Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Abstract
Introduction: Various electrocardiogram (ECG) patterns can determine the site of occlusion in culprit coronary artery in
ST-elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI) and the size of the myocardium that is jeopardized. Objectives: The aim of this study
was to assess diagnostic accuracy of the ECG localization of culprit vessel occlusion site as compared to coronary angiographic
findings. Material and methods: ECG criteria for localization of culprit vessel occlusion site were specified and patients with
STEMI (n = 21) were divided into three groups: Groups I, II and III, according to the localization of culprit vessel occlusion site
in left anterior descending (LAD), right coronary artery (RCA) and left circumflex (LCx) coronary arteries, respectively. Group I
was further divided into four subgroups: Ia, Ib, Ic and Ib+c according to whether occlusion in LAD was proximal to both first
septal (S1) and first diagonal (D1) branches, distal to S1 but proximal to D1 branches, distal to both S1 and D1 branches or distal
to S1 branch, respectively. Group II was further divided into two subgroups: IIa and IIb according to whether occlusion in RCA
was proximal or distal to RV branch, respectively. The results of coronary angiograms were compared with those predicted by
ECG. Results: The positive predictive accuracy (PPA) and negative predictive accuracy (NPA) of ECG criteria for LAD, RCA and
LCx coronary arteries were 90.91% and 100%, 90% and 100%, and undetermined and 90.48%, respectively. Among subgroups,
the sensitivity of ECG criteria was maximum for groups Ib+c and IIb (100%) followed by Group IIa (71.43%), Group Ic (50%),
Group Ia (42.86%) and least for Group Ib (0%). The specificity was maximum for Groups Ia and IIa (92.86%) followed by
Group Ib (90%), Group IIb (89.47%), Group Ic (78.95%) and Group Ib+c (77.78%) in that order. The PPA and NPA for Groups Ia,
Ib, Ic, Ib+c, IIa and IIb were 75% and 76.47%, 0% and 94.74%, 20% and 93.75%, 42.86% and 100%, 83.33% and 86.67% and 50%
and 100%, respectively. Conclusion: The present study demonstrates that ECG is an easily and widely available inexpensive
tool to localize site of occlusion in culprit vessel in acute STEMI.
590
cardiology
ECG Criteria to Identify Site of Occlusion in LAD (in
AWMI)
Criteria
1. Any one or more of the following
i. Complete RBBB
ii. ST V1 > 2.5 mm
iii. ST aVR
iv. ST V5
v. New onset LAHB
2. Q in aVL
3. Any one or more of the following
Occlusion site
Proximal to S1
i. ST II 1.0 mm
ii. Maximum ST appeared in V2
4. Q in V5
5. ST aVL
6. No ST III
Proximal to D1
Proximal to S1
and/or D1
Distal to S1
Distal to D1
Distal to S1 and/or D1
6. Max ST V2-V3
7. ST V7-V9
RCA
Present
Present
LCx
Absent
Absent
<1.2
T-wave upright
>1.2
Inverted
T-wave
Present
Absent (present in
occlusion of dominant
RCA causing posterior
wall MI)
Absent
Absent (present if RCA
dominant)
Present
Present
Proximal to RV
branch
ST 1 mm
Present
Present
Distal to RV
branch
No ST
Absent
Absent
< 0.5
Present
Present
Absent
Absent
591
cardiology
which is the terminal portion of a wraparound LAD.
Number (%)
55.09 10.08
Current smoker
BMI SD
9 (42.86%)
(kg/m2)
22.56 3.54
2 (9.52%)
Hypertension (HT)
6 (28.57%)
7 (33.33%)
11 (52.38%)
8 (38.10%)
7 (33.33%)
8 (38.10%)
13 (61.90%)
4 (19.05%)
4 (19.05%)
Sensitivity (%)
Specificity (%)
PPA (%)
NPA (%)
42.86
92.86
75.00
76.47
Ib
0.00
90.00
0.00
94.74
Ic
50.00
78.95
20.00
93.75
Ib+c
100.00
77.78
42.86
100.00
100.00
90.91
90.91
100.00
IIa
71.43
92.86
83.33
86.67
IIb
100.00
89.47
50.00
100.00
II
100.00
91.67
90.00
100.00
III
0.00
100.00
90.48
Ia
592
cardiology
ST-segment depression in aVR is more likely to occur
with LCx occlusion. An injury vector leftward enough
to cause ST-segment elevation in lead I is common with
LCx occlusion, but rare with RCA occlusion. Second,
the RCA provides almost all of the blood supply to the
right ventricle, which is rightward as well as anterior
to left ventricle. When the RCA is occluded proximal
to one or more of its major RV branches, ST-segment
elevation is likely to be seen in lead V4R. Similarly,
the ST-segment in lead V1 (V2R) may be elevated
even when the more leftward precordial leads show
ST-segment depression due to the posterior injury
that so frequently accompanies acute IWMI. Evidence
of acute RV infarction is important, not only because
it identifies the RCA as harboring the culprit lesion,
but especially because it predicts a greatly increased
morbidity and mortality. Consequently, right precordial
leads or at least lead V4R should be recorded in all
patients with acute IWMI. ST-segment depression in V1
and V2 indicates posterior injury and is typical of LCx
occlusion.
Mortality and morbidity in part are determined by the
location of the occlusion. For example, in patients with
inferior MI who have RV infarction, the culprit artery
virtually always is the RCA. Such patients, including
those in whom ECG evidence of RV MI is masked, are
at increased risk for death, shock and arrhythmias,
including atrioventricular block.2 Thus, identifying the
culprit artery in acute IWMI helps define those in whom
aggressive reperfusion strategies are likely to yield
most benefit. Coronary arteriography is the best means
of determining the culprit artery in acute IWMI. When
both the RCA and LCx are severely diseased, however,
deciding which one is the culprit can be difficult and
having an independent predictor of the culprit artery,
such as the ECG, can be very helpful.
Engelen et al in a study of patients with AWMI showed
that for different ECG criteria we used in our study to
localize LAD occlusion proximal to S1 and/or D1 (i.e.,
patients in group Ia and Ib in the present study), the
sensitivity, specificity, PPA and NPA varied from 12% to
44%, 85 to 100%, 67 to 100% and 61 to 70%, respectively.3
Similar figures for ECG criteria to localize occlusion
in LAD distal to S1 and/or D1 (i.e., patients in Group
Ib and Ic in the present study) were 22-41%, 86-95%,
77-92% and 46-53%, respectively.
In a study by Herz et al in patients with inferior wall
AMI, the sensitivity to localize RCA occlusion varied
from 55% to 94%.4 The specificity, PPA and NPA varied
from 71% to 100%, 88% to 100% and 29% to 75%,
respectively. The sensitivity, specificity, PPA and NPA
593
cardiology
Table 3. Diagnostic Accuracy of Different ECG Criteria in AWMI (Engelen et al3)
IRA
ECG criteria
Sensitivity
LAD distal to S1
NPA
ST aVR*
43
95
86
70
36
100
100
68
ST III 1.0 mm
60
71
60
71
ST III 2.5 mm
33
97
88
67
ST aVF 1.0 mm
52
84
71
71
ST aVF 2.0 mm
26
97
85
64
cRBBB*
14
100
100
62
ST V5 1.0 mm*
17
98
88
62
ST V1 2.5 mm*
12
100
100
61
ST II 1.0 mm*
34
98
93
68
ST III 1.0 mm
66
75
64
76
ST III 2.5 mm
32
95
81
67
ST aVF 1.0 mm
54
85
71
72
ST aVF 2.0 mm
27
97
85
66
Q aVL*
44
85
67
69
Absence of ST II
67
74
78
62
Absence of ST III*
34
86
77
49
Absence of ST aVF
45
90
87
54
Q V6
17
100
100
47
Q V 5*
Q V4
LAD distal to D1
PPA
ST II 1.0 mm*
LAD proximal to S1
LAD proximal to D1
Specificity
24
93
82
47
55
69
71
53
Absence of ST II
66
73
78
60
Absence of ST III*
41
95
92
53
Absence of ST aVF
44
90
87
53
STaVL*
22
95
87
46
*Criteria used in the present study; AWMI: Anterior wall myocardial infarction; IRA: Infarct related artery; NPA: Negative predictive accuracy,
PPA: Positive predictive accuracy, ST: ST-segment elevation; ST: ST-segment depression.
al4
Kosuge et
al5
Verouden et al8
Verouden et
al8
Zimetbaum et al9
ECG criteria
IRA
Sensitivity
Specificity
PPA
NPA
Various criteria
RCA
55-94
71-100
88-100
29-75
LCx
88
100
100
97
RCA proximal to
RV branch (<0.5)
91
91
88
93
RCA distal to RV
branch (>0.5, <1.2)
84
93
91
88
LCx (>1.2)
84
95
73
98
RCA
70
72
RCA
90
RCA
70
72
90
39
Chia et al10
RCA
76
66
89
42
Bairey et al11
ST in I
RCA
79
61
89
44
Bairey et al11
ST in aVL
RCA
95
24
82
56
IRA: Infarct related artery; IWMI: Inferior wall myocardial infarction; NPA: Negative predictive accuracy; PPA: Positive predictive accuracy,
ST: ST-segment elevation; ST: ST-segment depression.
594
cardiology
whom had severe degree of obstruction. Among them
one each was in Group Ia and IIa, two each in Group
Ib and IIb and four in Group Ic. One patient each from
Group Ia and IIa had occlusion in LCx coronary artery,
which were not diagnosed by ECG, which is a known
poor tool to diagnose such occlusion. One patient in
Group Ib had more distal occlusion in LAD coronary
artery (i.e., Group Ic by CART). Though, the occlusion
was in distal LAD, he had diseased posterior descending
artery (PDA) and thus the amount of myocardium
jeopardized might have been substantial by virtue of
the severity of disease in other artery and hence less
chance of good collateral circulation. Rest of the seven
patients had more proximal lesion by CART but in the
same artery as predicted by ECG. The more proximal
lesions in these cases were of severe degree and all
patients had single vessel disease. Thus, the possible
collateral circulation that might have developed long
before the AMI in such cases could have led to better
myocardial salvage in spite of a proximal lesion giving
rise to false ECG diagnosis of distal lesion.
Conclusion
The present study demonstrates that ECG is an easily
and widely available inexpensive tool to localize site of
occlusion in culprit vessel in acute STEMI.
Limitation
The present study has two major limitations. Its sample
size is small and coronary angiography was not done
immediately on presentation but at a later date in
other referral centers. Sometimes it becomes difficult to
incriminate a lesion as the culprit one if angiography is
done later in the course especially if there is multivessel
disease or thrombolytic therapy has been given.
References
10. Chia BL, Yip JW, Tan HC, Lim YT. Usefulness of ST elevation
II/III ratio and ST deviation in lead I for identifying the
culprit artery in inferior wall acute myocardial infarction.
Am J Cardiol 2000;86(3):341-3.
595