Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
In collaboration with both the South African and Japanese Government, I will
continue working towards increased co-operation in science and technology
between the two countries.
Dr B Ngubane
Ambassador of South Africa
September 2004
Table of contents
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY........................................................................................... 5
1. Introduction ......................................................................................................... 7
5.1 Biotechnology................................................................................................ 18
8. Conclusion......................................................................................................... 29
The first Science Forum meeting between SA and Japan in May 2004
established priorities for co-operation in S&T between SA and Japan. Priority
research areas that were identified include: biotechnology; information and
communication technology; advanced and new materials; nanotechnology;
infectious diseases; and S&T policy studies. The first Joint Committee
meeting between the Government of SA and Government of Japan adopted
these research priority areas as a basis for future co-operation in S&T
between the two countries. In addition to the areas adopted above, the
possibility to include additional areas of co-operation, such as the S&T policy
studies and co-operation between funding agencies was considered.
In the joint Committee Meeting, it was agreed that a Working Group chaired at
the level of Director for Bilateral Co-operation will be established to implement
co-operation in the areas above. The Working Group will meet once a year
and the dates for meetings would be finalised through correspondence. Other
new areas of co-operation will include the 7th SA-Japan Partnership Forum
meeting that will take place in Japan on 30 September to 1 October 2004.
South African delegation consisting of government representatives will
participate in the Partnership Forum meeting. South Africa will also be
participating in the 2005 World Expo to be held in Aichi, Japan on 25 March to
25 September 2005. Several South African Government departments and
other relevant public and private institutions will exhibit in the Expo.
The S&T Policy Forum is proposed to be held as a side event during the Aichi
Wold Expo in Japan in April 2005 to create a platform where Japanese and
South African Government officials and researchers can openly exchange
views and experiences on key S&T issues. The two key outcomes of the
Policy Forum will include: Increased understanding by government officials
and researchers of the reorganization of the Government of Japan to
significantly strengthen its national S&T administrative system; and shared
lessons by both the South African and Japanese Government officials and
researchers on compilation of indicators for scientific research, technological
development and innovation activities to strengthen national innovation
systems.
After the release of former President Nelson Mandela from prison, Japan
opened an Embassy in Pretoria in 1992, but fully-fledged diplomatic relations
between South Africa and Japan started only after 1994. President Thabo
Mbeki paid a state visit to Japan at the invitation of the Government of Japan
in October 2001. During this visit, President Mbeki said:
The Japan-South Africa Partnership Forum meeting was held for the first time
in January 1999 on the occasion of a visit to South Africa by former Japanese
Prime Minister Ryutaro Hashimoto. Mr Hashimoto, who became a Senior
Foreign Policy Advisor to the late Prime Minister Keizo Obuchi after resigning
in July 1998, headed the Japanese delegation to the Partnership Forum. He
also and had talks with then Deputy President Thabo Mbeki, then Foreign
Minister Alfred Nzo and other South African leaders.
The 2nd South Africa-Japan Partnership Forum meeting was held later in April
1999 when Vice Minister for Foreign Affairs Keizo Takemi held discussions
with Deputy Minister Aziz Pahad in South Africa.
The 3rd Japan-South Africa Partnership Forum meeting was held in March
2000 during a visit of Minister Nkosazana Dlamini Zuma in Japan. Co-
operation in science and technology between South Africa and Japan was
discussed amongst other matters.
In July 2001, Minister Essop Pahad chaired the 4th South Africa-Japan
Partnership Forum meeting, which was attended by Mr Seiken Sugiura, then
Senior Vice-Minister of Foreign Affairs. In this Forum, the Department of Arts,
Culture, Science and Technology (now DST) made an input, once again, on
the desirability of concluding a Science and Technology Agreement between
South Africa and Japan. The Japanese Government, once again, suggested
that it was important to first seek to achieve exchange between South Africa
and Japan in science and technology.
The two project proposals in the field of IT were submitted by the Department
of Arts, Culture, Science and Technology (now DST) to the Embassy of Japan
and the Japan International Co-operation Agency (JICA) for consideration.
One proposal was on “ICT Research and Training Capacity in South African
Institutions of Higher education” with a total budget of about R12.5 million
over 5 years. The second proposal was on “Assistance with Training of IT
Staff at Higher Education Institutions in South Africa” with a total budget of
about R9.9 million.
The Deputy Minister Aziz Pahad led the South African delegation to the 5th
Japan-South Africa Partnership Forum meeting in Japan in May 2002. The
South African delegation included four officials of the Department of Arts,
Culture, Science and Technology (DACST) including Mr Themba Wakashe,
Deputy Director-General; Dr Botlhale Tema, Chief Director International Co-
operation; Mr Simon Mpele, former Deputy Director Bilateral Co-operation;
and Mr Vuyani Lingela, former Assistant Director Technology Development.
The 6th South Africa-Japan Partnership Forum meeting was held in South
Africa on 28-29 August 2003. Participating institutions in the Partnership
Forum included the Departments of Trade and Industry; Arts and Culture,
Science and Technology; National Treasury; Environmental Affairs and
Tourism; Education; Agriculture; Health; and the South African Police Service.
The Department of Arts and Culture, Science and Technology (now the DST)
has undertaken a number of high-level visits to Japan, including the visits in
March 2000 by Mrs Bridgette Mabandla then Deputy Minister and by then
Minister Dr Ben Ngubane in October 2000, to discuss co-operation in the field
of science and technology. During Minister Ngubane’s visit, the two countries
agreed to intensify co-operation in areas of mutual interest, especially in
Information Technology, Biotechnology and New Materials.
Platinum group metals (PGM) are becoming key elements as alloy additions
or even as base metals because of their high melting points, high
oxidation/corrosion resistance, etc. Hence the effective use of PGMs for
developing high temperature alloys is the main aspect of the collaboration.
Continuing activities at the NIMS include the development of new materials for
Period Activity
st
02/05/2004 During the 1 South Africa-Japan Science Forum in May 2004, NIMS
concluded two Memoranda of Understanding with MINTEK and CSIR to
expand collaboration in the field of new and advanced materials.
12/2000 Dr H. Harada and Mr S Sato visited South Africa for a few days to
consolidate existing collaborations in both formal and practical aspects.
06-12/2000 Ms Patricia Hill of MINTEK visited NRIM to conduct microstructural
investigation of Platinum-based alloys. Several academic papers based
on this research were published in a scientific journal.
11/1999 South African delegation visited NRIM to follow up on the memorandum
on “Collaboration in Materials Research and Development”. The
delegation included Dr C. Scheffer (DST), Dr M. Corties (MINTEK), Prof
P. Ngoepe (University of the North), Mr J. Benson (CSIR), and Dr L.
Cornish (University of the Witwatersrand) who were received by Dr H.
Harada.
06/1999 NRIM launched the “High Temperature Materials 21” Project (FY. 1999-
2004). The Project plan involves Mattek (CSIR) and MINTEK
03/1999 Visit by NRIM delegation led by Dr H. Harada to the Department of Arts,
Culture, Science and Technology (now DST), Mattek, and MINTEK.
Mattek, MINTEK and NRIM signed a memorandum on “Collaboration in
Materials Research and Development” including four potential areas for
collaboration; Nickel-based superalloys, PGM-based alloys, Computer
simulation, and Ceramics.
10/1997 Visit of the South African Technology Foresight Programme members to
NRIM. Members included Mr John Stanko and Mr Bongani Mamela,
with specific responsibility for the Mining, Mineral and Metal processing
sector.
09/1997 Visit by the Dr Ngubane: Minister of Arts and Culture, Science and
Technology (now DST) to NRIM: Nickel-based superalloys with platinum
group metals (PGMs) additions, PGMs-base refractory superalloys, and
others.
09/1997 Evaluation test of Nickel-base superalloys developed at NRIM was
made by Mattek: collaboration bridged by the Dr Brendan Barker of the
British Council Tokyo, Japan.
The SANBI started collaborating with RIKEN in the field of life science on
Functional Annotation of Mouse Project.
RIKEN is engaged in basic research, which will form the foundation of nano-
science technology for future generations. This includes the measurement
and control of nano-level properties and functions, simple quantum
manipulation toward the development of new information processing devices,
and space-time function materials for manufacturing auto-changing, auto-
reacting materials, and materials that can change over time.
The Council for Geoscience is collaborating with the NIPR in the field of
Geology on polar research and on semi-controlled earthquake-generation
experiments in deep gold mines.
In October 2001, President Thabo Mbeki paid a state visit to Japan at the
invitation of the Government of Japan. He was accompanied by his wife, Mrs
Zanele Mbeki, and six Ministers including Dr Nkosazana Dlamini Zuma,
Minister of Foreign Affairs; Dr B Ngubane, Minister of Arts, Culture, Science
and Technology; Mr A Erwin, Minister of Trade and Industry; Mr V Moosa,
Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism; Ms AT Didiza, Minister of
Agriculture and Land Affairs; and Dr ME Tshabalala-Msimang, Minister of
Health.
During the course of the visit they had an audience with Their Majesties the
Emperor and Empress of Japan at the Imperial Palace on October 1.
President Mbeki met Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi, and a wide range of
views on bilateral relations, African regional issues, and multilateral issues
were exchanged. Japan expressed its willingness to facilitate co-operation for
IT dissemination throughout Africa. Japan also emphasised its active
implementation of a US$ 3 billion programme over five years under the
"Okinawa Infectious Diseases Initiative", also for African countries, which are
most seriously affected by infectious diseases. At the same time, Japan
repeated its intention to contribute US$200 million to the Global HIV/AIDS and
Health Fund, which is highly appreciated by the international community.
South Africa welcomed the policy visits by Japanese IT and Infectious
Diseases task teams to various African countries in this regard earlier in the
year.
During the 6th Partnership Forum, it was agreed between the Japanese and
South African Government that South Africa host the first South Africa-Japan
Science Forum in May 2004. At the invitation of the Ministry of Education,
Culture, Sports, science and Technology (MEXT), the Department of Science
and Technology (DST) delegation including Ms Anati Canca, General
Manager Human Capital and Science Missions; Mr Moeketsi Modisenyane,
Deputy Director Bilateral Co-operation; and Mr M Chetty, Programme
Manager NEPAD-ICT, CSIR visited Japan on 19-23 January 2004. The
delegation discussed areas of science and technology co-operation; a
framework of co-operation; preparation for the South Africa-Japan Science
The Science Forum was held in South Africa on 10-14 May 2004. The aim of
the Science Forum was to identify and stimulate specific areas of science and
technology collaboration by involving relevant research institutions in both
countries. It consisted of site visits to public research institutions; the
workshop between researchers, private organizations and government
organizations at the CSIR International Convention Centre; and the Joint
Committee Meeting between the two Governments. The framework for
research co-operation in biotechnology, information and communication
technologies, infectious diseases, new and advanced material and
nanotechnology was discussed by separate interest groups at the workshop.
5.1 Biotechnology
The relevance of food security for both South Africa and Japan
The opportunity for South Africa to learn from the extensive Japanese
experience on the public understanding of biotechnology arising from
the attitude of Japanese public towards genetically modified organisms.
The importance of wood (a major South African export item) and fibre
biotechnology and the importance of pulp and paper industry for Japan.
Research on indigenous crops (e.g. millet and sorghum) for the benefit
of the poorer African Union countries.
It was agreed that the above research themes do not prevent groups talking
to each other about other possible areas of collaboration in the future. Both
Japanese and South African organisations must be prepared to invest time
and effort into learning more about science policies and issues of strategic
importance between both countries.
It was suggested that Japan and SA should develop templates from their
universities and research organisations summarising their capacity and
expertise. It was agreed that short-term exchange visits by scientists from
both countries is an excellent way of learning about one another’s capacity
while working together to develop complete project proposals to be submitted
at a bi-lateral or international level for research funding.
The South African institutions that expressed interest in the areas identified
above include;
The group on new and advanced materials identified the following areas for
collaboration and the nodal points to facilitate joint collaboration:
Nickel-base superalloys and coatings. The nodal points are Mr. R Bean
(CSIR, South Africa) and Dr Harada (NIMS, Japan).
Refractory alloys. The nodal points are MINTEK (South Africa) and
NIMS (Japan).
Exchange of researchers.
5.5 Nanotechnology
The Japanese group that attended the session is not directly involved in
nanotechnology and for that reason the South African group proposed areas
that should be of mutual benefit. Areas of mutual benefit were based on
general focus and the Japanese nanotechnology research strategy articulated
in the Basic Plan. The following areas were identified for co-operation:
Precious Group Metals and gold. The nodal points are Dr D Compton
(MINTEK) and Dr Harada (NIMS).
The group on new and advanced materials, together with the nanotechnology
group considered human capital development. Their discussions focused on
the following areas:
Post doctoral exchange programs are required, but a support base will
be needed upon return. Industry contribution is critical to create to take
new researchers.
The total numbers of the South African (SA) and Japanese exchange
students under the Japanese Government Scholarship, as well as the South
African scientists in Japan under the Japan Society for the Promotion of
Science (JSPS) Program are detailed in Table 1 below. The data suggests
low numbers of exchange students between South Africa and Japan; even
then the number of Japanese students studying in South Africa is much lower
compared to South African students studying in Japan.
The number of South African JSPS Postdoctoral Fellows in Japan is also very
low compared to the number the Egyptian JSPS Postdoctoral Fellows. A
special funding mechanism proposed in the 1st South Africa-Japan Science
Forum meeting is necessary to stimulate joint research collaboration and
exchange of students and scientists between South Africa and Japan.
The chairpersons of the interest groups of the 1st Science Forum workshop
presented summary reports on the four areas of co-operation, which included
biotechnology, ICT, infectious diseases, new and advanced materials and
nanotechnology. The delegates discussed and deliberated issues such as key
areas of co-operation, identifying participating institutions, time-frames and
next steps such as exchange visits. The significance of future co-operation,
particularly in the application of the rice genome information, resources, and
alternative methods for research on “Africa’s crops” and “Infectious Diseases”
was emphasized. In is considered that the Memorandum of Understanding
concluded between NIMS, CSIR and MINTEK will help accelerate progress in
co-operation between these institutions.
It was agreed that the draft minutes of the Joint Committee meeting be
submitted for consideration by the Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs. The
final dates for the 7th Japan-South-Africa Partnership Forum in Japan will be
announced by both the Japanese and South African Governments.
The 7th South Africa-Japan Partnership Forum will take place in Tokyo, Japan
on 30 September to 1 October 2004. Mr Aziz Pahad, Deputy Minister of
Foreign Affairs, will lead the South African delegation. The aim of the
Partnership Forum is to strengthen the bilateral co-operation in the areas such
as international affairs, trade and investment, economic co-operation, science
and technology, and cultural exchanges. The S&T Representative will provide
assistance at the request of the South African Government departments and
the relevant public institutions to facilitate their participation in the Partnership
Forum.
Following the Cabinet approval, South Africa will be participating in the 2005
World Expo to be held in Aichi, Japan on 25 March to 25 September 2005.
The S&T Representative will provide assistance at the request of the South
African Government departments and the relevant public and private
institutions to facilitate their participation in the 2005 World Expo.
Stage 1
The Bilateral Co-operation Unit (Unit) in South Africa and the South African
Science and Technology Representative (S&T Representative) to Japan will
meet and interview researchers, research managers and policy makers in
both countries to assess the research situation and needs, as well as plans to
implement research strategies.
Following meetings with researchers in the Unit and the S&T Representative
identify researchers in both countries and request abstracts of their research
proposals. The relevant opportunities will be reported or communicated timely
to appropriate South African and Japanese institutions. Research proposals
from researchers (bottom-up approach) will also be accepted for submission
to appropriate researchers in both countries.
Stage 3
In addition to the above, both the Unit and the S&T Representative will consult
government, independent institutions (science councils and independent
administrative institutions) to identify opportunities for research funding. The
Unit and the S&T Representative will provide sufficient information on
opportunities for competitive research funding, where South African and
Japanese researchers can jointly apply for open competitive funding, based
on their novel research concept and a combination of their expertise.
Stage 4
Stage 5
“Now that NEPAD is in place, Japan's basic policy on co-operation for Africa will be
to support NEPAD through the TICAD process, and to expand partnership for that
purpose.”
The NEPAD Ministerial Conference in 2003 stressed that it is a priority for all
African countries to have comprehensive national science, technology and
innovation policies with emphasis on the development of effective National
Systems of Innovation. The Conference also recommended that all
programmes of NEPAD should ensure that S&T are integral inputs in their
conceptualisation and implementation in order to accelerate progress along
the pathways for the realisation of Africa’s goals: job and wealth creation,
poverty reduction and environmental sustainability.
The physical distance, economic and cultural differences between Japan and
South Africa are some of the obvious disparities between the two countries. In
the words of Mr Yasukuni Enoki, former Ambassador of Japan to South Africa
on 21 September 2001:
“…Japan and South Africa both stand with one foot in each two worlds. For Japan,
one foot is in Asia, while the other is in the Western World or the Global World. For
South Africa, one foot is in Africa, while the other is in the Western/Global World.”
The common interest in S&T policy between South Africa and Japan unlocks
opportunities for joint collaboration between researchers in higher education
institutions, as well as other public and private R&D institutions. On the other
hand, the differences characterised by the economic dominance of Japan
combined with the wealth of human capital with high-quality training in maths
and science unlocks opportunities to support South Africa’s S&T as well as
African systems of innovation in general.
Mr Vuyani Lingela
Science and Technology Representative