Sie sind auf Seite 1von 65

JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD

for
Population & Reproductive
Health Programmes
2008

Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

The Man and His Vision

B
harat Ratna, the late Mr JRD raise an alarm in 1951, in
Tata, was among those handful of the course of a speech, about
world citizens whom destiny the continuous and fast
itself so shaped to become an institution growth of the India’s
in a life-time. He had been regarded as population and its serious potential
one of the stalwarts among Indians in the consequences to the country’s economy
20th Century, who stamped his personality and progress. Realising later the need for
on the country’s affairs both before and non-governmental action, he founded the
after independence. He was the crusader Family Planning Foundation in 1970, of
for the promotion of family planning, both which he was the founder Chairman.
as a tool of curbing India’s rapidly- Family Planning Foundation was re-
increasing population, and an entirely new christened as the Population Foundation
way of life in a developing society in which of India in 1993 to reflect the wider
a family is not mere numbers but valuable dimensions of the population issue in a
relationships of shared growth. changing world. Mr Tata’s unique services
The late Mr Tata had promoted and in the cause of population had been
fostered several causes in the service of recognised by the United Nations who had
science and nation. His holistic view of chosen him for their prestigious
the population problem had turned him Population Award for 1992. For his many
into an equally strong humanist, splendoured achievements, India also
concerned no less with the problems of conferred on him ‘Bharat Ratna’, the
poverty and environment, intertwined highest civilian award of the Nation in
with population. Mr Tata was the first to 1992.

3|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

The Foundation

T
he Population Foundation of India the Government. It ought to be supported
(formerly known as Family and supplemented by private voluntary
Planning Foundation) was enterprises. In this regard, the
established in 1970 by a dedicated group Foundation has always worked in close co-
of industrialists and population activists operation and co-ordination with official
led by Bharat Ratna the late Mr JRD Tata agencies and programmes, both at the
who guided it as the founder Board Centre and in the States.
Chairman until his death in 1993. After
In its independent role, it has tried to
his demise, Dr Bharat Ram, noted
guide and influence the National
industrialist and a founding member of the
Population Policy and to serve as a
Foundation, was its Board Chairman.
catalytic agent to promote programmes at
After his demise in 2007, Mr. Hari Shankar
different levels directed towards the
Singhania, renowned industrialist took
ultimate goal of population stabilisation.
over as the Board Chairman of the
foundation. The Foundation supports innovative
The Foundation has been in the research, experimentation and social
forefront of non-governmental efforts at action to further the cause of population
population stabilisation and establishing stabilisation and provide a forum for
a balance between resources, environment pooling of experiences and sharing of
and population. professional expertise to strengthen and
Social development including enlarge the operational base of the
population stabilisation in India should Reproductive and Child Health (RCH)
not and cannot remain the sole concern of programmes.

Population Foundation of India |4


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

The Award

W
hen the founder Board
Chairman of the Foundation
Mr JRD Tata passed away in
1993, having laid a strong base for a social
movement to stabilise the growth of
population in India as an essential
prerequisite to attain higher qualities of
life for the Indian people, the Foundation
felt that it would be a fitting tribute to the
great man if national awards were
instituted in his name to further the cause
for which he was a champion
acknowledged all over the world.
In February 1996, the PFI Governing
Board formally decided to institute
national awards for the best State and the
best districts with outstanding
performance in population and
reproductive health and family planning
programme.

5|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

The Significance of the Award

T
he process of integration of related driven, high quality and integrated RCH
programmes of maternal and child services.
health initiated with the It is a legitimate right of the citizens
implementation of the Child Survival and to be able to experience sound
Safe Motherhood (CSSM) Programme was Reproductive and Child Health and
taken a step further in 1994 when the therefore the RCH Programme seeks to
International Conference on Population provide relevant services for assuring
and Development(ICPD) in Cairo Reproductive and Child Health to all
recommended that the participant citizens. RCH is even more relevant for
countries should implement unified obtaining the objective of population
programmes for reproductive health. stabilization in the country.
India took the lead by introducing the The selection of winners for the
target-free approach to family welfare Awards is not dependent just on the
programmes from April 1996. During the current levels of performance in a number
9 th Plan, the RCH Programme, of crucial indicators. Emphasis has been
accordingly, integrated all the related given on the change factor signifying the
programmes of the 8th Plan on maternal pace of progress achieved over a period of
and child health, family planning, time. It is well known that despite the
adolescent sexual health, etc. The concept relatively slow performance in the field
of RCH is to provide to the beneficiaries of RCH for the country as a whole, there
need based, client centred, demand are States within the country, which have

Population Foundation of India |6


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

made significant strides in the field of namely, Palakkad in Kerala (in the large
Reproductive and Child Health and their population size category), Toothukudi in
achievements are comparable to the best Tamil Nadu (in the medium population
even in advanced societies. These size category) and Kurukshetra in
demonstrate that, given the leadership, Haryana (in the small population size
will and conditions, such success can be category).
repeated in other regions. The awards are The second JRD Tata Memorial
recognition of this sustained effort and Awards were announced on 28th July 2000
will hopefully generate the much needed and were given to the winning state and
impetus and confidence amongst the districts by the Union Minister of Health
others that they could also achieve the and Family Welfare in a function organised
same standards. The criteria adopted for by the Foundation on 3rd January 2001.
the selection cover various aspects of The second JRD Tata Memorial Award
human development and reproductive for the best performing State was given to
health. Tamil Nadu. Awards for the best
Accordingly, the first JRD Tata performing districts were given to three
Memorial Awards were announced on July districts, namely, Chennai in Tamil Nadu
29, 1997 and were given to the winning (in the large population size category),
State and districts by the Prime Minister Alappuzha in Kerala (in the medium
of India, in a function organised by the population size category) and Jorhat in
Foundation on 13th November 1997. Assam (in the small population size
The first JRD Tata Memorial Award category). Awards were also given to the
for the best performing State was given to best performing district in the not so good
Kerala. Awards for the best performing performing states. In this category, the
districts were given to three districts, districts of Dehradun in the then Uttar

7|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Pradesh, Purbi Singhbhum in the population category), Churu in Rajasthan


erstwhile Bihar and Cuttack in Orissa (in the medium population category) and
were adjudged the winners. Lahul & Spiti in Himachal Pradesh (in the
The third JRD Tata Memorial Award small population category). Awards were
for the best performing state was given by also given to the best performing districts
Vice President of India to Himachal in the not so good performing states. In
Pradesh on November 7, 2003. Awards for this category, the districts of Ri Bhoi in
the best performing districts were given Meghalaya, Ranchi in Jharkhand and
to three districts, namely, West Godavari Bhagalpur in Bihar were adjudged the
in Andhra Pradesh (in the large winners.

Population Foundation of India |8


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Fourth JRD TATA Memorial Awards, 2008


Technical Advisory Committee Senior Professor, International
Institute for Population Sciences

A
Technical Advisory Committee
(IIPS), Mumbai
(TAC) was formed, comprising
experts from diverse academic Award Committee
affiliations. The TAC guided the
A high level Award Committee was
Foundation in selection of indicators and
constituted to go into the issue in depth
appropriate methodology for the selection
and set standard and ground rules for the
of state level awards.
awards.
Dr. A.K. Shiva Kumar, Senior Advisor,
Ms. Justice Leila Seth, Former Chief
UNICEF, was the chairperson of the
Justice of Himachal Pradesh and member
committee. The other members were:
of the Governing Board of PFI, was the
• Dr. P.M. Kulkarni, Professor, Centre Chairperson of the award committee for
for Study in Regional Development the year 2008.
(CSRD), Jawaharlal Nehru University,
The other members were:
New Delhi.
• Dr. M. S. Swaminathan, noted
• Dr. Saraswati Raju, Professor,
Agricultural Scientist, Magsaysay
Centre for Study in Regional
Award winner, Chairman, M. S.
Development (CSRD), Jawaharlal
Swaminathan Research Foundation
Nehru University, New Delhi.
and Chairman, Advisory Council, PFI.
• Dr. Faujdar Ram, Director and
• Mr. B. G. Deshmukh, former Cabinet

9|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Secretary and Vice Chairman, • Dr. A. K. Shiva Kumar, Senior


Governing Board PFI. Advisor, UNICEF and Chairperson
Technical Advisory Committee for the
• Dr. Abid Hussain, former Ambassador
Tata Award, 2008.
of India in USA and Member,
Governing Board, PFI. • Dr. P. M. Kulkarni, Professor, Centre
for Study in Regional Development
• Prof. K. Srinivasan, former Executive
(CSRD), Jawaharlal Nehru University,
Director, PFI and former Director,
New Delhi and Member, Technical
International Institute for Population
Advisory Committee for the Tata
Sciences, Mumbai.
Award, 2008.
• Mrs. Nirmala Buch, I.A.S (Retd.).
• Mr. A. R. Nanda, Executive Director,
PFI.

Population Foundation of India |10


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

The Methodology
State

F
or the selection of states for the
4th JRD Tata Memorial awards, it
was decided by the award
committee to institute two state level
awards, one among the bigger population
category(population of 10 million and
above) and another among smaller
population category(population of less
than 10 million).The selection of the states
for the state level award 2008 has been
done on the basis of 14 indicators, for
which data were compiled from various
published sources. These indicators were
finalized on the basis of
recommendations of the Technical
Advisory Committee. These indicators
have a strong bearing on reproductive
health, gender equity, family planning the district level awards till the
and fertility levels of the population. availability of next round of DLHS data
While selecting the 4th JRD Tata as due to large reorganization of districts
Memorial Awards for the states, it was the change was not accessed while
decided by the award committee to defer selecting the best districts.

11|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Indicators
Sl. No. Indicator Source
1 Women(20-24 years) married before age 18 NFHS II & III
2 CPR (Contraceptive Prevalence Rate)
–any methods NFHS II & III
3 Full Immunization NFHS II & III
4 TFR(Total Fertility Rate) NFHS II & III
5 At least 3 ANC(Ante-natal check ups) visits NFHS II & III
6 Safe Delivery NFHS II & III
7 % Children underweight(weight for age) NFHS II & III
8 IMR (Infant Mortality Rate) SRS (Sample Registration
System), 1999 and 2005
9 Under Five Mortality Rate Indirect Estimates, Census 2001
(Male/Female Ratio)
10 Child Sex Ratio(0-6 years) Census, 1991 and 2001
11 Girls School Attendance Rate (6-14 years) Census, 1991 and 2001
12 Female Youth (15-24 years) Literacy Rate Census, 1991 and 2001
13 Literacy Rate (7 and more years) Census, 1991 and 2001
14 Planned Expenditure on Social Sector,1997 National Human Development
and 2004 Report,2001 and Statistical
Abstract India,2001

Population Foundation of India |12


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Sources of Data

The first seven indicators have been derived from the last two rounds of the National
Family Health Survey (NFHS-II & III). The data on child sex ratio, girls school attendance
rate, female youth literacy and literacy rate are from the Census of India 1991 and 2001
and IMR is from the SRS. The M/F (Male/Female) ratio of under five mortality is based on
the indirect estimate from 2001 Census by Brass method. Social Sector includes education,
health, water supply and sanitation, urban development, information and welfare & labour.
Planned expenditure on social sector for the year 1997-98 is an average of 1996-98. Similarly,
planned expenditure for the year 2004-05 is an average of 2003-06.

As data are compiled from different sources, the base year and final year are not the
same for all the fourteen indicators. Efforts have been made to compile data for the most
recent year and making the indicators comparable. The base and final years of the different
state level indicators are as follows:

Source Base Year Final Year

Census 1991 2001

NFHS 1998-99 2005-06

SRS 1999 2005

National Human Development Report & Statistical 1997-98 2004-05


Abstract, India,2001

13|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Selection of the Best Performing State


Step 1 :
At first step, as it has been followed by UNDP for Human Development Index (HDI)
each variable is converted into an index ranging from 0 to 100. The index is computed as:
For positive indicators (like use of family planning and utilization of ANC) :
(State value - Minimum Value)
Index = x 100
(Maximum value - Minimum value)
For negative indicators (like TFR and IMR) :
(Maximum value – State value)
Index = x 100
(Maximum value - Minimum value)
Step 2 :
Secondly, a composite index is computed for base year and final year on the basis of
these fourteen indices. This composite index is the simple average of fourteen indices.

Step 3 :
Thirdly, a score is obtained for each state by combining the recent levels and changes
over the base and final years in the composite index in the ratio of 1:4.

Population Foundation of India |14


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

The Winners

A
fter final ranking of the nineteen
bigger states (population of 10
million and above) on the basis of
composite index, Chhattisgarh emerged
as the best state and among the ten
smaller states (population of less than 10
million) Sikkim emerged as the best state.
Chhattisgarh got a high score among all
the bigger states in the composite index
as the change is observed to be the highest
among all the 19 bigger states. Similarly
among 10 smaller states, Sikkim emerged
as the winner state, as the change in
between the base year and the final year
for Sikkim is observed to be the highest.

15|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Population Foundation of India |16


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Profile of the Winners

T
he best performing States have Chhattisgarh is one of the bigger states
their distinct characteristics, of India with a populaiton of about 21
which have led to their success. million persons according to the 2001
These relate varyingly to the historical Census. Chhattisgarh was carved out from
past, the geographical location, the ethnic Eastern part of Madhya Pradesh and the
composition, the social structure, political State of Chhattisgarh came into existence
commitment to development such as on 1st November 2000 as the 26th states
population policies, bureaucratic of the Union of India. The State has made
efficiency and other determinants which significant strides in developing an
contribute to the achievement. A study of educational and health infrastructure and
some of these factors would be rewarding transport and communication
for other comparable areas. networks.These advances had a significant
Winner among Bigger States impact on the socio-economic and
The 4th JRD Tata Memorial awards for demorgraphic status of the state.
execellence in reproductive health & Chhattisgarh ranks favourably in
population programmes for the year 2008 many of the indices used to determine the
is own by Chhattisgarh. The State with a performance of reporductive and child
score of 115.8 ranked first among the heath programmes in the states.
bigger states, followed by Rajasthan & Chhattisgarh has made improvement in
Andhra Pradesh with scores of 103.5 & almost all the indicators considered for the
100.6 respectively. 4th JRD Tata Memorial award. Full

17|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

immunization for the state improved from remarkable improvement in terms of


20.0 in 1998-99 to 48.7 in 2005-06. Similarly couple protection rate (53.8 to 57.6), full
for at least three ANC visits, the figure immunization (47.4 to 69.6), at least three
got a boost from 33.2 in 1998-99 to 54.2 in ANC visits (42.6 to 70.1) in between two
2005-06. The state has also shown successive National Family Health
improvement, in safe delivery, children Surveys (1998-99 and 2005-06). The state
underweight and infant mortality rate. has also made substantial reduction in
infant mortality rate and percentage of
Winner among Smaller States children underweight. The change in
Sikkim attained statehood as the 22nd between the overall index of final year and
state of the Indian Union in 1975. It is one base year was found to be highest for the
of the smaller states of India. It is having State of Chhattisgarh (13.5) among bigger
population of half million according to the states. For Sikkim change was found to be
2001 Census. Among the smaller states second highest (9.6) among smaller states.
(population of less than 10 million), This resulted in selection of the two states
Sikkim has done well in relation to all the under bigger and smaller population
indicators considered for the 4th JRD Tata category states for the 4th JRD Tata
Memorial award. The state has shown Memorial Awards.

Population Foundation of India |18


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

19|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Sikkim on the Path of Development


P.D. Rai*

T
his article is less about numbers development in total coordination with the
and more about ideas and the policies set out by the Planning
political economy – it captures the Commission of India, participating fully
essence of the direction of development, from the 5 th Five Year Plan onwards.
the policy instruments and indeed the flow Today it has attained spectacular growth
of Government funds to the people of in an atmosphere of peace and communal
Sikkim and its impact, as has been studied harmony, growing at a per capita GSDP
by independent institutions. There are of Rs. 26,215 (2004-05)1 and maintaining
many discrepancies and downsides, but as rate of growth at about 10 percent per
all development is about tradeoffs, these annum.
are being handled albeit in a way by So the ups and downs of development
acknowledging their import. that has persisted in India have also
affected the State. Sikkim’s accelerated
Sikkim’s leap into the 21st Century growth in the last ten years is indeed visible.
Sikkim joined the national mainstream Whether it has been done in a significantly
as the 22nd State of the Indian Union in different manner than others is a matter of
1975. Since then it has taken up the debate.
1
North-Eastern Region(NER), Vision 2020
*Deputy Chairman, Sikkim State Planning Commission, Government of Sikkim, Tashiling, Gangtok 737101, Sikkim

Population Foundation of India |20


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

21|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Sikkim is always described in glowing late 1800s for this very strategic reason
terms by nearly all visitors who happen and Sikkim became part of India in 1975.
to come here on one pretext or other. Always a bone of contention with China,
They find this place gloriously calm. The Sikkim is now acknowledged as part of India
hills and mountains dazzle. The peace and by that country but not after extracting
tranquillity thrill. However, they also some major concessions. Tibet has been
report a sudden disquiet especially after recognized by India as part of China. Dalai
they have visited Nathula and gone Lama is not to be highlighted, not even his
through the major part of Gangtok in some vision of a free autonomous Tibet under
detail. Pinpointing it may not be politically China.
correct. So we hear sentences like
“Gangtok could have been better planned!” Size Matters
or “The traffic is quite something!” The State’s land size is miniscule. With
The State is, geopolitically, highly a population of a little more than half a
strategic even though it is so small an area million it is sparsely populated, one of the
in the Eastern Himalayas. The mountain specificities of mountain communities.
passes of Jelepla and Nathula make it Indeed access to and for villagers is always
prized in terms of access to the Tibetan a challenge. Sikkim has but only 7 percent
Plateau and to the economic, social and land out of our 7096 Sq Km which can be
political exchanges. It offers the shortest made habitable by world standards2 . The
route to Lhasa, the capital of Tibet, from rest is too steep or wilderness. Little wonder
Kolkata and its sea ports – a mere 1350 Km then that it has over 80 percent of the land
or so. The British conquered Sikkim by the as Forests. Forest cover is increasing and

2
Surbana International Consultants, Strategic Urban Plan Report 2040, Singapore – commissioned by GOS

Population Foundation of India |22


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

23|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

at about 40 percent. Sikkim is proud of this from the Centre. The State is a special
great biodiversity reserve contributing category one. Furthermore, in 2002 Sikkim
significantly to India’s overall reserve. was assimilated into the North Eastern
Sikkim’s forests have been regenerated Council as the eighth member. This has
after policies which can be considered opened up another pool of assistance from
perhaps the greenest in India. Two most the NEC as well as the non-lapsable pool of
important initiatives of the Government resources of Government of India through
have been the Green Mission and the the Ministry of Development of North-
removal of graziers from high altitude Eastern Region (DONER).
pastures, since this was becoming Not all sections of society are happy with
unsustainable. Alternative livelihoods have the Hydro Power projects that are being
been provided though implementation is implemented in the State. However,
still an issue. dialogue has always been welcomed with
How can a small mountain state make dissenters. Many projects have then been
it thus far? Only from generous plan and modified or degraded suitably to take into
non plan funding from Government of India. account the concerns. However, it is
Sikkim’s own resources are limited and important to realise that there is justifiable
only eco-tourism and Hydro power is the key opposition to the implementation of these
to generate any real level of State resources. projects. On the other hand Sikkim has very
If and when Nathula pass opens up fully little options if it wants to become free of
for trade then the State will have to find a dependence on central funding, even for
mechanism of getting a share of the trade running the Government machinery on a
surpluses that will inevitably accrue. So, day to day basis. The overheads of
Sikkim’s annual plan size and non plan Governance are indeed very high!
component is mainly funded by assistance The objective is that by 2015 the State

Population Foundation of India |24


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

25|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

should be able to take care of the resource and so today it is best known for being the
requirements through aforementioned most peaceful State in India. Even though
routes. it is strategically placed with eyeball to
eyeball contact with China (Tibet) the
Political Power Facilitation integration with the mainstream is not
The Government in the State is formed really a problem.
by the leader of the Sikkim Democratic In response to the wishes of the people
Front Party, Dr. Pawan Chamling. Now a and during this time in office there has been
very well known politician in India and is a huge fillip given to rural development,
also known as the ‘greenest’ Chief Minister3 . health and universalisation of education.
The recent IFMR/CDF 2008 award of being Right from the start about 70 percent of the
the second in terms of Environmental Plan allocation has been used in the villages
Sustainability Index (ESI) among 28 States of Sikkim. The rural population is over 85
in India is in line and correlates positively percent and so in many ways this is truly
with the green policies of the State. targeted spending.
Chief Minister Chamling has been at the Just recently Dr. Chamling personally
helm of affairs for the last 14 years and into received the Rashtriya Nirmal Gram
concluding his third term in office4 . Political Puraskar, for 100 percent coverage in
stability has led to an enabling environment sanitation within the State. This is a clear
where deepening and indeed widening of indication that there is both depth and reach
reach of various schemes of State and in terms of scope of the projects that are
Central Government has been facilitated. being carried out in the State. This is aided
The State also has the lowest crime rate in part by the network of roads that have
3
First Acknowledged by Centre For Science & Environment (CSE) survey published in Down To Earth Feb 15, 1999 issue
4
Power to the People: 14 Glorious Years of the SDF Government 1994 – 2008, GOS publication

Population Foundation of India |26


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

27|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

been built up over the last thirty years. environment management, health and
Being a mountain State it tries its best education. The downside is that the rural
to fit the programs offered from Delhi to the people of Sikkim are far more dependent
mountain issues of the State. Mountain on Government largesse. This is not a
specificities are unique. Only recently have healthy situation for sustainable growth.
mountain issues have been given some
thought and mind space in the Planning Policy Planning Initiatives
Commission. Is there now scope for better Sikkim was perhaps one of the early
policy mechanisms that can be worked out adopters of assessing its Human
uniquely for mountain States? This question Development Index in 20015 . Sikkim’s HDI
is going to receive further impetus in the is close to the national index if not better.
time to come as Government grapples with It was 0.532 in 1999 and should have
an ‘inclusive growth’ agenda. increased in the last eight years.
So, with a strong leadership and clear Furthermore, Government commissioned
cut people-centric direction, policies have the making of a Vision Document in 1999
been formulated to enable opportunities for to understand the goals that needed to be
people. Access to funds and programs, for achieved over a sustained period of fifteen
remote villages, are also facilitated by years. Much of it has been achieved though
respective MLAs and Panchayat leaders. all have not been fulfilled and lots more
The way democracy has panned out here work is still to be done.
makes this possible. This accounts for One of the key initiatives has been for
much of the appreciation that Sikkim is Government to set out the direction for
currently receiving in the fields of growth. This was documented in the

5
Sikkim Human Development Report 2001, Mahendra P. Lama

Population Foundation of India |28


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

29|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Sikkim: The People’s Vision Report industry and emerging financial


authored by Ashok K. Lahiri et al from the businesses. These augers well for a
NIPFP, New Delhi. pronounced impact back in Sikkim in the
‘An accelerated path of eco-friendly years to come. Sikkim will reap its share
sustainable development’ – this was to be of this dividend but a policy to facilitate
Sikkim’s growth paradigm. “The aim is to this will have to be crafted out.
build on the state’s strengths, benefit from The means for achieving the overall
post-liberalisation spurt in growth in the vision has been well argued in the
rest of the country and, with judicious use document. This definitely formed the basis
of modern technology, in less than two on which much of the growth has happened.
decades, leave the centuries of Policies of Government were aligned to the
underdevelopment rapidly behind.”6 means as is thought through and stated.
Another important aspect was the The Government also constituted a
stabilization of population. This was to State Planning Commission and requested
achieve by 2050 constant population of half Prof. Muchkund Dubey7 to take the post of
a million. This goal however seems unlikely Deputy Chairman of the Commission in
to be achieved. Even at that time the 2002. He led the team for two consecutive
demographic dividend has been well three year terms. The Commission has been
articulated in the document. We see some able to make planning in the State more
of it playing out today as we find that many professional and capable. Capacity building
of the young people are working in all of the officers was also done especially in
different parts of the country and abroad bringing out much needed reports. This
in television and media, BPO and IT has allowed for much debate and better
6
Sikkim The People’s Vision, NIPFP, page 20
7
Former Foreign Secretary, GOI

Population Foundation of India |30


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

articulation of needs of the people. One of Future Challenges


the best things that came out of the Future challenges faced by Sikkim in
Commission was the devolution of powers the short and medium term relate to some
and functions to the Panchayats. District fundamental issues facing India and the
planning bodies have been constituted and world today. New economic outlooks will
bottom up approach of planning is now a have to be factored in even as globalisation
reality. Sikkim has today achieved the and its attendant problems kick in. Then
status of being recognised as the 3rd best there is the whole issue of climate change
State to implement the 73 rd and 74 th and making carbon friendly if not carbon
Amendments of the Constitution of India. neutral policy frameworks.
In fact more than 40 percent of women now Food security can be looked at the first
participate in the Panchayati Raj system of major challenge in the short term leading
local governance. to large scale vulnerability of Sikkim’s
Meanwhile, the Millennium population. Since about 75 percent of our
Development Goals (MDG) 8 is another food is imported the State faces the twin
important set of goals toward which challenges of increasing domestic
Government works in synchronisation for production as well as importing food without
achievement by 2015. Sikkim is doing better hindrance. We have the national highway
than most of the other States in achieving 31A as the only reliable entry to Sikkim.
these goals. Some of them have already been This is not without hassles from our
achieved. More research and surveys will neighbours, West Bengal and the
be done in the course of the next one year Gorkhaland agitators. Furthermore,
to ascertain the exact position and status severe landslides also have contributed to
of the State. this especially after the start of the
8
United Nations MDG adopted by GA 2000 – India Country Report 2005

31|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

construction of Teesta Stage 6 low dam sense of it all. This is where there are
project in West Bengal. different schools of thought. There is the
Access is also a major issue when trying perception of security and how does India
to bring high value tourists into the State. trade with our neighbour. The question of
The long route from Delhi or Kolkata and Tibet is always a ticklish one. Then there
then a four hour journey puts many people are issues of scaling up the items and having
off. People would like to come over the movement of people for tourism. The final
weekend and holiday and get back as soon thought in this is, of course, are the people
as possible, especially those who can afford of Sikkim ready? There is great concern on
to pay rather large sums. This has to be all fronts and so Government of Sikkim is
explored as a market option and tourism indeed taking a cautious approach.
positioning in the years to come. Sikkim will However, in the future this pass will be one
have its own airport by 2012. which will perhaps change Sikkim forever.
The third challenge is that Sikkim The fifth challenge is to achieve a major
cannot grow in isolation. The region breakthrough in the quality of delivery and
adjoining us also has to prosper in equal access of education and health. The
measure. For this to happen, the tussle Government and the Planning Commission
between the Darjeeling political movement is seized of this all important issue facing
for autonomy and the West Bengal the delivery system of Government.
Government has to be sorted out amicably. Governance will have to take this up with
The problem which is simmering is having greater focus in the next five years. One
a huge negative impact in the region as a of the ways to deliver greater coverage for
whole. health is to usher in Universal Financial
The fourth challenge is about the Inclusion, for the entire population of the
Nathula Pass and how to make commercial State using hitherto unavailable

Population Foundation of India |32


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

33|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

technologies. This would enable bank enough opportunities available for the
accounts to be opened up for every youth of Sikkim to be able to come back
household. This would be very useful for and contribute to the growth and
cutting down on middlemen for delivering development of the State is a must.
pensions and payments for NREG Scheme. Finally, there is the greatest challenge
Furthermore, all families would be linked of fiscal transformation. From a dependent
to some form of health and life insurance State on Central funds and grants to that
as well. There is also the issue of ensuring of being independent on a fiscal basis would
that the civil society plays a constructive be possible by 2015. Till then the Centre has
role in the furthering quality to prime the pump. Sikkim would be able
transformation that is required in all to harness enough of Hydro Power as well
spheres of social development. There are as make other fiscal arrangements to be able
high hopes that this will be possible but the to pay for its development agenda on a
key would be to deliver high quality sustainable basis.
primary education. Moreover, making

Population Foundation of India |34


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

35|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Chhattisgarh State Map Showing Districts

Map not to scale

Population Foundation of India |36


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Achievements of Chhattisgarh during


the Last Decade
T. Sundararaman*K.R. Antony**V.R. Raman***

Introduction and Summary expenditure, that improved the delivery

C
hhattisgarh is among the newest of quality health services and in improving
states of India, formed on 1 st the public health infrastructure and above
November 2000, by carving it out all that increased community awareness
from the then Madhya Pradesh State. and support for health programmes.
Throughout these seven years the state’s Of the various health outcome
health sector has recorded very good indicators, only Infant Mortality Rate (IMR)
improvements, though, given the base-lines and death rates are measurable and reliable
with which it started up, it has still a long on an annual basis and these showed
way to go to catch up to national averages significant declines in rural areas- though
on most parameters. One of the major they remained relatively unchanged in
contributors to this advance were the health urban areas where these reform measures
sector reforms in the state that led to a had not reached. In 2003, the Rural IMR
significant increase in public health was as poor as 77 per 1000 live births
* Executive Director, National Health System Resource Centre, New Delhi** Director, State Health Resource Centre, Chhattisgarh
*** Faculty, State Health Resource Centre , Chhattisgarh

37|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Population Foundation of India |38


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

whereas presently it is 62 which is equal declining IMR was the community level
to the national average. achievement in breastfeeding. In all aspects
Table-1: Mortality Trends in Chhattisgarh of breast feeding – in colostrum feeding, in
Indicators Chhattisgarh
early initiation of breastfeeding and in
2003 2007 exclusive breastfeeding, the state is now
Infant Mortality Rate( Total) 79 61 well above national averages. Both NFHS-
Infant Mortality Rate( Rural) 95 62 3 and District Level Household Survey
Infant Mortality Rate (Urban) 49 50
(DLHS) and the independent coverage
Crude Death Rate( Total) 8.5 8.1
Crude Death Rate (Rural) 9.1 8.5 evaluation survey done by UNICEF bears
Crude Death Rate (Urban) 7.1 6.3 this out. DLHS- 3 not only confirms these
Source: SRS, GoI general trends but shows further steep
On service delivery indicators the most gains in some areas. For example, children
reliable are the National Family Health receiving measles vaccine went up from
Survey (NFHS) data and a comparison 21.1% in 2002-03 to 79.9% in 2007-08. This
between the NFHS-2 done in 1998-99 (the outcome was a result of comprehensive
figures for Chhattisgarh were pulled out of community level health education drives
Madhya Pradesh sample and were sufficient that the state government was able to gear
for the purpose) and the NFHS-3, done in up through various measures like folk art
2005-06, further supports such a trend. based communication programmes followed
Thus complete immunisation rates more up together by health department staff and
than doubled (from 21.8% to 48.7% ), the central role played by the Mitanin.
children getting all three polio vaccines rose Also malnutrition made a modest
from 57% to 85% and antenatal coverage decline, much less than the improvement
went up also from 57 % to 89%. The other in service parameters. More important
parameter that correlates closely to child malnutrition still remains

39|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Comparison of Key trends under NFHS-2 and NFHS-3

Population Foundation of India |40


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

impermissibly high with over 52% of effective outreach to these children remain.
children below 3 years being malnourished. Improvement in Contraception
Though this improvement, reflects a much prevalence rate was also good, but not good
better inter departmental coordination enough to contain the birth rate, which is
and better access to services, the challenge now at 26.9. Much of the problem is in access
of addressing the social determinants of to services as unmet needs remain at a high
such high malnutrition and a much more 20.9% (DLHS-3).

NFHS-2 NFHS-3

41|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Population Foundation of India |42


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Apart from above, the state was able • Leprosy is another disease which is
to record major achievements in disease reaching the elimination stage. In 2003,
control - like: the prevalence rate was 7.20 per 10000
• YAWS- Disease of the underdeveloped populations which have been brought
areas- has been eliminated from the down to 1.99 through persistent efforts.
state and it is marching towards In 6 out of 16 districts national goal of
eradication. There were 15 identified less than 1 prevalence rate has been
cases of YAWS in the state in 2003, achieved and the remaining districts are
whereas within a year, this was brought moving quickly to achieve this. Though
down to zero. The Chhattisgarh efforts better case detection criteria would
on this has been highly appreciated by probably show a higher prevalence,
World Health Organisation (WHO) and there is no denying an overall decrease
our officials are now been invited to and an almost complete absence of new
support the YAWS operations in leprosy caused deformities.
countries like Indonesia. • In TB control, Malaria control and in
• The Polio scene has also been controlled HIV/AIDS the programmes inch
very well during this period. During the forward. The TB control programme,
initial days of the state, a threat of polio is now extended to all districts. In
was prevalent as some cases were Malaria control, the major achievement
reported in the state during that time. the Annual Parasite Incidence
With effective surveillance systems, (API), which was 10.6 in 2003, has been
management and immunisation brought down to 5.6, and epidemics with
initiatives, the disease has been deaths which were almost an annual
prevented as much as possible and “no feature in the past are much less now.
case” has been reported till date. Still, three of the southern districts

43|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Population Foundation of India |44


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

where API is high are critical. Innovations that have contributed to


Blindness control too has done well Chhattisgarh’s achievements.
and the performance is comparable to When the achievement of Chhattisgarh
the best amongst the states. are judged, they need to be seen against a
• A special programme to control Sickle baseline. At the time of its formation about
Cell Anaemia, a specific disease 40% of the sanctioned posts were vacant.
prevalent in the state is also being run. And each facility had less than one thirds
Operational research, mass screening of the staff it should have by Indian Public
and counselling as well as other Health Standard (IPHS) recommendations
measures initiated where support from and further almost one fifth of sub-centers,
Red Cross society is also availed. one third of Public Health Centres (PHCs)
• One of the areas where the state has were not created at all. Indeed the lack of
been most challenged and constrained infrastructure and development was one of
is in the improvement of institutional the reasons for creating a new state. The
deliveries under the Janani Suraksha new state had also got to create its own
Yojana (JSY). The institutional institutional framework for management
delivery level has stagnated at about and training of health staff and expand its
16% and this is reflective of the educational capacities.
constraints the state is facing with That the state was able to do all this was
facility based secondary services. With largely due to innovative and indigenous
the improvement in facilities and planning efforts linked to a wide variety of
human resource becoming available partnerships and trust in community
within a year of two, even these processes. Not all innovations and efforts
parameters should start showing have given immediate results and especially
considerable improvement. in improved service delivery in facilities the

45|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Population Foundation of India |46


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

states efforts must be strengthened and are giving their voluntary services in
sustained for one year before its impact every hamlet and in every nook and
would be measurable. We describe below corner of the state. They have undergone
some of the key innovations- many of which 10 rounds of trainings including one on
we note are today mainstreamed into the essential new born care and an
National Rural Health Mission (NRHM) at integrated management of the sick
the national level. Indeed the focus on neonate and child. They provide first
strengthening public health systems as the level curative care using drugs provided
centre-piece of health sector reform, as part of Mukhyamantri Dawa Peti
relegating public private partnerships to a Scheme. Learnings from the Mitanin
supplementary role, a major feature of the Scheme have had a major influence on
NRHM, was the approach that the design of ASHA (Accredited Social
Chhattisgarh took at a time when that had Health Activist) scheme under the
not yet become the major framework of National Rural Health Mission
reform. launched by Government of India. There
• Optimising the Community Level are seven important ways in which the
Measures- The Mitanin Programme: Mitanin programme differed with
The Mitanin Scheme of community earlier large scale community health
health volunteers, which began with worker programmes organised by the
much hesitation and teething troubles government. Firstly – all the Mitanins
has grown over the last few years into a are women. Secondly the area of
state level programme which serves as coverage was a habitation, which meant
an inspiration and an example for the less problem of heterogeneity and more
entire country. Today about 60000 access and what is most important a
Mitanins or voluntary health activists decreased work load making

47|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

voluntarism feasible. Thirdly selection programme made to, the visible


was by the community, but through a improvement in so many health
defined process and facilitated by a outcomes and service delivery
trained prerak who not only ensured outcomes, as disaggregated from other
that the community made an informed changes happening in this period, will
decision but also articulated the views forever remain difficult to determine.
of weaker sections. Fourthly, a strategy However, undeniably, five years after
where the main motivation was social its initiation the attendance at each
recognition and the spirit of service, round of training continues to be
where the honorarium in the form of undiminished, Mitanins in the vast
incentives for specific tasks, didn’t majority of hamlets continue to make
become central to her work. Fifth, modest daily contributions to better
training was considered and recurrent community health with undiminished
and continued activity for the entire enthusiasm, and tens of thousands of
duration of the programme and not just women have become empowered to
an initiating event. Sixth and what was articulate a variety of health and
important was a full time dedicated, related issues. These are in itself
specifically trained cadre of trainer- reasons for optimism and hope and the
facilitators who provided not only programme has become a flagship for
training, but also monitoring and much health sector reform, drawing not only
needed on the job support. And finally local leaders to attend to health issues,
management of the programme through but also finance departments to
state civil society partnerships at every sanction more funds for the health
level. The precise contribution that this sector..

Population Foundation of India |48


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

49|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

• Improving Performance of the silver stars and bronze stars


Hospitals: The Jeevan Deep respectively. The best hospital in every
Approach: In order to improve the district will get Rs. 2 lacs as reward
quality of management of the for good services. Chhattisgarh is the
government run hospitals and to pioneer state to have launched such a
change the perceptions of general peoples friendly target oriented scheme.
community about the poor quality of It will be a marked departure from the
services in government hospitals, a old Rogi Kalyan Samitis which were
pioneering hospital reform scheme running the hospitals earlier. Korba,
called the Jeevan Deep Scheme has Ambikapur and Durg are Silver Star
been put in place in the state. Under hospitals. The Korba District Hospital
this novel scheme a more responsive, has been since through a further process
more representative, more people of quality improvement been certified for
oriented and more target centric ISO 9001:2000- one of the very few
hospital management committees public hospitals in India to have been
called Jeevan Deep Samitis have been so certified.
created for every level of government • Developing FRU facilities and
hospitals up to the PHC. These bridging specialist gaps: the Equip
committees will also have the power Initiative: In terms of closing the gaps
to recommend disciplinary action in infrastructure, skilled manpower and
against non-performing officials. equipment in parallel to addressing
Under this scheme, every hospital in quality and adequacy of utilization of
the state will be graded on the basis of services, a new block by block approach
its service quality and best hospitals has been adopted by the state. This
will be given Jeevan Deep gold stars, approach goes by the acronym “EQUIP”-

Population Foundation of India |50


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Enhancing Quality in Primary health other disciplines are also started very
care- and it focuses on reduction of recently. This way the FRU service
maternal mortality as the quality index provision has been marked a much
around which health services are better status in the state if compared
rationalized. 32 blocks each has been to past- We would like to note that
taken up in the first two years and the these facilities are now becoming
entire state is planned to be covered in available even in some of those
another 3 years. So as to address the facilities situated in conflict-ridden
specialist gaps, an innovative training areas of the state.
programme for multiskilling doctors, • Placing Health into Panchayats
particularly in Emergency Obstetric Agenda- The Swasth Panchayat
Care (EmoC) and Anaesthesia, has been Scheme: This is a programme to
designed which has been replicated support local health planning and to
nationally now. These trainings are enhance Panchyat Raj Institutions (PRI)
conducted in 3 top medical institutions role in health. An indicator based health
of the state and so far 96 MBBS doctors & human development index has been
has been built capacities to impart prepared for all Panchayats of the state
EMoC services as well as anaesthesia. which is hamlet centred so as to capture
However only about 25% of this even the intra-panchayat variations. At
converted into functional First Referral present, the HHDI is ready for 9141
Units (FRUs), due to various operational Panchayats out of 9820 Panchayats in
constraints. Despite this, the number of the state. Honble Chief Minister of the
FRUs rose sharply and way forward on state has declared an award for two top
this difficult goal became clear. Training Panchayats of each block based on this
on essential neonatal care and some index and also provisions are made to

51|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

support weaker Panchayats identified Resource Centre (SHRC) to shape


under this process. The Programme is the reform processes and to initiate
now in the second year of them wherever it is necessary. The
implementation. This programme builds important innovation is not only that
on the community mobilisation initiated it is partnership between government
by the Mitanin programme and takes it and civil society, but also that it has
forward into village level comprehensive built a model of technical assistance
health planning. which is based on indigenous technical
• Reaching out to the people in every strengths, largely operates within a
corner- The Mobile Medical Units: government financial rules and what
Chhattisgarh is a tribal state where 44 is most important is based upon
% of the area is covered with forests. institutional capacity building and not
Reaching out to the far-flung corners of on external consultancy alone. Though
the state for providing health services this has been one of the earliest
is major challenge. In order to overcome innovations picked up for replication,
this challenge and to provide similar SHRCs have been slow to
uninterrupted health services in tribal emerge, and in retrospect one begins
blocks, as many as 74 mobile medical to appreciate the level of innovation
units have been operationalised in the and change that setting this up
state. They are providing valuable required.
services in the haat baazars of tribal
blocks in the state. Core Improvements:
• An innovative institutional model has Other than these major innovations,
been set up in the form of state-civil there are various “reform” milestones set
society joint initiative, the State Health by the NRHM that have been achieved by

Population Foundation of India |52


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

53|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

this state as well. These are not innovations- Community Health Centres(CHCs), 200
in that they represent well known, almost new Primary Health Centres and 874
routine measures of a functional health new sub centres have been sanctioned.
department. Yet it is often the By this, the state has achieved
implementation of these core measures that population norms for creation of
would have the maximum impact. We list a facilities except in the case of CHCs. In
few of these below: terms of filling the building gaps, 26
• Formation of State Health Mission CHCs, 39 PHCs and 201 sub centre
and Driving towards the NRHM buildings are under construction-
Goals: Moving towards health for the though the vast majority of sub-centres
poor, a state health mission has been still need to be provided with a building.
constituted under NRHM, Chaired by During the last 3 years, Rs 20 lacs per
the Hon. Chief Minister. State and block allocations are made under
District and Block programme various schemes for refurbishment of
Management Units are supporting the available buildings in all 146 blocks.
mission activities at respective levels. Under the ongoing European Union
Decentralised planning and State Partnership, infrastructure
management of resources to address development is a major focus.
local needs has become a reality. • Creation of the State Institute of
• Major Infrastructure Expansion: Health & Family Welfare(SIHFW):
The inadequacy in number of facilities A Human Resource Development policy
has been met during this period by for health has been adopted and SIHFW
sanctioning health facilities: apart from has been created to take forward the
district hospitals sanctioned and in most implementation of this policy. A state
cases built new for all districts, 17 new of the art building for SIHFW has been

Population Foundation of India |54


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

55|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

completed and the institution has given 150 primary health centres. Rural
adequate manpower and logistical posting of medical graduates as a
support in terms of achieving its goals. mandatory condition of consideration for
It is aimed that the capacity and post graduation has also led to over 150
motivation gaps among the field force doctors becoming every year on a
be addressed through systematic contractual basis. In addition to all of
planning and implementation of this all districts are empowered to fill
training programmes initiated by up vacancies on a contractual basis. To
SIHFW. expand the pool of medical officers
• Sanction of staff setup for the available for recruitment, two more
health department: A revised medical colleges, one in 2002 in
administrative set up was adopted in Bilaspur, and another in 2007 in
2006 under which adequate number of Jagdalpur have been added to the
posts was sanctioned in every health existing medical college at Raipur. More
facility. Though still short of the IPHS colleges are planned. In order to meet
norms, for Chhattisgarh it was a major the doctor deficiency, as an immediate
step forward. . measure the state has pooled 398 “rural
• Recruitment of Medical officers: For medical assistants” in PHCs from the
the first time after the state formation, ongoing 3 year medical course.
and almost after a period of 15 years, • Mainstreaming of Indian Systems of
449 doctors were appointed through Medicine: The Indian Systems of
Public Service Commission, and of these Medicine has been given top priority by
250 of them have joined the services. In the state. The Raipur Ayurveda College
addition AYUSH doctors have been used has been developed into a model college
to fill up medical officer posts in over and then as a University. Drug testing

Population Foundation of India |56


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

facilities, for ayurvedic drugs are now Emerging Policies and Initiatives:
available. Panchakarma therapy centres After an extensive process of discussion
and speciality clinics has been started with a wide variety of stakeholders, the
in a number of Allopathic health State Health & Population Policy has been
facilities so as to provide choice between prepared and this shall be notified soon. A
systems for the community in chronic new act for regulation of clinical
illness. As many as 86 Primary Health establishments under private sector is
Centres and Ayurvedic Dispenseries drafted and awaiting approval. There is a
have been merged. And all 60000 major plan being put in place to rapidly
Mitanins are being trained on household increase nursing education and nurse
herbal remedies availability within the system. A Bal
Hruday Suraksha Yojna (literally meaning
• Control of Food & Drugs: A state of Child Heart Protection Scheme) is proposed
the art Drug Testing Laboratory is as a special school health programme to help
ready for inauguration at Raipur city poor children with congenital cardiac
until now it was necessary to sent food/ diseases. A state wide urban health
drug samples to external laboratories programme and a scheme for building
for getting the sample tests done. In dharamsalas in every government hospital
addition to this, mobile laboratories are also being rolled out. 5000 telephone
have been made operational in order connections through BSNL to connect all
to make collecting samples from Sub Centres, PHCs, CHCs and district
remote and village areas possible. hospitals are under installation and an
Smoking and tobacco use has been emergency ambulance system is under
banned in public places. consideration.

57|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

A Comparative Chart on Health-Showing Growth on Various


Health Sector Reform Areas
AREA STATUS 2003 STATUS 2008 PURPOSE/ACHIEVEMENT

Policies and Programmes

Health and Population Policy Nil Finalised, awaiting approval Policy Governance

HRD Policy Nil Notified Planned HR Development

Drug Policy Nil Finalised, awaiting approval Towards rational drug use

Policy for Medically Underserved Areas Nil Under Preparation Reaching the unreached

Delegation and decentralisation of powers Upto District Upto Block Grassroots governance

Mainstreaming of AYUSH Not done Achieved Holistic approach

YAWS Control (No. of cases) 15 0 Towards Elimination

Polio Control (No. of cases) 2 0 Towards elimination

Leprosy Control (Prevalence Rate) 7.2 1.99 72.36 % reduction

TB Control (District Covered) 4 16 100 % coverage

Mitanin Programme (No. of Mitanins) Nil 60092 100 % coverage of rural areas

Medical Facilities in Public Sector

No. of Medical Colleges 2 3 1

No. of District Hospitals 9 15 6

No. of 100 bedded Civil Hospitals 8 16 8

No. of Community Health Centres 114 129 15

No. of Functional First Referral Units 0 64 64

No. of Primary Health Centres 512 727 215

No. of Primary Health Sub centres 3818 4728 910

Manpower

No. of Posts sanctioned of medical officers 1455 1737 282

Population Foundation of India |58


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Contd. ....
AREA STATUS 2003 STATUS 2008 PURPOSE/ACHIEVEMENT

No. of Posts sanctioned of Specialists 247 637 390

No. Doctors promoted as specialists 0 250 250

Doctors sanctioned for a PHC 1 2 2 times

Doctors sanctioned for CHC 4 8 2 times

Selection of Doctors through PSC 0 448 448

Completion of Buildings

New District hospital 0 6 6

New CHCs 0 36 36

New PHCs 0 73 73

New Sub centres 0 203 203

Fund Allocations

Budget outlay for Health Department 235.23 crores 485.7 crores Almost 2 times

Assistance Under Sanjeevni Kosh 2.49 crores 13.29 crores Almost 5 times

External Assistance Mobilised Less than 50 crores More than 300 crores Almost 3 times

Inpatient dietary allocations per head 8.00 Rs 16.00 Rs 2 times hike

Additional Untied Funds per District Hospital pa 0 5.0 lacs 5.0 lacs for 16 facilities

Additional Untied Funds per CHC pa 0 2.0 lacs 2.0 lacs for 117 facilities

Additional Untied Funds per PHC pa 0 0.5 lacs 0.5 lacs for 517 facilities

Additional Untied funds per Sub centre 0 0.18 lacs 0.18 lacs for 4692 facilities

59|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Indicators, Indices and Ranking of


States for the
4th JRD Tata Memorial Awards

Population Foundation of India |60


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Table 1: Inputs for Base Year in the States of India


Census, NFHS II NFHS II NFHS II NFHS II NFHS II NFHS II NFHS II SRS Census, Census, Census, National
1991 1991 1991 1991 Human
Development
Report,2001
State Sex Ratio Women CPR any Full TFR Atleast Safe % Children *IMR, Girl Female Literacy % of Plan
(0-6)-1991 (20-24) methods Immuni- three Delivery Underweight 1999 school Youth Rate(7+) Expenditure
married zation ANC attendance (15-24) on Social
by age 18 Visits rate (6-14), Literacy Sector,
1991 1997-98
Andhra Pradesh 975 64.3 59.6 58.7 2.3 80.1 65.2 37.7 66 46.1 41.0 44.1 22.46
Arunachal Pradesh 982 27.6 35.4 20.5 2.5 40.5 31.9 24.3 35 40.6 42.4 41.6 29.65
Assam 975 40.7 43.3 17.0 2.3 30.8 21.4 36.0 76 48.7 52.9 52.9 45.89
Bihar 953 71.9 23.5 12.5 3.7 15.6 25.3 54.4 63 29.1 28.3 37.5 17.26
Chhattisgarh 984 61.3 45.0 20.0 2.8 33.2 32.3 60.8 78 43.5 35.5 42.9 32.74
Delhi 915 19.8 63.8 69.8 2.4 68.2 65.9 34.7 25 76.3 75.0 75.3 51.9
Goa 964 10.1 47.5 82.6 1.8 95.7 90.8 28.6 17 84.3 85.7 75.5 42.83
Gujarat 928 40.7 59.0 53.0 2.7 60.2 53.5 45.1 63 58.0 58.4 61.3 22.97
Haryana 879 41.5 62.4 62.7 2.9 37.4 42.0 34.6 68 58.6 50.5 55.8 34.26
Himachal Pradesh 951 10.7 67.7 83.4 2.1 60.9 40.2 43.6 54 75.0 72.3 63.9 35.24
Jammu & Kashmir** 917 22.1 49.1 56.7 2.7 66.0 42.4 34.5 45 46.4 43.7 44.1 28.86
Jharkhand 979 64.1 27.6 6.5 2.8 24.5 17.5 54.3 71 34.2 30.1 41.4 17.26
Karnataka 960 46.3 58.3 60.0 2.1 71.4 59.1 43.9 58 56.1 54.8 56.0 32.31
Kerala 958 17.0 63.7 79.7 2.0 98.3 94.0 26.9 15 91.9 96.8 89.8 18.88
Madhya Pradesh 941 64.0 44.1 23.2 3.5 26.3 28.8 53.1 90 41.6 35.8 44.7 32.74
Maharashtra 946 47.7 60.9 78.4 2.5 65.4 59.4 49.6 48 66.5 67.0 64.9 20.69
Manipur 974 9.9 38.7 42.3 3.0 54.4 53.9 27.5 23 54.9 62.2 59.9 32.44
Meghalaya 986 25.5 20.2 14.3 4.6 31.3 20.6 37.9 61 42.6 56.9 49.1 37.83
Mizoram 969 11.6 57.7 59.6 2.9 75.8 67.5 27.7 14 68.2 87.2 82.3 30.35
Nagaland 993 22.9 30.3 14.1 3.8 23.1 32.8 24.1 32 54.4 70.0 61.6 36.73
Orissa 967 37.6 46.8 43.7 2.5 47.3 33.4 54.4 97 47.4 45.5 49.1 32.38
Punjab 875 11.6 66.7 72.1 2.2 57.0 62.6 28.7 53 65.4 66.5 58.5 20.67
Rajasthan 916 68.3 40.3 17.3 3.8 22.9 35.8 50.6 81 27.7 25.9 38.6 24.22
Sikkim 965 22.3 53.8 47.4 2.8 42.6 35.1 20.6 46 62.0 61.7 56.9 45.38
Tamil Nadu 948 24.9 52.1 88.8 2.2 91.4 83.8 36.7 52 71.1 63.9 62.7 38.89
Tripura 967 37.7 55.5 40.7 1.9 47.2 47.5 42.6 27 56.6 62.4 60.4 43.18
Uttar Pradesh 927 64.3 27.3 20.5 4.1 14.7 21.8 52.2 84 30.4 31.6 40.7 29.6
Uttarakhand 949 25.9 43.1 34.6 2.6 19.7 34.6 41.8 52 55.2 55.9 57.8 29.6
West Bengal 967 45.9 66.6 43.8 2.3 57.0 44.2 48.7 52 47.3 56.1 57.7 22.83
Maximum 1000 100.0 100.0 100.0 6 100.0 100.0 100.0 150.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100
Minimum 700 0 0 0 2.1 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0
*IMR for 1998, SRS Bulletin, April 2000
**1991 census figures=(2001-1981)/2+1981

61|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Table 2: Input for the Final Year in the States of India


Census, NFHS III NFHS III NFHS III NFHS III NFHS III NFHS III NFHS III SRS Under Five Mortality Census, Census, Census, Statistical
2001 Rate, 2001 2001 2001 Abstract,
Census, 2001 India,2001

State Sex Ratio Women CPR Full TFR, Atleast Safe % IMR, M/F M/F Girl Female Literacy % of Plan
(0-6) (20-24) any Immuni- three Delivery Children 2005 Ratio Ratio school Youth Rate(7+) Expenditure
married methods zation ANC Underweight (Truncated attendance (15-24) on Social
by Visits at 1) rate Literacy Sector,
age 18 (6-14 yrs) Rate 2004-05
Andhra Pradesh 961 54.7 67.6 46.0 1.8 85.4 74.9 32.5 57 1.09 1.0 74.3 64.7 60.5 30.0
Arunachal Pradesh 964 40.6 43.2 28.4 3.0 35.5 30.2 32.5 37 1.03 1.0 56.7 61.6 54.3 31.6
Assam 965 38.0 56.5 31.4 2.4 39.3 31.0 36.4 68 1.05 1.0 62.5 68.1 63.3 32.5
Bihar 942 60.3 34.1 32.8 4.0 17.0 29.3 55.9 61 0.88 0.9 40.6 42.8 47.0 33.3
Chhattisgarh 975 51.8 53.2 48.7 2.6 54.2 41.6 47.1 63 1.07 1.0 69.9 68.8 64.7 39.9
Delhi 868 21.2 66.9 63.2 2.1 75.1 64.1 26.1 35 0.96 1.0 83.4 85.2 81.7 50.6
Goa 938 11.7 48.2 78.6 1.8 94.9 94.0 25.0 16 0.98 1.0 89.4 91.0 82.0 43.2
Gujarat 883 33.5 66.6 45.2 2.4 67.5 63.0 44.6 54 0.99 1.0 71.4 72.4 69.1 37.3
Haryana 819 39.8 63.4 65.3 2.7 59.2 48.9 39.6 60 0.89 0.9 75.7 75.3 67.9 44.1
Himachal Pradesh 896 12.3 72.6 74.2 1.9 62.6 47.8 36.5 49 1.09 1.0 90.5 89.3 76.5 46.9
Jammu & Kashmir 941 14.0 52.6 66.7 2.4 73.5 56.5 25.6 50 0.96 1.0 60.3 57.4 55.5 29.7
Jharkhand 965 61.2 35.7 34.2 3.3 35.9 27.8 56.5 50 0.98 1.0 51.2 50.3 53.6 29.2
Karnataka 946 41.2 63.6 55.0 2.1 79.5 69.7 37.6 50 1.06 1.0 74.2 73.7 66.6 29.6
Kerala 960 15.4 68.6 75.3 1.9 93.6 99.4 22.9 14 0.87 0.9 95.1 98.1 90.9 22.3
Madhya Pradesh 932 53.0 55.9 40.3 3.1 40.7 32.7 60.0 76 0.95 1.0 65.7 62.6 63.7 30.3
Maharashtra 913 38.8 66.9 58.8 2.1 75.1 68.7 37.0 36 1.01 1.0 84.7 84.9 76.9 44.7
Manipur 957 12.7 48.7 46.8 2.8 68.6 59.0 22.1 13 0.96 1.0 77.9 79.5 70.5 36.2
Meghalaya 973 24.5 24.3 32.9 3.8 54.0 31.1 48.8 49 1.03 1.0 60.3 74.0 62.6 38.0
Mizoram 964 20.6 59.9 46.5 2.9 59.3 65.4 19.9 20 1.01 1.0 81.2 92.6 88.8 28.1
Nagaland 964 21.1 29.7 21.0 3.7 32.7 24.7 25.2 18 0.83 0.8 70.0 73.3 66.6 33.6
Orissa 953 36.3 50.7 51.8 2.4 61.8 44.0 40.7 75 1.05 1.0 64.9 66.3 63.1 29.0
Punjab 798 19.4 63.3 60.1 2.0 74.8 68.2 24.9 44 0.96 1.0 79.4 81.1 69.7 25.4
Rajasthan 909 57.1 47.2 26.5 3.2 41.2 41.0 39.9 68 0.92 0.9 60.9 54.9 60.4 31.4
Sikkim 963 30.1 57.6 69.6 2.0 70.1 53.7 19.7 30 1.03 1.0 81.2 79.8 68.8 40.9
Tamil Nadu 942 21.5 61.4 80.9 1.8 95.9 90.6 29.8 37 0.99 1.0 86.9 84.2 73.5 46.5
Tripura 966 41.0 65.7 49.7 2.2 60.0 48.8 39.6 31 1.01 1.0 75.0 78.7 73.2 44.3
Uttar Pradesh 916 53.0 43.6 23.0 3.8 26.6 27.2 42.4 73 0.89 0.9 57.8 53.2 56.3 30.6
Uttarakhan d 908 22.6 59.3 60.0 2.6 44.9 38.5 38.0 42 1.00 1.0 80.0 78.1 71.6 41.4
West Bengal 960 53.3 71.2 64.3 2.3 62.0 47.6 38.7 38 1.02 1.0 69.3 70.8 68.6 36.0
Maximum 1000 100 100 100 6 100 100 100 150 1 1 100 100 100 100
Minimum 700 0 0 0 2.1 0 0 0 5 0.83 0.83 0 0 0 0

Population Foundation of India |62


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Table 3: Index Values for Base and Final Years and Ranking
State Composite Rank of Composite Composite Rank of Change Rank 4*Change Rank of 4* Final Index Final Rank
index, NFHS III index (U5 index, NFHS II (NFHSIII-II) Change Change
NFHS III excluded), NFHS II (NFHS III-II) (NFHS III-II)
NFHS III
Chhatisgarh 61.8 19 58.9 45.4 24 13.5 1 54.0 1 115.8 1
Sikkim 73.5 5 71.5 61.9 12 9.6 5 38.3 5 111.8 2
Uttarakhand 66.4 15 63.8 53.8 19 9.9 3 39.7 3 106.1 3
Rajasthan 51.0 26 50.8 37.7 27 13.1 2 52.5 2 103.5 4
Manipur 70.7 9 70.3 62.8 9 7.5 11 30.0 11 100.8 5
Andhra Pradesh 68.9 11 66.5 58.5 13 7.9 9 31.8 9 100.6 6
Tamil Nadu 78.6 3 77.5 72.2 5 5.2 17 21.0 17 99.6 7
Jammu & Kashmir 66.0 16 65.2 57.7 16 7.5 12 30.0 12 95.9 8
West Bengal 67.2 14 64.7 57.9 15 6.8 13 27.4 13 94.6 9
Maharashtra 71.6 8 69.4 63.6 8 5.7 15 23.0 15 94.5 10
Madhya Pradesh 53.3 24 52.0 42.0 25 9.9 4 39.7 4 93.0 11
Orissa 62.0 18 59.1 51.5 22 7.6 10 30.3 10 92.4 12
Karnataka 69.8 10 67.5 62.1 10 5.4 16 21.5 16 91.3 13
Meghalaya 57.7 22 54.4 46.4 23 8.1 8 32.3 8 90.0 14
Jharkhand 50.8 27 48.0 39.3 26 8.6 7 34.6 7 85.4 15
Kerala 79.1 2 83.3 82.2 1 1.1 25 4.5 25 83.6 16
Tripura 68.3 12 65.9 62.1 11 3.8 21 15.2 21 83.5 17
Gujarat 65.2 17 62.9 58.5 14 4.4 20 17.7 20 82.9 18
Uttar Pradesh 44.6 28 45.3 36.2 28 9.1 6 36.5 6 81.1 19
Himachal Pradesh 72.5 6 70.3 68.7 6 1.6 23 6.5 23 79.0 20
Assam 59.6 20 56.4 51.8 21 4.6 19 18.5 19 78.0 21
Goa 80.4 1 79.8 80.5 2 -0.7 27 -2.8 27 77.6 22
Haryana 58.6 21 60.4 55.7 17 4.7 18 19.0 18 77.6 23
Punjab 67.8 13 67.2 65.5 7 1.7 22 6.6 22 74.5 24
Mizoram 74.0 4 72.0 73.3 3 -1.3 29 -5.3 29 68.7 25
Delhi 71.6 7 71.3 72.4 4 -1.2 28 -4.6 28 67.0 26
Bihar 40.9 29 41.8 35.8 29 5.9 14 23.8 14 64.7 27
Nagaland 52.4 25 56.4 54.8 18 1.6 24 6.5 24 58.9 28
Arunachal Pradesh 57.0 23 53.7 53.3 20 0.4 26 1.7 26 58.7 29

63|Population Foundation of India


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

Table 4: Ranking of States on Reproductive and Child Health Programmes in India

Bigger States Smaller States


S.No. States Rank S.No. States Rank
1. Chhattisgarh 1 1. Sikkim 1
2. Rajasthan 2 2. Uttarakhand 2
3. Andhra Pradesh 3 3. Manipur 3
4. Tamil Nadu 4 4. Meghalaya 4
5. Jammu & Kashmir 5 5. Tripura 5
6. West Bengal 6 6. Himachal Pradesh 6
7. Maharashtra 7 7. Goa 7
8. Madhya Pradesh 8 8. Mizoram 8
9. Orissa 9 9. Nagaland 9
10. Karnataka 10 10. Arunachal Pradesh 10
11. Jharkhand 11
12. Kerala 12
13. Gujarat 13
14. Uttar Pradesh 14
15. Assam 15
16. Haryana 16
17. Punjab 17
18. Delhi 18
19 Bihar 19

Population Foundation of India |64


JRD TATA MEMORIAL AWARD FOR POPULATION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMMES 2008

BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Government of India, Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation, (2002).
Statistical Abstract, India 2001. New Delhi: Ministry of Statistics and Programme
Implementation.
2. Government of India, Planning Commission, (2002). National Human Development
Report 2001. Delhi: Oxford University Press.
3. IIPS and Macro-International, (2007). India. National Family Health Survey (NFHS-
3). India. Vol.1. 2005-06.Mumbai: IIPS.
4. IIPS and ORC Macro, (2001a). India. National Family Health Survey (NFHS-2).1998-
99.Mumbai: IIPS.
5. India, Registrar General, (1997). Fertility Tables Part VI- F Series. Census of India
1991. Series 1- India, States and Union Territories. Delhi: Registrar General and
Census Commissioner.
6. India, Registrar General, (2004). Primary Census Abstract. Total Population. Table
A-5. Census of India 2001. India. Delhi: Registrar General and Census Commissioner.
7. India, Registrar General, (2002). Sample Registration System Statistical Report
1999. Delhi: Controller of Publication.
8. India, Registrar General, (2006a). Sample Registration System Statistical Report
2005. Report No.2 of 2006. Delhi: Controller of Publication.

65|Population Foundation of India


Vision -
“ Promoting, Fostering and Inspiring sustainable and balanced human development with a focus on
population stabilization through an enabling environment for an ascending quality of life with equity
and justice.”
Mission Statement-
PFI will strive to realize its Vision by promoting and formulating gender sensitive and rights based
population and development policies, strategies and programmes.
To this end, it will
· Collaborate with central, state and local government institutions for effective policy planning,
formulation and facilitation of programme implementation.
· Extend technical and financial support to individuals and civil society institutions and promote
innovative approaches.
· Undertake and support systems, action, translational and other forms of operational research.
· Create awareness and undertake informed advocacy at the community, regional, national and
global levels for socio-cultural and behavioural change.
· Focus on un-served, under-served areas and vulnerable sections of society and address the
challenges of an emerging demographic transition.
· Mobilize financial and human resources from all sources both national and international.

Population Foundation of India


B-28, Qutab Institutional Area, Tara Crescent, New Delhi 110 016
Tel. No : 42899770 , Fax : 42899795
Website : www.popfound.org, E-mail : popfound@sify.com
Designed and Printed by : IMAGE - 9811116841

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen