Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Received 11 August 2003; received in revised form 20 July 2004; accepted 30 October 2004
Available online 23 March 2005
Abstract
This paper presents a new control algorithm for an active power filter (APF) to compensate harmonic and reactive power of a 3-phase
thyristor bridge rectifier under non-ideal mains voltage scenarios. Sensing load current, dc bus voltage and source voltages compute reference
currents of the APF. APF driving signals are produced with these signals via a hysteresis band current controller. Matlab/simulink power
system toolbox is used to simulate the proposed system. The proposed method’s performance is compared with conventional instantaneous
power (p–q) theory. The simulation results are presented and discussed showing the effectiveness of the control algorithm. The proposed
algorithm is found quite satisfactory to compensate the reactive power and harmonics under non-ideal mains voltage conditions. The increased
performance of the active power filter under different non-sinusoidal mains voltage and dynamic load conditions are extensively demonstrated.
© 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Active power filter; Non-ideal mains voltage; Instantaneous power (p–q) theory
0378-7796/$ – see front matter © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.epsr.2004.10.014
364 M. Kale, E. Özdemir / Electric Power Systems Research 74 (2005) 363–370
In order to obtain the reference compensation currents in the The conventional instantaneous reactive power (p–q) the-
a–b–c coordinates the inverse of the transformation given in ory is inadequate under non-ideal mains voltage scenarios. In
expression (9) is applied [6]: order to improve the performance, the new algorithm is devel-
oped. Alternating value (p̃) of instantaneous real power (p)
∗ 1 0 and instantaneous imaginary power (q) are unwanted com-
ica 1 √
2 3 icα ponents of the power system. The shunt active power filter is
∗ −
icb = 2 2 (9) controlled as it gives the negatives of these components. If
3 √ icβ
i∗cc 1 3 the mains voltages are distorted and/or unbalanced, alternat-
− − ing values of the instantaneous real and imaginer power have
2 2
current harmonics and voltage harmonics. The shunt APF
does not generate compensation current equal to current har-
4. Hysteresis band current controller monics, since the APF compensating currents include mains
and load harmonics. Consequently, APF gives to mains more
The actual active power filter line currents are monitored than load harmonics than required. In order to eliminate this
instantaneously, and then compared to the reference currents drawback and to decrease total harmonic distortion to de-
generated by the control algorithm. In order to get precise in- sired level, the instantaneous reactive and active powers have
stantaneous current control, the current control method must to calculate after filtering of mains voltages. In the proposed
supply quick current controllability, thus quick response. For method, in order to reduce numbers of filters d–q reference
this reason, hysteresis band current control for active power coordinate transformation is used. In order to increase the
filter line currents can be implemented to generate the switch- performance of the instantaneous power theory to a distorted
ing pattern the inverter. There are various current control and unbalanced mains voltage, the measured mains voltage
methods proposed for such active power filter configura- is low-pass filtered in a rotating reference frame. Hence, the
tions, but in terms of quick current controllability and easy non-ideal mains voltages are converted to ideal sinusoidal
implementation hysteresis band current control method has shape by using the fifth-order 50 Hz cutoff frequency low-
the highest rate among other current control methods such pass filters in d–q coordinates.
as sinusoidal PWM. Hysteresis band current control is the The proposed method block diagram, that presents the
fastest control with minimum hardware and software but even calculations required in this method, is shown in Fig. 3 .
switching frequency is its main drawback. The filtered d–q components of the voltages (vd and vq ) are
The hysteresis band current control scheme, used for the converted to voltages in α–β coordinates as given in Fig. 3.
control of active power filter line current, is shown in Fig. 2, These voltages are used in Equation (5) in order to calculate
composed of a hysteresis around the reference line current. real and imaginary powers. The proposed method can be used
The reference line current of the active power filter is referred when the voltages are distorted or unbalanced and sinusoidal
to as i∗c and actual line current of the active power filter is re- currents are desired. Schematic block diagram of proposed
ferred to as ic . The hysteresis band current controller decides method controlled shunt APF is shown in Fig. 4.
366 M. Kale, E. Özdemir / Electric Power Systems Research 74 (2005) 363–370
In the proposed method, instantaneous voltages are first plied to the power system by switching of the power transis-
converted to α–β coordinates and then to stationary d–q co- tors of the inverter. The hysteresis band current controller as
ordinates. The produced d–q components of voltages are fil- mentioned above section IV achieves the method for gener-
tered and reverse converted α–β coordinates (as expressed in ation of the switching pattern.
Equation (10)). These filtered α–β components of voltages
are used in conventional instantaneous power theory (Equa-
6. Simulation results
tion (7)). Hence, the non-ideal mains voltages are converted
to ideal sinusoidal shape by using low pass filter in d–q co- The presented simulation results were obtained by us-
ordinates. The time constant of the low pass filter is 12 e−3 . ing Matlab–Simulink Power System Toolbox software, for
So, the mains voltages assumed to be an ideal source in the a three-phase power system with a shunt APF. The proposed
calculation process. method has been simulated under four scenarios, including
ideal mains voltage, unbalanced three-phase mains voltage,
Vα cos φ − sin φ Vd distorted mains voltage and unbalanced–distorted mains volt-
= (10)
Vβ sin φ cos φ Vq age conditions. In order to evaluate dynamic performance of
the proposed method, in 1.5-s thyristor rectifier firing an-
The three-phase reference currents, which the active power gle are changed from 15◦ to 30◦ . The proposed algorithm
filter configuration should supply to the three-phase actual dynamic performances under such dynamic conditions are
power system, should be obtained. These reference currents, investigated by detailed simulation study. The simulation re-
calculated by the control algorithm equations should be sup- sults are discussed below.
Fig. 5. Ideal mains voltage simulation results with the proposed method.
Fig. 6. Unbalanced mains voltage simulation results with p–q theory.
as:
vda = 311 sin(ωt) + 4 sin(3ωt) + 18 sin(5ωt − 120◦ ) + 4.6 sin(7ωt) + 3.1 sin(11ωt − 120◦ )
vdb = 311 sin(ωt − 120◦ ) + 4 sin(3ωt − 120◦ ) + 18 sin(5ωt) + 4.6 sin(7ωt − 120◦ ) + 3.1 sin(11ωt) (12)
vdc = 311 sin(ωt − 240◦ ) + 4 sin(3ωt − 240◦ ) + 18 sin(5ωt − 240◦ ) + 4.6 sin(7ωt − 240◦ ) + 3.1 sin(11ωt − 240◦ )
Figs. 9 and 10 show simulation results of distorted mains volt-
6.4. Distorted–unbalanced mains voltages
ages scenario with p–q theory and the proposed algorithm,
respectively. The performance of the instantaneous power al-
When the three-phase mains voltages are distorted and
gorithm for this case is shown not qualified. The three-phase
unbalanced (vdu ), the mains voltages have harmonic compo-
compensated mains currents have 7% THD level in phase
nents and unbalanced. For this case, the distorted and unbal-
“a” in instantaneous power theory. After compensation, these
anced three-phase mains voltages are expressed as:
vdua = 311 sin(ωt) + 31 sin(t) + 4 sin(3ωt) + 18 sin(5ωt − 120◦ ) + 4.6 sin(7ωt) + 3.1 sin(11ωt − 120◦ )
vdub = 311 sin(ωt − 120◦ ) + 31 sin(ωt − 240◦ ) + 4 sin(3ωt − 120◦ ) + 18 sin(5ωt) + 4.6 sin(7ωt − 120◦ )
+ 3.1 sin(11ωt) (13)
vduc = 311 sin(ωt − 240◦ ) + 31 sin(ωt − 120◦ ) + 4 sin(3ωt − 240◦ ) + 18 sin(5ωt − 240◦ ) + 4.6 sin(7ωt − 240◦ )
+ 3.1 sin(11ωt − 240◦ )
Fig. 11 and Fig. 12 show simulation results of
currents have sinusoidal waveform and 3.6% THD level for
distorted–unbalanced mains voltage scenario with p–q
the proposed method in distorted mains voltages scenario, a
theory and the proposed algorithm, respectively. The perfor-
smaller value than that is regulated by any power quality stan-
mance of the instantaneous power algorithm for this case is
dard. There is a significant reduction in harmonic distortion
shown not qualified. The three-phase compensated mains
level. Therefore, the performance of the proposed method is
better than that of the conventional p–q theory.
Fig. 10. Distorted mains voltage simulation results with the proposed
Fig. 9. Distorted mains voltage simulation results with p–q theory. method.
M. Kale, E. Özdemir / Electric Power Systems Research 74 (2005) 363–370 369
Fig. 11. Distorted–unbalanced mains voltage simulation results with p–q Fig. 12. Distorted–unbalanced mains voltage simulation results with the
theory. proposed method.
Table 2
THD levels of a, b and c phase currents in different operating conditions by different approach
Operating condition Load THD level (%) The p–q theory THD level (%) The proposed approach THD level (%)
Phase “a” Phase “b” Phase “c” Phase “a” Phase “b” Phase “c” Phase “a” Phase “b” Phase “c”
Ideal mains voltage 26.7 26.7 26.7 3.6 3.6 3.6 3.6 3.6 3.6
Distorted mains voltage 25.77 25.77 25.77 7 7 7 3.6 3.6 3.6
Unbalanced mains 22.26 28.41 29.71 11.2 11.2 11.2 3.6 3.6 3.6
voltage
Unbalanced–distorted 22 27.8 28.47 13 13 13 3.6 3.6 3.6
mains voltage
Table 3
1, 3 and 5 harmonic magnitudes of phase currents in load, p–q and the proposed method
Operating condition 1 Fundamental current magnitude (A) 3 Harmonic current magnitude (A) 5 Harmonic current magnitude (A)
Table 4
7, 9 and 11 harmonic magnitudes of phase currents in load, p–q and the proposed method
Operating condition 7, harmonic current magnitude (A) 9, harmonic current magnitude (A) 11, harmonic current magnitude (A)
All figures show that the actual currents are almost agrees Acknowledgement
with the reference currents. The above figures indicate that af-
ter compensation the mains currents are still sinusoidal even The authors would like to express there thanks to finan-
when the mains voltages are distorted and/or unbalanced. In cial support given by the Kocaeli University Research Fund,
an unsymmetrical or distorted voltage system, the results ob- Project Number: 2001/13.
tained by the p–q theory are not good. However, the proposed
theory gives good results for both non-ideal and distorted
voltage system. In the proposed method, the distorted mains References
voltages do not affect the compensated mains current.
[1] H. Akagi, Y. Kanazawa, A. Nabae, Instantaneous reactive power
compensators comprising switching devices without energy stor-
age components, IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl. 20 (1984) 625–
7. Conclusion 630.
[2] Y. Komatsu, T. Kawabata, A control method for the active power
In this paper, a new APF control scheme has been pro- filter in unsymmetrical voltage systems, Int. J. Electron. 86 (10)
posed to improve the performance of APF under non-ideal (1999) 1249–1260.
mains voltage conditions. The computer simulations have [3] S.J. Huang, et al., A study of three-phase active power filters un-
der non-ideal mains voltages, Electric Power Syst. Res. 49 (1999)
verified the effectiveness of the proposed control scheme. 125–137.
From the simulation results, the proposed approach was very [4] C.C. Chen, Y.Y. Hsu, A novel approach to the design of a shunt
successful and easily implemented. Active power filters, active filter for an unbalanced three-phase four-wire system under
based on the proposed theory, give satisfactory operation nonsinusoidal conditions, IEEE Trans. Power Deliv. 15 (4) (2000)
even when the system phase voltages are unsymmetrical and 1258–1264.
[5] H. Akagi, A. Nabae, S. Atoh, Control strategy of active power filters
distorted, because no distortion appears in the line currents. using multiple voltage-source PWM converters, IEEE Trans. Ind.
In non-ideal mains voltage condition, the source currents by Appl. 1A-22 (1986) 460–465.
the instantaneous power (p–q) theory are distorted, but the [6] J. Afonso, et al., Active filters with control based on the p–q theory,
source currents by the proposed method have no distortion. IEEE Ind. Electron. Soc. Newsletter 47 (3) (2000) 5–11.
The increased performance of the APF under different non- [7] F.Z. Peng, G.W. Ott, D.J. Adams, Harmonic and reactive power
compensation based on the generalized instantaneous reactive power
sinusoidal mains voltage conditions is extensively demon- theory for 3-phase 4-wire systems, IEEE Trans. Power Electron. 13
strated. The APF is found effective to meet IEEE 519 standard (November) (1998) 1174–1181.
recommendations on harmonics levels in all of the non-ideal [8] B. Singh, K. Haddad, A. Chandra, A new control approach to three-
voltage conditions. The performance of the proposed algo- phase active filter for harmonics and reactive power compensation,
rithm is therefore superior to that of conventional three-phase IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 13 (1) (1998) 133–138.
[9] W.E. Kazibwe, M.H. Sendaula, Electric Power Quality Control Tech-
APF control algorithm. Its control circuit is also simpler that niques, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, 1993.
those of published non-ideal mains voltage algorithms. [10] N.G. Hingorani, L. Gyugyi, Understanding FACTS, IEEE Press, New
The unsymmetrical distorted voltage system is the most York, 2000.
severe condition. However, good results can be obtained by [11] H. Akagi, New trends in active filters for power conditioning, IEEE
the proposed theory. Trans. Ind. Appl. 32 (1996) 1312–1322.