Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Chapter - 4
STANDARD MANUFACTURING QUALITY PLAN (MQP)
- GETCO
Mr. M. M. Goswami
- POWERGRID
Mr. Y. V. Joshi
- GECO
Mr. Krishnan
- Mahindra Intertrade
- ENPAY
Mr. Baghel
- ATSA Conductors
- Bharat Corrub
Mr. R S Thakkar
- GETCO
163
164
CHAPTER - 4
STANDARD MANUFACTURING QUALITY PLAN (MQP)
It is a contract document between customer and supplier to express commitment for delivery of transformer as per
agreed technical specification and match the type tested design.
Over a period of time as the transmission grid has grown leaps and bounds, with HVDC and 765 kV AC network,
this commitment document is gaining importance, because of rise in transformer failure rate and causing anxiety to
maintain uninterrupted supply for consumer and industry. Customer always wishes that transformer manufactured
and delivered must perform defect free service for its specified design life. It is always a challenge for supplier
(manufacturer) to keep consistency in material used and manufacturing process, which are the main cause for variation
in quality of transformer. While customer practically cannot monitor them and not expected to do so, manufacturers
are on their toes to offer cost competitive and cost effective product. The cost of material plays an important role,
considering the fact that majority of parts and components like bushing, OLTC, tank body, radiators, insulation, copper,
core material etc. are outsourced. The selection of material, its grades / type and design philosophy ultimately decide
the loss capitalization figures of final product. On the manufacturing process front, seamless integration of parts
/ components through mechanical and electrical design is the prerequisite. The change in sub-venders and skilled
manpower time to time at factory also require due diligence to control and maintain the consistency of manufacturing
process. Therefore a balanced view is needed to manufacture and deliver ideal Transformer meeting contract
specification and match type tested design.
It is evident from above background that there is need of mutually agreed manufacturing quality plan (MQP). Apart
from primary objective to have ideal transformer as per customer wish as explained above, the major benefit of MQP
would be timely delivery and any conflict shall be address upfront, so that manufacturing could take place uninterrupted
in a faithful manner. The role of design review is important to provide all necessary inputs for structuring the MQP.
It is proposed in this power transformer standardisation manual to have MQP covering following elements:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
It is equally very important that Transformer is manufactured in a dust free clean environment with humidity control.
Any compromise on this aspect will have adverse effect in expected design life of Transformer, however good is the
quality of material used.
Standard Manufacturing Quality Plan (MQP) has been designed in a manner to share the responsibility depending upon
the source of supply, testing, location and criticality of test for the performance of Transformer. Responsibility of subvendor is important for testing of raw material and components (P), but manufacturer has to play a role of verification
(V) as they have to integrate them for actual design of transformer. Similarly, responsibility of manufacturer is crucial
for routine tests (P) but customer has to actively witness (W) these tests to ensure that results are complying the
contract requirements and design review data.
165
Winding Conductor
(PICC)/ (CTC)/ Lead
wires
elongation
%
30 min
32 min
Bare conductor
Width /thick (mm)
Tolerance (in mm)
Up to 3.15
0.03
3.16 to 6.30
0.05
6.31 to 12.5
0.07
12.51 to 16
0.10
> 16 mm
0.10
Insulated conductor
Covering thick(mm)
Tolerance (%)
0.25 to 0.5
-10
0.51 to 1.25
-7.5
Over 1.25
-5
Acceptable Value
IS 7404
IS 13730
IS 7404
IS 13730
5. Hardness test
Performance
IS 7404
IS 13730
IS 13730
IS 1897
IS 13730
IS 7401
Reference /
Standard
IS 13730
One sample
per type per
lot
Sampling
rate
2. Resistivity at 20 deg.C
List of Tests
Item/Components
Sr.
No.
Sub
Vendor
Manufacturer
--
--
--
--
Customer
Category of Reponsibility*
166
POWER TRANSFORMER - STANDARDISATION MANUAL
Kraft Insulating
Paper
Performance
IEC 605543-1
IEC 605543-5
IEC
60554-2,
Methods of
Test
IS 7404
IS 13730
Reference /
Standard
Thikness (mm)
Over/Upto
Corner Radius(mm)
Up to 1.0
0.50
1.01 to 1.60
0.50
1.61 to 2.24
0.65
2.25 to 3.55
0.80
3.56 to 5.60
1.00
Acceptable Value
One sample
per type per
lot
Sampling
rate
4. Moisture Content
5. Tensile Index MD
6. Tensile Index CD
7. Elongation at Break MD
8. Elongation at Break CD
9. Electric Strength in Air
10. Ash Content
11. PH of Aqueous extract
12. Conductivity of Aqueous
extract
13.Air Permeability
14.Tear Index MD
15.Tear Index CMD
16. Water Absorption (Klemn
Method)
17.Heat Stability
a.) Reduction of Degree of
Polymerization
b.) Reduction of Bursting
Strength
c.) Increase of Conductivity of
Aqueous extract.
List of Tests
Item/Components
Sr.
No.
Manufacturer
Sub
Vendor
--
Customer
Category of Reponsibility*
167
CRGO Laminations
Performance
IS 3024
One sample
from
offered lot
IS 3024
IEC 60404
ASTM 4343
Each Lot
One sample
per lot
Acceptable Value
Reference /
Standard
Sampling
rate
2. Cutting Burr
3. Bend / Ductility test
4. Surface insulation resistivity check
List of Tests
Item/Components
Sr.
No.
--
Manufacturer
Sub
Vendor
--
Customer
Category of Reponsibility*
168
POWER TRANSFORMER - STANDARDISATION MANUAL
Pre-compressed
Press Board
Performance
One sample
of each size
per lot
Sampling
rate
IEC 606413-1
IEC
60641-2,
Methods of
Test
Reference /
Standard
Acceptable Value
8. pH of aqueous extract
9.conductivity of aqueous extract
6. Mositure Content
7. Shrinkage MD, CD & PD
5. Oil Absorption
3. Compressibility C
List of Tests
Item/Components
Sr.
No.
Sub
Vendor
V
Manufacturer
V
Customer
Category of Reponsibility*
169
Permawood
Porcelain Bushings
(Hollow)
Polyster Resin
Impregnated Glass
Fibre Tape
Synthetic Rubber
Bonded Cork sheet
(SRBC)
Performance
IS 4253
IS 15208
Acceptable Value
One sample
per lot
Each lot
As per IS/
IEC
IS 2099
IS 3513
IS 1708
IS 1736
IS 1998
One sample
of each size
per lot
100%
Reference /
Standard
Sampling
rate
7. Compressibility
8. Recovery
9. Aging in Oil-Finish, Flexibility & change
in volume
10. Ph value
1. Visual Check
2. Verification of shelf life
3. Thickness
4. Width
5. Tensile Strength
6. Resin Content
7. Softening point of resin
List of Tests
Item/Components
Sr.
No.
Sub
Vendor
Manufacturer
--
--
--
--
Customer
Category of Reponsibility*
170
POWER TRANSFORMER - STANDARDISATION MANUAL
Condenser Bushing
Buchholz Relay
Bimetallic Terminal
Connector
Marshalling Box
Remote Tap
Changer Control
Cabinet
10
11
12
13
Performance
1. Dimensional
2. Visual check
3. Tensile strength
4. Resistance
IS 3637
100%
100%
100%
Acceptable Value
Approved
drawing
and specification
Approved
drawing
and specification
IS 5561
IS 2099
IEC 60137
100%
100%
Reference /
Standard
Sampling
rate
Routine Test
(1) Measurement of dilectric dissipation
factor and capacitance
(2) Dry power frequency voltage withstand
test
(3) Measurement of partial discharge
(4) Pressure test
(5) Tightness test
(6) Creepage distance
(7) Visual & dimensional check
List of Tests
Item/Components
Sr.
No.
--
--
--
--
W
----W
W
P
V
V
V
V
V
V
Customer
Manufacturer
Sub
Vendor
Category of Reponsibility*
171
Roller Assembly
Pressure Relief
Device
Valves
Transformer Oil
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
Performance
100%
IS 335
IEC 60296
IS 778
--
IS 2500
100%
100%
--
100%
IS 8500
One sample
per melt/
heat
treatment
batch
Acceptable Value
Reference /
Standard
IS 3400
100%
Sampling
rate
List of Tests
Item/Components
Sr.
No.
Manufacturer
Sub
Vendor
--
--
--
--
--
--
Customer
Category of Reponsibility*
172
POWER TRANSFORMER - STANDARDISATION MANUAL
Radiators
OLTC
21
22
23
Performance
100%
100%
one per
design
CBIP
manual
2013
100%
1. No welding defect
2. Free from surface defect
5. Paint thickness
Outside: 155 micron
Inside : 30 micron
No peel-off
4. No leakage
Acceptable Value
IEC 60214
IEEMA
standard
CBIP
manual
2013
Reference /
Standard
Sampling
rate
List of Tests
Item/Components
Sr.
No.
Manufacturer
Sub
Vendor
--
Customer
Category of Reponsibility*
173
Cooling Fans
Nitrile Rubber
Gasket
Bushing CT
Remote
Temperature
detector
Oil pump
24
25
26
27
28
Performance
2. HV test
3. Oil pressure test
4. Locked rotor test
1. No load test
IS 2705
100%
100%
1. Within tolerance
2. 70 5 IRHD
3. 12.5 N/mm2 min
4. 20% max
5. 250% min
6. Max change in harness - 10 IRHD
7. Change in weight - 5 to 8.5%
Change in thickness - 4% max
Change in width & length - 0.2% max
Acceptable Value
--
--
BS 2751
1 sample/
Lot
100%
IS 2312
Reference /
Standard
100%
Sampling
rate
1. HV test
2. Calliberation accuracy check
3. IR value
1. Dimensions
2. Verification of terminal
marking & polarity
3. Overvoltage inter-turn test
4. Determination of error
5. HV Test
1.Dimensions
2.Shore Hardness
3.Tensile Strength
4.Compression set test
5. Elongation at break
6. Accelerated aging in air
7. Accelerated aging in oil
List of Tests
Item/Components
Sr.
No.
Manufacturer
Sub
Vendor
--
--
--
--
Customer
Category of Reponsibility*
174
POWER TRANSFORMER - STANDARDISATION MANUAL
One sample of
each type
One sample of
each type
One sample of
each type
Dimensional check
Edge bow
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
Core Diameter
Rectangularity of Core
Assembly
Leaning of Core
Earthing of Core
100%
100%
Winding
100%
Visual check
Core Building
One sample of
each type
Visual check
Sampling rate
Item/Process
Sr.
No.
As per specification
Design drawing
Design drawing
Design drawing
Design drawing
Design drawing
Design drawing
--
IS 3024
--
--
--
Reference / Standard
Proper connection
No leaning
As per design
As per design
As per design
As per IS 3024
Acceptable Value
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
Sub Vendor
Manufacturer
Customer
Category of Reponsibility*
175
100%
100%
Continuity test
Inter-turn Insulation
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
Ratio test
Alignment of Spacers/Blocks
HV test
Performance
100%
100%
Mfgrs standard
--
Aligned
As per design
As per design
As per design
No breaking of continuity
As per design
As per design
As per design
As per approval
As per approval
Acceptable Value
--
--
--
--
--
100%
Insulation arrangement
100%
Customer approval
--
Reference / Standard
100%
Dimensional checks
i) Outer diameter
ii) Inner diameter
iii) Unshrunk height
iv) Radial thickness
100%
Sampling rate
Nos of discs
No of turns / disc
Item/Process
Sr.
No.
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
Sub Vendor
Manufacturer
Customer
Category of Reponsibility*
176
POWER TRANSFORMER - STANDARDISATION MANUAL
100%
100%
100%
100%
Ratio test
100%
100%
100%
Dimensions
Pressure test
Vacuum test
100%
Performance
100%
Drying
100%
Thickness of walls
Tank
100%
100%
Sampling rate
Item/Process
Sr.
No.
Manufacturer standard
Manufacturer standard
As per CBIP
As per CBIP
As per design
Assembly tightness
As per design
As per design
Manufacturer standard
Acceptable Value
--
--
Manufacturer standard
Reference / Standard
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
Sub Vendor
Manufacturer
---
Customer
Category of Reponsibility*
177
100%
100%
100%
Impregnation process
Performance
As per specification
100%
2 kV HV test between
(i) Core & end frame
(ii) Core & yoke bolts
(iii) End frame and yoke bolts
100%
Manufacturer standard
Manufacturer standard
As per specification
Manufacturer standard
100%
Reference / Standard
Sampling rate
Item/Process
Sr.
No.
Manufacturer standard
As per specification
As per design
Shall be clean.
Acceptable Value
--
--
--
--
--
--
Sub Vendor
Manufacturer
---
---
---
Customer
Category of Reponsibility*
178
POWER TRANSFORMER - STANDARDISATION MANUAL
SFRA test
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Acceptable Value
Reference / Standard
100%
Sampling rate
Performance
Routine Tests
Description of Test
Test
Sr. No.
W
W
W
P
P
P
Customer
Manufacturer
Category of Reponsibility*
179
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Tests on OLTC
Reference / Standard
IEC 60214
CBIP manual
Acceptable Value
As per standards
As per standards
Permanent
deflection within
limit as per length
of plate used.
As per standards
As per standards
0.5 % max
Performance
Type Tests
19
18
Sampling rate
Description of Test
Test
Sr. No.
Customer
Manufacturer
Category of Reponsibility*
180
POWER TRANSFORMER - STANDARDISATION MANUAL
Bushings
Conservator tank
Transformer oil
10
11
Performance
Radiators
Acceptable Value
IS:5561
--
--
Reference / Standard
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
Sampling rate
Description of Test
Manufacturers Standard
Test
Manufacturers Standard
Manufacturers
Standard
Sr. No.
--------
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
--
--
--
--
--
Customer
Manufacturer
Category of Reponsibility*
181
182