Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Summary
In this introduction the authors develop a 2x2 matrix scheme to help classify and understand
existing sociological theories based on four major paradigms.
The authors coalesce these debates into two fundamental issues that form the axes of the 2x2
matrix:
Realism assumes that the real world has hard, intangible structures that exist irrespective of our
labels. The social world exists separate from the individuals perception of it. The social world
exists as strongly as the physical world.
There have been two major intellectual traditions. The first is "sociological positivism", that
applies models and methods from the natural sciences to social affairs. The second is "German
idealism", which sees reality in the "spirit" or "idea", rejects the scientific methodology to
understanding behavior.
Order-Conflict Debate
This old debate is around approaches that characterize the stabilizing effects of social order,
versus those approaches focused more on change. Now most people see both as embedded in
each other.
Traditionally, the prominent sociologists of Durkheim, Weber, and Pareto were concerned with
social order, while Marx was concerned with social change.
Dahrendorf sees the order-conflict debate centered around two camps, one emphasizing stability,
integration, functional co-ordination, and consensus, and the other emphasizing change, conflict,
disintegration, and coercion. In reality this dichotomy is more a continium.
Each of these opposite word-pairs is open to much interpretation, and each is not completely
accurate in describing the debate and can cause misinterpretation.
The authors put forth another way of descibing this debate as "regulation" vs "radical change".
Regulation theories explore socities unity and cohesiveness. Radical change theories emphasize
structural conflict, domination, and structural contradiction. It often focuses on the deprivation of
man and potential changes.
It seeks to explain the stability of behavior from the individual's viewpoint. They are most
interested in understanding the subjectively created world "as it is" in terms of ongoing
processes. It emphasizes the spiritual nature of the world. Philosophers like Kant formed it's
basis, and Weber, Husserl, and Schutz furthered the ideology. This paradigm has'nt generated
much organizational theory.