(12)

(19)

PETTY PATENT
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

(54)

Title
Apparatus to extend the range of human hearing to include the infrasonic and
ultrasonic frequency domains

(51)

(11) Application No. AU 200053477 B3

(10) Patent No. 733997

International Patent Classification(s)

H04R 003/00
H04R 017/00

(21)

Application No: 200053477

(43)

Publication Date:

2001.05.31

(43)

Publication Journal Date

Granted Journal Date

2001.05.31
2001.05.31

(71)

Applicant(s)
David John Collier

(72)

Inventor(s)
David John Collier

(74)

Agent/Attorney
David John Collier,GPO Box 1755,Canberra City,ACT 2601 Australia

(56)

Related Art
US 4629834
US 4839872

(22)

Application Date:

2000.08.18

Page Illof 1

ABSTRACT
An electronic apparatus which extends the range of human hearing to include the
infrasonic and ultrasonic frequency domains in air and water is disclosed.
The apparatus employs a piezoelectric transducer to convert infrasonic fluid pressure
waves, via a high impedance FET input circuit, into electrical signals which are
frequency filtered; amplified; digitised; frequency multiplied and transformed into
audible sine wave and visual outputs. Ultrasonic fluid pressure waves are converted into
electrical signals through a piezoelectric or electrostatic transducer; frequency filtered;
amplified; digitised; frequency divided and transformed into audible and visual outputs.
Provision is made for an external hydrophone connection, and for an internal or external
frequency meter.

Page 10of 11

CLAIMS
The claims defining the invention are as follows:1. An electronic apparatus which extends the range of human hearing to include both the
infrasonic and ultrasonic frequency domains in both air and water, substantially as
herein described with reference to accompanying drawings.
2. The apparatus of claim 1 in which there are visual indications of firstly the presence;
relative amplitude, and fundamental frequency of infrasonic fluid pressure waves, and
secondly the presence and relative amplitude of ultrasonic fluid pressure waves; also
in which there are auditory indications of the presence and fundamental frequency of
both infrasonic and ultrasonic fluid pressure waves, and lastly in which there is a
visual indication of the fundamental frequency of ultrasonic fluid pressure waves
when an optional frequency meter is incorporated into said apparatus or connected to
it.

2-

6Lit 704H_

22 i-I

fZ)

f.I.

BLOCK

D(A'YPANM

9fr

APPAR~ATUS.

Page 1 of 11

AUSTRALIA
Patents Act 1990
COMPLETE SPECIFICATION
PETTY PATENT
APPARATUS TO EXTEND THE RANGE OF HUMAN HEARING
TO INCLUDE THE INFRASONIC AND ULTRASONIC

FREQUENCY DOMAINS.

The following statement is a full description of this invention, including the best method
of performing it known to me.

Page 2 of 11

APPARATUS TO EXTEND THE RANGE OF HUMAN HEARING

TO INCLUDE THE INFRASONIC AND ULTRASONIC
FREQUENCY DOMAINS
The apparatus is an electronic apparatus which extends the range of human hearing to
include both the infrasonic and ultrasonic frequency domains in both air and water,
substantially as herein described with reference to accompanying drawings, Figs. 1, 2, 3,
&4.
The apparatus provides visual indications of firstly the presence; relative amplitude, and
fundamental frequency of infrasonic fluid pressure waves, and secondly the presence and
relative amplitude of ultrasonic fluid pressure waves; also auditory indications of the
presence and fundamental frequency of both infrasonic and ultrasonic fluid pressure
waves, and lastly a visual indication of the fundamental frequency of ultrasonic fluid
pressure waves when an optional frequency meter is incorporated into said apparatus or
connected to it.
The apparatus employs a piezoelectric transducer to convert infrasonic fluid pressure
waves, via a high impedance FET input circuit, into electrical signals which are
frequency filtered; amplified; digitised; frequency multiplied and transformed into
audible sine wave and visual outputs. Ultrasonic fluid pressure waves are converted into
electrical signals through a piezoelectric or electrostatic transducer; frequency filtered;
amplified; digitised; frequency divided and transformed into audible and visual outputs.
Provision is made for an external hydrophone connection, and for an internal or external
frequency meter. A hydrophone is simply connected instead of the piezoelectric or
electrostatic transducers described and indicated as T1 on Fig.2 and T2 on Fig.3: the
on both figures. A frequency meter is
connection points are shown as a small circled
connected in accordance with established electronics practice.
Description of infrasonic part of the apparatus.
Note:- all numbered references are to Fig.1 unless otherwise noted.
A readily available miniature piezo-electric speaker 1) on Fig.l'. designed to produce
audible sound waves in car alarms, greetings cards et cetera, is used as a transducer to
produce an electrical signal from infrasonic air pressure waves, i.e. in reverse of its
designed function and well outside the designed frequency range.
Said piezo-electric speaker is connected to a high impedance input circuit 2) employing
field-effect transistor (FET) input operational amplifiers. Said high impedance circuit
critically enables the efficient transduction of infrasound into an electrical signal through
said transducer by NOT placing a significant resistive load on said transducer, thus
preserving its low-frequency response.
Said high impedance circuit produces a maximum signal to noise ratio by an
instrumentation or differential amplifier circuit topology inherent to which is a high
common-mode rejection ratio (CMRR). Initial resistance/capacitance (RC) frequency

Page 3 of ll

filtering in said circuit also minimises interference from 50 or 60 Hz electromagnetic

power grid signals, and from most radio transmissions.
An automatic gain control (AGC) circuit
see also Fig. 2 for details, is set up as
follows: negative feedback from the output of said amplifier
is applied to a lightdependant resistor (LDR) through an operational amplifier or voltage follower and lightemitting diode (LED), the light from said LED falling upon said LDR. Said LDR is
connected between the inverting inputs of two input operational amplifiers, and its
dynamic resistance determines the amplification or voltage gain of the differential
amplifier 2) which includes said two operational amplifiers. Said feedback results in
stabilisation of the amplitude of the output of said differential amplifier
thus removing
the need for a species of volume control or signal attenuator in said high impedance
circuit.
Said amplifier 2) is also connected to a limiting amplifier 4) which has a frequency
response which includes the low frequencies of interest. Said limiting amplifier ensures
sufficient signal to drive a Schmitt trigger
Said trigger produces a fixed amplitude
square wave signal of fast rise time suitable for digital signal processing, and said trigger
is connected in turn to a phase-locked loop (PLL) frequency multiplier
Said
multiplier multiplies incoming frequencies by a factor of 32 such that a 10 Hz signal
becomes a 320 Hz signal.
Note:- other multiplication factors are also possible.

Said PLL frequency multiplier also acts as a sharp (theoretically infinite) cutoffbandpass signal frequency filter because a voltage-controlled oscillator (VCO) which is an
integral part of said multiplier has limits to its frequencies of oscillation set by the value
of two resistors labelled R3 and R4 respectively in Fig. 4.
A VCO frequency from 64 to 704 Hz automatically limits the signal frequency band to 2
to 22 Hz when the PLL multiplication factor is 32.
Notes:the VCO mentioned above oscillates at its minimum set frequency (64 Hz in this case) in the absence of
an incoming signal, which could confuse the user of the device described herein. A subsidiary onetransistor circuit provides an indication of a valid signal via a small LED indicator which lights when the
PLL is 'locked' on to a valid incoming signal. Another subsidiary circuit switches signals to both the
visual display 9) and output amplifier 8) 'on' or 'off' as appropriate, such that there are no invalid or
random outputs. These subsidiary circuits are not shown in Figs. 1 to 4 inclusive.
(ii) in a simpler manifestation of the apparatus the infrasonic PLL frequency multiplier and subsequent
circuitry can be replaced by a readily available integrated miniature piezo buzzer which is simply turned on
and off by the rectified signal from the Schmitt trigger, in time with these infrasonic half-cycles.

Said electrical signals are now of square and triangular wave form, irrespective of the
form of the original infrasonic signal.
Said multiplier is connected to a sinewave shaper 7) in which said triangular wave signals
are converted into an approximate sinewave form, closer in form to the original
infrasonic signal.
Said shaper is connected (via a subsidiary switching circuit) to an output amplifier 8)
which is connected to an internal loudspeaker 17) and/or to headphones 18).
The output of said amplifier 2) is also connected (via a subsidiary switching circuit) to a
visual display 9) which includes a LED bargraph display.

Page 4 of 1l

Note:- a liquid crystal display (LCD) can be used as an alternative.

Said display provides a visual indication of the presence of an infrasonic signal; of the
relative amplitude of said signal, and of the original frequency of said signal by means of
real-time fluctuation in light output or light reflection or light transmission.
Description of ultrasonic part of the apparatus.
A readily available piezo-electric transducer 10) used commonly in burglar alarms, in
proximity detectors and in electronic tape rules is connected to a low noise differential
amplifier 11) via a passive resistance/capacitance (RC) circuit which provides initial
band-pass frequency filtering.
Note:- an electret or condenser microphone may be used instead of a piezoelectric transducer. The
transducer used needs to be selected for a wide frequency response up to around 180 KHz, and the passive
RC circuit mentioned above may need to be modified to suit the frequency response of the particular
transducer used.

The automatic gain control (AGC) circuit 12) of this part of the apparatus works much as
described for the AGC circuit 3) in the infrasonic part of the apparatus; namely by taking
the output signal from the output of the differential amplifier 11) and feeding it back
through an AGC amplifier or voltage follower to an LED whose light output falls upon a
LDR connected to the amplifier 11). See Fig. 3 for details. The amplification factor or
gain of said amplifier is determined by the dynamic resistance value of this LDR because
the LDR is connected between two gain-determining terminals specified by the
manufacturer of said amplifier.
The effect of this negative feedback is to stabilise the amplitude of the signal from the
output of the amplifier 11).
The maximum frequency response of said AGC amplifier or voltage follower is designed
to be less than the lowest signal frequency of interest in order to assure a smooth or
delayed adjustment of the differential amplifier's gain.
The amplifier 11) is connected to a limiting amplifier 13) which ensures sufficient signal
to operate a Schmitt trigger 14). Said trigger is connected to a PLL bandpass filter (BPF)
labelled IC5 in Fig.3, whose frequency band or range is preset by resistors R1 and R2
in Fig.3.
Notes:(i)using a PLL in this way provides a more precise and sharper signal frequency cutoff than is obtained by
analogue active frequency filtering; it also provides for economy in component parts.
(ii)subsidiary circuits provide appropriate switching and valid signal indication as previously described for
the infrasonic part of the apparatus.

Said BPF 15) is connected to a digital frequency divider 16) which divides the digital
signal by a factor of 16, such that an inaudible 160 KHz signal becomes an audible
KHz signal when it is amplified in the output amplifier 8) and fed into a loudspeaker 17)
or into headphones 18).
Note:- other division factors are also possible in this part of the circuit.

The amplifier 11) is also connected to a visual display 9) (via a subsidiary switching
circuit), so that a visual indication of the presence and relative amplitude of an ultrasonic
signal is provided.

Page 5 of 11

Notes:it is not possible to sensibly display an ultrasonic frequency per se given the limited (audio) frequency
response of the display circuit and the limited 'flicker' response of human vision.
rising or falling frequency; relatively low or relatively
(ii) the original 'sense' or frequency spectrum
high frequency) is preserved with these digital methods of signal conversion. Those 'bat detectors' or 'gas
leak detectors', including the apparatus disclosed in US Patent 4,629,834, which use the frequency
heterodyne method of signal conversion invert the 'sense' as mentioned above, leading to some difficulty in
interpretation of the original signal or utterance.
(iii) the human ear is less able to discriminate actual waveform with higher audible frequencies, so that
waveform conversion of the digital squarewave obtained from the (ultrasonic) frequency divider 16) is less
important than it is with the digital squarewave normally obtained from the (infrasonic) PLL frequency
multiplier 6) previously described herein.
(iv) the apparatus can be used to detect ultrasonic or infrasonic utterances of animals or plants but is
designed for more general usage.
a digital or analogue frequency meter may be incorporated into the apparatus if an accurate frequency
readout is required, or a signal output connection may be provided for an external frequency meter.
(vi) subsidiary switching circuits detect and switch incoming infrasonic or ultrasonic signals as appropriate
so that visual and audible outputs are differentiated and valid.

Discussion of utility and novelty of apparatus.

Sound wave frequencies audible to humans are defined as extending from 20 Hz to
KHz inclusive.
1KHz 1,000 Hz.
Note that 1Hertz (Hz) 1 Cycle per second
Infrasound is generally and here defined as including those frequencies below 20 Hz,
extending down to decimals of 1 Hz.
Ultrasound is generally defined as including those frequencies above 20 KHz.
Both infrasound and ultrasound are therefore inaudible to humans, and thus generally
undetectable without instrumentation.
Infrasound is generated inter alia by large animals such as whales and elephants, also by
human activity. Associated with human activity are particular health and safety issues,
e.g. the 'sick building' phenomenon. This phenomenon has been associated with
electromagnetic radiation and inadequate air conditioning, but is also associated with
infrasound and resonant effects of such infrasound.
Short exposure to infrasound at high amplitude and particular frequency has reportedly
been shown to be lethal to humans in experiments conducted by the French (and probably
US) armies, Refer "The Sonic Weapon of Vladimir Gavreau" by Gerry Vassilatos on the
internet. In circa 1996 a patent for an 'infrasonic weapon' was granted to a Hungarian
inventor.
This begs the question of the exact significance of longer-term exposure to lower
amplitude infrasound in the environment. There is some knowledge in medical or
industrial circles of adverse health effects from longer term exposure to sub-lethal
amplitudes ofjnfrasound, e.g. lesions to bones and joints; cardiovascular disturbances;

Page 6 of 11

digestive tract disturbances -mentioned in the 'Vibrostop' internet website, copyright

1997.
Personal experience with the grain handling industry in Australia has shown that very
high levels of infrasound are generated by certain conveying equipment in normal usage:
possible effects of exposure to such energy appear not to be appreciated, and have not to
my knowledge been discussed in industry meetings. (What you can't hear can't hurt
you??).
It is highly likely that there are many sources of high amplitude infrasound in heavy
industry and to a lesser extent in the transport industry, including air transport. It is
reported that air defence forces restrict the flying time of fighter jet pilots due to the
adverse health effects ofinfrasound generated by jet aircraft or their engines. It is now
clear that 'Economy Passenger/DVT Syndrome' is most likely due to exposure to
infrasound generated by jet engines, and amplified in the resonant cavity of the fuselage.
There is now increasing use of infrasound, generated pneumatically (somewhat as in 'The
Sonic Weapon of Vladimir Gavreau'!) to clean bulk handling and storage facilities.
Neither Civilian Regulatory Agencies nor Trade Unions including the International
Labour Organisation appear to be sufficiently aware of the probable, or even inevitable,
health risks associated with exposure to infrasound. This is indicated by the apparent
relative absence of national or international Standards covering infrasound compared
with Standards covering sound and exposure to sound. For example, an internet search of
the USA and Australian Standards websites on 9 August 2000 revealed only one
Standard for infrasound, this being a frequency weighting scale for same. By contrast
there are many Standards for sound pressure meters; recommended maximum human
exposure to noise; specifications for the acoustics of buildings, et cetera.
Existing international Standards specify the
weighted curve for measurement of noise
levels, this curve being based on the normal frequency response of the human ear. This
curve extends from 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz so it excludes infrasound and ultrasound by
definition.
There appears to have been extensive research into infrasound in the Eastern bloc since
the Space Race, and Standards for occupational exposure to infrasound have now been
published in certain of these countries.
There are no international specifications or Standards for infrasound detectors or meters
except in the notable case of government systems set up to monitor nuclear explosions
under the auspices of the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty -refer
www.ctbt.rd.doe.gov/ctbt/introduction/infrasound fact sheet.html09/08/00.

See also information on the ANU Warramunga Seismic and Infrasound Array Station on
the internet.
The US prototype system has or had a frequency response from 0.02 Hz to 4.0 Hz and
has or had 'microbarograph' sensors spaced 1 km apart.

Page 7 of 11

Low frequency (infrasonic) signalling by submarines using hydrophones is another case

in which there are presumably some standards: at least one patent for a high-power
transmitting hydrophone has been published.
Universities are currently researching infrasound in the fields of geology or meteorology
Refer http//geology.heroy.smu.edu/-hayward/Projects/Infrasonics/assets/sow.html09/08/00.

Candidate infrasonic sensors mentioned in this published Statement appear to be both

specialised and expensive.
There is a reference in an article "Infrasound Monitoring with a Microbarograph"
published in the Bell Jar 5, No 4, viz.:- "Professional instruments with price tags in the
multikilobuck range." The author chose to use a transducer which cost about US$450,
with a frequency response (only) to 10 Hz. Refer
www.tiac.net/users/shansen/belljar/microbar.htm05/08/00.

At least one Italian university is researching bioacoustics -refer

www.univp.it/cibra/instru.html09/08/00.

I quote "The tasks of bioacoustics....call for specialised sets of instruments which are not
commonly available on the market." In this html paper only hydrophones are mentioned
as having a low frequency response.
Infrasound is of course generated by geological and meteorological phenomena, and may
also be generated by other bodies in the solar system or beyond via electromagnetic or
gravitational effects.
It is likely that infrasound is conducted; amplified; focussed or attenuated by architectural
and topographic features including underwater topographic features, and such effects
may be of biological importance, e.g. migration routes of whales. This could be a fruitful
area of scientific research, including archaeological research. Such research depends
importantly on the ready availability of suitable (inexpensive) detection equipment.
Some well-known winds such as the Mistral in southern France probably generate
infrasound and it may be this form of energy which contributes to negative health effects
in susceptible individuals, not merely an excess of positive ions.
There are groups of individuals around the world known as 'Hummers' who are
concerned with mysterious low frequency hums or noises found in different parts of the
world, e.g. the Taos hum; the Bristol hum. Refer
www.borderlands.com/iournal/nux.htm05/08/00.

the 'Low Frequency Noise Sufferers Association'

Such people have set up Societies
in Britain -to investigate and discuss these phenomena on the internet and elsewhere, and
they would presumably be particularly interested in portable low-cost detection
equipment for infrasound. A design published by one such interested party uses a
inch diameter loudspeaker in a wooden cabinet as a transducer for a practical instrument,
but this design is (inevitably) sensitive to electromagnetic radiation from the electric
power grid, given that a loudspeaker is an electromagnetic transducer and that a relatively
long connecting cable is necessary. Refer
www.eskimo.com/-billb/hum/lennart2.gif28/07/00.

RA

Page 8 of 11

There appears to be an absence of published designs using a simple and inexpensive

piezo-electric transducer as used in greetings cards to convert infrasonic fluid pressure
waves into an electrical signal. Industrial or scientific apparatus uses exceedingly
expensive purpose-built condenser microphones for this same purpose.
The only related design found is that by B.Kainka: a one-transistor circuit not a FET)
published in Elektor Electronics, July/August 2000, p.20, which uses a simple piezo
speaker to pick up the human heartbeat, in which said speaker is apparently placed on the
skin, thus transducing a pressure wave in or from a solid.
Devices to detect infrasonic fluid pressure waves mentioned in this Discussion, are
neither portable nor utilitarian.
Ultrasound is generated inter alia by animals such as bats, moths and cave-dwelling
birds; by green plants; by domestic refrigerators which employ an expansion valve, and
by electronic equipment such as televisions and other video monitors employing a
cathode ray tube with wire-wound scanning coils. These produce signals at 15.125 KHz
upwards, with inevitable harmonics at higher frequencies generated by the saw-tooth
'flyback' waveform employed.
There has been a recent trend to rodent and insect pest control equipment employing
ultrasound, also to electronic controllers (transmitters/receivers) operating at up to 200
KHz, of unknown significance for human health. It may be noted that laboratory strains
of rodents (Rattus norvegicus) are widely used as experimental animals in biology and in
medical science, and results thus obtained are used as indicators, or are simply
extrapolated, for a wide range of human responses. One wonders at the assumption that
there is or will be no effect on humans of unwitting exposure to ultrasound from such
equipment.
Another case of "What you can't hear can't hurt you.", and perhaps added reason to make
a suitable detector more generally available.
Both ultrasound and infrasound found in the environment are likely to be more
widespread and significant than is presently generally recognised, in the current absence
of generally available sensitive detection equipment. Both ultrasound and infrasound are
likely to be stressors in many cases, and are perhaps a causative factor in some diseases
of obscure aetiology.
The apparatus described in this application enables formal and informal surveys, by both
laypersons and scientists, of most environments for inaudible sound waves of likely
biological and in particular likely human health significance.
The employment of readily available and relatively inexpensive electronic components
enables the production of a relatively simple apparatus which is intended to be easily
affordable and hence available to many people, and maximises its utility.
The apparatus is designed as a portable or hand-held battery-powered instrument, of the
same order of size as an electronic multimeter.

Page 9 of 11

A portable combined infrasonic and ultrasonic detector with both auditory and visual
outputs and with more or less complete coverage of those frequency domains, namely
down to approximately 2 Hz and up to approximately 180 KHz, appears to be a novel
concept.
The apparatus disclosed in US Patent 4,629,834 (apparently now expired) has coverage
only tip to 30 KHz, and was apparently intended for enhanced auditory surveillance by
police and military forces. This US -designed apparatus specified conventional electret
microphones mounted in a parabolic reflector.
The combination of an inexpensive piezo transducer and a field-effect transistor (FET)
op-amp input circuit to enable the detection ofinfrasound in the present apparatus may be
considered to be an inventive step, as this combination appears not to have been
described for this use before. Such a combination appears to respond to atmospheric
pressure fluctuations of less than 1 Hz in frequency.
The use of phase-locked loop (PLL) circuits in this apparatus for firstly low frequency
multiplication and secondly precise band-pass filtering of both high and low frequencies
may be considered to be an inventive step. These particular PLL circuits are not new, but
their application described herein appears to be new, at least for the infrasonic part of the
apparatus.
Similarly the application of a sine-wave shaping cicuit to this apparatus appears to be
new; and this apparatus appears to be a new application for a LED/LDR coupled AGC
circuit.
Acknowledgments
References
Alexander Graham Bell -for inspiration.
(ii) Jan Cook Monica Hamers -for receiving and passing on the messages.
(iii) B.Kainka (2000) "Electronic Stethoscope", Elektor Electronics July/August, p. 2 0
(iv) Ian Hegglun (1991) "Sine Waves from a 4046 VCO", Electronics World+Wireless
World, September, p. 75 5
Don Lancaster (1977) "CMOS Cookbook", Howard W. Sams Co Inc.
(vi) Don Lancaster (1996) "Active Filter Cookbook", 2 nd Edition, Newnes.
(vii) Bryan Maher (1999) "Op Amps Explained", 2 nd Edition, Electronics
Australia/Federal Publications Company.
(viii) US Patent 4,629,834 of Dec. 16, 1986.

Page 10of 11

CLAIMS
The claims defining the invention are as follows:1. An electronic apparatus which extends the range of human hearing to include both the
infrasonic and ultrasonic frequency domains in both air and water, substantially as
herein described with reference to accompanying drawings.
2. The apparatus of claim 1 in which there are visual indications of firstly the presence;
relative amplitude, and fundamental frequency of infrasonic fluid pressure waves, and
secondly the presence and relative amplitude of ultrasonic fluid pressure waves; also
in which there are auditory indications of the presence and fundamental frequency of
both infrasonic and ultrasonic fluid pressure waves, and lastly in which there is a
visual indication of the fundamental frequency of ultrasonic fluid pressure waves
when an optional frequency meter is incorporated into said apparatus or connected to
it.

2-

6Lit 704H_

22 i-I

fZ)

f.I.

BLOCK

D(A'YPANM

9fr

APPAR~ATUS.

A,&YO. c&,qt At

=qV
L C-

L DR,

VoWVT )LSC I

3
p

F~NTEND Of IN1RAAIC

PAR~T

oF ^f

409 3

4 Vcc

7r. r 01AI

&,sH

IlC!1L

(1

2411-O

'I

220

bK~C

LED

LDI

VOJt--

J~..rRON-r EGrD

0
0

Q-

VTL3CAN,

OF

VL-1RASQNIC

QJ~t7j4

T:E:

'O)UO~

PART

OFr

APPARATrUS,

I I~
FL L, :L9t

Qs

9M

S.i,,uxvA

OTc6 K c>=4-2 (t Tc-9=

%4-6 ,TC97

tf

Qr I

VC-C

TDA 25,51

IA
oUtiCVTj-

s1-rc

Gf- ^~PPA RArvS