EE586 Artificial Intelligence

Programming Take Home

Sleyman Fatih Kara
1741214
8. In this question, the Monte Carlo Simulation is implemented. The programm I
created makes 5 to 25 moves from the Goal state and by this way the new start
state is generated.
For Each new Start state that are created by Monte Carlo Simulation, there should
be created a solution method with 5 algorithms (BFS, DFS, IDFS, A*Manhatten,
A*Misplaced). Also to increase the accuracy of the simulation I should perform this
solutions 20 times.
After collecting data from the simulation, graphs are created at matlab.

BFS DFS
651
6
0
651
6
0
216
9
8
216
6
8
216
9
8
390
7,2 4,8

BFS DFS
100
8
0
100
15 0
644
21 9

1 step away from solution

Elapsed Time
Nodes Stored
A*
A*Mispla
ID A*
A*Mispla
IDS Manhattan ced
BFS DFS S Manhattan ced
4

219 1

217 1

71

84

81 1 1
134
4
5
5
1,2 ,4
1 1
2 step away from solution
Elapsed Time
Nodes Stored
A*
A*Mispla
ID A*
IDS Manhattan ced
BFS DFS S Manhattan

34

34

209 1

1,6

A*Mispla
ced

15
21
16

5
121
5
193
3,8

BFS DFS
326
30 2
326
27 2
127
31 3
326
33 2
361
30 8
30, 293
2
5,4

BFS DFS
39 838
131
47 7
131
81 7
195
41 1
150
43 2
50, 138
2
5

BFS DFS
166
39 8
165
47 8
165
81 8

40 1 2
63,
7
7,2
6,8
1,2 6
1 1,4
3 step away from solution
Elapsed Time
Nodes Stored
A*
A*Mispla
ID A*
IDS Manhattan ced
BFS DFS S Manhattan

10

114 2

19

10

116 2

10

44

19

10

10

109 2

13

10

10

1,4

A*Mispla
ced

123 2 1
101 1,
14 9,6
8,8
1,4 ,2
8 1,6
4 step away from solution
Elapsed Time
Nodes Stored
A*
A*Mispla
ID A*
IDS Manhattan ced
BFS DFS S Manhattan
29 16
11
1
28 8 1

17

11

11

43

31

11

11

44

24

11

78

11

17 11
23,
6
12

A*Mispla
ced
1

48 2 1
48, 3,
10,6
1,4 2
4 1
5 step away from solution
Elapsed Time
Nodes Stored
A*
A*Mispla
ID A*
IDS Manhattan ced
BFS DFS S Manhattan

19

17

14

59

16

20

13

57

23

16

13

56

1,4

A*Mispla
ced

41
43
50,
2

105
0
436
129
4

BFS DFS
105 160
293
145 0
145 996
127 176
138 984
104
132 9,2

BFS DFS
442
251 7
482
251 5
329
239 4
233
199 9
482
239 5
235 394
,8
2

BFS DFS
185
105 0
196
355 3
213
524 1
426
188 8
395 493

45 13
59 16
32,
4
16,4

37 7 2
15 5 1
44, 4,
13,2
2,4 8
8 1,4
6 step away from solution
Elapsed Time
Nodes Stored
A*
A*Mispla
ID A*
IDS Manhattan ced
BFS DFS S Manhattan
22 23
21
3
6
6 2

4
1

115
20
35
35
45,
4

118 9 2
33 10 2
6
10 2
34 6 2
39, 8,
19,8
16,2
5,8 4
2 2
7 step away from solution
Elapsed Time
Nodes Stored
A*
A*Mispla
ID A*
IDS Manhattan ced
BFS DFS S Manhattan

1
3
1
2

85

26

24

13

151 11 3

26

24

24

13

220 8

26

24

17

12

140 8

24

20

27

77

18
23
18
17

127 23
57,
6
23,4

13
13

14
24
15
7

3
2

6
6
4
10

29

1,8

A*Mispla
ced
2

1,8

A*Mispla
ced

12 162 12 2
11,
9,
24,2
6
150 6 2,2
8 step away from solution
Elapsed Time
Nodes Stored
A*
A*Mispla
ID A*
IDS Manhattan ced
BFS DFS S Manhattan

250 25

17

59

22 2

83

17

37

24

63

13 2

83

26

17

65

95

14 2

261 37
261 17

17
27

8
29

139 18 3
156 18 2

2
2

2,2

A*Mispla
ced

8
313 303
,4
0

BFS DFS
685 436
109
626 7
364
221 2
329
616 3
128
574 8
544 195
,4
1,2

BFS
124
6
140
0
984
984
124
4
117
1,6

DFS
131
7
100
86
198
2
100
86
101
68
672
7,8

187
,6
24,4

25, 102
23
8
,4
17 2,2
9 step away from solution
Elapsed Time
Nodes Stored
A*
A*Mispla
ID A*
IDS Manhattan ced
BFS DFS S Manhattan
260 34
38
83 15 48 3

A*Mispla
ced
4

215 29

34

67

37

16

49

34

11

118 3

81

29

36

67

112 10 2

271 16
168
,6
31,4

29 2

2,2

14

58 44 30 2
57, 65,
31,2
2
2
24 2,8
10 step away from solution
Elapsed Time
Nodes Stored
A*
A*Mispla
ID A*
IDS Manhattan ced
BFS DFS S Manhattan
10
767 35
46
259 45 1 3

931 29

52

328 322 71 2

589 56

56

163 65

50 7

247 65

59

165 319 41 7

769 35
660
,6
44

91

259 323 89 3
234 214 70
,8
,8
,4 4,4

12

60,8

{36, 28, 42, 34, 28, 41, 28, 28, 41, 30, 41, 28, 34, 28, 42, 28, 42, 41, 36}

A*Mispla
ced
4

6,4