Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Deontological ethical views on euthanasia such as Kantian ethics differ from virtue ethics
as it focuses solely with the means to the end of the action, making this theory much
more rigid in comparison to virtue ethics. Kants categorical imperatives are the centre of
his philosophical concept, and they are a three part absolute basis for moral rationality.
To begin, Kant first stresses the importance of acting as if every action would become a
universal law, for example stealing, if the act of stealing became a universal law, society
would crumble. In application to euthanasia, views on the morality of the act are largely a
result of how the individuals view it. Whereas some may argue that voluntary euthanasia
should always be viewed as murder, which would make the application of this into a
universal law absurd. This is because it would lead to human extinction which directly
contradicts Kants Laws of Nature. Alternatively some Christians and others may argue
that it is in fact applicable, as elements of murder in the bible include Malicious Intent
and is Contrary to the desire of the victim. Another maxim in the categorical
imperative is "Act in such a way that you treat humanityas an end and never
merely as a means to an end." This means that a person must be treated as an
individual as they have intrinsic worth, and not just instrumental value, only man, and,
with him every rational creature is an end in itself. However in regards to
euthanasia, some may argue that the doctor is being used as a means to an end, as they
are being used as a means to kill another, therefore going against Kantian ethics.
Although when considering Kants views on autonomy, which he defined of control over
ones self and actions, the denying of euthanasia would be seen as barbaric and a denial
of basic human rights.
referencing
1)
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/euthanasia-voluntary/
2)
. Milan Kundera, The Unbearable Lightness of Being
3) http://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/euthanasia/overview/asstdyingbill_1.shtml
4)
http://www.etsjets.org/files/JETS-PDFs/19/19-1/19-1-pp015-024_JETS.pdf
5)
the noble descent of duty Immanuel kant from peter singer ethics book.