Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW 2
THE POLICE POWER
EMINENT
DOMAIN
Property
TAXATION
Only those
whose
property is
needed for
conversion to
public use
Imposed on
MOST people;
demands only
part of their
money as
their
contribution
of
government
upkeep.
Property
CHARACTERISTICS
MOST pervasive
LEAST limitable
MOST demanding
May be exercised as long as the activity
or the property sought to be regulated
has some relevance to the public
welfare.
Justifications
(subordination
of
individual benefit to the interest of the
greater number):
o Salus Populi Est Suprema Lex:
The welfare of the people shall
be the supreme law.
o Sic utere tuo ut alienum non
laedas: Use your own property
in such a way that you do not
injure other peoples rights.
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW 2
THE POLICE POWER
Based on the 2007 Edition of Constitutional Law 2 by Isagani Cruz
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW 2
THE POLICE POWER
Based on the 2007 Edition of Constitutional Law 2 by Isagani Cruz
Exclusive legislative discretion:
o Exercise of police power.
o To decide whether they should
act against a problem.
If they do: eh di okay.
If they dont: may not be
compelled by judicial
process. (Mandamus is
not a remedy)
The only remedy
against
legislative
inaction is a resort to the
bar of public opinion, a
refusal of the electorate
to return to the
legislature
members,
who in their view, have
been remiss in the
discharge of their duties
(I assume this means
dont vote for them lol)
o If the legislature decides to act,
the choices of measures or
remedies lie exclusively within its
discretion. Once determined, the
remedy cannot be attacked on
the grounds of it not being the
best suggested solution, lack of
wisdom,
impracticality,
inefficacy
or
immorality.
(Political question po ito)
o To ascertain facts on which the
power is based. Whatever it
decides is conclusive on the
courts.
If there is probable basis
for
sustaining
the
conclusion, its findings
are not subject to judicial
review.
Debatable
questions are for the
TESTS OF THE POLICE POWER
If the measures chosen are intrinsically
invalid, courts have the right and
obligation to declare them so.
1. The interests of the public generally, as
distinguished from those of a particular
class, require the exercise of the police
power (LAWFUL SUBJECT); and
2. The means employed are reasonably
necessary for the accomplishment of
the purpose and not unduly oppressive
upon individuals. (LAWFUL MEANS)
LAWFUL SUBJECT
(Welfare of the people is the supreme law)
The subject of the measure is within the
scope of the police power.
Activity or property sought to be
regulated affects public welfare.
OBJECT: Public welfare; SUBJECT OF
REGULATION must be related to the
object; then it is a lawful subject.
Taxicab Operators of Metro Manila v.
Board of Transportation (Old taxis case):
Taxicabs more than 6 years old must be
phased out as a police measure to
protect the public and promote their
comfort and convenience.
Velasco v. Villegas (Barbers and
massage case): The ordinance
preventing barber shops to massage
clients in a separate room prevents
immorality and enables the authorities
to properly assess license fees.
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW 2
THE POLICE POWER
Based on the 2007 Edition of Constitutional Law 2 by Isagani Cruz
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW 2
THE POLICE POWER
Based on the 2007 Edition of Constitutional Law 2 by Isagani Cruz