Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Analysis
The trial scene is the longest in the play and stands as one of the most dramatic scenes in all of
Shakespeare. A number of critics have raised questions about the accuracy and fairness of the courtroom
proceedings: the presiding duke is far from impartial; Portia appears as an unbiased legal authority, when
in fact she is married to the defendants best friend; and she appears in disguise, under a false name.
These points would seem to stack the deck against Shylock, but if the trial is not just, then the play is not
just, and it ceases to be a comedy. Thus, while Portia bends the rules of the court, her decision is
nonetheless legally accurate. More important for the cause of justice, the original bond was made under
false pretensesShylock lied when he told Antonio that he would never collect the pound of flesh.
Therefore, Portias actions restore justice instead of pervert it.
The portion of the scene that passes before Portias entrance shows a triumphant and merciless Shylock.
When asked to explain his reasons for wanting Antonios flesh, he says, I am not bound to please thee
with my answers (IV.i.6 4 ). The only answer that the court gets, ultimately, is that Shylock merely emulates
Christian behavior. Just as some Christians hate cats, pigs, and rats, Shylock hates Antonio. Just as some
Christians own slaves, Shylock owns a pound of Antonios flesh. Shylock has the law on his side, and his
chief emotion seems to be outrage that Christian Venice would deny him what is rightfully his. Shylock is
not so much attacking the Venetian worldview as demanding that he be allowed to share in it. His speech
about slavery is emphatically not an antislavery diatribe: he is in favor owning people, as long as he can
own Antonio. In spite of itself, Venetian society is made an accomplice to Shylocks murderous demands,
and while this complicity certainly does not exonerate Shylock, it has the almost equally desirable effect of
bringing everyone else down with him. Shylocks intention is not to condemn the institution of slavery, and
certainly not to urge its eradicationit is to express that his urges simply mirror those already found among
wealthy Venetians, and to demand that his desires be greeted with the same respect.
The trial is not modeled on the English legal system. The duke presides and sentences, but a legal expert
in this case, Portiarenders the actual decision. This absolute power is appropriate for her character
because she alone has the strength to wield it. None of the men seem a match for Shylock: Gratiano
shouts and curses with anti-Semitic energy, Bassanio pleads uselessly, and Antonio seems resigned to his
fate. Indeed, Antonio seems almost eager for his execution, saying, I am a tainted wether of the flock, /
Meetest for death (IV.i.1 1 3 1 1 4 ). Antonio has been melancholy from the plays beginning, and now he has
found a cause to suit his unhappiness. He may be the focus of Shylocks hate, but he is less an antagonist
than a victim. It is left to Portia to put a stop to the moneylender and to restore the comedysomething in
short supply in Shylocks courtroomto the play.