Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1.0
INTRODUCTION
components that have just sink down, which later leave the
other part of hotter and heavier component remain at much
lower level. This process is continuously happening as the
heat zone is enlarging towards the bottom water layer [6]. In
a series of test conducted by students from University of
Science and Technology of China, they claimed gasoline
could not cause boilover while Daqing crude oil is possible
to produce boilover [7]. Viscosity of fuel is also a
contributing factor toward the occurrence boilover as lower
viscosity of water would enable the superheated water at the
bottom of tank to easily pass through the oil layer, instead of
pushing the burning fuel layer upward.
There has been many boilover studies conducted
involving experimental works and mathematical modelling.
Many of the experiments are using crude oil with variation
in the fuel thickness and diameter of the container used [5
and 6]. These parameters, when varies would affect other
parameters related to the boilover phenomena such as time
to boilover, and thermal radiation rate. Some of the studies
also use various type of fuel with different proportion during
the test [4]. However, there are lacking of studies in term of
studying the type of fuel that could boilover and its effect on
time to boilover and size of area affected. There is one study
suggesting that biodiesel is possible to produce boilover, but
more research on the matter is still needed [8]. Hence, this
paper would conduct experimental works to see the impact
of variation in the type of fuel and their thickness upon the
time required to boilover as well as size of area affected. It
should be noted that other parameters like the diameter of
container and wind velocity are not going to be studied this
project.
2.0
2.1
MATERIALS
2.1.1
Type of fuel
Types of fuel proposed to be tested in this project are petrol,
diesel, biodiesel and mixture of petrol and diesel. Petrol and
diesel are being tested for boilover simply because they are
the two product of crude distillation unit that are more
widely used around the world compared to other fraction of
the crude oil. As the boiling point of both petrol and diesel is
different, their mixture could emulate one of the crude oil
properties which are wide boiling point. By having lighter
and heavier component, the heat zone can develop and
induce the boiling of the water layer. Biodiesel are going to
be tested in this experiment because currently there are
almost no boilover researches that identify the capabilities
of biodiesel to cause boilover. In fact, the world have started
to shift their attention towards green and sustainable energy
source and there could be a possibility that biodiesel is
going to be globally used in the future in replace of petrol
and diesel derived from petroleum.
2.1.2 Experimental site
The location suitable to conduct the experiment is at area
which is away from buildings and vehicle as the fuels are
highly flammable and the experiment involves burning. The
open area should also be away from other ignition source to
2.1.3 Container
To emulate the open top tank of crude oil storage tank, an
open cylindrical tin biscuit container is going to be used.
The container to be used would have diameter of 18.5cm
and height of 7.0cm.
2.1.4 Video Camera
Video camera is necessary to record every runs of the
experiment. This includes the recording of micro-explosion
sound just before boilover happens. From the video camera
the flame height and its characteristic during burning can be
analysed visually. Time to boilover obtained from both of
video camera recording and on-site data recording using
stopwatch will be compared to get more accurate result.
2.1.5 Measuring tape/ruler
Measuring tape/ruler is required to measure the distance of
burning oil ejected from the container during boilover.
Horizontal distance on the ground would be measured from
wall of the container to the oil/burnt mark on the ground
after the boilover happen.
2.2
METHOD
The experimental works comprises of two parts; the
first part of the experiment is to test the type of fuel that will
boilover and the second part of the experiment involve on
finding the relationship between the initial fuel layer
thickness and time required for boilover to occur. Both part
of experiment would use a constant thickness of water
which is at 1.0 cm from the bottom of the container. Basic
procedure of the experimental works would be started by
calculating and preparing necessary fuel volume. Next,
water is going to be poured into the container prior to
pouring the fuel. Once at the experimental area, the fuel
would be ignited and simultaneously stopwatch would be
started. The burning would be observed until a micro
explosion noise is heard followed by the occurrence
boilover. As soon as the flame enlarges into a fireball
indicating boilover has started, stopwatch would be stopped
and time would be recorded.
2.2.1
Identification of type of fuel that can boilover
All of fuel type mentioned before would be prepared to
a same volume which is 400 ml except for mixture of petrol
& diesel which would have volume of 500 ml. Mixture of
petrol and diesel, would be mixed according to the ratio of
petrol:diesel; 30:70, 40:60, 50:50, 60:40, and 70:30
respectively.
2.2.2
Determination of relationship between initial
fuel thickness and time to boilover and size of area
affected
Continuation of results from previous part of the experiment
would be used. The selected fuel types are going to be
studied for its relationship between the initial thickness of
the fuel layer and time taken to boilover as well as the area
of size affected by the boilover. Fuel layer thickness would
start at 2.0 cm and will be varied every 0.5 cm until 5.0 cm.
The end range of fuel thickness is decided to be 5.0 cm to
account the volume for the 1.0 cm water layer and the height
of the container of 7.0 cm. Extending the range will cause
overspill of the fuel out from the container. Besides
investigating the effect of variation of initial fuel layer
thickness to the time required to boilover, distance of ejected
fuel from the container would also be recorded. Probable
size of area affected by boilover could be determined by
finding the circular area around the container through the
horizontal distance from the container to the point of oil
mark on the ground.
3.0
Type of Fuel
Petrol
Diesel
Mixture of
petrol and
diesel
Biodiesel
(Fatty Acid
Methyl Ester)
Boilover Occurrence
No. Petrol combusts but no boilover
incident was observed.
No. Diesel combusts but no boilover
incident was observed.
Yes. Different proportion of petrol and
diesel gave different boilover time and
distance of ejected fuel.
Yes. Biodiesel combusts and later
formed boilover.
Proportion of petrol
and diesel
Petrol
Diesel
30%
(150ml)
40%
(200ml)
50% (250
ml)
60% (300
ml)
70% (350
ml)
70%
(350ml)
60%
(300ml)
50% (250
ml)
40%
(200ml)
30% (150
ml)
Time to
boilover
12 min 20
sec
13 min 15
sec
11 min 32
sec
11 min 08
sec
10 min 16
sec
Farthest
distance of
fuel ejected
from container
71 cm
275 cm
153 cm
117 cm
193 cm
Property
Unit
Biodiesel Specs.
Ester content
% (m/m)
97.8
Linolenic acid
methylester
% (m/m)
0.3
Polyunsaturated
methylester
% (m/m)
<1
Methanol content
% (m/m)
< 0.1
Monoglyceride
content
% (m/m)
< 0.1
Diglyceride content
% (m/m)
< 0.1
Triglyceride content
% (m/m)
< 0.1
3.2
DETERMINATION OF RELATIONSHIP
BETWEEN FUEL THICKNESS TOWARD BOILOVER
TIME
AND
SIZE
OF AREA AFFECTED
From the first part of the experiment it has been identified
that mixture of petrol and diesel and biodiesel were possible
to form boilover.
3.2.1
Mixture of 70% petrol and 30% diesel
This mixture was selected for the second part of the
experiment because of its shortest boilover time and second
largest size of area affected, thereby putting it to be the most
unsafe boilover scenario compared to the other four fuel
composition. Summary of the detail of the experiment are
presented in the table and figures below.
Table 4: Summary of fuel thickness variation on the boilover (petrol &
diesel mixture)
Fuel
Thickness
(cm)
Fuel volume
(ml)
Boilover
time (min)
Distance of
ejected fuel
(cm)
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
Petrol:
377
Diesel:
161
14.03
Petrol:
470
Diesel:
202
15.18
Petrol:
564
Diesel:
242
15.33
Petrol:
659
Diesel:
282
17.07
82
113
115
129
Fuel
volume
(ml)
Boilover
time (min)
Distance of
ejected fuel
(cm)
Graph of time for the first boilover vs. initial fuel thickness
20.00
15.00
f(x)
= 1.85x + 10.3
R10.00
= 0.91
5.00
538
672
806
941
1075
1210
20.23
26.03
32.05
33.22
37.05
43.16
35
45
38
65
42
55
0.00
1.00 3.00 5.00
60.00
Figure 2: Graph of time to boilover against thickness of mixture of
petrol and diesel
40.00
f(x) = 8.51x + 4.31
R = 0.97
Time to the first boilover (min) 20.00
0.00
150.00
Initial Fuel Layer Thickness (cm)
f(x)
= 28.6x + 31.1
100.00
R = 0.87
Distance of ejected fuel (cm) 50.00
0.00
1.00
3.00
5.00
Biodiesel
The summary of the boilover experimental runs using
biodiesel is displayed as in the table and figures below.
Table 5: Summary of fuel thickness variation on biodiesel boilover
Fuel
Thickness
(cm)
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
80.00
60.00
f(x)40.00
= 6.74x + 24.75
Distance of ejected fuel (cm)R 20.00
= 0.31
0.00
RECOMMENDATIONS
4.0
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
[6]
[7]
CONCLUSION
REFERENCES
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]