Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
a deemed dividend arising from FC10’s sale 5203, Internal Revenue Service, POB plan qualified under section 401(a) and
of the FC11 preferred stock to FC12. 7604, Ben Franklin Station, Washington, designed to invest primarily in
(ii) Analysis. FC10 has $5000x of earnings DC 20044. Submissions may be hand- qualifying employer securities. Section
and profits for 2008 attributable to a dividend
delivered Monday through Friday 4975(e)(8) states that the term qualifying
from a section 304 transaction which was
part of a plan a principal purpose of which between the hours of 8 a.m. and 4 p.m. employer security means any employer
was the avoidance of Federal income to: CC:PA:LPD:PR (REG–133578–05), security within the meaning of section
taxation. Under paragraph (e)(3)(v) of this Courier’s Desk, Internal Revenue 409(l). Section 409(l) generally provides
section, these earnings and profits are Service, 1111 Constitution Avenue, that the term employer security means
allocated to the common and preferred stock NW., Washington, DC. Alternatively, common stock issued by the employer
of FC10 in accordance with the relative value taxpayers may submit comments (or a corporation that is a member of the
of each class of stock. Thus, for taxable year same controlled group) that is readily
electronically directly to the IRS
2008, $2500x is allocated to FC10’s common
Internet site at http://www.irs.gov/regs, tradable on an established securities
stock and $2500x is allocated to its preferred
stock. or via the Federal eRulemaking Portal at market, if the corporation (or a member
http://www.regulations.gov (IRS–REG– of the controlled group) has common
(7) Effective dates. Except as provided 133578–05). stock that is readily tradable on an
in paragraphs (e)(3)(v) and (e)(4)(ii) of established securities market. Section
this section, this paragraph (e) applies FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Concerning the regulations, John T. 409(l)(4)(A) provides that, for purposes
for taxable years of a controlled foreign of section 409(l), the term controlled
corporation beginning on or after Ricotta at (202) 622–6060 with respect
to section 404(k) or Martin Huck at (202) group of corporations has the meaning
January 1, 2005. * * * given to that term by section 1563(a)
622–7750 with respect to section 162(k);
* * * * * concerning submission of comments or (determined without regard to
Mark E. Matthews, to request a public hearing, Robin Jones subsections (a)(4) and (e)(3)(C) of
at (202) 622–7180 (not toll-free section 1563). Section 409(l)(4)(B)
Deputy Commissioner for Services and
numbers). provides that, for purposes of section
Enforcement.
409(l)(4)(A), if a common parent owns
[FR Doc. 05–16610 Filed 8–24–05; 8:45 am] SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: directly stock possessing at least 50
BILLING CODE 4830–01–P
Background and Explanation of percent of the voting power of all
Provisions classes of stock and at least 50 percent
of each class of nonvoting stock in a first
DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY This document contains proposed tier subsidiary, such subsidiary (and all
regulations under sections 162(k) and corporations below it in the chain
Internal Revenue Service 404(k) of the Internal Revenue Code which would meet the 80 percent test of
(Code). These regulations address two section 1563(a) if the first tier subsidiary
26 CFR Part 1 issues that have arisen in the were the common parent) are treated as
[REG–133578–05] application of these sections. The first includible corporations.
issue arises in a case in which the Section 404(k)(2), for taxable years
RIN 1545–BE74
applicable employer securities held in beginning on or after January 1, 2002,
Dividends Paid Deduction for Stock an employee stock ownership plan generally provides that the term
Held in Employee Stock Ownership (ESOP) are not securities of the applicable dividend means any
Plan corporation or corporations that dividend which, in accordance with the
maintain the plan. The issue is which plan provisions—(i) is paid in cash to
AGENCY: Internal Revenue Service (IRS), corporation is entitled to the deduction the participants in the plan or their
Treasury. under section 404(k) for certain beneficiaries, (ii) is paid to the plan and
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking. dividends paid with respect to the stock is distributed in cash to participants in
held in the ESOP. The second issue is the plan or their beneficiaries not later
SUMMARY: This document contains whether payments in redemption of than 90 days after the close of the plan
proposed regulations under sections stock held by an ESOP are deductible. year in which paid, (iii) is, at the
162(k) and 404(k) of the Internal
Code and Regulations election of such participants or their
Revenue Code (Code) relating to
beneficiaries—(I) payable as provided in
employee stock ownership plans Section 404(a) provides that clause (i) or (ii), or (II) paid to the plan
(ESOPs). The regulations provide contributions paid by an employer to or and reinvested in qualifying employer
guidance concerning which corporation under a stock bonus, pension, profit securities, or (iv) is used to make
is entitled to the deduction for sharing, or annuity plan are deductible payments on a loan described in section
applicable dividends under section under section 404(a), if they would be 404(a)(9), the proceeds of which were
404(k). These regulations also clarify otherwise deductible, within the used to acquire the employer securities
that a payment in redemption of limitations of that section. Section (whether or not allocated to
employer securities held by an ESOP is 404(k)(1) provides that, in the case of a participants) with respect to which the
not deductible. These regulations will C corporation, there is allowed as a dividend is paid. Under section
affect administrators of, employers deduction for a taxable year the amount 404(k)(4), the deduction is allowable in
maintaining, participants in, and of any applicable dividend paid in cash the taxable year of the corporation in
beneficiaries of ESOPs. In addition, they by such corporation during the taxable which the dividend is paid or
will affect corporations that make year with respect to applicable distributed to a participant or
distributions in redemption of stock employer securities held by an ESOP. beneficiary.
held in an ESOP. The deduction under section 404(k) is Prior to 2002, section 404(k)(5)(A)
DATES: Written or electronic comments in addition to the deductions allowed provided that the Secretary may
and requests for a public hearing must under section 404(a). disallow the deduction under section
be received by November 23, 2005. Section 4975(e)(7) provides, in 404(k) for any dividend if the Secretary
ADDRESSES: Send submissions to: relevant part, that an ESOP is a defined determines that such dividend
CC:PA:LPD:PR (REG–133578–05), room contribution plan that is a stock bonus constitutes, in substance, an evasion of
VerDate jul<14>2003 15:46 Aug 24, 2005 Jkt 205001 PO 00000 Frm 00016 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\25AUP1.SGM 25AUP1
49898 Federal Register / Vol. 70, No. 164 / Thursday, August 25, 2005 / Proposed Rules
taxation. Section 662(b) of the Economic by an ESOP that are used to make once for the value of the stock originally
Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation benefit distributions to participants or contributed to the ESOP and again for
Act of 2001 (115 Stat. 38, 2001) beneficiaries, including distributions of the amount paid to redeem the same
amended section 404(k)(5)(A) to provide a participant’s account balance upon stock. See Charles Ilfeld Co. v.
that the Secretary may disallow a severance from employment. These Hernandez, 292 U.S. 62 (1934).
deduction under section 404(k) for any taxpayers have argued that the Moreover, despite the Ninth Circuit’s
dividend the Secretary determines payments in redemption qualify as conclusion in Boise Cascade, the IRS
constitutes, in substance, an avoidance dividends under sections 301 and 316 and Treasury Department continue to
or evasion of taxation. The amendment and, therefore, are deductible under believe that, even if a payment in
is effective for tax years after December section 404(k). redemption of stock held by an ESOP
31, 2001. In Rev. Rul. 2001–6 (2001–1 C.B. 491), were to qualify as an applicable
Section 162(k)(1) generally provides the IRS concluded that section 162(k) dividend, section 162(k) would disallow
that no deduction otherwise allowable bars a deduction for payments made in a deduction for that amount because
under chapter 1 of the Code is allowed redemption of stock from an ESOP. This such payment would be in connection
for any amount paid or incurred by a conclusion was based on the fact that with the reacquisition of the
corporation in connection with the section 162(k)(1) disallows a deduction corporation’s stock.
reacquisition of its stock or the stock of for payments paid in connection with This notice of proposed rulemaking,
any related person (as defined in section the reacquisition of an issuer’s stock and therefore, includes proposed regulations
465(b)(3)(C)). The legislative history of that the redemption payments are such under section 404(k) that confirm that
section 162(k) states that the phrase ‘‘in payments. The IRS also concluded that payments made to reacquire stock held
connection with’’ is ‘‘intended to be such payments were not applicable by an ESOP are not deductible under
construed broadly.’’ H.R. Conf. Rep. No. dividends under section 404(k)(1). The section 404(k) because such payments
99–841, at 168 (1986). IRS reasoned that allowing a deduction do not constitute applicable dividends
for redemption amounts would vitiate under section 404(k)(2) and a deduction
Corporation Entitled to Section 404(k)
important rights and protections for for such payments would constitute, in
Deduction
recipients of ESOP distributions, substance, an avoidance or evasion of
An ESOP may benefit employees of including the right to reduce taxes by taxation within the meaning of section
more than one corporation. In addition, utilizing the return of basis provisions 404(k)(5). It also includes proposed
an ESOP may be maintained by a under section 72, the right to make regulations under section 162(k) that
corporation other than the payor of a rollovers of ESOP distributions received provide that section 162(k), subject to
dividend. In these cases, the issue arises upon separation from service, and the certain exceptions, disallows any
as to which entity is entitled to the protection against involuntary cash- deduction for amounts paid or incurred
deduction provided under section outs. Finally, the IRS stated that a by a corporation in connection with the
404(k). Assume, for example, that a deduction under section 404(k)(1) for reacquisition of its stock or the stock of
publicly traded corporation owns all of such amounts would constitute, in any related person (as defined in section
the stock of a subsidiary. The subsidiary substance, an evasion of tax. 465(b)(3)(C)). The proposed regulations
operates a trade or business with In Boise Cascade Corporation v. also provide that amounts paid or
employees in the U.S. and maintains an United States, 329 F.3d 751 (9th Cir. incurred in connection with the
ESOP that holds stock of its parent for 2003), the Court of Appeals for the reacquisition of stock include amounts
its employees. If the parent distributes Ninth Circuit held that payments made paid by a corporation to reacquire its
a dividend with respect to its stock held by a corporation to redeem its stock stock from an ESOP that are then
in the ESOP maintained by the held by its ESOP were deductible as distributed by the ESOP to its
subsidiary, questions have arisen as to dividends paid under section 404(k), participants (or their beneficiaries) or
whether the parent or subsidiary is and that the deduction was not otherwise used in a manner described in
entitled to the deduction under section precluded by section 162(k). The court section 404(k)(2)(A).
404(k). This question arises in cases in reasoned that the distribution by the
which the parent and subsidiary file a ESOP of the redemption proceeds to the Proposed Effective Date
consolidated return as well as in cases participants was a transaction separate These regulations are proposed to be
in which the parent and subsidiary do from the redemption transaction. effective on the date of issuance of final
not file a consolidated return. Therefore, the court concluded that the regulations. However, before these
The IRS and Treasury Department distribution did not constitute a regulations become effective, the IRS
believe that the statutory language of payment in connection with the will continue to assert in any matter in
section 404(k) clearly provides that only corporation’s reacquisition of its stock, controversy outside of the Ninth Circuit
the payor of the applicable dividend is and section 162(k) did not bar the that sections 162(k) and 404(k) disallow
entitled to the deduction under section deduction of such payments. a deduction for payments to reacquire
404(k), regardless of whether the For the reasons stated in Rev. Rul. employer securities held by an ESOP.
employees of multiple corporations 2001–6, the IRS and Treasury See Chief Counsel Notice 2004–038
benefit under the ESOP and regardless Department continue to believe that (October 1, 2004) available at http://
of whether another member of the allowing a deduction for amounts paid www.irs.gov/foia through the electronic
controlled group maintains the ESOP. to reacquire stock is inconsistent with reading room.
Therefore, in the example above, the the intent of, and policies underlying,
section 404. In addition, the IRS and Special Analyses
parent, not the subsidiary, is entitled to
the deduction under section 404(k). Treasury Department believe that It has been determined that this notice
allowing such a deduction would of proposed rulemaking is not a
Treatment of Payments Made To constitute, in substance, an avoidance or significant regulatory action as defined
Reacquire Stock evasion of taxation within the meaning in Executive Order 12866. Therefore, a
Some corporations have claimed of section 404(k)(5)(A) because it would regulatory assessment is not required. It
deductions under section 404(k) for allow a corporation to claim two has also been determined that section
payments in redemption of stock held deductions for the same economic cost: 553(b) of the Administrative Procedure
VerDate jul<14>2003 15:46 Aug 24, 2005 Jkt 205001 PO 00000 Frm 00017 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\25AUP1.SGM 25AUP1
Federal Register / Vol. 70, No. 164 / Thursday, August 25, 2005 / Proposed Rules 49899
Act (5 U.S.C. chapter 5) does not apply § 1.162(k)–1 Disallowance of deduction for addition, these shares are listed on the
to these regulations, and, because the reacquisition payments. New York Stock Exchange, in the form
regulations do not impose a collection (a) In general. Except as provided in of American Depositary Shares, and are
of information on small entities, the paragraph (b) of this section, no actively traded through American
Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. deduction otherwise allowable is Depositary Receipts (ADRs) meeting the
chapter 6) does not apply. Pursuant to allowed under Chapter 1 of the Internal requirements of section 409(l). S
section 7805(f) of the Code, this notice Revenue Code for any amount paid or maintains an ESOP for its employees.
of proposed rulemaking will be incurred by a corporation in connection The ESOP holds ADRs of P on Date X
submitted to the Chief Counsel for with the reacquisition of its stock or the and receives a dividend with respect to
Advocacy of the Small Business stock of any related person (as defined those employer securities. The
Administration for comment on its in section 465(b)(3)(C)). Amounts paid dividends received by the ESOP
impact on small business. or incurred in connection with the constitute applicable dividends as
reacquisition of stock include amounts described in section 404(k)(2).
Comments and Public Hearing paid by a corporation to reacquire its (ii) Conclusion. P, as the payor of the
stock from an ESOP that are used in a dividend, is entitled to a deduction
Before these proposed regulations are
manner described in section under section 404(k) with respect to the
adopted as final regulations,
404(k)(2)(A). See § 1.404(k)–3. dividends, although as a foreign
consideration will be given to any
(b) Exceptions. Paragraph (a) of this corporation P does not obtain a U.S. tax
written (a signed original and eight (8)
section does not apply to any— benefit from the deduction. No
copies) or electronic comments that are (i) Deduction allowable under section
submitted timely to the IRS. The IRS corporation other than the corporation
163 (relating to interest); paying the dividend is entitled to the
and Treasury Department specifically (ii) Deduction for amounts that are
request comments on the clarity of the deduction under section 404(k). Thus,
properly allocable to indebtedness and because S did not pay the dividends, S
proposed regulations and how they may amortized over the term of such
be made easier to understand. All is not entitled to a deduction under
indebtedness; section 404(k). The answer would be the
comments will be available for public (iii) Deduction for dividends paid
inspection and copying. A public same if P is a U.S. C corporation.
(within the meaning of section 561); or
hearing will be scheduled if requested (iv) Amount paid or incurred in Q–2: What is the effective date of this
in writing by any person that timely connection with the redemption of any section?
submits written comments. If a public stock in a regulated investment A–2: This section applies with respect
hearing is scheduled, notice of the date, company that issues only stock which is to dividends paid on or after the date
time, and place for the public hearing redeemable upon the demand of the these regulations are published as final
will be published in the Federal shareholder. regulations in the Federal Register.
Register. (c) Effective date. This section applies Par. 4. Section 1.404(k)–3 is added to
with respect to amounts paid or read as follows:
Drafting Information
incurred on or after the date these
The principal authors of these regulations are published as final § 1.404(k)–3 Disallowance of deduction for
regulations in the Federal Register. reacquisition payments.
regulations are John T. Ricotta, Office of
Division Counsel/Associate Chief Par. 3. Section 1.404(k)–2 is added to Q–1: Are payments to reacquire stock
Counsel (Tax Exempt and Government read as follows: held by an ESOP applicable dividends
Entities) and Martin Huck of Office of § 1.404(k)–2 Dividends paid by corporation that are deductible under section
Associate Chief Counsel (Corporate). not maintaining ESOP. 404(k)(1)?
However, other personnel from the IRS Q–1: What corporation is entitled to A–1: (a) Payments to reacquire stock
and Treasury participated in the the deduction provided under section held by an ESOP, including
development of these regulations. 404(k) for applicable dividends paid on reacquisition payments that are used to
applicable employer securities of a C make benefit distributions to
List of Subjects in 26 CFR Part 1
corporation held by an ESOP if the participants or beneficiaries, are not
Income taxes, Reporting and ESOP benefits employees of more than deductible under section 404(k)
recordkeeping requirements. one corporation or if the corporation because—
paying the dividend is not the (1) Those payments do not constitute
Proposed Amendments to the corporation maintaining the plan? applicable dividends under section
Regulations A–1: (a) In general. Under section 404(k)(2); and
Accordingly, 26 CFR part 1 is 404(k), only the corporation paying the (2) The treatment of those payments
proposed to be amended as follows: dividend is entitled to the deduction as applicable dividends would
with respect to applicable employer constitute, in substance, an avoidance or
PART 1—INCOME TAXES securities held by an ESOP. Thus, no evasion on taxation within the meaning
deduction is permitted to a corporation of section 404(k)(5).
Paragraph 1. The authority citation maintaining the ESOP if that
(b) See § 1.162(k)–1 concerning the
for part 1 is amended to read, in part, corporation does not pay the dividend.
(b) Example. (i) Facts. S is a U.S. disallowance of deductions for amounts
as follows: paid or incurred by a corporation in
corporation that is wholly owned by P,
Authority: 26 U.S.C. 7805 * * *.
an entity organized under the laws of connection with the reacquisition of its
Section 1.162(k)–1 is also issued under 26
Country A that is classified as a stock from an ESOP.
U.S.C. 162(k) * * *. Q–2: What is the effective date of this
corporation for Federal income tax
Section 1.404(k)–3 is also issued under 26 section?
purposes. P is not engaged in a U.S.
U.S.C. 162(k) and 404(k)(5)(A) * * *.
trade or business. P has a single class of A–2: This section applies with respect
Par. 2. Section 1.162(k)–1 is added to common stock that is listed on a stock to payments to reacquire stock that are
read as follows: exchange in a foreign country. In made on or after the date these
VerDate jul<14>2003 15:46 Aug 24, 2005 Jkt 205001 PO 00000 Frm 00018 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\25AUP1.SGM 25AUP1
49900 Federal Register / Vol. 70, No. 164 / Thursday, August 25, 2005 / Proposed Rules
VerDate jul<14>2003 15:46 Aug 24, 2005 Jkt 205001 PO 00000 Frm 00019 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\25AUP1.SGM 25AUP1