Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
OT]
New method for the study of psychotropic drug effects under simulated
clinical conditions
Kudryavtseva N.N., Avgustinovich D.F., Bondar N.P., Tenditnik M.V.,
Kovalenko I.L., Koryakina L.A.
Neurogenetics of Social Behavior Sector, Institute of Cytology and Genetics SD RAS,
Novosibirsk, 630090, Russia, e-mail: natnik@bionet.nsc.ru
Abstract
The sensory contact model allows forming different psychopathological states (anxious depression, catalepsy, social
withdrawal, pathological aggression, hypersensitivity, cognition disturbances, anhedonia, alcoholism etc.) produced by
repeated agonistic interactions in male mice and investigating the therapeutic and preventive properties of any drug as well
as its efficiency under simulated clinical conditions. This approach can be useful for a better understanding of the drugs
action in different stages of disease development in individuals. It is suggested that this pharmacological approach may be
applied for the screening of different novel psychotropic drugs.
Key words: sensory contact model, psychotropic drugs, screening, antidepressants, anxiolytics, behavioral psychopathologies
Introduction
Screening of newly synthesized drugs (agents)
with putative therapeutic properties includes the
stages of preclinical and clinical trials. In the stage of
preclinical trials, tests on animals are performed to
determine such general drug characteristics as
lethality, toxicity, absorption and excretion rates and
also to study the mechanisms of action. Then new
drugs are compared with a well-known medical
analog using the experimental methods adopted in
International pharmacopoeia. If positive properties of
the drug intended for the treatment of a disease are
confirmed, the drug has to undergo clinical trials
when its action is tested in a group of patients. Such
studies are usually designed so that patients who
agreed to participate in the experiment are given
placebo or the drug tested. A group of patients
provided with conventional treatment or a group of
people with the same disease untreated for some
reasons is used as control.
The placebo method, however, is traditionally
blamed from the moral and ethical viewpoints as in
the variants with both placebo and a novel drug a
patient becomes the object of experimentation and is
likely to be deprived of necessary treatment or
provided with treatment not so effective as it could
have been otherwise. It sometimes happens that
volunteers become the victims of side effects of the
novel drug, which had not been revealed in animals.
One of common difficulties of clinical trials is the
selection of volunteers for the experiments among
people suffering a given disease. In any case, novel
drugs have to be studied on patients because the
reaction of a diseased organism to the administration
of the drug may differ drastically from that of a
healthy one.
The suggested approach, in our view, makes it
possible if not to do totally without clinical trials but
to minimize them at least for psychotropic drugs used
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
Strain
C57
C57
CBA
C57
C57
C
C57
CBA
C57
C57
CBA
C57
AGGRESSIVE MICE
Behavioral Pathologies and
Strain
Psychosomatic Disorders
[8, 11, 12, 26, 59, Pronounced anxiety
CBA
60, 64]
C57
[59, 60, 64]
Hyperactivity
CBA
Maniac state (?)
[34, 35, 39]
Cognition dysfunction
C57
[51, 71]
Addiction to aggression
C57
[63, 72,73, 75]
Stereotypic behavior
CBA
[12, 16, 59-61,
Pathological aggression
CBA
64]
Enhanced impulsivity
C57
[8]
Hypersensitivity,
C57
Enhanced irritability
CBA
[5 , 42, 60]
Sexual dysfunction
CBA
C57
[3, 33, 37, 42, 43, Learned aggression
CBA
84, 91]
C57
References
Drug treatment
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36
Agonistic interactions
References
Comfort conditions
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
Table 2. Effects of chronic preventive and medicative drug treatment on submissive C57 male mice.
Drugs
Dose, treatment
Tianeptine,
selective serotonin
reuptake enhancer
Effects
References
Partition test
Open field test
Exploration test
Porsolt test
Partition test
Open field test
Exploration test
Porsolt test
Pain sensitivity
Partition test
Plus-maze test
Open field test
Porsolt test
No effect
Weak anxiolytic
No effect
Antidepressive
Anxiogenic
Weak anxiolytic
No effect
Antidepressive
Nociceptive
Anxiolytic
No effect
Increased exploration
Weak antidepressive
[60]
Preventive treatment
25 mg/kg/day, p.o.,
14 days
Partition test
Plus-maze test
Open field test
Porsolt test
No effect
No effect
No effect
Prodepressive
[48]
Preventive treatment
10 mg/kg x 2 times/day,
14 days
Partition test
Open field test
Porsolt test
Pain sensitivity
Exploration test
Partition test
Plus-maze test
Porsolt test
Partition test
Plus-maze test
Porsolt test
No effect
No effect
No effect
No effect
No effect
No effect
Anxiolytic
Weak antidepressive
No effect
Anxiolytic
No effect
[70]
Preventive treatment
10 mg/kg/day, i.p.,
14 days
Imipramine,
tricyclic antidepressant,
serotonin and
norepinephrine reuptake
inhibitor
Fluoxetine,
selective serotonin
reuptake inhibitor
Citalopram,
selective serotonin
reuptake inhibitor
Buspirone,
5-HT1A receptor agonist
Ipsapirone,
5-HT1A receptor agonist
Preventive treatment
10 mg/kg x 2 times/day,
i.p., 14 days
Medicative treatment
15 mg/kg/day, p.o.,
14 days
Preventive treatment
1 mg/kg/day, i.p.,
14 days
Preventive treatment
3 mg/kg/day, i.p.,
14 days
Behavioral tests
[64]
[7]
[9]
[9]
Fluoglyzine,
analogue of fluoxetine
[41]
Medicative treatment
665 mg/kg, p.o.,
18 days
Partition test
Plus-maze test
Open field test
Porsolt test
No effect
Anxiolytic
Anxiolytic
Antidepressive
Preventive treatment
665 mg/kg, p.o.,
18 days
Partition test
Plus-maze test
Open field test
Porsolt test
Partition test
Plus-maze test
Open field test
Porsolt test
No effect
Anxiolytic
No effect
Antidepressive
Anxiolytic
No effect
No effect
Antidepressive
Partition test
Plus-maze test
Open field test
Porsolt test
No effect
No effect
No effect
Prodepressive
Medicative treatment
15 mg/kg/day, p.o.,
14 days
Preventive treatment
25 mg/kg/day, p.o.,
14 days
[25, 26]
[7, 48]
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
A
number of rearings
25
20
15
10
5
0
control
B
s
placebo
Noolit
180
135
90
45
0
control
placebo
FLK
FLG
Drug treatment
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 days
Agonistic interactions
Fig.3. Regimen of preventive treatment. See the text for
explanation.
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
immobility time
***
300
***
250
200
150
100
50
0
control
placebo
Noolit
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
Table 3. Effects of acute drug treatment on intact animals and submissive mice with 3 (T3), 10 (T10)
and 20 (T20) days of social defeats in agonistic interactions.
Drugs
Dose, treatment
Partition test
Plus-maze test
Porsolt test
Intact Partition test
Porsolt test
T20
C57
T10
C57
C57
CBA
No effect
Anxiogenic (0.5 mg/kg)
No effect
No effect
No effect
No effect
Anxiogenic
Prodepressive
Partition test
Porsolt test
Intact Partition test
Porsolt test
No effect
No effect
No effect
Prodepressive
T10
[+]
Anxiogenic
Prodepressive
Partition test
Porsolt test
T20
SKF 38393,
D1 receptor
agonist
Anxiogenic
Anxiogenic (0.5 mg/kg)
No effect
Partition test
Porsolt test
T20
Cis-flupentixol,
D1/D2 receptor
antagonist
References
C57
T10
Sulpiride,
D2 receptor
antagonist
Effects
Partition test
Porsolt test
Intact Partition test
Porsolt test
No effect
No effect
No effect
No effect
Partition test
Porsolt test
T20
Partition test
Porsolt test
Active defense
Active defense
Anxiolytic
Antidepressive
Stimulation (0.25mg/kg)
Decrease (1 mg/kg)
Active defense
Active defense
No effect
No effect
T10
[1, 2]
No effect
Prodepressive
T10
T3
[1, 2]
[1]
Anxiolytic
No effect
[57]
Note: Here and in other tables: (0.5 mg/kg) effective dose of drug was shown in brackets. Active defense was estimated during
intermale interaction. * - partition test measures anxiety level in submissive mice. + - in press.
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
Table 4. Effects of acute drug injection on intact animals and aggressive mice with 1 (T1), 3 (T3),
10 (T10) and 20 (T20) days of social victories in agonistic interactions.
Drugs
Dose, Treatment
Haloperidol,
D1/D2 receptor
antagonist
SCH-23390,
D1 receptor
antagonist
Naltrexone,
Opioid
receptors
antagonist
CBA
C57
C57
C57
Diazepam
benzodiazepin
e derivative
Buspirone,
5-HT1A
receptor
agonist
C57
C57
[66]
Partition test*
Aggression
Decrease
Decrease
T20
Partition test
Aggression
Partition test
Aggression
No effect
No effect
Decrease
Decrease
T3
Partition test
Aggression
Aggression
No effect
No effect
Decrease
T10
Aggression
No effect
T1
Partition test
Aggression
Decrease
Decrease
T20
Partition test
Aggression
Aggression
Plus-maze test
No effect
Increase
Decrease
Anxiogenic
Aggression
Plus-maze test
Intact Partition test
Plus-maze test
Decrease
Anxiolytic
No effect
No effect
T1
T3
T20
References
T1
T20
Effects
T3
Partition test
Plus-maze test
Aggression
Decrease
Anxiogenic
Decrease
T20.
Partition test
Plus-maze test
Aggression
No effect
No effect
No effect
[23]
[57]
[76]
[65]
[22]
Note: * - partition test measures the level of aggressive motivation in the winners [55].
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
220
%
20
sec
Total time
200
180
160
16
140
12
120
100
**
**
80
60
40
20
***
0
0 0.6 1.25 2.5
0
s
250
Control
T3
T20
total time of hostile behavior
200
150
50
0
T20
Ethanol
U-50
Losers
Winners
E
+
+
14 days of
5 days of ethanol
ethanol intake
deprivation
Losers
(Fig. 6). At the same time, DAGO (DAMGO), the opioid receptor agonist produced social withdrawal in
the partition test and anxiogenic effect in the plusmaze test in the control and winners and had no effect
in the losers [53]. It is worth noting that animals of
different social groups incipiently demonstrate
significant behavioral differences in this test. Chronic
administration of U-50,488H did not significantly
affect the intake of ethanol under the free two bottles
choice paradigm (water, ethanol) in the winners and
increased it in the losers (Fig. 7). The dopamine D2
receptors agonist (+)3PPP had no effect on
conditioned passive avoidance reaction (CPAR) in
intact animals, inhibited it in the winners and
enhanced in the losers [39] (Table 5).
Different reaction to the administration of the
same drug was also found in the studies of
physiological response in animals with different
social status. In particular, acute administration of
serotonin into the 3d ventricle of the brain produced
g/kg/day
6
T3
Winners
100
2
after deprivation
3 days
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
Table 5. Individual sensitivity of the winners, losers and intact male mice to the effects of acute drug
treatment.
Drugs
Dose, treatment
Strain
Groups
Behavioral tests
Effects
References
Decrease
Decrease
No effect
[69]
Partition test
Plus-maze test
Decrease
Anxiogenic
[53]
Decrease
Anxiogenic
C57 Intact
Partition test*
T10 winners
T10 losers
C57 Intact
T10 losers
Partition test
Plus-maze test
C57 Intact
T20 winners
T20 losers
Partition test
Plus-maze test
CPAR
No effect
No effect
[53]
Decrease (1.25 mg/kg)
Anxiolytic (2.5mg/kg)
No effect
No effect
Increase
Anxiolytic (2.5mg/kg)
No effect
Inhibition
Stimulation
[39]
Note: CPAR conditioned passive avoidance reaction. * Increase or decrease of behavioral reaction to the partner in the neighboring
compartment in the partition test may involve different motivations in animals of different groups (control, winners and losers).
10
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
C57BL/6J
Erosions, N
35
30
++
18
Metastases, N
25
16
**
14
12
10
20
15
10
8
6
0
Control
W -1
L-1
W -2
L-2
Control
Erosions, N
Winners
Losers
C B A /L ac
18
16
**
14
12
**
10
8
6
4
2
0
C ontrol
W inners
L osers
11
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
companies
developing
or
screening
novel
psychotropic drugs with different spectra of action.
REFERENCES
Alekseenko OV. Features of the brain dopaminergic
regulation
of
the
experimental
depression
development in male mice of C57BL/6J strain. PhD.
Thesis. 2001. 115p.
2. Alekseenko O.V., Avgustinovich D.F., Lipina T.V.
The participation of the brain dopamine D1 and D2
receptors in the process of the development of
depression induced by social confrontations in mice //
Zh Vyssh Nerv Deiat Im I P Pavlova. 1998. - Vol. 48.
N 6. P. 1090-1098.
3. Al'perina E.A., Pavina T.A. Changes in
immunological reactivity of C57Bl/6J mice during
the zoosocial conflict // Bull Eksp Biol Med. 1996. Vol. 122. N 11. P. 541-543.
4. Arregi A., Azpiroz A., Fano E. and Garmendia L.
Aggressive behavior: Implications of dominance and
subordination for the study of mental disorders //
Aggres. Viol. Behav. 2006. - Vol. 11. - N. 4. - P.
394-413.
5. Amikishieva A.V., Ovsyukova M.V. Effects of
alternative social experience on the sexual function of
male mice // Bull Exp Biol Med. 2003. Vol. 136.
N 6. P. 607-610
6. Avgustinovich D.F., Kovalenko I.L., Bondar N.P.
Choice of "control" in experimental researches of
animal social interactions in mice // Ross Fiziol Zh
Im I M Sechenova. 2005. Vol. 91. N 12. P.
1454-1468.
7. Avgustinovich D.F., Kovalenko I.L., Sorokina I.V.,
Tolstikova T.G., Tolstikov A.G. Ethological analysis
of the effects of fluoglyzine on mice exposed to
chronic social stress // Bull Exp Biol Med. 2004.
Vol. 137. N 1. P. 86-89.
8. Avgustinovich
D.F.,
Alekseenko
O.V.,
Bakshtanovskaia I.V., Koryakina L.A., Lipina T.V.,
Tenditnik M.V., Bondar N.P., Kovalenko I.L.,
Kudryavtseva N.N. Dynamic changes of brain
serotonergic and dopaminergic activities during
development of anxious depression: experimental
study // Usp Fiziol Nauk. 2004. Vol. 35. N 4. P.
19-40.
9. Avgustinovich D.F., Alekseyenko O.V., Koryakina
L.A. Effects of chronic treatment with ipsapirone and
buspirone on the C57BL/6J strain mice under social
stress // Life Sci. 2003. Vol. 72. P. 1437-1444.
10. Avgustinovich D.F., Lipina T.V., Kudryavtseva N.N.
Response of the serotoninergic brain system to social
stress of various duration in male mice C57BL/6J and
CBA/Lac // Ross Fiziol Zh Im I M Sechenova. 2001.
Vol. 87. N 4. P. 532-542.
11. Avgustinovich D.F., Lipina T.V., Alekseenko O.V.,
Amstislavskaia T.G., Kudryatseva N.N. The
characteristics of the functional activity of the brain
serotoninergic system in the manifestation of natural
and pathological anxiety in mice: the effect of the
genotype // Zh Vyssh Nerv Deiat Im I P Pavlova.
1998. Vol. 48. N 2. P. 331-341.
12. Avgustinovich D.F., Gorbach O.V., Kudryavtseva
N.N. Comparative analysis of anxiety-like behavior
13.
1.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
12
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
13
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
68. Kudryavtseva
N.N.,
Bakshtanovskaia
I.V.,
Avgustinovich D.F. The effect of the repeated
experience of aggression in daily confrontations on
the individual and social behavior of male mice // Zh
Vyssh Nerv Deiat Im I P Pavlova. 1997. Vol. 47.
N. 1. P. 86-97.
69. Kudryavtseva N.N., Lipina T.V., Vishnivetskaia
G.B., Avgustinovich D.F. The participation of
serotonin S1A and S2 receptors in the formation of
different levels of anxiety in male mice under the
influence of the experience of social victories and
defeats // Zh Vyssh Nerv Deiat Im I P Pavlova. 1996.
Vol. 46. N 2. P. 370-377.
70. Kudryavtseva
N.N.,
Bakshtanovskaia
I.V.,
Madorskaia I.A., Popova N.K., Marona-Lewicka D.,
Vetulani I. Experimental model of depression:
neurochemical changes and the effects of imipramine
and citalopram // Zh Nevropatol Psikhiatr Im S S
Korsakova. 1992. Vol. 92. N 1. P. 106-109.
71. Kudryavtseva
N.N.,
Madorskaya
I.A.,
Bakshtanovskaya I.V. Social success and voluntary
ethanol consumption in mice of C57BL/6J and
CBA/Lac strains // Physiol. Behav. 1991. Vol. 50.
- N 1. P.143-146.
72. Kudryavtseva N.N., Bakshtanovskaia I.V., Popova
N.K. The development of pathological forms of
behavior in submissive male C57BL/6J mice during
agonistic zoosocial interactions. A possible model of
depression? // Zh Vyssh Nerv Deiat Im I P Pavlova.
1989. Vol. 39. N 6. P. 1134-1141.
73. Kulikov A.V., Kozlachkova E.Y., Kudryavtseva
N.N., Popova N.K. Correlation between tryptophan
hydroxylase activity in the brain and predisposition to
pinch-induced catalepsy in mice // Pharmacol.
Biochem. Behav. 1995. Vol. 50, - N 3. P. 431435.
74. Lapin I.P. Stress, anxiety, depression, alcoholism,
epilepsy. Saint-Petersburg, 2004. 220 p.
75. Lipina T.V., Mikhnevich N.V., Kudriavtseva N.N.
The development of catatonic reactions in male mice
of CBA/Lac strain: the effect of repeated experience
of aggression and submission // Zh Vyssh Nerv Deiat
Im I P Pavlova. 2003. Vol. 53. N 1. P. 88-93.
76. Lipina T.V., Avgustinovich D.F., Koriakina L.A.,
Alekseenko O.V., Kudriavtseva N.N. Differences in
the effects of naltrexone on the communicative and
aggressive behaviors of subjects with different
experiences of social conquests // Eksp Klin
Farmakol. 1998. Vol. 61. N 3. P. 13-18.
77. Lister R.G. The use of a plus-maze to measure
anxiety in the mouse // Psychopharmacology (Berl).
1987. Vol. 92, - N 2. P. 180-185.
78. Malatynska E., Knapp R.J. Dominant-submissive
behavior as models of mania and depression. //
Neurosci. Biobehav. Rev. 2005. Vol. 29. N 4-5.
P. 715-737.
79. McKinney W.T.J., Bunney W.E.J. Animal model of
depression. I. Review of evidence: implications for
research // Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1969. Vol. 21.
P. 240-248.
80. Miczek K.A., Faccidomo S.D.E., Almeida R.M.,
Bannai M., Fish E.W., Debold J.F. Escalated
aggressive behavior: new pharmacotherapeutic
14
arXiv:0707.3671 [q-bio.OT]
81.
82.
83.
84.
85.
86.
87.
88.
89.
90.
91.
92.
93.
94.
C.A. Hendrie. NY: John Wiley & Sons Ltd, 1994. P. 9-44.
Rygula R., Abumaria N., Flugge G., Hiemke C.,
Fuchs E., Ruther E., Havemann-Reinecke U.
Citalopram counteracts depressive-like symptoms
evoked by chronic social stress in rats // Behav
Pharmacol. 2006. Vol. 17, - N 1. P. 19-29.
Stokes P., Holtz A. Fluoxetine tenth anniversary
update: the progress continues // Clinic. Therapeutics.
1997. Vol. 19, - N 5. P. 1137-1225.
Tenditnik M.V., Shurlygina A.V., Mel'nikova E.V.,
Kudryavtseva N.N., Trufakin V.A. Effect of chronic
psychoemotional stress on subpopulation spectrum of
T-lymphocytes in immunocompetent organs in male
mice // Ross Fiziol Zh Im I M Sechenova. 2004.
Vol. 90. N 12. P. 1522-1529.
Tolstikov A.G., Tolstikova T.G., Sorokina I.V.,
Dolgih M.P., Tolstikov G.A., Fedoseeva L.A. / The
patent of the Russian Federation 2232574 // Bull.
SD RAMN. Medical product for treatment of various
forms of depression "fluoglyzine". 2004. 20
Vegas O., Fano E., Brain P.F., Alonso A., Azpiroz A.
Social stress, coping strategies and tumor
development
in
male
mice:
Behavioral,
neuroendocrine and immunological implications. //
Psychoneuroendocrinology.- 2006. Vol. 31. N 1.
P. 69-79.
Willner P. Chronic mild stress (CMS) revisited:
consistency
and
behavioural-neurobiological
concordance in the effects of CMS. //
Neuropsychobiology. -2005. Vol. 52. - N 2. - P. 90110.
Note. This method was published first in Russ J Neurosci, 2007, 1(9), 5-18 (in Russian)
15