Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Tamira K. Brennan
Southeast Missouri State University
[SLIDE 1] The South Cape site (23CG8) is a Mississippian period (AD 1000-1450) village
located in Cape Girardeau County of southeast Missouri. Despite tantalizing evidence of rich
ceremonialism revealed during five seasons of professional investigations at the site from 1977-1981,
relatively little is known about the nature of this village and its interaction with contemporaneous
sites. Current research at South Cape as part of a renewed archaeology field program within
directed at such topics. This article reports on the preliminary findings of the 2007-2009 field
seasons under the direction of the author and briefly reviews those findings in light of the
unpublished excavation data to present a more thorough picture of this unique site.
[SLIDE 2] South Cape occupies approximately 2.3 ha of land atop of an erosional remnant
within the Mississippi River floodplain, less than a mile west of the river. The site’s position is at the
northern limit of what Carl Chapman (1980:184) classifies as the Bootheel Riverine Locality and
abuts the Ozark escarpment to the south. This ecotonal location offers the advantage of access to
resources both of the alluvial valley and the Ozark Highlands, while its elevation makes it a safe
haven during frequent and often severe flooding episodes. The nearest contemporaneous mound
center, Ware Mounds [SLIDE 3], is only 20 miles upriver, though too little is known about this site
[SLIDE 4] South Cape has also been referred to as Hunze-Evans, or simply the Hunze
Mound, although no artificial mound is present at the site. The most notable published data on the
site can be found in Chapman’s (1980) The Archaeology of Missouri II, wherein he dates it to Early
and Middle Mississippian times on the basis of ceramics, the most remarkable of which are pictured
in Figure 6-13 of that text. Among these is an intriguing head pot, one of several vessels given to the
Hunze family by looters in exchange for permission to excavate on the family farm which, to this day
1
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
still occupies the southern half of the site. These vessels likely originate from burials on site,
[SLIDE 5] The Hunze head pot is unusual for the region in that its appearance is both
youthful and cognizant. His open eyes and a crooked “smirk” differentiate this individual from the
deathlike guise depicted among most other head pots recorded from northeast Arkansas and the
Missouri Bootheel region. Although nearly whole, this particular pot appears to have been modified
by the looters before being presented to the Hunze family. Grinding has entirely removed the
original surface from the base of the vessel in the shape of a ring, indicating that this piece once sat
upon a neck or a collar of some sort [SLIDE 6]. The unusually flat rim of the vessel, in combination
with the crudeness of finish immediately inside of the rim indicates that this pot once could have had
a longer “carafe” style neck, although no grinding or filing is immediately apparent upon
macroscopic inspection. Both rim and base have some modern surface treatment such as wax or
varnish applied to make them appear consistently burnished with the rest of the vessel. This and
other pieces in private collections from South Cape attest to a long history of amateur excavations
which disturbed the site to an unknown extent prior to the mid 1970s.
Professional Excavations
[SLIDE 7] The first professional investigations into the site began in 1976 when Duncan
Wilkie was hired to take over the instruction of archaeology courses offered within the sociology
department at Southeast Missouri State University. For two semesters, field work was done as a one
hour a day university course, with Wilkie driving the students to the site from campus and back each
day. A more traditional summer field school began in 1978, with a focus on the northern half of the
site. Excavations ceased at the site in 1981 in an effort to complete the curation and analysis of the
resulting 50 boxes of material before pulling more materials out of the ground, a task undertaken by
students in exchange for course credit. Shortly after this, the recently formed anthropology program
2
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
at Southeast was eliminated from the university, leaving the material processing incomplete and
results unpublished. For more than two decades these materials sat in storage, awaiting the attention
that Wilkie had intended for them prior to the termination of the anthropology program.
archaeological field program was not fully restored until 2007, and has been a huge success [SLIDE
8 video]. [SLIDE 9] This move was prompted by the need to properly curate the Wilkie materials
and accompanied by the enthusiastic cooperation of the Hunze family. Exploratory excavations
commenced that summer with the goal of assessing the site for the development of a long-term
research and preservation program and to provide comparative data to that of Wilkie’s, particularly
samples for radiocarbon dating and features on the southern side of the site. The following 2008 and
2009 seasons were aimed at providing additional data on community layout and extent, with a
primary focus on exploring the eastern site boundary. Ten weeks of excavation and several days of
survey have now been completed during the course of the renewed field program, resulting in
2800m2 of magnetometry survey and 94m2 of hand excavation. [SLIDE 10] While the
magnetometry proved relatively unsuccessful at South Cape, the utility of other geophysical
Materials
Thus far, all 2007 and 2008 materials have been washed and sorted both by field school
students and 2009 materials are being processed. Analysis has been completed on the majority of
the 2007 materials. The ceramics and projectile points from the Wilkie collection have been
analyzed in full by Sarah Stephens, as you will hear about in the next paper, though other Wilkie
Lithics
3
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
[SLIDE 11] The lithics under discussion include all 2007 materials from feature contexts and
the entire 2007 chipped stone assemblage. The chipped stone analysis reveals a pattern of local raw
material procurement. Twenty-one percent of the chert by count and 48% by weight source from
Devonian deposits which underlie the eastern portion of Cape Girardeau County. These include both
Clear Creek and Bailey cherts. Locally available gravel makes up another 9% by weight, although it
occurs largely as tested cobbles and is less than 2% of the assemblage by count.
[SLIDE 12] The presence of non-local cherts occurs nearly exclusively in the form of
finished tools, including hoes and a chisel manufactured out of Mill Creek chert from Southern
Illinois, adzes of Dover chert from Tennessee, and a few Burlington points sourcing to an area in
Missouri just east of St. Louis. Very small percentages of Cobden, Jefferson City, and Kaolin
represent the remaining non-local chipped stone varieties, while Commerce quartzite and Kornthal
from the Thebes gap area as well as flakes of basalt from the St. Francis mountains represent the
procurement of raw materials for on-site production of tools. Point types include those spanning
from Early Archaic to Middle Mississippian time periods, although only Mississippian period
features have been identified at South Cape. Based on this limited analysis there does not appear to
be a large ground stone tool industry at the site, although use of mineral pigments is evident in the
Ceramics
[SLIDE 13] Ceramics in this discussion includes all rims and handles from the 2007
surprisingly, the preponderance of sherds are plain coarse shell tempered, followed by plain fine shell
and shell grog combinations. Decorated sherds are very limited and include incised, engraved, and
red slipped examples. Analysis of the Wilkie collection ceramics by Sarah Stephens proves that a
much wider array of decoration was in use by South Cape’s potters (personal correspondence),
4
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
though apparently not in the features that I’ve been examining! This could be indicative of
differential status between the residents of the northern portion of the site, where Wilkie’s
excavations took place, and the southern portion, but is more likely due to the preponderance of non-
[SLIDE 14] Serving wares represent a larger than expected proportion of all vessels
identifiable to type (34% count, 33% weight), a trend that is mirrored at some but not all Midsouth
sites during their later periods. Positive correlations include Cahokia Mounds during Moorehead
times AD 1200-1275 (Pauketat 1998) and Wickliffe during the Late Wickliffe time period of AD
1250-1350 (Wesler 2001). Similarities to the Tennessee-Cumberland and Lower Ohio Valley
ceramics are apparent in my own and Stephen’s analyses, though an extended discussion on regional
Subsistence
Although only preliminary analyses have been completed on a small sample of South Cape’s
floral and faunal materials, they represent a wide range of resource utilization. [SLIDE 15] This is
not surprising given the excellent state of preservation at the site and its ecotonal position, lying
along the interstice of the Ozark Escarpment, the Mississippi River, and the Ozark Highlands. A
gross inspection of the taxa reveals eastern box turtle, venomous and non-venomous snake species,
rodents, turkey, canine, raccoon, possum, white tailed deer, several species of fish including gar,
drum and catfish, and a very large artiodactyl yet to be positively identified. Several lower limb
elements from this animal likely indicate bison or elk, whose range was significantly broader in
Black bear has also been identified from five different contexts on site. Among these
remains are a metacarpal, several mandibular fragments, several incisors, and a canine tooth. Both
the bear and canine bones recovered may or may not represent the fulfillment of subsistence needs as
5
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
both species have known significance to southeastern peoples beyond the realm of food-stuffs
(Hudson 1976). Furthermore, the elements represented – cranial and forelimb - are low utility in
regards to food.
[SLIDE 16] A large portion of the floral assemblage from 2007, including all flotation
samples and any hand collected seeds and timbers were examined by archaeobotanical consultant
Justine Woodard McKnight (2008). Within these samples she identified grape, persimmon, and
sumac seeds, as well as hickory nuts, acorn, and black walnut. Several cob fragments and kernels of
Zea mays were recovered from the earliest building episode identified within 2007 excavations (AD
1350 +/- 25; UGAMS-03498) and are of the eight-row variety. This is in contrast to the only two
botanical samples known to have been analyzed from the Wilkie collections – two cobs of ten-row
Zea mays with open cupules. Leonard Blake examined these specimens in 1978 and suspected that
they were an older variety of mays “under the influence” of the more recent and cold-tolerant eight
row version (written correspondence between Wilkie and Blake on file, May 23, 1978).
Features
[SLIDE 17] A total of thirty features excavated in part or full during the 2007-09 seasons
include: domestic houses and associated hearths and wall trenches, small and large storage pits, a
midden area, a large post pit, individual post holes, one burial, a fortification wall and a possible
bastion. The number of features excavated by Wilkie has not yet been determined, although he
reports portions of 7 houses, several subfloor pits, 11 burials, and many isolated posts. Unless
otherwise noted, the following feature descriptions are based both on the 2007-09 data as well as
several of Wilkie’s conference papers (1982, 1983) and unpublished field notes (on file, Department
Houses
6
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
[SLIDE 18] Very few complete houses have been excavated at South Cape, although the few
examples that we do have are semi-subterranean and employ wall trench construction with the
notable exception of one single post structure that I will discuss momentarily. Rebuilding is common
and has been noted for as many as four times on the southern side of the site, indicating
Pauketat 2003:46). Incinerated wall fall indicates that hickory was a common structural element,
while pine, ash, and both the red and white oak groups have been identified among smaller building
Houses basins on the south side of the site are found to terminate as deep as 80cmbs,
although erosion and modern day farming precludes determination of the original basin depths.
Hearths are present within some but not all houses and vary from areas of oxidized soil to hardened
clay rings. Daub heavily tempered with organics had been recovered in moderate amounts in
contexts where burning was evident, indicating that it was a common surface treatment to house
walls. [SLIDE 19] A handful of red and white painted pieces from the 2009 season indicate that at
least some structures were decorated as has been noted at the Wickliffe, Kincaid and Angel mound
sites to the east (Wesler year, University of Chicago 1934-1944 notes on file, Center for
Archaeological Investigations Carbondale, Black 1967). This daub came from one of the
stratigraphically earliest occupations on site, located amongst a very heavily occupied area. [SLIDE
19]
Specialized structures are represented on both halves of the site. The first of these (Feature
2) lay along the southern periphery of the site are where the terrace begins to slope. [SLIDE 20] A
rebuilding episode revels that special soils with a high clay content were brought in to fill the outside
of the 50cm deep western wall trench of this feature. This unusual arrangement may represent an
attempt to bolster the wall within these very sandy soils by bringing in more stable fills and by
7
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
additionally heaping this dirt against the outer edge of the structure’s wall once erect. Although this
feature was not fully excavated, its suspected larger than average size may have necessitated such
engineering. In addition to domestic debris, large chunks of Kaolin clay, worked galena, and
portions of four separate miniature vessels -an artifact class that a recent study by Heather Carey
(2006) reveals may be tied to ritual activity – were also uncovered within F.2 (Brennan 2007).
[SLIDE 21] The other example of a specialized structure is Wilkie’s House 1. This feature is
approximately 33m2 in area and exhibits single post wall construction – a technique primarily
employed during early Mississippian times throughout much of the Midsouth, but also known to
have occurred sporadically in the latest Mississippian occupations throughout this region as well
(Lewis and Lewis 1995). House 1 produced an impressive array of unusual artifacts which include: a
triskele shell gorget, five infant burials, a very small fragment of sheet copper, a chunky stone, a bear
canine, a negative painted mother nursing child figurine, and large worked and unworked sheets of
mica. Wilkie addressed this feature at length in a conference paper, with a focus on the gorget
(1983). He very convincingly concludes that House 1was a women’s structure, perhaps associated
This conclusion is well supported by the material evidence. The infant burials were all
interred in shallow pits near the wall of the structure with a turtle carapace placed over their small
bodies in most cases (Wilkie 1982). The style of the shell gorget is also consistent with those found
overwhelmingly in infant and female burials throughout the Midsouth (Kneburg 1957). [SLIDE 22]
Finally, a negative painted bottle depicting a mother nursing child is consistent with Wilkie’s
conclusions. This piece sits in contrast to other known examples of Mississippian nursing mother
figurines in that it does not possess the “hunchback” commonly seen amongst mother figurines in
this region. [SLIDE 23] The only comparably naturalistic fertility figure that I have located in the
region sources to Wickliffe Mounds, and appears to be a woman seated in a birthing position.
8
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
Exploration of the eastern boundary of the site proper has revealed several very interesting
non-domestic features, including a large post pit, a palisade wall that was previously unknown, and
an isolated burial. [SLIDE 24] The post pit (Feature 12) measured 98cm deep with a post mold >34
cm in diameter. A small ramp leading up to this feature would have aided in its placement. This
feature was approximately nine meters west of the palisade wall and superimposed an earlier
domestic house with only one building episode. The defensive wall itself (Feature 16) was
discovered in 2008 and is visible immediately at the base of the plow zone. [SLIDE 25] This feature
was followed in 2009, thus far revealing ~eleven continuous meters of this feature. Overlapping
posts reveal that this wall was rebuilt or repaired in the same location at least one time. These posts
penetrate beneath the base of the trench itself up to 38cm and range from 12 – 25cm in diameter at
their bases. A radiocarbon date from nutshell within this trench is AD 1325 +/- 25 (UGAMS-03499).
The palisade also superimposed an earlier house feature with only one building episode, suggesting
Although no bastions have been encountered along this stretch of wall, the corner of an
oversized rectangular wall trench feature (Feature 17) was located in 2009 lying just several meters
east of F.16 palisade and bearing the same orientation. [SLIDE 26] The wall trenches of this feature
penetrate 160cm below surface and are over 40cm wide where they first appear in plan view.
Although it is not out of the question that this feature is a very large roofed structure of some kind, as
it has not been fully excavated, its orientation and proximity to F.16 makes it more likely that this
Only one burial has been located in recent years, that of an adult female oriented
perpendicular to and superimposing a section of the palisade wall. Portions of the burial were
disturbed by modern day plowing and no grave goods were noted, the skeleton reburied in situ. This
9
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
was an unexpected find given that a formal cemetery area was previousy located by Wilkie in 1977
on the southeastern toe of this slope, away from habitation. The two conventional dates on bone
from this cemetery span AD1240-1320 based on Wilkie’s corrections (notes on file), placing it just
slightly earlier than contemporaneous with the palisade. Whether the 2009 burial represents a later,
isolated instance of interment or yet another example of reappropriation of a portion of the site is not
yet known.
Radiocarbon Dating
Radiocarbon samples were particular important to the new research program at South Cape
as the site’s chronology is poorly understood - or perhaps misunderstood may be a better term. My
initial draw to research at this site were several in a suite of 9 conventional radiocarbon dates run by
Wilkie that ran into the late 15th and mid 16th centuries. [SLIDE 27] These dates would make South
Cape an anomaly within the “Vacant Quarter,” a region across the Midsouth (and including Cape
Girardeau) that was largely abandoned post AD 1450 for unknown reasons while Late Mississippian
cultures elsewhere throughout the southeast persisted (but see also Butler and Cobb 2000, Edging
As exciting as this prospect is, neither the preliminary ceramic analyses nor recent AMS
dates support a late occupation at South Cape. [SLIDE 28] Furthermore, examination of Wilkie’s
notes reveals a discrepancy between the dates listed on the few reports from the lab that ran the tests,
DiCarb analytic, and the dates from these same samples as listed by Wilkie in his notes. While some
are in complete agreement, other samples listed by Wilkie are up to a century earlier, likely
representing his own corrections on the reported lab dates which exclude anything past the mid 15th
century. Heated correspondence between Wilkie and the DiCarb lab evidences his feelings that the
later dated samples were in fact “goofed” (written correspondence from Duncan Wilkie to Irene Stele
10
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
Aside from the very real possibility of inaccurate lab results, it is also possible that more
recent charcoal contaminated the samples from the northern half of the site, which is heavily
disturbed by rodent and looter activity alike. AMS dates run on samples from 2007 and 2008
excavations do not support a 15th century occupation. Both date the south side of the site to the early
- mid 14th century. In light of the contrasting material and radiocarbon data, perhaps the best avenue
of resolve would be to re-run these later samples where possible, or to run more suitable samples
from the same contexts. Of course, a larger suite of dates will also prove helpful to resolving the
CONCLUSION
[SLIDE 29] South Cape has an important story to tell - one of a people at the intersection of
multiple environmental and stylistic zones. Although no previous published data exists on the Wilkie
materials and only preliminary conclusions can be made about the more recent excavation data, it is
clear that South Cape is a remarkable site. The presence of focused fertility-related ceremonialism,
the diverse array of material goods and the perceived need to enclose this site with a large and well
maintained defensive wall all beg further research into timing of South Cape and its relation to
Mississippian sites elsewhere in the region. Future seasons of excavation promise to resolve this and
other important questions, such as the nature and layout of the South Cape’s domestic community.
Understanding how the inhabitants of this site negotiated their borderland position and with whom
they traded, affiliated, and emulated, will offer much in the way of examining both local and regional
11
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
Acknowledgements
The success of the ongoing research at the South Cape site is the result of the support and
enthusiasm of many parties. Among these are the Department of Foreign Languages and
Anthropology at Southeast Missouri State University, the Missouri Archaeological Society, who
generously funded a radiocarbon date through the Lyman, Barnhill, Irving Fund, and to the
Hunze family, whose contributions and involvement have ensured the success of Southeast’s
fledgling field program. Special thanks also go both to Dr. Paul Welch, to the Center for
necessary equipment, and to Dr. John Schwegman for completing magnetometry survey on a
large portion of the site. Finally, thanks to my laboratory workers and volunteers, and to three
seasons of eager field school students, staff and volunteers, especially Ayla Amadio, caitlan
12
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
REFERENCES CITED
Black, Glenn A.
1976 Angel Site. Vols I and II. Indiana Historical Society.
Blake, Leonard
1978 Personal Correspondence to Duncan Wilkie. May 23, 1978.
Brennan, Tamira K.
2007 2007 Field Season Summary and Preliminary Report. Manuscript on file, Department
of Foreign Languages and Anthropology, Southeast Missouri State University.
Carey, Heather B.
2006 More than Mere Child’s Play: An Analysis of Mississippian Miniature Vessels from
the Tennessee-Cumberland and Lower Ohio River Valleys. Master’s Thesis
Submitted to the Department of Anthropology, Southern Illinois University Carbondale.
Chapman, Carl H.
1980 The Archaeology of Missouri, II. University of Missouri Press, Columbia.
Cole, Fay-Cooper, Robert Bell, John Bennett, Joseph Caldwell, Norman Emerson, Richard
MacNeish, Kenneth Orr and Roger Willis
1951 Kincaid: A Prehistoric Illinois Metropolis. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Davis, Donald E.
2006 Southern US: An Environmental History. ABC-CLIO, Inc. Santa Barbara, California.
Edging, Richard
2007 The Vacant Quarter Hypothesis: A Survivor’s Story. The Missouri Archaeologist
68:29-58.
Kneburg, Madeline
1959 Engraved Shell Gorgets and Their Associations. Tennessee Archaeologist 15:1-39.
Lewis, R. Barry
1990 The Late Prehistory of the Ohio-Mississippi Rivers Confluence Region, Kentucky and
Missouri. In, Towns and Temples Along the Mississippi. David H. Dye and Cheryl Anne
Cox, eds. Pp.38-58. University of Alabama Press, Tuscaloosa.
13
The South Cape Site: a Fortified Mississippian Village in Southeast Missouri Brennan
Pauketat, Timothy R.
2003 Resettled Farmers and the Making of a Mississippian Polity. American
Antiquity. 68:39-66.
1998 The Archaeology of Downtown Cahokia: Tract 15A and Dunham Tract Excavations.
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Studies in Archaeology No.1. Illinois
Transportation Archaeological Research Program, University of Illinois, Urbana.
Wesler, Kit W.
2001 Excavations at Wickliffe Mounds. University of Alabama Press, Tuscaloosa.
Williams, Stephen
1990 The Vacant Quarter and Other Late Events in the Lower Valley. In Towns and
Temples Along the Mississippi, edited by David H. Dye and Cheryl Anne Cox, pp.170-
180. University of Alabama Press, Tuscaloosa.
Wilkie, Duncan C.
1977-1981 Field Notes, 23Cg8. On file, Department of Foreign Languages and
Anthropology, Southeast Missouri State University, Cape Girardeau, MO.
1983 Shell Gorget in a Small Village Context. Paper Presented at the 48th Annual Meeting
of the Society for American Archaeology, Pittsburgh, PA.
Woodard-McKnight, Justine
2008 Interim Report on the Analysis of Hand-Collected and Flotation-recovered
Archeobotanical Remains from the South Cape Site (23CG8), Cape Girardeau County,
Missouri. Manuscript on file, Department of Foreign Languages and Anthropology,
Southeast Missouri State University.
14
South Cape: A Fortified
Mississippian Site in Southeast
Missouri
Tamira K. Brennan
• Common Fields
• Ware Mounds
Cape Girardeau you are here
South Cape *
• Towosahgy
St. Louis
• Common Fields
• Ware Mounds
Cape Girardeau you are here
South Cape *
• Towosahgy
Above, from Chapman 1980 p.245
Basalt
Above and bottom left from Wilkie 1983
From Wilkie 1983
DIC-1885 500±45BP
DIC-1886 480±55BP
DIC-1887 480±45BP
DIC-1890 470±45BP
DIC-1891 430±50BP
DIC-1892 650±110BP
DIC-2195 640±70BP
UGAMS-03498 600±25BP
UGAMS-03499 625±25BP
AD 1300 +/- 25
AD 1325 +/- 25
Special thanks to: Department of Foreign
Languages and Anthropology at Southeast
Missouri State University, the Hunze family,
the Missouri Archaeological Society, Dr.
Paul Welch, the Center for Archaeological
Investigations at Southern Illinois University
Carbondale, and to three seasons of eager
field school students, staff and volunteers.
Contact: tbrennan@semo.edu