Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Home
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
Fiqh
Articles
Islamophobes
Dawah
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
UserRating:
/40
Poor
Best Rate
CreatedonTuesday,31December201300:08
WrittenbyAbdulBaseer
Hits:6912
Send
Like
35
Tweet
Share
Share
Bismillahhirrahmaan
nirraheem,
BahishtiZewarisoneofthefamousbooksofdeobandiswrittenontheissuesofWomen.Theauthorofthis
bookisMolanaAshrafAlithanwisahabandhewasoneofthepioneersofdeoband.Deobandisrecommend
thisbooktoprobablyeverydaughter,motherorsisterthatexistamongstdeobandis.Theyhighlypraisethis
bookandtheyregarditasoneofthetopandreliablebookonhanafifiqh.Thereisgoodinthisbookwithouta
doubt.ForexampleAshrafAlithanwisahabwritesabouttheimportanceoffollowingQuranandSunnah:
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
1/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
Translation:"ToActupontheHukmofQuranandHadeeth:TheProphetsalAllahualeyhiwasallamsaid:
"Whoeveradherestomysunnahwhenmyummahiscorrupt,(he)willhavetherewardofa100martyrs".and
theprophetsalAllahualeyhiwasallamsaid:IamleavingbehindtwothingsamongyouYouwillnevergo
astrayifyouholdfasttothem:OneisthebookofAllaahwhichmeansQuran,thesecondistheprophet's(s.a.w)
sunnahwhichmeanshadeeth."BahishtiZewarPart7QuranoHadeeskeHukmperChalna
Thisreferenceproves2thingsA)Ifweabidebythe
Quranandsunnah,wewillnevergoastrayandAlhamdulillahthis
dawahofcallingpeopletoQruanandSunnahisonlygivenanddone
byAhlulhadeethbutunfortunatelyalotofdeobandibrotherobjectto
thisdawahforuselessreasons.B)SunnahmeansHadeeth.Some
deobandibrothersobjectthatAhlulhadeethdoesnotmeanAhlu
SunnahbecausehadeethdoesnotmeanSunnah.Thisreferenceis
enoughfordeobandibrothersasaresponsetotheirobjection.
InAnotherplaceAshrafAliThanwisahbwrites:
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
2/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
Translation:"AllahandhisRasoolsalAllahualeyhiwasallamhaveshownallthematterspertainingtodeenin
theQuranandHadith.Tobringsomenewthingintothedeenisnotpermitted.Suchnewthingsareknownas
bid'aat(innovations).AninnovationisaMajorsin."BahishtiZewarPart1,AqeedokaBayaanMasla22
Thisisexactlythedawah,aqeedahandmanhajofteAhlulhadeethbutalotofourdeobandibrothersoftodaydo
notadheretothisatallandopposeusfortheexactsamemessageasmentionedbyAshrafAlithanwisahb.
Theyarebyfarfromthisbeliefwhichisveryverydangerous,Allaahknowsbestbutihaveseenpeoplethanking
ImamAbuHanifarahimahullahforgivingthemtheCOMPLETESALAHbecausetheybelievethatthesalah
wasntcompleteatthetimeoftheprophets.a.w.Comingbackthepoint,Webelievethatthemattersofdeenare
completeinQuranandHadeethanditisnicetoseethetruthbeingtoldtotheawaambuttruthofthematteris
thateventhisbookitselfi.eBahishtizewarhassomanythingsthatarenotfromQuranandhadeeth.
BahishtiZewarcontainsissuesthatareoutright
Blaspheme,issuesthatcontradicttheSunnah,issuesthatareno
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
3/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
wherefoundanywhereintheQuranandSunnahyettheyhave
beenmadeapartofdeen,thisbookcontainsinnovations,Xrated
stuffandmanymore.Ithasinnovationsandeveryinnovationis
misguidanceandmisguidanceleadstohellfire.Alotofour
deobandibrothersdonthavethisaqeedahandhencetheyindulge
invariousinnovationswhichyoucanseeintheotherreferences
thatihaveprovided.MolanaAshrafAlithanvihimselfsaysitsa
majorsinandyetthebookhassomanyinnovationsinitthat
havenothingtodowithQuranorhadeeth.
Idecidedtodothisarticleonlytoallowthepublictoopentheireyesandseetherealityofthisbook.
LetmemakeitclearthatmyintentionisnottohurtanyoneinshaAllahandyouarefreetoletmeknow
mymistakes.Iknowthatmajorityofthelaymanamongstdeobandiswontlikethisarticleonlydueto
theirloveforBahishtiZewarandAshrafAliThanwi,butItellyouinshaAllahthatbytheendof
thisarticleyouwillhavesomethingtothink.Onemustnotforgetthatourpriorityistofollowprophet
MuhammadsalAllahualeyhiwasallamandAllaahhasguaranteedJannahtousbyfollowingAllah
himselfandtheProphetsalAllahualeyhiwasallam.AshrafAlithanwisahbwillnotbebenefityouon
thedayofjudgementnorcanhedoyouanygoodinyourgrave.Mydutyistoonlyletyouknowthetruth
ofthisbooksoyoucangetridofthisdisturbingbookandgiveyourselvesanopportunitytostudythe
purebooksbasedonQuranandSahiHadeeth.MayAllaahhelpus,guideusandopenourheartsto
acceptthetruthfromQuranandSunnahandactuponit,Ameen.
IfIsayanythingcorrectinthisarticle,thenitisfromAllaah(subhanahuwataa'ala),andifIerred,then
thatisfrommeandshaytan.
Note:PagenumbersmayvaryfrompublishertopublishersoiwillinshaAllahonlymentionthepart,
headingandmaslanumbers.Theenglishtranslationofthisbookistremendouslyforgedtohidethe
reality.Theyhaventtranslatedagoodpartofthebookandonmanyocassionstheyhavetwistedthe
traslationSoiwillnotrelyingcompletelyonthetranslation.AnyonecancrosschecktheUrdureference
providedandcheckbacktheenglishtranslationtoknowtheforgeriesdoneoverthere.
ReturntoTop
ArticleContents
1)SevereInsulttotheQuranofAllaah
2)HowtoEnlargePrivatePartsRecipefromBahishtiZewarofAshrafAlithanwi
3)StepbyStepguidetoleavesalaah
4)RecipeforZina
5)InnovationsinWudhooA
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
4/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
6)InnovationsinWudhooB
7)FourrakaatsunnatbeforetheFardofIsha:Absolutelyprooflessandbaseless
8)WomenShouldprayNaked
9)InnovationsinFuneralPrayerJanazah
10)ReverseWudhoo
11)AmazingMajorsins
12)ConfusiononUtteringintentions
13)WritingDuaonKafanwithfingersonthechest&forehead
1)SevereInsulttotheQuranofAllaah
Translation:LabourPain:Writethisaayahonapieceofpaper,wrapitinacleanclothandtieitontheleft
thighofthewomanorReaditonasweetandallowhertoeatit.InshaAllahthechildwillbedeliveredeasily.
TheAayahis:
BahishtiZewarPart9,JhaarrPhoonkKaBayaan
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
5/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
ItriedalottofindthetranslationofthispartfromtheenglishtranslationofBahishtiZewarbutifailedand
couldntfinditanywhere.DeobandishavenottranslatedthispartandAllahknowsbest.Iamspeechlessabout
thetaweezbeingwrittenontheleftthighofawomanandthereaderiswiseenoughtorejectthisridiculousact
butIaskmybrothersandsistersthatadheretothisbooktopleasehelpmeincreasemyknowledgeforthesake
ofAllaahandtellmeifitsalrighttotiequranicaayahonthighsofwomen.
ThisblasphemoustaweezhasnothingtodowithQuran,sunnahorImamAbuHanifa(rahimahullah).Yetthis
bookisregardedasoneofthebestbooksonhanafifiqhandthisbooksaysallmatterspertainingtodeenare
mentionedinQuranandhadeethsoifthisisdeenthenitmustbesomewhereinQuranandhadeethbutitisnt.
2)HowtoEnlargePrivatePartsRecipefromBahishtiZewarof
AshrafAlithanwi
Translation:"Gotograveyardandbringback7bigants,killthemonebyoneandputtheminJasmineoilina
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
6/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
bottlethenburythatbottleingoat'sdroppingfordayandnight.Nextdaytakeitoutandmixtheseants
properlyintheoil.Rubyourprivatepartwiththickclothuntilitisreddishthenmassagethisoilonitandleave
itfor20mins."BahishtiZewarPart11,ChandMutafarrikNuskhay
Nowcananydeobandionearthtellmeifhecanshowthistohismother,daughterorsister?Leaveasidethem,
wecantevenshowittomeneither.SuchshamelessnesswallahiandallthisisdoneinthenameofFIQHand
Masaailofwomen.IsthisQuran,SunnahorImamAbuhanifa'sfiqh?
ThereareothernonsenselikethisinBahishtiZewarbutthisoneisenough.
Thiswasneversupposedtobedeen..Howhavethesepeoplemadeamockeryofwhatwassupposedtobea
revelationfromAllaah.WeasmuslimsarguewithChristiansandshowthemtheXratedstoriesinthebiblebut
whataboutthis?
3)StepbyStepguidetoleavesalaah
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
7/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
Translation:
"Masla9)Afterstandingupfromruku,apersondidnotrecite:SamiAllahulimanHamidaRabbanaLakal
HamdORinrukuhedidnotrecite:SubhaanaRabbiAlAdheemORinsajdahhedidnotrecite:Subhaana
RabbiAlAlaaORinthelastsittingpositionhedidnotreciteduroodafterattahiyyaat.Theninalltheabove
caseshissalaatwillbevalid,butitwillbecontrarytotheSunnah.Similarly,ifafterthedurood,hedidnotread
anydua,butmadesalaamimmediatelyafterrecitingdurood,thentoohissalaatwillbevalidbutcontrarytothe
Sunnah.
Masla10)ItisSunnahtoraisethehandsatthetimeofmakingintention.Ifonedoesnotraisehishands,itwill
stillbeproperbutcontrarytotheSunnah.
Masla17)IfapersondoesnotreadSurahFaatihahinthelattertworakaatsbutmerelyreadsSubhaanAllah
threetimes,eventhenhissalaatwillbeproper.However,itispreferabletoreciteSurahFaatihah.Andifhe
readsnothingatallandmerelyremainssilent,eventhenthereisnoharmandthesalaatwillbeproper.
BahishtiZewarPart2,NamaazParrhnaykaTareeqa(Methodofperformingsalaah).
SubhanAllah,thisistheirmethodofperformingfardsalaahandtheydebateusonRafayadain,sayingameen
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
8/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
loudlyandrecitingsurahalfaatihabehindtheimam.
StepbyStepGuideonhowtoleavenamaaz:
a)FirstleaveSamiAllaahuLimanHamida
b)ThenleaveSubhaanaRabbiAlAdheem
c)ThenleaveSubhaanaRabbiAlA'laa
d)Thenleaveoutduroodshareef
e)Thenleavetheduaafterduroodshareef
f)Andthenfinallyleavesurahfaatehaaswell.
Thebottomline,ifyoudontreadanythinginyoursalaah,stillitwillbeproperandcorrect.SubhanAllaah,this
isfardsalaahandiwonderwhatsleftbehindtoreciteinSalaah??
Heevensaysthatthisis"contrarytothesunnah"butheforgotthebasicusoolthatAllaahdoesnotaccepta
formofworshipifitsnotinaccordancetoQuranandSunnah.TheydebateusonRafayadain,ameenbiljahr,
recitingsurahalfatehabehindtheimaam...Whatstheuseofallthesedebateswhensuchrecipesaregivento
makeamockeryoftheworshipofAllaah?
SomedeobandissaythisisaboutapersonthatisnewtoIslamordoesntknowtheduas.Thatisnotthecase
hereatallandnorisitmentioned.TheissueisaboutrecitingandNOTreciting,ReadingandNOTReading.It
isntaboutsomeoneUnabletoreciteORCannotrecite.IfsomeoneisnewtoIslamandifheisunabletorecite
anythingthenAllaahwillinshaAllahaccepthissalaahevenifhedoesntknowanythingandstandsforprayer.
Further,thereferencestatesthattheprophets.a.wraisedhishandswhilemakingintentions.Thisisabuhtaan
onRasoolAllahsalAllahualeyhiwasallambecausetheprophetsalAllahualeyhiwasallamdidnotraisehis
handsatthetimeofmakingtheintentionforsalaahasstated.TheEnglishtranslationofBahishtiZewarhas
mistranslatedthispartas:
ItisSunnahtoraisethehandsATTHETIMEOFCOMMENCINGSALAAT
ThisisafailedattempttohidethetruthwhichdeobandisalwaysdototheonesthatCannotunderstandorread
urdu.TheyhaveforgedtranslationsoftheirownonoccasionstohidethetruthfromtheEnglishspeaking
public.
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
9/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
Iaskmydeobandibrothersagain..whichquranicaayahorhadeethorsayingofimamabuhanifamentionsall
this?
4)RecipeforZina
Translation:"Apersonhadsexualintercoursewithawomanaftermistakingherforhiswife.Hewillhaveto
givehermahrulmithlaswell,andthisintercoursewithherwillnotberegardedasadultery(zind)norwillthere
beanysin.Infact,ifthewomanfallspregnant,thelineageofthechildwillbeinorder.Itwillnotbetaintedand
itisnotpermissibletolabelthechildasbeingabastard.Themomentthemanrealizesthatthisisnothiswife,
heshouldimmediatelyseparatehimselffromheranditwillnotbepermissibleforhimtocontinuewiththe
intercourse.Itisalsowdjibonthiswomantoobservetheiddah.Itisnotpermissibleforhertostaywithher
husbandortoengageinsexualintercoursewithhim."BahishtiZewarPart4,Mahrkabayaanmasla16
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
10/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
Mydeobandibrothersandsisters,iaskyouforthesakeofAllaahtousesomebasiccommonsenseonthis
reference.WetakethefollowingteachingsfromthisrulingofAshrafalithanwiinbahishtizewar:
a)Apersonismistakenandhassexwithsomeoneelse'swife.ThisiscalledZinainanylanguagebutthisbook
'BahishtiZewar'saysitshouldnotbecalledZina.
b)HewillhavetogiveherMahrulmithlaswellwhichisapartofNikaah.
c)ThechildthatisbornwiththiszinashallnotbecalledHaraami(Bastard).
d)Thenwhenthemanrealisesthatsheisntmywife,thenheshouldstophavingsexwithherandleaveher.
e)ThewomanhowevermustnowobserveIddahandshecannotgobacktoherhusbandwithouttheIddahafter
havingdonezina.
Howonearthcansomeonehavingintercoursewithsomeone'swifenotbetermedasZina?Howonearthis
MahrulMithlapplicableandgiventotheonethatyouhadzinawith?Andhowonearthisthatchildbornnot
illegitimate?Whatshallicallthis....?IcanthelpbutcallthisarecipeforZina.Whatwasthewomandoingall
thistime?Wasshemistakenaswell?
Onebrother,mayAllaahguidehim,hetoldme"YOUDIDNTPRESENTANYTHINGFROMQURANAND
SUNNAHAGAINSTTHIS.THEREISWISDOMBEHINDTHISFIQH!!WHATIFTHISTAKESPLACEINAN
AREAWHERETHERE2COUPLESLIVING?!!"etcetc
Iwaswonderingthefollowingharshresponsebutididntgiveittohimbackthenbutnowimforcedtoshareit
coztheremightbepeoplelikehimreadingthisrightnow.SosomeonewanttojustifythisactofZinathenjust
putmeintheplaceofthat"mistakenperson"andputyourmotherinplaceofthatwoman.Orjustsupposethat
themistakenpersonisyourveryownbrotherandthewomanisurwifeormother.Willyouthengoaround
justifyingthis...?
ImverysorryimharshbutemotionscantbecontrolledwhenthesethingsarebeingattributedtoIslamwhenas
theyhavenothingtodowithIslam.ThisbookBahishtizewarisbeingdistributedinourwomenbythepeople
thathaveneverbotheredreadingitthemselves.They'vejustheardacertainsectarianmullahpraisingthebook
becausehiselderwroteit.Andhencewebeingtheblindfollowersthatweare,wejusttakethebookandsay
'WOWWHATABOOK'whereasithasabsolutelynoreferencefromwhereitstakingthesefatwasandmasaail.
Allthisisdoneinthenameof"Hanafifiqh".ThisdirthasnothingtodowithIslamorimamabuhanifa(rah)
andwerejectthisfabricateddirt.
MybrothersandsistersthisisnotfromanyQuranicaayatoranyhadeethinthetreasuresofahadeethtodothis
practiceandimsureinshaAllahthatthisisntevenmentionedbyImamAbuHanif(rah).
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
11/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
5)InnovationsinWudhooA
Translation:Whilemakingwudu,wordlytalkshouldbeavoided.Instead,BismillahandtheKalimashouldbe
readonwashingeachandeverypart
Afterhavingperformedthewudu,Surahalqadrshouldberecited.[BahishtiZewar,Wuzooka
Bayaan,Maslano.9andmaslano.13]
Brothersandsisters,theprophetsalAllahualeyhiwasallamnevertaughthisUmmahanythingtoberecited
duringWudhoonordidhetaughtustoreciteSurahAlQadrafterwudhoo.
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
12/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
TheProphets.a.wtaughtustosay"Bismillah"beforeWudhoo,thereisnoDuaduringtheWudhoo,thereafter
onehascompleteddoingWudhoohemustsay:
OR
OR
ThereisnosuchthingasRecitingSurahAlQadrorrecitingbismillahandKalimauponwashingeachandevery
partduringwudhoo.ItsnotintheQuran,sunnahoranywherebyImamabuhanifarahimahullah.
MayAllahguideusallandmayAllahprotectusfromeverykindsofinnovations(Bidat)inIslam.Ameen.
TheProphets.a.wsaid:"everyinnovationismisguidanceandallmisguidanceisintheHellfire."Sunanan
Nasaa'ee(1/224)
6)InnovationsinWudhooB
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
13/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
BahishtiZewarPart1WuzooKa
BayaanMasla4
Translation:"AfterhavingmadeWudhooifonehasadoubtthataparthasnotbeenwashedbuthedoesnot
knowexactlywhichpartitwas.Inordertogetridofthisdoubt,heshouldwashhisleftfoot."BahishtiZewar
Part11,HadaseAsgharYaaniBayWuzooHonaykiHaalatkeAhkaam,Maslano.6
Mybrothersandsisters,thisisnotfromanyQuranicaayahoranyhadeethinthetreasuresofahadeethandim
sureinshaAllahthatthisisntevenmentionedbyImamAbuHanifa(rahimahullah).Fromwhereisthanwisahb
gettingthesethings?
7)FourrakaatsunnatbeforetheFardofIsha:Absolutelyproofless
andbaseless
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
14/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
BahishtiZewarPart2SunnatAur
NafalNamaazoKaBayaan
Translation:Ateshatime,itisbetterandmustahabtofirstofferfourrakaatsofSunnah,thenthefour
rakaatsoffard[BahishtiZewar,Part2,SunnataurNafalNamazokabayaanMaslano.5]
Alotofourbelovedbrothersanddearsistershavemade4rakaatsunnahbeforeIshaasapartofDeenandthey
callitSunnahorratherSunnatGhairMuwakkada.WeknowthatSunnatGhairmuwakkadaisthesunnahwhich
theprophets.a.wdidntdoregularly.Thatmeansifthese4rakaatareSunnatGhairMuwakkadathenSurely
thereshouldbejustoneproofatleasttoshowthattheprophetsalAllahualyhiwasallamprayedthese4rakaat
butwallahithereisnotasinglehadeethwithSahiorHasanchainwhichevenindicatesthattheprophetsal
Allahualyhiwasallamoffered4rakaatsunnahbeforeIshafard.
MolanaYusufBinoriwritesinMaarifusSunanSharhJaamiTirmidhi,Pagenumber115that:
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
15/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
MaarifAlSunan
Roughtranslation:Afteralotofhardwork,Icouldnotfindanyhadeethinthehadeethbookswhich
mentions4rakaahbeforeIsha
ThenonPage116hehaswrittenthat:
Roughtranslation:Thehanafibooksarefilledwiththementionof4rakaatbeforeIshasoMaybethereis
proofforitinthebooksthatareAimatnalMakhtootaorthebooksthathavebeenwasted.
ImunabletotranslateAimatnalmakhtootafornowsopleasepardonme.
Muftitaqiusmanitriedtojustifythese4rakaatwithaproofofhisbutAlhamdulillahattheendhemakeitclear
thattheprophets.a.wdidntdeterminetheserakaatandthatsmywholepoint.Hesaysattheendofhisfatwa
that:
However,itshouldbeborneinmindthatthese4rakatsshouldnotbetakenasdeterminedby
Nabi(SallallahuAlaihiWasallam),norasaspecificSunnah.
http://www.askimam.org/public/question_detail/15881
Withthisstatementhehasbasicallydismissedthepositionofnearlyallofthehanafifiqhwhichholdstheview
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
16/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
thattheprophets.a.wprayed4rakaatsunnahghairmuwakkada.
However,Idohavedoubtsoverhisattempttojustifythis4rakaatwiththehadeethofSahiAlBukhari.Thelink
providedsays:
OnthebasisofthisHadith,MuslimJuristshaveinferredthatitismustahab(desirable)to
performsomeprayer,naflorsunnah,beforeeveryobligatoryprayer,exceptbeforeMaghrib,
accordingtotheHanafiMazhab.
Youcanseehowheaddedtheexceptionbeforemaghrib.ThehadeethofSahiAlBukhariwhichmuftiTaqi
UsmaniusedisnarratedbyAbdullahbinMughaffalAlMuzani.NowthesameSahabinarratesanothersimilar
hadeethwhichismentionedinSahiAlBukhari.
Chapter:The(optional)Salat(prayer)beforethe(compulsory)Maghribprayers,Hadeeth#1183
NarratedAbdullhAlMuzani:
TheProphet,said,Perform(anoptional)Salat(prayer)beforethe(compulsory)Maghrib
prayers.He(repeateditthrice)andthethirdtime,hesaid,Whoeverwantstoofferit,candoso,lest
thepeopleshouldtakeitasaSunnah.
Theexactsamesahabimakesitclearthatthereisanafalprayerbeforemaghribsalahandhedidnotgiveany
exceptiontomaghribSalaahbutmuftitaqiusmaniusedahadeethnarratedbytheexactsamesahabiandgives
anexceptiontothemaghribsalaah.ItslikeJustifyingsomethingthathasnoproofanywhereandleavingout
somethingthathasprooffromthesameproofthatonehaspresented.Thenafalbeforemaghribsalaahhas
itsdaleelandthe4rakaatSunnatghairmuwakkadahasnodaleel.Thereisnoexceptionformaghribsalaahin
thishadeethatallandthedaleelprovidedbyhimappliestothenafalbeforemaghribsalaahaswell.Itdoesnot
haveanyexceptionformaghribsalaaheitherwhichnegatesthemajorityoftheposition
ofhanafifiqh.Allaahknowsbest.
8)WomenShouldprayNaked
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
17/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
BahishtiZewarPart2NamazKiSharto
KaBayaanMasla6
Translation:Iftheentireclothingisimpure,ormostofitisimpure,i.elessthanaquarterofitispureand
thebalanceofitisimpure,theninsuchacaseonecouldeitherofferthesalahwhilewearingthoseimpure
clothesorREMOVETHECLOTHESANDOFFERTHESALAHWHILENAKED.However,itispreferableto
offertheSalahwiththeimpureclothes.BahishtiZewarPart2,NamazkiSharokaBayaan,Maslano.6
Thebrothersthatadheretothisbook,theysaytheirImaminPeripherals(Furoo'Masaail)isImamAbuHanifa,
theysaytheproofofa(deobandi)muqallidisonlythesayingofhisImam(AbuHanifa)andthatBahishtiZevar
isOneofthebestbooksonHanafifiqh.Howevertheabovereferenceofwomenprayingsalaahwhilenakedis
notmentionedanywherebyImamAbuHanifa(rahimahullah).Thisisnothanafifiqh,thisisnotwhatImam
AbuHaneefaeversaidoreverwrote.ThisissueisalsonotmentionedanywhereintheQuranandSunnah.
ItshouldbenotedhoweverthatImamshaf'eehasmentionedasimilarfatwainHisKitaabulUmmbutitisnot
endorsedandthemajorityoftheUlamadonotadheretothatfatwaofImamShaf'ee.
ShaykhAlIslaamIbnTaymiyyahrahimahullahsays:
"Whatifapersoncannotfindanythingbutanimpuregarment?Itwassaidheshouldpraynaked,orheshould
praywearingitandrepeattheprayer,orheshouldprayinitandnotrepeattheprayer,andthisisthemost
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
18/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
correctofthescholarlyviews.."IbnTaymiyyah[Majmoo'Alfataawa22/34,35]
DeobandiulamadonotconsiderImamShafeeasproofnordotheygiveaniotaofimportancetohim.Ifthey
hadgivensomeimportancetoImamShafee,ImamMaalikorImamAhmadbinHanbalrahimahullahthen
surelytheywouldneverhaveobjectedtotheirAqeedahofTawheedorviewssuchasRafaYadain(Raisingofthe
hands)beforeRukooandafterRukooorsayingAameenloudlyorprayingSurahAlFatehabehindtheImam.
Allofthese3imamsdidrafayadainbeforerukooandafterrukooastheyregardeditastheSunnahofthe
prophetsalAllahualeyhiwasallambutdeobandisinreturnattacktheonesthatdorafayadain,theyridicule
them,mockthem,makefunofthemandtheytrytorefutetheminvainaswell.
SothemostcorrectviewisthatOneshouldprayinitandnotrepeattheprayer.Allaahknowsbest.Offering
salaatnakedisnotfromhanafifiqhorImamAbuHanifaneitherisitanywherementionedinQuranand
Sunnah.
9)InnovationsinFuneralPrayerJanazah
BahishtiZewarPart11JanaazayKe
NamazKeMasaail
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
19/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
Translation:"TheSunnahandMustahabMethodofJanazahsalaatisasfollows:Thedeceasedshouldbe
placedinthefrontandtheImamshouldstandinlinewithhischest.Everyoneshouldmakethefollowing
intention:
"IintendofferingtheJanaazahsalaatforthepleasureofAllahTa'alaandasaduaforthedeceased."Bahishti
ZewarPart11,JanaazaykiNamazkeMasaail,Maslano.13
AshrafAliThanwisahbmentionsthe"SUNNAHANDMUSTAHABMETHOD"ofSalatulJanaazahbutthenhe
startsoffwithanintentionthatisnowherementionedinAnySunnah.Therearenowordsofintentionfor
salaatuljanaazahoranyformofsalaahanywhereintheQuranorhadeeth.AshrafAlithanwiincludedthisas
thesunnahwhereasitisnotthesunnahbyanymeanswhatsoever.
10)ReverseWudhoo
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
20/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
BahishtiZewarPart1WuzooKa
BayaanMasla4
Translation:Sunnahistomakewuduexactlyashasbeenmentionedabove.butifanyonealtersorreverses
theprocedureofwudhu,eg.bywashingthefeetfirst,thenmakingmasah,andthenwashingthehands,and
thereafterwashingtheface,oralterstheprocedureinanyotherwayThenwuduwillstillberegardedas
complete.However,itwillnotbeconsideredtobeinaccordancewiththesunnah,andthereisalwaysthefearof
havingsinned.Similarly,Ifthelefthandortheleftfootiswashedfirst,wuduwillbecompleted,butitwillbe
contrarytobeingmustahab.BahishtiZewarPart1,WuzookaBayaaan,Maslano.4
OncetherewasoneofourbrotherswhojustaskedadeobandibrotherhowitistoperformWudutheotherway
around?(asmentionedinBahishtiZewar).TheDeobandibrothergaveanemotionalanswerthat"Thisisthe
WudhooofShias".TheDeobandibrotherdidntknewthatAshrafAliThanwihadthesamereverseprocedure
ofWudooinhisbook.Khair,AllaahcompletedHisDeen1400yearsbackandOneofTheCrucialCriteriasof
AllaahacceptingourA'maalisthatithastobeaccordancetotheSunnah.IfitsnotinaccordancetotheSunnah
thennomatterhowsugarcoatedtheactlookslike,Allaahdoesnotacceptit.Thisreversemethodisnowherein
thedeenofAllaahandthisisaninnovationinthedeenofAllaah.TheProphets.a.wsaid:
"everyinnovationismisguidanceandallmisguidanceisintheHellfire."SunananNasaa'ee(1/224)
Somedeobandisjustifythisbyreferringtothevariantofmethodofwudhoowhichtheprophets.a.wdidon
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
21/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
occasions.TheyalsoquotesomeulamasayingthatthesequenceofWudhooisntnecessary.
Wetellthemthatthesemethodsoftheprophets.a.whavenothingtodowiththeforged"ReverseWudoo".
RathertheyaretheVariousmethodsofdoingwudoofromtheprophets.a.w.Alhamdulillahourmadhabas
AhlulhadeethisnottoholdontoOnemethodfromtheProphets.a.wanddismissothersbylabellingitwitha
sect.WeaccepteverySunnahthatisprovenfromtheprophets.a.w.Weacceptthevariantmethodsbutwedont
fabricateamethodofourownratherwesticktothevariantmethodswhichtheprophets.a.wdidtoshowus
thatthesequenceisntnecessary.
11)AmazingMajorsins
BahishtiZewarPart1BaazBarray
BarrayGunaah
BahishtiZewarPart1,BaazBarraybarrayGunaahjinkekarnewaalayperbohtsakhtiaayihai.
Thetitleofthissectiontranslatedintoenglishmeans"SomeMajorSinsregardingwhichsevere
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
22/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
warningshavebeenmentioned".InthissectionAshrafAlithanwisahbmadealistedsuchmajorsins
andinthislistheincluded:
a)ToComplainorlistentocomplain.
b)Tobejoyfuluponriseofpricesofgood.
c)Somewomenplayandgirlsplay"Budbudkeguttay"oranyothergame.ThisisalsoGambling.
Mybrothersandsistersthese3actsareincludedinBahishtiZevar'slistofMajorSins.BahishtiZevaris
supposedtobeabookofHanafifiqh.Ifailtorealiseastohowarethesethingsevenlistentobesinsandiwould
lovetoknowanyQuranicAayahoranyauthentichadeethoranyauthenticreferencetoImamAbuHanifaabout
these3thingstobeMajorsins.AtleastinshaAllahwecanhavecluethatComplainingorlisteningtoaComplain,
expressingjoyontheincreaseofpriceofgoodsorgirlsplayingareMajorsins.InshaAllahiwillappreciateyour
timeandefforttohelpmeunderstandbutfornowidontthinkthesethingsareanywhereneartobecalledasin
anywhereinQuran,SunnahorAnySayingofImamAbuHanifarahimahullah.
Isitasintocomplainandtolistentoit?
CheckthislinkinshaAllahtohaveanideaofhowmuchthesahabacomplainedandhowmuchtheprophetsal
Allahualeyhiwasallamheardtheircomplainsonvariousissues:www.sunnah.com/search/complain
Isitasinifthemarketvalueofmygoodsareincreasedandiexpressjoyoveritsoicanearnafewmorerupees?
Istillrememberthatmydearfriendwasworkinginautilitystoreandhewouldbehappythedaythepricesgot
increasedbarely5rupeesormoreonacertainRunningproduct.Itwouldhelphimearnmoreandpayoffhis
rentseasily.Sobasicallythepoorguywascommittingamajorsin?
Ifsomegirlsplay"budbudkeguttay"oranyothergame,isthatgambling?
Ihonestlycannottranslatebudbudkeguttaysopleasepardonmeformyshortcomingsbutifgirlsplayany
game...isthatgambling?
Note:TheenglishtranslationofBahishtiZewarhasforgedthetranslationofthesewordsandtheyhavetranslateditas
follows:
Tocomplainagainstsomeone,ortohearsuchacomplaint.
Toexpressjoyontheriseandinflationofthevalueofcommoditiesorgoods.
Togamble.Somewomenandgirlsplaycertaingameswithstakesonthem.Thisisalsoakindofgambling.
Thisisanabsolutelyfalsetranslationandanyonethatcanunderstandandreadurdu,hecanseeitforitself.
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
23/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
12)ConfusiononUtteringintentions
BahishtiZewarPart2NiyyatKarneKaBayaan
Translation:"Itisnotnecessarytomakeaverbalintention.IfapersonthinksinhisheartthatIamreading
thefardofZuhrfortoday,orifitisaSunnah,thenIamreadingtheSunnahofzuhrthenthiswillbesufficient.
Allthoselengthyintentionswhicharepopularamongthepeoplearenotnecessaryatall.
Ifsalaatofseveraldayshasbeenmissedthenoneshouldalsospecifythedayanddatewhenmakingthe
intention..
Ifheismakingqadaforseveralmonthsoryears,heshouldalsospecifythemonthandyearandsay:Iam
offeringtheqadaoffajrsalaatofaparticulardayinaparticularmonthandinaparticularyear"Bahishti
ZewarPart2,Niyyatkarnekabayaan.
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
24/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
Scholarshaveagreedthatintentionisessentialconditionforanyworshippingacttobeaccepted.RasoolAllah
salAllahualeyhiwasallamsaid:"Deedsdependuponintentions,andeverypersongetsbutwhathehas
intended..."[SahiBukhari,SahiMuslim].Ihavecollectedbasically2pointsfromthesectionof"Niyyatka
bayaan"fromBahishtiZevar.Thequestionhereisnotabouttheintentionbutitisabout"UTTERING"the
intentionverballylike"Niyyatkartahoon4rakaatfarzmoomerakaabakitarafetcetc".
TheMaslano.1asstatedbyMolanathanviisveryrightwithoutadoubt.Theplaceofintentionistheheart,not
thetongue.Thereisnoneedfortheverbalintentiontobemadeforsalaah.TheprophetsalAllahualeyhi
wasallamdidntteachthistousnorwasitdonebythesahaba.Nothingisprovenaboutthisfamousverbal
intentionfromQuranandSunnahatall.
Butthenalmostalloftheremainingsectionof"Niyyatkabayaan"fromBahishtiZevarisfullofintentions,what
tosayorhowtoutteretcetc.Ijustsharedonereferencei.eMaslano.6togiveanexample.Allthesewordsfor
intentionsandexampleshavenothingtodowithQuranandSunnah.TheyarenttaughttousintheQuran,nor
aretheyanywherepresentinthesacredSahiAhadeethofRasoolAllahsalAllahualyhiwasallam.
ShaikhulIslamibnTaymiyyahrahimahullahthrowslightonthisissueofverbalintention:
http://www.islamqa.com/en/ref/13337
Alsosomereferencesfromthehanafi,shafi,hanbaliandmaalikischoolofthoughts:
http://www.ahlalhdeeth.com/vbe/showthread.php?t=133
AllamaIbnHammaam,AllamaIbnAlQayyimandAllamaIbnbaazhavealsoagreedanddeclaredtheverbal
intentiontobeaninnovation.
UtteringtheintentionverballyisdefinetelynotfromtheSunnahanditoughttobeavoided.Itshouldbedonein
theheartasstatedbytheoverwhelmingmajorityoftheUlama.
13)WritingDuaonKafanwithfingersonthechest&forehead:
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
25/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
BahishtiZewarPart11JanaazayKe
MutafarrikMasaail
Translation:"ItispermissibletowriteadualikeEhadNaamaonthekafanofthemayyatjustbymovingthe
fingerswithoutusingapenORbismillahirrahmaanirraheemonhischestortheKalma"LailaahailAllah
MuhammadurRasoolullah"onhisforehead(bymovingthefingers),however,thispracticehasnoprooffrom
anysahihhadith.Therefore,thispracticeshouldnotberegardedassunnahormustahab".BahishtiZewar
Part9,JanaazaykeMutafarrikMasaailno.13
Thanwisahbhimselfsaysthatthismethodofwritingkalmaorbismillahisnotinanysahihhadeethnorisit
mustahabyethesaysitispermissible.Thanwisahbpreviouslysaidthatallmatterspertainingtodeenare
mentionedinQuranandHadeeth.SoifthisisapartofdeenthenwhichQuranicaayahorhadeethisusedto
justifythis??
None.
Therearemanymanyotherreferencesbutiwillendmyarticleoverhere.Iaskthereaderstopleasethinkover
thepointsihavementioned.MyintentionisinshaAllahtocallyoutoQuranandSunnah,idontintendtohurt
youbutexposingthetruthismyduty.Ifihaveerredthenyouhavetherighttocorrectmebutifiamrightthen
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
26/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
itisObligatoryuponyoutocorrectyourselfaccordingtoQuranandSunnah.ByAllahweaskyoutocorrect
youraffairsaccordingtoQuranandSunnah,ifyoursectorthanwisahbismoredeartoyouthennothingwill
haveaneffectonyou.butifAllaahorhisprophetsalAllahualeyhiwasallamorthedeenofAllaharemore
importantthenyouwilldefinetelythinkofcomingtotherightpathofQuranandSunnahwhichisnothingbut
thepathofAhlulhadeeth.IntheendiaskAllahtoforgivemyshortcomings.IaskAllahtoaccepttheseefforts,
Ameen.
BahishtiZewarbyAshrafAliThanwiisnotabookforanymanorwoman.Allahknowsbest.
Deoband
hanafifiqh
<PreviousArticleInshallah:DebatebetweenIbnalMubarakandahlalkufa
NextArticleInshallah:DeobandRejectSahabaSayings>
Newernewsitems:
DebatebetweenIbnalMubarakandahlalkufa12/04/201520:37
Oldernewsitems:
DeobandRejectSahabaSayings18/09/201315:34
DeobandRejectsIjmaConsensus02/09/201302:29
DeobandProofs:AhlulHadeetharenotonlyMuhadditheen28/07/201321:49
MirzaGhulamAhmadQadianiwasHanafi07/07/201307:30
TaqleedProhibitedMuhadditheenwerenotMuqallidpart205/06/201311:40
Randomnewsitems:
TaqleedProhibited:100ProofsSalafusSaliheenwerenotMuqallideen07/05/201210:26
Read14226times
MirzaGhulamAhmadQadianiwasHanafi07/07/201307:30Read10613times
TaqleedProhibited:MuhadditheenwerenotMuqallidpart130/05/201316:00Read3497
times
ImamAbuDawoodwasnotaMuqallid13/12/201211:57Read2952times
DeobandrejectsImamAbuHanifainFiqh24/06/201212:28Read17603times
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
27/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
Who'sOnline
Wehave57guestsandnomembersonline
DISCLAIMER::Copyrights20082014SystemofLife!ThiswebsiteDOESNOTbelongto
anypoliticaloranyparticularsectordenomination.Thecontentsonthiswebsitedonot
necessarilyreflecttheviewsofsystemoflife.com.Wearenotaffiliatedwithanyofthe
organizations.Itisanindependentsitewithoutanydirectorindirectlinktoanyofthe
organizations.Youarenotonlygivenpermission,butencouragedtocopy,printandotherwise
reproduceanddistributeinanyformat,articlesfromthiswebsitetoteachothersaboutIslam,
aswidelyaspossible.WebelievethatALLIslamicKnowledgeisPropertyofAllah,andassuch
itisourduty,asMuslimstospreadknowledge.Wejustaskthatyouractivityshouldbefor
spreadingAllahAlmighty'sTruthandnotformakingprofits.IfyouhaveanyqueryonIslam,
thenpleaseforwarditto:Thisemailaddressisbeingprotectedfromspambots.Youneed
JavaScriptenabledtoviewit.WeareNOTSCHOLARS.Wequoteopinions&fatwasof
Scholars&fromtheirbooks.IfyouwanttocontactaScholarthengohere:Islamqa,
AssimAlHakeem,IslamwebJazakallahKhayran(MayAllahrewardyouwithgooddeeds).
AssalamualaikumwaRahmatullahiWaBarkatahu(MayPeaceBlessings&MercyofAllahbe
onYou)
SearchIslamicArticlesbyCloudTagsInshallah
abudawudabuwalidaddarAhlulBidahAhlulhadeethAllahAboveArsh
AskingfromDead
Aqeedah
BareilvisbelowtheanklesBidahCreedDeoband
draggingDreamsFiqhForbiddengraveworshiphanafifiqhHanafischolarsHazirNazirHijabibnabdulbarr
ibndihyaibnhajaribnjareerIbnKathirIbnTamiyaIlmeGhayb
ImamAbuHanifaImamAbuShaamah
imammaalikIntercessionisbaalistegathaistigathaJaalHaqknowledgeofunseenLifeofIbnTaymiyyahmaaliki
scholarsMadhabmalikmalikaddarmarzooqmarzuqMawlidmilaad
Muhadditheen
MuqallidmuqallideenNajdiProphetofmercyProphetomnipresentqaahirahQadiyanisRamadan
SalafSalafiSalahSectsShaitanshiaShirkSufisSunnahTahirulQuadriTakfeer
taqlidTaraweeh
Taqleed
TawassulvisitinggravesWahdatulwajoodwaseelaWaseelahwasilaWeak
hadeethzawawi
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
28/28