
17
21.2/ 106
198
22 Foramina palatina
minoranus
52.9/
63
43.8/
230
40.24/
33
50.0/
14
38.84/ 121
49.1/
60
52.94/
17
51.1/
23 Sulcus mylohyoideus
18.4/
30
24.7/
116
19.35/
24 Foramina mentale
accessor
21.6/
29
9.2/
56
62
22.0/
55
77
22.0/
55
* O: number of crania actually observed; A: number of crania showing trait (affected); R radians.
139
Anahit Y. Khudaverdyan
II
III
0.976
0.017
0.066
Foramen supraorbitale
-0.711
0.642
0.227
0.486
0.693
-0.500
Os zygomaticum bipartitum
0.014
0.932
-0.253
-0.233
0.882
0.280
Os epiptericum
0.823
0.326
0.399
Os asterii
0.882
0.427
0.064
Foramen parietale
0.938
-0.090
0.007
0.975
-0.003
0.114
0.897
-0.290
-0.106
Values
58.403
29.200
6.361
Nonmetric cranial variation in human skeletal remains from the Armenian Highland: microevolutionary relations and an intergroup analysis
Table 5. Matrix of distance, values for eleven Armenian Highland mortuary samples examined in this study.
Sample name
Akunk
Artik
Shirak Plateau /I period/
Sevan region /II period/
Beniamin, Vardbakh,
Black Fortress I
Karchakhpyur-Shirakavan
Armenian Highland
/I period/
Armenian Highland
/II period/
Armenian Highland
/Classical Age/
Bingel Dag
Lchashen
Akunk Artik
Shirak
Plain
Sevan
region
Beniamin,
Vardbakh,
Black Fortress I
KarchakhpyurShirakavan
Armenian
Highland
/I period/
Armenian
Highland
/II period/
2.24
0.54
3.68
2.05
2.08
5.62
4.19
4.03
2.46
1.92
3.97
5.62
4.04
2.30
3.14
0.89
1.49
1.02
4.37
2.76
4.72
2.91
5.07
3.25
1.24
1.00
2.64
3.69
1.71
3.85
2.07
2.04
0.54
2.85
2.48
1.23
1.94
3.60
2.03
2.51
1.95
2.07
2.65
2.21
1.43
7.85
9.40
7.64
8.32
7.65
7.68
8.53
7.39
7.58
Armenian Bingel
Highland
Dag
/Classical Age/
7.73
141
Anahit Y. Khudaverdyan
II
III
Cribra orbitale
0.911
-0.179
0.169
Os bregmaticum
0.276
-0.761
0.460
0.702
-0.618
-0.054
Os apicis lambdae
0.725
-0.227
0.163
0.686
0.660
0.144
0.691
0.636
0.102
0.306
0.947
-0.034
Tuberculum praecondylare
0.971
-0.040
-0.137
0.515
-0.334
-0.752
Values
46.398
32.173
9.841
Fig. 4. Factor analysis: 4 Artik, 5 Armenian Highland /I period: Bronze Age/, 10 Akunk, 13 Lchashen, 15 Armenian
Highland /II period: Bronze and Early Iron Ages/, 16 Shirak
Plateau /I period/, 17 Sevan region /II period/, 18 Karchakhpyur-Shirakavan, 19 Beniamin, Vardbakh, Black Fortress I, 20
Armenian Highland /Classical Age/, 21 Bingel Dag.
Nonmetric cranial variation in human skeletal remains from the Armenian Highland: microevolutionary relations and an intergroup analysis
Table 7. Matrix of distance, values for eleven Armenian Highlands mortuary samples examined in this study.
Sample name
Akunk
Artik
Shirak Plateau /I period/
Sevan region /II period/
Beniamin, Vardbakh,
Black Fortress I
Karchakhpyur-Shirakavan
Armenian Highland
/I period/
Armenian Highland
/II period/
Armenian Highland
/Classical Age/
Bingel Dag
Lchashen
Akunk Artik
Shirak
Plain
Sevan
region
Beniamin,
Vardbakh,
Black Fortress I
KarchakhpyurShirakavan
Armenian
Highland
/I period/
Armenian
Highland
/II period/
1.48
1.85
5.75
3.78
1.41
4.80
2.43
5.52
2.98
2.94
4.77
4.04
4.93
1.38
2.86
1.12
1.17
1.57
4.76
2.89
3.87
5.50
4.47
5.21
0.48
2.53
1.41
4.53
3.29
1.98
2.68
3.07
0.53
2.74
2.42
2.68
3.96
3.78
4.33
2.97
3.49
1.99
3.06
3.06
3.22
5.88
5.65
7.04
6.13
6.12
5.13
5.96
5.96
5.78
Armenian Bingel
Highland
Dag
/Classical Age/
5.97
143
Anahit Y. Khudaverdyan
I
-0.465
-0.297
-0.316
0.100
0.799
0.788
0.262
0.877
0.892
0.794
0.097
0.524
35.194
II
0.749
0.444
0.896
0.708
0.039
0.202
0.847
-0.081
-0.031
0.023
0.429
0.608
28.205
III
-0.210
0.741
0.044
0.245
0.376
0.069
0.371
0.148
0.208
-0.358
-0.850
-0.552
17.989
Nonmetric cranial variation in human skeletal remains from the Armenian Highland: microevolutionary relations and an intergroup analysis
Table 9. Matrix of distance, values for fourteen Eurasia mortuary samples examined in this study.
Sample name
Armenian Highland
/II period: Bronze and
Early Iron Ages/
Shirak Plateau /I period/
Artik
Sevan region /II period/
Akunk
Lchashen
Central Asia /Sapallitepe,
Gonur Depe/
Volga region
/Fatianovo Culture/
Volga region
/Balanovo Culture/
Siberia /AndronovoCulture/
Siberia /Afanasevo Culture/
Siberia /Karasukskaya Culture/
Siberia /Tagarskaya Culture/
Sevan
region
Balanovo
Culture
2.38
0.57
5.27
1.71
6.26
5.18
2.71
3.06
0.72
3.92
2.90
5.49
2.04
6.48
5.44
3.59
1.71
0.46
4.59
3.48
1.68
4.06
2.74
4.52
3.39
2.90
4.63
3.11
5.98
5.13
6.15
6.66
5.48
5.98
6.43
7.15
5.29
4.62
5.57
6.55
4.92
6.16
6.26
6.28
1.59
6.33
4.93
3.87
3.69
5.01
3.32
2.35
2.58
6.86
5.45
4.38
4.18
5.91
4.16
3.94
4.65
5.43
3.77
2.76
2.91
5.87
4.47
4.36
4.90
5.46
3.71
3.54
4.29
4.37
2.59
2.49
3.41
5.65
5.53
4.88
4.08
4.45
4.52
3.88
2.94
1.92
2.68
2.84
1.14
1.95
1.05
Anahit Y. Khudaverdyan
II
III
Sutura metopica
-0.047
0.871
-0.143
Foramen supraorbitale
-0.802
0.497
-0.024
0.397
0.859
0.159
Os asterii
0.659
-0.033
-0.456
Foramen parietale
0.826
0.006
0.012
0.658
0.630
0.061
0.863
-0.343
0.266
-0.074
0.042
0.916
Values
38.788
28.276
14.611
Fig. 9. Cluster tree: 1 Armenian Highland /Beniamin-VardbakhBlack Fortress I/, 2 Armenian Highland /Karchakhpyur-Shirakavan/, 3 Armenian Highland /Classical Age/, 4 - Ukraine
/Dzuravka/, 5 Ukraine /Chernykhov, Romashki, Derevynnoe,
Teleshovka/, 6 Ukraine /Gavrilovka, Voloshskoe/, 7 Ukraine
/Koblevo, Ranjevoe, Viktorovka/, 8 Dnestr region /Budeshti/, 9
Dnestr region /Malaeshti/, 10 Latvia /Latgali/
Fig. 8. Factor analysis: Armenian Highland /Beniamin-VardbakhBlack Fortress I/, 2 Armenian Highland /Karchakhpyur-Shirakavan/, 3 Armenian Highland /Classical Age/, 4 - Ukraine
/Dzuravka/, 5 Ukraine /Chernykhov, Romashki, Derevynnoe,
Teleshovka/, 6 Ukraine /Gavrilovka, Voloshskoe/, 7 Ukraine
/Koblevo, Ranjevoe, Viktorovka/, 8 the Dnestr region
/Budeshti/, 9 the Dnestr region /Malaeshti/, 10 Latvia /Latgali/
Nonmetric cranial variation in human skeletal remains from the Armenian Highland: microevolutionary relations and an intergroup analysis
Table 11. Matrix of distance, values for ten Eurasia mortuary samples examined in this study.
Sample name
Beniamin-Vardbakh
-Black Fortress I
KarchakhpyurShirakavan
Armenian Highland
/Classical Age/
Dzuravka
Chernykhov, Romashki,
Derevynnoe, Teleshovka
Gavrilovka, Voloshskoe
Koblevo, Ranjevoe,
Viktorovka
Budeshti
Malaeshti
Latgali
KarchakhpyurShirakavan
Armenian Dzuravka
Highland
/Classical Age/
Chernykhov,
Romashki,
Derevynnoe,
Teleshovka
Gavrilovka,
Voloshskoe
Koblevo,
Ranjevoe,
Viktorovka
Budeshti
Malaeshti
Latgali
1.69
2.64
2.09
4.21
1.82
2.45
3.78
3.75
3.03
3.42
5.96
4.15
2.94
5.68
5.06
4.85
2.04
4.23
3.83
5.27
3.77
2.32
2.73
2.87
3.10
3.49
2.83
4.62
5.75
4.57
2.91
3.85
2.88
3.58
3.50
1.68
4.24
3.21
1.88
4.57
4.28
3.14
2.37
1.45
1.34
BERGMAN P (1987) Cribra orbitalia und ausgewhlte Discreta der Schdel aus dem Reihengrberfeld von Milicz,
Niederschlesien (12. 14. Jh.) unter Bercksichtigung
der Grabausstattung. Acta Musei Nationalis Pragae, 43:
103-108.
BERGMAN P, HAUSER G (1985) Multi-dimensional complexes of skull traits. Anthropol Anz, 43: 165-171.
BERGMAN P (1993) The occurrence of selected non-metrical
traits of the skull in relation to cribra orbitalia and grave
equipment. Variability and Evolution, 2: 63-75.
BERZIN E, GRANTOVSKY E (1962) Kinsman of Indians on
Black Sea shores. Soviet Land, (publ. by the Soviet
Embassy in India) XV (10): 26-27.
BERRY AC, BERRY RJ (1967) Epigenetic variation in the
human cranium. J Anat, 101: 361-379.
BERRY AC (1975) Factors affecting the incidence of nonmetrical skeletal variants. J Anat, 120: 519-535.
BLOM DE (1998) Tiwanaku regional interaction and social identity: a bioarchaeological approach. Ph.D. Thesis. University
of Chicago, Chicago.
BROTHWELL DR (1959) The use of non-metrical characters
in the skull in differentiating populations. Ber. 6. Tag
Dtsch Ges Anthropol Kel, 103: 103-109.
BROTHWELL DR (1981) Digging up bones. The excavation,
treatment and study of human skeletal remains. Oxford University Press.
BUNAK VV (1927) Crania Armenica. Moscow.
ESNYS G (1986) Discrete signs of a skull at people Fatianovo and Balanovo Cultures. Anthropology questions, 76:
117-127.
ESNYS G (1988) The variability of discrete cranial traits in
the East Baltic area and adjacent territories. Homo, 38:
75-97.
ESNYS G, TUTKUVIEN J (2007) Topographical approach to
kinship assessment within population according to discrete cranial traits: the 5th-6th cc. Plinkaigalis cemetery.
Acta medica Lituanica, 14: 7-16.
CHESNIS GYA, KONDUKTOROVA TS (1982) Non-metrical
traits of the skulls of Chernyakhov Culture. Anthropology
questions, 70: 62-76.
CHEVERUD JM, BUIKSTRA JE (1981) A comparison of genetic and phenotypic correlations. Am J Phys Anthropol, 42:
958-968.
147
Anahit Y. Khudaverdyan
CHEVERUD JM, BUIKSTRA JE, TWICHELL E (1979) Relationships between non-metric skeletal traits and cranial size
and shape. Am J Phys Anthropol, 50: 191-198.
CHRISTENSEN AF (1997) Cranial non-metric variation in
North and Central Mexico. Anthropol Anz, 55: 15-32.
CHRISTENSEN AF (1998) Colonization and microevolution in
formative Oaxaca, Mexico. World Archaeology, 30: 262285.
FISENKO VA (1966) On the origins and chronology of the Catacomb-grave culture. Sratov University, Saratov.
FORNACIARI G, MALLEGNI F, BERTINI D, NUTI V (1981)
Cribra orbitalia and elemental bone iron in the punics of
Carthage. Ossa, 8: 63-77.
GAMKRELIDZE TV, IVANOV VV (1984) Indo-European language and Indo-Europeans. Tbilisi University, Tbilisi.
GRIFFIN M (1995) Artificial cranial deformation and nonmetric
cranial variation revisited: evidence from a southeastern U.S.
coastal population sample. Paper presented at the 2nd
Annual Meeting of the Midwest Bioarchaeology and
Forensic Anthropology Association. Dekalb. September
30.
HANIHARA T, ISHIDA H, DODO Y (2003) Characterization of
biological diversity through analysis of discrete cranial
traits. Am J Phys Anthropol, 121: 241-251.
HAUSER G, BERGMAN P (1984) Some biological and
methodological problems of asymmetrical development,
illustrated with reference to sutural bones. Anthropol
Anz, 42: 101-116.
HAUSER G, DE STEFANO GF (1989) Epigenetic variant of the
human skull. Ngele & Obermiller, Stuttgart.
HERODOTUS (1972) History in Nine Books. Translation and
Notes by G.A. Stratanovsky. Leningrad.
HEWSEN RH (1997) The geography of Armenia. In: Hovannisian RG (ed). The Armenian people from ancient to modern
times. Vol. 1. St. Martins Press, New York.
HLUSKO LJ (2004) Integrating the genotype and phenotype
in hominid paleontology. Nat Acad Sci USA, 101: 26532657.
ILINSKAYA VA, TERENOZHKIN AI (1983) Scythia 7th-4th centuries BC. Kiev.
ISHIDA H, DODO Y (1997) Cranial variation in prehistoric
human skeletal remains from the Marianas. Am J Phys
Anthropol, 104: 399-410.
KHODJAIOV TK (1977) Anthropological structure of the population of Bronze Age from Sapallitepe. Fan, Tashkent.
KHOHLOV AA (2000) Craniological materials Srubnaya cultures of the south of the Average Volga region. In: Efimova S (ed). The people of Russia: from the past to the present.
Moscow.
KHUDAVERDYAN AY (2000) The population of the Armenian
uplands during Antiquity, based on data from the Beniamin
cemetery. Tigran Mec, Yerevan.
KHUDAVERDYAN AY (2005) Population Vardbakh of
ancient age according to data to anthropology: cranioscopy, odontology, paleodemograhy, paleoecology.
The VI Congress of the Ethnographers and Anthropologists of Russia, St. Petersburg.
KHUDAVERDYAN AY (2009) The bronze population of Armenian highland. Ethnogenesis and ethnic history. Van
Aryan.Yerevan.
KHUDAVERDYAN A (2011a) Migrations in the Eurasian
steppes in the light of paleoanthropological data. The
Mankind Quarterly, LI (4): 387-463.
KHUDAVERDYAN AY (2011b) Ancient communities of the Caucasus - in the worlds dialogs (an anthropological etude). Lap
148
Nonmetric cranial variation in human skeletal remains from the Armenian Highland: microevolutionary relations and an intergroup analysis
149