Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
January 2006
This document has been produced with the financial assistance of the European Union.
The contents of this document are the sole responsibility of Marie Stopes Cambodia, Marie
Stopes International Myanmar, Marie Stopes International Viet Nam and Marie Stopes
International Australia and can under no circumstances be regarded as reflecting the
position of the European Union.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Marie Stopes Cambodia (MSC), Marie Stopes International Myanmar (MSIM) and Marie Stopes
International Viet Nam (MSIVN) would like to extend their sincere thanks to the European Commission for
funding this literature review and publication as a part of the Mekong Integrated VCT project. Special thanks
to Dr. Douglas Shaw, HIV Technical Advisor, who conducted this comprehensive research, and for his
valuable input to this project over the first six months. Thanks also go to all members of the Regional Task
Force (RTF) who provided consistent encouragement and timely feedback. They were:
1. Ms. Jo Howard
2. Mr. Ros Thoeun
3. Dr. Khin Tar Tar
4. Ms. Nguyen Thi Bich Hang
Our particular thanks go to Dr Om Chhorvoin the Regional Project Manager, also a member of the RTF, who
led this new project through the preparation phase with energy, enthusiasm and unfailing support. Special
thanks go to the Technical Teams in each country for their strong support, and especially for their gracious
hospitality and efficiency in arranging Key Informant Interviews. Our thanks go also to the staff of the
Medicam Library in Phnom Penh, who were both patient, and responsive, to requests for various
publications and reports.
Finally, our thanks go to the Key Informants themselves for setting aside some of their valuable time to
share their knowledge and insights which have added value to this report.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
page #
9
11
11
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
12
12
12
13
13
15
17
18
18
20
20
21
21
21
21
22
22
23
24
25
25
27
27
27
29
30
30
31
31
31
32
33
34
35
37
38
38
39
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
40
40
41
41
43
43
47
47
48
51
51
55
56
57
57
57
58
59
59
59
59
63
65
65
67
69
69
72
75
75
77
80
81
82
83
84
84
85
85
86
87
87
88
89
89
90
91
92
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
94
94
95
96
96
96
97
97
99
99
99
102
102
102
102
102
103
103
104
104
104
104
105
105
106
107
107
108
108
108
108
108
109
109
109
109
110
111
112
112
114
114
115
115
116
117
118
118
118
120
121
121
121
122
122
124
126
126
127
127
127
129
130
130
134
135
136
136
136
138
139
139
140
141
141
141
142
143
144
146
148
9. REFERENCES
150
10. ANNEXES
163
163
164
164
165
166
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
LIST OF ACRONYMS
GENERAL
Asian Development Bank
ADB
Adolescent and Reproductive
ARH
Health
Anti-Retroviral Therapy
ART
Anti-Retro Viral
ARV
AusAID Australian Agency for International
Development
British Broadcasting Commission
BBC
(World Service Trust)
Behaviour Change Communication
BCC
Behavioural Sentinel Surveillance
BSS
MDG
MSIA
MSM
MSF
MTCT
NGO
Non-Government Organisation
OI
PEPFAR
PLHA
PLWHA
PSI
SRH
Opportunistic Infection
President's Emergency Plan for
AIDS Relief
People Living with HIV/AIDS
People Living With HIV/AIDS
Population Services International
Sexual and Reproductive Health
STD
STI
TB
UNAIDS
UNDP
UNHCR
UNICEF
UNV
USAID
KAP
International Organisation
International Planned Parenthood
Federation
Japan International Cooperation
Agency
Knowledge, Attitudes and Practice
KII
MARPS
WB
WHO
CBO
CDC
CSW
DFID
DOTS
DSW
ELISA
FHI
GFATM
GIPA
HDI
HSS
IDU or
IDUs
IDSW
IEC
ILO
IO
IPPF
JICA
UNESCO
UNFPA
UNGASS
UNHCHR
UNODC
VCT
VCCT
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
CAMBODIA
Cambodian Demographic and
CDHS
Health Survey, 2000
CHRHAN Cambodian Human Rights and
HIV/AIDS Network
Cambodia Millennium
CMDG
Development Goals
Continuum of Care
CoC
Complementary Package of
CPA
Activities
Cambodian Network of People
CPN+
Living with HIV/AIDS
(100%) Condom Use Program
CUP
MPA
MSC
NAA
NACD
MoWVA
NCHADS
NCHP
HACC
NMCHC
KHANA
NSP II
MoH
Ministry of Health
RHAC
MYANMAR
Drug Detoxification/ Treatment and
DDTRU
Rehabilitation Unit, Ministry of
Health
Central Committee for Drug Abuse
CCDAC
Control
Fund for HIV/AIDS for Myanmar
FHAM
VIET NAM
Community-based Counseling and
CCSC
Support Centre
Marie Stopes International
MSIVN
Viet Nam
NAP
MSIM
PAC
SAVY
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This document is a situation analysis of HIV/AIDS in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam, with
specific reference to voluntary counseling and testing (VCT). The main purpose of this analysis is
to provide sufficient detail to effectively plan integrated VCT services, tailored to the
epidemiological, cultural, behavioural and economic context of each country. A comprehensive
literature review, supplemented by Key Informant Interviews in all three countries was used to
prepare this report. A selection of the most important findings is presented here.
Global Overview
HIV counseling and testing is the "entry point" or "gateway" to the Continuum of Care.
Globally, there is low coverage of HIV counseling and testing services.
A human-rights based approach to HIV counseling and testing contributes to reducing
stigma and discrimination.
Studies confirm that VCT is cost-effective and promotes positive behaviour change.
Community outreach to raise HIV/AIDS awareness and the provision of treatment, care
and support services, are strong motivators to increase uptake of VCT services.
VCT services integrated into existing sexual and reproductive health settings is a model
that is strongly supported in the international literature.
Challenges include reaching the partners of VCT clients and encouraging voluntary
disclosure of results to partners while preventing the possibility of gender-based violence.
Regional Overview
There is extreme geographical and temporal diversity in the HIV epidemics in Asia.
The contributing factors that fuel these epidemics are: poverty; other sexually transmitted
infections; the sex industry; human trafficking; mobility; stigma and discrimination; the
vulnerability of women; and high risk behaviours among Injecting Drug Users (IDUs) and
men who have sex with men (MSM).
Cambodia
Cambodia has demonstrated strong political commitment to a national multi-sectoral
response, resulting in a consistent fall in HIV prevalence (1.9% in 2003).
There is increased condom use by sex workers and fewer sexual partners for male
sentinel groups, but condom use in sweetheart relationships is still relatively low.
There are significant gender and cultural barriers that limit a more effective response:
young women are expected to remain virgins until marriage and not to know about sexual
matters, while male promiscuity is tolerated.
Most HIV transmission in Cambodia is now husband-to-wife and mother-to-child.
The HIV/AIDS Law in Cambodia is considered best practice in Asia.
The National Strategic Plan 2006-2010 recognizes the need to include IDUs and MSM as
population groups for HIV prevention.
Cambodia has received significant support from the international donor community,
including the Global Fund for HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria.
There are well developed and active networks of International and Non-Government
Organisations (NGOs), and of People Living with HIV/AIDS (PLHA) in Cambodia.
There is evidence of reducing levels of stigma and discrimination in Cambodia.
There are rapidly increasing numbers of PLHA receiving antiretroviral therapy and well
developed home based care and support services, at least in urban areas.
There is an urgent need for youth-friendly sexual and reproductive health.
There is a strong demand for HIV counseling and testing services.
There are over 109 licensed VCT sites using rapid tests and a comprehensive set of
national policies, guidelines and training curricula is available.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
Couple's counseling and testing, is increasing but there is still low uptake VCT for the
Prevention of Mother-To-Child Transmission of HIV.
Myanmar
The HIV epidemic in Myanmar is moving from a concentrated form, with high prevalence
among IDUs, to a more generalized form. The national prevalence in 2004 was 1.3%.
There is an urgent need to promote wider discussion on sexual, cultural and behavioural
practices to increase awareness of HIV/AIDS.
The National AIDS Programme is located within the Ministry of Health which limits the
ability to plan a multi-sectoral response. The current context also limits the ability to form
effective partnerships to allow scale-up of critical interventions.
The United Nations Expanded Theme Group is implementing the Joint Programme for
HIV/AIDS in partnership with the government and International and local NGOs, but with
limited resources. The Global Fund withdrew from Myanmar in late 2005.
There are a few small groups of PLHA which are becoming active in responding to
HIV/AIDS in partnership with the government.
Capacity building for all sectors involved in the HIV/AIDS response is urgently needed.
High levels of stigma and discrimination towards PLHA and IDUs are a barrier to HIV
prevention efforts.
Harm reduction initiatives for IDUs are starting to be implemented as pilot activities.
There is strong community demand for VCT services, despite low levels of treatment,
care and support services. Coverage of VCT services for high risk behaviour groups is
expanding, but coverage for the general population remains low. Population Services
International have been given approval to conduct screening and confirmatory testing.
Most VCT in Myanmar is in the context of the PMTCT program.
Technical resources for VCT are at various stages of development with detailed
Operational Guidelines in draft form.
Viet Nam
The HIV epidemic in Viet Nam is moving from a concentrated to a more generalized form
with wide variations in prevalence among target groups in different Provinces (high rates
among IDUs and increasing rates among sex workers). The national prevalence in 2004
was 0.4%. There are a significant number of female sex workers who are injecting drugs.
Levels of stigma and discrimination towards PLHA and towards IDUs and sex workers,
remain high.
There is increased political commitment to addressing HIV/AIDS with a move from a
"social evils" approach to a harm reduction approach. A new Law which should
contribute to reducing stigma and discrimination awaits endorsement
While the Greater Involvement of PLHA principle is endorsed, in practice there is limited
involvement in responding to HIV/AIDS at present.
Women in Viet Nam have relatively high levels of health, education and gender equity,
but there are persisting cultural and social norms that limit HIV prevention efforts, such as
the expectation that women will remain virgins until marriage and taboos on discussing
sexual issues.
There is limited recognition of MSM as an important population group for HIV prevention.
There is an urgent need to expand access to treatment, care and support services.
There is a strong need for youth-friendly sexual and reproductive health services.
There is a national plan to expand VCT services but currently NGOs are not allowed to
do confirmatory testing. Current protocols use non-rapid tests with resultant delays in
informing clients of results.
There are comprehensive Vietnamese and English language training resources for VCT
available from International and NGOs working in partnership with the government.
Mass organizations in Viet Nam have the potential to widely promote VCT services.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
10
This review will use the acronym VCT to refer specifically to the type of HIV counseling and testing service that the Marie
Stopes Clinics plan to provide. For more general discussion, the term "HIV counseling and testing" will be used.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
11
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
12
The global efforts to scale-up critical interventions in response to HIVAIDS require a strong
monitoring and evaluation framework with accurate, timely and comparable data to assess
progress, strengthen local programs and demonstrate accountability. There are a number of
international resources available with detailed indicators and tools for monitoring and evaluation
of the whole spectrum of HIV/AIDS interventions6, 7.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
13
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
14
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
15
In reviewing the progress that member States have made in implementing the Declaration of
Commitment on HIV/AIDS, the UN Report noted that only 62% of responding States had laws
and policies in place to protect against discrimination towards people living with, or affected by,
HIV/AIDS, and that many of these were general, rather than HIV specific, laws and policies.
There were far fewer States (38%) with policies that prohibited discrimination against specific
vulnerable population groups5.
Because human rights issues are strongly linked to stigma and discrimination, a short discussion
of this important issue is included in this literature review. A recent study by Ogden and Nyblade
in 200516, in Ethiopia, Tanzania, Viet Nam and Zambia, described stigma as "a process of
devaluation" of people either living with, or associated with, HIV and AIDS. Discrimination, which
follows stigma, was defined as the unfair or unjust treatment of an individual based on his or her
real or perceived HIV status (citing a UNAIDS December 2003 Fact Sheet). A short summary of
this study is presented here with more details of the results from Viet Nam given in Section 7.7.
The key finding was that HIV/AIDS stigma and discrimination was "remarkably consistent" across
the four countries studied. The country contexts were very different, with the three African
countries experiencing generalized HIV epidemics, while in Viet Nam the epidemic was
concentrated among injecting drug users and strongly linked in policies and programs to illegal
drug use and prostitution, both considered as "social evils". A detailed analysis of the results
indicated that in all four study locations a process of fear related to unlikely casual modes of
transmission, combined with fear-based public messages and underlying moral judgments, led to
a division between "them" and "us". People living with HIV/AIDS tended to be placed on a
continuum from innocence (children) to guilt (sex workers and injecting drug users). Stigma was
found to be greater towards women than men, perhaps because women are expected to uphold
the moral traditions of society.
Four broad types of stigma were found in all four countries, although with varied specific
expression:
physical stigma: isolation and violence
social stigma: isolation, voyeurism, loss of identity and role
verbal stigma: gossip, taunting, experience of blame and shame, labeling and use of
derogatory words
institutional stigma: loss of livelihood and housing and differential treatment in school,
health care, public spaces and in the media.
The consequences for individuals with HIV infection were: loss of marriage and child-bearing as
life options; loss of livelihood; poor care in the health sector; withdrawal of care-giving in the
home; and internalized or "self-stigma", with effects on mental health including loss of hope,
feeling worthless, having no future, anxiety and depression.
Stigma has an impact on treatment programs for HIV, with those experiencing stigma less able or
willing to access and use treatment services. Stigma also has an impact on prevention programs,
as fear of stigma may lead to some people with HIV denying their infection as a self-protective
response. This could lead to further transmission of HIV. Stigma also was found to have an
impact on HIV testing services, preventing people from accessing testing services, or not
returning for the results of tests.
Of importance to this literature review was the finding that people experiencing stigma and
discrimination avoided clinics known as HIV testing sites and expressed fears that test results
may not be kept confidential. The impact of stigma on disclosure of results is discussed in more
detail in Section 3.2.5: Impact of HIV counseling and testing.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
16
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
17
The World Health Organisation (WHO) and the United States Centre for Disease Control (CDC)
have produced a Generic Training Package for the Prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission of
HIV with modules on specific interventions to prevent transmission; infant feeding options; stigma
and discrimination in relation to PMTCT; HIV counseling and testing for PMTCT; linkages to
treatment, care and support for mothers and families with HIV infection; safety and supportive
care in the work environment; and PMTCT program monitoring20.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
18
The role of health services in protecting young people from HIV and AIDS has been specifically
addressed in a recent WHO publication27. Health services have a key role in providing accurate
and up-to-date information, in implementing interventions such as condom promotion and harm
reduction for IDUs, and in the provision of diagnosis, treatment and care, with counseling and
testing for HIV being an important health service responsibility.
In addressing gender issues among young people, there has been an understandable focus on
girls and women. However, the role of young men in promoting sexual and reproductive health,
including their role in HIV prevention, needs to be addressed. There are some successful small
scale initiatives working with young men to encourage them to take increasing responsibility for
their own, and their partners, sexual health, but such interventions remain limited in their scope28.
Useful practical resources have been developed by WHO. A Rapid Assessment and Response
guide for especially vulnerable young people (defined as those who sell sex or inject drugs,
young migrants and refugees, young men who have sex with men and groups such as homeless
youth and orphans) was published in 200429. WHO has also developed a guide for monitoring
and evaluating HIV prevention programs for young people in recognition that there is limited data
specific for young people7. Most national HIV surveillance systems only include a small subsample of youth aged 15-24 years which makes it difficult to accurately assess the magnitude of
some indicators and to assess trends in prevalence and behaviours30. Even among youth, data
needs to be disaggregated by age, gender, school attendance, marital status, urban or rural
residence, as well as for specific risk behaviours such as needle sharing during injecting drug
use, unprotected commercial sex work and unprotected sex among men who have sex with men.
Injecting drug use is a behaviour mostly practiced by youth, and directly relevant to Myanmar,
Viet Nam and Cambodia. Among Injecting Drug Users (IDUs), HIV infection can be transmitted
by needle sharing and unprotected sex. The following comments provide a brief global overview,
with the Regional Overview (Section 4.6) and country-specific sections adding more detail. WHO
notes that injecting drug use continues to spread around the world "regardless of religious
persuasion, stage of economic development, social class, environment (urban or rural) or political
system"31. It is estimated that IDUs account directly for 10% of all reported AIDS cases globally.
In Asia, explosive epidemics among IDUs have been reported in Myanmar and Viet Nam as well
as in China, Nepal, Thailand, Malaysia and north-east India. Within 6 to 12 months of the
appearance of the first case, 60-90% of the IDUs in a particular location can be infected. The
infection spreads from drug distribution epicenters and along drug distribution routes. Sexual
transmission to non-IDU sexual partners can fuel a more generalized HIV epidemic, particularly if
significant proportions of IDUs are also engaged in commercial sex work31.
WHO has commissioned a comprehensive literature and program review to assess the
effectiveness of community-based outreach in preventing HIV/AIDS among injecting drug users32.
Outreach is one component of a comprehensive approach to prevent HIV infection among IDUs,
along with the provision of clean needles and syringes, drug dependency treatment options,
condom promotion and HIV counseling and testing. The conclusion of the review was that there
was strong evidence of reduced risk behaviour, lowered exposure to HIV and increased use of
voluntary counseling and testing and drug dependency services as a result of outreach:
"Outreach is an effective strategy for reachingIDUs and provides the means for enabling IDUs
to reduce their risk behavioursHIV transmission in IDUs is preventable"32, 33. Based on this
evidence, WHO have produced a Training Guide for HIV prevention outreach to IDUs which
contains details of the planning and content for an orientation workshop, a program development
workshop, a program management workshop and field worker training in core outreach skills34.
However, the cultural and legal situation in some countries limits a harm reduction approach to
injecting drug use, with needle and syringe exchange programs and drug substitution programs
not officially approved. Details specific to Cambodia, and especially to Myanmar and Viet Nam,
are presented in the country-specific sections that follow. Section 7.11 describes the important
link between injecting drug use and sex work in Viet Nam, a situation that is common in many
other countries to varying extents.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
19
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
20
Key indicators for these interventions, selected for this literature review are6
HIV sero-prevalence among all TB patients
intensified case finding for TB among PLHA
rate of new cases of TB diagnosed clients attending HIV counseling and testing
services or HIV treatment and care services
proportion of all registered TB patients who are tested for HIV
proportion of these who are HIV+
proportion of HIV+ TB patients who receive post-test counseling.
3.2.2 HIV counseling and testing: the entry point or gateway to HIV
prevention, treatment, care and support
Over the past 20 years, HIV testing has clearly moved from a diagnostic tool to an essential
component of HIV prevention, treatment, care and support, best summarized in the diagram
below. HIV counseling and testing is now considered as the "entry point" or "gateway" to a
Continuum of Care. "Among interventions which play a pivotal role both in treatment and
prevention, HIV counseling and testing stands out as paramount"41.
ii
WHO uses the term "HIV testing and counseling". In this review, the order is reversed as "HIV counseling and testing"
to highlight the importance of counseling and to put the steps in the preferred order.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
21
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
22
motivate partners to seek testing, change behaviour and ultimately reduce transmission; it
provides increased opportunities for social support; improved access to medical care, including
antiretroviral therapy; and increased opportunities to discuss and implement risk reduction with
partners and plan for the future. However there are some potential risks for the individual,
including loss of economic support, blame, abandonment, physical and emotional abuse,
discrimination, and disruption of family relationships.
A detailed review of the impact of disclosure of HIV status by WHO44 found that:
rates of disclosure in developing countries were notably lower than rates in
developed countries
larger proportions of studies in developing countries reported women that did not
share results with anyone (10-78%), compared to women in developed countries (310%)
the most common barriers to disclosure were fear of abandonment, loss of economic
support from partners, rejection/discrimination, violence and accusations of infidelity
motivating factors for disclosure were a sense of ethical responsibility for the
partner's health and the need for social support to cope with the diagnosis
the outcomes of HIV status disclosure were generally positive in both developed and
developing countries, but the review noted that those who chose not to disclose may
be those more likely to have negative outcomes.
The key relevant recommendations from this study were:
develop and test different models of VCT to ensure that people, particularly women,
are not put at risk
assess issues of disclosure among youth, including injecting drug users
develop effective ways to involve men in HIV counseling and testing and promote
couples' counseling
develop '"screening tools" to help counselors identify women least likely to disclose
and most likely to experience negative outcomes from disclosure
assess whether community-based stigma reduction interventions increase uptake of
HIV testing and disclosure rates
test models to incorporate interventions to address violence against women in HIV
counseling and testing settings
consider cross-training of HIV and domestic violence staff and promote referral
between these services
consider culturally appropriate mediated forms of disclosure, for example through the
counselor or a trusted family member or friend.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
23
referral to peer-support networks can help HIV+ persons come to terms with their
status
it is important to involve the community in the development of new services
sustainable funding for VCT services must be ensured.
This Manual was a key reference document for the Marie Stopes Mekong VCT Project Proposal as the national level
situation analysis outline described in this Manual is reproduced in the Project Proposal.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
24
A Reference Guide for Counselors and Trainers53. This Manual contains 11 chapters
covering a wide range of HIV/AIDS issues in relation to counseling and testing.
Chapter 2 discusses various HIV testing strategies and protocols, types of HIV tests,
the interpretation of HIV tests and confidentiality.
Counseling and Testing for Youth: a manual for providers54. This Manual covers most
aspects of HIV counseling, but with a focus on youth.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
25
Private Sector models can provide high quality services, are seen as private and
confidential and responsive to client needs, but with limited access to the poor.
For these models it may be more difficult to ensure national standards are
followed.
Public sector and NGO partnerships can build on the strengths of both these
models.
Mobile/ outreach VCT service models. There is currently limited international
experience of these models, most of which have operated as pilot activities. A
potential advantage is the ability to serve hard to reach groups, such as injecting
drug users and sex workers. However, these services are expensive and
confidentiality may be difficult to maintain.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
26
to-reach-youth have limited experience in developing countries and are expensive. Private sector
VCT services can reach some youth, but pre-test counseling, informed consent and testing may
not be of adequate quality. Home testing is becoming available in some countries, but this not
VCT as such, and not a desirable model as results may be inaccurate or misinterpreted, pre-test
counseling not provided, and there is no referral mechanism to other services50.
Issues to consider in choosing models
Several key criteria help to decide the most appropriate service model(s) in the unique
epidemiological, behavioural and economic context of each country42, 47. These include:
program goals
choice of local authorities
target populations
level of stigma and discrimination in the community
management and administrative ease
potential for linkages
existing demand and likelihood of service utilization
equity issues
cost of the service model
cost-effectiveness of the service model
feasibility
ability to be replicated
sustainability
ethical and legal considerations (see below).
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
27
"Central to making the "3 by 5"iv initiative work at the local level will be civil society
leadership and involvement with HIV testing. Community groupswould be involved in
all aspects of HIV testing, from education to providing the testing itself (in a secure,
friendly, non-judgmental environment). It makes more sense to invest in these
communities and their organizations to deliver because there is very little hope that
scaling up with a focus on government doctors and labs can take place in the short term.
It simply takes too long, is too expensive, and can not even begin to deal with the
numbers of people needing to access HIV testing and treatment services that currently
exist in the highly affected regions, much less will be able to scale up56".
"The time has now come to implement HIV counseling and testing more widely using
existing health care settings, moving beyond the model of provision that relies entirely
upon concerned individuals seeking out help for themselves to permit broader access for
all. In this new approach, such services will become a routine part of health care, for
example during attendance at antenatal clinics or at diagnosis and treatment
forsexually transmitted infectionsThese innovations cannot come quickly
enoughthe lost opportunities for providing care and for strengthening prevention efforts
are enormous57, 58".
"To achieve large scale implementation of HIV VCT, Family Health International supports
the notion espoused by WHO and other international organizations that it is critical to
move beyond the idea of VCT as a package always to be provided in the exact way in all
circumstances42".
"Yet, all too often, VCT has been introduced in isolation from services meeting people's
overall sexual and reproductive health needs59".
"VCT services may have to be general or targeted depending on a range of factors
including HIV prevalence, health-seeking behaviour, levels of stigma, access to hard to
reach groups and supportive legal and policy environmentFew services have been
developed to help young people in developing countries who are at increased
vulnerability to HIV/AIDS as a result of risk practice or experience" (italics in original)50.
"VCT initiatives have been slower to develop in Asiaand have not been adequately
prioritized in the past, resulting in a shortage of a broad range of good practice models
from the regionless attention has been given to developing models for integrated
community-based VCT programs" (p2). "In a relatively low prevalence setting such as
Asiaintegrating services could not be more important, particularly in the fight against
stigma and discrimination" (p4). "VCT is best placed and more likely to be a valuable
service if integrated and mainstreamed within existing community servicesit is
imperative that the test is accessible, available and suitable for specific client
populations" (p23-24)60.
The United States Agency for International Development (USAID) Regional Strategy for
Asia supports the expansion of VCT services through NGOs and community based
groups for vulnerable populations.
"Since it is especially difficult for those most at risk for HIV to access VCT in
government clinics and other institutions, it is especially important that NGOs and
other organizations that can reach MARPs [Most At Risk Population groups],
have the ability to provide VCT, or at least counseling with referral to testing"61.
iv
The 3 by 5 initiative is a program led by WHO to have 3 million People Living with HIV/AIDS on antiretroviral therapy by
the year 2005.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
28
Family planning settings offer specific opportunities for reaching women with an
integrated VCT service, in particular:
this approach helps to meet the demand for knowing HIV status, as VCT services
are currently not available to many people, especially women, who want to know
their HIV status
VCT and Sexual and Reproductive Health (SRH) services have similar aims
integration makes it easier for some clients to use VCT servicesmany people
are not comfortable attending free-standing sites because of the stigma and
discrimination associated with HIV testing
this approach provides opportunities to reach young people, men and couples
groups who might not otherwise access VCT services
the costs of integration are lower because of the similarities between VCT and
SRH services lower start-up costs, minimal changes to existing infrastructure,
many service providers already with basic counseling skills, logistical
management systems for SRH services that can manage VCT commodities,
SRH service providers already familiar with referrals, and existing SRH outreach
can be expanded to include VCT promotion62.
Appendices include checklists for counseling and testing and sample monitoring forms
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
29
In response to these barriers, youth-friendly VCT services have been suggested as a way to
encourage youth to present for HIV testing with the opportunity to provide HIV prevention,
treatment, care and support education.
The components of VCT are more than pre-test counseling, testing and post-test counseling (see
3.2.4: Components of HIV counseling and testing). Each sexual and reproductive health service
site needs to decide which components of a comprehensive HIV counseling and testing service
are able to be integrated into existing clinic services, and which are best done by other groups or
organizations62.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
30
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
31
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
32
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
33
Cambodia
Myanmar
Viet Nam
13,798,000
38%
2.5%
4.1
19%
450
52,170,000
31%
1.5%
2.3
30%
360
83,123,000
31%
1.6%
2.3
26%
130
97
140
56
76
106
61
17
23
71
130
99
81
74%
64%
34%
129
50
90%
86%
80%
108
83
47
90%
87%
73%
10.9%
na
27.3%
$US 320
$US 192
34%
$US 220
$US 30
-
$US 550
$US 148
<2%
1.9%
123,000
20.8%
1.2%
[0.6-2.2]
330,000
27.5%
0.4%
[0.2-0.8]
220,000
4.4%
not known
2.2%
34.4%
1.8%
29.3%
0.35%
10,000
11.8%
955
6.8%
1,000+
1.8-3.0%
24%
32%
38%
45%
34%
57%
76%
32%
79%
85%
86%
28%
(1) UNICEF website www.unicef.org/ accessed 20 December 2005. Unless indicated, data is for 2004.
71
(2) Human Development Indicators, 2005 from http://hdr.undp.org/reports/global/pdf/HR05_HDI.pdf (HDI
is a composite measure of longevity, educational attainment and standard of living). (3) HIV/AIDS data from
most recent national sources: see country-specific Sections 5, 6 and 7. (4) Statistical Year Book 2003,
Central Statistical Organisation, Yangon, Myanmar which states the Annual Population growth rate to be
2.02%.
vi
The unadjusted MMR for Cambodia is 437, based on the Cambodian Demographic and Health Survey 2000 and widely
cited in national and international references. This table shows the adjusted MMR for all three countries from the UNICEF
website.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
34
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
35
140000
50% Spouse
SW 15%
IDU 20%
MTCT 15%
120000
100000
90% SW
Spouse 5%
IDU 5%
80000
60000
40000
20000
70% IDU
SW 26 %
19
85
19
86
19
87
19
88
19
89
19
90
19
91
19
92
19
93
19
94
19
95
19
96
19
97
19
98
19
99
20
00
20
01
20
02
Year
Lao, Philippines,
Bangladesh,
Pakistan,
Afghanistan,
Bhutan, Maldives
Cambodia,
Thailand
Year
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
36
United States government documents usually use the former country name of Burma in preference to Myanmar.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
37
high. The variables that have the greatest impact on unit costs are: the number of counselors
and their remuneration; number of clients counseled; whether the VCT service is delivered in a
free-standing facility or integrated into existing structures; and program management.
CARE International
CARE International, a major international NGO, has a Regional Strategy for the Asia Region
(2003) with four strategic objectives which aim to reduce the vulnerability of mobile populations;
reduce the vulnerability of sex workers; promote meaningful involvement of PLHA; and promote
recognition of IDUs as stakeholders in policy and program development. The strategy has an
intentional gender and human rights based focus81.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
38
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
39
13,798,000
38%
2.5%
4.1
19%
450
97
140
56
130
99
81
74%
64%
34%
10.9%
$US 320
$US 192
34%
1.9%
123,000
20.8%
not known
2.2%
10,000
11.8%
24%
32%
38%
45%
(1) UNICEF, unless indicated, data is for 2004. (2) Human Development Indicators, 2005
(3) HIV/AIDS data from most recent national sources
There is a large and growing literature related to HIV/AIDS in Cambodia. Much of this is countryspecific, but reference to HIV/AIDS in Cambodia is also found in many regional and international
articles and publications. All this literature can be broadly classified into two main categories.
The first are primary source documents, studies, articles and other publications. The second are
review or summary documents which bring together many of the primary sources. This Section
of the literature review uses both categories: key review articles are summarized and additional
viii
The unadjusted MMR is 437 and is based on the Cambodian Demographic and Health Survey 2000 and widely cited in
national and international references. This table shows the adjusted MMR for Cambodia from the UNICEF website.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
40
details on relevant issues, especially for HIV counseling and testing, are provided from the
primary sources. There are two key review publications that have been extensively used for this
Cambodia country-specific section:
The UNAIDS Country Profile: an overview of the HIV/AIDS/STI Situation and the
National Response in Cambodia, 5th Edition, December 200488. Several sections of
this document are now out-of-date and this literature review provides updated
information, where available.
The National AIDS Authority, National Strategic Plan for a Comprehensive and
Multisectoral Response to HIV/AIDS 2006-2010 which was released in November
200589.
At the time of completing this review (January 2006), an important document was in the process
of being finalized: Scaling Up Voluntary Counseling and Testing Services: lessons learned from
Cambodia, prepared on behalf of UNICEF90. This will be an additional key reference for the
Marie Stopes Mekong Regional VCT Project.
In addition to a review of publications and reports, a total of eight Key Informant Interviews (KII)
were conducted with representatives from the government, International Organisations and
NGOs in Cambodia. A further three less structured meetings were held with representatives of
three other organizations, prior to the development of the KII questionnaire (Annex 2).
The key issues related to HIV/AIDS in Cambodia that were identified by the Key Informants were
as follows (in no particular order):
the Cambodian government has demonstrated continuing high political commitment
to addressing HIV/AIDS, reflected in a strong health sector response with increased
regulation and coordination with International Organisations (IOs) and NGOs.
there have been significant changes in awareness of HIV/AIDS in Cambodia with
almost all people now having heard of HIV/AIDS
increased resources have allowed increased and expanded responses to HIV/AIDS
compared to limited resources in the past
there is now increased transmission from husband to wife and mother to child
possible epidemic among IDUs in the near future
need to intensify prevention among students and migrant workers
many people still don't speak openly about sexual matters, but there are signs of
positive changes in this practice
there is a need to increase motivation among community leaders, especially at the
commune level, to address HIV/AIDS in their communities
globalization, with related population mobility and changed economic circumstances,
has placed some population groups in Cambodia at increased risk of infection
condom use in non-commercial sexual relationships remains low due to issues
related to trust.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
41
For the 2003 HSS there were changes in quality assurance testing where samples from 1999 to
2003 were re-analysed to assess the rate of false positive and negative results. The prevalence
rates from these years were then retrospectively adjusted. The adjusted 2003 HSS results are
summarized here, together with trends from comparison with earlier HSS:
Direct Female Sex Workers 20.8%, with a consistent trend down from 42.8% in 1998
Indirect Female Sex Workers 11.7%, with a less marked but downward trend from
18.4% in 1998
Police 2.5%, reduced from a high of 4.5% in 1997
Antenatal women 2.2%, rising from 1.9% in 1996, leveling at 2.5% from 1998-2000,
then followed by a small reduction to 2.2% in 2003
The national prevalence for adults aged 15-49 years, using the adjusted methodology, was
calculated to be 1.9%, with a consistent reduction in prevalence from a high in 1997 of 3.0%
shown in the diagram below. This national prevalence decrease cannot be explained by
increased deaths from AIDS alone and therefore means that the incidence must be declining.
Percentage
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
2.9
3.0
2.8
2.7
2.5
2.1
2.2
2.1
1.9
2002
2003
0.5
0
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
Year
Based on this HSS 2003 prevalence data, there were an estimated 123,000 PLHA in 2003
(65,600 men and 57,000 women). The proportion of female PLHA has been consistently
increasing to reach almost 50% in 2003. The estimated number of AIDS cases in 2004 was
19,814 (11,470 men and 8,344 women). These numbers represent a considerable reduction
from calculations using earlier unadjusted data. For example, the UNAIDS December 2004
Update92 uses data from the US Bureau of Census database which combines data from different
sources. At the end of 2003, it was estimated that 170,000 adults and children were living with
HIV/AIDS (51,000 women), with 15,000 AIDS deaths in 2003. The adult prevalence for 2002
using the unadjusted data was 2.6% [1.4-4.4], a figure widely quoted in many recent references.
The HSS provides province-specific data, but the sample size is too small for district level
analysis. In Cambodia, the highest HIV prevalence rates are found in the south-east and central
provinces and along the Thai border.
Using the Asian Epidemic Model and data from the 2002 HSS, transmission between married
couples now accounts for about half of all new infections, while about one-third are due to
mother-to-child transmission88.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
42
2002
0.59
6.45
2.87
0.26
The conclusion was that there was a reduced incidence of HIV infection in all groups except
pregnant women attending antenatal clinics. This was considered to be consistent with reduced
transmission among the high risk population, but with more constant transmission among the
general population. Further recently published research by Saphonn et al (cited by UNAIDS2)
has shown that there has been a significant increase in HIV incidence among pregnant women
along the Thai-Cambodian border from 0.35% in 1999 to 1.48% in 2002.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
43
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
44
12.8% of the men had more than one sex partner in the last year
13% had sex with a sex worker in the last year.
men, both urban and rural, who traveled away from home for more than one
month in total in the last year were more likely to purchase sex
consistent condom use in the last three months with a DSW was 70.1% for rural
men and 81% for urban men, while with a sweetheart, the rates were 17.7% and
42.1% respectively
there was a low reported rate of urethral discharge (3.8%)
12% of men had ever been tested for HIV (7.7% rural and 25.2% urban) with
40% of the total tests occurring in public clinics and 36% in private clinics. Only
18.6% of urban men and 8.5% of rural men were tested at a VCT.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
45
knowledge of prevention varied, with condoms cited by 84% of men and 89% of
women, but abstinence by only 26% of men and 17% of women
knowledge of where HIV testing could be done varied by urban or rural location, with
urban respondents listing health centres/ hospitals, VCT centres or the Pasteur
Institute in Phnom Penh, and rural respondents listing health centres/ hospitals. Most
(89%) urban respondents knew at least one location for HIV testing compared to
71.4% of rural respondents
86% of men and 80% of women assessed that they were at "no risk" of HIV infection
issues related to condom use were embarrassment in buying a condom (77% of men
and 81% of women), embarrassment in carrying a condom (70% men, 78% women),
low acceptance that unmarried women could buy condoms (18% men, 10% women),
higher acceptance that married women could buy condoms (68% men, 79% women)
and high levels of belief that condom use implied mistrust (92% men, 82% women).
only 48.5% of men and 33.2% of women had ever discussed condom use with
another person (family, friend or sexual partner)
attitudes towards PLHA were varied with most men (73%) and women (88%) willing
to care for a relative with AIDS; most men (63%) and women (91%) agreeing that a
HIV positive female teacher who is not sick can continue teaching; but only 21% of
men and 45% of women would buy food from a HIV infected food seller.
only 5% of the sample (29% in Phnom Penh) had ever been tested for HIV, but 98%
of the urban sample and 86% of the rural sample were interested in having a test
for men, condom use in last sex with a sex worker was high at 98%, but lower for last
sex with any non-spousal partner (79%) and only 50% with a regular non-spousal
partner.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
46
37% state that a female teacher who is HIV+ should be able to continue to teach
(53% for those with higher education)
only 30% have positive attitudes towards PLHA: a combination of the two indicators
above (46% for those with higher education)
24% believe that a patient should be allowed to keep their HIV status private
66% state that correct use of condoms can provide protection from HIV infection
66% also state that having one faithful sexual partner is protective
40% have no incorrect beliefs about AIDS: a composite variable of those stating that
a healthy looking person can have AIDS and that HIV is not transmitted by mosquito
bites or sharing meal with a HIV+ person (68% for those with higher education)
overall knowledge about mother to child transmission of HIV was 73% with separate
results for transmission during pregnancy at 70%, during delivery, 62% and during
breast feeding, 67% (all higher for women with higher education). When all three subvariables are combined, 59% of the women have correct knowledge about MTCT
(75% for those with higher education).
36% know two ways to prevent HIV infection and reject 3 misconceptions (61% for
those with higher education)
only 14% know three ways to prevent HIV and reject 3 misconceptions (23% for
those with higher education)
only 3% had ever received HIV testing (8% in urban areas and 8% for those with
higher education)
64% believe that a woman can negotiate safer sex with her husband (refuse sex or
use a condom if husband has an STI)
none of the women in this sample had higher risk sex in last 12 months
the median age for first sex for those aged 15-24 years was 21.6 years
no young women (15-24 years) were recorded as having had pre-marital sex in the
last 12 months.
An STI Prevalence study was conducted in 2001101. This used cross sectional cluster sampling
in seven provinces to determine the prevalence of the most common STIs in priority populations:
brothel based sex workers, police and women attending antenatal clinics. The study included
diagnostic tests for symptomatic and asymptomatic STI. Key findings were:
low rates of ulcerative and non-ulcerative STI for all groups except sex workers
high level of sensitivity to currently used antibiotics
evidence of behaviour change with fewer partners and more condom use
STI prevalence consistently lower than in 1996
The survey report concluded that "the low STI prevalence rates add biological evidence that
strengthens the credibility of reported behaviour change and helps explain recent declining HIV
trends".
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
47
The report notes that poverty in Cambodia fuels the HIV epidemic through:
gender inequalities with strict division of roles between men and women inside
society and inside families, with strong hierarchies leading to rigid stratification
commercial sex consumption by young men that is socially tolerated, making married
women vulnerable to infection from their husbands
a weak public sector, including health and education, that hinders a multi-sectoral
response
migration and mobility for economic reasons
disempowering the poor from claiming their rights.
It is estimated that from 2004, 20,000 Cambodian people will die each year from AIDS, with 70%
of these deaths in people aged 20-44 years. In addition to the burden this will place on the health
system, there will be a need to strengthen social safety nets to support the families affected88. A
recent study by Allenbrack et al in 2004103 provides evidence for this claim. The study aimed to
identify the social and economic impact of HIV/AIDS on children, adolescents and their guardians
through a case-comparison study design of two groups of 500 households. Each case group
household had at least one adult living with HIV, while control households were those in close
proximity to the case household. Interviews were conducted with the guardian and at least one
child aged 6-12 or adolescent aged 13-18 years. Key results relevant to this review were:
case households had a higher percentage of widows
case households had lower income, higher health expenditure and fewer household
assets
stigma and discrimination was reported more often by women in case households
children in case households had fewer meals per day
adolescents in case households were less likely to be enrolled in school and more
likely to work for income and take on additional household responsibilities
using a specially adapted Quality of Life assessment tool, the quality of life in case
households was significantly lower than in control households.
Another study assessed the impact on HIV/AIDS on older people in Cambodia104. Case studies
in 15 rural villages in Battambang Province showed that HIV/AIDS resulted in significant changes
in the responsibilities and needs of older people. There were substantial increases in workload
as older people, especially women, assumed the role of primary carer for sick relatives and
orphaned children. With the added responsibilities of income generation and domestic duties,
older people were found to be vulnerable to extreme poverty. This finding is further compounded
by a unique situation in the population demography of Cambodia. As a result of war and civil
unrest, there were fewer births between 1970 and 1980. Many of those born during that time
were denied basic health and education and now, as adults, have limited skills. This, combined
with the reduced population of males over 45, means that there are fewer grandparents in
Cambodia to care for sick relative and orphans105.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
48
A study by Phan and Patterson in 1994106 is widely cited, as the study title uses a Cambodian
saying: "Men are gold, women are cloth". Some key cultural and behavioural findings are
presented here:
Cambodian men are able to seek sexual pleasure with beautiful women at whim
The concept of beauty is superficial and out of the reach of the majority of
housewives as it is equated with youth and virginity
Men believe they are in control of their futures, while women believe they are subject
to men's inability to curb sexual desire, but are unable to give them the sexual
gratification they need. Men visiting sex workers is a normal part of the culture
Men dominate women in Cambodian society. "Love, affection and trust in marriage
is rarewives are expected to take the traditional role of respectable women quiet
and submissive"
Wives are generally not considered to have good sexual techniques so men go to
sex workers who have such skills
Single women have little opportunity to learn about sex. They are considered "bad
women" if they reveal too much knowledge of sexual issues.
The 1994 findings related to HIV/AIDS knowledge can be contrasted with current levels of
knowledge. In 1994, levels of knowledge and awareness about HIV in Phnom Penh were
relatively high in men and a little less in women, but there were many misconceptions. One of
these was that specific groups, including Vietnamese sex workers and foreigners, were most
likely to contract HIV infection. Interestingly this study noted that even in 1994 there were signs
of changes in traditional values, with mothers wanting young couples to be tested for HIV before
marriage - at a time when there were no HIV counseling and testing services in Cambodia.
In 1999, Tarr and Aggleton published a study of young people in Cambodia which explored risks,,
but also sought to understand the meanings that underpin behaviours and related sexual
identities and cultures107. The key finding was that the dominant discourses about sexuality and
their consequences for young men and women are best characterized by "contradiction". Young
women are expected to do everything in their power to resist the sexual advances of young men,
while the latter, regardless of what they do, avoid condemnation for their actions. The study was
based on fieldwork among 281 young people and 62 older informants in 1995 and 1996 in Phnom
Penh and one rural location near the city. Key findings are summarized here:
none of the sexually active young women practiced any form of safe sex
young men stated they would never use a condom with a woman their own age with
whom they were romantically involved
young male's early sexual contacts were motivated by "sex for pleasure" and the
"release of semen"
male respondents described a variety of forms of oral sex, all of which were more
popular than anal sex, which was often portrayed as something dirty
paying for sex with sex workers, often in groups, was considered an integral part of
peer group socializing for young men
beer promotion using young and glamorous women symbolizes what alcohol
consumption could, in theory, do for men
nearly all young people interviewed agreed that the family reputation was an
important consideration in making decisions about sexual activity.
This study criticized the superficial understandings of sexuality described using external
categories in most epidemiological and behavioural surveys where there are convenient divisions
of people into separate groups that can be targeted for prevention efforts. This study noted that a
more complex interplay of what is socially respectable and socially illicit is present and this needs
to be considered in designing interventions for HIV prevention.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
49
ix
This refers to a situation where a woman, usually but not always a sex worker, is coerced to a venue where a number of
young men are waiting for sex. Studies suggest this is a form of male bonding and is known as bauk in slang terms.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
50
In the uniformed services there is a culture of masculinity and risk taking, working
away from family, additional income, feelings of invulnerability, peer pressure and
excessive alcohol consumption (See Section 5.11.3).
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
51
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
52
MDG5: Improve maternal health. The targets for Cambodia for 2015 are to:
reduce the Maternal Mortality Ratio from 437 (1997) to 140
reduce Total Fertility Rate from 4 (1998) to 3
increase births attended by trained persons from 32% (2000) to 80%
increase use of modern methods of birth spacing from 18.5% (2000) to 60%
increase antenatal visits to at least two for each pregnancy from 30.5% (2000) to
90%.
Other specific targets relate to malnutrition and micronutrient deficiencies in women. The
2003 Report suggests that Cambodia will fall short of most targets with the exception of
the Total Fertility Rate.
MDG6: Combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases: The HIV/AIDS targets for
Cambodia for 2015 are:
reduce HIV prevalence among persons 15-49 from 2.6% (2002) to 1.8%
reduce HIV prevalence among pregnant women from 2.7% (2002) to 1.5%
increase condom use during last commercial sex from 91% (2002) to 98%
increase youth using condoms with non-regular partner from 82% (2000) to 95%
increase condom use in married "at risk" women from 1% (2000) to 10%
increase antiretroviral therapy (ART) for PMTCT from 2.7% (2002) to 50%
increase ART for people with advanced AIDS from 3% (2002) to 75%.
The 2003 report suggests that Cambodia will meet the prevalence goal for the
general population but may fall short in reducing prevalence among pregnant
women. For many of the other indicators, there is insufficient data at present to
anticipate trends.
National Poverty Reduction Strategy 2003-2005
This official document is produced by the Council for Social Development and endorsed by the
Prime Minister113. The priority poverty reduction actions are: to maintain macroeconomic stability;
improve rural livelihoods; expand job opportunities; improve capabilities; strengthen institutions
and improve governance; reduce vulnerabilities and strengthen social inclusion; and promote
gender equity. The document makes multiple references to HIV/AIDS, particularly in the sections
on vulnerability and gender (see also Section 5.8: Gender Analysis in Cambodia). One key quote
states: "HIV/AIDS has stripped most of the victims of their future and hope, and their ability to live
in equal stance as ordinary citizens" (p22).
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs (NCHADS) Strategic Plan for
HIV/AIDS, 2001-2005
NCHADS are the lead agency in the Ministry of Health for responding to HIV/AIDS. This plan
was prepared to complement the National Strategic Plan 2001-2005 and to outline the roles and
responsibilities of the Ministry of Health114. The plan has three main elements:
to reduce transmission in high risk situations through targeted STI care and
increased condom use
to provide awareness raising, counseling and testing services to the general
population
to equip the health system to cope with increased demand.
There are eight strategies:
1. HIV/AIDS and STI awareness and education, including IEC and outreach
2. 100% condom use for brothel-based sex workers
3. STI services
4. Blood safety
5. PMTCT
6. AIDS care, including institutional and home based care, hospices and self-help
groups, counseling, testing and universal precautions
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
53
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
54
Ministry of Rural Development (MRD) aims to integrate HIV/AIDS issues into all
programs to mitigate the impact on rural communities through a five-year strategic plan
2002-2006.
Ministry of Social Affairs, Labor, Vocational Training and Youth Rehabilitation
(MoSALVY) aims to improve the social environment of vulnerable groups and support
PLHA and other vulnerable groups. This Ministry is in the process of being reorganised
into a Ministry of Labor and Vocational Training and a separate Ministry of Social Affairs
and Youth Rehabilitation. A Strategic Plan 2002-2006 was developed and funds from the
Global Fund awarded, but poor infrastructure and a shortage of skilled staff have meant
that little of these funds have been disbursed.
Ministry of Women's and Veteran's Affairs (MoWVA) has its own strategic plan for a
comprehensive response to HIV/AIDS and has also published a Policy on Women, the
Girl Child and STI/HIV/AIDS in 2003120. The key objectives of this policy are to work in a
multi-sectoral way to prevent STI and HIV/AIDS infections, reduce the impact of STI and
HIV on women and girls, and to ensure access to care for women and girls with STI and
HIV/AIDS.
National Authority for Combating Drugs (NACD) has developed a Drug Control Master
Plan 2004-2009 that refers to harm reduction for HIV/AIDS prevention.
Government Response at the Provincial Level includes Provincial AIDS Committees
(multi-sectoral), Provincial AIDS Secretariats which support the PAC, and Provincial
AIDS Offices (PAO) which address the health sector response to HIV/AIDS.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
55
Round 1: Partnerships for going to scale with proven interventions for HIV/AIDS, TB
and malaria, was approved for peer education among garment factory workers,
youth, military and police; STI case management; treatment and care for PLHA;
impact mitigation; and social marketing of condoms. The requested and approved
funding was $US 15.7 million with $ 9.7 million disbursed by September 2005. The
Grant agreement was signed on 27 January 2003 and Grant Start Date recorded as
01 September 2003122.
Round 2: Partnerships for going to scale with proven interventions for HIV/AIDS. A
total of $14.9 million was requested with $5.3 million approved and $4.7 million
disbursed by September 2005. The Grant Agreement was signed on 14 October
2003 with the Grant Start date of 1 January 2004123. The goal of this proposal is to
reduce the mortality and morbidity resulting from HIV/AIDS through the
implementation of the National Strategic Plan for HIV/AIDS. The objectives are:
o to expand coverage and enhance quality prevention activities to include
vulnerable populations not adequately addressed so far, including increasing
the availability of VCT
o to improve access to quality comprehensive care interventions including
Highly Active Anti-Retroviral Therapy (HAART), and promoting GIPA
o to secure reliable and adequate drug supplies in order to improve access to
quality comprehensive care interventions, including Opportunistic Infections,
STI, PMTCT and ART.
Round 4: Continuum of Care, requested $US 36.5 million of which $8.8 million had
been approved and $2.8 million disbursed by September 2005124. The Grant
Agreement was signed on 24 June 2005 with start date of 01 September 2005. The
goal of the Round 4 proposal is to increase the survival of PLHA in Cambodia and
reduce the percentage of infected infants born to HIV infected mothers. The three
objectives are:
o to increase the number of PLHA receiving ART; support capacity of health
care professionals; and build partnerships with PLHA. One target is to have
26,715 patients with advanced HIV on ART by the end of 2009, representing
75% of those in need of treatment
o to increase the capacity of health care facilities to support comprehensive
HIV care and fill gaps in the continuum of care
o to increase the percentage of HIV infected pregnant women and their
newborn who receive ARV prophylaxis to prevent MTCT of HIV.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
56
Other NGOs with major investments in Cambodia's HIV/AIDS response are CARE Cambodia,
Family Health International and Population Services International (see Section 5.6: National Level
HIV/AIDS Networks).
NGOs play important roles in behaviour change communication, empowerment interventions,
peer education, community awareness and outreach, advocacy, providing counseling and testing
services, resource mobilization and in care and support services for PLHA and their families88.
The media response to HIV/AIDS has been reviewed in a 2003 POLICY Project study128 which
assessed the thematic content of selected print media over three months in late 2002. The study
recognized that the media is a central actor in disseminating information on HIV/AIDS and
shaping community attitudes towards those most affected. The key findings were:
Reaksmey Kampuchea and Popular Magazine were the most read publications
English language materials represented 77% of the total number of relevant materials
the theme of prevention and infection by HIV/AIDS was dominant
attitudes towards PLHA, discrimination and the lives of infected women were scarcely
reported
women are perceived as vectors of contamination, contributing to stigma, especially
for women who work in the entertainment sector
PLHAs are reported objectively in only one-third of materials analyzed. They tend to
be excessively dramatized, sensationalised or romanticized
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
57
the local media also place an exaggerated emphasis on charlatanism related to the
treatment and cure of PLHAs through traditional medicines
recommendations relate to the diversification of themes covered and training for
journalists in identifying key themes and reflecting on appropriate reporting styles.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
58
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
59
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
60
Equal status of vulnerable populations: Women have formal equal legal status under
the Constitution and the Law on Marriage and the Family, "but the reality is that they
are less equal than men in many respects, including property, finances, work and
domestic relationships".
Therapeutic Goods: Cambodia became a member of the World Trade Organisation in
October 2003. The Law on Patents, Utility Model Certificates and Industrial Design
(January 2003) allows Cambodia to take advantage of the special conditions for least
developed countries and exempts pharmaceutical products, including anti-retroviral
drugs, from patent protection until 1 January 2016. The safety of therapeutic goods is
dealt with under the Law on the Management of Pharmaceuticals, 1996, but in
practice, pharmaceutical products are widely available and largely unregulated, with
resultant concerns about drug-resistance to antiretroviral and other antibiotics used
for HIV/AIDS management. No legal barriers exist for accessing condoms and the
quality and safety of condoms is regulated under the Law on the Management of
Quality and Safety of Products and Services 2000.
Ethical research: Cambodia has a functioning national ethical review committee
based at the National institute of Public Health.
In the context of the current legal and human rights situation for HIV/AIDS in Cambodia, it is
interesting to reflect on the findings of a hospital based survey of medical staff and AIDS patients
receiving treatment in Phnom Penh in 2001, before the Law was enacted136. At that time there
was
"little awareness, much less compliance, with national policies for HIV testing in public
facilitiesThe procedure for informing, counseling and obtaining consent from patients
seems to be determined by the staff or institution with little regard for national policies
and guidelines. Medical staff routinely test patients without informing them or obtaining
consent, results are sometimes withheld from the patient despite their request to be told,
test results are given to relatives and other medical staff without patient authorization, pre
and post-test counseling are often skipped and of poor quality".
More recent monitoring of HIV/AIDS related human rights by the Cambodian Human Rights and
HIV/AIDS Network (CHRHAN), cited by the NAA Technical Working Group135, has shown that
breaches of human rights are most likely to occur in health care, family and community settings.
Of 83 recorded cases on the CHRHAN database there were:
5 cases (2 females) of testing a person without their voluntary informed consent
11 cases (6 females) of failing to provide adequate pre-and post-test counseling
15 cases (10 females) of breaching confidentiality with HIV/AIDS related information
6 cases (4 females) of discrimination in employment
5 cases (all females) of discrimination in education
49 cases (35 females) of restrictions on the freedom of movement or residence, with
the majority of these related to isolation of a person because of their HIV status or
restricting a person's right to choose where to live because of their HIV status.
Of relevance to this literature review is the fact that 72% of all recorded cases involve alleged
breaches of the law by workers and institutions in the health sector.
Implementing Guidelines of the Law on the Prevention and Control of HIV/AIDS, 2005
In 2005 the NAA published Implementing Guidelines in English and Khmer in order to explain the
provisions of the Law in plain language; to identify duties and responsibilities under the law; to
explain how these responsibilities will be fulfilled; and to increase awareness and understanding
of the Law. Each of the chapters of these Guidelines is summarized here, with more details
provided in Section 5.12 on HIV counseling and testing.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
61
Chapter 1 explains why the Law was needed and why the Guidelines were prepared.
Respecting the human rights of PLHA, dealing with discrimination, recognizing rights of
privacy and confidentiality and encouraging the involvement of PLHA are stressed.
Penalties, including fines and imprisonment, may be imposed for breaches of some
sections of the Law.
Chapter 2 notes that HIV education should provide "timely, accurate, specific and
relevant HIV information that will empower people to think and act in ways to protect
them from HIV infection, to minimize transmission and mitigate the personal and social
consequences of infection". The content of all education initiatives should be guided by:
accuracy, clarity, culturally appropriate, detailed, gender-sensitive, affirmative and
demonstrating a respect for human rights. School-based HIV education, education for
health care workers, for women and girls, for other vulnerable populations, for tourists
and travelers and HIV/AIDS in the workplace are given separate specific mention. The
role of religious institutions is recognized as playing a vital role in the national response.
The Law requires that all HIV prevention materials, such as condoms and sterile injecting
equipment, must be accompanied by printed information in Khmer to explain proper use.
The NAA will develop and enforce standards in relation to this requirement as well as
address compliance with advertisements for HIV/AIDS treatment or prevention materials.
Chapter 3 states that infection control in the community must respect the human rights of
PLHA but must also address unregulated activities such as tattooing and alternative
health practitioners. Infection control in health care facilities must be based on universal
precautions. People have the right to demand a HIV test of blood, organ or tissue
donations and penalties can be imposed for breaches of these Sections of the Law. The
intentional transmission of HIV is considered a criminal offence, but the Guidelines do not
recommended an over-reliance on criminal law and punitive approaches.
Chapter 4 covers counseling and testing which are recognized as central to an effective
response to HIV/AIDS. Pre and post-test counseling provide opportunities to deliver
education and information about HIV/AIDS. The Guidelines explain in simple language
the provisions of the Law that prohibits any HIV testing that is not voluntary and informed.
Premarital testing is given specific mention, as this is not required by law and testing
must always be anonymous, voluntary and informed for both persons, with disclosure of
results not permitted to anyone other than the person requesting the test. HIV testing for
minors requires the written consent of the person's legal guardian. The definition of
"minor" varies between different Cambodian Laws (marriage is permitted at age 18 for
women and age 20 for men, or younger with parental consent; anti-trafficking laws
defines a minor as under 15 years; and the employment law as under 16 years), but the
Guidelines state that an appropriate definition for the purposes of HIV testing is a person
under the age of 18 years. The written permission from the child's legal guardian must be
obtained before testing, but if this is impossible, a decision must be made as to whether
having a HIV test is in the best interests of the minor. If so, and the minor gives written
consent, the test may go ahead in the normal way. In the case of persons who are
mentally ill, the State can give consent for testing. This Chapter briefly mentions that
standards for HIV counseling and testing and the licensing of testing centres is the
responsibility of the Ministry of Health through NCHADS.
Chapter 5 notes that all sectors of society need to contribute to the provision of adequate
health care and support services for PLHA. Specific mention is made of the need to
increase the HIV/AIDS awareness and skills of Traditional Birth Attendants. Under the
Law, PLHA are entitled to receive free primary health care in all public health facilities.
The definition of primary health care is based on the Minimum Package of Activities
(MPA) provided at Health Centres, together with the Complementary Package of
Activities (CPA) at the Referral Hospital. The Guidelines note that many Health Centres
operate cost-recovery schemes and the NAA will lead a process of seeking external
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
62
funding to cover the health care costs of PLHA. People exposed to HIV/AIDS through
rape or health care staff through needle-stick injury are entitled to free post-exposure
prophylaxis. This Chapter also discusses the prevention of STI as a vital intervention to
reduce HIV transmission.
Chapter 6 notes that the Law requires a comprehensive program to monitor HIV
vulnerability and patterns of sexual behaviour. NCHADS will continue to conduct HSS
and BSS, but all data collection must respect confidentiality. The NAA has established a
Monitoring and Evaluation Working Group to assess needs and plan activities.
Chapter 7 provides a working definition of confidentiality: "not to disclose information
about a person's HIV status or any behaviour they may have engaged in that makes
them vulnerable to HIV infection and not to disclose the fact that they have been tested or
considered being tested, without that person's consent". Penalties can be imposed for
breaches of this Section of the Law. The only exceptions are where it is necessary to
give the information to health care workers involved in providing treatment to the person
who has HIV/AIDS, or where a court orders the information to be disclosed.
Chapter 8 covers discrimination and notes that imprisonment and large fines can be
imposed for persons found to be discriminating against anyone on the basis of HIV
status, which is defined by the Law as either known or suspected to have HIV/AIDS.
Discrimination in employment, in educational institutions, in health care services,
restrictions on freedom of movement and the right to seek public office, access to credit
and insurance are all given separate mention.
Chapter 9 lists the various Articles of the Law together with the Penalties that apply for
breaches of the Articles.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
63
The division of labour is changing, with an increased tendency for women to engage
in a broader range of tasks
Women still have heavier work burdens than men
Men still make most of the household decisions. The CDHS 2000100 results indicated
that 52% of women believed important decisions should be made by men, 59% that it
was better to educate a son than a daughter, and 33% that married women should
not be allowed to work outside the home
Gender relations between men and women are shifting, with men's underemployment and loss of economic power leading to frustration and contributing to
domestic violence. However the increased economic autonomy of women allows
some of them to leave violent or abusive situations and avoid exploitation and high
risk employment such as commercial sex work
The Human Poverty index for women is greater than for men
Woman headed households are among the poorest in the community. Women head
26% of Cambodian households100.
Note that the incidence study described in Section 5.2 suggests that the rate of infection is not declining.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
64
The Policy on Women, the Girl Child and STI/HIV/AIDS (Ministry of Women's and Veteran's
Affairs, 2003120) recognizes that girls and women are more vulnerable to HIV infection. Women
are noted to be disproportionately represented among the 36% of Cambodians who live below
the poverty line. Female unemployment, low wages and high illiteracy forces dependence on
male partners for financial support.
The National Poverty Reduction Strategy113 recognises that gender, poverty and HIV/AIDS are
"inextricably intertwined". The key gender issues identified in this Strategy are:
The significantly higher workload for women than men (women provide 65% of
agricultural labour and 75% of fisheries production)
Limited employment opportunities for women and limited sources of market
orientated skills training with women earning 30-40% less than men88
Limited educational opportunities for women
Higher risk of ill health
Increased numbers of women with HIV infection and increased burden of care
Trafficking and the sex trade targets vulnerable women and children
Issues of domestic violence: the 1998 Population Census found that 15% of married
women had experienced domestic violence in last 12 months
Exclusion of women from participation in many consultations during community and
government discussions.
However, while acknowledging that tradition plays a significant role in perpetuating gender
disparity in many societies, the NPRS document states the "this is not so much the case for
Cambodia" (p36). This statement is inconsistent with the view in most other reports on gender
issues "that Cambodia has strong traditions with gender discrimination deeply embedded in and
reinforced by social attitudes"137.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
65
The following elements provide the basis for the Strategic Plan:
sector wide management
provision of basic health services with full involvement of the community
provide affordable, essential specialised hospital services
decentralise and de-concentrate finance, planning and administrative functions
priority emphasis on prevention and control of communicable and selected chronic
and non-communicable diseases, on injury, the elderly, adolescents and vulnerable
groups such as the poor, and on managing public health crises
priority emphasis on provision of good quality care to mothers and children,
especially obstetric and paediatric care
active promotion of healthy lifestyles and health-seeking behaviour
emphasis on quality, effective and efficient provision of health services by health
providers
optimisation of human resources
increase promotion of effective public and private partnerships
effective use of health information for evidence-based planning, implementation,
monitoring and evaluation
implement health financing systems to promote equitable access to priority services
especially by the poor
further development of appropriate health legislation
The priority demographic and health concerns are:
rise in infant and child mortality, diarrhoeal diseases, acute respiratory infections,
vaccine-preventable diseases, dengue and malaria.
high rates of under-nutrition among women and malnutrition among children
high maternal mortality ratio and deaths from obstetric trauma and septic abortions
high case fatality rate from HIV/AIDS, TB and malaria
high total fertility rate
population growth
harmful practices among consumers and providers.
The Priority Areas of Work are:
Health service delivery
Behavioural change
Quality improvement
Human resource development
Health financing
Institutional development
This Strategic Plan contains the following HIV/AIDS specific actions:
reduce transmission in high risk groups through targeted STI treatment and
increased condom use
increase awareness of HIV and promote HIV counseling and testing to high risk
groups and the general population
strengthen the health system to respond to the increased demand for prevention and
care services.
In October 2004, the Ministry of Health released an Action Plan 2004-2007 to implement this
Strategic Plan141. The combined cost per capita of government funds, user fees and external aid
was calculated to be $US 6.92 in 2004, and projected to reach $US 7.45 by 2007. The Action
Plan has surprisingly few specific references to HIV, perhaps because these are detailed in the
NCHADS Strategic Plan.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
66
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
67
In 2000, less than half (42.2%) of the total demand for family planning in Cambodia was satisfied
{the met need was 23.8%, the unmet need 32.6%, making a total demand of 56.4%), and with
43.6% being those who did not need contraception146. However this is a major improvement from
an unmet need of 84% in 1995. The Contraception Prevalence Rate in 2000 for modern methods
of contraception was 19% (32% in urban areas) with injectable contraception accounting for
31.2% of the modern methods, the oral contraceptive pill for 30.4%, female sterilization 6.4% and
Intrauterine Device (IUD) 5.0%, while condom use as a method of contraception was low at
4.3%100, 145. The use of modern methods of contraception has been rising from 7% in 1995, to
16% in 1998 and 19% in 2000, but accurate comparisons are difficult due to different survey
methods147.
There are several important enabling factors for effective family planning in Cambodia147:
high levels of awareness, approval and demand for services, with no religious or
cultural constraints
demonstrated political will
close cooperation between government and NGOs
Ministry of Health willingness to experiment with community based interventions for
service delivery
a functioning national logistics system for the flow of commodities.
The public sector currently provides 53% of all contraceptive supplies and services144 while the
Reproductive Health Association of Cambodia (RHAC), created in 1994, is the largest
reproductive health provider in Cambodia outside the government. In 2002, Population Services
International facilitated the formation of a Sun Quality Health Network of private sector clinics to
deliver family planning, STI and VCT services. By October 2004 there were 95 service delivery
points in four provinces, but only a minority were reporting to be providing VCT145.
Abortions have been legal in Cambodia since the Law on Abortions was ratified in 1997.
However, until 2003 no Operational Guidelines were available to put the Law into effect. While
there is no accurate data on the number of abortions in Cambodia, mortality from abortions is
believed to contribute to about 130 of the 437 maternal deaths/ 100,000 live births. The Law and
Guidelines recognise that there is a significant need and demand for safe abortion services in
Cambodia. However, there is little or no formal training for the WHO recommended abortion
techniques by qualified health providers. Many services are performed in the private sector by
unqualified persons, including traditional birth attendants and there are varied costs for the
service which further limits access for poorer women148.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
68
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
69
with a range from 200 to 2000 reil. Over 40% of vendors stated that condoms were never
purchased by female clients, or rarely purchased by female clients (19%).
The 100% Condom Use Program (100% CUP) began in Cambodia in 1998 and was modeled on
a similar successful program in Thailand. The 100% CUP was reviewed in 2003 with the
following findings152:
Sex work in Cambodia is characterized by mobility in terms of geographical location
and movement between direct sex work and indirect sex work
In urban locations, sex work is better organized, with higher incomes and better
health
Striking differences were observed between ethnic Khmer and Vietnamese sex
workers, with the latter more prosperous, well organized, more articulate and
entrepreneurial, and having closer contact with their families with the future
anticipation of settling down and marrying with the full knowledge of their families.
This is in marked contrast to the shame Khmer sex workers feel in relation to their
families.
Indirect sex workers were more likely to deny involvement in sex work, had fewer
clients, but received a higher income per client than direct sex workers
Violence and abuse were reported, but noted to have been present before the launch
of the 100% CUP. There was an impression that violence and abuse was less in
urban areas perhaps due to increased organization of sex workers in these locations
Mandatory STI screening and treatment of brothel based sex workers is part of the
100% CUP.
Blood safety
All official blood donations in Cambodia are screened for HIV. The prevalence of infection in
blood donors has declined significantly from 4.2% in 1998 to 1.8% in 2002. More recently there
has been an increased effort to recruit voluntary, non-remunerated donors who generally come
from lower risk groups, such as Buddhist monks. At present about 25% of current blood donors
are voluntary and 95% of these are first time donors88, 135.
Prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission (PMTCT)
NCHADS and the National Maternal and Child Health Centre (NMCHC) produced a National
Policy on Preventing Mother-to-Child Transmission of HIV in 2001153. In relation to the link
between PMTCT and HIV testing, the policy states that:
"All women and men, irrespective of their HIV status, have the right to determine the
course of their reproductive life and health and to have access to information and
services that allow them to protect their own, and their families, health. Integrated RH
[reproductive health] and STI services and family counseling will be promoted. In
addition, VCT will be conducted as a long term strategy to protect HIV infected women
from stigma and discrimination".
The Policy also states that the PMTCT strategy will be integrated into existing mother and child
health, reproductive health, Integrated Management of Childhood Illness and STI programs within
the Ministry of Health, other related Ministries, International Organizations, bilateral agencies,
NGOs and the private sector. In relation to VCT, the Policy states that: HIV counseling must be
conducted and managed by properly skilled, trained and qualified staff; that VCT for HIV will be
incorporated into antenatal care services or provided in free standing sites, to allow women to
make choices based on their individual situation; that mandatory HIV testing of women or children
is prohibited; and that strict confidentiality of HIV test results must be maintained.
The PMTCT approach in Cambodia closely follows international recommendations for resourceconstrained settings. The main constraints are lack of access to, and utilization of, antenatal care
and trained providers at birth and the relatively low prevalence of HIV infection in pregnant
women, which means that many women will need to agree to be tested to identify the 2.5% who
are HIV infected154.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
70
The key components of the PMTCT program in Cambodia are135, 154, 155:
primary prevention of infection
prevention of unwanted pregnancies for all women, and especially for HIV infected
women
improved health services during antenatal, intra-partum and post-partum periods
destigmatisation of condom use and promotion of the dual protection role of condoms
improved safe birthing practices
improved diagnosis and treatment of malaria and other diseases
behaviour change to promote exclusive breast feeding
care and support for HIV infected mothers and infants
HIV counseling and testing
nevirapine prophylaxis for mother and infant where the mother is given a single dose
of nevirapine at the onset of labour (and at least two hours before delivery) while the
newborn infant is given a single oral dose of nevirapine syrup within 72 hours of birth.
In Cambodia, the "opt-out" approach is being implemented in a few PMTCT sites but the NMCHC
prefers the "opt-in" approach, because of the possible negative consequences if a housewife tells
her husband about STI or HIV infection.
Infant feeding counseling is considered a major challenge in Cambodia88. Current approaches in
Cambodia endorse international recommendations to give women, and their partners, sufficient
information in order to make an informed choice from a number of possible options. However, in
practice, the current recommendation in Cambodia for most HIV positive women is for exclusive
breast-feeding for the first six months, followed by abrupt weaning135. If the mother chooses
formula feeding, it must meet the five criteria of being acceptable, feasible, affordable,
sustainable and safe.
Current access to and uptake of VCT for PMTCT is low, as few women attend antenatal services
and even fewer deliver in public health facilities. Coverage in 2004 included Phnom Penh and 13
Health Centres in 11 Operational Districts, compared to only two sites in 2003. To date these
PMTCT centres have covered 26.6% or 132,767 of the estimated annual 500,000 pregnant
women. Of the women covered by these services, 11.7% attended pre-test counseling with
11.4% being tested. A cumulative total of 303 mothers and infants have taken nevirapine from
2002 to 2004. As a result of this low coverage and uptake of services, the cost-effectiveness of
the current PMTCT program is still under consideration88, 135.
Harm reduction
There is very limited data available on coverage of harm reduction services, which is still very
low. In 2003, the NGO Mith Samlanh/Friends saw 2,573 clients for drug-related problems. Only
recently has approval been given to pilot a needle and syringe program and drug substitution
therapy has only just started in Cambodia, but on a small pilot scale.
Unmet prevention needs
In preparation for the new 2006 - 2010 National Strategic Plan for HIV/AIDS, the Technical
Working Group on Prevention identified unmet prevention needs in their draft report135:
limited participation of commune level officials in prevention activities
limited prevention initiatives arising from communities
misconceptions about transmission persist, with low personal risk perception
lack of programs specifically targeting married women
limited participation of PLHA
low levels of consistent and correct condom use for casual sex partners and
sweethearts
lack of HIV prevalence data and behavioural data for young people
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
71
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
72
Antiretroviral Therapy
Cambodia has made a strong commitment to support the WHO "3 by 5" initiative and the Global
Fund has provided resources from Round 2 and Round 4 to procure sufficient medications to
meet national need and capacity. NCHADS has produced National Guidelines for the use of ART
for adults, adolescents and children. These Guidelines advise that the first step is to confirm the
diagnosis of HIV infection through HIV antibody testing.
Counseling and testing services are therefore a very important entry point for treatment, care and
support where "the quality of the first encounter often influences future health and treatment
seeking behaviours"163. Experience in several other countries has demonstrated that the
availability of ART can have a great impact on the uptake of VCT services, which further supports
the urgent need for expansion of VCT services in Cambodia.
However, there are important issues that need to be addressed. In Phnom Penh, ART is officially
available at four national hospitals, but there are several procurement mechanisms operating
concurrently under different donors. In addition, ART can be bought in Phnom Penh and other
urban centres with or without a prescription from a number of pharmacies and wholesalers, many
of whom are neither trained nor registered. The cost can be as low as $30-50 per month88.
The challenges faced by the government are to increase commitment and ensure that low cost
drugs are available and administered appropriately. Cambodia's negotiations for the World Trade
Organisation could facilitate or constrain this. There is a need to inform the population and
encourage public debate to ensure that those who require treatment receive it, regardless of
poverty, gender and stigma88.
The number of people with advanced HIV infection receiving ART is increasing. In September
2003, it was estimated that 1,506 patients of an estimated need of between 22,000 to 32,000
were receiving ART from 11 sites. By October 2004, 4,300 patients were on ART88 and latest
figures from NCHADS state that at the end of 2005 about 10,000 PLHA were receiving ART
(personal communication).
HIV and Tuberculosis collaboration
The National Health Policies and Strategies for Tuberculosis (TB) control in the Kingdom of
Cambodia released in 2001 recognized the link between HIV/AIDS and TB, but gave little detail
or direction164. A review in 2001 exploring the links between HIV and TB noted major barriers to
collaboration and linking HIV and TB interventions165. At the time of this report there were only
six approved HIV counseling and testing centres in Cambodia, all in urban areas, and all using
non-rapid tests with delays in obtaining results. Other important barriers were limited coordination
between TB DOTS and HIV/AIDS Home Based Care teams, and the fact that private sector
providers and traditional healers were the first point of contact for 70% of the population
presenting a major barrier to case-detection. However, since 2001, there has been increased
attention and priority given to HIV/AIDS and TB collaboration.
Like HIV/AIDS, stigma and incorrect beliefs about TB contribute to delays in seeking treatment.
Tuberculosis prevalence of all forms in Cambodia in 2003 was estimated to be 540/ 100,000
while for new smear positive pulmonary TB the rate was estimated to be 241/ 100,000, with a
mortality of 90/ 100,000. The HIV seroprevalence among all TB patients increased from 2.5% in
1995 to 11.8% in 2003166. The 2002 HSS estimated that the HIV prevalence in newly diagnosed
TB patients was 8.4%167. The TB burden among VCT clients who test HIV+ and who are referred
for TB screening ranged from 13% to 32% in four pilot sites. Of TB patients sent for HIV testing,
between13% to 77% were found to be HIV+. Overall nearly 38% of TB patients were co-infected
with TB and HIV135.
In a cross sectional study of 441 HIV+ persons in a home care setting in Phnom Penh, 9% were
found to have active pulmonary TB on culture of which 71% were smear positive. Only one
person was on TB treatment and the total burden of pulmonary TB in this population was 12%168.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
73
Active case-finding identified three times as many cases as those already detected. HIV+
persons in this setting were 16 times more likely to have TB than the general population, with
high mortality as 49% of the TB cases identified subsequently died. The study evaluated the
utility of asking about a cough of three weeks duration for TB diagnosis and found this to be
poorly predictive. A single sputum screening test was recommended as having better diagnostic
utility for HIV+ persons with symptoms.
In August 2004, a workshop was held addressing the scale-up of TB/HIV collaborative activities in
Cambodia169. Several topics addressed the two-way referral between HIV counseling and testing
(and home based care) services and TB screening services.
The workshop findings for referral from VCT/Home Based Care to TB services noted that:
the quality of counseling skills was limited with a lack of understanding of the
impact of TB/HIV co-morbidity by counselors
there were no staff or others able to accompany the HIV+ client for TB screening
there was insufficient budget for transport support
waiting times for TB screening were long.
For referral from TB clinics to VCT centres, the findings were:
a lack of transport support
the VCT centre was usually far from the TB ward
information about VCT was limited
TB patients may not believe they are at risk of HIV infection
instances of staff discrimination against PLHA.
Recommendations were made for scale-up and to address these findings.
For referral from VCT/Home Based Care to TB services:
all HIV+ clients should be referred for TB screening with a referral slip
transport support should be provided
clients should be accompanied by a peer or volunteer
clear information on the location of the TB screening location should be provided
records should be kept of referral and follow-up
counseling should be provided on the importance of TB screening and treatment.
For referral from TB services to VCT:
all TB suspects should be referred for HIV counseling and testing
all TB patients registered and on treatment should be referred for HIV counseling
and testing
referrals should be recorded and tracked.
STI management
In the absence of laboratory services to diagnose STI in many health facilities, syndromic
management of STI is the core strategy of the national response. NCHADS produced Guidelines
for implementation of Sexual Transmitted Infection services in August 2001170. STI services are
seen as a priority for population groups with the highest prevalence of STI and the highest risk of
HIV infections. The Guidelines seek an appropriate balance of three complementary STI
prevention and care strategies:
integration of components of STI care as part of the Minimum Package of Activities
(MPA) at the primary health care level, combined with IEC distribution and partner
notification
specific approaches for the "early detection and treatment of persons at high risk of
acquiring or spreading STI through routine or periodic voluntary testing and screening
of high risk asymptomatic persons" (in reality this refers to female sex workers)
patient care with laboratory support at the referral hospital level through the
Complementary Package of Activities (CPA).
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
74
Barriers to effective STI management are the client's preference for private providers, including
traditional healers, or the use of self-medication. In addition there is very limited partner
notification and counseling available88.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
75
counseling for youth tends to be more based on giving advice, identifying problems
and suggesting solutions
there are broad interpretations of confidentiality among service providers that needs
to be discussed so that a more consistent approach is followed
use of mass media (radio) appears to be a powerful way to speak directly to youth
about SRH education
more information is needed about migration and the related vulnerability to SRH
problems.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
76
The review concluded by presenting three models for adolescent-friendly reproductive health
services based on resource requirements: interventions using existing resources; interventions
requiring minimal additional resources; and interventions requiring significant additional
resources.
A complementary study by Fordham175 is one of 13 country studies on adolescent reproductive
health (ARH) in Asia and the Near East, including Cambodia and Viet Nam, funded by USAID.
This study again highlights that adolescent health is a clear priority, but with no national policy on
the subject. The study notes that:
twice as many girls as boys have no education
births to adolescent girls will double to 226,000 from 2000 to 2020
unmet contraceptive need is high for girls aged 15-19 years (37.1%) and 20-24 years
(36.1%)
there is low knowledge of reproductive health issues, including birth spacing
marriage and domestic labour are viewed as the primary goals for girls
there are double standards where adolescent girls are expected to uphold the virtues
and honour of the family by maintaining their virginity and a good reputation, but no
such strictures are placed on boys
there is substantial social pressure for young girls to marry, and the choice of partner
is still considered the right of the parents, especially for their daughters.
Adolescent and reproductive health issues that need to be addressed at the national level are:
early high-risk pregnancies (8.2% of females aged 15-19 years are mothers or
pregnant with their first child)
sex and violence, including rape, and the impact on the reputation and future of
"fallen" women
STI/HIV/AIDS with low condom use among sweethearts and links with alcohol and
violence
migrant adolescent workers from rural locations
increasing drug use
trafficking of women and children.
Fordham notes that there are no legal barriers to implement ARH activities, but there are
substantial infrastructural barriers and an apparent denial of the need for policies and programs to
target sexually active youth. He stresses the importance of school based ARH programs as well
as programs managed by communities with NGO and other support. The main recommendations
are the need to develop a national ARH policy and to conduct good qualitative research on the
sexual behaviours of specific population groups, including male sexuality and masculinity.
In response to the studies by Wilkinson, Fordham and others, draft National Guidelines for
Adolescent/ Youth Friendly Reproductive and Sexual Health Services, dated August 2005, were
being circulated for feedback at the time of writing, but not available for inclusion in this review.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
77
Section 5.10.1 presents details of the brothel-based 100% Condom Use Program. Lowe176, in
2002, documented the experience of sex workers involved in this Program in four sites, including
Koh Kong Province. The report found that:
The 100% CUP was not enough in itself, as sex workers continued to need to
negotiate condom use with some clients
Direct Sex Workers (DSW) are required to be registered and attend STI clinics but
this has not involved informed consent, is not confidential and there were reports that
sick and under-age sex workers were hidden from the registration process
STI clinic staff were perceived to be judgmental and vaginal examinations were rough
and painful
There was very limited sex worker involvement in the 100%CUP - compliance was
passive only
NGOs were mostly excluded from work with DSW.
In relation to HIV counseling and testing, the study found that sex workers receiving STI
management and who requested HIV tests were referred to other sites. Of those who were
tested, almost all received pre-and post-test counseling and the testing was stated to be
voluntary.
Another report relevant to this review was qualitative study conducted among 46 sex workers in
Koh Kong Province, where Marie Stopes Cambodia has a Clinic with plans to integrate HIV
counseling and testing177. This study found that most of the sex workers had only lived in the
area a short time, usually less than one year, and almost all were from Provinces elsewhere in
Cambodia or from Viet Nam. Most were working in Koh Kong voluntarily, but in the context of
family poverty and/or conflict. Many spoke of a future when they would cease sex work. The
women had sex with "boyfriends", sometimes for money, but also when there was an emotional
attachment. Sex with "guests", mostly Khmer men, was for money. Violence from clients was
reported, but the actual frequency difficult to determine. Some sex workers felt confident to
speak of 100% condom use with clients while others said it was ultimately the man's choice.
There were reported fears of STD, HIV/AIDS and unplanned pregnancies.
The presence of Vietnamese female sex workers in Cambodia is a controversial regional issue.
A three month study was conducted between July and November 2002178 with the findings that
Vietnamese sex workers in Cambodia were extremely vulnerable to HIV/AIDS. They experienced
ethnic discrimination from Cambodians, and violence, physical and sexual abuse from clients,
brothel owners and law enforcement officers. They had a high frequency of sexual contacts but
low rates of condom use. The political and economic situation encouraged them to migrate to
Cambodia for sex work. Some came voluntarily but others were trafficked into prostitution
against their will. Poverty, high mobility, discrimination, sexual abuse and human trafficking make
them a particularly important group to target with interventions, in both Cambodia and Viet Nam.
Many groups working with sex workers have developed useful prevention methods and tools. In
a project funded by the Asia Development Bank and UNDP, World Vision Cambodia in 2001 fieldtested a toolkit of prevention responses in Sihanoukville, a recognized HIV hot-spot179. The
components of the toolkit included: an outreach program to specific groups of sex workers and
their clients; IEC materials development and distribution; focus group discussions; public
campaigns; peer education; promoting available health services; social marketing of condoms
and social networking. This study was part of a regional project that included similar toolkits for
mobile fishermen and their families in Myanmar and Viet Nam. A brief summary of these toolkits
is presented in the country-specific sections that follow.
The studies noted above are focused mostly on direct or brothel-based sex workers (DSW). Two
studies on entertainment workers are presented here, as this group includes many women
classified as indirect sex workers (IDSW). One study interviewed 41 indirect sex workers in nightclubs, karaoke establishments and massage parlours in Phnom Penh in 2001180. This study was
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
78
limited by the Prime Minister's order to close all night-clubs, discotheques and karaoke bars on
November 20, 2001 because of reports of violence and drug trafficking. The data collection for
this survey was scheduled to commence a few days after this announcement and therefore it was
much more difficult to identify and obtain consent from these women. Key findings were:
Most women were aged between 16-25 years and had come from many different
provinces in Cambodia
Poverty, unemployment and low income attracted them to sex work
There were very different working conditions related to the expectation of providing
sexual services, depending on the type and location of employment
Some women lived on the premises and were in debt to the owner or procurer
(usually an older woman) and could not refuse sex or freely visit health practitioners
Discrimination encouraged these women to keep their illnesses secret. There was a
lack of regular health screening and a preference for drug-sellers and private sector
services which were seen as more confidential, with staff more courteous, treatment
more effective, faster and with sterilized equipment
Awareness and knowledge of HIV and STI was limited and all expressed a need for
HIV and STI education and services at a quiet location not far from their workplace,
with a preference for female service providers.
A more extensive KHANA study in 2001181 interviewed 1,594 people in five locations (including
Phnom Penh): 75% were female entertainment workers, 10% customers and 7% establishment
owners or managers. There were additional interviews with 112 NGO, UN and government staff.
The key findings were:
Young females constitute the majority of workers in the informal entertainment sector
Varied working conditions can increase vulnerability to HIV infection
There are many interconnected factors contributing to HIV vulnerability, especially
poverty, gender inequality and migration
Most workers live in shared private accommodation with co-workers
There is evidence of movement from direct sex work into entertainment work
Entertainment workers do not perceive themselves as sex workers and do not
perceive the sex they have with men during their work as high-risk behaviour. They
appear to be able to choose the men they have sex with and therefore reported
condom use is low.
Most customers view entertainment workers as sexually available and as "safe" and
"clean", again contributing to low condom use
Negotiating condom use is further complicated by the desire to avoid conflict,
violence and abuse
Alcohol consumption and/or drug use by workers or clients also reduces the ability to
negotiate condom use
Levels of harassment, violence and intimidation in the workplace are high
There are different types of relationships between workers and owners and
managers ranging from highly exploitative and controlling to more supportive
relationships
Relations between some groups of workers are competitive, especially for karaoke
workers and beer promoters, who compete for the attention of customers.
Personal health is perceived as a low priority and access is usually through
pharmacists and private clinics
There appears to be low levels of HIV discrimination in the workplaces studied.
The study recommended that:
Prevention messages should not imply that entertainment workers are involved in
commercial sex work as this is not how they perceive themselves
Promotion of condom use more widely in all relationships would allow increased
condom use for entertainment workers
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
79
Owner and management support could make the workplace a more supportive
environment to reduce HIV vulnerability.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
80
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
81
Casino workers may also be an important mobile population. One study188 of casinos in Poipet
and Koh Kong, bordering Thailand, found that:
the vast majority of casino workers were young people, mostly single
almost all were functionally literate
most had moved to the casino location from other areas of Cambodia
casino work was considered desirable as it provided good income and benefits and
accompanying social status
workers usually lived and mixed with other casino employees, sometimes in casinoprovided accommodation
casino workers had some knowledge of HIV/AIDS/STI but required more
comprehensive information
all participants knew that condom use can prevent HIV infection.
Two qualitative studies of mobile populations in Koh Kong have been published by Greenwood.
One examined fishermen and noted that many had moved to Koh Kong in the early 1980s from a
variety of provinces. Income was highly seasonal and many had difficulties providing for their
families' basic needs. Social drinking, karaoke and visits to the brothels were popular
entertainment options. Condom use appeared to be low overall and condoms were not used with
sweethearts and within marriage189.
The second study, entitled "I'm not afraid of AIDS, I'm afraid of no sex", was among 60 motor taxi
drivers in Koh Kong190. All of the study participants had relocated to Koh Kong from other
provinces in the hope of finding improved fortunes, but with the collapse of the high-income
logging industry in early 1999, most now had reduced incomes, with little money for nonessentials, but did spend money on alcohol and women. Brothel based sex workers were
considered cheaper and more accessible than the more desirable karaoke workers. The study
found variable reports on condom use with direct sex workers but condom use with sweethearts
and within marriage was very low. The men had high levels of concern about STI/HIV/AIDS but
low levels of accurate knowledge.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
82
The most recent study, published in January 2004194, added to this available information in
finding that MSM had low levels of knowledge of the risks of HIV infection through sex with other
men; that many, especially long-hair MSM, found it difficult to access HIV and sexual health
services and were subject to discriminatory treatment; and significantly, that MSM are a "bridge"
group for HIV transmission to the general population. Recommendations included conducting
further research; reviewing national polices and programs to address MSM; promoting the active
involvement of MSM in these activities; developing and delivering MSM sensitivity training for
police, service providers and staff of organizations targeting MSM; adopting new approaches for
Information, Education and Communication (IEC) materials for MSM; providing free condoms and
lubricant to MSM, especially long-hair MSM; and developing and delivering sexual health services
that are sensitive to the needs of MSM.
As in many other countries, HIV programs for MSM in Cambodia are hindered by the following
factors133:
denial that sex between men takes place
stigmatization of MSM
lack of epidemiological data
invisibility of MSM in the National response framework and programmatic response
harassment of MSM, particularly feminine or "long-hair" MSM, by police
rejection by families, communities, employers and others
shortage of HIV/AIDS and sexual health services that are sensitive to and nonjudgmental of the sexual health needs of MSM
inadequate information materials to address HIV/AIDS risks for MSM
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
83
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
84
One major purpose of the review was to develop options for greater NGO/ government interaction
in VCT, and the report notes the great interest within the NGO sector for conducting trials of
different models of service delivery and concluded that "NCHADS is not averse to greater
involvement of NGOs in VCT provision".
In 2005, rapid tests are used in nearly all HIV testing centres. In general, NCHADS approves any
rapid test that meets WHO standards. The most popular tests used in public and NGO centres
are Abbot Determin, with Uni-Gold as the confirmatory test135. Serodia is another approved
and commonly used rapid-test.
Since 2004, in accordance with the Law on HIV/AIDS, all VCT centers, public, NGO or private,
are required to be registered with the Ministry of Health through NCHADS. While the registration
has yet to be strictly enforced, 58 of 86 operating VCT centers (67%) were registered by early
2005135. The main requirements for registration are:
Staff trained in counseling and testing through courses approved by or run by
NCHADS
Facilities meeting standards that are assessed by NCHADS staff conducting a sitevisit using a standardized checklist.
Key informants expressed different opinions as to whether HIV counseling and testing in
Cambodia was primarily a health-sector response or a multi-sectoral response, or both. While
VCT services are mostly within health facilities, community awareness raising and referral to
other HIV/AIDS services takes place in a multi-sectoral context. One Key Informant noted that
health staff working in other government Ministries understood the importance of HIV counseling
and testing but, as they were not under Ministry of Health (NCHADS) management, coordination
of a multi-sectoral was not as good as it could be.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
85
The BSS 2003 data allows an assessment of utilization of VCT services by the different sentinel
groups (Section 5.2.3)94. VCT services were used by over 50% of karaoke workers and direct
sex workers for their last HIV test (32.5% for beer girls). There was lower use of VCT services by
male sentinel groups, with the last test at a VCT centre for 30.7% of the military, 10.7% of police
and 12.2% of motor-taxi drivers. The BSS Household Male Survey in 200096 found that only 12%
of men had ever been tested for HIV (7.7% rural and 25.2% urban). The CDHS 2000100 found
that only 3% of women aged 15-49 had been tested (8% in urban areas). The PSI population
survey (2003)98 noted only 5% of the men and women sampled had ever been tested (29% in
Phnom Penh) but there was a strong demand for testing. The BBC survey of 18-35 year old men
and women in 2003 found that 13% had been tested, with 43% wanting a test99.
The Key Informants made several comments related to coverage of VCT services. Available data
shows increasing numbers of women being tested, including "housewives" and factory workers.
There are also increasing numbers of children receiving testing. Several Key Informants noted
an increasing trend towards couple counseling prior to marriage, which has been promoted on
national TV, but stressed that such testing must remain voluntary. Concerns were expressed
about family conflict in the case of a woman requesting a test, which highlighted a role for couple
counseling among those already married.
The Key Informants generally agreed that a variety of HIV counseling and testing models was
both appropriate and needed in Cambodia. These included stand alone centres, VCT integrated
with public health facilities, VCT integrated with reproductive health and STI facilities, "one stop
shops" such as the Clinics managed by RHAC, the Mondul Mith Chuoy Mith centres, and mobile
clinics (although there were concerns about the cost-effectiveness of mobile clinics). A variety
models would contribute to the process of normalizing HIV testing as part of routine health care.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
86
Section 4 also gives procedures for ensuring confidentiality, guidance on pre-and post-test
counseling and supportive counseling and describes the approved testing protocol. The
document notes that NCHADS/ MoH has the responsibility to ensure quality control for all HIV
testing services in both private and public sectors, and that simple/rapid tests are recognized by
the Ministry of Health in Cambodia as acceptable, based on WHO recommendations.
Voluntary Confidential Counseling and Testing for HIV (VCCT): a guide for implementation,
(NCHADS, January 2004)200
This booklet provides updated and additional information for personnel working in VCT services
in Cambodia in the context of increased capacity for treatment and support for PLHA. The
document places VCT in the Continuum of Care with the process starting by raising community
awareness about the availability of VCT services. A separate paragraph addresses VCT for sex
workers, stressing the need for health providers to have a non-judgmental approach, avoid blame
and stigmatization, to screen for other STIs and support access to Family Planning Services.
Pre-marital counseling and testing is now an increasingly common practice, but both partners
should undergo testing voluntarily. This may be done as a couple or as separate individuals. HIV
testing in children is discussed, with the recommendation not to test for HIV antibodies until the
child is 18 months of age. VCT is acknowledged as an essential element of PMTCT. Referral for
TB screening is recommended as TB preventive therapy can reduce the incidence of active TB
among HIV+ people by 50%. Barriers to VCT are noted: stigma and discrimination; fear that the
test result will be disclosed or lack of confidentiality and privacy; and lack of perceived benefit
from testing. Quality assurance and supervision are mentioned, but not in detail, and lessons
learned from other countries are briefly presented, including the finding that "HIV counseling and
testing should be integrated into other services, including STI, antenatal and family planning
clinics and TB services".
Continuum of Care for People Living with HIV/AIDS: Operational Framework, NCHADS, 1st
Ed. April 2003156
This Framework provides further guidance for VCT services in the context of the Continuum of
Care. The framework notes several actions that need to be taken for HIV counseling and testing,
including: an assessment of current HIV testing usage patterns; recommendations of the
advantages and disadvantages of different VCT models; development of monitoring and
evaluation tools; revision of supervision tools; a national counseling network; and training and
employment of PLHA as counselors in VCT centres. The document encourages a diversity of
VCT services within the province or Operational District as "likely to increase the access to and
the utilization of VCT" with options including stand alone VCT sites located outside or inside the
referral hospital compound, VCT integrated services in Mondul Mith Chuoy Mith (Friend helping
Friends Centres), in clinical care settings, STI clinics, antenatal clinic and TB services.
5.12.6 Achievements
Cambodia has made significant progress in provision of HIV counseling and testing services, both
in terms of geographical coverage and in compliance with the Law on HIV/AIDS. The situation in
2001 described in Section 5.7, before the Law was passed and implemented, has improved
significantly. In 2001 there was "little awareness, much less compliance, with national policies for
HIV testing in public facilitiesMedical staff routinely test patients without informing them or
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
87
obtaining consent, results are sometimes withheld from the patient despite their request to be
told, test results are given to relatives and other medical staff without patient authorization, pre
and post-test counseling are often skipped and of poor quality"136. The Law and more recently
approved Implementing Guidelines have contributed to a much improved situation with respect to
human rights and the quality of the services, although important challenges remain (see Section
5.8 and below). Specific achievements include88:
improved training, supervision and procurement of equipment and reagents for public
VCT centres coordinated by NCHADS
improved capacity of the NCHADS VCT sub-unit
publication of a comprehensive set of National Policies and Guidelines
a Counseling Directory in English and Khmer developed by HACC.
5.12.7 Challenges
The Mid-Term Review of the NCHADS HIV/AIDS Strategy in 2003 included an appraisal of HIV
counseling and testing services198. At that time, the dominant model was a stand alone VCT
service. The review noted that there was widespread access to unregulated VCT services in
Phnom Penh and some major towns. There was low utilization of some public VCT services
related to poor quality of counseling, lack of confidentiality, staff attitude and financial barriers.
Although the test was meant to be free in public VCT centres, there were reports that some
clients were charged. The key challenges for HIV counseling and testing in Cambodia, collated
from a variety of recent sources88, 135, 198, and including comments from the Key Informants, are:
Access and Infrastructure
improving access and coverage: while coverage is improving, many of the potential
target population are not able to access VCT services
increasing awareness of the benefits of HIV testing and promoting the concept of
routine preventive health care, in the context of low self-perception of risk
stigma is decreasing but remains a barrier for some people.
Stigma and
discrimination in the workplace was highlighted by one Key Informant
low levels of antenatal care limits uptake of VCT for PMTCT
Stigma and Discrimination
improved ways to address potential for family conflict if a woman requests or has had
a HIV test
confidentiality is an important issue for all clients, but especially for women, youth
and high risk behaviour groups
Technical
there is no clear referral system to and from VCT centres, and counselors need more
training on the importance of referral to other services including home based care,
TB, PMTCT and ART services
inconsistent and poor quality of counseling services. One Key Informant stated that
"the success of VCT is more related to counseling than to testing"
existing supervision is limited to quantitative checklists and does not include quality of
counseling. There is no internal and external quality assessment for HIV tests for
most VCT centres
variations in HIV testing methods results in delays in providing results to clients
differences in incentives provided to VCT staff by various donors may create
problems
there are missed opportunities to link IEC/BCC to target populations
there are no mechanisms for follow-up or in-service training for counselors
there is a need for counseling support networks, especially to support counselors to
de-brief after seeing many clients
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
88
data collection needs strengthening. An Epi-Info based program has been used to
send data to NCHADS from VCT sites but the program has experienced some
problems. There is a need for a program with simple data entry, analysis and
reporting characteristics
private providers are doing HIV testing, with concerns about the lack of, or poor
quality, counseling, testing quality, no monitoring system and no license
issues of the credibility of results may need to be examined. One Key Informant
mentioned unconfirmed anecdotal stories that some persons were requesting a HIV
positive test, even though they had tested negative, as this would allow them to
collect a salary from their employer without having to do any work. Another story
related to persons testing HIV positive at pre-marriage testing and who requested
VCT staff to change to result to HIV negative.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
89
centered, and understand the feelings involved when being tested for HIV and in facing up to the
effects of living with HIV/AIDS. The training comes with 12 short video sessions demonstrating
six deficient counseling sessions and six good counseling scenarios. The training emphasizes
active listening, paying attention to feelings, and the provision of preventive and supportive
counseling.
At the end of the recommended five-day training, each participant should work under the
supervision of an experienced VCT counselor for at least 3-5 days to gain some real experience
before returning to their VCT service and working on their own. The Manual notes that counselors
should be given further opportunities to continue their learning through a variety of methods such
as refresher trainings, case conferences, and sharing of experience within a counseling network.
The active participation of PLHA in training as counselors is encouraged.
The Manual is divided into 18 Activities, with Lesson Plans and supporting transparencies and
graphs. The Activities present an overview of HIV/AIDS in Cambodia (using 2002 data which
now needs to be updated); the place of VCT in HIV prevention and care; knowledge about
HIV/AIDS; risk assessment; attitudes and values; principles and skills of counseling, leading to
specific pre-test and post-test counseling; referral; and concluding with an outline of the approved
VCT policy, guidelines and protocols for Cambodia.
Health Messenger Issue 24, September 2005 on HIV/AIDS Voluntary, Confidential,
Counselling and Testing and Prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission155
Health Messenger is a quarterly publication in Khmer and English that is widely distributed among
health professionals in Cambodia and has covered many health and HIV/AIDS subjects. The
September 2005 issue was devoted to HIV counseling and testing and PMTCT, was sponsored
by UNICEF, and published with the close cooperation of NCHADS and the NMCHC. The
contents include an overview of VCT, legal considerations, pre and post-test counseling, the
psychological perspective, overcoming barriers to HIV testing, HIV testing and quality control, the
current PMTCT situation in Cambodia, mechanisms of MTCT, PMTCT during pregnancy, PMTCT
during labour and delivery, Universal Precautions, HIV and infant feeding options and Care of the
HIV exposed infant. The issue ends with a useful dual language list of all currently licensed HIV
counseling and testing sites in Cambodia, by Province and indicating whether PMTCT services
are also provided at each site.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
90
2001
4,019
2002
6,890
2003
7,763
2004
12,895
2005
16,753
In 2005, 27.0% of all visits were for STI management, 18.1% for antenatal care, 10.4% for family
planning services, 6.4% for management of complications of abortion/safe abortion, 4% for
HIV/AIDS services and 3.5% for the tubal ligation service (with other services provided to 34.6%
of clients). The majority of clients are women (95%) with 50% employed as factory workers. In
addition, the community outreach program in 2005 trained 739 female sex workers, 1,460 factory
workers (1,106 women), 2,688 youth (1,651 young women) and 699 persons from groups such
as uniformed personnel, making a total of 5,586 who received training through community
outreach.
A detailed Site Assessment for each of the three MSC Clinics is planned as part of the
preparation phase to integrate HIV counseling and testing into the existing sexual and
reproductive health services being provided. Separate reports for these Site Assessments will be
prepared over the six months January to June 2006.
In addition to these Clinics, MSC has experience in implementing a number of Sexual and
Reproductive Health Projects with a variety of donors.
Current Projects:
The Mekong VCT project to integrate and scale-up VCT in Marie Stopes Clinics in
Cambodia, Myanmar and Vietnam with funding from the European Commission for three
years from July 2005.
A project to address the unmet need for comprehensive reproductive health information
and services among vulnerable groups and the general population in Phnom Penh,
Kandal and Koh Kong, funded by the European Commission for three years from June
2003.
Voluntary Surgical Contraception (VSC) to provide tubal ligation and vasectomy services
in MSC Clinics, with funding from Marie Stopes International, UK on an annual basis.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
91
Recent Projects
A project to improve access and utilization of quality, client-focused reproductive health
services for target groups in Chbar Ampov, Phnom Penh was implemented for 12 months
from May 2002 and funded by the British Embassy in Phnom Penh.
A project to improve the sexual and reproductive health (SRH) of urban poor populations
in Phnom Penh was implemented for 12 months from March 2003 with funding from the
States of Jersey.
A project to increase awareness among the urban poor population of Phnom Penh of the
sexual and reproductive health (SRH) information and services available at the MSC
Clinic in Chbar Ampov was implemented for 12 months from January 2003 with funding
from the Hewlett Foundation.
A project called "Implementation of the Positive Lives", a campaign in conjunction with
street theatre in Phnom Penh was implemented for 12 months from June 2003 with
funding from Levi Strauss Positive Lives.
A project to promote health seeking behaviour to reduce the rate of STI/HIV transmission
among high-risk target groups in Svay Pak, Phnom Penh was implemented for 12
months in 2002 with funding from the Canadian Initiative Fund, Canadian Cooperation
Office, Phnom Penh.
A project to promote health seeking behaviour by improving access for high risk
adolescent groups in the Svay Pak area to youth friendly RH information and education
was implemented over 18 months from April 2002 with funding from UNFPA.
A project to improve access to reproductive health information and services and to
prevent the transmission of Sexually Transmitted Infections (STIs), including HIV/AIDS,
amongst garment factory workers in Phnom Penh was implemented in 2002 with funding
from Oxfam GB.
National Reproductive Health Project (1997-2001). MSI Australia worked in partnership
with the Government to implement the National Reproductive Health Project. This
included training to public and private providers of SRH services and the delivery of these
services through the creation of a reproductive health infrastructure and appropriate
protocols. Funding was from UNFPA, WHO and DFID/UK.
The active promotion of couple's counseling should be a key strategy in providing a VCT
service. This should be integrated with an overall approach to encourage greater
involvement of men in sexual and reproductive health, in particular, the male partners of
female clients who receive STI, antenatal care and family planning services at MSC
Clinics. This should be done both through the Clinic-based services and community
outreach activities. Couple's counseling will include pre-marriage counseling and testing
as well as services for those already married.
MSC, as a provider of quality sexual and reproductive health services for women, should
develop culturally appropriate ways to encourage disclosure of results to the male
partners of woman clients and to support women who fear or experience gender-based
violence in the context of wanting or having a HIV test.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
92
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
93
52,170,000
31%
2.02%
2.3
30%
360
76
106
61
129
50
90%
86%
80%
not available
$US 220
$US 30
1.2% [0.6-2.2]
330,000
27.5%
34.4%
1.8%
955
6.8%
34%
57%
76%
32%
(1) UNICEF, unless indicated, data is for 2004. (2) Human Development Indicators, 2005. (3) HIV/AIDS
data from most recent national sources. (4) Statistical Year Book 2003, Central Statistical Organisation,
Yangon, Myanmar.
In contrast to Cambodia and Viet Nam, there was less available published literature on HIV/AIDS
in Myanmar for this review. The most important references were the UN Expanded Theme Group
on HIV/AIDS, Joint Programme for HIV/AIDS: Myanmar 2003-2005203, the Joint Programme for
HIV/AIDS in Myanmar Progress Report 2003-2004 and Fund for HIV/AIDS in Myanmar (FHAM)
Annual Progress Report April 2004-March 2005 (one combined document)204 and a Synthesis of
Social, Behavioural and Economic Research Studies on HIV Infection and AIDS Conducted in
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
94
Myanmar, dated 1998205. This Section follows the same sequence as for Cambodia, but where
information is limited, some sub-sections have been combined under a single heading.
In addition to a review of publications and reports, a total of six Key Informant Interviews were
conducted with eight representatives from the government, International Organisations and
NGOs in Myanmar (Annex 3). The Key Informants interviewed in Myanmar stated that the most
important issues related to the spread of HIV were (not in any particular order):
increased vulnerability of the general population, with the epidemic continuing to
spread among high-risk behaviour groups and also moving into a more generalized
form
the need to promote wider discussion on sexual, cultural and behavourial practices to
increase awareness of HIV/AIDS
the need to develop enabling policies and the availability of reliable data to inform
programs
measures to address high levels of stigma and discrimination, both towards people
living with HIV/AIDS and Injecting Drug Users
addressing broader socioeconomic issues, such as the widening gap between the
rich and the poor
limited ability to form effective partnerships to allow scale-up of critical interventions
an urgent need to build the capacity of government, IO, NGO and private providers
involved in responding to HIV/AIDS.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
95
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
96
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
97
expensive and less convenient than injectables and pills. There were also low levels
of belief that condoms could prevent HIV infection.
The perceived risk of contracting HIV was low among most of the population,
regardless of behaviour, with the exception of IDUs and some CSW. Perceived risk
was especially low among married women who did not engage in high risk behaviour
and tended to have "unquestionable faith" in the fidelity of their partners.
Information about the characteristics of female sex workers was unclear and there
was no information about male sex workers. Female sex workers were usually
young, poor and with little education. Many were divorced or widowed and from large
families with broken homes. They were mobile and in high demand in mining towns
and transport hubs. Rates of condom use were low: regular condom use varied
between studies from 34-62%. Brothel based sex workers had relatively good
access to health care through mandatory check-ups, but the quality of care was
questionable as the services were delivered almost exclusively through private clinics
giving antibiotic injections. Stigma and discrimination towards sex workers appeared
to vary by ethnicity, with little reported among the Shan ethnic group.
MSM were a particularly vulnerable and isolated group with little known about their
social networks and behaviours. Two groups are apparent: effeminate transgender
men among whom a few studies have been done; and covert gay men who are often
married to women and have children, of whom very little is known. Condom use was
very low (2% in one study) and they tended to have multiple sexual partners with a
low perception of risk of contracting HIV infection. There is no large scale
commercial sex trade for MSM and homosexuality is fairly well accepted in Myanmar
because of the role transvestites play in religious rituals.
Attitudes towards PLHA were "overwhelmingly hostile", based in part on
misconceptions regarding transmission and AIDS being seen as punishment for
immorality. In 1992 only 53% of medical students stated they would be willing to care
for a HIV positive patient. However, attitudes are more accepting for HIV infected
children, and there is no evidence that PLHA are abandoned by families and
communities.
A significant number of men had their first sexual contact with commercial sex
workers, and extra-marital and pre-marital sex is not "as rare as would be expected".
Among different groups reporting extra-marital sex were 76% of truck drivers, 29% of
transport workers, 16% of migrant workers, 14% of high-risk men, 13% of military
trainees, 18% of low-risk rural men and 2% of low-risk rural women. Visiting brothels
after drinking alcohol was a social group activity for some young men.
Different target groups receive health information from different sources, with TV and
video having the most potential for general dissemination of HIV knowledge. Peer
education and workplace based education is appropriate for some groups and large
posters and billboards are an important source of information for transport workers
and truck drivers.
Transport workers and migrant workers have mostly been studied only for knowledge
and sexual behaviour. Migration is usually for economic reasons and fairly common.
There is very little Knowledge, Attitudes, Practice and Behaviour data on IDUs with
most information coming from studies in institutional settings where HIV/AIDS
education leads to apparent high levels of knowledge. Syringes are illegal in
Myanmar and home-made devices are impossible to sterilize.
This synthesis report notes that much of the early research was small scale, descriptive and
quantitative. There were methodological concerns about the representativeness of the samples
and the variety of indicators, leading to a reduced ability to generalize findings, compare studies
and assess trends. The report ends with an Annotated Bibliography by year, providing reference
details and an abstract of most of the studies included in the synthesis.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
98
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
99
www.worldbank.org
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
100
which contravened earlier assurances. The Global Fund, in consultation with the UNDP, the
Principal Recipient, concluded that the grants could not be implemented in a way that ensures
effective program implementation. The decision was made with full awareness of the proportions
of the three epidemics (HIV/AIDS, TB and malaria) in Myanmar, and the fact that, "without
resolute intervention, these diseases could soon reach catastrophic proportions, affecting the
entire region".
In Myanmar, several international organizations, including Marie Stopes International Myanmar
(MSIM), were granted sub-recipient status for The Global Fund. Four national NGOs were also
approved to participate in the project: Myanmar Council of Churches, Myanmar Anti-Narcotics
Association, Myanmar Medical Association and Myanmar Nurses Association. The Press
Release states that The Global Fund will work with the UNDP to gradually terminate activities,
including all sub-recipient contracts, by 1 December 2005.
Even though the Global Fund have decided not to proceed with disbursement for Round 3, the
details of the Global Fund proposal are summarized here as particularly relevant to the provision
of HIV counseling and testing services in Myanmar. The Goal of the proposal was "to reduce HIV
transmission and enhance care services by improving access to education, care and support for
the general population and targeted groups".
There were three Objectives
1. to reduce the risk of HIV infection through sexual transmission by expanding the 100%
targeted condom use program (CUP)
2. to reduce the risk of HIV infection among IDUs through a range of harm reduction
interventions
3. to build capacity for VCT and care and support services
Activities for Objective 1 (selected for this summary) were:
nationwide coverage of the 100% targeted CUP
strengthening STI services in public health settings
development of peer education networks for sex workers
Activities for Objective 2 (selected for this summary) were:
rapid assessment of IDUs
range of treatment modalities
drop-in centres for IDUs and peer education networks
HIV/AIDS education for prisoners
needle and syringe exchange programs
Activities for Objective 3 (in detail) were:
establish public sector VCT centres in 40 towns per year over 5 years
provision of VCT through 100 specially trained GPs
development of VCT services in 25 existing NGO/CBO services
establish 25 new public sector STI services to provide VCT, STI and
HIV/AIDS education, prevention, care and treatment services
opening 7 adolescent reproductive health centres to provide a
comprehensive range of RH services including VCT, HIV/STI prevention,
diagnosis and treatment
promoting VCT services through advocacy, mass media, IEC materials and
peer education
peer based HIV/AIDS education
establishing a range of support services in 40 towns per year over 5 years
providing ART and Opportunistic Infection (OI) treatment in 40 towns per
year over 5 years
extending PMTCT services to 40 towns per year over 5 years
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
101
The proposal noted that access to VCT services is an entry point to related services and is a
major element of the Global Fund proposal. The proposal links directly to the UNAIDS Expanded
Theme Group Joint Program for HIV/AIDS Myanmar, 2003-2005. Innovative aspects of the
proposal are stated to be:
"VCT can now be provided by appropriate NGOs and private practitioners. The
provision of VCT services was previously confined to pubic sector services"
condoms can now be more openly promoted
harm minimization approaches have been adopted my Myanmar in the last 12
months.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
102
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
103
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
104
estimated to be 16% among married women of reproductive age and would be higher if
unmarried women were included. A reproductive health assessment in 1999 found that almost all
antenatal care services, many deliveries and most treatment of obstetrical and abortion related
complications were provided by the public sector217.
Myanmar does not have a national population policy but the UNFPA contributed to the
development of a population policy in 1992 which "remains in draft." There is a scarcity of
reliable population data on which to base interventions217.
The UNFPA Myanmar website210 lists several past and current HIV/AIDS and reproductive health
related projects. A Reproductive Health Services project (2002-2005) is implemented by UNFPA,
WHO, the Department of Health and the Myanmar Medical Association to: improve and expand
reproductive health services; strengthen program management; promote access to secure,
reliable supply of contraceptives; and improve reproductive health information and research. An
Information and Education for Behaviour Change Project (2002-2005) is implemented by UNFPA
and a Japanese NGO (JOICFP) with the Department of Health Planning and the Myanmar
Maternal and Child Welfare Association (MMCWA) to deliver targeted behaviour change
communication and life skills education. A Data Analysis of Fertility and Reproductive Health
Survey project aims to utilize data collected over the past 10 years and study trends. The second
Fertility and Reproductive Health Survey was conducted in 2001. A HIV/AIDS Prevention for
Targeted Populations Group project (2003-2005) implemented by UNFPA, National AIDS
Program and Population Services International aims to expand the 100% targeted condom use
program. An Improving Adolescent Reproductive Health project (2003-2005) will increase
utilization of reproductive health services by adolescents (UNFPA, IPPF, MMCWA and Marie
Stopes International Myanmar).
The major sexual and reproductive health challenges faced by Myanmar are: a high unmet
demand for contraception; a lack of reliable information on adolescent and reproductive health;
gender inequality; and male involvement in reproductive health82.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
105
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
106
Antiretroviral Therapy
Key documents to support the provision of ART have been prepared or drafted: National Care
and Treatment Guidelines for Opportunistic Infection and Anti-Retroviral Therapy in adults and
adolescents and Clinical Management Guidelines for HIV/AIDS in children. The estimated
number of PLHA who needed ART was 46,500 in February 2004. Antiretroviral therapy for
people with advanced HIV infection was initiated in Yangon in 2003. In October 2004, there were
361 patients on treatment, and by mid-2005 about 1,000 PLHA were receiving ART at
government approved centres. There were an estimated additional 1,000 to 2,000 PLHA
receiving ART in the private-for-profit sector, but with concerns about drug quality, compliance
and the development of drug resistance204.
HIV and Tuberculosis collaboration
Myanmar has one of the highest TB rates worldwide, with 97,000 new cases detected each year.
Multi-drug resistant TB has increased from 1.5% in 1995 to 4% among new patients, and 15.5%
among previously treated patients. WHO, using 2002 data, estimated that between 6.8% - 10.9%
of TB patients are co-infected with HIV and that 60-80% of AIDS patients have TB infection204, 215.
STI management
This is addressed by the Joint Programme with specific objectives and targets to increase access
to quality services following recently updated National Treatment Guidelines. The Joint Program
Annual Report notes the increase in number of patients diagnosed and treated for STI and the
increase in the number of service delivery points providing integrated STI services204.
6.11.1 Youth
While 30% of the population is aged 10-24 years, there is limited youth-specific HIV/AIDS data.
The UNICEF publication, Opportunity in Crisis26 has no youth-specific data for Myanmar on: the
numbers and percentages of young men and women living with HIV/AIDS; knowledge on
misconceptions related to transmission; knowledge of prevention; the median age at first sex; and
the percentage of females aged 20-24 years who first had sex before age 15 years.
However, the UN Theme Group Progress Report released in late 2005 provides prevalence data
for 2002 for youth aged 15-24 years in Yangon (1.65%) and in other locations (1.8%), but does
not provide separate results for males and females204. This report also provides the following
youth-specific data for Myanmar (unpublished study, 2004 unless otherwise indicated):
9.9% of sexually active youth used condoms during last sex with non-regular partner
(UNGASS 2002)
85.4% of sexually active youth used condoms with paid partners and 44.5% used
condoms with casual partners
26.5% of youth had accepting attitudes towards PLHA
21% of youth correctly identified the 3 most common routes of transmissions
(UNGASS 2002)
41.6% of youth correctly identified the 3 most common routes of transmission
25.1% of youth rejected major misconceptions about transmission
2.7% of youth accessed VCT in the last 12 months
The primary focus of youth HIV interventions in Myanmar is prevention messages on life skills,
behaviour change communication, adolescent reproductive health information and HIV IEC.
Youth-friendly corners have been established by the Department of Health in 30 townships, some
in collaboration with Marie Stopes International Myanmar. Youth participation in project activities
is a key strategy for effective behaviour change. UNICEF introduced the School-Based Healthy
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
107
Living and HIV/AIDS Prevention Education (SHAPE) program in 1998 and this is now part of the
national education curriculum in Myanmar, with 2.1 million pupils reached in the first semester of
2005. Over 54,000 teachers have received training on health and social issues, including HIV
and drugs204.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
108
The situation is slowly changing. The Joint Programme and the aborted Global Fund proposal
clearly acknowledge the importance of prevention, treatment, care and support for IDUs with
several specific objectives and interventions. Preparations for substitution therapy are well
advanced, and more innovative approaches to drug-use, including drop-in centres and peer
education, are being tested and expanded.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
109
The Key Informants listed several barriers to VCT (in no particular order):
limited promotion of VCT services
a perception that there was little benefit to be gained from knowing one's HIV status
with limited post-test services available and high levels of stigma and discrimination
concerns about the consequences for women who test positive for HIV or STI
limited geographical access with the cost of transport as a barrier
limited resources for expansion of services
concerns about confidentiality and the "registration" of persons who are HIV+
current HIV counseling services are not seen as "youth friendly", especially for
sexually active youth who are not married
long waiting times
perceived poor quality of services
attitude of health providers
delay in provision of results as rapid tests are still not regularly used.
A variety of HIV counseling and testing models were suggested by the Key Informants as
appropriate and needed for Myanmar:
community-based models integrated into antenatal clinics, STI clinics and
reproductive health services
stand alone centres in major urban areas with high client loads
specialized services for specific groups such as MSM and Sex Workers, including
mobile clinics
private franchised General Practitioner-based model with GPs trained in STI and HIV
management., including VCT (Sun Network promoted by PSI).
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
110
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
111
A detailed Site Assessment for 10 of the 12 MSIM Clinics is planned as part of the preparation
phase to integrate HIV counseling and testing into the existing sexual and reproductive health
services being provided. Separate reports for these Site Assessments will be prepared over the
twelve months from January to December 2005.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
112
The promotion of VCT services through MSIM Clinics and outreach should focus on
raising awareness of the benefits of knowing one's HIV status, together with advocacy
efforts to increase available post-test services, including treatment.
Couple's counseling for HIV testing, both pre-marriage and for those already married, can
be done. MSIM should carefully monitor this situation to promote couple's counseling.
However, current efforts to promote greater involvement of men in sexual and
reproductive health, in particular, the male partners of female clients who receive STI,
antenatal care and family planning services at MSIM Clinics, should be strongly
supported.
MSIM, as a provider of quality sexual and reproductive health services for women, should
develop culturally appropriate ways to encourage disclosure of HIV test results (and STI
results) to the male partners of woman clients, and to support women who fear or
experience gender-based violence in the context of wanting or having a HIV test.
Given the high levels of stigma and discrimination related to HIV/AIDS in Myanmar,
MSIM will need to give careful consideration to the involvement of PLHA as community
outreach workers to promote VCT services and as providers of group or individual pretest counseling, and possibly post-test counseling.
Youth are a key target group for the Mekong VCT project. MSIM should continue to
expand youth-friendly sexual and reproductive health services, especially for unmarried
female youth, with an additional focus on the promotion of VCT services. Counselors
may need additional specific training in counseling skills for youth. Resources should
continue to be allocated to outreach to in-school and out-of-school youth, including
promotion of VCT services.
Some MSIM Clinics may be well placed to expand services, including VCT services, to
reach migrant workers, particularly women.
The Mekong VCT project provides MSIM with an opportunity to actively participate in
supporting the national PMTCT program. Clients receiving antenatal services can
currently receive pre-test and post-test counseling, with testing hopefully approved in the
near future. Pregnant women who test positive can be referred to existing PMTCT
services. Depending on available resources, MSIM may also have the opportunity to
support follow-up and referral to other HIV/AIDS services for mothers who are HIV
positive.
MSIM can make a significant contribution to the strengthening of all other referral
linkages for clients who test positive to HIV/AIDS. This can be done at the facility/ district
level, but also at the Provincial and national level. Continued participation in national
level networks such as the UN Theme Group and the NGO Consortium will provide
opportunities to learn from the experiences of others and to share MSIM experiences in
these areas.
MSIM can effectively use the Mekong VCT project resources to develop a high quality
VCT service. This will include Monitoring and Evaluation, Quality Assurance and Quality
Control mechanisms which can support national initiatives in these areas. In addition,
MSIM should participate in, and actively support, counselor networks comprising both
public and private sector VCT counselors. Stress-management skills for counselors
should be shared within these networks.
MSIM needs to develop clear guidelines for any fee for HIV counseling and testing. Key
Informants were divided on the issue of whether VCT should be free or clients should pay
a fee. If a fee is charged for some clients, based on ability to pay, MSIM will need to
develop a practical and equitable working definition to identify clients for whom HIV
counseling and testing would be free or subsidised.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
113
83,123,000
31%
1.6%
2.3
26%
130
17
23
71
108
83
47
90%
87%
73%
27.3%
$US 550
$US 148
<2%
0.4% [0.2-0.8]
220,000
4.4%
29.3%
0.35%
1,000+
1.8-3.0%
79%
85%
86%
28%
(1) UNICEF, unless indicated, data is for 2004. (2) Human Development Indicators, 2005
(3) HIV/AIDS data from most recent national sources
The UNAIDS Viet Nam website (www.unaids.org.vn/) provided links to many of the documents
used for this review. These included many poster presentations from the XV International AIDS
Conference in Bangkok in 2004. With a few exceptions, only those directly related to VCT were
selected for inclusion in this review.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
114
In addition to a review of publications and reports, a total of seven Key Informant Interviews were
conducted with 13 representatives from the government, International Organisations and NGOs
in Viet Nam (Annex 4). These Key Informants identified the following issues as most important in
relation to HIV/AIDS in Viet Nam (in no particular order):
need to continue to focus on higher risk groups, but to include their partners and
lower risk groups as the epidemic is showing signs of becoming more generalized
the need to expand access to treatment, care and support is becoming increasingly
important
increased need to move away from a "social evil" approach to a harm reduction
approach
levels of stigma and discrimination towards PLHA, and towards IDUs and sex
workers, are high and need to be addressed
social and cultural norms need to be clearly understood in planning behaviour
change communication
broader underlying issues, particularly poverty, need to be addressed.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
115
The overall prevalence among FSW increased from 0.6% in 1995, to 5.9% in 2002
and reduced to 4.4% in 2004. However rates remain high in Hanoi (3.7% in 1998
and 14.5% in 2002) and Ho Chi Minh City (3.1% in 1998 and 23.4% in 2002) with
"extreme variations" between provinces
The prevalence among antenatal women has increased from 0.0% in 1994, to 0.34%
in 2002, 0.24% in 2003 and 0.35% in 2004
The prevalence among military recruits has increased from 0.0% in 1994 to 0.8% in
2001 in Hanoi
The HIV prevalence among STD patients was 0.5% in 1994 and 1.6% in 1999. In
2001 the median prevalence in major urban centres was 7.25% and 1.9% outside
major urban centres.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
116
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
117
loss of jobs and income by PLHA: about one third of PLHA were employed, but lost
their job due to ill health or stigma and discrimination in the workplace
loss of jobs and income by caregivers: 75% of caregivers were women and 50%
were mothers. About three-quarters of the PLHA required assistance from a caregiver for an average of 5 hours per day; one-quarter of care-givers had to give up
their job; and one third experienced a reduction in income as a result of care-giving
households with PLHA function in a highly stigmatized environment
households cope most commonly by borrowing money, often at high interest,
followed by reducing food intake and reduced health care
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
118
evaluation
The overall objective of the Plan is to control the HIV prevalence to less than 0.3% among the
general population by 2010. The specific objectives are to:
increase HIV/AIDS prevention and control in all socioeconomic development
programs
increase people's knowledge about prevention
control HIV/AIDS transmission from high risk groups to the community through
implementation of comprehensive harm reduction interventions
ensure appropriate care and treatment for HIV/AIDS infected people
perfect the management, monitoring, supervision and evaluation systems
prevent HIV/AIDS transmission through medical services.
The National Plan recognizes the need to improve the legal documentation on HIV/AIDS "step by
step", including the review, revision and cancellation of measures no longer considered
appropriate. The National Plan allows for the provision for harm reduction activities among drug
users and female sex workers for the first time, and also refers to comprehensive antiretroviral
therapy and care services225.
One of a list of technical solutions in the Plan is to "strengthen and improve the quality of
HIV/AIDS voluntary counseling and testing activities". Among the difficulties and challenges
noted is that voluntary counseling and testing is not systematically organized due to the absence
of specific regulations and guidelines. A separate paragraph in the Plan gives more details in
relation to voluntary counseling and testing:
implement voluntary counseling and testing programs in 40 Provinces by 2005 and
100% of Provinces by 2010
integrate counseling services into health care programs, family planning, maternal
and child care and protection and primary health care
to guarantee all tests are conducted on an anonymity principle to preserve the
confidentiality of tested people
to expand voluntary counseling and testing services to the district level
to build up the voluntary test notification and referral system and mobilize the
participation of the private system in providing counseling and support
to train staff in voluntary counseling and testing and to mobilize multisectoral
participation in this work.
A Directive of the Prime Minister in Strengthening HIV/AIDS Prevention and Control236 lists the
reasons for the rapid increase in the number of HIV infected persons as due to:
an increase in social evils, especially prostitution and drug abuse
lack of coordination among Ministries and localities
inadequate community knowledge about HIV/AIDS and about people living with
HIV/AIDS
lack of comprehensive management, care, support and treatment for PLHA.
The Directive describes the lead roles to be taken by various government Ministries and how they
should cooperate in fulfilling their roles.
The Ministry of Culture and Information leads the strengthening of IEC activities
The Ministry of Public Security leads the management of people living with HIV/AIDS
in prisons and re-education centres
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
119
The Ministry of Labour, Invalids and Social Affairs leads the management of PLHA in
the community
The Ministry of Planning and Investment and Ministry of Finance leads budgeting
considerations
The Ministry of Education and Training has the lead role in including HIV/AIDS in the
teaching curricula in all schools
The Ministry of Health is the lead Ministry to consolidate and strengthen systems to
prevent and control HIV/AIDS, to strengthen harm reduction, epidemiological
surveillance, safe blood transfusion, PMTCT, STI management, care and support of
PLHA and to develop a proposal related to production of generic drugs.
A review conducted by The POLICY project estimated the HIV/AIDS budget needed for 2007 at
$US 214 million, with $101 million for preventive interventions and $112 million for treatment and
care. There was a large gap of $178 million between the funds available in 2003 and those
needed for 2007. Funds required for VCT were estimated to be $2.5 million in 2005, increasing
to 3.6 million in 2007232.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
120
The funding is to be used to establish community based networks of "care and support" and
capacity building for local health workers. This includes the provision of VCT, community-based
care, hospital care and PMTCT in 20 provinces/cities with the highest prevalence. The main
objectives of this Global Fund activity are to:
strengthen HIV/AIDS care, counseling and support networks
provide access to care and support services for 90% of PLHA in 20 provinces/
cities and increase the number of PLHA on ART to 750 by the second year
provide 100,000 pregnant women at antenatal care with information on HIV and
access to PMTCT and provide appropriate care and support to HIV positive
children by the end of the second year.
The planned activities related to VCT are: to develop and finalise HIV/AIDS care-related policies
and regulations, guidelines and training modules (including VCT and PMTCT) and to pilot models
of HIV/AIDS care and support, VCT and PMCT. The intended results are to establish VCT
services in the 20 provinces/cities and to provide information on HIV and access to VCT to
100,000 pregnant women receiving antenatal care in these areas.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
121
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
122
Sections 12 and 13 relate to the roles and responsibilities of the National AIDS
Committee. Section 13.3 states that the Ministry of Health shall have responsibility to
organize tests and create favorable conditions for Vietnamese and foreigners in Viet Nam
to voluntarily have tests to detect HIV/AIDS infection and to provide counseling on the
prevention and control of HIV AIDS infection for the persons who come for tests.
Sections 14 to 17 deal, respectively, with the duties of the Ministry of Culture and
Information, the Ministry of Education and Training, the Ministry of Labour, War Invalids
and Social Affairs, and the Ministry of Finance. Section 18 refers to the roles of the
People's Committees at all levels. These include a duty to ensure that HIV/AIDS
prevention and control is closely associated with the prevention and combat of
prostitution and drug abuse; to mobilize and guide the people to take part in the medical
and mental care for HIV/AIDS patients; and to "ensure that they are not treated in a
discriminatory manner and facilitate their integration into the community."
Under a Decree dated 15 May 2003247, the Ministry of Health is responsible for regulating the
professional and technical standards for HIV/AIDS and to act as the standing office on HIV/AIDS
for the National Committee for HIV/AIDS, Drugs and Prostitution Prevention and Control. A
separate document dated 15 August 2003248, states that the General Department of Preventive
Medicine and HIV/AIDS Control is "mainly responsible for the development of strategy, masterplans and plans for HIV/AIDS control". Viet Nam also enacted legislation in 2003 in relation to
International Cooperation in the Field of Drug Prevention and Combat249. This document refers to
drug addicts, drug-related crimes and other drug-related illegal acts as "drug evils for short".
In November 2003, CARE International in Viet Nam published a review examining international
law, national policy and legislation for the prevention of HIV/AIDS and protection of human rights
of PLHA in Viet Nam250. The key findings were:
Despite positive steps, "there remain shortcomings, both in law and in reality, in
protecting the human rights of patients in general and of people living with HIV/AIDS
in particular"
The information currently disseminated is based more on the need to prevent HIV
transmission than on human rights based principles and practices
The law does not contain provisions specifically for associations of PLHA
Sections of the Ordinance on the Prevention and Control of HIV/AIDS (see above)
need to be reviewed and revised to include the rights and obligations of PLHA
Other Laws that should be reviewed include the Law on the Protection and Health of
People, 1989 which provides for mandatory treatment of persons with HIV/AIDS and
the Law on Marriage and the Family which requires foreigners to produce evidence
that they are HIV negative before marriage to a Vietnamese citizen
In relation to HIV counseling and testing, the review notes that this should be on a
voluntary basis with respect for dignity and fundamental human rights. Specific
recommendations are that more establishments should be opened with various forms
of counseling, and to ensure a high standard of specialised counseling.
In relation to other international Conventions, Viet Nam has ratified the Convention of the
Elimination of all forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), the International Convention
of Civil and Political Rights in 1982, the International Convention on Economic, Social and
Cultural Rights, the Convention on the Elimination of all Forms Racial Discrimination and the
Convention on the Rights of the Child in 1990 (with two Optional Protocols signed in 2000).
However, Viet Nam is not yet a signatory to the Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel and
Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment251.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
123
Stigma and discrimination is a critical issue in responding to HIV/AIDS in Viet Nam. Among the
reasons given for stigma and discrimination towards people living with HIV/AIDS are16, 250, 252, 253:
fear for one's own personal safety because of an over-estimation of the
infectiousness of HIV. People generally understand ways in which HIV is transmitted
but ambiguity persists, leading to fears of acquiring HIV casually with the adoption of
actions that stigmatize PLHA in an attempt to avoid infection
a view of PLHA as individuals involved in social evils. In the minds of the community,
leaders and health workers, HIV/AIDS is "inextricably linked" to drug use and sex
work, which are both regarded as social evils
a perception that PLHA can no longer work and cannot contribute to society and the
family
a perception that PLHA carry a "moral" disease, and that priority should not be given
to such a group when there are many other groups in society who need to receive
attention
women with HIV/AIDS tend to be more highly stigmatized than men on the
assumption that HIV is acquired through immoral means and the expectation of
society that women should uphold the morality and integrity of family and society.
However, there are also encouraging signs in relation to stigma and discrimination. One study in
Can Tho and Hai Phong, published in 2004, found that "despite the stigma and discrimination,
most PLHA receive love, care and support from their families and compassion from some
members of their communities"253. At the national level the National Strategy 2004-2010 openly
acknowledges the increasing HIV epidemic and the increased sexual transmission of HIV, fully
recognizes the problem of stigma and discrimination and identifies the roles of the Party,
government, mass organizations and the community to combat stigma and discrimination252.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
124
more permissive in their tolerance of premarital and extramarital sex for men. In relation to STDs,
both men and women expressed anxiety about telling their partners about an STD. Women's
expressions were characterized more by fear of social and physical consequences, whereas men
expressed embarrassment.
A separate study has examined violence towards women in Viet Nam in some detail251. While
the Vietnamese Constitution grants de jure equality between men and women in political,
economic, cultural, social and family spheres, violence and other discrimination against women
still persist in Viet Nam. Traditionally, women in Viet Nam were considered to enjoy special
position and privilege in the family and in society compared to women in other countries in the
region. However, the arrival of Confucianism 1000 years ago is understood to have weakened
this traditional gender equity, which was only formally restored by the Socialist government in
modern times.
This study noted many positive features in relation to the position of women in Viet Nam.
More than 50% of women are members of the Vietnamese Women's Union, an
organization which should be consulted and involved in any discussions on women
and children at all levels of government.
There is a National Committee for the Advancement of Women, the peak government
body addressing women's issues
Vietnamese women enjoy relatively high levels of health, education and gender
equity compared with other countries in the region and States with comparable gross
domestic product. However, there are important differences for rural areas and
among minority ethnic groups where 60% of women give birth without a qualified
birth attendant and where many rural health centres have inadequately trained staff,
poor quality equipment and supplies and limited budgets256
Women are entitled to equal access to educational opportunities, which has been
largely realized for primary and secondary education, but less so for tertiary
education. However, 20% of women from the poorest quintile are illiterate256.
The main areas where gender inequality remains an important issue are256:
Labour: women constitute 52% of the total labour force but are concentrated in lower
status occupations with substantially less income (72% of the male salary for
equivalent work). With the shift to a market economy, women have been pushed into
more precarious household and informal sector work.
Land ownership: in theory there is legal equality in relation to land ownership but
women frequently depend on male relatives for access to land. 80-90% of land titles
are in the husband's name, creating difficulties for divorced or widowed women
Age for Marriage: men and women are legally considered equal, but the minimum
age for marriage is 20 for men and 18 for women
Indigenous and Minority Women face multiple layers of discrimination based on
gender and ethnicity: they are geographically isolated, have higher levels of poverty,
ill health and reduced access to services
Access to credit: women have less access to formal credit (more women are
customers of mass organizations credit funds).
Violence against women in the family has been given limited attention by the government and
there is no accurate data, as many victims do not report domestic violence. In 1999, a
comprehensive study commissioned by the World Bank (cited by Bourke-Martignoni251) described
domestic violence as "a very real and widespread issue in Viet Nam, affecting women from all
social and geographical groups". Wife battering was not perceived as a criminal act, despite
provisions in the criminal law against such actions. The term "marital rape" is unknown in Viet
Nam but there is evidence of "forced" sex in marriage. Reported acid attacks on women as
punishment for alleged adultery are increasing in number. The re-emergence of a bride price in
some areas of Viet Nam has also been noted with concern.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
125
Violence in the community includes rape and other forms of sexual violence. This is covered by
criminal law and, while there are an increased numbers of reports, many cases are not reported.
Sex work is viewed as a social evil, and, while sex work itself is not criminalized, third party
involvement in prostitution is a criminal offence. Sex work is linked to domestic violence and
trafficking of women.
In response to the issues noted above, the government has taking action. A Gender
Mainstreaming document has been published by the National Committee for the Advancement of
Women to support all government officials to understand their roles and responsibilities and
develop skills to achieve gender equality257. This 156 page document (English version) describes
gender mainstreaming as an approach or strategy towards gender equality. Part 1 discusses the
Vietnamese approach to advancing women and achieving gender equality. The government has
a National Strategy for the Advancement of Women in Viet Nam by 2010 which was published in
2002 and refers to the rights of women in labour and employment, education, health care and
leadership. The Comprehensive Poverty Reduction Strategy, May 2002, recognizes the
relationship between gender inequality and poverty and sustainable economic growth. The
Millennium Development Goals have been contextualized with specific Viet Nam Development
Goals addressing Education, Gender Equality and Women's Empowerment.
Most of this lengthy document discusses gender issues in general terms, but Part 4 addresses
sector-specific gender issues. A separate section is given to Health and HIV/AIDS in Viet Nam
with the key issues identified as:
the impact of health reform on the poor and on poor women
women's health status, nutrition, maternal health and maternal mortality
access for women and men to reproductive health and family planning services
HIV/AIDS infection rates in men and women
violence against women
long working hours resulting in less rest, relaxation and opportunities for learning and
participation for women. Women spend 2.5 times longer than men every day with
housework256.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
126
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
127
The study also noted the growing number of young people who have sex before marriage and
recommended that the Government and NGOs make this vulnerable group a key priority. A
segmented approach to social marketing was recommended for the following specific groups:
married couples, young unmarried women and men, clients of sex workers, sex workers, IDUs
and their partners and men who have sex with men.
Blood safety
In 1992, Viet Nam passed regulations to establish standards and guidelines for blood safety. By
2000, 100% of blood units were stated to be screened for HIV.
Prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission
The Prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission is a relatively new intervention in Viet Nam.
Coverage in 2001 was estimated to be 2% of the women who needed PMTCT services3 and in
2003 seven sites were recorded as providing these services4. In the 12 months to September
2004238, 1,220 pregnant women were recorded as receiving PMTCT servicesxii.
The Ministry of Health has a National Plan on the Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission and
the third draft, dated June 2005, is summarized here260. The goal of the Plan is to control the
MTCT rate to less than 15% by 2010, with the objectives being to:
reduce the risk of HIV infection for women of reproductive age
increase the percentage of pregnant women with access to HIV counseling and
testing services
increase the percentage of HIV infected pregnant women and their children who
receive prophylactic treatment
increase post-partum care and support for these women and children.
Several technical solutions are listed in the Plan, including the following relevant to this review:
to prevent MTCT by promoting HIV counseling and testing prior to marriage,
pregnancy and delivery
to establish a network of HIV counseling and testing services for pregnant women at
the province, district and commune levels
to conduct HIV screening with rapid tests and the confirmatory test at standardized
laboratories
to integrate VCT activities into other activities such as antenatal care and family
planning services.
The National Plan proposes two options for infant feeding. Option 1 is formula feeding only if
eligible (the family agree, have sufficient funds, clean water and good sanitation, able to prepare
the formula and ensure supply), while Option 2 is exclusive breast feeding for 4 to 6 months with
immediate weaning. Specific regimens for prophylaxis are provided in the Plan. The monitoring
and evaluation indicators related to VCT are the number of women receiving HIV counseling, the
number accepting testing, and districts with available PMTCT services.
Pilot PMTCT projects have been conducted in several locations but the National Plan lists some
of the difficulties faced:
there are no policies for HIV infected women in disadvantaged family conditions, for
HIV infected children and for children affected by HIV/AIDS
there are no specific guidelines with details of roles and responsibilities for
implementation at different levels
there is limited IEC material specific for PMTCT
stigma and discrimination about HIV/AIDS is strongly linked to the social evils
concept
xii
The data is from the US government PEPFAR report for 2005 and it is not clear whether this refers to all PMTCT
programs in Viet Nam or only to PEPFAR-funded programs.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
128
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
129
Antiretroviral Therapy
The provision of antiretroviral therapy (ART) is acknowledged as an emerging need for Viet Nam
with the National Plan having a goal to treat 70% of AIDS patients by 2010. In June 2004 there
were about 1000 adults aged 15-49 years with advanced AIDS on ART of an estimated need (in
2003) of 22,000223.
National Guidelines for Diagnosis and Treatment of HIV/AIDS were released by the Ministry of
Health in March 2005. This document comprehensively covers diagnosis and clinical staging,
clinical management, prevention of opportunistic infections, management of common clinical
syndromes, diagnosis and management of Opportunistic Infections (OI) and ARV therapy. The
section on PMTCT presents three regimens based on the time at which a pregnant woman is
diagnosed HIV positive. Of relevance to this literature review on HIV testing are the diagnostic
requirements. For diagnosis, the serum sample is "confirmed HIV positive when it is reactive to 3
HIV serology tests with different test principles and different antigen preparations (Strategy III)"
and..."Only laboratories meeting Ministry of Health standards are authorized to inform the positive
HIV results".
HIV and Tuberculosis collaboration
The incidence of tuberculosis in 2003 was estimated to be 178 for all cases (including those
HIV+) per 100,000 people (WHO website). Between 1996 and 2001, 298,418 new infectious
cases were treated with a 89% cure rate. By 1999, 100% of districts in Viet Nam were covered
by the DOTS strategy. There are an increasing proportion of TB infections in females which is
thought to be due to gender barriers in accessing TB services with consequent delays in
diagnosis and treatment263.
HIV surveillance among TB patients shows an increase in the national rate from 0.57% in 1995 to
3.0% in 2002, but 10 Provinces had rates over 3%, including a rate of 9.4% in Ho Chi Minh City.
However, there is some inconsistency in the data, with a national rate of HIV infection in TB
patients of 1.8% in 2002 cited in a WHO publication225. Between 1997 and 2002 there were
1,842 cases of co-infection in Ho Chi Minh City with cure rates of about 50% and death rates over
30%263. Steep increases in HIV prevalence among tuberculosis patients were reported in 12
urban districts of Ho Chi Minh City from 0.5% in 1995 to 4% in 2000264 . The immediate concern
for the tuberculosis programme in this city was to provide appropriate care to tuberculosis
patients with HIV co-infection and to strengthen HIV counseling services.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
130
Education
school attendance and literacy levels are high and attitudes to schooling and
teachers are very positive.
Work and Employment
work and increased opportunities to work are the highest priorities for future
aspirations it is considered difficult to find a job.
Friendship, Sexuality and Reproductive Health
traditional attitudes and practices towards relationships are the norm in Viet Nam
where premarital sex is still considered improper and relationships with young
people of the same sex is usual, with very little acceptance of homosexuality
sexual intercourse is not common, and when it does occur, it is usually wellconsidered, in an already committed relationship and in safe environments
young people believe in the practical effectiveness of condoms but attitudes
towards condom use were generally negative as they were associated with
indecent relationships including sex work
contraception is used by many married couples, but irregularly by single people
two thirds of young women still have limited knowledge of the fertile time in the
menstrual cycle
sex work is generally viewed negatively
33% of single urban men aged 22-25 years reported premarital sex compared to
3.7% of single urban women and 26% of single rural men had premarital sex
compared to 3.3% of single rural women in the same age range
of those sexually active, 85% had only one partner in the last 12 months
the first sexual experience was with a girlfriend/ boyfriend for 72% of those who
had ever had sex
the average age at first sex was 20 for men and 19.4 for women
very few sexually active men had ever had sex with sex workers (5.3%)
condom use with sex workers was high at 93%, with higher rates in urban youth
compared to rural youth, but attitudes towards condoms were negative. These
included reduced pleasure and association of condoms with prostitutes and
unfaithful people
Pregnancy and Abortion Experiences
there is still stigma associated with pregnancy for unmarried women
a high percentage of women reported having antenatal care for their first
pregnancy
abortion services are used by both married and unmarried women, but reported
rates are lower than other surveys
Reproductive Health Knowledge
generally young people are well informed about reproductive health (less so
about STI), but accuracy of knowledge is not high
HIV/AIDS
there were high levels of knowledge about HIV/AIDS, but accuracy of knowledge
was lower, with a clear relationship between education and more accurate
knowledge. Using a composite score for knowledge of transmission and
prevention, 52% scored high, 39% medium and 9% low. UNICEF data from
other sources indicates that 63% of youth aged 15-24 years know that HIV
infection can be prevented by having one faithful partner, 60% know that
condoms can prevent transmission, 34% that abstinence can prevent
transmission, 44% that mosquitoes cannot transmit HIV infection and 63% know
that a healthy looking person can have HIV/AIDS26
there were generally positive attitudes towards PLHA with limited fear, but three
times as many ethnic youth said they would not help someone with HIV/AIDS
awareness of HIV/AIDS was less in ethnic minorities and among those who had
never attended school
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
131
the four most frequent sources of HIV/AIDS information were mass media,
family, professionals and mass organizations
64% of the sample could identify at least 3 different HIV testing sites, but the
report noted that fear, lack of confidentiality, stigma, cost, lack of treatment for
HIV and poor process in sharing results were all barriers to VCT
while attitudes towards condoms were negative, 97% agreed that condoms can
prevent HIV/AIDS.
Substance Use
there was easy access to legal drugs, including alcohol. Young men are
encouraged to drink through peer pressure, but social constraints on young
women limit alcohol consumption
69% of males and 28% of females had finished a drink of alcohol at least once
Of these, 58% of males and 30% of females had been drunk at least once
illicit drug use was low (0.5%), almost certainly reflecting under-reporting
95% knew that not sharing needles can prevent HIV/AIDS
one quarter of the sample said they knew someone who used illicit drugs.
Health Services
70% of the youth sampled had bought medication for self-treatment
27.4% had received medical care at a private clinic
26.7% had received medical care at a commune health centre, but this utilization
rate was much lower for urban youth.
The Study identified the following areas for effective intervention:
promote the positive behaviour of youth, including monogamy and fidelity in
marriage
address poverty and under-employment by providing work opportunities for
young men and women
focus on ethnic minority youth who are more disadvantaged
HIV/AIDS efforts should focus on the most vulnerable youth, including IDUs and
sex workers
gender equality is improving in education and employment but further efforts are
needed to improve SRH knowledge and skills and access to services.
These national level findings are reasonably consistent with smaller, more specific samples. A
study among 569 Grade 12 students from 20 randomly selected schools in Ho Chi Minh City in
2001 used an interviewer administered questionnaire266. Key findings were that 1.9% of the total
survey (2.6% males) had used heroin or other addicting substances and that 6.7% had ever had
sex, but only 4.9% in the last 12 months (mostly males). Among those who had sex in the last 12
months, 35.7% used condoms during last sex. Only 0.2% reported having an STD. Between
86% to 94% had correct knowledge of HIV/AIDS and 75% accepted HIV infected students
attending school.
An earlier study, also published in 2001231 looked at the issue of sexually transmitted infections.
In reviewing available studies, the report confirmed the finding that few high school students are
likely to be sexually active. However, the report noted evidence that more adolescents were
becoming sexually active during and soon after attending high school. Student's knowledge of
STD, HIV and contraception was considered to be low and the study concluded that Viet Nam's
young people were "ill-equipped to deal with a rapidly emerging HIV epidemic". In this study,
very few students reported having a HIV antibody test (2.1% males and 1.2% females). This was
felt to be related to the perception by the majority of the students about their low risk of getting
HIV.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
132
A recent review of adolescent reproductive health in Viet Nam was conducted as part of a 13
country study, which included Cambodia. The key findings for Viet Nam, which have not already
been highlighted in the studies cited above, are summarized here267:
In 2000 an estimated 37% of pregnancies in youth resulted in abortion and 48% in
births. The increase in abortion is probably due to young unmarried women choosing
to terminate a pregnancy. Repeat abortions are also common.
The unmet need for family planning is low at 9.7% for those aged 15-19 years and
13.3% for those aged 20-24 years (based on 1997 data)
Gender socialization is changing in response to the socioeconomic situation in Viet
Nam
The gender gap in education is minimal, but there is a greater gap between urban
and rural areas. Three times as many urban men than rural men attend university
and five times as many urban women
The legal age for employment is 15 years, and women comprise 49.5% of all
employed 15-29 year olds. Unemployment is highest in the 15-19 year age group
(11%) and next highest in the 20-24 year age group (6.6%), compared to the national
average of 4%
With the change to a market economy, more young men are moving to urban areas
for employment, resulting in a greater proportion of young rural women who are
under increased pressure to marry due to the shortage of male partners
There are relatively few early high risk pregnancies (5.7% of 15-19 year olds were
pregnant or had given birth to their first child). The majority of the pregnant young
women who had no antenatal care and delivered at home were ethnic minority
women from remote areas.
This review noted that, while there are no legal barriers to promoting adolescent and reproductive
health (ARH) in Viet Nam, there are no specific government policies for ARH. Adolescents have
been largely ignored in population and family planning policies, but there is gradually increasing
attention. A National Plan of Action on ARH was drafted in 1999, but has not been officially
adopted (at January 2003) and therefore not widely disseminated. The National Strategy for
Reproductive Health (NSRH) 2001-2010 has been approved by the Prime Minister and does
draw attention to adolescent health. This Strategy recommends the following approaches to
ARH:
IEC materials development and dissemination for adolescents on sexual
development and sexuality
increased access to RH and Family Planning services
the inclusion of sex and sexuality education into the school curriculum.
The review concluded by identifying the following important barriers to ARH in Viet Nam:
young people's lack of knowledge and skills
adults hesitant to discuss ARH issues
teachers and parents lacking knowledge and skills related to sexual health
lack of capacity and resources for ARH
limited reproductive health services for unmarried adolescents.
Several published reports have suggested specific responses to ARH issues in Viet Nam. The
study among high school students Ha Noi231 recommended that new ways be found to provide
sexuality and gender education in Viet Nam, based on the importance of Confucian morality and
Citizen Education, but also dealing with changing cultural values and circumstances. Mensch
and colleagues268 noted that most research among adolescents in Viet Nam has examined
unprotected sexual activity and its health consequences, namely abortion and STI, and especially
HIV. Their review advises caution against an approach that focuses only on risky sexual
behaviours. They suggest that the lack of adequate employment opportunities may be more of a
threat to adolescent reproductive health.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
133
A case study of new approaches for reproductive health education for youth in Quang Ninh was
published in 2001269. These approaches seek to integrate social activities with improving life
skills through youth community development so that youth are empowered in decision-making
and implementing their own activities. The study notes that when such approaches are
implemented by "outsiders", activities are less likely to continue long term.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
134
In Viet Nam there is an "unusually large overlap between injecting drug users and sex workers2".
There is wide variation between provinces in the prevalence of injecting drug use among female
sex workers. In Ho Chi Minh City about 38% of 1000 sex workers were injecting drugs and 49%
of injecting female sex workers were HIV positive, compared to a rate of 8% in sex workers who
did not use drugs. In Hai Phong about 40% of all sex workers said they injected drugs compared
to 17% in Hanoi. Sex workers using drugs were half as likely to use condoms with clients as
those who did not use drugs223. There is a pattern of relatively high drug use and inconsistent
and low condom use among sex workers who inject drugs, but concerns have been raised about
the representativeness of samples that only include sex workers from rehabilitation and reeducation centres274.
One study, which may not be representative for the reasons noted above, was an assessment of
risk factors for drug abuse among 500 female prostitutes in different areas of Viet Nam, including
Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City, conducted by the Department of Social Evils Prevention of the
Ministry of Labour, Invalids and Social Affairs and the UN Drug Control Program in 2001275. The
relevant findings werexiii:
70.8% were drug addicts
63.5% of the sample were aged 18-25 years and 52.1% were not married
41.9% were migrants from other provinces, usually rural
7% stated they were forced or deceived into prostitution
31% supported their parents with income earned, 27% supported children, 6%
supported siblings and 4% supported their husbands
of those who use drugs, 65% were injecting drug users, with a pattern of initially
smoking then moving to injecting drugs
over half the sample stated they had seen a death caused by drug overdose
85% of those who did not use drugs stated they always used condoms with clients,
compared to 48.5% of those in the drug use group.
xiii
The report is written in the "social evil" language of sex work and drug use and is presented here using this same
language.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
135
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
136
The report discusses characteristics of each of the main mobile population groups. Additional
data from other studies is included here.
Truck drivers: Mobility and use of commercial sex services are characteristics of long
distance truck drivers. Studies suggest that condom use among truck drivers is high
with commercial sex workers (citing a 1998 World Vision Viet Nam study). In a
separate study of 1,098 Long Distance Truck Drivers277 in 2000 in four locations (two
bordering Cambodia and two bordering Laos) the key findings were:
o over 96% had completed primary school and 43% finished secondary school
o 67% knew at least two modes of transmission, but knowledge of MTCT was
low at 49%
o there were low levels of misconceptions about transmission (5%)
o 54.7% knew at least two means of prevention
o 36.2% stated they always used condoms with non-regular sex partners
o 39% had extramarital sex in the last month
o only 1% reported ever using drugs
Seafarers and sailors: this group may also use commercial sex services while away
from home, but little information is available on their sexual behaviours.
Construction workers and workers at factories: Many in this group live in the locality
where they are working. There is often there is a shortage of entertainment in these
areas but commercial sex is usually available.
Migrant workers in general are vulnerable to HIV infection because of poor living
conditions, difficulty in accessing information and health care and an inadequate
legal structure to support their human rights.
Traders are a high risk population because of their mobility and stress in work. Their
income is quite high and they often spend money on drinking and entertainment with
friends, which may include using commercial sex services.
State officials are often required to travel outside their duty stations and may visit
commercial sex workers during these times.
Foreign tourists may also use commercial sex, sometimes as part of sex tours
operating under the guide of tourism.
This review, and two other published studies on assessing vulnerability to HIV on national
highways in Viet Nam (which are based on the same research)278, 279, describe the characteristics
of hot spots for prostitution on national highways. The studies note that prostitution on highways
is quite open and with reasonable prices so that clients are easily attracted. Sex workers may be
based in service establishments or function as freelance workers. Hot spots are easy to identify
and many are located at truck stops, gas stations and entertainment establishments on the
national highway routes. Other locations are tourist sites, industrial zones and border areas
where there can be considerable cross-border movement of sex workers. Sex workers in these
establishments regularly change locations to avoid anti-social evil campaigns, or are dismissed
by the establishment's owner, or move to a higher paying establishment. This mobility makes it
difficult to implement effective prevention interventions. Hot spots fluctuate in the degree of
activity, with new hot spots developing as others are suppressed. There is also evidence of a
network to direct the operation of sex workers to areas where there is greater demand for
services. Alcohol use at hot spots contributes to low condom use in commercial sex.
A smaller and more focused rapid assessment study along National Highway 7 reached the
following conclusions280:
drivers basic knowledge of HIV is high and most drivers claim to use condoms for
commercial sex
some sex workers report using drugs, including injecting heroin
sex workers appear to have a high knowledge of HIV but some do not use condoms
people from ethnic minorities are among the those injecting drugs.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
137
Viet Nam was included in the field testing of a toolkit to prevent HIV infection among fishermen
and the communities in which they live in Hai Phong281. This is an industrial zone and the centre
of the epidemic in northern Viet Nam, which attracts migrants from rural areas, traders and
transport workers. Similar studies, all conducted by World Vision, among sex workers in
Cambodia and fishermen in Myanmar have already been described. The steps involved in the
field testing were to form a Task Group, conduct a situation analysis and lead PLA exercises with
the community. These exercises included casual diagrams of HIV infection, 10 seed analysis to
rank community attitudes towards PLHA and identify high risk behaviour, and pie diagrams to
identify who could positively influence behaviour. About 70% of the fishermen were migrant
workers with limited HIV/AIDS knowledge. HIV testing was available free of charge at nearby
government facilities. Interventions included condom social marketing, distribution of IEC
materials and mobile Peer Educators to reach fishermen who were working. The results were:
increased awareness of HIV, the related social and economic relationships and the importance of
condoms; starting the process for community groups to work together; good central and local
political support; and appreciation of the PLA exercises by the community.
The two main sources for this Section are a Master of Public Health Treatise by Colby in 2001282
and a review of MSM in Viet Nam in 2003 by Colby et al283. Men who have sex with men in Viet
Nam are increasing in numbers and visibility in urban areas, but the homosexual lifestyle is not
considered normal or acceptable, even though it is not viewed as a social evil. Because of the
influential writings of a well known Vietnamese Doctor, which are not based on scientific
evidence, "true" homosexuality is believed by many to be very rare, while "fake" homosexuality is
more common, and refers to men lured into trying the homosexual lifestyle who will eventually
return to a heterosexual life.
The limited data available highlights an increased risk for HIV infection for MSM through poor
knowledge of HIV transmission, high numbers of sexual partners, high rates of unsafe sex and
inconsistent condom use. Many MSM also have sex with women, and many are married. In Viet
Nam, media and public health prevention programs have tended to ignore MSM as a risk
population and many MSM therefore believe they are at low risk of infection and less likely to
protect themselves. The HIV prevalence in MSM is not known but one study of 208 MSM in Ho
Chi Minh City attending VCT showed a 5.8% HIV infection rate (study cited by Colby et al283).
Colby's MPH study in 2001 among 219 MSM aged 17-51 years in Ho Chi Minh City found the
following:
66% of the men were homosexual and 31% bisexual
the median number of sexual partners was two in the last month and seven in the last
year
81% had sex, usually anal sex, with non-regular partners
40% used a condom for the last anal sex
condom use with female partners was consistently higher for all types of female
partners
HIV transmission and prevention knowledge was "fairly good"
only 6% rated their HIV risk as high
less than 2% admitted to injecting drug use
30% had ever had a HIV test, with the last test taken an average of 6 months before
the interview and with 70% reporting the test as negative, 5% as positive and 24%
who chose not to respond to the question
those previously tested were significantly more likely to have ever used a condom,
used a condom with last sex and to have used a condom with last anal sex with a
non-regular partner compared with those who were not tested.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
138
There is even less published data on male sex workers in Viet Nam. One study in Hanoi found
most were aged 18-25 years, self-identified as heterosexual and engaged in commercial sex
because it was an easy way to make money. The majority of clients were Vietnamese men and
drug use was perceived to be uncommon (study cited by Colby et al283).
The conclusions of these studies are that MSM in Viet Nam are mostly underground, tend to be
ignored and have no routine surveillance through HSS or BSS. However, they are easy to locate
and willing to interact with outreach workers so that Peer Education, combined with condom and
lubricant distribution, should be possible282.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
139
There is some experience in operating a mobile VCT service for sex workers, IDUs and their
immediate family members which started in December 2003 in Ho Chi Minh City290. The services
provided are peer education, medical examinations, IEC material distribution, screening tests for
HIV, Hepatitis B and C, STI and TB as well as Hepatitis B vaccination and referral to other
services. While these services are provided free of charge, the construction cost of the mobile
clinic was $US 50,000 with ongoing costs of $US 4,500 per month.
Most Key Informants agreed that it was both needed and appropriate for Viet Nam to have
different models of HIV counseling and testing services to increase coverage. Stand-alone,
hospital-based, antenatal clinic-based, reproductive health clinic-based, STI-clinic based,
community-based and mobile clinics were all mentioned as appropriate models for the various
target groups. Models to support stronger linkages with TB services were mentioned by one Key
Informant.
Referral to other HIV/AIDS services is a critical issue for Viet Nam where home based care and
ART services are only just being developed. The Ho Chi Minh City VCT centre mentioned above
noted the frustration experienced by clients in accessing care and support services, mostly due to
high costs and lack of confidentiality. In response the counseling staff developed a
comprehensive list of 60 agencies to which clients could be referred291.
The Key Informant Interview with the representative of the Ho Chi Minh City Provincial AIDS
Committee (PAC) was of interest in understanding what appears to be a successful multi-sectoral
approach to HIV counseling and testing. The PAC is itself multi-sectoral with 21 members and
has strong links to mass organizations and to mass media. The Standing Office manages and
coordinates the HIV/AIDS response. There is strong political support from the city leaders and
funds are provided by both local government and international donors. There are currently 28
VCT sites in HCMC, all of which are moving towards a confidential, rather than anonymous,
approach to testing. The key unit is the Community Based Counseling and Support Centre
(CCSC) at the District level. There are currently 14 of these in the City which provide VCT
services as well as Peer Education, support for PLHA self-help groups and clinical services such
as ART, TB, treatment for Opportunistic Infections and referral to other services. Most of these
services were stated to be free. One CCSC is also designated as a training centre for
counselors, using trainers from city hospitals. Results show increasing numbers of VCT clients
among sex workers, IDUs and pregnant women.
Monitoring and evaluation of VCT services is gradually being strengthened. CDC/LIFE-GAP are
using an EPI-Info based computerized data management system in the VCT sites they
support287.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
140
7.12.5 National Policies and Guidelines and key resource documents for
HIV counseling and testing in Viet Nam
It was unclear whether there are official government Policies and Guidelines specific for VCT,
other than references made in the National Strategic Plans (see Section 7.5.1). However, CDC
LIFE-GAP and FHI have many relevant Vietnamese-language resources which are approved for
use by government partners. These include the following detailed curricula:
VCT Participants Manual
VCT Training Manual
VCT Training of Trainers (TOT) Manual.
CDC LIFE-GAP also have Procedures, Training Curricula, TOT curricula, Quality Assurance
tools, data collection tools and integrated data management for community outreach, outpatient
HIV care, PMTCT and Peer Education for high risk groups.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
141
Key Informants confirmed that the current VCT program in Viet Nam uses a variety of serological
tests, including rapid tests for screening. However, confirmation requires three further tests using
different methods and can only be done at approved government laboratories, resulting in delays
of up to 7 days for test results to be available.
Key Informants were asked about the age of consent for HIV testing. There appears to be no
official age of consent, but FHI stated that they will test clients aged 16 years who are able to give
written informed consent. The proposed new law may help to clarify this matter as well as legal
issues related to partner disclosure.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
142
There was an overall lack of laboratory staff, who had other tasks in addition to HIV
testing. The education level of lab staff was not high, with only half having graduated
from technical or high schools
At the national level, laboratory staff were well trained and experienced in more
complicated testing such as ELISA and Western Blot methods
Organisational restructuring resulted in staff trained in HIV testing being moved to
other roles.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
143
there is a need to develop a more effective system for a person testing HIV positive
to obtain treatment. The current system requires the client to be registered and retested by the treatment provider to confirm HIV status before starting treatment
concerns about the safety of health workers need to be addressed
Centre
Location
Aug 1994
MSI Nghe An
Nov 1997
MSI Ha Tinh
Jun 1999
37 Dong Thap Muoi street, Nam Dinh city (handed back to local
project partner in 2002)
Jun 1999
MSI HCM 01
101A Hoang Van Thu, Ward 8, Phu Nhuan District, Ho Chi Minh City
(handed back to local project partner in February 2004)
Oct 1999
26A Quang Trung, Thai Binh township, Thai Binh province (handed
back to provincial project partner in 2004).
Jan 2000
MSI Hue
29 Hai Ba Trung, Hue city (handed back to local project partner end of
2002)
Oct 2000
MSI Hanoi 01
5 Nguyen Quy Duc, Thanh Xuan District, Hanoi (handed back to local
project partner end of 2002)
Jul 2001
MSI HCM 02
Apr 2005
MSI Ha Noi
Oct 2005
30/12 Moi street, Nhi Dong quarter, Di An town, Binh Duong province
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
144
MSIVN also implements specific projects. The following Table shows the experience and
technical expertise of MSIVN in working with a diverse range of donors.
Year
Projects
Donors
Duration
1989 Provide technical assistance to the district health centers of Hai Phong and
Quang Ninh provinces to improve reproductive health care quality
4 years
1993 Preventive maternal and child health and family planning project for lowincome women and their families, including community health volunteer
training in Nghe An Province
European Commission
4 years
1996 Address the unmet needs of women and men in family planning and
reproductive health through establishment of three static clinics and mobile
teams in the provinces of Ha Tinh, Nam Dinh and Thai Binh
European Commission
4 years
1998 Adolescent reproductive health in Thua Thien Hue (Project No. RAS/98/P21)
and Ha Noi (Project No. RAS/98/P22) under the Reproductive Health
Initiative in Asia of EU/UNFPA
4 years
1998 Community based family planning and reproductive health clinic in Ho Chi
Minh City (Project No. JFS 1492)
4 years
2000 Family Planning and Reproductive Health Serving Women and their Families
with Quality, Affordable Services through Innovative Mini-Clinics and
Outreach Teams in the Urban and Peri-urban Areas of Ho Chi Minh City
4 years
2002 Project to provide mobile family planning & reproductive health services to
poor women in remote areas of Nghe An, Ha Tinh & Thai Binh provinces
2 years
2003 Project to pilot the integration of HIV Voluntary and Confidential Counselling
and Screening Test into existing Marie Stopes clinics in Vietnam
States of Jersey
10 months
2003 Project to conduct needs assessment and design interventions to meet the
unmet needs on information and services of FP/ RH of migrant workers in
the supplier factories of Adidas Salomon in Ho Chi Minh city
6 months
2003 Project to continue the provision of VCCT at Marie Stopes clinics in Vietnam
with HIV/AIDS community prevention education with a focus on vulnerable
groups: young students, commercial sex workers and migrant workers
AusAID
11 months
33 months
2004 Project to provide mobile family planning and reproductive health services to
poor women of two isolated island communes of Thanh An and Tam Thon
Hiep, Can Gio district, Ho Chi Minh city
1 year
2004 Build technical capacity for the public service providers of the Maternal and
Child Health Care/Family Planning network in Ho Chi Minh City in providing
quality FP/RH services
9 months
2004 Improve maternal and child health through the development of capacity of
Traditional Birth Attendants in Vietnams northern province of Lao Cai
NZAID
3 years
2005 Improve sexual and reproductive health amongst the workers of supplier
factories of Adidas in Ho Chi Minh City and Binh Duong Province
Adidas-Salomon Asia
Regional Office
4 years
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
145
World Bank
1 year
Atlantic Philanthropies
3 years
The Marie Stopes Clinics in Viet Nam began providing VCT services in 2003. Between
December 2003 and April 2005, MSIVN provided VCT services to 2,632 clients (62% of whom
were women), all of whom received pre-test counseling. A high proportion (86% or 2,257 clients)
agreed to have a HIV test and 85.6% of these clients returned for the test results. Technical and
general workers comprised 18.3% of the VCT clients, government officials 20%, housewives
and/or farmers 13%, small business people 11%, sex workers 10% and students 6%xiv. The ECfunded Mekong VCT Project provides MSIVN with the opportunity to strengthen and expand
these current VCT services. A detailed Site Assessment for four of the five MSIVN Clinics is
planned as part of this expansion phase. Separate reports for these Site Assessments will be
prepared over the 12 months January to December 2005.
xiv
The promotion of VCT services through MSIVN Clinics and outreach should focus on
raising awareness of the benefits of knowing one's HIV status, together with advocacy
efforts to increase available post-test services, including treatment. MSIVN should
strengthen linkages with mass organizations for these promotion activities.
MSIVN should review all current check-lists or similar tools used by clinical staff in
providing current SRH services and add in appropriate prompts or questions to ask all
clients if they are interested in accessing the MSIVN VCT services. Similarly, all tools
used in providing current VCT services should be reviewed with the addition of
appropriate prompts to ask clients about any needs they may have for family planning/
contraceptive services, antenatal services and STI management. This will support
effective and integrated "cross-promotion" of MSIVN SRH services.
Couple's counseling appears to be acceptable in the current context in Viet Nam. MSIVN
should explore this possibility. This could be integrated with the current MSIVN approach
to encourage greater involvement of men in sexual and reproductive health, in particular,
the male partners of female clients who receive STI, antenatal care and family planning
services at MSIVN Clinics. This should be done both through the Clinic-based services
and community outreach activities. Couple's counseling will include pre-marriage
counseling and testing as well as services for those already married.
MSIVN, as a provider of quality sexual and reproductive health services for women,
should develop culturally appropriate ways to encourage disclosure of results to the male
partners of woman clients and to support women who fear or experience gender-based
violence in the context of wanting or having a HIV test.
Given the relatively high levels of stigma and discrimination related to HIV/AIDS in Viet
Nam, MSIVN will need to give careful consideration to the involvement of PLHA as
community outreach workers to promote VCT services and as providers of group or
individual pre-test counseling, and possibly post-test counseling.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
146
Youth are a key target group for the Mekong VCT project. MSIVN already has
considerable experience in providing youth-friendly sexual and reproductive health
services, and the Mekong VCT project resources will allow expansion of these services,
with increased promotion of VCT services.
MSIVN already have one Clinic reaching large numbers of migrant workers. Again, the
Mekong VCT project resources will allow increased promotion of VCT to this important
population group.
The Mekong VCT project provides MSIVN with an opportunity to actively participate in
supporting the national PMTCT program. Clients receiving antenatal services can
receive pre-test counseling and a screening test, with those testing positive being
referred for confirmatory testing and, if positive, referred to government PMTCT services.
Depending on available resources, MSIVN may also have the opportunity to support
follow-up and referral to other HIV/AIDS services for mothers who are HIV positive.
MSIVN can make a significant contribution to the strengthening of all other referral
linkages for clients who test positive to HIV/AIDS. Particular attention should be given to
increased collaboration with TB screening programs. This can be done at the facility/
district level, but also at the Provincial and national level. Increased participation in
national level HIV/AIDS networks, such as the VCT Working Group coordinated by
UNAIDS, will provide opportunities to learn from the experiences of others and to share
MSIVN experiences in these areas.
MSIVN can effectively use the Mekong VCT project resources to develop a high quality
VCT service. This will include Monitoring and Evaluation, Quality Assurance and Quality
Control mechanisms which can support national initiatives in these areas. In addition,
MSIVN should participate in, and actively support, counselor networks comprising both
public and private sector VCT counselors. Stress-management skills for counselors
should be shared within these networks.
MSIVN needs to develop clear guidelines for any fee for HIV counseling and testing. Key
Informants were divided on the issue of whether VCT should be free or clients should pay
a fee. The government may also regulate for testing to be provided free. If a fee is
charged for some clients, based on ability to pay, MSIVN will need to develop a practical
and equitable working definition to identify clients for whom HIV counseling and testing
would be free or subsidised. If, for any reason, a fee is not charged for HIV counseling
and testing, MSIVN should develop a sustainability strategy from the start of this project,
with the goal of being able to continue to provide VCT services after current donor
funding ends. This will include the identification of any other available resources.
MSIVN should explore any role in reaching female IDUs and the female partners of male
IDUs. Female sex workers who also inject drugs are a very important population group
that may also be reached by MSIVN services. Counselors may require additional
counseling skill training if such groups are offered VCT services.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
147
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
148
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
149
9. REFERENCES
GLOBAL AND REGIONAL
1
UNAIDS. 2004 Report on the global AIDS epidemic, 4th global report; June 2004.
UNAIDS, AIDS Epidemic Update; December 2005 available from www.who.int/hiv/epi-update2005_en.pdf
3
World Health Organization. Coverage of selected health services for HIV/AIDS prevention and care in
less developed countries in 2001; 2002.
4
The POLICY Project. Coverage of selected services for HIV/AIDS prevention and care in low and
middle income countries in 2003; June 2004.
5
United Nations General Assembly. Progress towards implementation of the declaration of Commitment
on HIV/AIDS. Report of the Secretary General, 58th session, 25 July 2003
6
World Health Organization. Monitoring and Evaluation Toolkit: HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria;
June 2004.
7
World Health Organization, Department of HIV/AID. National AIDS Programmes: a guide to
indicators for monitoring and evaluating national HIV/AIDS prevention programmes for young people:
2004.
8
World Health Organization, Department of Gender and Women's Health. Integrating gender into
HIV/AIDS programmes: a review paper; 2003.
9
UNAIDS, UNFPA, UNIFEM (Joint publication). Women and HIV/AIDS: confronting the crisis; 2004.
10
The Global Coalition on Women and AIDS. Violence against women and HIV/AIDS: Critical
intersections. Intimate partner violence and HIV/AIDS. Information Bulletin Series, No.1. World Health
Organization; 2004.
11
The Global Coalition on Women and AIDS. Violence against women and HIV/AIDS: Critical
intersections Sexual violence in conflict settings and the risk of HIV. Information Bulletin Series, No.2.
World Health Organization; 2004.
12
Patterson D, London L. International law, human rights and HIV/AIDS. Bulletin of the World Health
Organization; 2002;80(12): 964-969.
13
Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights and UNAIDS. HIV/AIDS and
Human Rights: international guidelines. Second International Consultation on HIV/AIDS and Human
Rights, Geneva, 23-25 September 1996, United Nations; 1998.
14
Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights and UNAIDS. HIV/AIDS and
Human Rights: international guidelines. Revised Guideline 6- access to prevention, treatment, care and
support. United Nations; August 2002.
15
Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Committee on the Rights of the
Child. General Comment No. 3 (2003). HIV/AIDS and the rights of the child. United Nations, 32nd
session, 13-31 January 2003: available from
http://www.unhchr.ch/tbs/doc.nsf/(symbol)/CRC.GC.2003.3.En?OpenDocument
16
Ogden J, Nyblade L. Common at Its Core: HIV-related Stigma across contexts. International Center for
Research on Women; 2005.
17
Global HIV Prevention Working Group. Access to HIV Prevention: closing the gap, May 2003 on CDROM: Women, Children and HIV: resources for prevention and treatment, 3rd Ed, Centre for HIV
Information, University of California San Francisco.; July 2004.
18
WHO, UNAIDS, UNFPA. Position Statement on Condoms and HIV Prevention; July 2004.
19
Boonstra H. The Role of Reproductive Health Providers in Preventing HIV. Issues in Brief. The Alan
Guttmacher Institute, UNAIDS; 2004.
20
World Health Organization. Prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission of HIV: Generic Training
Package-Training Programme and Course Director Guide; 2004.
21
World Health Organization, Regional Office for the Western Pacific. HIV/AIDS Care and Treatment,
Guide for Implementation; December 2004.
22
World Health Organization. Community home-based care in resource limited settings: a framework for
action; 2002.
23
UNICEF, UNAIDS, WHO, MSF. Sources and prices of selected medicines and diagnostics for people
living with HIV/AIDS; June 2003.
2
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
150
24
UNAIDS Inter-Agency Task Team on Young People. At the crossroads: accelerating youth access to
HIV/AIDS interventions; 2004.
25
Aggleton P, Chase E, Rivers K. HIV/AIDS prevention and care among especially vulnerable young
people: a framework for action. Thomas Coram Research Unit, Institute of Education, University of
London; April 2004 available from: http://www.who.int/hiv/pub/prev_care/en/evypframework2004.pdf
26
UNICEF, UNAIDS, WHO. Young People and HIV/AIDS: opportunity in crisis; July 2002.
27
World Health Organization. Protecting young people from HIV and AIDS: the role of health services;
2004.
28
Rivers K, Aggleton P. Working with young men to promote sexual and reproductive health. Thomas
Coram Research Unit, Institute of Education, London; January 2002.
29
Malcolm A, Aggleton P. Rapid assessment and response: Adaptation guide for work with especially
vulnerable young people. Thomas Coram Research Unit, Institute of Education, London and World
Health Organization; September 2004.
30
Rodriguez MP, Hayes R. Reducing HIV prevalence among young people: a review of the UNGASS
prevalence goal and how it should be monitored. London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine,
London, UK; October 2002 on CD-ROM World Health Organization HIV/AIDS Key Documentation
and Strategic Information Products, May 2004.
31
World Health Organization. Policy and programming guide for HIV/AIDS prevention and care among
injecting drug users; 2005 available from:
http://www.who.int/diagnostics_laboratory/procurement/en/hiv_bulk_flyer_EN.pdf
32
World Health Organization. Evidence for Action: effectiveness of community-based outreach in
preventing HIV/AIDS among injecting drug users; 2004.
33
WHO, UNAIDS, UNODC. Policy Brief: reduction of HIV transmission through outreach; 2004:
available from http://www.who.int/hiv/pub/advocacy/en/throughoutreachen.pdf
34
World Health Organization. Training Guide for HIV prevention outreach to injecting drug users:
workshop manual; 2003.
35
UNAIDS, WHO. Consultation on STD interventions for preventing HIV: what is the evidence? UNAIDS
Best Practice Collection; May 2000.
36
Hargreaves N, Scano F. Guidelines for implementing collaborative TB and HIV programme activities.
Stop TB Partnership, Working Group on TB/HIV, World Health Organization; 2003.
37
World Health Organization, Stop TB Department and Department of HIV/AIDS. Strategic Framework to
decrease the burden of TB/HIV; 2002.
38
World Health Organization, Stop TB Department and Department of HIV/AIDS. Interim Policy on
Collaborative TB/HIV Activities; 2004.
39
World Health Organization, Stop TB Department and Department of HIV/AIDS. A guide to monitoring
and evaluation for collaborative TB/HIV activities, Field Test Version; 2004.
40
World Health Organization. Scaling-up HIV counseling and testing services: a toolkit for programme
managers; 2005.
41
UNAIDS and WHO. Policy Statement on HIV Testing; June 2004 available from:
http://www.unaids.org/Unaids/EN/In+focus/Topic+areas/Counselling_voluntary+counselling+and+testing.asp
42
Family Health International. VCT Toolkit: Voluntary Counseling and Testing for HIV: a strategic
framework; September 2003.
43
McCauley AP. Equitable access to HIV counseling and testing for youth in developing countries: a
review of current practice. Horizons Report. Washington, DC: Population Council; 2004.
44
Maman S, Medley A. Gender Dimensions of HIV. Status Disclosure to Sexual partners: rates, barriers
and Outcomes. A Review Paper. World Health Organization; 2004: available from
www.who.int/gender/documents/en/
45
Oberzaucher N, Baggaley R. HIV Voluntary Counselling and Testing: a gateway to prevention and care.
UNAIDS Case Study, June 2002.
46
World Health Organization. HIV/AIDS Training Materials. Voluntary Counselling and Testing: Manual
for Training of Trainers; updated 6 July 2005, available from:
http://w3.whosea.org/en/Section10/Section18/Section1562.htm
47
Family Health International. VCT Toolkit: A Guide to establishing voluntary counseling and testing
services for HIV; July 2002.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
151
48
Family Health International. VCT Toolkit: HIV Voluntary Counseling and Testing: skills training
curriculum, Facilitator's Guide; January 2005.
49
Family Health International. VCT Toolkit: HIV Voluntary Counseling and Testing: skills training
curriculum, Participant's Manual; January 2005.
50
Boswell D., Baggaley R.. VCT Toolkit: Voluntary Counseling and Testing and Young People: a
summary overview, Family Health International; December 2002.
51
Family Health International. VCT Toolkit: Trainer's Manual: Counseling Supervision and Training;
August 2005.
52
Walkowiak H, Gabra M. Commodity Management in VCT Programs: a planning guide. Management
Sciences for Health, Family Health International; 6 June 2002 on CD-ROM: Women, Children and HIV:
resources for prevention and treatment, 3rd Ed, Centre for HIV Information, University of California San
Francisco; July 2004. Also available from www.fhi.org
53
Family Health International. VCT Toolkit: HIV Voluntary Counseling and Testing: A reference guide for
Counselors and Trainers; January 2004.
54
Fischer S, Reynolds H, Yacobson I, Barnett B, Schueller J. HIV Counselling and Testing for Youth: a
manual for providers. Family Health International; 2005 available from: www.fhi.org.
55
UNAIDS Global Reference Group on HIV/AIDS and Human Rights. Issue Paper: Current Debates on
HIV Counseling and testing, 2nd meeting; 25-27 August 2003 available from:
http://www.unaids.org/Unaids/EN/In+focus/Topic+areas/Counselling_voluntary+counselling+and+testing.asp
56
UNAIDS Global Reference Group on HIV/AIDS and Human Rights. Issue Paper: Strategies for
involvement of civil society in HIV testing within context of "3 by 5": Focus on NGOs. 3rd meeting, 2830 January 2004 available from
http://www.unaids.org/Unaids/EN/In+focus/Topic+areas/Human+rights,+ethics,+and+law.asp
57
World Health Organization. Increasing access to HIV counseling and testing: report of a WHO
consultation, 19-21 November 2002, Geneva, Switzerland; 2002 available from
http://www.who.int/hiv/pub/vct/pub36/en/index.html
58
World Health Organization. The Right to Know: new approaches to HIV counseling and testing; 2003
available from: http://www.who.int/hiv/pub/vct/pub34/en/index.html
59
UNFPA. New guidelines for including HIV counseling and testing in sexual and reproductive health
programmes; 17 February 2004 available from: www.unfpa.org/
60
International HIV/AIDS Alliance, Asia and Eastern Europe Team. Voluntary Counselling and Testing:
emerging approaches from Asia and Eastern Europe; April 2004.
61
USAID Regional Development Mission/Asia. HIV/AIDS Strategic Plan for the Greater Mekong Region,
FY 2003-2006 (Draft); 18 February 2004.
62
International Planned Parenthood Federation, South Asia Regional Office and UNFPA. Integrating HIV
voluntary counseling and testing services into reproductive health settings- stepwise guide for
programme planners, managers and service providers; 2004.
63
World Health Organization. Rapid HIV tests: guidelines for use in HIV testing and counseling services in
resource-constrained settings; 2004.
64
John Snow, Inc./Deliver. HIV Test Kit Selection: operational considerations for VCT and PMTCT
services, John Snow Inc. on CD-ROM: Women, Children and HIV: resources for prevention and
treatment, 3rd Ed, Centre for HIV Information, University of California San Francisco; July 2004.
65
World Health Organization. HIV Assays: operational characteristics. Report 14/ Simple/rapid tests; 2004.
66
Rapid Diagnostics website; 2005 available at: www.rapid-diagnostics.org/rti-hiv-com.htm
67
John Snow, Inc./DELIVER. Guide for Quantifying HIV Test Kits. Arlington, Va.; 2003 on CD-ROM
HIV/AIDS Prevention, Care and Treatment resources 2004 for use in developing countries, Family
Health International, 2004.
68
World Health Organization. WHO HIV Test Kit- bulk procurement scheme; 2002 available from:
http://www.who.int/diagnostics_laboratory/procurement/en/hiv_bulk_flyer_EN.pdf
69
Kamenga C, Coates T, Rehle T. Evaluating Programs for HIV/AIDS Prevention and Care in Developing
Countries, Chapter 6II Operational Strategies for Evaluating Intervention Strategies. Evaluating
Voluntary HIV counseling and testing, Family Health International; 2005, available from:
http://www.fhi.org/en/HIVAIDS/pub/Archive/evalchap/evalchap6.htm
70
UNAIDS. Tools for Evaluating HIV voluntary counseling and testing; May 2000.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
152
71
United Nations Development Programme. Human Development Report 2005: available from
www.hdr.undp.org
72
The World Bank, Human Development Network. Addressing HIV/AIDS in East Asia and the Pacific.
Health, Nutrition and Population Series; 2004.
73
Ruxrungtham K, Brown T, Phanuphak P. HIV/AIDS in Asia. The Lancet 2004:364:69-82.
74
Monitoring the AIDS Pandemic (MAP). AIDS in Asia: face the facts: a comprehensive analysis of the
AIDS epidemics in Asia; MAP Report; 2004 available from: www.fhi.org
75
Sarkar S. Global HIV/AIDS Situation and Asia Pacific Opportunities: investing to avert a crisis
[Powerpoint]. HIV/TB Conference for Mekong Region Countries, Ho Chi Minh City, Viet Nam;
October 2004.
76
The POLICY Project. HIV/AIDS in the Mekong Region: Cambodia, Lao PDR, Thailand and Viet Nam:
current situation, future projections, socioeconomic impacts and recommendations; June 2003.
77
World Health Organization. HIV/AIDS in Asia and the Pacific Region 2003; 2004.
78
World Health Organization, Regional Office for South-East Asia. HIV/AIDS Strategic Framework for
WHO South-East Asia Region 2002-2006; November 2002.
79
Asian Development Bank. Development, poverty and HIV/AIDS: ADB's strategic response to a growing
epidemic: April 2005 available from www.adb.org/Documents/Others/in90-05.pdf
80
UNAIDS, Asia Development Bank. Costing Guidelines for HIV/AIDS Intervention Strategies; February
2004.
81
CARE International. HIV/AIDS Strategy, Asia Region; 2003.
82
UNFPA. Asia and the Pacific: a region in transition; 2002.
83
OHCHR, Asia-Pacific Regional office, UNAIDS South-East Asia Pacific Intercountry Team.
Recommendations on integrating human rights into HIV/AIDS responses in the Asia-Pacific Region;
June 2004.
84
Task Force on Drug Use and HIV Vulnerability. Drug Use and HIV Vulnerability: policy research study
in Asia. UNAIDS, UNODCCP; October 2000 available from: www.unaids.org/
85
Regional Task Force on Drug Use and HIV Vulnerability. Preventing HIV/AIDS among drug users: case
studies from Asia. UNAIDS, Asian Harm Reduction Network, UNODC, not dated.
86
The Centre for Harm Reduction, Macfarlane Burnet Centre for Medical Research and Asian Harm
Reduction Network. Manual for Reducing Drug-Related Harm in Asia, 2nd Edition; 2003 available
from: www.fhi.org/en/HIVAIDS/pub/guide/HarmReductionManual.htm
87
Reid G, Costigan G. Revisiting 'The Hidden Epidemic': a situation assessment of drug use in Asia in the
context of HIV/AIDS. The Centre for Harm Reduction, The Burnet Institute, Australia; January 2002.
CAMBODIA
88
UNAIDS Cambodia. Country Profile: An Overview of the HIV/AIDS/STI situation and the national
response in Cambodia, 5th Edition; December 2004.
89
National AIDS Authority. National Strategic Plan for a Comprehensive and Multisectoral Response to
HIV/AIDS 2006-2010; November 2005.
90
UNICEF. Scaling up Voluntary Counseling and Testing Services: lessons learned from Cambodia; draft
dated October 2005.
91
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs, Surveillance Unit. HIV Sentinel Surveillance
(HSS) 2003: results, trends and estimates [Powerpoint], Sunway Hotel, 3 December 2004.
92
UNAIDS, UNICEF, WHO. Epidemiological Fact Sheets on HIV/AIDS and Sexually Transmitted
Infections: Cambodia 2004 update, available from: http://www.who.int/hiv
93
Saphonn V. HIV incidence among sentinel surveillance groups in Cambodia 1999-2002 [Powerpoint].
MICASA Hotel, Phnom Penh, 11 May 2004.
94
Heng S. BSS 2003: Sexual behaviour among sentinel groups, Cambodia. BSS Trends 1997-2003, Centre
for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STD; 24 March 2004. Powerpoint presentation available from
www.nchads.org
95
Gorbach PM, Heng S, Saphonn V, Mean CV, Seng SW, Hor BL. Behavioral Sentinel Surveillance
(BSS)V: Sexual behavior among urban sentinel groups, Cambodia 2001, National Centre for HIV/AIDS,
Dermatology and STD; August 2003 available from: www.nchads.org
96
Heng S, Mun P, Hor BL, Seng SW, Gorbach PM. Cambodian Household Male Survey (BSSIV 2000)
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and Sexually Transmitted Diseases; 9 March 2002.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
153
97
Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport, Department of Pedagogical Research. Cambodia National
Youth Risk Behaviour Survey, Summary Report; 2004.
98
Population Services International. Knowledge, attitudes and behaviour regarding HIV/AIDS in
Cambodia: results of a 2003 national survey; May 2004.
99
Yocum LF. Media, HIV and AIDS in Cambodia: Knowledge, attitudes and self-reported behaviour,
Baseline Results, July 2003. [Powerpoint presentation 20 July 2004].
100
National Institute of Statistics, Ministry of Planning, Directorate General for Health, Ministry of Health.
Cambodia Demographic and Health Survey 2000. ORC Macro Calverton, Maryland, USA and
Kingdom of Cambodia; June 2001.
101
Hor BL, Seng SW, Ly PS, Seng S, Sar B, Monchy D et al. Cambodia STI Prevalence Survey, National
Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs, Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Cambodia; 2001
available from www.nchads.org
102
Ministry of Planning, Kingdom of Cambodia. Cambodia Human Development Report: societal aspects
of the HIV/AIDS Epidemic in Cambodia, Progress Report; 2001 available from:
http://www.un.org.kh/undp/publications/nhdr/2001_English.pdf
103
Alkenbrack S, Ty C, Forsythe S. The social and economic impact of HIV/AIDS on families with
adolescents and children in Cambodia, The POLICY Project; 2004.
104
John K, Sainsbury C. The impact of HIV/AIDS on older people in Cambodia, Help Age International:
2003.
105
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs and National AIDS Authority. HIV/AIDS in the
Kingdom of Cambodia: background, projects, impact and interventions; December 2001.
106
Phan H, Patterson L. "Men are gold, women are cloth": a report on the potential for HIV/AIDS spread in
Cambodia and implications for HIV/AIDS education. CARE International in Cambodia; 1994.
107
Tarr CM, Aggleton P. Young people and HIV in Cambodia: meanings, contexts and sexual cultures.
AIDS Care 1999;11:3:375-384.
108
Population Services International, Cambodia. Sweetheart relationships in Cambodia: Love, sex and
condoms in the time of HIV; December 2002.
109
National AIDS Authority. National Strategic Plan for a Comprehensive and Multi-sectoral Response to
HIV/AIDS 2001-2005; December 2001.
110
National AIDS Authority. A Situation and Response Analysis of the HIV/AIDS epidemic in Cambodia;
2001.
111
Forsythe S. Resource requirements for Cambodia's 2001-2005 HIV/AIDS National Strategic Plan. The
POLICY Project; September 2002.
112
Ministry of Planning. Cambodia Millennium Development Goals report, Kingdom of Cambodia;
November 2003.
113
Council for Social Development. National Poverty Reduction Strategy 2003-2005, Kingdom of
Cambodia; December 2002.
114
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STD. Strategic Plan for HIV/AIDS and STI
Prevention and Care in Cambodia 2001-2005, Ministry of Health; October 2000 available from:
www.racha.org.kh/
115
Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport, School Health Department. Strengthening HIV/AIDS
prevention education for secondary schools in Cambodia: Final Evaluation Report, Kingdom of
Cambodia; 1 July 2002.
116
Tan S. Mainstreaming HIV Prevention in the Military: a case study from Cambodia. UNDP South East
Asia HIV and Development Programme; May 2004 available from: www.hiv-development.org
117
Ministry of Health. Health and HIV/AIDS Chapter in the Socio-Economic Development Plan (SEDP2);
2003 available from: http://rc.racha.org.kh/docDetails.asp?resourceID=324&categoryID=11
118
Ministry of Planning. Towards a population and development strategy for Cambodia, Kingdom of
Cambodia; July 2002.
119
Ministry of Planning. National Population Policy of Cambodia: first draft, 3 June 2003, Kingdom of
Cambodia; 2003.
120
Ministry of Women's and Veterans' Affairs. Policy on Women, the Girl Child and STI/KIV/AIDS,
Kingdom of Cambodia; July 2003.
121
USAID. Cambodia HIV/AIDS Strategic Plan 2002-2005, USAID; March 2004 available from:
www.racha.org.kh/
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
154
122
Cambodia Country Coordinating Committee. Country Coordinated Proposal for The Global Fund for
HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria, Summary of Proposal, Round 1; 2001 available from:
http://www.theglobalfund.org/search/docs/1CAMH_341_38_summary.pdf
123
Cambodia Country Coordinating Committee. Country Coordinated Proposal for The Global Fund for
HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria, Full Proposal, Round 2; 2002 available from:
http://www.theglobalfund.org/search/docs/2CAMH_32_0_full.pdf
124
Cambodia Country Coordinating Committee. Country Coordinated Proposal for The Global Fund for
HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria,, Summary of Proposal, Round 4; 2004 available from:
http://www.theglobalfund.org/search/docs/4CAMH_775_0_summary.pdf
125
Pak P. Strategic Plan 2004-2008, Khmer HIV/AIDS NGO Alliance (KHANA); 2004.
126
World Vision Cambodia. Hope and Dignity: HIV/AIDS Strategic Plan 2004-2006; 2004.
127
Paxton S. Steps to Empowerment: challenges to the Greater Involvement of People Living with HIV in
the response to AIDS in Cambodia, The POLICY Project; 2005.
128
Pichara L, Kim AO. Media Review: Analysis of reporting on HIV/AIDS in Cambodia: Executive
Summary, The POLICY Project; November 2003.
129
Pillai G, Donaldson B, Sok K. A Directory of Organisations Implementing or Supporting HIV/AIDS
Activities in Cambodia and A Compilation of Abstracts submitted to the XV International AIDS
Conference, July 11-16. Prepared for the Royal Government of Cambodia; July 2004.
130
Royal Government of Cambodia, Law on the Prevention and Control of HIV/AIDS; 26 July 2002,
available from: http://www.ilo.org/public/english/protection/trav/aids/laws/cambodia1.pdf
131
National AIDS Authority. Implementing Guidelines for the Law on the Prevention and Control of
HIV/AIDS; 2005.
132
Watchirs D, Ward C. Cambodian HIV/AIDS and Human Rights Legislative Audit, The POLICY
Project/ USAID; December 2003.
133
Ward C. HIV/AIDS and Human Rights in Cambodia a situation report, The POLICY Project; June
2005.
134
UNAIDS Cambodia, National AIDS Authority. HIV/AIDS and Human Rights in Asia-Pacific Expert
Meeting 23-24 March 2004, Bangkok (HIV/AIDS and Human Rights in Cambodia), The POLICY
Project; 2004.
135
National AIDS Authority. National Workshop on National Strategic Plan for HIV/AIDS Response
review: Technical Working Groups Reports; April 2005.
136
Cambodian Health and Human Rights Alliance, Cambodian Researchers for Development. The
assessment of patient rights within the context of HIV testing in Cambodia; September 2001.
137
UNIFEM, WB, ADB, UNDP and DFID/UK. A Fair Share for Women: Cambodia Gender Assessment,
Phnom Penh, Cambodia; 2004 available from:
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTCAMBODIA/Resources
138
Ministry of Health, Department of Planning and Health Information. Health Coverage Plan,, Kingdom
of Cambodia; June 2002.
139
Fabricant S. Cost Analysis of Essential Health Services in Cambodia, Ministry of Health/WHO Health
Sector Reform Phase III Project, Final Report; 2002, available from: www.racha.org.kh/
140
Ministry of Health. Health Sector Strategic Plan 2003-2007, Kingdom of Cambodia, Summary; August
2002 available from: www.racha.org.kh/
141
Ministry of Health, Department of Planning and Health Information. Action Plan 2004-2007 for
implementation of the RGC's [Royal Government of Cambodia] rectangular strategy in the 3rd
Legislature of the National Assembly, unofficial translation; October 2004.
142
Ministry of Health. National Policy on Behaviour Change Communication, Kingdom of Cambodia;
2004.
143
Akachi Y. Situational Analysis: Pharmaceutical Sector in Cambodia, Draft, Ministry of Health,
Kingdom of Cambodia, available from www.racha.org.kh/
144
Chamroeun K. Birth Spacing in Cambodia. Discussion Paper #2, National Population Development
Policy Unit, Council of Ministers, Phnom Penh; April 2002 available from:
http://www.un.org.kh/unfpa/about/documents/birthspacing2.pdf
145
Walston N. Country Analysis of Family Planning and HIV/AIDS Programs: Cambodia, The POLICY
Project; February 2005.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
155
146
Ministry of Planning. Fertility and family planning in Cambodia, Kingdom of Cambodia; December
2002.
147
Eng H, Chhun L, Stoeckel J, Sturgis R. Birth Spacing in Cambodia: History, current status and future
prospects, RACHA Studies No.18; January 2003.
148
Lester F. Abortion in Cambodia: an overview of the current situation, UC Berkeley/UC San Francisco
Joint Medical program and UC Berkeley School of Public Health, MPH Report; August 2002 available
from: http://www.un.org.kh/unfpa/about/documents/abortion.doc
149
UNAIDS. Actions and Opportunities: Cambodia's response to HIV/AIDS; December 2001.
150
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STD. Guidelines for Implementation of Outreach and
Peer Education Programme in the Community, First Ed., Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Cambodia;
2003.
151
Butler R. The availability of social marketed contraceptives through the private sector: distribution
survey 2002. Population Service International/Cambodia; January 2004.
152
O'Reilly K, Jana S, Tia P, Ly PS, Ngin L, Sau K, Kien SP, Sethi G. The review of the 100% condom
use program in Cambodia, National AIDS Authority, National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and
STD and UNAIDS; June 2-16, 2003.
153
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs. National Policy on Preventing Mother-toChild Transmission of HIV, Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Cambodia; 2001.
154
Carlson JM. A practical approach to PMTCT in rural Cambodia (RACHA Studies #20); November
2002.
155
Health Messenger. HIV/AIDS Voluntary, Confidential, Counselling and Testing and Prevention of
Mother To Child Transmission, Issue 24; September 2005.
156
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs. Continuum of Care for People Living with
HIV/AIDS. Operational framework, First Ed., Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Cambodia; April 2003.
157
McPherson R. Implementing a Continuum of Care for PLHA including ART in Moung Russey,
Cambodia, National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs and Family Health International;
July 2004.
158
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STD. National Guidelines on Home and Community
Care for People Living with HIV/AIDS. Ministry of Health, Cambodia, World Health Organization;
January 2000.
159
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs. National Guidelines for the use of
Antiretroviral Therapy in Adults and Adolescents. Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Cambodia;
November 2003.
160
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs. National Guidelines for Prophylaxis of
Opportunistic Infections in People Living with HIV/AIDS, Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Cambodia;
November 2003.
161
Ministry of Health. Essential Drug List, Kingdom of Cambodia; 18 February 2002 available from:
www.racha.org.kh/
162
WHO, UNAIDS, USAID, CDC, World Bank. Coverage of Essential HIV/AIDS services in Cambodia
[draft], October 2003.
163
Dhaliwal M, Ellman T. Improving access to anti-retroviral treatment in Cambodia, International
HIV/AIDS Alliance and Khmer HIV/AIDS NGO Alliance (KHANA); September 2003 available from:
hivinsite.ucsf.edu/global?page=cr08-cb-00
164
National Centre for Tuberculosis and Leprosy Control (CENAT), Ministry of Health. National Health
Policies and Strategies for TB Control in the Kingdom of Cambodia 2001-2005; July 2001.
165
Wilkinson D. Linking HIV and TB- underlying issues to consider when scaling up integration of HIV
and TB services in Cambodia. International HIV/AIDS Alliance; December 2001.
166
National Centre for Tuberculosis and Leprosy Control (CENAT), Ministry of Health and Japanese
International Cooperation Agency. 9th National Annual TB Conference; 18-19 March 2004.
167
Hor BL, Heng S, Tobi S, Saphonn V, Ly PS, Seng SW, Mean CV. Report on HIV Sentinel Surveillance
in Cambodia 2002, Ministry of Health, National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STD; July
2004 available from: www.nchads.org
168
Kimerling ME, Schuchter J, Chanthol E, Kunthy T, Stuer F, Glaziou P, Ee O. Prevalence of Pulmonary
Tuberculosis among HIV infected persons in a home care program in Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Int J Tuberc Lung Dis: 2002: 6(11):988-994. 2002.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
156
169
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
157
195
Burrows D. Policy and Environment Assessment: Illicit drug use, the burden of drug related harm and
HIV vulnerability in Cambodia, The POLICY Project; October 2003.
196
Cambodia Daily, Monday October 17, 2005; p17.
197
Fletcher G. Voluntary Confidential Counseling and Testing in Cambodia: an overview. The POLICY
Project and CARE; September 2003.
198
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs. Report of the Mid-Term Assessment of the
Ministry of Health Strategic Plan for HIV/AIDS and STD Care: 2001-2005, Ministry of Health,
Kingdom of Cambodia; Draft 7-17 July, 2003.
199
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STDs. Policy, Strategy and Guidelines for HIV
Counseling and Testing, Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Cambodia; 2001.
200
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STD. Voluntary Confidential Counseling and Testing
for HIV (VCCT): a guide for implementation. Ministry of Health, Cambodia; January 2004.
201
Prom P. HIV Testing and Quality Control, in Health Messenger. HIV/AIDS Voluntary, Confidential,
Counselling and Testing and Prevention of Mother To Child Transmission, Issue 24; September
2005:37-40.
202
National Centre for HIV/AIDS, Dermatology and STD. Voluntary Confidential Counseling and Testing
for HIV: VCCT Counseling Training Manual, Ministry of Health, Kingdom of Cambodia; May 2004.
MYANMAR
203
United Nations Theme Group on HIV/AIDS. Joint Programme for HIV/AIDS: Myanmar 2003-2005,
UNAIDS Myanmar: 2003 (Revised April 2004) available from www.unaids/org/
204
United Nations Expanded Theme group on HIV/AIDS. Joint Program for HIV/AIDS in Myanmar
Progress Report 2003-2004 & Fund for HIV/AIDS in Myanmar (FHAM) Annual Progress Report,
April 2004-March 2005; 2005.
205
Burrowes S. A synthesis of social, behavioral, and economic research studies on HIV infection and
AIDS conducted in Myanmar. Research Report No.10, HIV/AIDS Project and Human development
Initiative Project; 20 June 1998 available from http//:hivinsite.ucsf.edu/global?page=cr08-bm-00
206
UNAIDS, UNICEF, WHO. Epidemiological Fact Sheets on HIV/AIDS and Sexually Transmitted
Infections: Myanmar 2004 update, available from: http://www.who.int/hiv
207
Beyrer C, Razak MH, Labrique A, Brookmeyer R. Assessing the magnitude of the HIV/AIDS epidemic
in Burma. J Acquir Immune Dedic Syndr. 2003 Mar 1;32(3):311-7 abstract available from:
http//:hivinsite.ucsf.edu/global?page=cr08-bm-00
208
Myint Zaw, Min Thwe. Second generation surveillance in Myanmar. National AIDS/STD Programme,
Department of Health, WHO, UNAIDS, Myanmar [Powerpoint]; 2003 available from:
http//:hivinsite.ucsf.edu/global?page=cr08-bm-00
209
Ministry of Health, Department of Health, National AIDS Programme, 2002.
210
UNFPA Myanmar. Projects: specific project components; 2004 available from:
http://myanmar.unfpa.org/projects.htm
211
UNDP Myanmar. HIV/AIDS Prevention and Care Project, available from:
www.mm.undp.org/HDI/HIVAIDS.html (accessed on 19 September 2005).
212
USAID. Country Profile HIV/AIDS: Burma; April 2004 available from www.usaid.gov/
213
World Bank, Myanmar Country Profile; available from www.worldbank.org/
214
Country Coordinating Mechanism Myanmar. Strengthening of Prevention and Control Programme on
HIV/AIDS in the Union of Myanmar, Round 3; 2003 available from:
http://www.theglobalfund.org/search/docs/3MYNH_690_0_summary.pdf
215
The Global Fund for HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria. Termination of Grants to Myanmar, Fact
Sheet; 18 August 2005 available from www.theglobalfund.org.en/media_center/press/pr_050819.asp
(accessed 1 November 2005).
216
The Child Law. The State Law and Order Restoration Council Law No. 9/93. Dated 14 July 1993
available from: http://www3.who.int/idhl-rils/frame.cfm?language=english
217
UNFPA Myanmar. Population and Reproductive Health Situation in Myanmar: 2004 available from:
http://myanmar.unfpa.org
218
Myanmar Nurses Association (NAP, Division of Nursing, Department of Health, UNOPS/UNDP,
UNAIDS, UNICEF and WHO). Community Home Based Care in Myanmar: a resource and training
guide for caregivers. Draft edition: September 2002.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
158
219
Htein Win. Field Testing Report Myanmar Fishermen. Toolkit for HIV prevention among mobile
populations in the Greater Mekong Subregion. World Vision Australia, MacFarlane Burnet Centre,
Asian Development Bank and UNDP; 14 August 2001 available from www.hiv-development.org/
220
National AIDS Programme, Department of Health, Ministry of Health. Manual for HIV/AIDS
Counselling. Yangon, Myanmar; 2003.
221
National AIDS Programme, Department of Health, Ministry of Health. Voluntary Counselling and
Confidential Testing, Operational Guidelines, Draft 2005.
222
UNAIDS. Fund for HIV/AIDS in Myanmar: six-monthly progress report (1 April 2004 30 September
2004); 30 March 2005 available from www.unaids.org/
VIET NAM
223
UNAIDS, UNICEF, WHO. Epidemiological Fact Sheets on HIV/AIDS and Sexually Transmitted
Infections: Vietnam 2004 update, available from: http://www.who.int/hiv
224
Luu Thi Minh Chau. Overview of HIV/AIDS Epidemiology in Viet Nam, LIFE-GAP Program in Viet
Nam [Powerpoint]. Ministry of Health, Vietnam, US/CDC/Global AIDS Program Collaboration; 2005
available from: http://www.vctmeeting.tk/
225
World Health Organization. Summary Country Profile for HIV/AIDS Treatment and Scale-Up:
Vietnam; 2005 available from www.who.int/3by5/en/VietNam.pdf
226
Bureau for Global Health, USAID. Country Profile HIV/AIDS: Vietnam; April 2004 available from
http://pdf.dec.org/pdf_docs/PNADA682.pdf
227
National AIDS Standing Bureau, CDC Atlanta, Military Medical Institute, Department of Public Health.
Assessment on Capacities and Needs of Laboratories in Vietnam, Hanoi; July 2001 available from:
www.unaids.org.vn/
228
Nguyen Duy Tung, Nguyen Anh Tuan, Tran Vu Hoang, Nguyen Tran Hien, Bui Duc Thang, Kane TT et
al. HIV/AIDS Behavioural Surveillance Survey Vietnam 2000, BSS Round 1 Results, English Report;
2001 available from: www.fhi.org/en/HIVAIDS/country/VietNam/vietnamtools.htm
229
Family Health International. What can we do to control the HIV epidemic in Viet Nam: using
behavioural surveillance results from high-risk groups, 2002 (date of publication not certain).
230
Thang D Bui, Chi K Pham, Thang H Pham, Long T Hoang, Thich V Nguyen, Thang Q Vu, Detels R.
Cross-sectional study of sexual behaviour and knowledge about HIV among urban, rural, and minority
residents in Viet Nam. Bulletin of the World Health Organization; 2001; 79 (1):15-21.
231
Institute of Sociology, Ha Noi, La Trobe University, Melbourne. HIV/AIDS-related knowledge,
attitudes and behaviours, and the sexual health of secondary students in Ha Noi: results of a pilot study.
Ha Noi and Melbourne; January 2001.
232
The POLICY Project, Community of Concerned Partners. The Socioeconomic impact of HIV/AIDS in
the Socialist Republic of Viet Nam; June 2003 available from www.dec.org/pdf_docs/PNACU684.pdf .
233
Socio-economic impact of HIV/AIDS in Vietnam: a preliminary note (undated); available from
www.unaids.org.vn/resource/topic/children/seimpacte.pdf
234
Starink M, de Bruin L. Mobility and Vulnerability: an explorative study among female sex workers in
Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam; February 2001 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
235
Socialist Republic of Viet Nam. Decision No.36/2004/QD-TTg of March 17, 2004 approving the
National Strategic Plan on HIV/AIDS Prevention and Control in Viet Nam until 2010 with a Vision to
2020.
236
Socialist Republic of Viet Nam. Directive of the Prime Minister on Strengthening HIV/AIDS Prevention
and Control. No. 02/2003/CT-TTg; Hanoi, 24 February 2003.
237
World Bank, Viet Nam Country Profile; available from www.worldbank.org/
238
Office of the United States Global AIDS Coordinator. Country Profile-Vietnam: U.S. President's
Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief; 2005 available from www.cdc.gov/nchstp/od/gap/countries/docs/
239
Country Coordinating Mechanism Vietnam. Strengthening Care, Counseling, Support to People living
with HIV/AIDS and Related Community-based Activities to prevent HIV/AIDS in Vietnam, Ministry
of Health of the Government of Vietnam, Round 1; 2001 available from:
http://www.theglobalfund.org/search/docs/1VTNH_364_133_summary.pdf
240
Family Health International. Country Profile: Viet Nam; July 2004 available from www.fhi.org
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
159
241
CARE International in Vietnam, The POLICY Project. Moving Forward: operationalising GIPA in
Vietnam, Final Study Report; October 2003 on CD-ROM The Futures Group and The POLICY Project,
July 2004.
242
UNAIDS Viet Nam website. Vietnamese Non-Government Organizations; 2004 available from:
www.unaids.org.vn/facts/mappingreport/4report.pdf
243
UNAIDS Viet Nam website. HIV Prevention by Organization in Vietnam; 2004 available from
www.unaids.org.vn/facts/docs/hiv_intervention_matrices05.xls
244
Nguyen Duy Tung, Le Ha, Nguyen Truong Son. Report: information and data related to
HIV/AIDS/STD and commercial sex workers in Vietnam. National Committee for AIDS Prevention and
Drug and Prostitution Prevention, Hanoi; November 2000 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
245
Uhring J [moderator]. Email from JV Net; 10 October 2005.
246
Socialist Republic of Viet Nam. Government Decision No. 34/CP on Guidance to Execute Laws on
HIV/AIDS Prevention and Protections dated 1 June 1996.
247
Socialist Republic of Viet Nam. Government Decision No. 49/2003/NN-CP, Defining the Function,
Responsibility, Authority and Framework of Organization of the Ministry of Health; 15 May 2003.
248
Socialist Republic of Viet Nam. Provisions on the Functions, Tasks, Authorities and Organizational
Structure of the General Department of Preventive Medicine and HIV/AIDS Control. Promulgated in
conjunction with Government Decision No. 4351/2003/QB/BYT; 15 August 2003.
249
Socialist Republic of Viet Nam. Government Decree No. 05/2003/ND-CP on International Cooperation
in the Field of Drug Prevention and Combat; January 21, 2003.
250
Vietnamese Research Centre for Human Rights, Ho Chi Minh National Political Academy. International
Law, National Policy and Legislation for the Prevention of HIV/AIDS and Protection of Human Rights
of People Living with HIV/AIDS in Vietnam. Care International in Vietnam, Final Report, Hanoi;
November 2003 on CD-ROM Futures Group and The POLICY Project, July 2004.
251
Bourke-Martignoni J. Violence against women in Vietnam. Report prepared for the Committee on the
Elimination of Discrimination against Women, 25th Session; 2-20 June 2001, OMCT available from:
www.unaids.org.vn/
252
Fee N. HIV/AIDS Stigma and Discrimination in Viet Nam. UNAIDS Vietnam [Powerpoint]; April 2004
available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
253
Khuat Thu Hong, Nguyen Thi Van Anh, Ogden J. Understanding HIV and AIDS-related stigma and
discrimination in Vietnam. Institute for Social Development Studies, Hanoi and International Center for
Research on Women, Washington DC; 2004 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
254
Sheehan M. Gender Issues and HIV in Viet Nam. World Health Organization [Powerpoint]; March 2005
available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
255
Go VF, Vu Minh Quan, Chung A, Zenilman J, Vu Thi Minh Hanh, Celentano. Gender gaps, gender
traps: sexual identity and vulnerability to sexually transmitted diseases among women in Vietnam. Soc
Sc Med; 2002: 55: 467-481 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
256
Tran Thi Van Anh. Key Gender Issues. Institute for Family and Gender Studies [Powerpoint].
Presentation on HIV/AIDS and Gender Meeting, Hanoi; March 17 2005 available from:
www.unaids.org.vn/
257
National Committee for the Advancement of Women in Viet Nam. Gender mainstreaming guidelines in
national policy formulation and implementation, Hanoi: 2004 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
258
Doyle N. The social marketing of condom in Vietnam: towards a national strategy. UNFPA; September
2001 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
259
McCoy NR, Kane TT, Rushing R. HIV/AIDS Prevention and Care in Viet Nam: lessons learned from
the FHI/IMPACT Project, 1998-2003 Family Health International Vietnam; 2004 on CD-ROM
HIV/AIDS Prevention, Care and Treatment resources 2004 for use in developing countries, Family
Health International, 2004.
260
Ministry of Health. National Plan on "Prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission of HIV" Period
2006-2012 (third draft), Hanoi; June 2005 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
261
Nguyen Tran Hien. Situation assessment of drug injecting and its health consequences among IDUs in
Hanoi City, Vietnam. Hanoi School of Public Health; June 2001 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
262
Trang Vu. Harm Reduction for Injecting Drug Users in Vietnam: a situation assessment. Victorian
Public Health Training Scheme, Macfarlane Burnet Centre for Medical Research; March 2001 available
from: www.chr.asn.au/freestyler/gui/files/Vietnam-HR-SA.pdf
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
160
263
World Health Organization. Evaluation of Vietnam National Tuberculosis Program [Powerpoint]; 2003
available from www.unaids.org.vn/resource/topic/tuberculosis0803.ppt#2
264
Hoanng T Quy, Dang TT Nhien, Nguyen TN Lan, Borgdoff MW, Broekmans JF. Steep increase in HIV
prevalence among tuberculosis patients in Ho Chi Minh City. AIDS 2002; 16:6: 931-932 available from
www.unaids.org.vn/
265
Ministry of Health, WHO, UNICEF. Survey Assessment of Vietnamese Youth (SAVY); 2005.
266
Thinh T, Hoang TT, Giang LT, Colby DJ. Behavioral Survey among grade 12 students in Ho Chi Minh
City, Vietnam, in 2001. Abstract TuPeC4790, XV International AIDS Conference, Bangkok; July 2004
available from www.unaids.org.vn/
267
Khuat Thu Hong. Adolescent and Youth Reproductive Health in Vietnam: status, issues, policies and
programs. The POLICY Project; January 2003 available from: www.dec.org/
268
Mensch BS, Clark WH, Dang Nguyen Anh. Premarital sex in Vietnam: is the current concern with
adolescent reproductive health warranted? Policy Research Division Working Paper No. 163. New
York: Population Council; 2002, abstract available from:
www.popcouncil.org/publications/wp/prd/163.html
269
Dao Tran Phuong, Tran Thi Thu Huong, Nguyen Thi Huong, Trinh Quang Long. Report: Youth and
Reproductive Health Issues in Ha Long: problems and solutions using a youth community
development approach. Research and Training Centre for Community Development, Hanoi; December
2001 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
270
Elmer L. HIV/AIDS Intervention Data on Commercial Sex Workers in Vietnam: a review of recent
research findings. National AIDS Standing Bureau, Hanoi, Vietnam; February 2001 available from:
www.unaids.org.vn/
271
Rekart ML. Sex in the city: sexual behaviour, societal change, and STDs in Saigon. Sex Transm Infect
2002;78(Suppl 1):i47-154 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
272
Nguyen Thi Thanh Thuy, Lindan CP, Nguyen Xuan Hoan, Barclay J, Ha Ba Khiem. Sexual risk
behavior of women in entertainment services, Vietnam. AIDS and Behavior; 2000:4 (1):93-101
available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
273
Nguyen Duy Tung, Nguyen Truang Son, Nguyen The Trung. Population mobility, prostitution and
factors related to HIV transmission on Vietnam's main transportation routes. National Committee for
AIDS Prevention, Drug and Prostitution Prevention; November 2000 available from:
www.unaids.org.vn/
274
Nguyen Tran Hien, Le Truong Giang, Phan Nguyen Binh and Wolffers I. The social context of HIV risk
behaviour by drug injectors in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam. AIDS Care; 2000: 12:4:483-495 available
from: www.unaids.org.vn/
275
United Nations Drug Control Program, Ministry of Labour, Invalids and Social Affairs. Report: results
of the survey on high risk factors of drug abuse among groups of female prostitutes in Vietnam, Hanoi;
2001 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
276
Voytek C. Go VF, Tham LV, Hoa TT, Trung DV, Van Anh HT, Thuy BT, Ngu D, Quan VM. The
socio-cultural context of stigma and other barriers to voluntary counseling and testing for HIV among
injecting drug users in Bac Ninh, Vietnam. Abstract MoPeD3944, XV International AIDS Conference,
Bangkok; July 2004 available from www.unaids.org.vn/
277
Ha Thanh Binh. HIV/AIDS Prevention: Knowledge, attitudes and practices of long distance drivers.
Border Areas HIV/AIDS Prevention Project; March 2000 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
278
Chung A, Nguyen Duy Tung, Vu Tuan Huy, Do Van Binh, Tran Quang Thuan, Uhrig J. Rapid
Assessment of HIV Vulnerability on Major Transport Routes in Vietnam; UNDP South East Asia HIV
and Development Project; May 2000 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
279
Uhrig J. HIV Vulnerability Mapping: Highway One, Viet Nam. UNDP South East Asia HIV and
Development Project; October 2000 available from:
www.hiv-development.org/text/publications/Vietnam_highwayOne.pdf
280
Griffiths P, Nguyen Hong Son. Nghe An Lao Capacity Assistance Project: mapping the HIV risk
environment along Highway 7 a rapid assessment. Supporting Centre for HIV/AIDS Control;
September 2000 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
281
Nguyen Viet My Ngoc. Field Testing Report Vietnam: Fishermen. Toolkit for HIV prevention among
mobile populations in the Greater Mekong Subregion. World Vision Australia, MacFarlane Burnet
Centre, Asian Development Bank and UNDP; 23 July 2001 available from www.hiv-development.org/
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
161
282
Colby DJ. HIV knowledge and risk factors among men who have sex with men in Ho Chi Minh City,
Vietnam. Master of Public Health, University of Washington; 2001 available from:
www.unaids.org.vn/
283
Colby D, Nghia Huu Cao, Doussantousse S. Men who have sex with men and HIV in Vietnam: a
review. AIDS Education and Prevention; 2004;16(1):45-54 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
284
Thinh T, Thi MDA, Bain DL, Giang LT, Mandel JS, Lindin CP. Epidemiological data from the first
anonymous testing site (ATS) in Vietnam. Abstract D11239, XIV International Conference on AIDS,
Barcelona; 2002 available from www.unaids.org.vn/
285
Phuong TVA, Bain DL, Colby DJ, Thinh T, Giang LT, Mandel JS. The importance of offering
anonymous HIV testing in Vietnam. Abstract TuPeD5042, XV International AIDS Conference,
Bangkok; July 2004 available from www.unaids.org.vn/
286
Nguyen HTT, Kamb ML, Hoang TN, Tran DT, Luu MN, Luu Cm, Chong PS. VCT referral network as
a catalyst for a comprehensive HIV program. Abstract WePeE6699. XV International AIDS
Conference, Bangkok; July 2004 available from www.unaids.org.vn/
287
Tran Tien Dat. Voluntary Counseling and Testing: an effective intervention in HIV prevention and care
[Powerpoint]. National VCT Experience-Sharing meeting, Nha Trang; August 24-26, 2005 available
from www.vctmeeting.tk/
288
Ministry of Health, Vietnam, US/CDC/GAP Cooperation Project. Linkages between community based
outreach and VCT programs [Powerpoint]. National VCT Experience-Sharing meeting, Nha Trang;
August 24-26, 2005 available from www.vctmeeting.tk/
289
Luu MN, Tran DT, Nguyen HT, Hoang TN, Chong PS, Kamb ML, Luu CM. Comparison of FacilityBased and Free-Standing VCT Services in Vietnam. Abstract E11902, XV International AIDS
Conference, Bangkok; July 2004 available from www.unaids.org.vn/
290
Le Truong Giang, Paquette M. Mobile Clinic Experience [Powerpoint], Medicins du Monde; 2005
available from: http://www.vctmeeting.tk/
291
Trung NQ, Bain DL, Colby DJ, Thinh T, Giang LT, Mandel JS. Vietnam's voluntary counseling and
testing (VCT) must improve referral services for people living with HIV/AIDS. Abstract TuPeD5041,
XV International AIDS Conference, Bangkok; July 2004 available from www.unaids.org.vn/
292
Dinh TH, Kamb ML, Detels R, Nguyen MA. Factors associated with reluctance to accept HIV testing in
pregnant women in Vietnam. Abstract ThPeC7304, XV International AIDS Conference, Bangkok; July
2004 available from: www.unaids.org.vn/
293
Hoang TN, Nguyen HT, Luu MN, Tran DT, Chong PS, Kamb ML, Luu CM. Vietnam established a
national program on Voluntary Counseling and Testing (VCT) for high-risk persons; preliminary
results. Abstract WePeE6810. XV International AIDS Conference, Bangkok; July 2004 available from
www.unaids.org.vn/
294
Tran DT, Luu MN, Nguyen HT, Hoang TN, Chong PS, Kamb ML, Luu CM, Pham HT, Le HT. Highrisk behaviors and HIV positive status among VCT clients in Quang Ninh Province, Vietnam. Abstract
C11723, XV International AIDS Conference, Bangkok; July 2004 available from www.unaids.org.vn/
295
Nguyen HT, Kamb ML, Tran DT, Chong PS, Hoang TN, Luu CM, Nguyen TH. Changing patterns of
HIV Transmission in Vietnam. Abstract MoPeC3550, XV International AIDS Conference, Bangkok;
July 2004 available from www.unaids.org.vn/
296
Dao Duc Giang. Family Health International supported VCT [Powerpoint]. National VCT ExperienceSharing meeting, Nha Trang; August 24-26, 2005 available from www.vctmeeting.tk/
297
Kamb M. Voluntary Counseling and Testing in Vietnam [Powerpoint]; CDC Viet Nam; 2003 available
from www.unaids.org.vn/
298
Hang Trinh. Population Services International and VCT: social marketing approach to voluntary
counseling and testing [Powerpoint]. National VCT Experience-Sharing meeting, Nha Trang; August
24-26, 2005 available from www.vctmeeting.tk/
299
Tran Thi Thanh Thuy. Voluntary HIV Counseling and Testing [Powerpoint]. US/CDC/Global AIDS
Program on HIV/AIDS prevention and care in Vietnam (LIFE-GAP), Hai Phong Department of Health;
2005 available from www.vctmeeting.tk/
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
162
10. ANNEXES
ANNEX 1: LIST OF KEY WEB SITES AND RESOURCE CENTRES
Website address
hivinsite.ucsf.edu/global?page=cr08-cb-00
hivinsite.ucsf.edu/global?page=cr08-bm-00
hivinsite.ucsf.edu/global?page=cr08-vm-00
http://myanmar.unfpa.org
www.adb.org/
www.aidsalliance.org
www.cdc.gov/hiv/
www.cdc.gov/hiv/rapid_testing/
www.dec.org/
www.fda.gov/cber/products/testkits.htm
www.fhi.org
www.hdr.undp.org/
www.hiv-development.org
www.measuredhs.com/hivdata
www.medicam-cambodia.org
www.mm.undp.org/
www.nchads.org
www.policyproject.com
www.racha.org.kh/
www.rapid-diagnostics.org/rti-hiv-com.htm
www.un.org.kh/undp
www.un.org.kh/unfpa
www.un.org.vn/unfpa
www.unaids.org
www.unaids.org.vn
www.unfpa.org/
www.who.int/hiv/en/
www.who.int/globalatlas/default.asp
http://www3.who.int/idhl-rils/frame.cfm?language=english
www.who.int/diagnostics_laboratory/procurement/en/
www.worldbank.org
www.worldbank.org/kh
www.worldbank.org/mm
www.worldbank.org/vn
www.worldbank.org/eapaids
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
163
UNAIDS
Organization
Department for
International Development
HIV/AIDS Coordinating
Committee
National Aids Authority
National Center for
HIV/AIDS, Dermatology
and STD
UNAIDS
Contact/ Position
Ms Nicolet Hutter
Program Support Officer
Mr. Seng Sopheap
Executive Officer
Dr Teng Kunthy
Vice-Secretary General
Dr Prum Phanit
Chief of VCCT Sub-Unit
email
dfidpso@online.com.kh
HACC@online.com.kh
kunthy@naa.org.kh
phaprom@yahoo.com
Mr Matthew Warner-Smith
warnersmithm@unaids.org
M&E Advisor
UNICEF
United Nations
Mr. Chin Sedtha, HIV/AIDS
schin@unicef.org
Children Fund, Cambodia
Assistant Project Officer
USCDC
Center for Disease Control/ Dr. Hour Bun Leng
lhor@state.gov
Global AIDS Program
Deputy Director
WVC
World Vision Cambodia
Dr Srey Mony
mony_srey@wvi.org
HIV Program Manager
Notes: An in-depth interview with Dr Ping Chutema of the Reproductive Health Association of Cambodia
(RHAC) was conducted in August 2005, before the development of the Generic Questionnaire. Similarly,
a meeting was held with Om Chhen, a representative of Population Services International (PSI) at around
the same time. The MSC Program Manager and MSIA Project Support Manager met with Betina Maas,
Country Director of UNFPA, early in the process of developing this review and a separate Key Informant
Interview was considered unnecessary. Multiple requests to attempt to arrange an interview with a
representative of the Ministry of Women's and Veteran's Affairs were unsuccessful.
NAP
PSI
UNAIDS
Organization
CARE
International
Myanmar
National Control
AIDS Program
Population
Services
International
UNAIDS
Contact/ Position
Ms Dympha Kenny,
Assistant Country Director
(Programs)
Dr Min Thwe,
Deputy Director &
Programme Manager
Mr Guy Stallworthy,
Myanmar Country Director
email
dymphna@care.org.mm
thwe@mptmail.net.mm
guy@psimyanmar.org.mm
Mr Brian Williams,
williamsb@unaids.org
Country Coordinator
sid.naing.unaids@undp.org
Dr Sid Naing,
Program Advisor
UNODC
United Nations
jean-luc.LEMAHIEU@unodc.org
Mr Jean-Luc Lemahieu,
Office on Drugs
Country Representative
lermetotcu@idu.org.mm
and Crime
Mr Olivier Lermet,
International Coordinator
UNICEF
United Nations
Ms Anne Vincent,
avincent@unicef.org
Children's Fund
Chief, Health and Nutrition
Section
Note: This Table lists the details of persons contacted for Key Informant Interviews who gave permission
for their names and contact details to be referenced for this report.
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
164
FHI
PAC
UNAIDS
VAAC
WVV
Organization
CARE International
in Viet Nam
US Centre for
Diseases Control,
Global AIDS
Program
Family Health
International
Provincial AIDS
Committee, Ho Chi
Minh City Standing
Office
UNAIDS
Viet Nam
Administration of
HIV/AIDS Control,
Ministry of Health
World Vision
Vietnam
Contact/ Position
Nguyen Ngoc Thang,
Component Manager
Dr Mitchell Wolfe,
Country Director
Mr Tran Tien Dat and
Dr Dao Quang Vinh,
Medical Research Technologists
(Coordinator), Voluntary HIV
Counseling and Testing Program
Dr Vu Ngoc Bao,
Program Manager
Dao Duc Giang,
Program Officer, HIV Counseling
and Testing
Dr Tran Thinh,
Project Coordinator, PAC
email
nnthang@care.org.vn
Louise Dann,
UNV Associate Volunteer,
Planning and Management Officer
Dr Nguyen Huy Nga,
Director-General
louise@unaids.org.vn
Sera Bonds,
HIV/AIDS Technical Advisor
Monique Zammit,
Project Assistant, HIV/AIDS and
Information Management
sera_bonds@wvi.org
MSW6@CDC.GOV
TranDT2@state.gov
DaoVQ@vn.cdc.gov
bao@fhi.org.vn
giang@fhi.org.vn
tranthinhpac@yahoo.com
huynga@netnam.vn
Monique_zammit@wvi.org
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
165
Location of Interview: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Email: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
INTRODUCTION
QUESTIONS
CORE: must ask this question
REC: recommended try to make sure this question is asked
OPTIONAL: ask only if there is enough time or an opportunity
1. CORE (for Gov, IO and ?NGO):
What are the key issues related to the spread of HIV/AIDS in [name of country]: cultural/
behavioural issues? social/ economic issues? gender/ human rights issues?
2. CORE (for Gov and IO):
What is the current place (or role) of HIV testing and counseling in [name of country]
responding to HIV/AIDS in [name of country]? Is HIV testing and counseling seen mainly
as a health intervention or a multi-sectoral responsibility, or both?
3. CORE (for Gov, IO and NGO):
What is your assessment of the current coverage of HIV testing and counseling services
in [name of country]? geographical coverage, coverage of specific population groups?
4. CORE (for Gov, IO and NGO):
What are the most important barriers to HIV testing and counseling services in [name of
country]for the general population and for specific population groups (women, youth, high
risk behaviour groups)? [Assessment of stigma and discrimination as a barrier].
5. CORE (for Gov, IO and ?NGO):
What models of HIV testing and counseling are needed and appropriate to [name of
country] to scale-up HIV testing and counseling to reach more of the general population?
What appropriate models to reach specific population groups youth, women, risk
behaviour groups?
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
166
HIV Counseling and Testing: a situation analysis in Cambodia, Myanmar and Viet Nam
167