Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Product-Oriented and
Non-Product-Oriented
Activities
Carol S. Thibodeaux,
Feral Menks Ludwig
Key Words: activity analysis. exertion.
motivation
This study investigated the hypothesis that purposeful activity is an intrinsic motivator. We hypothesized that subjects would take longer to perceive
themselves to be working hard and would have a
higher heart rate increase when working on a product-oriented activity than when working on a nonproduct-oriented activity. Fzfteen subjects sanded a
cutting board that they could keep and a piece of
wood that they could not keep until they reached a
rating of 15 (hard) on the Borg Rating Scale of Perceived Exertion. No significant differences were
found in the subjects' heart rate increase or in the
time it took subjects to perceive themselves as working hard. Subjects reported significantly more enjoyment in sanding the cutting board than in sanding
the wood, and significance increased further upon
completion of the sanding board Ex post facto,
when subjects were categorized into three groups
depending upon the degree of likingfor each activity, it appeared that the degree of liking may be important in predicting exercise effort. Implications
for practice and further research are discussed
169
Intrinsic motivation. After determining which activities are appropriate for a patient's physical, sensorimotor, psychosocial, and cognitive needs, occupational therapists select activities on the basis of interest to the patient, that is, on the basis of what would
intrinsically motivate the patient. This is done on the
"implicit assumption that the patient would experience satisfaction in the activity itself and this satisfaction would be sufficient to sustain performance"
(Florey, 1969, p. 320).
Proponents of intrinsic motivation models state
that there is a dynamic force, other than external need
reduction drives, underlying behavior. This force
builds toward self-reward in the competent performance of perceptual-motor and cognitive skills
(Florey, 1969). Several psychologists have examined
the concept of intrinsic motivation in relation to competence and environment throughout the life cycle.
White (1971) defined competence as haVing skills
"sufficient or adequate to meet the demands of a situation or task" (p 273). White (1959) believed that
children have the need to achieve a sense of competence. This need is an intrinsic, moderate but persistent, motivator.
To facilitate intrinsic motivation, the environment should be free of stressors, and the external
motivators should be reduced. The environment
should allow for novelty with the chance for exploration, repetition, and imitation. Tasks should be within
the individual's cognitive abilities, be moderately difficult, and have significance in the adult world
(Florey, 1969).
Purposeful activities. Fidler (1981) stated that a
historical tenet of occupational therapy is that purposeful activity proVides incentive and opportunity
for individuals to achieve mastery and to add to their
sense of competence. Both Cynkin (1974) and Fidler
170
Downloaded From: http://ajot.aota.org/ on 10/24/2015 Terms of Use: http://AOTA.org/terms
Table 1
Borg Rating Scale of Perceived Exertion
6
7 very, very lighr
8
9 very light
10
11 fairly light
12
13 somewhat hard
14
15 hard
16
17 very hard
18
19 very, very hard
20
, Level to which subjects were asked
to
exert themselves
171
Results
Neither hypothesis was supported by the data (see
Table 4). The amount of time reqUired to work hard
Table 2
Questionnaire Given to Subjects Who
Had Sanded Cutting Board
J. How much did you like sanding this cutting board, knowing
Disliked a lot
Disliked a little
Neutral
Liked a little
Liked a lot
Points
1
2
3
4
2. How much did you like making this cutting board, now that it is
finished? (Select one)
Points
(a) Disliked a lot
1
2
(b) Disliked a little
(c) Neutral
3
4
(d) Liked a little
(e) Liked a lot
5
3. What do you plan
to
Table 3
Questionnaire Given to Subjects Who
Had Sanded Piece of Wood
1. How much did you like sanding thiS piece of wood' (Select one)
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
Disliked a lot
Disliked a little
Neutral
Liked a little
Liked a 1m
Points
1
2
3
4
Discussion
The small sample size (N= 15) may have resulted in a
Type II error in the first hypothesis regarding differences in performance time between the two actiVities.
The fact that a large standard deviation occurred raises
the possibility that a larger number of subjects would
have provided the power to determine a significant
difference.
The large negative t value (-1.9; P = .95) for
Hypothesis 2 is noteworthy in that a onetailed t test
for correlated data was used If the hypothesis had
been in the opposite direction, it would have been
supported. Thus, a difference between the two sanding activities would be found in the direction of a
higher increase in heart rate for the non-product-oriented group. This would be in opposition to Kircher's
(1984) hypothesis. There might be a need to expand
the definition of purposeful activity to include nonproduct-oriented activities such as exercise as Trombly (1982) suggested. Although exercise may not be
product oriented, it may still be considered a purposeful activity. Society's value system was cited as
172
Downloaded From: http://ajot.aota.org/ on 10/24/2015 Terms of Use: http://AOTA.org/terms
Table 4
Differences in Performance Time and Increases in Heart
Rate for Cutting Board and Wood
Variable
Mean
Performance lime
Cuuing board
Wood
Difference
172.30 sec
14860 sec
2370
13.07 beats/min
1733 beats/min
-4.26 beats/min
SD
pValue
9351
10647
102
.20
8.62
11.78
-19
95
started sanding and then again when the subject reported that she was working hard. Sophisticated
equipment could have provided a more accurate heart
rate record for this study.
Subjects reported that they enjoyed sanding the
cutting board significantly more (alpha = .01) than
they enjoyed sanding the wood. This difference became more pronounced after subjects completed the
cutting board (alpha = .001). Rocker and Nelson
(987) found that subjects became significantly more
hostile and energetic when they were not permitted
to keep a product they had made
Ex post facto, when the responses to the questionnaires were paired with the increase in heart rate
and performance time scores for each subject, we
found that the subjects could be divided into three
groups of five each. One group reported liking the
process of sanding and/or making the cutting board
two or more points more than they liked sanding the
wood. This was termed the Big Difference Group because these subjects reported a big difference between how much they liked the two activities. Using a
one-tailed t test for correlated measures, we found
that all of these subjects worked a significantly greater
time on sanding the cutting board than on sanding the
wood (alpha = .025). Three of the subjects had a
higher increase in heart rate for sanding the cutting
board than for sanding the wood.
The subjects in the second group, termed the
Little Difference Group, reported that they liked the
process of sanding and/or making the cutting board
one point more than they liked sanding the wood. Of
these five, four sanded the cutting board longer than
the wood, but four had an increase in heart rate while
sanding the cutting board that was smaller than, or
equal to, the increase in heart rate they experienced
while sanding the wood.
The last group, the No Difference Group, reported that they liked sanding the cutting board as
much as, or less than, sanding the wood. Four of the
five sanded the wood longer than the cutting board;
and four of the five had an increase in heart rate while
sanding the cutting board that was equal to, or smaller
Table 5
Comparison of Subject's Degree of Liking for Sanding
Cutting Board and for Sanding Wood
Liking
Nlean
SD
44
34
10
.74
106
After finishing
Cutting board
Wood
Difference
48
34
1.4
41
106
p Value
3.09
.0 I
458
.001
173
Limitations
This study investigated only two activities; therefore,
findings cannot be generalized to infer that similar
results will be found when other activities are compared. Likewise, the use of a small sample of female
occupational therapy students who reported themselves to be healthy physically and psychologically
limits generalizability to other populations. The validity and the reliability of the questions we devised for
this study are unknown. Thus, the study's results are
tentative.
Recommendations
This study reiterates the need to individualize treatment for each patient. Tools to do this are activity
analyses that include a checklist of the patient's interests and occupational history. Other tools such as the
therapeutic interview can be used to determine the
personality of a patient, the characteristics of the environment the patient lives in, and the patient's social
involvements. The patient's enjoyment of or liking for
an activity needs to be considered and how it may
affect his or her level of involvement, both physical
and mental, in the activity.
Further research with larger samples and more
activities is needed to explore the variables affecting
motivation in tasks. The concept of purposeful activity
needs to be examined, especially in relation to exercise. Subjects might be grouped and compared according to their degree of liking or enjoyment of the
activity Purpose and enjoyment as independent variables need further research and clarification.
Acknowledgments
We extend our appreciation to Harriett DaVidson, MA, OTR,
and Gale Haradon, MA, OTR, for their assistance and advice
and to the students for participating in the study.
This article was based on research conducted by the
first author at Texas Woman's University, Houston Center,
in partial fulfillment of the reqUirements for a Master of
Occupational Therapy degree.
References
Borg, G. A. (1977). Perceived exertion: A note on history and methods. Medical Science Sports, 5, 90-93.
Breines, E. (1984). An attempt to define purposeful
activity. American journal of Occupational Therapy, 38,
543-544
Cynkin, S. (1974). Occupational therapy: Toward
health through activities. Boston: Little, Brown.
English, C, Kasch, M., Silverman, P., & Walker, S.
(1982) The Issue Is: On the role of occupational therapists
in physical disabilities. American journal of Occupational
Therapy, 36, 199-20l.
Fidler, G. S. (1978). Doing and becoming: Purposeful
action and self-actualization. American journal of Occupational Therapy, 32, 305-310.
Fidler, G. S. (1981). From crafts to competence. American journal of Occupational Therapy, 35, 567-573.
Florey, L. L. (1969). Intrinsic motivation: The dynamics of occupational therapy theory. Americanjournal of
Occupational Therapy, 23, 319-322.
Gamberale, F. (1972). Perceived exertion, heart rate,
oxygen uptake, and blood lactate in different work operations. Ergonomics, 15, 545-554.
Henry, A. D., Nelson, D. L., & Duncombe, L. W. (1984).
Choice making in group and individual actiVity. American
journal of Occupational Therapy, 38, 245-25l.
Hopkins, H. L., & Smith, H. D. (Eds.). (1983) Willard
and Spackman's occupational therapy (6th ed.). Philadelphia: Lippincott.
Huss, A. ]. (1981). From kinesiology to adaptation.
Americanjournal of Occupational Therapy, 35, 574-580.
Kasch, M. C (1985). Motivation and activity [Letter to
the editor]. Americanjournal ofOccupational Therapy, 39,
114-115
King, L. J. (1978). Toward a science of adaptive responses. American journal of Occupational Therapy, 32,
429-437.
Kinsman, R. A., & Weiser, P. C. (1976). Subjective
symptomatology during work and fatigue. In E. Simonson &
P. Weiser (Eds.) Psychological aspects and physiological
correlates of work and fatigue. Springfield, IL: Charles C
Thomas.
Kircher, M. A. (1984). Motivation as a factor of perceived exertion in purposeful versus non purposeful activity.
Americanjournal of Occupational Therapy, 38, 165-170.
Kremer, E. R., Nelson, D. L., & Duncombe, L. W.
(1984). Effects of selected activities on affective meanings
174
Downloaded From: http://ajot.aota.org/ on 10/24/2015 Terms of Use: http://AOTA.org/terms
0/ Occupational
Therapy, 38, 522-528.
Mosey, A. C (1980). A model for occupational therapy.
Occupational Therapy in Mental Health, 1, 11-31
Nelson, D., Thompson, G., & Moore,]. (1982) Identi-
fication of factors of affective meaning in four selected activities. American journal 0/ Occupational Therapy, 36,
381-387
Rocker, ]. D., & Nelson, D. L. (1987). Affective responses to keeping and not keeping an activity product.
175