Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Statutory Construction
-
CONSTRUCTION
Of Written Law:
Discovering and
expounding the
meaning and intention
of the authors of the
law with respect to its
application to a given
case, where that
intention is rendered
doubtful either by
reason of apparently
conflicting provisions or
directions, or by reason
of the fact that the
given case is not
explicitly provided for in
the law.
INTERPRETATION
Of Written Law:
Discovering and
expounding the
intended signification of
the language used in
the law, that is the
meaning which the
authors designed to
convey to others
Drawing of conclusions
respecting subjects that
lie beyond the direct
expressions of the text,
from elements known
from and given in the
text; conclusions which
are in the spirit, though
not within the letter of
the text
Comparati
ve
Resorted to in
comparing two different
enactments of the
same legislative body,
there is found a
contradiction where
there was evidently no
intention of such
contradiction one of
another, or where it
happens that part of a
writing or declaration
contradicts the rest
ORDINARY KINDS OF
INTERPRETATION AND CONSTRUCTION
Strict
Liberal
Prospectiv
e
Retrospect
ive
Artificial,
Forced, or
Strained
Methods of Interpretation
1) Verba legis- very words of the law itself
2) Bacio legis- occasion of making the law
3) Mans Legislatoris- intention of the maker
Legal Hermeneutics
-
Purpose of construction
- To ascertain the meaning and intention of
the legislature so that the same may be
enforced since the legislative intent is the
vital part, the heart, the soul and the
essence of the law
-
Legislative Intent
-
RULES OF CONSTRUCTION
Scope of Application
- Where the language of the statute is plain,
clear, and definite, there is no need to
resort to the rules of statutory construction
-
CHAPTER II
SUBJECTS OF CONSTRUCTION
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Constitution
Statutes
Resolutions
Ordinances
Presidential Issuances
Constitution
Statute
Lays
down
general Has to set in detail its
principles
and
the purposes or the subject
foundation
of matter of which it
government
treats
Relatively PERMANENT TENTATIVE
character
***Note: Common parts of Constitution
Constitution of Liberty: series of prescriptions
setting forth the fundamental civil and political
rights of the citizens with correlative limitations
on the power of government as a means of
securing the full enjoyment of those rights;
Constitution of Govt: set of provisions setting
up the governmental framework
Constitution of Sovereignty: provision or set
of it prescribing the procedure for amending the
constitution
Kinds of Constitution
1. Written and Unwritten:
written if it is embodied in a single formal
document or set of documents which is a
product of a deliberate effort to lay down the
fundamental principles in accordance with which
the government shall be organized and
conducted.
Unwritten is one whose provisions have not
been reduced into writing and formally
embodied in a single document/s consisting
largely of a mass of customs, usages, and
judicial decisions together with a few legislative
enactments of a fundamental character.
consistent
&
statute
as
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
Introduction
Reading
Reference to Committee
Discussion and Amendment
Vocation and passage determined by
the rules of the legislative body
2) Approval and Disapproval
a. Tacit Approval
b. Express Approval
3D.
Form
1) Affirmative
Statute:
generally
cumulative; one where existing right or
remedy is continued and a new one is
created
2) Negative Statute
3) Compiled/Revised: collection of the
statutes existing and in force in a given
state, all laws and parts of laws relating
to each subject matter being brought
together under 1 head, and the whole
arranged systematically in one book
either
under
an
alphabetical
arrangement or some other plan of
classification
4) Codified: reenactment of the whole
body of a positive law
3E.Origin or Source
1) Adopted: taken wholly or in part from
another state and enacted as a law of the
state adopting it
2) Reenacted: one passed by the same
legislative body, in the same terms, or in
substantially the same language, and for
the same purpose and object, as the
former statute
Why?
1) To prevent hasty and improvident legislation
2) To compel the careful examination of
proposed laws
3) Afford the opportunity for that purpose
3G.
Language of Statute
3H.
Parts of Statute
1) # of the Act
2) Subject and Title: used as a guide to
ascertain the legislative will when the
2) Resolutions
- Enactments of the legislature employed
either to express sentiments or opinions, or
to carry out the internal affairs of the
legislative body, or to make temporary laws,
or to establish procedures for constitutional
amendments. Resolutions are generally less
formal and therefore are less authoritative
expressions of legislative purposes.
Kinds of Resolution
1) Simple Resolution
- Formalized motion passed by a majority of
single legislative chamber. It is usually used
to create special committees,
o to express recognition for meritorious
services,
o to extend sympathy on the death of a
member, and
o to express opinions to another
governmental body;
o establish rules governing internal
affairs
2) Concurrent Resolution
- Simple resolution but passed by both
chambers of the legislature. Same functions,
but it reflects the opinion of the entire
legislative body.
3) Ordinance
- An act passed by a municipal council, in the
exercise of its law-making authority;
operates only in the territory of the
municipality in which it is enacted and can
have no force beyond it
CHAPTER III
CARDINAL RULES OF CONSTRUCTION
1. Ascertain the legislative intent in cases of
obscurity, ambiguity or other fault of
expression, and uncertainty in meaning of
statutes
2. Liberal or Strict Construction
a. Former law
b. Persons or rights which it deals
c. Letter or language of law
d. Purpose and objects of the statute
o
o
o
MALEDICTA
EXPOSITIO
QUAE
CORRUMPIT TEXTUM- It is a dangerous
construction which is against the express
words
PARTS OF STATUTES
1
2
10