Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
PERGAMON
Abstract
The present research examined the e}ects of occupational stress in psychiatric nursing on employee well!being using
the full Job Strain Model[ The Job Strain Model was assessed for its ability to predict employee well!being in terms of
job satisfaction and mental health[ The original Job Strain Model was expanded to include social support based on
previous research concerning the impact of social support on well!being[ In the present study\ both work support and
non!work were assessed for their contribution to well!being[ The results of this study indicate that the full Job Strain
Model can be used to signi_cantly predict job satisfaction and mental health in this sample of Australian psychiatric
nurses[ Furthermore\ social support was shown to be an important component of the Job Strain Model[ 0887 Elsevier
Science Ltd[ All rights reserved[
Keywords] Occupational stress:work stress^ Job Strain Model^ Social support^ Job satisfaction^ Mental health[
0[ Introduction
It is well accepted that nurses work in a high stress
environment and a large amount of research has focussed
on the sources of this stress[ Additionally\ specialised
nurses such as psychiatric nurses\ have been identi_ed as
most likely to experience the negative consequences of
occupational stress such as physical and psychological
ill!health "Tyler et al[\ 0880#[ While research recognises
that psychiatric nurses are exposed to high levels of work
stress\ Karasek and Theorell "0889# and Bussing "0877#
propose that nursing is a low strain occupation when
assessed using the Job Strain Model "Karasek\ 0868#[
However\ there is little empirical research in nursing that
utilises the full Job Strain Model to test this assertion[
Recent studies testing the Job Strain Model support
the prediction that increased job control can reduce the
impact of job demands "Dwyer and Ganster\ 0880#[ In
addition to lessening the impact of job demands\ Hurrell
and McLaney "0878# found that increased job control
E!mail] jrodwelldeakin[edu[au
S99196378:87:, ! see front matter 0887 Elsevier Science Ltd[ All rights reserved[
PII] S 9 9 1 9 6 3 7 8 " 8 7 # 9 9 9 3 8 1
239
2[ Employee well!being
2[0[ Worker health
Psychological stressors\ job demands in particular\
have an important impact on the well!being of the worker
"Caplan et al[\ 0879#[ Stress has a wide range of e}ects
on worker behaviour including adaptive and maladaptive
responses resulting in short! and long!term health impli!
cations\ including substance abuse\ depression\ anxiety\
sleep disorders\ and eating habits "Smith\ 0889#[ Tyler et
al[ "0880# found a signi_cant correlation between overall
nursing stress scores and symptomatology\ and con!
cluded that workload could be a principal predictor of
health and well!being[ The relationship between psycho!
logical stressors at work and adverse health outcomes\
and the need to develop coping patterns\ are in~uenced
by both the e}ects of support in the work!place and social
support away from the work environment[
2[1[ Job satisfaction
Job satisfaction has been shown to play a signi_cant
role in both worker health "Jackson\ 0872# and per!
formance "Chay\ 0882#[ Low levels of job satisfaction
have been associated with high levels of perceived work
stress "Jones et al[\ 0876^ Perrewe and Ganster\ 0878#[
Job satisfaction has been linked with health outcomes
including depression\ anxiety\ and tension "Caplan et al[\
0879#[
In Karasek|s "0868# original tests of the Job Strain
Model\ job demand and job control were found to have
signi_cant impacts on satisfaction measures for both life
and work[ Fox et al[ "0882# tested the Job Strain Model
in a hospital setting and found support for the model
using job satisfaction and physiological health indices as
outcome variables[ Landsbergis et al[ "0881# found that
workers in low strain jobs reported the lowest job dis!
230
4[ Method
4[0[ Sample
The study was conducted at a private inpatient facility
for psychiatric patients[ The sample consisted of psy!
chiatric nursing sta} drawn from each of the _ve units of
an Australian private psychiatric hospital[ Sta} were
given two weeks to complete and return the questionnaire
to the sealed boxes provided[
A response rate of 59) "N 59# was obtained from
the sta} rostered to work over the two week period during
which the study was conducted[ The participants rep!
resented all grades of registered nursing sta}[ Seventy!
three percent "N 32# of the participants were female\
42) were aged 2039 years\ and 58) of participants
worked less than seven shifts per fortnight[
4[1[ Measures
The demographic variables\ gender and position\ were
included in the analyses with the scales below[ Gender
was coded one for males and two for females[ The pos!
ition variable was coded zero for junior sta} "e[g[ Regis!
231
5[ Results
Descriptive statistics and correlations are shown in
Table 0[ All analyses were performed using the SPSS
package[ To begin with\ the correlations were analysed
to highlight the pattern of relationships among the vari!
ables in the analysis[ Hierarchical regressions are used to
explore the predictive nature of the relationships
described in the propositions above[
The large number of signi_cant correlations in Table
0 is explored in more detail by employing multiple
regression analyses[ A three step hierarchical regression
was performed on both of the measures of well!being\
worker health "N 34# and job satisfaction "N 33#[
Social support was entered in the _rst step\ ahead of job
demand and job control in the second block\ to determine
the main e}ects of support on well!being[ The demo!
graphics were entered with the support variables in order
to account for personal and position di}erences in the
outcome variables[ The job demand by job control inter!
action term was entered in the third and _nal block so as
to ascertain the independent contribution of the inter!
action term[ The overall demand equation signi_cantly
explains the variance in worker health\ R1adj 9[4099\
F"6\26# 6[43\ P 9[9990[ The overall demand equa!
tion also proved signi_cant for the outcome measure
job satisfaction with R1adj 9[5587\ F"6\25# 02[35\
P 9[9990[
Non!work support and work support had signi_cant
main e}ects for both worker health and job satisfaction[
Job control was a signi_cant predictor of both health
and satisfaction[ The demand:control interaction term in
block three was not signi_cant and did not contribute
232
Health
Satisfaction
Work support
Non!work support
Job demand
Job control
Satisfaction
Work support
Non!work support
Job demand
Job control
Mean
Standard deviation
9[1194
9[2800
9[3015
9[9649
9[9088
19[08
5[90
9[5599
9[5434
9[2314
9[5818
49[77
09[57
9[5839
9[2033
9[3317
22[54
6[45
9[2303
9[2505
12[15
4[88
9[1342
24[87
5[86
46[39
00[00
Note] P 9[94[
Table 1
Hierarchical multiple regression analyses of worker health and job satisfaction
"Block# Predictor
Worker health
B
"0# Gender
"0# Position
"0# Non!work support
"0# Work support
"1# Job demand
"1# Job control
"2# Job demand
Job control
Constant
1[1498
9[3693
9[3671
9[1175
9[9957
9[0352
9[9931
Satisfaction
b
9[0617
9[9265
9[3674
9[2995
9[9967
9[1639
9[2763
R1 "cum#
9[4249
9[4752
9[4768
03[8449
B
1[8166
9[7262
9[7254
9[3376
9[0950
9[4070
9[9938
R1 "cum#
9[0123
9[9265
9[3539
9[2040
9[9614
9[4240
9[1495
9[4251
9[6117
9[6125
07[3147
6[ Discussion
233
References
Banks\ M[H[\ Clegg\ C[W[\ Jackson\ P[R[\ Kemp\ N[J[\ Sta}ord\
E[M[\ Wall\ T[D[\ 0879[ The use of the General Health Ques!
tionnaire as an indicator of mental health in occupational
studies[ Journal of Occupational Psychology 42\ 076083[
Beehr\ T[A[\ King\ L[A[\ King\ D[W[\ 0889[ Social support and
234