Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
REQUIREMENTS OF MAN
JAMES A. HALSTED
and
M. ISABEL
IRWIN
Nutrition Institute
Agricultural Research Service
United States Department of Agriculture
Beltsvie,Maryland 20705
(Pages 345-378)
THE JOURNAL
OF NUTRITION
VOLUME 104,
3, MARCH 1974
NUMBER
TABLE OF CONTENTS
347
347
348
348
348
348
349
350
350
350
351
352
352
352
352
352
352
352
354
354
354
355
356
357
357
359
359
359
359
360
360
360
360
361
361
361
361
362
363
364
365
367
368
368
Introduction
Zinc in nature
Development of knowledge about zinc
Early discovery-uses in metallurgy
Chemistry
Biological essentiality
Biological functions
Methods of measuring zinc
Zinc in food
Content in classes of foods
Content of typical meals or diets
Factors influencing content
Manufacturing techniques
Preparation of foods
Metabolic aspects of zinc in human nutrition
Distribution in the body
Plasma and serum
Red blood cells
Leucocytes
Hair
Absorption of zinc
Availability of zinc
Excretion of zinc
Binding of zinc to serum protein
Factors influencing the concentration of zinc in plasma ....
Relationship of zinc to endocrine functions
Interrelationships with other minerals
Calcium
Cadmium
Copper
Others
Interrelationships with vitamins
Vitamin A
Vitamin D
Riboflavin
Zinc deficiency
Animals
Manclinical and metabolic features
Parameters for assessing zinc status in man
Zinc toxicity
Human requirements for zinc
Conclusions
Acknowledgments
Literature cited .
INTRODUCTION
348
J. A. HALSTED,
Cliemistry
Zinc has an atomic number of 30 and an
atomic weight of 65.4. It has a relatively
low melting point of 419.Fifteen isotopes
of zinc have been described ranging from
80Zn to 72Zn. Ten of these isotopes are not
stable. Their half-lives vary from 1.48
minutes (61Zn) to 245 days (8SZn) (98).
Metallic zinc is a good reducing agent, is
amphoteric and will dissolve in mineral
acids and strong bases. Zinc exists in solu
tion only in the oxidized state of Zn2t. The
soluble salts of zinc include chloride, bro
mide, iodide, formate, acetate, sulfate, and
Biological essentiality
Over 100 years ago (1869) Raulin (236),
a pupil of Pasteur, discovered that zinc was
indispensable for the growth of a black
bread mold, Aspergillus niger. This finding
was confirmed in 1911, 40 years later, by
Bertrand and Javillier (16). According to
Bertrand and de Wolf ( 12-15 ) Aspergillus
niger requires zinc in order to synthesize
phenylalanine, tryptophan, and tyrosine as
well as several enzymes. Growth of penicil
lin-producing fungi is greatly retarded by
zinc deficiency of the culture medium ( 60 ).
Evidence indicating that zinc is essential to
the growth of microorganisms has been
summarized recently (330 ).
In 1919 Birckner ( 18 ) reported that egg
yolk, human milk, and cow's milk con
tained zinc and suggested that zinc was of
nutritive value. Shortly thereafter, Sommer
and Lipman (278) demonstrated that zinc
was essential for plant life. Lutz (137)
noted that there had been reports from
time to time indicating that zinc was a
common and nearly universal constituent
of animal as well as plant tissues. He em
phasized
zinc wasnotnotgreatly
present
"traces" butthatin amounts
differin
ent from that found for other heavy metals
such as iron. Analyses of many foods at
that time showed amounts somewhat
greater than in present day analyses, pre
sumably the result of contamination of
samples and less precise analytical methods
than those used at present. After extensive
and meticulous analyses of tissues from
rats, cats, and man, Lutz (137) calculated
that the human body contained a total of
2.2 g of zinc, an amount about half that of
iron. This value has been widely quoted.
The only other similar work is that of
Widdowson et al. (325), who reported
human body zinc content to be between
1.4 and 2.3 g.
Some plant diseases have been traced to
zinc deficiency, such as leaf rosette in
349
350
METHODS
OF MEASURING
ZINC
TABLE 1
Zinc contents of selected foods1
Food item
Meat products
Roast beef
Beef patty (raw)
Chicken breast
Chicken thigh
Dairy products
Milk
Cream (half and half)
Zinc
ma/100 g
(wet wt)
6.4
4.7
1.1
2.8
o.:
OF MAN
351
0.40
352
RESEARCH
ON ZINC REQUIREMENTS
v.S
'SN
opM
to
10-H-H
*
T)<
r-!
OF MAN
(N
-H-HrHoo-H -H
'S-aoBII<'agoW4g.3
toto
m
t^oiro
o
o t^.
moo oo *
pC" p
co
CO5-H
CO
"-^
-H-Hoooo -H
-!0
io
001/3
1^
O>
00t-H
C
CO
353
e;
C*
-t
"O
-f
G5
IO
r-tssss
s
Ooi CC-iO
00
i>
t-HlC^
i-
oooo
COO1-1
CO O: CO
1-t-H-H-H
3Normao-a"1iiNo
1^<M
O O
-H
-H-HC5
-H-H
00oooot^co
O t^ ^H
1^. Ci
C^l
t-S
tOOO
IN
cooo11COCOCOiO
toto
r-
S's
11l-l
-s-
?" 3
"
Sjl'1yScTg'SMIOgntao
coo
Ja
t^
o ci oo * t^ tu
ot
1SS'-Ncig;of
1
T
1
rH i
-ffiffi'"""'
S
00 2 2S02 00 (NINIM
cctOtOcoto
-r-rx*i
i
^^*
cocoto
^*~r*~-aTaT"*
-crof^^Ci
2-2!.TP
COCOtO
S2-G.
fTSE"^COCOWCOOOf,
^
i-HdOO(NC'IOpC'ii-Hjj,^
t^-COOOr-H'4<t-Lt-LJ5rH<^
OOtC
C-ICOOO
i*OCSr-l
lOCO'N
i 1
*-H
i t.3
$t
5^
^* 'o
SIlliilll1-1!111!!igja3Mked
G) o)
"SS^O
^
dlu^
valuH.sIt00lo-5a*oioA\fsMmoODH
mean
&5i"gSe
354
J. A. HALSTED,
Investigator
Reference
Year
Mean SD
Range
Not
Method
WolffVikbladhBerfenstamKoch
al.Vallee
et
al.SmitFuwa
et
al.Gofman
et
al.Butt et
al.Prasad
et
al.Kahn et
al.Sullivan
et
LankfordOlehy
&
al.Helwig
et
al.Parkeret
al.Rosneret
GorfienHalsted
&
al.Mahanand
et
al.Davies et
al.Halsted
et
malesand
for
femalesNewborn,
2(P)12023(P)12119(S)13929(S)122
1255Males,
2955 121
adultsAdults39
3(8)98
2(S)5140
6(S)510414(P)103
adults170
adults64
9(P)84
30(8)9412(S)93
5(P)9117(S)9010(S)13813(P)9613(P)94
adults23
adultsChildren,
(P)9513(P)9612(P)12020(S)92
SmithSinha
&
TABLE 3
Plasma or serum tine concentration in normal adults1
(ng/100 ml)
10815Males,
13Females,
95
1611Children,
8913Males,
9613Females,
9711100
18100
males 121
GabrieliMeret
&
1182145
females
3(S)696
90337
females
HankinLindeman
&
3Males,
males 94
96Females,
(P)119(8)10217(S)84-16370-170101-13972-11287-23486-10276-12572-11576-16063-14768
al.Kurz
et
8811
1102137
adults
al.Pekarek
et
1281799
children
males
et al.(328)(311)(11)(122)(308)(272)(65)(67)(26)(229)(115)(292)(196)(92)(205)(255)(81)(143)(41)(85)(269)(156)(134)(125)(209)19501950
1 Zinc concentration has been found to be 16% higher in serum than in plasma in one study (21)8).
plasma.
4 A.A.S. ; atomic absorption spectrophotometry.
>SE.
! (S) ; serum.
RESEARCH
ON ZINC REQUIREMENTS
355
OF MAN
356
J. A. HALSTED,
ficiency was the basic cause of this dwarfism syndrome, it was logical to suspect that
Iranian clay might hinder zinc absorption.
Furthermore, when a solution of 6BZnwas
mixed with this clay, 97% of the radio
activity was removed from the solution.
When, however, Iranian clay was fed to
zinc-deficient rats, it proved to be a lifesaving source of zinc (274). A plausible
deduction, therefore, is that the subjects in
Iran may have sought zinc through the
ingestion of clay.
Chelating agents. Considerable work has
been reported on the effect of chelating
agents on zinc absorption. Most of these
studies were carried out in animals and
have been summarized by Vohra and
Kratzer (314) and Maddaiah et al. (141).
The ability of EDTA(ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid) to complex readily with zinc
has led to its use in removing radioactive
zinc from the body ( 279 ).
Vitamin D. Worker and Migicovsky (329)
found that the movement of zinc into the
bones of chicks was enhanced by vitamin
D. They effect
suggested
thatmetabolism
the site ofmight
the
vitamin's
on zinc
be "in the absorption mechanism." Later
Becker and Hoekstra (8) observed in
creased absorption of dietary zinc in rats
treated with vitamin D. Additional studies
with 65Zn convinced them that the in
creased absorption of zinc was not the pri
mary response but rather was the result of
an increased need for zinc secondary to in
creased skeletal growth.
Excretion of zinc
McCance and Widdowson (153) found
that regardless of whether zinc enters the
body orally or parenterally, it is excreted
almost wholly via the feces. Animal experi
ments have shown that fecal excretion is
chiefly by way of the pancreatic juice re
gardless of the route of zinc intake. Negli
gible amounts are excreted by the liver
into bile (153, 267). Urinary zinc excretion
in normal individuals and those with dis
eases was summarized by Roman (250).
In normal subjects, most of published
means ranged between 400 and 600 /g/24
hours.
Steele (284) recently reported data sug
gesting that renal handling of zinc is dif
ferent from that of other divalent cations.
357
358
359
nant disease. Ross et al. (256), using 65Zn establish more precisely the interrelation
in patients with neoplastic disease, found ships between zinc and endocrine function.
that uptake of zinc in leukemia leucocytes
Interrelationships with other minerals
was about one-half that of normal sub
Calcium. Tucker and Salmon (302) first
jects.
zinc content
ents inThe
Hodgkin's
disease of
hasblood
been constitu
reported
demonstrated that increasing the calcium
to be low (4). Davies et al. (42) and content of practical diets for swine en
Morgan (176) reported low plasma or hanced zinc-deficiency symptoms (skin
serum zinc levels in patients treated for lesions and growth retardation). Because
bronchogenic carcinoma. Smith et al. (275), the basal diets fed were relatively high in
however, found no differences in serum zinc, 34 to 44 ppm, this was an apparent
zinc levels between patients with untreated
demonstration of the antagonism of cal
bronchogenic carcinoma and normal con
cium to zinc. Numerous investigations with
trols. DeWys et al. (45) found that Walker swine using diets containing plant protein
256 sarcoma implanted in zinc-deficient
have confirmed the calcium-zinc antago
rats grew at a markedly reduced rate com
nism (35, 130, 131, 135, 136, 183, 286). In
pared with ones implanted in control, pair- contrast, when swine were fed animal pro
fed rats. These results suggest an increased
tein diets the deleterious effect of calcium
zinc requirement for tumor growth.
on zinc utilization was not demonstrable
The wide variety of pathological states
(10, 324). In 1960 (57) Forbes reviewed
in which plasma zinc concentration has the interrelationship of zinc and calcium.
been found to be depressed suggests that As pointed out by Forbes (58, 59) and
there may be several mechanisms involved more recently by O'Dell (192), the con
whereby zinc metabolism is altered in flicting results regarding the antagonistic
disease. On the other hand, there also may effect of calcium toward zinc can be ex
be a fundamental mechanism common to plained by the presence of phytate. That
all. It is attractive to speculate that zinc is is, excess calcium in the presence of phytate
required rapidly for enzyme formation or (which accompanies plant but not animal
protein synthesis when bodily insults occur, protein) results in decreased zinc absorp
and that the zinc that is loosely bound to tion, enhancing zinc deficiency. The inter
albumin is immediately available for these relationships of calcium, zinc, and phytic
purposes. Of interest is the fact that the acid in promoting growth of pigs are
zinc level rarely falls below 30 to 35% of shown in figure 1.'
the normal. This may correspond to that
It is doubtful whether the calcium an
amount loosely bound to albumin.
tagonism to zinc absorption plays an im
portant role in a well-balanced diet con
Relationship of zinc to endocrine functions
taining animal protein. Spencer et al. (283)
Endocrine abnormalities in human zinc could not demonstrate a calcium-zinc an
deficiency have been studied only in cases tagonism in human subjects fed meat as a
of nutritional dwarfism reported from protein source when calcium was varied in
Egypt (34, 226). Somewhat ambiguous re
the diet tenfold. However, the antagonism
sults were obtained in assessing growth may be a factor in diets high in plant pro
hormone, gonadotropin, adrenocortical, and tein, i.e., beans, peas, and cereal grains.
testicular function. In human pregnancy,
Cadmium. Cadmium and zinc have sev
plasma zinc concentration is usually de
eral similar chemical properties, including
pressed to about two-thirds that of normal a usual coordination number of 4, tetra(114). In a study with rats, McBean et al. hedral configuration,
and isoelectronic
(151) confirmed the findings, previously valence shells. In 1957 Pafizek (204)
observed in women (82), that depression
showed that the destructive effect of in
of plasma zinc concentration occurs when jected cadmium upon testicular tissue
contraceptive hormones are fed. McBean could be alleviated by zinc, and suggested
et al. (151) found that the estrogen com
that the injury was due to interference with
ponent of the contraceptive compounds
was responsible for the plasma zinc lower
9 By permission of the author B. L. O'Dell and the
ing effect. Additional work is needed to publisher American Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
360
1Protein
600-Cn-
500-2
400-1
300-200-100-il1
CCP.A.,
added,%
1.4a,
1.5Zn,
%
ppm
S
C
C1.4
0
0
0 1.4nmiJ^i>ifiC
1.5 1.5 0.8 0.8 1.5
25 14 141414
114
Animals
In animals, zinc deficiency has been de
scribed in rats (300), mice (43), swine
(302),
chickens
(193),
turkeys
(124),
cattle (162), goats (167), lambs (200),
dogs (248), Japanese quail (62), rabbits
(69), squirrel monkeys
(138), hamsters
(20), and guinea pigs (152).
The signs and svmptoms
of zinc de
ficiency are markedly similar in different
animals. They include dermatitis,
emaci
ation, alopecia, ocular lesions, testicular
atrophy,
retarded
growth, and anorexia.
All of these conditions with the possible
exception of testicular lesions are reversed
by zinc supplementation
(6,161).
Malformations of embryos and/or fetuses
due to zinc deficiency were reported for a
number of species. Blamberg et al. (19)
reported gross malformations
involving the
brain, vertebrae, limbs, beak, and head of
chick embryos produced
from eggs laid
by zinc-deficient hens. Kienholz et al. (119)
confirmed these findings. Hurlev and coworkers (108-111)
demonstrated
congeni
tal malformations
in rat fetuses delivered
from zinc-deficient females. The malforma
tions included a high incidence of short or
missing mandibles, clubbed feet, fused or
missing digits, cleft palate, and brain ab
normalities. Related studies bv Apgar (3)
and Hurley and Swenerton (112) indicated
that female rats fed a zinc-deficient
diet
during pregnancy
cannot mobilize
zinc
from tissue stores in amounts sufficient to
supply the needs of normal fetal develop
ment. Swenerton
et al. (294) suggested
that the high incidence of gross congenital
malformations
resulting
from zinc defi
ciency may be caused by impaired DNA
synthesis. The evidence of a relationship
between
zinc deficiency
and congenital
malformations
in the rat was reviewed in
1967 (2). To our knowledge no congenital
malformations
due to zinc deficiency have
been reported in humans. It is of interest,
nevertheless, that a brother of one patient
with the dwarfism syndrome originally re
ported in 1961 (224) had pronounced bony
abnormalities
as well as extreme dwarfism.
361
362
TABLE 4
Zinc balance studies of adult Iranian villagers1'
Subject
number12345678910111213SexMMMFMMFMFMFMFAgeVr32253825354730302437224017Weightk
gaiakg/dayN.A.0.070.070.18-0.060.03N.A.0.240.080.210.250.300.
15.4%-6.7-9.712.413.014.923.125.226.528.829.330
From Reinhold et al. (240). ' AI! were sufficiently healthy
to carry out normal activities of a villager.
>Not available
Alean for a 6- to 7-day period during which intakes in food
andiosses in excreta were measured. The hospital diet provided
2 400 calories, 75 g of protein (15% from pulses, 21% from meat,
8%from bread, and 36% from milk and cheese), 80 to 120 e
of fat from butter and corn oil, 24.6 mg of zinc, 1,031 mg of
calcium, and 1,513 mg of phosphorus.
RESEARCH
ON ZINC REQUIREMENTS
363
OF MAN
364
J. A. HALSTED,
TABLE 5
Hair zinc concentration as reported by various investigators
zincppm2551396.41
InvestigatorEggletonReinhold
al.Strain
et
al.Eininians
et
al.KlevayMcBean
et
al.'MeanisD.
et
181
36.3'54 ZinconE.S.E.S.
62121
5s
10342 E.S.
120
5s163222127
49'17637l
19922'MethodDithizoneZincon
spectrography.
' A.A.S. ; atomic absorption spectrophotometry.
'Reference(48)(241)(290)(50)(121)(150)Mean
SE.Year193819661966196719701971E.S.;Subjects11
ZINC TOXICITY
adults19
Chinese
male adult Iranian villagers
20 male control adult subjects
Iran)10
(Shiraz,
zinc deficient Egyptian male dwarfs
16 to 20 years
8 zinc-treated dwarfs 16 to 20 years
12 normal Egyptians 27 to 40 years
E.S.A.A.S.A.A.S.A.A.S.A.A.S.emission
years12
6 normal Rochester residents 23 to 37
old31
healthy village children 11 years
years14
Panamanian males 6 to 10
normal adults (Washington, D. C.)
75 Iranian village children 6 to 12 years
(growth retarded)Hair
365
TABLE 6
Controlled studies on human requirements for zinc
SubjectsInfante
of
of
subjects10studies1
oldPreschool
5 to 8 days
oldSchool
3 to 6 years
368
13
children
oldAdolescentsNumber
7 to 12 years
0Xumber0Daily
Adults
men and women6164.9
intake10.20
retention1-0.85
1.19mg/kii3.80
to
to 0.08
mg/kg-2.70
3.390.5
to
5.874.6
to
daily
requirement10.300
to 0.307
(265)(51,
mg/kg6.2Reference(32)
to 9.2
to 3.8
13.85 to 18.35Daily 4.92 2.94Estimated
6.1
9.018.0to
to 14.1
to 22.0-0.8
0.0
-4.0 to 8.8
1.0to to 8.3(153.(153)
234)
(140)
366
RESEARCH
ON ZINC REQUIREMENTS
367
OF MAN
368
J. A. HALSTED,
CITED
--:^
';->-:-lits-s-
RESEARCH
ON ZINC REQUIREMENTS
OF MAN
309
370
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
68.
40.
J. A. HALSTED,
74.
76.
77.
78.
79.
80.
81.
82.
83.
84.
85.
90.
91.
92.
93.
94.
95.
96.
97.
98.
99.
100.
101.
(1966)
The crystal structure of insulin. II.
An investigation of rhombohedral zinc insulin
crystals and a report of other crystalline
forms. J. Molec. Biol. 16, 212-226.
Heller, V. G. & Burke, A. D.
(1927)
Toxicity of zinc. J. Biol. Chem. 74, 85-93.
Helman, E. Z., Wallick, D. K. & Reingold,
I. M. (1971)
Vacutainer contamination in
trace element studies. Clin. Chem. 17, 61.
Helwig, H. L., Hoffer, E. M., Thielen, W. C.,
Alcocer, A. E., Hotelling, D. R. & Rodgers,
W. H.
(1966)
Modified zinc analysis
method and serum and urinary zinc levels in
control subjects. Amer. J. Clin. Pathol. 45,
160-165.
Henkin, R. I. & Bradley, D. F.
(1970)
Hypogeusia corrected by Ni*+ and Zn**. Life
Sci. 9, 701-709.
Henkin, R. I., Graziadei, P. P. G. & Bradley,
D. F. ( 1969 ) The molecular basis of taste
and its disorders. Ann. Intern. Med. 71,
791-821.
Henkin, R. I., Schechter, P. J., Hoye, R. &
Mattem, C. F. T. (1971)
Idiopathic hypogeusia with dysgeusia, hyposmia, and dysosmia. A new syndrome. J. Amer. Med.
Ass. 217, 434-440.
Heth, D. A., Becker, W. M. & Hoekstra,
W. G. s (1966)
Effect of calcium, phos
phorus and zinc on zinc-65 absorption and
turnover in rats fed semipurified diets. J.
Nutr. 88, 331-337.
Hibbard, P. L. ( 1937) A dithizone method
for the measurement of small amounts of
zinc. Ind. Eng. Chem. 9, 127-131. Cited by:
Tribble, H. M. & Secular, F. I. (1954)
Zinc metabolism of young college women on
self-selected diets. J. Nutr. 52, 209-216.
Hicks, H. G. (I960)
The Radiochemistry
of Zinc. National Academy of Sciences, NRC
Pubi. no. N3015National Research Council,
Washington, D. C.
Hill, C. H., Matrone, G., Payne, W. L. &
Barber, C. W. ( 1963 ) In vivo interactions
of cadmium with copper, zinc and iron. J.
Nutr. 80, 227-235.
Hodgson, J. F., Allaway, W. H. & Lackman,
R. B. (1971)
Regional plant chemistry as
a reflection of environment. In: Environmen
tal Geochemistry in Health and Disease.
(Cannon, H. L. & Hopps, H. C., eds.), pp
57-72, The Geological Society of America
Memoir.
Hoefer, J. A., Miller, E. R., Ullrey, D. E.,
Ritche, H. D. & Luecke, R. W. ( 1960) In-
75.
371
372
J. A. HALSTED,
12p.
121.
122.
123.
124.
125.
126.
127.
128.
129.
130.
131.
132.
133.
134.
153.
154.
155.
156.
157.
158.
159.
160.
161.
162.
163.
164.
165.
166.
167.
168.
169.
373
374
170.
171.
172.
173.
174.
175.
177.
178.
179.
180.
181.
182.
183.
184.
185.
186.
204. Parizek, J.
(1957)
176.
J. A. HALSTED,
205.
206.
207.
208.
209.
211.
212.
213.
214.
215.
216.
217.
218.
219.
210.
375
37G
235.
236.
237.
238.
239.
241.
242.
243.
244.
245.
246.
247.
248.
249.
250.
252.
253.
254.
255.
256.
257.
258.
259.
260.
261.
262.
263.
240.
J. A. HALSTED,
377
I I H
I .
I 1M .
, > LILI
-,'
I ,
"
II.
378
J. A. HALSTED,