Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
11/3/15, 7:03 PM
World
About
Contact
Submit
Advertise
ArchDaily | Broadcasting
the world's
most visited
architecture website
Architecture
Worldwide
Projects
News
Articles
Materials
Interviews
Competitions
Events
Classics
More
Search ArchDaily
Log in | Sign up
Unified
Theory: Chapter 2B
BookmarkArchitectural
this picture!
20
OCT
2013
by Nikos Salingaros
News Articles
Unified Architectural Theory
Nikos Salingaros
Bookmark
37
Like
33
MORE
ARTICLES
Tweet
22
Some traditions are anachronistic and misguided, but as reservoirs of traditional solutions
against which to check new proposals they are of immense importance. A new solution may
at some point replace a traditional solution, but it must succeed in reestablishing the
connections to the rest of knowledge. In the context of social patterns, architecture, and
MOST
VISITED
Famous Landmarks
Reimagined with Paper
Cutouts
urbanism, new solutions are useful if they connect to traditional social, architectural, and
urban patterns (i.e., all those before the 1920s). If there is an obvious gap where nothing in
a discipline refers to anything outside, then there could be a serious problem.
Architecture News
Recently, Edward Wilson has introduced the notion of consilience as the interlocking of
causal explanations across disciplines (Wilson, 1998a). Consilience claims that all
explanations in nature are connected; there are no totally isolated phenomena. Wilson
focuses on incomplete pieces of knowledge: the wide region separating the sciences from
Selected Projects
Selected Projects
the incoherence of a dream, at once banal and fantastical. It is innocent of the science of
mind and language developed elsewhere in the civilized world, rather like the
pronouncements of a faith healer unaware of the location of the pancreas. (Wilson, 1998b:
p. 41).
Unfortunately, most of the humanities today subscribe to belief systems that damage the
http://www.archdaily.com/439498/unified-architectural-theory-chapter-2b
MOST VISITED
PRODUCTS
Page 1 of 6
11/3/15, 7:03 PM
Metal 2.0
Apavisa
Deconstruction goes through certain social and political structures, meeting with resistance
Porcelain Stoneware
web of consilient knowledge. Although never directly expressed, the goal of deconstruction
and displacing institutions as it does so effectively, you have to displace, I would say
solid structures, not only in the sense of material structures, but solid in the sense of
cultural, pedagogical, political, economic structures. (Norris, 1989: p. 8).
TerraClad Ceramic
Sunshade System
Boston Valley Terra Cotta
Many people crave novelty without regard for possible consequences. This craving is often
manipulated by unscrupulous individuals. Not everything that is novel is necessarily good.
Ceramics
An example of this is a new, artificially-developed virus unleashed into the world. Because
of the immense destructive power that humanity now possesses, it is imperative to
understand possible consequences.
Daily Newsletter
Fortnightly Materials Newsletter
YOUR EMAIL
SUBSCRIBE
Putting aside the question of truthful content, a discipline is not valid unless it rests on a
solid intellectual edifice. One characteristic of a coherent discipline is hierarchical
complexity, in which correlated ideas and results define a unique internal structure. Like a
valid bank note, this structure should be extremely difficult to counterfeit. That is not the
case with deconstruction. Thus, a phony article in Statistical Mechanics, using all the
appropriate words and mathematical symbols in a nice-sounding but scientificallymeaningless jumble, would be detected instantly.
Even a single mistake in such an article could not survive unnoticed. It is the function of
referees to check each and every step in the argument of a scientific article submitted for
publication in a professional journal. The very survival of the discipline depends on a system
of checks that identifies and expels bogus contributions. By contrast, the survival of
deconstruction in which there is nothing to verify depends upon generating more and
more deconstructed texts and buildings.
A well-crafted deconstructive text does make sense, but not in any logical fashion. It is a
piece of poetry that abuses the human capacity for pattern recognition to create
associations, employing random technical jargon.
As Roger Scruton has pointed out: Deconstruction should be understood on the model
of magic incantation. Incantations are not arguments, and avoid completed thoughts and
finished sentences. They depend on crucial terms, which derive their effect from repetition,
and from their appearance in long lists of cryptic syllables. Their purpose is not to describe
what is there, but to summon what is not there Incantations can do their work only if key
words and phrases acquire a mystical penumbra. (Scruton, 2000: pp. 141-142).
The use of words for emotional effect is a common technique of cult indoctrination. This
practice reinforces the cults message. Whether in chants that make little sense yet can
raise followers emotions to fever pitch, or in the speeches of political demagogues that
rouse a wild and passionate allegiance, the emotional manipulation is the message. Even
after the exposure of the deconstructive philosophers fraudulent character, their work
continues to be taken seriously. Deconstructionist books are available in any university
bookstore, while respectable academics offer lengthy critical commentary supporting these
books supposed authority. By affording them the trappings of scholarly inquiry, the
impression is carefully maintained that they constitute a valid body of work.
Page 2 of 6
11/3/15, 7:03 PM
References
Christopher Alexander (2001) The Phenomenon of Life: The Nature of Order, Book 1, The
Center for Environmental Structure, Berkeley, California.
John Huth (1998) Latours Relativity, in: A House Built on Sand, Edited by Noretta
Koertge, Oxford University Press, New York, pages 181-192.
Lon Krier (1998) Architecture: Choice or Fate, Andreas Papadakis, Windsor, England.
Retitled The Architecture of Community, with new material, Island Press, Washington, DC,
2009.
David Lehman (1991) Signs of the Times: Deconstruction and the Fall of Paul de Man,
Poseidon Press, New York.
Roger Scruton (2000) The Devils Work, Chapter 12 of: An Intelligent Persons Guide to
Modern Culture, St. Augustines Press, South Bend, Indiana.
Alan Sokal & Jean Bricmont (1998) Fashionable Nonsense, Picador, New York. European
title: Intellectual Impostures.
Edward O. Wilson (1998a) Integrating Science and the Coming Century of the
Environment, Science, 279, pages 2048-2049.
Edward O. Wilson (1998b) Consilience: The Unity of Knowledge, Alfred A. Knopf, New
York.
Cite:
Nikos Salingaros. "Unified Architectural Theory: Chapter 2B" 20 Oct 2013. ArchDaily. Accessed 3 Nov 2015.
<http://www.archdaily.com/439498/unified-architectural-theory-chapter-2b/>
http://www.archdaily.com/439498/unified-architectural-theory-chapter-2b
Page 3 of 6