Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Features of RA 7691
-
REAL ACTIONS
PERSONAL
ACTIONS
MTC
FE and UD
Civil actions which involve title to or
possession or RP or any interest
therein does not exceed 20k in
ASSESSED VALUE (50k in Metro
Manila)
(exclusive of interest, damages, attorneys
fees, litigation expenses, and costs)
RTC
"(2)
In all civil actions which involve the title
to, or possession of, real property, or any
interest therein, where the assessed value of the
property involved exceeds Twenty thousand
pesos (P20,000,00) or, for civil actions in Metro
Manila, where such value exceeds Fifty thousand
pesos (P50,000.00)
>>>except actions for forcible entry into and
unlawful detainer of lands or buildings
"(1)
In all civil actions in which the subject of
the litigation is incapable of pecuniary
estimation;
1. Examples of IPEs:
a. action for specific performance;
b. action of UD relies on
interpretation of a provision in a
contract of lease
c. question of nullity of assignment
of rights with chattel mortgage
2. exceptions in cases:
a. alternative prayer to the specific
performance = capable of Pes
b. agreement of refund of money
upon compliance with certain
conditions = capable of PEs
3. Test to ascertain: NATURE of the Principal
Action or Remedy sought
a. Primarily for recovery of a sum
money = capable of PEs
b. Basic issue is something other
than money/ money claim is
merely incidental = incapable of
Pes
4. In event of BREACH OF CONTRACT
a. Option of aggrieved party to sue
for:
b. Specific performance +
Damages
c. SP / D
i. Jurisdiction is
Determined by amount
of damages prayed for
d. D
i. Jurisdiction is
Determined by amount
of damages prayed for
e. SP AND/OR D
"(3)
In all actions in admiralty and maritime
jurisdiction where the demand or claim exceeds
(P300,000.00) or, in Metro Manila, where such
demand or claim exceeds (P400,000.00);
"(4)
In all matters of probate, both testate
and intestate, where the gross value of the
CRIMINAL CASES
6.
OJ in OTHER
CASES
7.
HOLD
DEPARTURE
ORDER
Whether of
General or
Limited
Jurisdiction
8.
5.
1.
LIMITED JURISDICTION
Jurisdiction ONLY over those CASES
EXPRESSLY PROVIDED BY LAW as
falling within its jurisdiction
INTRACORPORATE controversies
EOJ in ALL CRIMINAL CASES not within
the EOJ of any court
1. In ISSUANCE of WRITS of C,P,M,QW,HC,I
Which may be enforced in any part of
their respective regions
2. Actions affecting ambassadors and other
public ministers and consuls
Under SC Circular No. 39-97
Issued only in CRIMINAL CASES within
the exclusive jurisdiction of the RTC
Still a court of GENERAL JURISDICTION
o It still has jurisdiction over ALL
cases NOT FALLING within the
EXCLUSIVE JURISDICTION of ANY
Court
Tribunal
Body or
Person exercising judicial or quasi-judicial
functions
EXCEPTION
LIMITED JURISDICTION
Cases EXPRESSLY provided
by law as falling within its
jurisdiction
Jurisdiction is not presumed
Must appear clearly
from the statute or
it will not be held to
exist
GENERAL JURISDICTION
Case not expressly fall within the jurisdiction of any court, tribunal
or person = safely filed with the RTC
Other Details:
a.
b.
-
Real Actions
Definition
1.
2.
ACTIONS
Affecting
a. TITLE to or
b. POSSESSION of RP or
c. INTEREST therein.
Assessed Value
I.
Purpose
Basis for determining jurisdiction in REAL ACTIONS
II.
Source
Made by the assessor
III.
Position
Appears at the back of the Tax Declaration
IV.
Effect of NO AV of property or adjacent lots
a. ESTIMATED VALUE alleged by the claimant
i. Basis for computing the fees
Silence
Obscurity or
Definition:
o Matters of
Faith
Practice
Doctrine
Form of worship
Custom or rule of the church having reference to the power of excluding from the church those
allegedly unworthy of membership
It CANNOT entertain a suit for damages were plaintiffs were expelled from a church or sect WITHOUT due
process
Cases:
o The Church and State are separate and distinct from each other.
GR: Testate or intestate court cannot decide questions of ownership of properties included in the
inventory of the estate
o
o
2.
Jurisprudence
o
o
o
MTC->
o
o
Records
Memoranda or
Brief
RTC -> CA
Appealed by PR to the CA
CA may give such petition due course only when it shows prima facie that the lower court has
committed an error of fact or law that will warrant a reversal or modification of the decision or
judgment sought to be reviewed.
In a PRE-TRIAL
Court may allow the plaintiff to PRESENT HIS EVIDENCE EX PARTE
a. If the defendant fails to appear
>>>EXCEPTION: When a lawyer or representative appears in his behalf with a POWER of ATTORNEY
GENERAL RULE: Damages are merely incidental to or a consequence of the main cause of the action =
DAMAGES ARE IMMATERIAL
a. >>>EXCEPTIONS: (amount of damages claim considered in determining jurisdiction)
i. Claim for the DAMAGES is the MAIN CAUSE of ACTION
ii. / one of the causes of action
Totality of ALL damages prayed for should be the jurisdictional amount
o Different amounts of different kinds do not constitute separate causes of action
If each separate claim furnishes the jurisdictional test = action would have to be split
o But this is not possible if there is a SINGLE CAUSE OF ACTION, prohibited by law.
JOINED CAUSES
o If main cause is cognizable by the MTC = all joined causes should be included in one complaint filed in
the MTC
o If main cause is cognizable by the RTC = incidental cases should follow the main cause
Filing Fees
Purpose:
Jurisprudence
I.
II.
III.
IV.
V.
VI.
VII.
VIII.
IX.
Rules
I.
II.
FULL AMOUNT of Appellate Court DF must be paid within the period of taking an appeal
a. Effect of non-compliance: judgment or order appealed from will be FINAL
i. AC does not acquire jurisdiction
ii. Appeal is not perfected
b. Necessary for the perfection of the appeal
i. To prevent the judgment or order from becoming final
ii. To take the case out of the jurisdiction of the TC and bring it within the jurisdiction of the AC
How made
a. Proof of Payment + Record on Appeal
IV is not one of the grounds on which the Court may dismiss a case on its own motion
Rendition of Judgment
I.
II.
Meaning:
a. filing by the judge of the signed decision with the clerk of court
b. NOT when the decision is actually promulgated
Period: 90 days
a. Counted from the date the case is submitted for decision
b. NOT from transcription of the stenographic notes
i. Unless, the judge did not try the case
II.
III.
IV.
How
a.
Docket Fee
Paid to perfect the appeal = to vest appellate jurisdiction
in the RTC
Law presumes that plaintiff continues to suffer the damages arising from loss of possession
Antidote:
o SB and rent
o periodic deposit of rent or reasonable value of use and occupation (determined in judgment), if there is
no contract
RTC has no authority to accept a BOND in lieu of cash deposits for future rents
SB is transmitted by the MTC with other papers => RTC CoC
Small Claims
-
Basis: Constitutional Mandate of SC to promulgate rules of pleading, practice, and procedure to provide a
simplified and inexpensive procedure for the speedy disposition of cases (Sec. 5; par. 5; Art. VIII; Const.)
Separate and distinct from rule of summary procedure for FE and UD
Implemented by MTCs
a.
Filing Fees
Whether juridical or natural person, plaintiff must pay FF
>>>EXCEPTION: when allowed to litigate as an indigent
If Motion to Litigate as an Indigent is DENIED = plaintiff has 5 days to pay the FF
Cannot pay = case dismissed; without prejudice to refiling
Service of Summons and Processes not included in exception
Indigent party also needs to pay
PROCEDURES:
1. Plaintiff files the claim with the filling fee (Statement of Claim)
2. Summons served to D
3. Notice of Hearing serviced to D an P
a. Sets date and time for hearing
4. Response
a. A.k.a. answer of D
b. Must be verified
c. Must be within 10 days
d. Interposes a counterclaim if any
i. If permissive = pay prescribed FF
ii. NOTE: NO DEFAULT JUDGMENT if there is failure to do so
1. D can still appear at the hearing
2. Court shall ascertain if he has a defense
iii. Effect of failure: D is not allowed to set up a COUNTERCALIM
No Lawyers
-
Procedure of hearing
In nature of JDR
o Through M,C, ENE / other mode of JDR
Court is presided by a judge trained in JDR
o JDR fails = case shall be tried by another judge
Unless parties agree in writing to allow the judge who conducted JDR to try the case
Trial: informal and expeditious manner
o Terminated within 1 day
After hearing, court shall render its decision on the SAME DAY
In writing
Served on the parties
DECISION SHALL BE FINAL AND UNAPPEALABLE
Decision may be assailed in a Petition for Certiorari under Rule 65 (GAD)
Applies only to procedural matters
Jurisdiction is substantive, not procedural
SC rules cannot amend the Judiciary Reorganization enacted by Congress
- Power to define, prescribe, and apportion jurisdiction of various courts (except SC) is the Congress of the
Philippines