GRADING RUBRIC

SEF 2015: Week 3 - Task 4 - Swimlanes and Sequen

Assessment
SNo.
1.

Criteria
Swimlane Actors and System
Components

Poor (<80%)
It is difficult to identify the
actors and/or system
components; they do not relate
meaningfully to the same
concepts in the full-dressed use
cases.
Points: <8

2.

Swimlane Actions

Actions within the swimlanes do

not properly relate to the
swimlane title.
Points: <8

3.

Swimlane Logic and Flow

The Swimlane Logic and Flow is

chaotic and does not align with
the fully-dressed use cases.
Points: <8

4.

Swimlane Technical Details

The Swimlane Diagrams do not

properly use a number of the
drawing elements used in the
references.
Points: <8

5.

Sequence Diagram Objects

The Sequence Diagrams do not

appear to be modeling objects
or their responsibilities.
Points: <8

6.

Sequence Diagram Actions

The Sequence Diagram actions

do not appear to be modeling
object methods or the kind of
actions they perform.
Points: <8

7.

Sequence Diagram Logic and Flow

The Sequence Diagram Logic

and Flow is not consistent with
the requirements or the
provided examples and
references.
Points: <8

8.

Sequence Diagram Technical Details

The Sequence Diagrams do not

properly use a number of the
drawing elements or styles used
in the references.

Points: <8

wimlanes and Sequence Diagrams

Average (80-89%)
Most of the actors and system
components from the fully-dressed
use cases appear in the swimlane
diagram, but there is a major issue.

Good (90-99%)
All of the actors and system components from
the fully-dressed use cases appear in the
swimlane diagram, but there is a minor issue.

Points: 8

Points: 9

Most Swimlane Actions are

appropriate, but there is a major
issue or omission.

All swimlane Actions are good and

appropriate, but there is a minor issue or
omission.

Points: 8

Points: 9

The Swimlane Logic and Flow is

The Swimlane Logic and Flow is good and
adequate and mostly aligns with the aligns with the fully-dressed use cases, but
fully-dressed use cases, but there is a there is a minor issue or omission.
major issue or omission.
Points: 8

Points: 9

The Swimlane Diagrams properly use The Swimlane Diagrams properly use all of
most of the drawing elements used in the drawing elements used in the references,
the references, but there is a major
but there is a minor issue or omission.
issue or omission.
Points: 8

Points: 9

The Sequence Diagrams model most

of the key objects and their
responsibilities, but there is a major
issue or omission.

The Sequence Diagrams model all of the key

objects and their responsibilities, but there is
a minor issue or omission.

Points: 8

Points: 9

The Sequence Diagram actions

The Sequence Diagram actions model object
appear to model object methods and methods well, but there is a minor issue or
most of the common actions, but
omission.
there is a major issue or omission.
Points: 8
Points: 9
The Sequence Diagram Logic and
Flow is mostly consistent with the
requirements and the provided
examples and references, but there is
a major issue or omission.

The Sequence Diagram Logic and Flow is

consistent with all of the requirements and
the provided examples and references, but
there is a minor issue or omission.

Points: 8
Points: 9
The Sequence Diagrams properly
uses most of the drawing elements
and styles used in the references, but
there is a major issue or omission.

The Sequence Diagrams properly uses all of

the drawing elements and styles used in the
references, but there is a minor issue or
omission.

Points: 8
Points: 9

Excellent (100%)
All of the actors and system components
from the fully-dressed use cases appear
in the swimlane diagram with no issues.

Score

10
Points: 10

All Swimlane Actions are excellent and

appropriate with no issues or omissions.
10
Points: 10
The Swimlane Logic and Flow is excellent
and aligns smoothly with the fullydressed use cases with no issues or
omissions.

10

Points: 10
The Swimlane Diagrams properly use all
of the drawing elements used in the
references with no issues or omissions.
Points: 10

10

The Sequence Diagrams model all of the

key objects and their responsibilities
with no issues or omissions.
10
Points: 10
The Sequence Diagram actions model
object methods nicely with no issues or
omissions.
10

Points: 10
The Sequence Diagram Logic and Flow
compellingly aligns with all of the
requirements and the provided examples
and references with no issues or
omissions.

10

Points: 9
The Sequence Diagrams compellingly
uses all of the drawing elements and
styles used in the references with no
issues or omissions.
10
Points: 10

Score

100.0

Comments

Sno.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23

Learning Center

Roll Number

Name

Week 1

Week 2

Week 3

Week 4

Week 5

Week 6