Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The Siren Mode: Female Body Image in the Ballets Russes and
Haute Couture c.1927- 1929
Katerina Pantelides
From 1920-1927 the garonne, an androgynous female icon dominated Paris
fashion and Sergei Diaghilevs Ballets Russes, as a boyish silhouette and youthful,
unsophisticated mannerisms were promoted by fashion arbiters and the Russian
migr ballet company alike. However, during the late 1920s, the garonne gave
way to more traditional visions of femininity. Couturiers, most notably Madeleine
Vionnet, pioneered complex garment constructions that alternately clung to and
flowed from the body, thus exaggerating its feminine form, while Diaghilevs
ballets began to feature chimerical sirens and goddesses whose appearance and
reality were discordant. Whereas in the early 1920s woman was envisioned as
playful and childishly straight-forward, from about 1927 gender difference was
accentuated as women from both the spheres of fashion and ballet began to be
portrayed as seductive, fascinating and remote.
My paper seeks to explore the relationship ballet and fashion in the late 1920s
through this supremely feminine and mysterious siren figure. It will firstly consider
how and why the siren evolved from the garonne and eventually replaced her, and
will then compare evocations of siren-like femininity in ballet and fashion. It will
particularly address the parallels between the couturier Vionnet and the
choreographer George Balanchines revelation and stylisation of the female body.
The influence of the Neoclassical and Modernist artistic movements will be
evaluated alongside the ballet dancers prolonged exile from Russia, as the paper
examines why woman was mythologised as a muse and seductress during this
period.
Key Words: Balanchine, ballet, bias-cut, classicism, body, dance, essential,
femininity, light, movement, shadow, siren, Vionnet
emulate classical arts allegedly timeless celebration of the wellproportioned natural bodys lines. As Pamela Golbin has observed,
Vionnets chief innovation to this end was to use the bias cut, which
traditionally lined bodices, for the entire garment. This caused the
fabric to alternately delineate and flow from the bodys contours,
thus enabling it to gain elasticity and become a sort of second skin
around a body in motion.xxix
Like Balanchines glove-like
choreography Vionnets innovations with the bias cut enabled her to
refine and flatter her clients bodies in motion. This is apparent in
Cecil Beatons 1929 photograph of a mannequin wearing a bias-cut
pale blue crepe romain dress with a handkerchief hem and a gold
bead embellishment that traverses the torso diagonally and mirrors
the bodices pointed hem. (image 5) The sleeveless dress imbues the
mannequin with agility: her athletically toned arms are exposed; the
diagonal gold decoration causes light to stream across her form and
the asymmetric triangular handkerchief skirt skims the curve of her
hips and anticipates a dynamic play of legs. Arnold has observed that
by freeing the fabric through such applications of the bias cut,
(Vionnet) was also freeing the woman, enabling her body to be
revealed and celebrated, unhampered by bourgeois notions of
modesty and decorum.xxx Vionnets dresses then, much like Apollos
choreography, reinvigorated classical feminine body image by
pursuing the synaesthetic trope of bodily movement and warmth
within visual clarity. This paradox evokes Michel Serress discussion
of Cinderellas slipper, which in Charles Perraults original fairytale
was vair (Old French for fur), but transubstantiated to verre
(French for glass) in eighteenth-century variants of the tale. While
Balanchine and Vionnet strove for the transparent homogeneity of
verre in their classical bodily schemas, in reality the transformative,
contrasting forms that they grafted onto the body resembled vair,
whose etymology lies in variety. Serres wrote that the vair slipper
unlike its rigid verre antecedent was flexible but specific, with the
potential for all shapes but fitting one only... holding the foot firmly
but allowing it to dance.xxxi The vair slippers contrapuntal
precision and flexibility, along with its contained support of the
10
11
command the spectator to stop and devote his attention to her. With
her explicitly stylised, provocative appearance, Dubrovskas Siren
embodies Freuds conception of female vanity as compensation for
original sexual inferiority, a notion tailored to the biblical parables
moral.
The emphasis on shadow in Dubrovskas body image, along with the
slow, supine, coitally suggestive aspects of her choreography which
jarred with the ballets otherwise accelerated tempo, evoked
seductresses in contemporary silent film. A similar exposition of
serpentine, sirenic femininity was revealed in The Woman he
Scorned (1929).xxxviii In a comparable manner to Prodigal Son, a film
still foregrounds the protagonist Pola Negris legs, which are
suggestively folded and elongated through laddered black stockings.
(image 7) The stockings webbed texture recalls the painted
patternation of Doubrovskas legs, and arguably hints at the dubious
morality of flesh revealed through thread-like textures. Oscillating
between the contraries of revelation and concealment, construction
and decadence, open, lace-like fabrics imply enchantment through
titillation and deception. Negris character in the film was morally
tainted, and therefore an acceptable source of titillation. Similarly, in
being revealed and later defeated, Dubrovskas body, much like
Negris symbolised bourgeois societys simultaneous fascination and
fear of female sexuality.
Still, the magnetism of such stage and screen seductresses, whose
imagery was accessible to all who encountered it in the theatre or
press, coupled with a relaxation of sexual mores in the 1920s, meant
that adaptations of their webbed costumes filtered into the evening
wear and lingerie of middle class women. Under the umbrella of
bourgeois consumption it became socially acceptable for women to
portray elements of the femme fatale, albeit in a less overt manner
than Dubrovska and Negri. This was often achieved through latticelike fabrics that embodied the feminine riddle through their
contrapuntal translucency and highly-worked, intricate surfaces. A
12
13
Notes
14
xiii
The ballet La Chatte premiered on April 30, 1927. The choreography was by
George Balanchine, the music by Henri Sauget and the set and costume design by
Naum Gabo.
xiv
Martin Hammer, Constructing Modernity: The Art and Career of Naum Gabo
(New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2000), 159.
xv
Hammer, Art and Career of Naum Gabo, 159.
xvi
Grigoriev, Diaghilev Ballet, 235.
xvii
Alice Nikitina, Nikitina: by herself , (London: Wingate, 1959), 59.
xviii
The couturier Premet said in an interview If fashion stays the way it is, it will
become a public menace. Clothes nowadays dont vary enough from one season to
the next. Premet interview with M. Winters in Les Cahiers, January
1927.Translated from the French by Jacqueline Demornex. Quoted in Jacqueline
Demornex, Lucien Lelong, (London: Thames & Hudson, 2008), 56.
xix
Translation by author : the line is kinetic and the effect is obtained by treatment
of different parts of the silhouette. Lucien Lelong, La Mode kinoptique,
LOfficiel de la Couture et la Mode de Paris, (Paris, March 1927).
xx
Lelong, La Mode Kinoptique.
xxi
LOfficiel de la Couture et la Mode de Paris, (Paris, May 1928).
xxii
Arnold, Vionnet and Classicism, 3.
xxiii
Apollo was originally titled Apollon Musagte and premiered on April 27,
1928. It was choreographed by George Balanchine, designed and costumed by
Andr Bauchant, with music by Stravinsky.
xxiv
Igor Stravinsky, An Autobiography, (London: Boyars, 1990), 134.
xxv
Stephanie Jordan, Stravinsky Dances: Re-visions Across a Century, (Alton:
Dance Books, 2007), 147.
xxvi
George Balanchine, quoted in Arnold Haskell, Arnold Haskell, Balletomania:
the Story of an Obsession, (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1934), 146.
xxvii
Alexandra Danilova, Choura: the Memoirs of Alexandra Danilova, ( New
York: Knopf, 1986), 99; Nikitina, Nikitina by Herself , 89.
xxviii
Madeleine Vionnet quoted in: Betty Kirke, Madeleine Vionnet, (San
Franscisco: Chronicle Books, 1998), 27.
xxix
Pamela Golbin, Madeleine Vionnet, (New York: Rizzoli, 2009), 25.
xxx
Arnold, Vionnet and Classicism, 5.
xxxi
Michel Serres, The Five Senses: A Philosophy of Mingled Bodies, translated
from the French by Margaret Sankey (London and New York: Continuum, 2009),
62.
xxxii
The Prodigal Son was choreographed by George Balanchine, designed by
George Rouault with music by Prokofiev. It premiered on May 21, 1929.
xxxiii
Felia Dubrovska quoted in Barbara Newman, Striking a Balance: Dancers
Talk About Dancing (London: Elm Tree Books, 1982), 7.
xxxiv
Dubrovska, Striking a Balance, 7.
15
xxxv
Bibliography
Arnold, Rebecca. Vionnet and Classicism in Madeleine Vionnet, 15 Dresses
from the Collection of Martin Kamer, Judith Clark Costume, 15 March 26 April
2001, ed. Judith Clark (London: Judith Clark Costume, 2001).
De Beauvoir, Simone. The Second Sex , Translated from the French by H.M
Parshley (New York : Modern Books, 1968).
Bolton, Andrew and Koda, Harold. Chanel, (New York: Metropolitan Museum
of Art, 1991).
Conor, Liz. The Spectacular Modern Woman: Feminine Visibility in the 1920s
(Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2004).
Danilova, Alexandra. Choura: the Memoirs of Alexandra Danilova, (New York:
Knopf, 1986).
Demornex, Jacqueline. Lucien Lelong, (London: Thames & Hudson, 2008).
Golbin, Pamela. Madeleine Vionnet, (New York: Rizzoli, 2009).
Grigoriev, Sergei. The Diaghilev Ballet 1909-1929, Translated from the Russian by
Vera Bowen (London: Constable, 1953).
Hammer, Martin. Constructing Modernity: The Art and Career of Naum Gabo
(New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2000).
Harpers Bazaar (New York: Hearst Publications).
16
Haskell, Arnold. Balletomania: the Story of an Obsession, (New York: Simon &
Schuster, 1934).
Jordan, Stephanie. Stravinsky Dances: Re-visions Across a Century, (Alton: Dance
Books, 2007).
Kirke, Betty. Madeleine Vionnet, (San Franscisco: Chronicle Books, 1998).
Kracauer, Siegfied. Travel and Dance, The Mass Ornament: Weimar Essays,
Translated from the German by Thomas Y. Levin (Cambridge MA: Harvard
University Press, 1995).
LOfficiel de la Couture et la Mode de Paris, (Paris).
Newman, Barbara. Striking a Balance: Dancers Talk About Dancing, (London:
Elm Tree Books, 1982).
Nikitina, Alice. Nikitina: By Herself , (London: Wingate, 1959).
Schilder, Paul. The Image and Appearance of the Human Body: Studies in
Constructive Energies of the Psyche (New York: International Universities Press
Inc., 1950).
Serres, Michel. The Five Senses: A Philosophy of Mingled Bodies, translated from
the French by Margaret Sankey (London and New York: Continuum, 2009).
Stravinsky, Igor. An Autobiography, (London: Boyars, 1990).
Filmography
The Woman He Scorned, Film, directed by Paul Czinner (1929, United Kingdom).
List of Illustrations
Image 1. Alice Nikitina and Serge Lifar in La Chatte, 1927, photographic print,
Tate collections, in Martin Hammer, Constructing Modernity : The Art and
Career of Naum Gabo, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2000, pg. 152.
17
Image 2. Chanel dress, 1928, illustrated print, in LOfficiel de la Couture et la
Mode de Paris, Paris, May 1928.
Image 3. Figure 18. G.L. Manuel Freres, Alice Nikitina as Terpsichore in Apollon
Musagete. Paris, 1928. In Musee Nationale de lOpera de Paris, Bibliothque
nationale de France, Paris.
Image 4. Unknown photographer, Danilova as Terpsichore in Apollon Musagete
. c.1928. In Choura: the Memoirs of Alexandra Danilova by Alexandra Danilova.
New York: Knopf, 1986, pg. 9.
Image 5. Cecil Beaton, Mannequin in Vionnet dress, 1929. In Madeleine Vionnet
by Betty Kirke, San Franscisco: Chronicle Books, 1998, pg. 38.
Image 6. David, Felia Doubrovska in Le Fils Prodigue, 1929, photographic print,
Parmenia Ekstrom Collection (157) ,Harvard Theatre Collection, Cambridge,
Massachusetts .
Image 7. Pola Negri in The Woman he Scorned, 1929, photographic print in Pola
Negri, Memoirs of a Star (Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1970).
Image 8. Kitmir, Seed pearls, glass beads and silk thread on black silk tulle
sample, late 1920s in Fonds Kitmir, Maison Hurel, Paris.
Image 9. Lingerie of Cobweb Texture, illustrated print in Harpers Bazaar (New
York: Hearst Publications) March, 1929.
18
Illustrations
19
20
21
Image 8- Kitmir, Seed pearls, glass beads and silk thread on black silk tulle
sample, late 1920s
22