Sie sind auf Seite 1von 4

Federal Register / Vol. 71, No.

17 / Thursday, January 26, 2006 / Proposed Rules 4341

environmental factors on plant species Authority petition, supporting data, and comments
in general, no substantial scientific or The authority for this action is section will be available for public inspection,
commercial information regarding 4 of the Endangered Species Act of by appointment, during normal business
Aliciella tenuis was provided. Drought, 1973, as amended (16 U.S.C. 1531 et hours, at the above address.
flood, climate change, and plant- seq.). FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Pete
pollinator interactions may have the Gober, Field Supervisor, South Dakota
Dated: January 19, 2006.
potential to affect small populations. Ecological Services Office at the above
However, we find no indication of long- Thomas O. Melius,
address (telephone 605–224–8693;
term species decline for A. tenuis due to Acting Director, Fish and Wildlife Service. facsimile 605–224–9974).
these or any other factors. Most A. [FR Doc. E6–947 Filed 1–25–06; 8:45 am]
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
tenuis sites have greater than 100 BILLING CODE 4310–55–P
individuals and, as more recent studies Background
indicate, most populations have several Section 4(b)(3)(A) of the Act (16
hundred to several thousand DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR U.S.C. 1531 et seq.), requires that we
documented individuals (Clark 2005). make a finding on whether a petition to
Fish and Wildlife Service
Such populations possess greater list, delist, or reclassify a species
resiliency to the threats identified in the presents substantial scientific or
50 CFR Part 17
petition. commercial information indicating that
A few sites are in active floodplains Endangered and Threatened Wildlife the petitioned action may be warranted.
where plants are periodically washed and Plants; 90-day Finding on a We are to base this finding on
away (Clark 2005); however, seed source Petition To List the American Dipper in information provided in the petition
for recolonization of these sites is the Black Hills of South Dakota as and other information that is readily
provided by larger sites found at higher Threatened or Endangered available to us (e.g., in our files). To the
elevations in the landscape (D. Clark, maximum extent practicable, we are to
AGENCY: Fish and Wildlife Service, make this finding within 90 days of our
pers. comm. 2005). Interior. receipt of the petition, and publish our
The information presented in the ACTION: Notice of 90-day petition notice of this finding promptly in the
petition regarding climate change and finding. Federal Register.
its potential impact on Aliciella tenuis Our standard for substantial scientific
is speculative. SUMMARY: We, the U.S. Fish and
information within the Code of Federal
Wildlife Service (Service), announce a
Finding Regulations (CFR) with regard to a 90-
90-day finding on a petition to list the
day petition finding is ‘‘that amount of
distinct vertebrate population segment
We have reviewed the information as information that would lead a
(DPS) of American dipper (Cinclus
it is cited in the petition, along with reasonable person to believe that the
mexicanus unicolor) in the Black Hills
other pertinent literature and measure proposed in the petition may
of South Dakota as threatened or
information readily available in our be warranted’’ (50 CFR 424.14(b)). If we
endangered under the Endangered
files. After this review and evaluation, find that substantial scientific
Species Act of 1973, as amended (Act).
we find the petition does not present information was presented, we are
We find that the petition and other
substantial scientific information to required to commence a review of the
readily available information do not
indicate that listing Aliciella tenuis may status of the species.
provide substantial scientific or
be warranted at this time. Most of the In making this finding, we relied on
commercial information indicating that
threats described in the petition are information provided by the petitioners
listing the American Dipper in the Black
speculative in nature, and petitioners and information in our files, and
Hills of South Dakota may be warranted.
admit that only a few populations are evaluated that information in
This finding is based on our
susceptible to the threats raised. accordance with 50 CFR 424.14(b). Our
determination that the American Dipper
We will not be commencing a status process of coming to a 90-day finding
in the Black Hills of South Dakota does
review in response to this petition. We under section 4(b)(3)(A) of the Act and
not constitute a valid DPS and,
encourage interested parties to continue § 424.14(b) of our regulations is limited
therefore, cannot be considered a
to gather data that will assist with the to a determination of whether the
listable entity pursuant to section 3(15)
conservation of the species. If you wish information in the petition meets the
of the Act. Therefore, we will not
to provide information regarding ‘‘substantial scientific information’’
initiate a status review to determine if
Aliciella tenuis, you may submit your threshold.
listing this species is warranted in
information or materials to the Field We do not conduct additional
response to this petition. However, the
Supervisor, Utah Fish and Wildlife research to make a 90-day finding, nor
public may submit to us new
Office (see ADDRESSES). do we subject the petition to rigorous
information concerning the species, its
critical review. Rather, as the Act and
References Cited status or threats to it at any time.
regulations contemplate, in coming to a
DATES: The finding announced in this 90-day finding, we acknowledge the
A complete list of all references cited document was made on January 19, petitioner’s sources and
herein is available, upon request, from 2006. characterizations of the information
the Utah Fish and Wildlife Office (see ADDRESSES: Information, data, unless we have specific information to
ADDRESSES). comments, or questions concerning this the contrary.
erjones on PROD1PC68 with PROPOSALS

Author petition and our finding should be Our 90-day findings consider whether
submitted to the Field Supervisor, the petition states a reasonable case for
The primary author of this notice is South Dakota Ecological Services Office, listing on its face. Thus, our finding
Heather Barnes, U.S. Fish and Wildlife U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 420 expresses no view as to the ultimate
Service, Utah Fish and Wildlife Office South Garfield Avenue, Suite 400, issue of whether the species should be
(see ADDRESSES). Pierre, South Dakota 57501. The listed. We reach a conclusion on that

VerDate Aug<31>2005 14:54 Jan 25, 2006 Jkt 208001 PO 00000 Frm 00029 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\26JAP1.SGM 26JAP1
4342 Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 17 / Thursday, January 26, 2006 / Proposed Rules

issue only after a more thorough review (Kingery 1996; Tyler and Ormerod 1994; streams in the Black Hills—Spearfish
of the species’ status. Price and Bock 1983; Feck 2002) with Creek and Whitewood Creek.
abundant and healthy populations of Dipper nest surveys in the Black Hills
Petition were started in 1993 and became more
benthic macroinvertebrate, the dipper’s
On March 28, 2003, we received a prey (Price and Bock 1983; Kingery extensive from 2003 to 2005. The lowest
petition dated March 15, 2003, 1996; Tyler and Ormerod 1994; Ealey number of dippers reported on
requesting that we list the distinct 1977). Dippers are usually found in Spearfish Creek was 10 in 1997, with
population segment (DPS) of American streams with rock, sand, and rubble only 2 nests found (Backlund 2001). In
dipper (Cinclus mexicanus unicolor) in substrates, which also are associated 2004, the number of dippers reported on
the Black Hills of South Dakota as with the highest abundance of aquatic Spearfish Creek was approximately 49,
threatened or endangered under the Act, invertebrates. American dippers with 31 nest attempts (Lovett 2004). In
and for the designation of critical establish linear territories along a river 2004, Whitewood Creek had 12 adults
habitat for that DPS. In addition, the in early spring (Kingery 1996). They observed and 7 known nest attempts
petition requested emergency listing of remain in or near their territories most (Lovett 2004).
the DPS. The petition, submitted by the of the year, depending upon the
Biodiversity Conservation Alliance, Distinct Vertebrate Population Segment
availability of open water. Dipper nest
Center for Native Ecosystems, Native sites can be found on streamside rock The petitioners have asked us to
Ecosystems Council, Prairie Hills cliffs, waterfalls, on large rocks in consider listing a DPS of the American
Audubon Society and Jeremy Nichols, midstream, or under bridges (Kingery dipper in the Black Hills of South
was clearly identified as a petition for 1996). Dakota. Under the Act, we can consider
a listing rule, and it contained the for listing any species, subspecies, or
There are few records of American DPS of any species of vertebrate fish or
names, signatures, and addresses of the
dippers making long distance flights, wildlife that interbreeds when mature, if
requesting parties. Included in the
and these records do not substantiate information is substantial to indicate
petition was supporting information
that these movements contribute to the that such action may be warranted. To
regarding the species’ taxonomy and
establishment of new populations. No implement the measures prescribed by
ecology, historical and current
instances of long distance dispersal of the Act and its congressional guidance,
distribution, present status, and
dippers between the Black Hills and the we developed a joint policy with the
potential causes of decline.
next nearest populations of American National Oceanic and Atmospheric
We acknowledged the receipt of the
dipper to the west in the Big Horn Administration entitled Policy
petition in a letter to Mr. Jeremy
Mountains of north-central Wyoming Regarding the Recognition of Distinct
Nichols, dated May 20, 2003. In that
and the Laramie Range of east-central Vertebrate Population Segments under
letter, we advised the petitioners that
Wyoming have been documented. the Act (61 FR 4722; February 7, 1996)
emergency listing was not justified and
that, due to funding constraints, we Distribution, Abundance, Trends (DPS Policy). Under the DPS policy, we
would not be able to begin processing must consider three elements in making
The American dipper is at the eastern our decision whether an entity qualifies
the petition in a timely manner.
On July 21, 2003, we received a edge of its range in the Black Hills. The as a DPS that warrants listing as
Notice of Intent to sue from the dipper is a permanent year-round endangered or threatened under the
petitioners contending that the Service resident of the Black Hills and has ESA. The three elements are: (1) The
had violated the ESA by failing to make historically been known to inhabit population segment’s discreteness in
a timely 90-day finding on the petition nearly all permanent, fast-flowing relation to the remainder of the species
to list a DPS of the American dipper. streams in the area (Pettingill and to which it belongs; (2) the population
On August 20, 2004, the petitioners Whitney 1965). The species is not segment’s significance to the species to
filed a complaint in Federal District known to disperse or migrate long which it belongs; and (3) the population
Court against the Secretary of the distances; the extent to which it moves segment’s conservation status in relation
Interior and the Service for failure to to any degree between the to the Act’s standards for listing (i.e.,
make a 90-day finding under section 4 geographically separated areas that it when treated as if it were a species, is
of the ESA. In a stipulated settlement occupies is undocumented (Tyler and the population segment endangered or
agreement, we agreed to submit a 90-day Ormerod 1994). The dipper population threatened?). Following is our
finding to the Federal Register by in the Black Hills is isolated from other evaluation of these elements in relation
January 20, 2006 [Black Hills Dipper, et populations by geographical barriers to to the petitioned entity (the American
al. v. Norton et al. (04-cv-1293 (DDC))]. dispersal in the form of extensive dipper in the Black Hills of South
The settlement agreement was signed grasslands, poor quality stream habitat, Dakota).
and adopted by the District Court for the and the lack of water connections to
dipper populations existing west of the Discreteness
District of Columbia on January 24,
2005. This notice constitutes our 90-day Black Hills (Backlund 2001). The DPS policy states that a
finding for the petition to list a DPS of Verified historic American dipper population segment of a vertebrate
the American dipper in the Black Hills reports have been recorded on six species may be considered discrete if it
of South Dakota as endangered or streams and/or their tributaries in the satisfies either one of the following two
threatened, pursuant to the agreement. Black Hills: French Creek; Rapid Creek; conditions: It must be markedly
Box Elder Creek; Elk Creek; Whitewood separated from other populations of the
Species Information Creek; and Spearfish Creek (Backlund same taxon as a consequence of
The American dipper is a small, gray 2001). Other streams are unable to physical, physiological, ecological, or
erjones on PROD1PC68 with PROPOSALS

passerine bird that inhabits western support self-sustaining populations of behavioral factors, or it must be
Canada and the western United States, dipper due to habitat degradation, delimited by international governmental
including the Black Hills (Pettingill and erratic water flows, loss of water flow, boundaries within which significant
Whitney 1965; Anderson 2002). The poor water quality, and other impacts differences in control of exploitation,
American dipper utilizes permanent, (Backlund 2001). Currently, nesting management of habitat conservation
clean, cold, and swift mountain streams dippers can be found on only two status or regulatory mechanisms exist

VerDate Aug<31>2005 14:54 Jan 25, 2006 Jkt 208001 PO 00000 Frm 00030 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\26JAP1.SGM 26JAP1
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 17 / Thursday, January 26, 2006 / Proposed Rules 4343

that are significant in light of section population segment would result in a Kingery 1996) states that the American
4(a)(1)(D) of the Act. significant gap in the range of the taxon; dipper’s breeding range extends from
(3) evidence that the population western Alaska eastward across
Information Provided in the Petition
segment represents the only surviving northcentral Alaska; southward along
Substantial information is presented natural occurrence of a taxon that may the Pacific Coast and throughout the
in the petition to indicate that the Black be more abundant elsewhere as an Rocky Mountains into New Mexico.
Hills population may be markedly introduced population outside its They are absent from the Great Basin
separated from other populations of the historical range; and (4) evidence that area except for scattered populations.
American dipper as a consequence of the discrete population segment differs The range includes mountain streams in
physical factors. The Black Hills is an markedly from other populations of the an area that is approximately 5,000 km
isolated mountain range located within species in its genetic characteristics. from north to south and approximately
the plains of western South Dakota and 1,800 km from west to east at its widest
northeastern Wyoming (Raventon 1994). Information Provided in the Petition
point. Within that range, there are
The Great Plains, which entirely a. Persistence of the population thousands of suitable streams and tens
surrounds the Black Hills, creates a segment in an ecological setting that is of thousands of kilometers of occupied
major physical barrier separating the unique for the taxon. streams. The Black Hills dipper
Black Hills American dipper from other The American dipper occupies population occupies two streams that
Rocky Mountain populations to the west permanent, clean, cold, and swift represent less than 80 km of occupied
(Hall et al. 2002). The Bighorn mountain streams throughout the stream habitat. The dipper-occupied
Mountains, approximately 150 to 200 western half of North America, streams in the Black Hills are on the
miles (mi) (241 to 322 kilometers (km)) including the Black Hills (Kingery eastern edge of the overall dipper’s
to the west, is the closest mountain 1996). The petition contends that the range and if lost would not create a gap
range to the Black Hills (Froiland 1990). streams in the Black Hills inhabited by in the overall species range with other
The expanse of grassland separating the dippers may be a unique ecological dipper populations. The mountain
Black Hills from other mountain ranges setting because the Black Hills streams of the Black Hills provide the
is incapable of supporting American themselves are a unique ecosystem. We easternmost habitat for the American
dippers and represents a significant recognize that the Black Hills have dipper. We conclude that the petition
barrier to dispersal (Backlund 2001; many unique ecological features, but does not present substantial information
Voelker 2002). The streams and rivers of information readily available in our files that loss of the population segment
the Great Plains are described as (e.g., Kingery 1996) indicates that these would result in a significant gap in the
typically silt-laden, turbid, alkaline, and mountain ecosystems share range of taxon.
subject to erratic flows which precludes commonalities such as clean, cold, swift c. The population segment represents
their use by dippers (Smith and Hubert mountain streams with suitable the only surviving natural occurrence of
1989). substrate that provide the habitats for a taxon that may be more abundant
Information in the petition, as invertebrate species used by dippers. In elsewhere as an introduced population
supported by information readily that respect, the Black Hills are similar outside its historical range.
available in our files, suggests that there to other western mountain ecosystems. The petition does not address this
is a substantial physical isolation of the In addition, the petitioners claim that factor. The American dipper survives
Black Hills population of the American Black Hills streams have features that naturally throughout much of western
dipper. Therefore, the petition presents make them ecologically unique. Streams North America.
substantial information indicating that throughout the Rocky Mountains vary in d. The discrete population segment
the Black Hills population of the many features, including elevation, differs markedly from other populations
American dipper meets a condition for gradient, substrate, parent geological of the species in its genetic
discreteness under our DPS policy. The material, riparian vegetation, etc., such characteristics.
Black Hills population of the American that virtually every stream could be The petition does not address this
dipper is not delimited by international considered ‘‘unique.’’ Information factor. We are aware that a genetic
governmental boundaries within which readily available in our files (e.g., analysis is being conducted to
significant differences in control of Kingery 1996) indicates that the key determine whether the Black Hills
exploitation, management of habitat features of Black Hills streams used by population of the American dipper is
conservation status or regulatory dippers—cold temperatures, good water genetically distinct from other American
mechanisms exist that are significant in quality, suitable substrate, and swift dipper populations in North America
light of section 4(a)(1)(D) of the ESA. flow—are the same key features of (C. Anderson, Black Hills State
dipper-utilized streams elsewhere University, pers. comm. 2005). To date,
Significance
throughout the Rocky Mountains. the research has analyzed samples from
Pursuant to our DPS policy, in Accordingly, we do not believe the 6 populations (Black Hills, SD;
addition to our consideration that a petition presents substantial Bighorns, WY; and four locations in
population segment is discrete, we information that the clean, cold swift west central Montana and east central
further consider its biological and streams of the Black Hills occupied by Idaho). Preliminary information from
ecological significance to the taxon to dippers are an ecological setting that is this research suggests that genetic
which it belongs, within the context that unique for this subspecies. differences may exist among the dipper
the DPS policy be used ‘‘sparingly’’ b. Loss of the population segment populations studied. However these
while encouraging the conservation of would result in a significant gap in the results are too preliminary to determine
genetic diversity (61 FR 4722; February range of taxon. the significance of the Black Hills
erjones on PROD1PC68 with PROPOSALS

7, 1996). This consideration may The petition claims that the Black population of American dipper to the
include, but is not limited to: (1) Hills dipper population is at the eastern taxon as a whole.
Evidence of the persistence of the edge of its global distribution, and its
discrete population segment in an loss would result in a significant gap in Finding
ecological setting that is unique for the the range of the dipper. Information We have reviewed the information
taxon; (2) evidence that loss of the readily available in our files (e.g., presented in the petition, and have

VerDate Aug<31>2005 14:54 Jan 25, 2006 Jkt 208001 PO 00000 Frm 00031 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\26JAP1.SGM 26JAP1
4344 Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 17 / Thursday, January 26, 2006 / Proposed Rules

evaluated that information in relation to DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:


information readily available in our
files. On the basis of our review, we find National Marine Fisheries Service Background
that the petition does not present Section 4(b)(3)(A) of the ESA, as
substantial scientific or commercial 50 CFR Parts 223 and 224 amended (16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.)
information to indicate that listing the [Docket No. 060113009–6009–01; I.D. requires that NMFS make a
American dipper in the Black Hills of 010506D] determination as to whether a petition
South Dakota may be warranted. This to list a species presents substantial
finding is based on the lack of Endangered and Threatened Species; scientific or commercial information
substantial scientific evidence to Notice of 90–day Finding on a Petition indicating that the petitioned action
indicate that the American dipper in the to List the North Pacific Right Whale as may be warranted. To the maximum
Black Hills of South Dakota constitutes an Endangered Species Under the extent practicable, this finding is to be
a valid DPS. Although the population is Endangered Species Act made within 90 days of the date the
discrete, neither the information in the petition was received, and the finding is
AGENCY: National Marine Fisheries
petition nor the information readily to be published promptly in the Federal
Service (NMFS), National Oceanic and
available in our files constitutes Register. If NMFS finds that substantial
Atmospheric Administration,
substantial scientific information that scientific information is presented, it is
Commerce.
the Black Hills dipper population is required to promptly commence a
ACTION: Notice of petition finding;
significantly unique in relation to the review of the status of the species
remainder of the taxon. Therefore, we request for information; and initiation of
status review. involved if one has not already been
conclude that the American dipper in initiated.
the Black Hills of South Dakota is not SUMMARY: NMFS announces a 90–day
a listable entity pursuant to section NMFS has made a 90–day finding on
finding regarding a petition to list the a petition to list the North Pacific right
3(15) of the ESA. We will not be North Pacific right whale, Eubalaena
commencing a status review in response whale. The petition, dated August 16,
japonica, as an endangered species 2005, was submitted by the Center for
to this petition. However, we will under the Endangered Species Act of
continue to monitor the taxon’s Biological Diversity, P.O. Box 40090,
1973, as amended (ESA). After review, Berkeley, CA 94704–4090, and was
population and status and trends, NMFS finds that the petition presents
potential threats, and ongoing received by NMFS on August 19, 2005.
substantial scientific information Petitioner requests NMFS to list the
management actions that might be indicating that this action may be
important with regard to the North Pacific right whale as a new
warranted. NMFS is initiating a review species, Eubalaena japonica, and to
conservation of the American dipper of the status of the North Pacific right
across its range. We encourage designate the species as endangered
whale, and is soliciting data, under the ESA. Its request is based, in
interested parties to continue to gather information, and comment on the
data that will assist with these part, on recent scientific information
subject action. which establishes a new taxonomic
conservation efforts. New information DATES: To be considered in the 12–
should be submitted to the Field classification for the right whale. This
month finding, information and reclassification would recognize the
Supervisor, South Dakota Ecological comments should be submitted to
Services Office (see ADDRESSES). North Pacific right whale as the new
NMFS by April 26, 2006. species E. japonica.
The petitioners also request that ADDRESSES: Data, information, or
critical habitat be designated for this NMFS has reviewed the petition, the
comments concerning this petition literature cited in the petition, and other
species. The petition does not present should be submitted to Kaja Brix,
substantial information that the literature and information available in
Assistant Regional Administrator, NMFS files. On the basis of that
American dipper is a DPS so we need Protected Resources Division, Alaska
not address the designation of critical information, we find the petition
Region, NMFS, Attn: Lori Durall. presents substantial scientific
habitat at this time. Comments may be submitted by: information indicating that the
• E-mail: 0648–XB41–
References Cited requested action may be warranted.
NPRW@noaa.gov. Include in the subject
NMFS’ finding is based in part on recent
A complete list of all references is line the following document identifier:
scientific papers recognizing the North
available upon request from the Field North Pacific Right Whale Listing. E-
Pacific right whale as genetically
Supervisor (see ADDRESSES). mail comments, with or without
distinct from the North Atlantic right
attachments, are limited to 5 megabytes.
Author • Mail: P.O. Box 21668, Juneau, AK whale, as well as recent findings of the
99802. International Whaling Commission on
The primary authors of this document • Hand delivery to the Federal the subject. We request any information
are staff at the South Dakota Ecological Building: 709 W. 9th Street, Juneau, regarding the taxonomy and status of
Services Office (see ADDRESSES). Alaska. the North Pacific right whale, its habitat,
• Fax: (907) 586–7012. biology, movements and distribution,
Authority
• Federal e-rulemaking portal: http:// threats to the species, or other pertinent
The authority for this action is the www.regulations.gov. information. A copy of the petition may
Endangered Species Act of 1973, as FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mr. be viewed at the NMFS website: http://
amended (16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.). Brad Smith, NMFS, 222 West 7th www.fakr.noaa.gov/protectedresources/
erjones on PROD1PC68 with PROPOSALS

Avenue, Anchorage, AK 99517, whales/default.htm


Dated: January 19, 2006.
telephone (907) 271–5006, fax (907) Authority
Thomas O. Melius,
271–3030, Ms. Kaja Brix, NMFS, (907)
Acting Director, Fish and Wildlife Service. 586–7235, fax (907) 586–7012; or Dr. The authority for this action is the
[FR Doc. E6–943 Filed 1–25–06; 8:45 am] Kate McFadden, NMFS, (301) 713–1401, ESA, as amended (16 U.S.C. 1531 et
BILLING CODE 4310–55–P fax (301) 427–2523. seq.).

VerDate Aug<31>2005 14:54 Jan 25, 2006 Jkt 208001 PO 00000 Frm 00032 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\26JAP1.SGM 26JAP1

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen