Sie sind auf Seite 1von 2

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING ENCH 444

PROCESS ENGINEERING ECONOMICS AND DESIGN I


UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND BALTIMORE COUNTY
Individual Grade Sheet and Team Contribution #1 Due: Monday, October 19, 2015

Individually you are to provide a grade sheet for the Design I report that you and your
team received to review and grade (and provide the second phase of the design which include
detailed design calculations, specifications and equipment costing). The grade sheet should be
consistent with the one-page critique that your team provided with your Design II report. Please
remember that the critique should be concise, specific (i.e. do not say the material balance was
incorrect provide the specific information as to what was incorrect in the material balance),
constructive, accurate, helpful and professional. Please think about how you would feel if you
were the team who was receiving the critique and remember that the goal is to move the design
forward to completion. The grade sheet should provide scores in each of the following
categories and should sum to a score out of 100 points.
Table 1: Grading Rubric for Draft Report and Final Report
Points / Possible Points
Technical Content (60%)
Topic mastery, including technical correctness
All requested deliverables included
Appropriate level of detail and thoroughness of
documentation
Completeness of analysis and interpretation of data

/ 20
/ 15
/ 15
/ 10

Organization (15%)
Clearly identified purpose and approach
Content is clearly organized and supports the objective
Transitions between topics

/ 15

Presentation (15%)
Easy to read
Grammatically and stylistically correct
Uniform writing style

/ 15

Layout/Visuals (10%)
Consistent presentation of graphics
Uniform document design and layout

/ 10

TOTAL

/ 100

In addition, please provide specific information how your team worked together to
complete the first two design projects. Please estimate the number of team meetings that took
place as your team completed Design Project I and Design Project II and provide
attendance/contribution information for each member of your team. Also provide a table, for
each design project, which provides the various tasks for each project and who completed the
task for your team. These tasks might have been broken down into the following categories (but
are not limited to these categories) for Design Project I raw material/product pricing, process
synthesis, material balances, energy balances, wrote specific section(s) of the report,
proofreading, etc. Design Project II tasks might include (but are not limited to) corrections to
design project I (process synthesis, material balances, energy balances), equipment design
(reactor(s), heat exchanger(s), separator(s), etc.), equipment data sheets, equipment costs, wrote
specific section(s) of the report, proofreading, etc. Please provide as much detail as possible for
the distribution and completion of labor.
The submission of the individual grade sheet and team contribution should be in the form
of a memorandum addressed to the ENCH 444 Instructor.

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen