Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
BioMed Central
Open Access
Research
doi:10.1186/1746-1448-5-3
Abstract
The cyst banks of 6 coastal hypersaline lakes of South-East Europe have been investigated. The
study concerned the bottom sediments of Khersonesskoe and Koyashskoe lakes in the Crimea
(Ukraine), Nart saltworks (Albania), Vecchia Salina at Torre Colimena (Apulia, Italy), Pantano
Grande and Pantano Roveto at Vendicari (Sicily, Italy). A total of 19 cyst types were recognised.
The cyst banks of lakes were found to be well separated in the representation derived from a
statistical multivariate data analysis. For all the lakes examined a comparison was possible between
the resting community in sediments (cyst bank) and the active one in the water. The cyst banks
contained more species than those recorded over a multi-year sampling effort in the water column.
The study of cyst hatching, performed on 5 cyst types under lab conditions, demonstrated that
cysts do not hatch under the same conditions. Furthermore, each cyst type shows a wide range of
preferential hatching conditions, which allow us to confirm the ecological generalism of salt lake
species.
Background
Hypersaline lakes have been stimulating the interest of
biologists for a long time, principally on account of their
simple biological composition [1]. Over the last decades,
the scientific literature on salt lakes has grown with the
appearance of a large number of papers, and new research
directions, e.g. ecology of hypersaline environments [2],
agriculture applied to saline lakes [3], and saline lake conservation and management [4]. Recently, research on
saline lake species assemblages has developed in scope
and intensity. A general rule on the composition of biological communities has been recognised with an inverse
correlation existing between species richness and salinity
[1], with a small number of trophic roles each represented
by just one species [5]. The species composition differs in
saline waters of different chemistry [6,7], being characterized by marine originated fauna with Artemia shrimps
Page 1 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
http://www.salinesystems.org/content/5/1/3
Results
A total of 19 cyst morphotypes were found (only 13 are
given in Figure 1) in the 6 hypersaline lakes studied. Seven
of them have been identified at the genus level, also due
to the successful hatching experiments carried out in laboratory conditions. On the average, the number of cyst
morphotypes extracted from the sediment cores was more
than double the number of the active organisms found in
the plankton over the study time [see Additional file 1].
The richest cyst bank was that of Vecchia Salina (17 morphotypes), and the poorest was that of lake Koyashskoe (5
morphotypes).
The most common cyst types were Turbellaria cocoons,
which were present in all the sediment samples. Regard-
Figure stages
Resting
sediment
1 of the(cysts)
studied
of hypersaline
plankton organisms
lakes collected in the
Resting stages (cysts) of plankton organisms collected in the sediment of the studied hypersaline
lakes. In some groups the outer sculpturing may help in
taxon identification: a) resting eggs of large branchiopods (a1
Phallocryptus spinosa; a2 Artemia parthenogenetica) (range 200
400 m); b) ephippium of anomopod cladocerans (Moina
salina) holding one resting egg (range 0,51 mm); c) types of
spherical resting eggs in calanoid copepods (range 80200
m); d) types of monogonont rotifers resting eggs (d2 Hexarthra fennica; d3 Brachionus sp.; d4 Ptygura sp.)(range 80200
m); (e) flask-shaped cyst in ciliates (Fabrea salina) (range 80
200 m); f) undetermined spherical resting eggs (range 80
200 m); g) type of spherical resting eggs in turbellarians
(range 80200 m).
http://www.salinesystems.org/content/5/1/3
The SIMPER procedure associated with MDS of all samples identified the main species responsible for the biotic
characterisation of each lake [see Additional file 2].
Artemia sp. eggs characterised the "cyst bank" of Nart saltworks (SIMPER, similarity percentage: 73%), A. urmiana
eggs characterised the Koyashskoe lake (SIMPER, similarity percentage: 69%), Copepoda Calanoida eggs (unidentified) and Hexarthra fennica eggs characterised the
Khersonesskoe lake (SIMPER, similarity percentage:
84%), while Turbellaria cocoons and Hexarthra fennica
eggs were the main responsible for the average similarity
of Vecchia Salina, Pantano Grande and Pantano Roveto in
Italy (SIMPER, similarity percentage: 72%, 70% and 75%,
respectively).
3=
at
KHE
dicari
pond
KOY
Figure
Vendicari
=
(Apulia,
=(Sicily,
Khersonesskoe
Koyashskoe
2 of(Sicily,
Italy);
Italy);
TCL
lake
Italy);
NRT
lake
(Crimean
=PRV
=sediment
(Crimean
Torre
Nart
); Pantano
PGR
Colimena
saltworks
Peninsula,
Peninsula,
= Pantano
Roveto
(Vlor,
Ukraine)
pool
Grande
Albania);
Salina)
at Venpool
Abundance
lakes
(number
cysts
of cysts/100
in
the
cm
layers
of(Vecchia
theUkraine);
investigated
Abundance of cysts in the sediment layers of the
investigated lakes (number of cysts/100 cm3); PGR =
Pantano Grande pool at Vendicari (Sicily, Italy); PRV
= Pantano Roveto pool at Vendicari (Sicily, Italy); TCL
= Torre Colimena (Vecchia Salina) pond (Apulia,
Italy); NRT = Nart saltworks (Vlor, Albania); KHE
= Khersonesskoe lake (Crimean Peninsula, Ukraine);
KOY = Koyashskoe lake (Crimean Peninsula,
Ukraine).
Figure
MDS
"seed
plot
banks"
3 showing
from the
differences
studied of
lakes
cyst composition among
MDS plot showing differences of cyst composition
among "seed banks" from the studied lakes. The absolute densities of each resting morphotypes were fourth root
transformed. VEN = Vendicari pools (Sicily, Italy); TCL =
Torre Colimena (Vecchia Salina) pond (Apulia, Italy); NRT =
Nart saltworks (Vlor, Albania); KHE = Khersonesskoe lake
(Crimean Peninsula, Ukraine); KOY = Koyashskoe lake
(Crimean Peninsula, Ukraine).
http://www.salinesystems.org/content/5/1/3
Figure
thenogenetica
Best hatching
laboratory
Hexarthra
4 fennica
controlled
eggs;
patterns
eggs;
e) Moina
conditions:
of
c) Brachionus
some
salina
resting
a)
ephippia
Fabrea
sp.
stages
eggs;salina
d)
submitted
Artemia
cysts; b)
parto
Best hatching patterns of some resting stages submitted to laboratory controlled conditions: a) Fabrea
salina cysts; b) Hexarthra fennica eggs; c) Brachionus
sp. eggs; d) Artemia parthenogenetica eggs; e) Moina
salina ephippia. The values reported on the x-axis correspond to the storage time (in days); the y-axis represents the
hatching percentages.
Page 4 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
http://www.salinesystems.org/content/5/1/3
Methods
Study site
The research interested, from April 2004 to September
2006, Khersonesskoe (4435'12"N; 3324'00"E) and
Koyashskoe (4502'31"N; 3612'20"E) lakes in the Crimea peninsula (Ukraine), Nart (4032'13"N;
1925'48"E) saltworks (Southern Albania), Vecchia
Salina (4018'06"N; 1743'56"E) at Torre Colimena
(Gulf of Taranto, Apulia, Italy), Pantano Grande and Pantano Roveto (3648'29"N; 1506'02"E) at Vendicari
Nature Reserve (Sicily, Italy) (Figure 5).
Figure
Geographical
ern
European
5
location
Region of the sampling sites in the South-EastGeographical location of the sampling sites in the
South-Eastern European Region. 1,2: Pantano Grande
and Pantano Roveto at Vendicari Nature Reserve (Italy); 3:
Vecchia Salina at Torre Colimena (Gulf of Taranto, Apulia,
Italy); 4: Nart saltworks (Albania); 5: Khersonesskoe lake (Crimea, Ucraine); 6: Koyashskoe lake (Crimea, Ucraine).
Cysts were reported as number per 100 cc of sediment.
The most abundant resting stages (2 types for the fraction
>212 m; 3 types for the fraction >45 m) were used in
hatch experiments in the laboratory. Sets of 30 cysts of
each morphotypes, taken from each layer (from the superficial to the deepest one), were stored in 3 cc wells raised
with 2 cc of original water filtered at 0,45 m. To avoid
bacterial growth, in each well, 20 l of an antibiotic mix
(streptomycin/penicillin 1:1) was added. Resting stages
were submitted to different storage conditions in thermostatic rooms (an "equinox" simulation, with 13C and 12
hL:12 hD photoperiod and a "early summer" simulation,
with 24C and 14 hL:10 hD photoperiod) at 4 different
salinity values (46, 36, 26, freshwater) obtained
by diluting the original-site water. Hatching plates were
checked daily to test the presence of active stages, which
were counted and removed for identification.
The related water column, on each lake, has been sampled
in different periods of the year (at least 2 seasons), and in
different years (between 2002 and 2006) to compare its
faunal composition to each other. Zooplankton samples
were collected monthly (three replicates), with two plankton nets (mouth diameter, 25 cm; length, 65 cm; mesh
size, 200 m and 50 m) towed horizontally, equipped
with a water-flow meter at the mouth. The Italian hypersaline lake Vecchia Salina and Crimean ones were already
studied in the past (see data in [10] and [16], respectively).
Data analysis
Data were analysed by multivariate statistical techniques
with a non-parametric approach because of the wide disparity in density of some cysts in different lakes. The sig-
Page 5 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
http://www.salinesystems.org/content/5/1/3
Additional file 2
Table S2. Cyst categories contributing most (80% cut off) to the biotic
characterisation of each lake (av.ab. = average abundance; av.sim. = average similarity; contrib.% = contribution percentage; cum.% = cumulative
percentage).
Click here for file
[http://www.biomedcentral.com/content/supplementary/17461448-5-3-S2.doc]
Abbreviations
Additional file 3
Table S3. Hypersaline lakes considered in the present study (listed in longitudinal order): salinity () and depth (m) values.
Click here for file
[http://www.biomedcentral.com/content/supplementary/17461448-5-3-S3.doc]
Acknowledgements
This research was supported and gathers ideas produced in the framework
of the "Investigation of energy flows coupling to carbon cycle in hypersaline
lake/lagoon ecosystems for environmental management and new biotechnology development" INTAS Project.
The authors express their gratitude to E. Shesterina and N. Shadrin (IBSS,
Ukrainian Academy of Sciences, UKR), and to M. Shehu and B. Shkurtaj
(University of Vlor, AL) for inestimable assistance provided during the field
work.
VEN: Vendicari ponds; PGR: Pantano Grande; PRV: Pantano Roveto; TCL: Torre Colimena (Vecchia Salina) saltworks; NRT: Nart saltworks; KHE: Khersonesskoe lake;
KOY: Koyashskoe lake; hL: hours of light; hD: hours of
dark; sim%: similarity percentage.
References
Competing interests
4.
5.
1.
2.
3.
6.
Authors' contributions
SM participated in the design of the study, executed cyst
collection in all the lakes, performed the statistical analysis and is responsible for the first draft of the manuscript.
GB conceived of the study, participated in its design and
coordinated all the steps, comprising the discussion of
results.
9.
Additional material
10.
Additional file 1
Table S1. Number of taxonomic groups representing the total biodiversity
(realised and potential) of the different lakes investigated.
Click here for file
[http://www.biomedcentral.com/content/supplementary/17461448-5-3-S1.doc]
7.
8.
11.
12.
13.
14.
Page 6 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
http://www.salinesystems.org/content/5/1/3
BioMedcentral
Page 7 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)