Sie sind auf Seite 1von 17

Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry (2007)

16:104–120 DOI 10.1007/s00787-006-0580-1 ORIGINAL CONTRIBUTION

Peter S. Jensen Management of psychiatric disorders in


Jan Buitelaar
Gahan J. Pandina children and adolescents with atypical
Carin Binder
Magali Haas antipsychotics
A systematic review of published clinical trials

j Abstract We aimed to provide a endocrine effects. The review of


Accepted: 3 July 2006
Published online: 30 October 2006 descriptive review of treatment published scientific data suggests
studies of atypical antipsychotics that most of the atypical antipsy-
Supported by funding from Janssen, L.P. in paediatric psychiatric disorders. chotics, excluding clozapine, have
A systematic review of the litera- a favourable risk/benefit profile
P.S. Jensen ture used Medline and EMBASE and effectively reduce disabling
Center for the Advancement of Children’s databases to identify clinical trials behaviours in paediatric psychiat-
Mental Health
Columbia University of atypical antipsychotics in chil- ric patients. While there is a body
New York State Psychiatric Institute dren and adolescents between of evidence published of treatment
New York, NY, USA 1994 and 2006. Trials were limited of DBDs and PDDs, there is a lack
J. Buitelaar to double-blind studies and open- of controlled data to guide clinical
Department of Psychiatry, and Karakter label studies of ‡8 weeks duration practice for the use of atypical
University Center for Child and that included ‡20 patients. Nine- antipsychotics for paediatric psy-
Adolescent Psychiatry teen double-blind and 22 open- chotic disorders and bipolar dis-
Radboud University
Nijmegen Medical Center label studies were identified. order. While there have been
Nijmegen, The Netherlands Studies included use of clozapine, studies with duration up to
olanzapine, quetiapine, risperi- 2 years, no definitive data are
G.J. Pandina, PhD (&)
Janssen Pharmaceutica Inc. done, and ziprasidone in the available that suggest long-term
1125 Trenton-Harbourton Rd treatment of disruptive behavio- safety; additional studies are war-
Titusville, NJ 08560, USA ural disorders (DBDs), pervasive ranted.
Tel.: +1-609/730-2324 developmental disorders (PDDs),
Fax: +1-609/730-3125
E-Mail: gpandina@janus.jnj.com tic disorder, psychotic disorders,
and mania. These medications
C. Binder generally reduced the severity of a
Janssen-Ortho Inc. j Key words atypical antipsy-
Toronto, Canada variety of psychiatric symptoms in chotics – paediatric psychiatric
children and adolescents. Less disorders – clozapine –
M. Haas frequent adverse events included
Johnson & Johnson Pharmaceutical olanzapine – quetiapine –
Research and Development extrapyramidal symptoms, hyper- risperidone – ziprasidone
Titusville, NJ, USA glycaemia and diabetes, and

psychotics include disruptive behavioural disorders


Introduction (DBDs), pervasive developmental disorders (PDDs),
Atypical antipsychotics have been used to treat a tic disorders, schizophrenia, and bipolar disorder.
variety of psychiatric disorders, many of which also These disorders include disturbing and disruptive
affect the paediatric population. Common disabling behavioural symptoms that have a significant and
ECAP 580

psychiatric disorders in children and adolescents that often long-lasting negative effect on the quality of life
have been targeted for treatment with atypical anti- of both the patients and their caregivers [29, 53, 61].
P. Jenson et al. 105
Paediatric Atypical Review

Paediatric psychiatric disorders typically require a syndrome, four studies; schizophrenia, six studies;
combination of psychoeducation, cognitive and mania/bipolar disorder, six studies; safety and toler-
behavioural management strategies, and, where ability, three studies). For each study, mean daily
appropriate, pharmacological agents. In schizophre- doses of the medication are reported both as total
nia and bipolar disorder, medication use is the first milligrams and, when available, milligrams per kilo-
line of treatment. However, in DBD, PDD, and tic gram. Because different efficacy endpoints were used
disorders, medications are typically reserved for those in the clinical trials for specified disorders, direct
patients whose moderate-to-severe symptoms have comparisons across studies were difficult, but the data
not responded adequately to behavioural interven- were summarized and contrasted whenever possible.
tions and who have continued impaired functioning. In addition, where placebo-controlled double-blind
Medication choice is often driven by side-effect pro- studies were conducted and available for review, we
files in paediatric patients and may influence com- report effect sizes (ES) for making comparisons of
pliance, development, and educational performance. efficacy (ES = mean active drug score—mean placebo
Over the past few years, atypical antipsychotics have score/pooled standard deviation). Adverse events
been increasingly used in children and adolescents. noted in each study are also presented.
However, it appears that the use of these agents has
often surpassed the available evidence, especially with
regard to safety. While some guidelines suggest that j Disruptive behavioural disorders (Table 1)
atypical antipsychotics may be preferred over typical
antipsychotics for selected indications [38, 48], recent DBDs of childhood include conduct disorder
concerns about weight gain, diabetes, and elevated (destructiveness and violence), oppositional defiant
prolactin levels indicate the need to re-examine the disorder (e.g. defiance of authority and rule-breaking
evidence on true risk/benefit of these agents. This behaviour), and DBD-not otherwise specified. These
review aims to systematically examine the published are among the most common reasons for psychiatric
evidence for treatment with atypical antipsychotics of referral in children.
paediatric psychiatric disorders. When psychosocial interventions such as
behavioural therapy or family therapy are inadequate
to treat the symptoms of DBD, atypical antipsychotics
appear to be increasingly used. Short-term reductions
Methods in DBD symptoms have been demonstrated with both
olanzapine and risperidone (Table 1). Double-blind
A systematic literature search using the Medline and controlled studies are only available for risperidone
EMBASE databases was performed to identify all and show consistently superior efficacy versus pla-
paediatric clinical trials of atypical antipsychotics cebo in reducing symptoms. Data were available to
whose results were published in the peer-reviewed calculate the ES of treatment with risperidone com-
literature from January 1994 through March 2006. pared with placebo on the primary measure of efficacy
Unpublished data or abstracts from conferences were for three of the double-blind studies reported in Ta-
not considered in order to prevent any bias related to ble 1. The ES ranged from )0.6 (medium) to )1.5
the accessibility of the data. The keywords used were (very large). Global improvements in the patients’
[children or preschool or juvenile or youth* or ado- condition were observed, as well as reduction in the
lescent*] and [antipsychotic* or neuroleptic* or main symptoms of aggression and agitation. In the
quetiapine or risperidone or olanzapine or aripip- double-blind and open-label risperidone (0.02–
razole or clozapine or ziprasidone] (* = wild-card 0.06 mg/kg/day) trials and the one open-label trial
term). Search results were limited to publication type: with olanzapine (0.15–0.20 mg/kg/day), significant
clinical trial. The search identified over 100 controlled behavioural improvement was seen within the first 1–
and open-label studies. Trials limited to double-blind 2 weeks of treatment. Furthermore, a placebo-con-
and open-label studies of ‡8 weeks duration with ‡20 trolled maintenance versus withdrawal trial showed
patients were included in this review. that patients who responded to initial treatment with
risperidone would benefit from continuous treatment
over the longer term [55]. Long-term maintenance of
Results efficacy in treating DBD has been demonstrated with
risperidone in open-label studies [15, 20, 55, 68].
Nineteen double-blind studies and 22 open-label Both risperidone and olanzapine were generally
studies met the criteria for final review. These studies well tolerated in children with DBD. There were either
and their findings are presented below by indication no or mild extrapyramidal symptoms (EPS), and
(DBD, 12 studies; PDD, 10 studies; tics/Tourette’s sedation was typically mild and transient. Weight gain
Table 1 Atypical antipsychotics in the treatment of disruptive behaviour disorders in paediatric patients
106

Inclusion criteria
(mean age or
Study Duration Mean daily dose (n) age range) Efficacy Safety and tolerability Limitations

Double-blind studies
Findling et al. [19] 10 weeks Risperidone Conduct disorder of RAAPP score )1.7 risperidone No EPS. Sedation in 3 risperidone Short duration of treatment
0.03 mg/kg (10), at least moderate vs. )0.2 placebo (P < 0.05); patients vs. 2 placebo Small sample size
placebo (10) severity (9.2 years) ES = )1.0. Weight gain 4.2 kg risperidone vs. Different drop-out rates per
CGI )2.6 risperidone vs. )0.1 0.7 kg placebo (P < 0.01) treatment group
placebo (P < 0.01)
Buitelaar et al. 6 weeks Risperidone 2.9 mg DBD or ADHD with Risperidone > placebo after Risperidone: no or mild EPS; Short duration of treatment
[11] (0.04 mg/kg) (19), severe chronic 2 weeks transient tiredness in 58%. Behavioural changes were
placebo (19) aggression CGI score )1.6 risperidone vs. Weight gain 2.3 kg risperidone vs. evaluated by a number of nurses
requiring +0.2 placebo (P < 0.001); 0.6 kg placebo (P < 0.05) and teachers, which might have
hospitalization ES = )1.5. resulted in a measurement error
IQ 60–90 (14 years) ABC significantly improved with
risperidone (P < 0.05)
van Bellinghen 4 weeks Risperidone 1.2 mg Persistent ABC score improvement in 65% EPS similar with risperidone and Short duration of treatment
et al. [69] (0.05 mg/kg) (6), behavioural risperidone vs. 7% placebo placebo Results limited to borderline IQ
placebo (7) disturbance Weight gain 1.8 kg risperidone vs.
IQ 45–85 (6– 0.6 kg placebo (P = 0.319)
14 years)
Snyder et al. [64] 6 weeks Risperidone DBD with N-CBRF Risperidone > placebo after Hypertonia 8% risperidone vs. 2% Short duration of treatment
0.98 mg (0.03 mg/ conduct scale 1 week placebo; somnolence 42% vs. 14% Results limited to borderline IQ
kg) (53), placebo scores ‡24. N-CBRF conduct scale score placebo; increased appetite 15% vs. Lack of structured diagnostic
 Steinkopff Verlag 2006

(57) IQ 36–84 )15.8 risperidone vs. )6.8 8%; weight gain 2.2 kg vs. 0.2 kg interviews
(8.7 years) placebo (P < 0.001);
ES = )0.6.
CGI much improved in 38%
risperidone vs. 16% placebo
(P < 0.001)
Aman et al. [4] 6 weeks Risperidone 1.2 mg DBD with N-CBRF N-CBRF conduct scale score EPS low severity with risperidone Short duration of treatment
(0.04 mg/kg) (55), conduct scale )15.2 risperidone vs. )6.2 and placebo Results limited to borderline IQ
placebo (63) scores ‡24. placebo (P < 0.01); ES = )0.8. Mild/transient somnolence 51%
IQ 36–84 (5– BPI aggressive scale )6.8 risperidone vs. 10% placebo; weight
12 years) risperidone vs. )2.4 placebo gain 15% (2.2 kg) vs. 2% (0.9 kg)
European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry (2007) Vol. 16, No. 2

(P < 0.01)
CGI improvement in 77%
risperidone vs. 33% placebo
(P < 0.001)
Reyes et al. [55] 6 months Risperidone DBD with N-CBRF Symptom recurrence rate: Weight increased with risperidone Only patients who responded to
blinded 0.02 mg/kg (172); conduct scale 42.3% with placebo vs. 27.3% during the initial 12 weeks (weight initial treatment were randomized;
risperidone placebo (163) scores ‡24. with risperidone; HR 2.24 (95% z-score change = 0.3) and use of psychostimulants
withdrawal IQ ‡55 (11 years) CI = 1.54–3.28) stabilized afterwards
Somnolence (11.6%)
Infrequent EPS and prolactin
related adverse events
Open-label studies
Soderstrom et al. 2–10 months Olanzapine 0.15– Conduct disorder Five treatment responders Weight gain in 5 (mean Small sample size
[65] 0.20 mg/kg (6) with severe within 2 weeks gain = 10 kg); sedation in 4.
aggression (14–
19 years)
Table 1 Continued

Inclusion criteria
(mean age or
Study Duration Mean daily dose (n) age range) Efficacy Safety and tolerability Limitations

Buitelaar et al. 8 weeks Risperidone 2.1 mg Persistent 56% decrease in aggression Moderate akathisia and hand Short duration of treatment
[10] (26) aggression and CGI improved much/very much tremor 1; mild sedation 2; weight Lack of weekly outcome
subaverage intellect in 14 patients and moderate in gain 2 (8 and 10 kg). Two measurements
IQ 78 (15 years) 10. discontinued (sedation plus weight Results limited to borderline IQ
gain)
Findling et al. [20] 48 weeks Risperidone 1.5 mg Severe DBD Long-term improvements in No changes in ESRS Exclusion of patients who had
or 0.041 mg/kg (N-CBRF conduct N-CBRF problem behaviour and Somnolence 33%, headache 33%, experienced adverse events leading
(107) score ‡24). IQ prosocial scales (P < 0.001) weight gain 21% (mean = 5.5 kg) to discontinuation in a previous
36–84 (9 years) and CVLT and continuous double-blind study
performance task (P < 0.05) Unblinded
Results limited to borderline IQ
Turgay et al. [68] 48 weeks Risperidone 0.02– DBD with N-CBRF Stable improvement in N-CBRF No severe EPS Exclusion of patients who had
0.06 mg/kg (77) conduct score ‡24. conduct scale scores Weight gain more pronounced experienced adverse events leading
IQ 36–84 >50% reduction in VAS most during first months of treatment to discontinuation in a previous
(5–12 years) troublesome symptoms Two patients discontinued after 34 double-blind study
CGI severe ratings 68% at and 37 weeks (headache and Results limited to borderline IQ
P. Jenson et al.

baseline vs. 17% at endpoint dyspnea)


Croonenberghs 1 year Risperidone 0.02– DBD with N-CBRF Reductions in N-CBRF conduct Low incidence of EPS. ESRS scores Selective inclusion of children with
et al. [15] 0.06 mg/kg (504) conduct score ‡24. scores and other behaviour reduced over the 48 weeks subaverage intelligence and severe
IQ 36–84; subscales (P < 0.001) Two cases of tardive dyskinesia disruptive behaviours
Paediatric Atypical Review

(5–14 years) Improvements at week 1 Transient increase in prolactin, then


maintained to within normal levels
Reyes et al 2006 2 years Risperidone DBD with N-CBRF Improvement sustained over Three cases of involuntary muscle Small patient number
[55] extension study 1.92 mg or conduct score‡24. 2 years, CGI-S score of 3.1 at contractions Inclusion of patients who
0.046 mg/kg (35) IQ 36–84; end point BMI mean increase responded and showed good
(5–17 years) 1 year = 1.4 kg/m2; tolerance to risperidone
2 years = 1.1 kg/m2

ABC = Aberrant Behaviour Checklist; ADHD = attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder; BMI = body mass index; BPI = Behaviour Problems Inventory; CGI = Clinical Global Impression; CI = confidence interval;
CVLT = California Verbal Learning Test; DBD = disruptive behavioural disorder; EPS = extrapyramidal symptoms; ES = effect size (risperidone vs. placebo); ESRS = Extrapyramidal Symptom Rating Scale;
HR = Hazard ratio; N-CBRF = Nisonger-Child Behaviour Rating Form; RAAPP = Rating of Aggression Against People and/or Property scale
107
108 European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry (2007) Vol. 16, No. 2
 Steinkopff Verlag 2006

was often significantly greater in children receiving an It is of interest that a secondary analysis of the
atypical antipsychotic than placebo. RUPP data [58] by McDougle et al. [46] showed that
risperidone treatment (1.8 mg/day) could lead to
significant improvement in core symptoms of autism
Methodological limitations
such as restricted, repetitive, and stereotyped patterns
Overall, the double-blind studies were of short of behaviour, interests, and activities in children with
duration and thus unlikely to report rare adverse severe autism. However, risperidone treatment did
events. In addition, findings cannot be generalized to not result in significant effects on deficits in social
long-term treatment of DBD, which is a chronic interaction and communication.
condition. The only double-blind study of interme- The most common side-effects in children with
diate duration [55] followed patients with DBD who PDD receiving risperidone were mild transient som-
had initially responded to risperidone treatment and, nolence and weight gain with short-term treatment.
therefore, results might have been prone to a selec- One trial that followed with children with autism for
tion bias. The majority of the studies were limited to 6 months showed that intermediate-duration risperi-
paediatric patients with borderline or subaverage done treatment was associated with weight gain of
intelligence (IQ 36–85). One open-label study [55] 5.1 kg, a significantly greater increase than would be
followed patients up to 2 years, but the findings expected from developmental norms [46]. No extra-
should be viewed against the limitations of a small pyramidal or neurological symptoms were noted in
sample size and a selection of patients who had these children, except for caregiver-reported tremor
shown good tolerability to risperidone in a previous (P = 0.06 vs. placebo) [45] or ‘‘abnormal movements’’
1-year open-label study. [46]. EPS that resolved with dose adjustment were
reported in children receiving olanzapine.
j Pervasive developmental disorders (Table 2)
Methodological limitations
PDDs as defined here include autism, Asperger’s The study by McCracken et al. [45] and the follow-
syndrome, PDD, and PDD-not otherwise specified. up study by McDougle et al. [46] were limited to
PDDs are often associated with disruptive behaviour, children with autism and severe behavioural prob-
including aggression, hyperactivity, screaming, and lems. Due to small sample sizes, the open-label
self-injurious behaviour that adds to the burden of studies were not able to detect rare adverse events.
care for these children [31]. The double-blind study by Troost et al. [67] and the
Olanzapine (10.7 mg/day) and risperidone (0.49– open-label study by Kemner et al. [33] were limited
1.8 mg/day) have demonstrated efficacy in reducing to high-functioning patients. Overall, there is a need
symptoms in children with PDD (Table 2). The only for further standardization of tools to be used for
double-blind studies available were with risperidone. tracking changes in core and associated behavioural
Data were available to calculate the ES of treatment symptoms of autism in children with autism and
with risperidone versus placebo on the primary other PDDs.
measure of efficacy (change from baseline on the
Aberrant Behaviour Checklist [ABC]-Irritability sub-
scale score for both of these studies (McCracken et al. j Tic disorders (Table 3)
[45] ES = )1.2; Shea et al. [62] ES = )0.8). Early, 2-
week efficacy was demonstrated by Shea et al. [62]. Tic disorders include Tourette’s syndrome, chronic
Conversely, gradual blinded risperidone discontinu- motor and vocal tic disorder, transient tic disorder,
ation after 6 months was associated with a rapid re- and tic disorder-not otherwise specified [6]. Atypical
turn of disruptive and aggressive behaviours in 62.5% antipsychotics are often used when tic disorders are
of placebo patients compared with 12.5% of those accompanied with symptoms of aggression or rage.
who continued risperidone [58]. Comparable results The efficacy of risperidone and ziprasidone in the
were obtained by Troost et al. [67]. treatment of tic disorders has been assessed in four
In the open-label study of olanzapine [33], signif- double-blind trials (Table 3). A crossover comparison
icant improvements in both ABC and Clinical Global treating Tourette’s disorder with risperidone (2.5 mg/
Impression (CGI) scores were reported. In 2 open- day) and pimozide (2.4 mg/day; 4 weeks each)
label risperidone trials, significant improvements in showed greater improvements in tic severity with
Childhood Autism Rating Scale scores were reported risperidone (42% vs. 21% with pimozide; P = 0.05)
[17, 44]. Maintenance of treatment benefits was re- [27]. Tolerability was generally similar in the two
ported in 77–81% of children with PDD treated with groups, with the exception of greater weight gain with
risperidone for 6–7 months [17, 42]. risperidone. Two other double-blind studies also
Table 2 Atypical antipsychotics in the treatment of pervasive developmental disorders

Inclusion criteria
Study Duration Mean daily dose (n) (mean age) Efficacy Safety and tolerability Limitations

Double-blind studies
McCracken et al. 8 weeks Risperidone 1.8 mg Autism with tantrums, ABC-I score )57% risperidone vs. Mild, transient drowsiness and Short duration of treatment
[45] (49), placebo (52) aggression, and/or self- )14% placebo; ES = )1.2. fatigue with risperidone Study limited to patients with
injurious behaviour CGI much/very much improved at Weight gain 2.7 kg risperidone vs. autistic disorders and severe
(8.8 years) 8 weeks: 76% risperidone vs. 12% 0.8 kg placebo behavioural problems
placebo
Shea et al. [62] 8 weeks Risperidone 1.2 mg PDD with or without Risperidone efficacious after Risperidone: no increase in EPS; Short duration of treatment
(0.04 mg/kg) (41), mental retardation 2 weeks transient somnolence
placebo (39) CARS score ‡30 Improvement in all ABC subscale Weight gain 2.7 kg risperidone vs.
(7.5 years) scores in 55–64% risperidone vs. 1.0 kg placebo
24–40% placebo (P £ 0.05) See McCracken et al. [45]
ES = )0.8 (ABC-Irritability)
McDougle et al. 8 weeks Risperidone 1.8 mg Autism with tantrums, Ritvo-Freeman Real Life Rating Study limited to patients with
[46] + 16 weeks OL (49); placebo (52) aggression, and/or self- Scale—significantly greater autistic disorders and severe
continuation injurious behaviour reduction with risperidone in total behavioural problems
(8.8 years) scores (ES = )1.08); subscales Rating diagnostic instruments not
scores for sensory motor behaviours validated
(ES = )0.45), Affectual Reactions
P. Jenson et al.

(ES = )1.10), Sensory Responses


(ES = )0.77)
RUPP Autism 4 months OL + Risperidone Subject with severe Relapse rate: 62.5% with placebo Weight gain 5.1 kg Inclusion of patients with severe
Network 2005 [58] 8 weeks DB 1.96 mg/day autism who responded vs. 12.5% with risperidone; median behavioural problems was an entry
Paediatric Atypical Review

risperidone (OL, 63; DB to risperidone during a time to relapse 34 and 57 days, criteria
withdrawal withdrawal, 32) previous short term trial respectively
[45]
Troost et al. [67] 6 mo OL + 8 wks Risperidone PDD with CGI-S Relapse rate: 67% with placebo vs. Weight gain of 5.7 kg. Two patients Findings are not generalizable for
DB risperidone 1.8 mg/day (OL 36; disruptive behaviour 25% with risperidone; median time discontinued due to unacceptable the impaired autism population,
withdrawal DB withdrawal 24) rating ‡ moderate; to relapse 42 and 49 days, weight gain because sample studied included
ABC-I score ‡18. respectively relatively high-functioning
(5–17 years) patients
Open-label studies
Kemner et al. [33] 12 weeks Olanzapine Autism or PDD-NOS ABC irritability, hyperactivity, EPS in three patients resolved with Small sample size. Findings are not
10.7 mg (25) (11.2 years) excessive speech scale scores dose adjustment generalizable for the impaired
reduced (P < 0.05) Weight gain in 56% (mean gain autism population, because sample
CGI-severity 13% reduction 4.7 kg) studied included relatively high-
Gestures and verbal actions reduced functioning patients
(P < 0.05)
Masi et al. [44] 16 weeks Risperidone PDD with CARS CPRS score improved 21%. Increase appetite in six; enuresis in Small sample size
0.49 mg (24) scores > 30 (4.6 years) Improvements of 22–34% three Evaluation of efficacy was based on
(P < 0.001) in 7 CARS scales, and Mean weight gain 1 kg only 2 ratings (CPRS and CARS)
CARS total (14%; P < 0.001) Two patients discontinued
Much/very much improvement on (sedation and hyporeflexia in one
CGI in 36%. and tachycardia in other)
Malone et al. [42] 7 months Risperidone 1.2 mg Autism with severely CPRS-14 score improved 21%. No EPS Small sample size
(22) disruptive symptoms CGI much/very much improvement Mild, transient sedation in 68%. Long-term efficacy was based on
(7.1 years) in 77% at 1 month and in 10/13 at Mean weight gain after 7 months CGI alone
6 months 3.3 kg
109
110 European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry (2007) Vol. 16, No. 2
 Steinkopff Verlag 2006

showed improvement with risperidone (1.5 and

Evaluation of efficacy was based on

Evaluation of efficacy was based on

ABC-I = Aberrant Behaviour Checklist, irritability subscale; CARS = Childhood Autism Rating Scale; CGI = Clinical Global Impression; CPRS = Children’s Psychiatric Rating Scale; DB = double-blind;
2.5 mg/day), with a reduction in obsessive-compul-
sive traits and a reduction in tic severity [24, 60].
Greater weight gain was noted in patients receiving
CGI-I and CARS only risperidone than either clonidine or placebo in these
Small sample size

Small sample size

CPRS ratings only


studies. A placebo-controlled study of ziprasidone
(28.2 mg/day) demonstrated a 39% reduction in tic
Limitations

severity after 8 weeks vs. 16% in the placebo group


(P < 0.05) [59]. Data were available to calculate ES for
treatment with active drug versus placebo on tic
severity reduction for two of these studies: Scahill
Weight gain >10% in two patients

et al. [60] (ES = )1.2) and Sallee et al. [59]


12 weeks and 3.7 kg at 24 weeks

EPS = extrapyramidal symptoms; ES = effect size (risperidone vs. placebo); OL = open-label; PDD-NOS = pervasive developmental disorder-not otherwise specified
(ES = )0.8). No weight gain was reported with zipr-
Mild sedation in four patients

Mild, transient sedation in six

Mean weight gain 2.6 kg at

asidone in this study, but mild, transient sedation was


reported in more children receiving ziprasidone than
Safety and tolerability

placebo. No open-label studies met our inclusion


criteria.
patients
No EPS

Methodological limitations
Studies were limited by short duration and small
sample sizes.
Reductions of 13–37% (P < 0.05)
CPRS-14 scores improved 17%.

in scores on 8 CPRS-14 scales


CGI improvement in 81%.
CARS total reduced 18%

j Schizophrenia and related disorders (Table 4)

Schizophrenia and bipolar disorder are typically


recognized in adolescents or young adults rather
(P = 0.001)

than children. Childhood-onset schizophrenia is re-


Efficacy

ported in about 0.01% of children aged <12 years,


with the incidence increasing during the teenage
years [51]. Few trials have been conducted in this
Autism (4.95 years)

Autism with CARS

age group.
Inclusion criteria

Kumra et al. [37] reported improvements (Brief


(mean age)

scores ‡30

Psychiatric Rating Scale scores) in significantly more


(6.0 years)

patients receiving clozapine (3.1 mg/kg/day) than


haloperidol (0.29 mg/kg/day) in a 6-week study (Ta-
ble 4). In an 8-week comparison of haloperidol, ris-
Mean daily dose (n)

1.53 mg (0.09 mg/

peridone, and olanzapine, Sikich et al. [63] reported


similar treatment benefits for all three treatments in
1.26 mg (20)
kg/day) (20)

50 children and adolescents with schizophrenia or


Risperidone

Risperidone

affective disorder with psychotic features. Mean daily


doses were 12.3 mg olanzapine, 4.0 mg risperidone,
and 5.0 mg haloperidol. Mean time to efficacy re-
sponse was about 2 weeks in all 3 groups. Severity of
EPS was similar in all treatment groups. Greater
weight gain was reported with the atypical antipsy-
6 months

24 weeks

chotics (olanzapine 7.1 kg; risperidone 4.9 kg; halo-


Duration

peridol 3.5 kg; P < 0.05). Open-label studies of


atypical antipsychotics in the treatment of schizo-
phrenia and related disorders have identified treat-
Table 2 Continued

ment responses occurring as early as 1–3 weeks after


Diler et al. [17]

Gagliano et al.

treatment initiation (Table 4). Preliminary data


showed that clozapine treatment (476 mg/day) is
Study

efficacious in adolescents with treatment refractory


[25]

schizophrenia and aggressive behaviour [36].


P. Jenson et al. 111
Paediatric Atypical Review

Table 3 Atypical antipsychotics in Tourette’s syndrome and tic disorders

Mean daily Inclusion criteria


Study Duration dose (n) (mean age) Efficacy Safety and tolerability Limitations

Double-blind studies
Gaffney et al. [24] 8 weeks Risperidone 1.5 mg Tourette’s Response similar in two Sedation in 1 Short duration of
(9), clonidine (11.4 years) groups risperidone patient and treatment
0.18 mg (12) Tics reduced 21% 5 clonidine patients Use of active
risperidone vs. 26% Weight gain 2.1 kg comparator
clonidine risperidone vs. 0.1 kg Small sample sizes
OCD traits reduced 42% clonidine
risperidone vs. 20%
clonidine
Scahill et al. [60] 8 weeks Risperidone 2.5 mg Tic disorder with IQ Tic severity reduced No EPS Short duration of
(12), placebo (14) ‡70; subanalysis of 36% risperidone vs. 9% Weight gain 2.8 kg treatment
paediatric patients placebo (P < 0.01); risperidone vs. 0 kg Small sample sizes
(11.1 years) ES = )1.2 placebo Patients ascertained
CGI much/very much from a specialty clinic
improvement in 9 Exclusion of patients
risperidone vs. 1 with obsessive-
placebo compulsive disorder
Gilbert et al. [27] 4 weeks Crossover: Tourette’s Greater reduction in tic AEs similar in two Short duration of
risperidone 2.5 mg syndrome severity with groups treatment
and pimozide (11 years) risperidone (42%) vs. Weight gain 1.9 kg Small sample sizes
2.4 mg (9) pimozide (21%; risperidone vs. 1.0 kg
P = 0.05) pimozide
CGI improvement in 2
(much improved)
risperidone vs. 3
(minimally improved)
pimozide
Sallee et al. [59] 8 weeks Ziprasidone Tourette’s Tic severity )39% Severe akathisia in 1 Short duration of
28.2 mg (16), syndrome or ziprasidone vs. )16% ziprasidone patient treatment
placebo (12) chronic motor or placebo (P = 0.02); resolved with dose Small sample sizes
vocal tic disorder ES = )0.8. reduction
(11.5 years) CGI changes 30% Mild/transient sedation
ziprasidone vs. 16% in 11 ziprasidone vs. 5
placebo; ES = )0.5. placebo
Weight gain 0.7 kg
ziprasidone vs. 0.8 kg
placebo

AE = adverse event; CGI = Clinical Global Impressions; EPS = extrapyramidal symptoms; ES = effect size (atypical v2s. placebo); OCD = obsessive-compulsive
disorder

In these open-label studies, children and adoles- j Mania in bipolar disorder (Table 5)
cents receiving haloperidol had more severe EPS than
those receiving olanzapine or risperidone. In the Reductions in the severity of symptoms of mania,
open-label study [53] with clozapine, six of the 36 psychosis, aggression, and depression in children or
patients discontinued owing to a variety of adverse adolescents with bipolar disorder have been shown in
events. open-label studies of olanzapine (9.6 mg/day) and
risperidone (1.7 mg/day), with improvement noted
Methodological limitations during the first week of treatment (Table 5). Quetia-
pine (450 mg/day) produced superior control of
Overall, the studies were limited by short duration, mania in adolescents in a double-blind study when
small sample sizes, and use of adjunctive medication. used as adjunctive therapy to valproate compared
The study by Remschmidt et al. [53] is limited by its with valproate plus placebo [14]. Sedation with que-
retrospective character. Patients were not randomly tiapine combination therapy was mild to moderate in
assigned to haloperidol, olanzapine, or risperidone in severity and did not result in drug discontinuation.
the study by Gothelf et al. [28]. While no patients in either group discontinued be-
Table 4 Atypical antipsychotics in paediatric schizophrenia or other psychotic disorders
112

Study Duration Mean daily dose (n) Inclusion criteria (mean age) Efficacy Safety and tolerability Limitations

Double-blind studies
Kumra et al. [37] 6 weeks Clozapine 176 mg Schizophrenia BPRS improvement in 32% Drowsiness 9 clozapine vs. 3 Short duration of treatment
(3.1 mg/kg/day IQ ‡70 (14.0 years) clozapine vs. 15% haloperidol haloperidol
(10), haloperidol (P = 0.03) Tachycardia 7 clozapine vs. 5
16 mg (0.29 mg/ Significant improvements in haloperidol
kg/day (11) positive and negative Weight gain 0.9 kg clozapine
symptoms with clozapine and haloperidol
Sikich et al. [63] 8 weeks Risperidone 4.0 mg Psychotic disorder with ‡ 1 BPRS improvement 50% No difference in EPS among Short duration of treatment
(19), olanzapine positive psychotic symptom of risperidone, 56% olanzapine, groups Limited sample size
12.3 mg (16), moderate severity on BPRS and 33% haloperidol Weight gain 7.1 kg olanzapine, Differences in the diagnosis
haloperidol 5.0 mg IQ >69 (14.7 years) BPRS total reduced 47% 4.9 kg risperidone, 3.5 kg across the treatment groups
(15) risperidone, 50% olanzapine, haloperidol (P < 0.05) Adjunctive use of mood
36% haloperidol stabilizers and/or
CGI much/very much improved antidepressants
and ‡ 20% BPRS reduction
74% risperidone, 88%
olanzapine, 53% haloperidol
Open-label studies
Remschmidt et al. [53] 22 weeks Clozapine 330 mg Schizophrenia (18.3 years in Improvements in 27 patients; Discontinuation in six due to Retrospective study
(36) entire sample of 113 patients; complete remission in 4 AEs: stupor, leukopaenia (8%),
age of those receiving clozapine Positive symptoms improved in cardiovascular abnormalities
not given) 65%. (44%), or abnormal liver
enzymes
 Steinkopff Verlag 2006

Ross et al. [57] 1 year Olanzapine Schizophrenia or schizoaffective Symptom severity No significant change in EPS Small sample size
10.4 mg (20) disorder (10.5 years) reduced ‡ 20% and/or residual Weight gain at 1 year 12.8 kg Outcomes limited to symptom
mild symptoms in 68% at assessment
6 weeks and 74% at 1 year Concurrent medication use was
not controlled
Gothelf et al. [28] 8 weeks Olanzapine Schizophrenia (16.9 years) PANSS score reductions of More severe EPS and Short duration of treatment
12.9 mg (19), 11.3% (olanzapine), 24.1% depression with haloperidol Small sample sizes
risperidone 3.3 mg (risperidone), 39.5% (57%) than olanzapine (12%) or No randomization in the choice
(17), haloperidol (haloperidol) in positive risperidone (24%) groups of medication
8.3 mg (7) symptoms and 17.7% (P < 0.01)
(olanzapine), 14.0%
European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry (2007) Vol. 16, No. 2

(risperidone), 19.2%
(haloperidol) in negative
symptoms
Kranzler et al. [36] 6 months Clozapine 476 mg Schizophrenia/schizoaffective Decreased frequency of Not reported Unblinded
(20) disorder (14.2 years) administration of emergency Mirror-image design
oral/injectable medication and Use of adjunctive psychotropic
seclusion (P < 0.001 for each) medication

AE = adverse event; BPRS = Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale; CGI = Clinical Global Impression; EPS = extrapyramidal symptoms; PANSS = Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale
Table 5 Atypical antipsychotics in paediatric mania and bipolar disorder

Study Duration Mean daily dose (n) Inclusion criteria (mean age) Efficacy Safety and tolerability Limitations

Double-blind studies
Delbello et al. [16] 6 weeks Divalproex plus quetiapine Bipolar I disorder, mixed or More patients showed YMRS No EPS Short duration of treatment
450 mg (maximum) (15) or manic, YMRS score ‡20 improvements with addition of Sedation: quetiapine 80% vs. Small sample sizes
placebo (15) (14.3 years) quetiapine (87%) than placebo placebo 33%. All patients were hospitalized
(53%) (P < 0.05) Nonresponders to valproate were
excluded from the study
Open-label studies
Frazier et al. [23] 8 weeks Olanzapine 9.6 mg Bipolar disorder, YMRS score Improvements maintained for Somnolence in 10.
(0.21 mg/kg) (23) ‡15 (10.3 years) 8 weeks
YMRS & BPRS improved 62% Weight gain in seven patients
(P < 0.001) (mean 5 kg)
CGI-S reduced 38% bipolar 1 discontinuation (depression)
disorder, 40% mania, 37%
depression (P < 0.001)
Frazier et al. [22] 6 months Risperidone 1.7 mg (28) Mixed or hypomanic bipolar CGI-S reduced 46% mania, 41% Sedation and weight gain each Retrospective study
disorder (10.4 years) aggression, 14% ADHD reported in 18%. Short duration of drug exposure
CGI improvement (£2) 82% Small sample size
mania and aggression, 69%
psychosis, 8% ADHD
P. Jenson et al.

Pavuluri et al. [49] 6 months Risperidone Mixed or manic episode with ‡50% reduction in YMRS scores Risperidone + lithium discontinued Small sample sizes
0.70 mg + divalproex YMRS >20 (12.1 years) in 80% of in 2 (enuresis and fatigue) Short wash-out period (3–4 days)
925 mg (106 lg/dl) (20), risperidone + divalproex Weight gain 6 kg Concomitant use of clonidine,
risperidone group, 82.4% of risperidone + lithium, 6.8 kg trazodone allowed
Paediatric Atypical Review

0.75 mg + lithium 750 mg risperidone + lithium group risperidone + divalproex Patients known to worsen on study
(0.9 mEq/l) (17) Improvements (P < 0.001) in Sedation in 23.5% of lithium group medication were excluded
YMRS, CGI-BP, and CDRS-R and 20% of divalproex group
scores in both groups with no Prolactin elevation in 4 resolved by
between-group differences reducing risperidone dose
Biederman et al. [8] 8 weeks Risperidone 1.25 mg (30) Mixed, manic or hypomanic Response rate (CGI- Weight gain 2.1 kg Short duration of treatment
episode with YMRS ‡15 (6– Improvement [£2]): 70% 4-fold increase in prolactin levels Unblinded treatment
17 years) Improvements (<0.001) in from baseline Spontaneous reports of adverse
YMRS, BPRS, CDRS events
Biederman et al. [8] 8 weeks Risperidone 1.4 mg (16) Mixed or manic episode with Response rate (30% reduction Increase in prolactin levels in both Short duration of treatment
Olanzapine 6.3 mg (15) YMRS ‡15 (4–6 years) in YMRS or CGI-Improvement groups, but significantly larger with Unblinded treatment
[£2]): 69% with risperidone vs. risperidone Spontaneous reports of adverse
53% with clozapine, NS Weight gain 2.2 kg risperidone, events
3.2 kg olanzapine

ADHD = attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder; BPRS = Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale; CDRS-R = Child Depression Rating Scale-Revised; CGI-BP = Clinical Global Impression Scale for Bipolar Disorder; CGI-
S = Clinical Global Impression-Severity; EPS = extrapyramidal symptoms; NS = not significant; YMRS = Young Mania Rating Scale
113
114 European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry (2007) Vol. 16, No. 2
 Steinkopff Verlag 2006

cause of side-effects, the combination therapy group study that followed children up to 2 years. There were
experienced a much higher dropout rate than the few studies with quetiapine and ziprasidone.
monotherapy group (7 vs. 1, respectively). Somnolence was frequently reported with atypical
Biederman et al. [8] reported comparable response antipsychotics, although it was usually mild to mod-
rates in children aged 4–6 years treated with risperi- erate in severity and infrequently resulted in treat-
done 1.4 mg/day (69%) or olanzapine 6.3 mg/day ment discontinuation [52]. The impact of somnolence
(53%) for 8 weeks measured as £30% reduction in was effectively reduced in studies with olanzapine and
scores of Young Mania Rating Scale or CGI- risperidone by switching from morning to evening
Improvement (£2). The increase in prolactin levels dosing, using divided dosing, or reducing dosage [62,
from baseline to endpoint was twofold larger with 65].
risperidone, while weight gain associated with ola- Weight gain is another important consideration in
nzapine was 1.5-fold larger than with risperidone. the use of atypical antipsychotics in paediatric pa-
Significant improvement in mania symptoms was tients. The weight gain observed with atypical anti-
observed in youths aged 6–17 years treated with ris- psychotics can range from 1 kg for 16 weeks [44] up
peridone monotherapy (1.25 mg/day) for 8 weeks [8]. to 12.8 kg over a year of treatment [57]. A summary
Six-month efficacy with risperidone was reported in a of weight gain data with atypical antipsychotics in
retrospective chart review [22] and in a prospective studies meeting inclusion criteria for this review is
open-label trial of risperidone in combination with shown in Table 6. As with efficacy data, most studies
either lithium or divalproex [49]. In the latter study, meeting inclusion criteria involved trials with ris-
neither combination demonstrated superiority over peridone. Most weight gain with risperidone occurred
the other. Both of these studies noted weight gain and during the initial 2 months of treatment, with rela-
sedation with risperidone. Pavuluri et al. [49] also tively less additional weight gain during long-term
reported prolactin elevation in four patients, which therapy [43]. In a follow-up study of 14 children with
resolved with dose reduction. Prospective, long-term DBD who discontinued treatment with risperidone
studies are needed to identify the long-term effects of because of weight gain, a comparison of standardized
atypical antipsychotic in the treatment of manic epi- weight scores at termination and at 3, 9–12, and
sodes in adolescents. 24 months after termination suggested that weight
gain during treatment was reversible [41]. However,
the authors cautioned that more data were needed
Methodological limitations
before this could be asserted for all children. A more
The only double blind study [16] was limited by its recent study that followed 527 children with DBD over
short duration, small sample sizes, and the inclusion a period of 6 months concluded that weight increased
of hospitalized patients. The open-label study by over the initial 12 weeks of treatment, after which it
Frazier et al. [22] was a retrospective study. Patients plateaued [55].
known to worsen on study medication were excluded EPS were infrequently noted with atypical anti-
from the study by Pavuluri et al. [49], potentially psychotics (Tables 1–5). A previous review of atyp-
resulting in a selection bias. In the 2 open-label ical antipsychotics in the treatment of psychosis [39]
studies by Biederman et al. [8], adverse events were identified a higher incidence of EPS in paediatric
spontaneously reported, which might have resulted in patients than in adult patients. Therefore, it is
an underestimation. noteworthy that EPS occurred infrequently in the
current analysis of more recent studies treating a
broad range of psychiatric symptoms at lower doses.
Safety and tolerability of atypical antipsychotics A recent review of studies that included 2,769 pa-
in paediatrics tients treated with atypical antipsychotics identified a
weighted mean annual incidence of tardive dyski-
In general, atypical antipsychotics are better tolerated nesia of 2.1% across all age groups [14]. The use of
and show improved medication compliance than atypical antipsychotics may be associated with lower
typical antipsychotics [12]. In the studies reviewed, dyskinesia risk compared with typical antipsychotics.
risperidone, clozapine and olanzapine were generally For example, a recent study that prospectively eval-
well tolerated, with few patients discontinuing treat- uated 102 children and adolescents receiving anti-
ment as a result of adverse events (2.6% up to 8.3% psychotics reported a rate of 5.9% for probable
across the different studies). The most frequent sig- tardive dyskinesia found to be significantly associ-
nificant adverse events reported with these atypical ated with the use of typical antipsychotics [13].
antipsychotics in a paediatric population were seda- However, the duration of this study was only
tion and weight gain. The maximum length of dura- 3 months and this could have resulted in underes-
tion of the various studies was 1 year, and only one timation of the prevalence rates.
P. Jenson et al. 115
Paediatric Atypical Review

No randomization of
Hyperglycaemia and diabetes have also been linked

Retrospective study
Small sample sizes

Small sample sizes


to the use of atypical antipsychotics, in particular
clozapine and olanzapine [40], but few data are
Limitations

available for the paediatric population. In 3 long-term

patients
open-label trials of risperidone that included a total of
688 children, only one case of a diabetes-associated
adverse event was reported, indicating that these are
not common adverse events with risperidone treat-

)1.01 kg/m2 no antipsychotic


ment [15, 20, 68].

Risperidone vs. neuroleptic,


+0.31 kg/m2 neuroleptic,
+3.67 kg/m2 risperidone,
Physical and sexual development should also be
Mean change in BMI

carefully studied in paediatric patients, particularly


when exposed to long-term therapy. A recent meta-
analysis assessed growth in 350 children and sexual
Not reported

Not reported
P = 0.001.
maturation in 222 children who participated in long-
term treatment of DBD with risperidone [18]. After
12 months, there was no inhibition of the expected
growth (National Health and Nutrition Examination
Survey data and growth velocity charts), nor was there
at 6 months, 8.2 kg at 12 months;

any delay in sexual maturation as assessed by Tanner


in patients aged 13–16, 4.2 and
in patients aged 8–12, 3.8 kg

staging, with risperidone. However, additional data


)1.04 kg no antipsychotic

are needed to confirm the long-term safety of the


Range )4.0 to + 15.3 kg
risperidone than placebo
Weight gain higher with

+2.8 kg after 2 months


+5.8 kg after 6 months

atypical antipsychotics during pubertal development.


+3.03 kg neuroleptic
+8.64 kg risperidone
8.4 kg, respectively

Antipsychotic treatment has also been linked to


Change in weight

hyperprolactinaemia. A survey of prolactin levels at


(P < 0.0001)

baseline and after 6 weeks of treatment in children


Mean gain

and adolescents (mean age 14.1 years) showed ele-


vations with both atypical and typical antipsychotics
[70]. Prolactin increase was significantly higher with
haloperidol (mean: 47.8 ng/ml) compared with ola-
nzapine (23.7 ng/ml) or clozapine (mean: 11.2 ng/ml;
agitation, or self-injurious
Autism with aggression,
or property destruction

P < 0.001). Prolactin levels with treatment exceeded


aggression, self-injury,

Adolescent inpatients

behaviour (8.6 years)

the upper limit of normal in 90% of the patients


PDD with severe
Inclusion criteria

treated with haloperidol, 70% treated with olanzapine,


(13.4 years)

(14.1 years)
(mean age)

and in none treated with clozapine. A follow-up


extension to this study similarly found significant
prolactin elevation after 6 weeks of treatment with
Table 6 Weight change with atypical antipsychotics in paediatric patients

haloperidol or olanzapine (P < 0.01), but not cloza-


pine [2]. Post-hoc analysis from five large prospective
BMI = body mass index; PDD = pervasive developmental disorder
no antipsychotic (19)

clinical trials including a total of 592 children with


Mean daily dose (n)

antipsychotics (23),

DBD and subaverage intelligence demonstrated that,


Risperidone (18),

Risperidone (63)
crossover study

despite hyperprolactinaemia associated with the first


placebo (15),
Risperidone
1 mg (11),

4–8 weeks of risperidone treatment, prolactin levels


tended to normalize by 1 year of treatment [21].
Adverse events potentially related to prolactin were
reported in 4.9% (most commonly gynaecomastia in
males, seen in 3.7%). One of the limitations of this
6 months

6 months
50 weeks
Duration

study, however, was that there was no long-term


control group to show the incidence of gynaecomastia
that would occur normally in such a population.
Interestingly, prolactin elevation did not correlate
Double-blind studies

with these side-effects, nor was there any correlation


Hellings et al. [30]

Open-label studies

Martin et al. [43]

between dose, prolactin level, and adverse events


Kelly et al. [32]

potentially related to prolactin. Although this post-


hoc analysis suggested that hyperprolactinaemia can
Study

be transitory, long-term awareness is required and


additional studies are warranted.
116 European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry (2007) Vol. 16, No. 2
 Steinkopff Verlag 2006

Cognitive adverse events were infrequently re- olanzapine, and risperidone for psychotic disorders;
ported with atypical antipsychotics. Although cogni- and with quetiapine for mania. A recent international
tive deficits do not improve in adult patients with expert panel recommended risperidone as the medi-
schizophrenia receiving conventional antipsychotics, cation treatment of choice for conduct disorder be-
it has been reported that they can improve with cause of demonstrated efficacy in this population and
atypical antipsychotics [47]. Verbal learning and good tolerability [38]. It has been reported that ris-
continuous performance tasks showed improvements peridone has a favourable risk/benefit profile when
with risperidone in two large open-label studies of combined with methylphenidate for the treatment of
children with DBD [15, 20]. Additional studies mea- attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, which is fre-
suring cognitive changes and academic performance quently comorbid with DBD [3, 38]. However, ris-
in paediatric patients are needed. peridone is currently approved only for DBD
Serious adverse events have been reported with treatment in several countries and in few countries for
atypicals, including clozapine, olanzapine and zipr- the treatment of autism. For the other indications
asidone. Particularly troublesome are the haemato- mentioned in this review, more data are needed. In
logical adverse events associated with clozapine preliminary studies, however, atypical antipsychotics
treatment. A recent retrospective study reported have been shown in both double-blind and open-label
neutropenia (absolute neutrophil count <1,500/mm) studies to reduce a variety of disabling psychiatric
in 13% (23/172) and agranulocytosis (absolute neu- symptoms in children and adolescents.
trophil count <500/mm) in 0.6% (1/172) of the hos- The most common adverse events in paediatric
pitalized psychiatrically ill children treated with patients documented for treatment with risperidone,
clozapine and observed for 8 months [26]. Similarly, clozapine, or olanzapine in both short- and long-term
serious electrocardiographical changes have been re- studies include somnolence and weight gain, whereas
ported with low-dose ziprasidone (£40 mg/day) there are few data for ziprasidone and quetiapine.
among paediatric outpatients treated up to 6 months: Serious haematalogical adverse events have been re-
the mean QTc prolongation was 28 ± 26 ms, with ported with clozapine. There is evidence that treat-
three patients reaching 450 ms and 1 subject experi- ment with ziprasidone can result in serious
encing a 114 ms prolongation [9]. electrocardiographical changes that are known to be
associated with increased risk of arrhythmia and
sudden death. Data on rare adverse events should be
Discussion considered preliminary because of the lack of long-
term studies designed to systematically investigate all
Ideally, children and adolescents with DBDs, PDDs, or possible adverse events that extend beyond 1 year.
tic disorders would be managed with nonpharmaco- Weight gain is regarded as a class effect, although a
logical therapy alone to minimize the occurrence of recent review of the literature showed that it was more
adverse events. However, when symptoms are severe, substantial with clozapine or olanzapine, moderate
fail to respond to behavioural interventions, and with risperidone or quetiapine, and low with zipr-
interfere with social, family, or academic functioning, asidone [66]. Evaluating weight change in children
medications are often recommended. Thus, proper must take into account expected weight changes
diagnostic assessment is important in order to identify associated with normal growth, and thus comparative
an appropriate medication treatment course for pae- trials versus typical antipsychotics or placebo are
diatric patients with DBDs, PDDs, or tic disorders. useful to understand the magnitude of weight change
However, for paediatric psychotic disorders or acute associated with use of atypical antipsychotics. Limited
mania in paediatric bipolar disorder, medication is the data are available in children and adolescents
first line strategy and early pharmacological interven- regarding the risk of obesity and the associated
tion is important with regard to prognosis. Atypical cluster of metabolic adverse events, e.g. the metabolic
antipsychotics might be considered because of their syndrome and diabetes, when atypical antipsychotics
documented efficacy in both double-blind and open- are given. However, the consensus on antipsychotic
label studies and low incidence of EPS. As noted above, drugs and obesity and diabetes recently published by
a number of double-blind and open-label studies have the American Diabetes Association in collaboration
demonstrated rapid efficacy in combination with with the American Psychiatric Association [5] rec-
favourable short- and long-term tolerability of atypical ommends closely monitoring patients’ weight at reg-
antipsychotics for treating a broad spectrum of psy- ular intervals and providing nutrition and physical
chiatric disorders in children and adolescents. activity counselling to both patients and caregivers. It
Double-blind clinical trials have been conducted is recommended that if an adult patient gains ‡5% of
with risperidone for DBD and PDD; with risperidone his/her initial weight, therapy should be re-evaluated
and ziprasidone for tic disorders; with clozapine, [5]. This value, however, is possibly not specific en-
P. Jenson et al. 117
Paediatric Atypical Review

ough for the paediatric population. Current guidelines limited to the published peer-reviewed literature. A
indicate that children or adolescents who are over- more exhaustive review might have included unpub-
weight (body mass index 85th percentile for age and lished data or abstracts from conferences. However,
sex) and have family history of diabetes in a first- or the inclusion of unpublished data could have biased
second-degree relative are at increased risk to develop the findings, since not all published data are readily
diabetes [1]. An analysis of the cases of hyperglyca- accessible and such studies are not invariably of suf-
emia reported to the US Food and Drug Administra- ficiently high quality to warrant publication. While
tion MedWatch drug surveillance system in patients the inclusion of other databases (such as the Coch-
younger than 19 years identified an increased number rane Reviews) could have been done, Medline and
of cases (compared with the background rate) in pa- EMBASE are principal sources for the world’s litera-
tients treated with clozapine, but not olanzapine [34]. ture of controlled clinical trials in high quality peer-
A more recent query of MedWatch relating to chil- reviewed journals, and would be unlikely to change
dren treated with risperidone identified 12 cases of the findings reported here.
diabetes-associated adverse events between 1993 and To allow for comparisons of efficacy, we report
2002, but the relative rate was not reported [35]. effect sizes where placebo-controlled double-blind
Certain ethnic groups carry an increased risk of dia- studies were available for review. Caution is required,
betes and metabolic adverse effects, e.g. African however, when interpreting effect sizes across studies,
American, Hispanic, Asian Islander, because of ge- because differences in dosing, duration of studies, and
netic predisposition to insulin resistance [1]. These sample characteristics could have influenced the
patients may require extra caution when treated with medication vs. placebo differences.
atypical antipsychotics.
Other, less frequent adverse events that should
nonetheless be closely monitored include EPS, hyper-
glycaemia and diabetes, and endocrine adverse events. Conclusion
While the initial TRAAY recommendations did not
suggest monitoring for glucose and lipids in patients at Significant psychiatric illness occurs in about 20% of
risk of development of diabetes [48], in light of the children. These psychiatric disorders lead to impaired
recent American Diabetes Association and American academic and social development, as well as increased
Psychiatric Association guidelines [5], it appears pru- societal costs. In patients with DBDs and PDD and
dent to consider that these same recommendations moderate-to-severe symptoms who have not ade-
might also apply to children and adolescents. quately responded to behavioural interventions or
Several long-term studies (>6 months) indicate primary disease therapies, it is apparent that atypical
that, at least with risperidone, there are no negative antipsychotics can effectively reduce disabling
effects of atypical antipsychotics on cognitive func- behaviours across a broad spectrum of common
tioning or growth and sexual maturation. In addition paediatric psychiatric disorders, with a growing lit-
to measuring cognitive development, future studies erature suggesting tolerability. Conversely, there is
using atypical antipsychotics in paediatric patients unmet need of controlled data to guide clinical
should also measure long-term academic and social practice with atypical antipsychotics for paediatric
development in treated children, as well as the need psychotic disorders and mania.
for long-term maintenance therapy. Pharmacoeco- There is growing evidence of the favourable risk/
nomic studies, measuring both treatment and societal benefit profile of risperidone, olanzapine, and quetia-
costs from paediatric psychiatric diseases, should also pine in both short- and long-term studies. Side-effects
be conducted. such as weight gain and endocrine side-effects have
The improved tolerability and safety profile com- been elucidated in clinical studies, but additional data
pared to their predecessors is one factor that has led are warranted to confirm the long-term safety of
to the increased use of the atypical antipsychotics in atypical antipsychotics during pubertal development
children and adolescents. However, caution is re- and the risk of metabolic abnormalities. Therefore,
quired because this population may be more suscep- endocrine side-effects and weight gain should be
tible to EPS and hyperprolactinaemia-related adverse carefully managed by the treating physician. Properly
events. While there have been some studies with designed studies should systematically assess the risk
duration up to 2 years, no definitive data are available for rare adverse events and tardive dyskinesia. The use
that suggest long-term safety, and additional studies of clozapine should be limited in children because of
are therefore warranted. the reported serious haematalogical adverse events.
Although we aimed to provide an extensive review Close electrographical monitoring is required when
of the available clinical trials with atypical antipsy- prescribing ziprasidone to children because of harm-
chotics in children and adolescents, our search was ful cardiac rhythm disturbances.
118 European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry (2007) Vol. 16, No. 2
 Steinkopff Verlag 2006

References
1. Alberti G, Zimmet P, Shaw J, Bloom- 10. Buitelaar JK (2000) Open-label treat- 21. Findling RL, Kusumakar V, Daneman
garden Z, Kaufman F, Silink M (2004) ment with risperidone of 26 psychiat- D, Moshang T, De Smedt D, Binder C
Type 2 diabetes in the young: the rically-hospitalized children and (2003) Prolactin levels during long-
evolving epidemic: the international adolescents with mixed diagnoses and term risperidone treatment in children
diabetes federation consensus work- aggressive behavior. J Child Adolesc and adolescents. J Clin Psychiatry
shop. Diabetes Care 27:1798–1811 Psychopharmacol 10:19–26 64:1362–1369
2. Alfaro CL, Wudarksy M, Nicolson R, 11. Buitelaar JK, van der Gaag, Cohen- 22. Frazier JA, Meyer MC, Biederman J,
Gochman P, Sporn A, Lenane M et al Kettenis P, Melman CT (2001) A ran- Wozniak J, Wilens TE, Spencer TJ et al
(2002) Correlation of antipsychotic and domized controlled trial of risperidone (1999) Risperidone treatment for juve-
prolactin concentrations in children in the treatment of aggression in hos- nile bipolar disorder: a retrospective
and adolescents acutely treated with pitalized adolescents with subaverage chart review. J Am Acad Child Adolesc
haloperidol, clozapine, or olanzapine. J cognitive abilities. J Clin Psychiatry Psychiatry 38:960–965
Child Adolesc Psychopharmacol 12:83– 62:239–248 23. Frazier JA, Biederman J, Tohen M,
91 12. Chakos M, Lieberman J, Hoffman E, Feldman PD, Jacobs TG, Toma V et al
3. Aman MG, Binder C, Turgay A (2004) Bradford D, Sheitman B (2001) Effec- (2001) A prospective open-label treat-
Risperidone effects in the presence/ tiveness of second-generation antipsy- ment trial of olanzapine monotherapy
absence of psychostimulant medication chotics in patients with treatment- in children and adolescents with bipo-
in children with ADHD, other disrup- resistant schizophrenia: a review and lar disorder. J Child Adolesc Psycho-
tive behavior disorders, and subaver- meta-analysis of randomized trials. Am pharmacol 11:239–250
age IQ. J Child Adolesc J Psychiatry 158:518–526 24. Gaffney GR, Perry PJ, Lund BC, Bever-
Psychopharmacol 14:243–254 13. Connor DF, Fletcher KE, Wood JS Stille KA, Arndt S, Kuperman S (2002)
4. Aman MG, De Smedt G, Derivan A, (2001) Neuroleptic-related dyskinesias Risperidone versus clonidine in the
Lyons B, Findling RL (2002) Double- in children and adolescents. J Clin treatment of children and adolescents
blind, placebo-controlled study of ris- Psychiatry 62:967–974 with Tourette’s Syndrome. J Am Acad
peridone for the treatment of disrup- 14. Correll CU, Leucht S, Kane JM (2004) Child Adolesc Psychiatry 41:330–336
tive behaviors in children with Lower risk for tardive dyskinesia 25. Gagliano A, Germano E, Pustorino G,
subaverage intelligence. Am J Psychia- associated with second-generation an- Impallomeni C, D’Arigo C, Calamoneri
try 159:1337–1346 tipsychotics: a systemic review of 1- F et al (2004) Risperidone treatment of
5. American Diabetes Association; Amer- year studies. Am J Psychiatry 161:414– children with autistic disorder: effec-
ican Psychiatric Association; American 425 tiveness, tolerability, and pharmacoki-
Association of Clinical Endocrinolo- 15. Croonenberghs J, Fegert JM, Findling netic implications. J Child Adolesc
gists; North American Association for RL, De Smedt G, Van Dongen S, and Psychopharmacol 14:39–47
the Study of Obesity (2004) Consensus the Risperidone Disruptive Behavior 26. Gerbino-Rosen G, Roofeh D, Tompkins
development conference on antipsy- Study Group (2005) J Am Acad Child DA, Feryo D, Nusser L, Kranzler H,
chotic drugs and obesity and diabetes. Adolesc Psychiatry 44:64–72 Napolitano B, Frederickson A, Hen-
Diabetes Care 27:596–601 16. Delbello MP, Schwiers ML, Rosenberg derson I, Rhinewine J, Kumra S (2005)
6. American Psychiatric Association HL, Strakowski SM (2002) A double- Hematological adverse events in
(1994) Diagnostic and statistical man- blind, randomized, placebo-controlled clozapine-treated children and adoles-
ual of mental disorders. 4edn. Wash- study of quetiapine as adjunctive cents. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psy-
ington, DC: American Psychiatric treatment for adolescent mania. J Am chiatry 44:1024–1031
Association Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 27. Gilbert DL, Batterson JR, Sethuraman
7. Biederman J, Mick E, Wozniak J, Ale- 41:1216–1223 G, Sallee FR (2004) Tic reduction with
ardi M, Spencer T, Faraone SV (2005) 17. Diler RS, Firat S, Avci A (2002) An risperidone versus pimozide in a ran-
An open-label trial of risperidone in open-label trial of risperidone in chil- domized, double-blind, crossover trial.
children and adolescents with biploar dren with autism. Curr Ther Res 63:91– J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry
disorder. J Child and Adolesc Psycho- 102 43:206–214
pharmacol 15:311–317 18. Dunbar F, Daneman D (2004) Growth 28. Gothelf D, Apter A, Reidman J, Brand-
8. Biederman J, Mick E, Hammerness P, and sexual maturation during long Gothelf A, Bloch Y, Gal G et al (2003)
Harpold T, Aleardi M, Dougherty M, term treatment with risperidone. Am J Olanzapine, risperidone and haloperi-
Wozniak J (2005) Open-label, 8-week Psychiatry 161:918–920 dol in the treatment of adolescent pa-
trial of olanzapine and risperidone for 19. Findling RL, McNamara NK, Branicky tients with schizophrenia. J Neural
the treatment of bipolar disorder in LA, Schluchter MD, Lemon E, Blumer Transm 110:545–560
preschool-age children. Biol Psychiatry JL (2000) A double-blind pilot study of 29. Greene RW, Biederman J, Zerwas S,
58:589–594 risperidone in the treatment of conduct Monuteaux MC, Goring JC, Faraone SV
9. Blair J, Scahill L, State M, Martin A disorder. J Am Acad Child Adolesc (2002) Psychiatric comorbidity, family
(2005) Electrocardiographic changes in Psychiatry 39:509–516 dysfunction, and social impairment in
children and adolescents treated with 20. Findling RL, Aman MG, Eerdekens M, referred youth with oppositional defi-
ziprasidone: a prospective study. J Am Derivan A, Lyons B (2004) Long-term, ant disorder. Am J Psychiatry
Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 44:73– open-label study of risperidone in 159:1214–1224
79 children with severe disruptive behav-
iors and below-average IQ. Am J Psy-
chiatry 161:677–684
P. Jenson et al. 119
Paediatric Atypical Review

30. Hellings JA, Zarcone JR, Crandall K, 41. Lindsay RL, Leone S, Aman MG (2004) 51. Remschmidt H (2002) Early-onset
Wallace D, Schroeder SR (2001) Weight Discontinuation of risperidone and schizophrenia as a progressive-deteri-
gain in a controlled study of risperi- reversibility of weight gain in children orating developmental disorder: evi-
done in children, adolescents and with disruptive behavior disorders. dence from child psychiatry. J Neural
adults with mental retardation and Clin Pediatr 43:437–444 Transm 109:101–117
autism. J Child Adolesc Psychophar- 42. Malone RP, Maislin G, Choudhury MS, 52. Remschmidt H, Hennighausen K,
macol 11:229–238 Gifford C, Delaney MA (2002) Risperi- Clement HW, Heiser P, Schulz E (2000)
31. Jarbrink K, Fombonne E, Knapp M done treatment in children and ado- Atypical neuroleptics in child and
(2003) Measuring the parental, service lescents with autism: short- and long- adolescent psychiatry. Eur Child Ado-
and cost impacts of children with term safety and effectiveness. J Am lesc Psychiatry 9:9–19
autistic spectrum disorder: a pilot Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 41:140– 53. Remschmidt H, Schulz E, Martin PM
study. J Autism Develop Disord 147 (1994) An open trial of clozapine in
33:395–402 43. Martin A, Scahill L, Anderson GM, thirty-six adolescents with schizophre-
32. Kelly DL, Conley RR, Love RC, Horn Aman M, Arnold LE, McCracken J et al nia. J Child Adolesc Psychopharmacol
DS, Ushchak CM (1998) Weight gain in (2004) Weight and leptin changes 4:31–41
adolescents treated with risperidone among risperidone-treated youths with 54. Renouf AG, Kovacs M, Mukerji P
and conventional antipsychotics over autism: 6-month prospective data. Am (1997) Relationship of depressive,
six months. J Child Adolesc Psycho- J Psychiatry 161:1125–1127 conduct, and comorbid disorders and
pharmacol 8:151–159 44. Masi G, Cosenza A, Mucci M, Brove- social functioning in childhood. J Am
33. Kemner C, Willemsen-Swinkels SN, de dani P (2001) Open trial of risperidone Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 36:998–
Jonge M, Tuynman-Qua H, van Enge- in 24 young children with pervasive 1004
land H (2002) Open-label study of developmental disorders. J Am Acad 55. Reyes M, Olah R, Csaba K, Augustyns I,
olanzapine in children with pervasive Child Adolesc Psychiatry 40:1206–1214 Eerdekens M (2006) Long-term safety
developmental disorder. J Clin Psy- 45. McCracken JT, McGough J, Shah B, and efficacy of risperidone in children
chopharmacol 22:455–460 Cronin P, Hong D, Aman MG et al with disruptive behaviour disorder:
34. Koller E, Malozowski S, Doraiswamy (2002) Risperidone in children with Results of a 2-year extensive study. Eur
PM (2001) Atypical antipsychotic drugs autism and serious behavioral prob- Child and Adolesc Psychiatry 15:97–
and hyperglycemia in adolescents. lems. N Engl J Med 347:314–321 104
JAMA 286:2547–2548 46. McDougle CJ, Scahill L, Aman MG, 56. Reyes M, Buitelaar J, Toren P, Augus-
35. Koller EA, Cross JT, Schneider B (2004) McCracken JT, Tierney E, Davies M, tyns I, Eerdekens M (2006) A ran-
Risperidone-associated diabetes mell- Arnold LE, Posey DJ, Martin A, Ghu- domized, double-blind, placebo-
itus in children. Pediatrics 113:421–422 man JK, Shah B, Chuang SZ, Swiezy controlled study of risperidone main-
(author reply 421–422) NB, Gonzalez NM, Hollway J, Koenig K, tenance treatment in children and
36. Kranzler H, Roofeh D, Gerbino-Rosen McGough JJ, Ritz L, Vitiello B (2005) adolescents with disruptive behavior
G, Dombrowski C, McMeniman M, Risperidone for the core symptom do- disorders. Am J Psychiatry 163:402–410
DeThomas C, Frederickson A, Nusser mains of autism: results from the study 57. Ross RG, Novins D, Farley GK, Adler
L, Bienstock MD, Fisch GS, Kumra S by the Autism Network of the Research LE (2003) A 1-year open-label trial of
(2005) Clozapine: its impact on Units on Pediatric Psychopharmacol- olanzapine in school-age children with
aggressive behavior among children ogy. Am J Psychiatry 162:1142–1148 schizophrenia. J Child Adolesc Psy-
and adolescents with schizophrenia. J 47. Meltzer HY, McGurk SR (1999) The chopharmacol 13:301–309
Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry effects of clozapine, risperidone, and 58. RUPP (Research Units on Pediatric
44:55–63 olanzapine on cognitive function in Psychopharmacology) Autism Network
37. Kumra S, Frazier JA, Jacobsen LK, schizophrenia. Schizophr Bull 25:233– (2005) Risperidone treatment of autis-
McKenna K, Gordon CT, Lenane MC et 255 tic disorder: longer-term benefits and
al (1996) Childhood-onset schizophre- 48. Pappadopulos E, MacIntyre JC, Crim- blinded discontinuation after
nia: a double-blind clozapine-haloper- son ML, Findling RL, Malone RP, 6 months. Am J Psychiatry 162:1361–
idol comparison. Arch Gen Psychiatry Derivan A et al (2003) Treatment rec- 1369
53:1090–1097 ommendations for the use of antipsy- 59. Sallee FR, Kurlan R, Goetz CG, Singer
38. Kutcher S, Aman M, Brooks SJ, Bu- chotics for aggressive youth (TRAAY). H, Scahill L, Law G et al (2000) Zipr-
itelaar J, van Daalen E, Fegert J et al Part II. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psy- asidone treatment of children and
(2004) International consensus state- chiatry 42:145–161 adolescents with Tourette’s syndrome:
ment on attention-deficit/hyperactivity 49. Pavuluri MN, Henry DB, Carbray JA, a pilot study. J Am Acad Child Adolesc
disorder (ADHD) and disruptive Samson G, Naylor MW, Janicak PG Psychiatry 39:292–299
behavior disorders (DBDs): clinical (2004) Open-label prospective trial of 60. Scahill L, Leckman JF, Schultz RT,
implications and treatment practice risperidone in combination with lith- Katsovich L, Peterson BS (2003) A
suggestions. Eur Neuropsychopharma- ium or divalproex sodium in pediatric placebo-controlled trial of risperidone
col 14:11–28 mania. J Affect Disord 82(Suppl in Tourette syndrome. Neurology
39. Lewis R (1998) Typical and atypical 1):S103–S111 60:1130–1135
antipsychotics in adolescent schizo- 50. Ratzoni G, Gothelf D, Brand-Gothelf A, 61. Scott S, Knapp M, Henderson J, Mau-
phrenia: efficacy, tolerability, and dif- Reidman J, Kikinzon L, Gal G et al ghan B (2001) Financial cost of social
ferential sensitivity to extrapyramidal (2002) Weight gain associated with exclusion: follow up study of antisocial
symptoms. Can J Psychiatry 43:596– olanzapine and risperidone in adoles- children into adulthood. BMJ 323:191–
604 cent patients: a comparative prospec- 193
40. Lindenmayer JP, Nathan AM, Smith RC tive study. J Am Acad Child Adolesc
(2001) Hyperglycemia associated with Psychiatry 41:337–343
the use of atypical antipsychotics. J
Clin Psychiatry 62(Suppl 23):30–38
120 European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry (2007) Vol. 16, No. 2
 Steinkopff Verlag 2006

62. Shea S, Turgay A, Carroll A, Shulz M, 65. Soderstrom H, Rastam M, Gillberg C 68. Turgay A, Binder C, Snyder R, Fisman
Orlik H, Smith I, Dunbar F (2004) (2002) A clinical case series of six ex- S (2002) Long-term safety and efficacy
Risperidone in the treatment of dis- tremely aggressive youths treated with of risperidone for the treatment of
ruptive behavioral symptoms in chil- olanzapine. Eur Child Adolesc Psychi- disruptive behavior disorders in chil-
dren with autistic and other pervasive atry 11:138–141 dren with subaverage IQs. Pediatrics
developmental disorders. Pediatrics 66. Stigler KA, Potenza MN, Posey DJ, 110:e34
114:e634–e641 McDougle CJ (2004) Weight gain 69. van Bellinghen M, de Troch C (2001)
63. Sikich L, Hamer RM, Bashford RA, associated with atypical antipsychotic Risperidone in the treatment of
Sheitman BB, Lieberman JA (2004) A use in children and adolescents: prev- behavioral disturbances in children
pilot study of risperidone, olanzapine, alence, clinical relevance, and man- and adolescents with borderline intel-
and haloperidol in psychotic youth: a agement. Paediatr Drugs 6:33–44 lectual functioning: a double-blind,
double-blind, randomized, 8-week trial. 67. Troost PW, Lahuis BE, Steenhuis MP, placebo-controlled pilot trial. J Child
Neuropsychopharmacology 29:133–145 Ketelaars CE, Buitelaar JK, van Enge- Adolesc Psychiatry 11:5–13
64. Snyder R, Turgay A, Aman M, Binder land H, Scahill L, Minderaa RB, Hoek- 70. Wudarksy M, Nicolson R, Hamburger
C, Fisman S, Carroll A (2002) Effects of stra PJ (2005) Long-term effects of SD, Spechler L, Gochman P, Bedwell J
risperidone on conduct and disruptive risperidone in children with autism et al (1999) Elevated prolactin in pedi-
behavior disorders in children with spectrum disorders: a placebo discon- atric patients on typical and atypical
subaverage IQs. J Am Acad Child tinuation study. J Am Acad Child antipsychotics. J Child Adolesc Psy-
Adolesc Psychiatry 41:1026–1036 Adolesc Psychiatry 44:1137–1144 chopharmacol 9:239–245

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen