Sie sind auf Seite 1von 52

Electric&HybridVehicleResearchat

Electric
& Hybrid Vehicle Research at
ImperialCollegeLondon
p
g
Presentedby:DrGregoryOffer
Presented
by: Dr Gregory Offer
EPSRCCareerAccelerationFellow
ImperialCollegeLondon,UK

Electric and Hybrid Vehicles Network


ElectricandHybridVehiclesNetwork

Departments
MechanicalEngineering
Electrical&Electronic
Electrical & Electronic
Engineering
EarthScienceand
Engineering
ChemicalEngineering
Materials
Bioengineering
CentreforTransportStudies
ImperialCentreforEnergy
Policy and Technology
PolicyandTechnology

Researchactivities

Fuelcells
Batteries
Electricmotors
Powerelectronics
Internalcombustionengines
l
b i
i
Vehiclearchitecture
Motorsport
Testing
Policy

Why?
ClimatechangeandCO2emissions
Climate change and CO2 emissions
Diversityofenergysupply
Localairpollution

Howey DA,North,RandMartinezBotas,R,
DA North R and Martinez Botas R Road
Road
transporttechnologyandclimatechangemitigation
BriefingPaperNo.2 GranthamInstituteforClimate
Change Imperial College London
Change,ImperialCollegeLondon
http://www3.imperial.ac.uk/climatechange/publications

UKlongtermresearchprioritiesfor
Electric&HybridVehicles

Lowcostcompacthighefficiencymotors
L
Lowcost,durable,energydensebatteries
d bl
d
b
i
Lowcostpowerelectronics
Intelligentthermalmanagement
gy
g
Controlofoverallenergymanagement
Toolsfordesignandoptimisation

Refs:
AnIndependentReportontheFutureoftheAutomotiveIndustryintheUK,
NewAutomotiveInnovationandGrowthTeam(NAIGT)
LowCarbonVehiclesInnovationPlatform,TechnologyStrategyBoard(TSB)
4

Improvingconventionaltechnology

Turbocharger group
Turbochargergroup
W
Worldleadingresearch
ld l di
h
intoturbochargers
Toachievesignificant
g
improvementsinthe
performanceandenergy
efficiencyofinternal
combustionenginesbyuse
ofturbomachinery
Inthepast10yearshave
developedahighspeed
dynamometerfor
turbochargerresearch,
enablingaverywiderange
bli
id
oftestconditionstobe
achieved
http://www3.imperial.ac.uk/turbochargers

Thermalaspectsofelectricalmachines

Convection in axial flux electrical machines


Convectioninaxialfluxelectricalmachines
Statorconvection:
h=q/(TsTref)

rotor

case
airflow
fl
(Geiras, 2008)

rotationaxis

Howey,D.A.,Childs,P.R.N.,Holmes,A.S.,Airgapconvectionin
y
g p
rotatingelectricalmachines,invitedreviewpapertotheIEEE
TransactionsonIndustrialElectronics accepted

Electrical measurement technique


Electricalmeasurementtechnique
heat transfer into
fl id
fluid
copper
FR4
550 m
200 m

PCB1

solder
resist

tres 25
m

ttrack 25
m

Howey,D.A.,Holmes,A.S.andPullen,K.R.,Radially resolved
measurementofstatorheattransferinarotorstatordiscsystem,
InternationalJournalofHeatandMassTransfer53(13)(2010)pp.
493501,DOI10.1016/j.ijheatmasstransfer.2009.09.006

PCB2
tFR4 = 1.65
mm

Observed flow transition at stator


Observedflowtransitionatstator

Turbulent
Laminar

Heat transfer
(dimensional)

Rotational Reynolds number

Howey,D.A.,Holmes,A.S.andPullen,K.R.,Predictionand
measurementofheattransferinaircooleddisctypeelectrical
t fh tt
f i i
l d di t
l ti l
machines,IETPEMD2010,1921April2010,ThistleHotel,Brighton
UK,DOI10.1049/cp.2010.0138

10

Parameterisation ofmodels

Hey,J.,Howey,D.A.,MartinezBotas,R.,Lamperth,M,Transient
thermalmodelling ofanaxialfluxpermanentmagnet(AFPM)
machine with model parameter optimisation usingaMonteCarlo
machinewithmodelparameteroptimisation
using a Monte Carlo
method,VTMS10 VehicleThermalManagementSystems,1519
May2011,IMechE,London

11

Thermal &electricalmanagementof
batteries

12

Battery Pack Development

System modelling & validation


Systemmodelling&validation
Continuous
powergui

Bus Bar 17

Bus Bar 2

Contact R7

M
Modelling,designing,building
d lli d i i b ildi
andtestingofbatterypacks
forEVs,including:

+
v
-

Real
RealVehicletesting&
Vehicle testing &
validation!

Bus Bar 1

Contact R

Battery27

Bus Bar 98

Contact R93

_
Battery37

Bus Bar 60

Contact R91

_
Battery38

Bus Bar 61

Contact R59

_
Battery39

Bus Bar 43

Contact R51

_
Battery26

Bus Bar 44

Contact R55

_
Battery6

Bus Bar 45

Contact R54

_
Battery

Bus Bar 46

Contact R58

_
Battery3

Bus Bar 48

_
Battery4

Contact R8

Bus Bar 4

Contact R4

m
Battery5

Contact R6

Contact R5

Contact R2

Contact R1

Contact R9

Contact R57

Contact R56

Contact R53

Battery50

Contact R52

+
v
-

Battery45

Contact R60

Voltage Measurement6

Contact R92

Contact R94

Ideal Switch
Bus Bar 97

Bus Bar 8

Bus Bar 7

Bus Bar 6

Bus Bar 5

Bus Bar 49

Bus Bar 19
Contact R17

Contact R13

+
+
v
-

Contact R14

Contact R16

Contact R12

Contact R65

Contact R11

Bus Bar 56

Contact R96

m
_

Battery46

Contact R63

+
v
-

m
_

Battery31

Bus Bar 99

Contact R98

m
_

Battery28

Contact R64

Bus Bar 57

Contact R70

+
m

_
Battery29

Contact R67

Bus Bar 33

Contact R62

+
m

_
Battery30

Contact R68

Contact R19

Bus Bar 34

Contact R66

Battery25

Battery11

Bus Bar 35

m
_

Battery7

Contact R15

Contact R69

m
_

Battery8

Bus Bar 36

m
_

Battery9

Contact R18

m
_

Battery10

Contact R10

m
_

Voltage Measurement2

Contact R71

Voltage Measurement7

Battery47

Contact R97

Contact R99

Scope2

Bus Bar 96
+

Bus Bar 16

Bus Bar 15

Bus Bar 14

Bus Bar 13

Bus Bar 37

Bus Bar 32

Bus Bar 31

Bus Bar 30

Bus Bar 47

Bus Bar 55

Bus Bar 62

Bus Bar 100

i
-

Current Measurement

Contact R27

+
v
4

Voltage Measurement4
Scope1

Contact R23

Bus Bar 18

Bus Bar 12

Contact R47

+
v
-

Bus Bar 10

Contact R44

m
_

+
v
-

m
_

Battery44

Bus Bar 101

Contact R104

m
_

Battery41

Bus Bar 59

Contact R90

m
_

Battery42

Voltage Measurement9

Contact R103

Bus Bar 58

Contact R88

m
_

Battery43

+
v
-

_
Battery49

Contact R101

Bus Bar 42

Contact R50

m
_

Battery40

m
_

Battery48

Contact R81

Bus Bar 38

Contact R84

m
_

Battery24

m
_

Battery36

Contact R73

Bus Bar 39

Contact R83

m
_

Battery21

Bus Bar 40

Contact R87

m
_

Battery22

Bus Bar 41

Contact R48

m
_

Battery23

Bus Bar 9

Contact R40

m
_

Battery20

Contact R102

m
_

Battery33

Contact R74

Contact R100

m
_

Battery34

Contact R77

Contact R80

m
_

Battery35

Contact R78

Contact R72

m
_

Battery32

Contact R29

Contact R76

m
_

Battery2

Contact R21

Bus Bar 11

Contact R43

+
m

Contact R75

m
_

Battery12

Contact R22

Contact R79

m
_

Battery13

Contact R25

Contact R28

m
_

Battery14

Contact R26

Contact R20

m
_

Battery1

Voltage Measurement8

Contact R24

Voltage Measurement10

Battery51

Battery52
Scope

Contact R46

Contact R45

Bus Bar 28

Contact R39

+v
-

Voltage Measurement1

Bus Bar 75

Bus Bar 73

Contact R149

Bus Bar 76

Voltage Measurement12

Contact R121

Bus Bar 83

Contact R166

+
v
-

m
_

Battery82

Bus Bar 104

Contact R144

+
m

Contact R165

Bus Bar 93

+
v
-

_
Battery71

Bus Bar 82

Contact R164

_
Battery81

Bus Bar 103

C tact
Con
t R120

+
m

Contact R143

+
m

Contact R157

Bus Bar 89

Contact R31

Bus Bar 71

C tact
Con
t R142

_
Battery70

Bus Bar 81

Contact R156

_
Battery78

Contact R158

Bus Bar 90

Contact R119

+
m

Contact R141

Bus Bar 77

m
_

Battery79

Contact R161

Bus Bar 91

+
- v

Voltage Measurement11

_
Battery59

Bus Bar 70

C t
Con
tact R140

_
Battery69

m
_

Battery80

Contact R162

Bus Bar 92

Contact R160

m
_

Battery77

Contact R155

Bus Bar 88

Contact R117

+
m

Contact R133

Bus Bar 78

Contact R159

m
_

Battery76

Contact R147

Bus Bar 84

+
m

_
Battery58

Bus Bar 69

C tact
Cont
t R132

_
Battery66

Contact R134

Bus Bar 79

Contact R163

m
_

Battery73

Contact R148

Bus Bar 85

Contact R109

+
m

_
Battery67

Bus Bar 102

Contact R30

+
m

_
Battery57

Bus Bar 65

C tact
Con
t R136

+
m

Contact R137

Bus Bar 80

Contact R154

m
_

Battery74

Contact R151

Bus Bar 86

Contact R146

m
_

Battery75

Contact R152

Contact R110

Bus Bar 66

C tact
Con
t R135

_
Battery68

Contact R105

Bus Bar 64

Contact R118

+
m

_
Battery54

Contact R113

+
m

Contact R138

Contact R95

Bus Bar 63

Contact R116

+
m

_
Battery55

Bus Bar 67

C tact R139
Con

_
Battery65

Contact R131

Bus Bar 72

m
_

Battery72

Bus Bar 87

Contact R150

Contact R114

+
m

_
Battery64

Contact R123

Contact R89

Bus Bar 54

Contact R108

+
m

_
Battery56

Bus Bar 68

C tact R130
Con

+
m

_
Battery61

Contact R124

Bus Bar 74

Contact R153

+
v
-

Voltage Measurement5

Bus Bar 24

C tac
Con
t t R122

+
m

_
Battery62

Contact R127

Contact R61

Bus Bar 50

Contact R112

+
m

_
Battery53

Contact R107

Bus Bar 20

C t
Con
tact R126

+
m

_
Battery63

Contact R128

Contact R82

Bus Bar 51

Contact R111

+
m

_
Battery19

Contact R33

Bus Bar 21

C tact
Con
t R125

+
m

_
Battery60

Contact R85

Bus Bar 52

Contact R115

+
m

_
Battery16

Contact R34

Bus Bar 22

C tact
Con
t R129

+
m

Contact R86

Bus Bar 53

Contact R106

+
m

_
Battery17

Contact R37

Bus Bar 23

+
v
-

Bus Bar 29

Contact R32

+
m

_
Battery18

Contact R49

Bus Bar 25

Contact R36

+
m

Contact R41

Bus Bar 26

Contact R35

+
m

Battery15

Voltage Measurement3

Contact R42

Bus Bar 27

Contact R38

Detailed
Detailedbatterymodels
battery models
Thermalmanagement&
electricalmanagement,
including BMS
includingBMS
Systemsintegrationinto
vehicles
Energymanagement
gy
g
Safetyandmechanicalintegrity
Fault&qualitydiagnostics

Bus Bar 3

Contact R3

Voltage Measurement

Step

Voltage Measurement13

Battery83

Contact R167

Bus Bar 94

Contact R145

Bus Bar 95

Bus Bar 105

ElectrochemicalImpedance
Spectroscopy

FromInvestigationoflithiumionpolymer
y
g
y
p
batterycellfailureusingXraycomputed
tomographybyYufitetal.,Electrochemistry
Communications,2011

T H E PA N - A M E R I C A N H I G H WAY

www.racinggreenendurance.com

Drove26,000kms
PanAmerican Highway
PanAmericanHighway
4months
AlaskatoArgentina

Thunderskycells

20

Fuelcellsystem design&testing

21

SOFC/ZEBRA Battery Hybrid


SOFC/ZEBRABatteryHybrid
.

( g
p
)
Combinea(hightemperature)ZEBRA
batteryandanintermediate
temperaturesolidoxidefuelcell(IT
SOFC)
Surpass theefficiency ofapurely
fuelcelldrivenvehicle
Extend therange ofaa purely
batterydrivenvehicle
Optiontooperateonhydrocarbon
Option to operate on hydrocarbon
fuel

Fuel

IT-SOFC
System

DC/DC

ZEBRA
Battery

FCMI

DC/DC
Control

BMI

MotorLoad

CAN

Driver

Modelledthesystem
Testedat1/10th scale
Aguiar,P. BrettD.J.L.Brandon,N P,Feasibilitystudyandtechno
economicanalysisofanSOFC/batteryhybridsystemforvehicle
applications,JPowerSources,2007,Vol:171,Pages186197.

VMU

Designing,building,integrating&
testingaFCHEVpowertrain
Rangeextendermode
Range extender mode
Minimisedynamic
operation
Optimisecomponentsfor
fixedoperatingpoint
Minimisestart
Minimise startup/shut
up/shut
downevents

Result
Simplifysystemdesign
Opportunitytoremove
some BoP
someBoP
Reducecost
Improveddurability
p
y
ImperialCollegeLondon

Humidifier

Blower

Fuel Cell Stack

Purge
Valve

Back pressure
Control valve
Hydrogen
Humidifier

Hydrogen System

Recirculation pump

Air System
Cooling System
Nitrogen system
Hydrogen supply

Manual
Valve

Solenoid
Valve

Nitrogen supply

Manual
Valve

Solenoid
Valve

Deionising
Filter

Radiator

Coolant
Pump

Fan

Objectiveofthisprojectwastodesignbalanceofplant
appropriateforhybridelectricvehicleapplicationsunder
urbandutycycles.Smallelectricdeliveryvanwithuser
unsatisfied with limited range
unsatisfiedwithlimitedrange

Page23

System specification
Systemspecification
12

LLowpressureNedstack
N dt k
P9.575PEMFCstack.

10
8

75cellswithnominal
maximumpowerof9.5
kWe

ImperialCollegeLondon

Power (kW)

Vehicle
Vehiclesimulations
simulations
estimatedaveragegross
powerrequirementof4
kWe
Opportunitytooperate
y
g
y
systemathighefficiency
ifbalanceofplant
optimised

2
0
0

50

100

150

200

-2
-4
-6
-8

Time (s)
Motor power

Rolling losses

Aerodynamic losses

Powerrequirementsandlossesfromelectric
powertrainfromonerepeatedcycleofthe
ECE15drivecycle
Page24

System modelling & validation


Systemmodelling&validation
M
Modelling,designing,
d lli d i i
buildingandtestingof
fuel cell range extenders
fuelcellrangeextenders,
including:
Balanceofplant,
Startup/shutdown
strategies,
Controlandoptimisation
Control and optimisation
Degradation&failure
modes

RealSystemtesting&
validation!
Progressreportedin:CordnerM,MatianM,OfferGJ,etal,Designing,building,testingandracingalowcostfuel
cellrangeextenderforamotorsportapplication,JournalofPowerSources,Vol 195,Iss 23,2010,pages78387848

Degradation
Primarymodes*
Pi
d *
Startupandshutdown
(44%)
Powercycling(28%)
Idlingatlowcurrent(28%)

Modellingincludes
simplifiedsteadystate
values
l
Comparisonofsteady
state and dynamic
stateanddynamic
operation
ImperialCollegeLondon

Underpureproportionalcontrol,stacktemperature
Under
pure proportional control stack temperature
wasmaintainedatasteady61Cwiththermal
oscillationsof0.5Candperiod40scausedbythe
10sphaselagbetweentheinletandoutlet
temperatures
Degradation models based upon:
* Miller, M. and Bazylak, A. Journal of power sources, 196(2):601613, 2011.
Ryoichi Shimoi, R., et al. SAE International Journal of Engines, 2(1):960-970, 2009.

DC/DC converters
DC/DCconverters
DC/DCconverters
DC/DC
AnumberofDC/DC
converters have been
convertershavebeen
usedbytheteamover
theyears
Thesehavealways
proventobethehardest
to find!
tofind!
Bespokedesignnormally
necessaryy
Electricalandcontrol
integrationachallenge
ImperialCollegeLondon

ReportedinProceedingsofEVS24,Stavanger,
Norway,2009,FuelCellRacing:ImperialCollege
LondonPresentstheRacingGreenTeam,Clague,R.,
Offer, R., Matian, M., et al.
Offer,R.,Matian,M.,etal.

Page27

RacedinFormulaZero2008and
2009Seasons,poweredby
Hydrogenics PEMFC,Maxwell
Supercapacitors,LEMCOmotors,
Zahn DC/DC,andNavitas
DC/DC and Navitas motor
motor
controllers,controlledby
CompactRIO

Realworldtesting

28

RAC Future Car Rally


RACFutureCarRally
Imperialwroterules
andjudgedpremierlow
carbonvehicleeventin
theworld
Resultswrittenupas
journalpaper
And,asreport HoweyDA,MartinezBotasRF,LyttonL,etal,Comparative

5th

Nov2011

measurementsoftheenergyconsumptionof51electric,
hybridandinternalcombustionenginevehicles,
TransportationResearchD,2011,Pages:16

Undergraduate teaching project


Undergraduateteachingproject
Over100studentsayear,highlightsinclude

IRG04vehicle
FullbatteryelectricFormulaStudentvehicle,racingatSilverstoneinJuly2011
y
,
g
y
Over50studentsinvolvedinvehicleraceteam

RnD division,energystorageteam

Batteryandsupercapacitordesigning,making&testing
Fundamental science modelling
Fundamentalscience,modelling
Batterymanagementsystemsandcontrol
Involving23students

RnD division,hybridONEteam
Hybridpowertraindesign,designingandtestingbattery/supercap hybridsystems,incBMS
andenergymgmt
Enginemanagementandenergymanagementincombustionenginehybridpowertrain
Involving21students
g

Rnd division,fuelcellteam
Designing,buildingandtesting3rd generationoffuelcellsystemforinstallationintoelectric
deliveryvan
Involving10students
Involving 10 students

Studentsarehavingtoworkonsimilarchallengestomajorautomotivecompanies,atthe
forefrontoftechnologydevelopment

Page32

Technoeconomics

35

Rationale

ElectrochemicalAutomotive
E i
Engineering
i
Fundamentalelectrochemistryof
componentsandsystems
Performanceoptimisation,controland
energymanagementt
Degradation&failuremodemodelling
Systemsintegrationmodellingand
optimisation

ExampleAim
l i
Topredictoptimum fuelcellandbattery
configurations forapluginhybridbased
upontheinteractionsbetween
components and the impact on durability
componentsandtheimpactondurability
andsystemcomplexity,costandweight
Todesign,buildandtestsuchafuelcell
rangeextendedelectricvehicle,
ambitiousaim intimefortheLondon
Olympics.

Examplefigurefrom:OfferGJ,ContestabileM,HoweyDA,etal,Techno
economicandbehaviouralanalysisofbatteryelectric,hydrogenfuelcell
i
db h i
l
l i fb
l
i h d
f l ll
andhybridvehiclesinafuturesustainableroadtransportsysteminthe
UK,

EnergyPolicy,2011,Vol:39,pages:19391950

Progressreportedin:CordnerM,MatianM,OfferGJ,etal,Designing,
building,testingandracingalowcostfuelcellrangeextenderfora
motorsportapplication,

JPS,Vol 195,Iss 23,2010,pages78387848

Hydrogen & Electricity


Hydrogen&Electricity
Synergistic
Synergisticnotantagonistic.
not antagonistic
Assumption:Hybridconfigurationscheaper!
Question:Isthistrueandwhatisoptimum
hybrid configuration?
hybridconfiguration?
Hydrogen&FuelCells

Electricity&Batteries

Fuel lifecycle efficiency


Fuellifecycleefficiency

Goodfor
Good
for conventional
Poorforelectrolysis

Goodforconventional
Good
for conventional
V.Goodforrenewables

Technologycost

Costlyforpeakpower
Okay foraveragepower
for average power

Cheapforpeakand
average power
averagepower

Range

Independent ofdevice

DependentandCostly

Costoffuel

Largevariability

Cheap

ImperialCollegeLondon

Page37

Simple Answer Part A


SimpleAnswerPartA.
Yes,hybrid
, y
configurations
arecheaper.
FCEVAssumed
FCEV Assumed
20kWfuelcell
6kWhbattery
50:50usage

BEVAssumed
25
25kWh
kWh
battery

QuestionB.
Whatis
optimum?
OfferG.J.etal.,Comparativeanalysisofbatteryelectric,hydrogenfuelcell
Offer
G J et al Comparative analysis of battery electric hydrogen fuel cell
andhybridvehiclesinafuturesustainableroadtransportsystem.
ImperialCollegeLondon

EnergyPolicy,2010,Vol:38,Pages:2429

Driving behavioural analysis


Drivingbehaviouralanalysis
20

UKNational
TravelSurvey
Data
Nationwide
Nationwide
distribution

Similar
distributions
in USA and
inUSAand
Germany

Average
Small
Small/Medium
Medium
L
Large

18
16
14

8
6
2
4
2
0

0
<5

< 10

< 15

< 25

< 35

< 50

< 100

< 200

200 <

EnergyPolicy,2011,Vol:39,pages:19391950
FirstpresentedatGroveFuelCellConferenceinLondon,
October2009

Perc
cent

10

Day
y Distance Driven (banded)
(
) / miles
ImperialCollegeLondon

12

Perce
ent

Aggregated
gg g
&
Differentcar
types
yp

Hybrid battery size generation


Hybridbatterysizegeneration
Forbaseline
vehicle
h l
NTS=Medium
VED=Multi
purpose

Assumptions
100%capacity
useable
Singleovernight
charge

SimilartoUSand
Germany*
Andhence
similarmodel
resultstoo

100

Cum
mulative Percentage
e/%

80

60

40

20

All electric days possible / total days


Electric miles possible / total miles
0
0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

Battery size / kWh


ImperialCollegeLondon

ForUSAseeT.H.BradleyandC.W.Quinn,JournalofPowerSources,2010,195,53995408.
ForGermanyseeSteigerW.,VolkswagenAG:EuropeanForumAlpbach2008

Results

Baseline=allassumptionsaverage

Resultsshownonleftexclude carbon
Resultsshownonrightincludefixedcarboncost(average=$120)
Results shown on right include fixed carbon cost (average $120)
Allotherassumptionsfixedunlessotherwisestated(yellow)

Shadederrorbars

((

Xaxis

Fixedassumptions

Cost = f C H 2 .C E .C FF .(C Batt .C FC .C ICE )(


. BSize .FC Size ). CCO2 . f (EGen ) .( f (behaviour ). f (vehicle ))

ImperialCollegeLondon

Page41

Batterycosts,mostimportant
assumption

Dominate
costsofFCHEV
Highly
sensitivefor
largebattery
g
y
size

Diminishing
returnsbeyond
~10
10kWh
kWh
Ifrangenota
concernaBEV
maybe
y
possible

((

Cost = f C H 2 .C E .C FF .(C Batt .C FC .C ICE )(


. BSize .FC Size ). CCO2 . f (EGen ) .( f (behaviour ). f (vehicle ))

ImperialCollegeLondon

Page42

Hydrogencosts,dominatesforsmall
batterysize

FCEV

Highlysensitive

FCHEV

Highlysensitive
forsmall
batterysizes
Highcost
favourslarger
batterysize
Forlarge
l
batterysize
negligible
effect

Fuelcellcostsaffect
comparisonwithICE
butdonot affect
FCHEV result
FCHEVresult
significantly!!!

((

Cost = f C H 2 .C E .C FF .(C Batt .C FC .C ICE )(


. BSize .FC Size ). CCO2 . f (EGen ) .( f (behaviour ). f (vehicle ))

ImperialCollegeLondon

Page43

Decarbonisingelectricitygeneration,necessary,
butCO2 emissionsonlyaffectcostalittle

Dominatesemissions

FFavourslarger
l
batterysize
Effectonprice
negligibleevenat
$120/tonne

Hydrogenproduction
d
d i

Assumedsteam
reformedmethane
Differentmethods
ofhydrogen
y g
productionmay
balancethiseffect

Note:IntheUKBothelectricityandhydrogen
offer~50%reductioninemissionstoday!

((

Cost = f C H 2 .C E .C FF .(C Batt .C FC .C ICE )(


. BSize .FC Size ). CCO2 . f (EGen ) .( f (behaviour ). f (vehicle ))

ImperialCollegeLondon

Page44

Carbon price affects comparison ICE


Carbonprice,affectscomparisonICE

FCEVvs FCHEV

FCHEV

ICEcomparison

Negligible effect
Negligibleeffect

Smallfavouring
largerbatteries
becauseofH2
production
production
method

Highlysensitive
Effectivecarbon
price necessary
pricenecessary
tofavournew
technologies
BothFCEV,
FCHEVandBEV
Higherthebetter

((

Cost = f C H 2 .C E .C FF .(C Batt .C FC .C ICE )(


. BSize .FC Size ). CCO2 . f (EGen ) .( f (behaviour ). f (vehicle ))

ImperialCollegeLondon

Page45

Different vehicle type batterysize


Differentvehicletype
battery size
Hybridisation

SSensitiveto
iti t
vehicletype
Largevehicles
needlarge
batteries

Drivingbehaviour

Differentfor
vehicletypes
Increasingvehicle
si e increases
sizeincreases
totalmilesper
day

Effects

Botheffects
Both
effects
suggestincreased
costsandless
benefitfromthe
FCHEV
Large vehicle is
Largevehicleis
clearlydifferent

ImperialCollegeLondon

Page46

Different vehicle types


Differentvehicletypes
FCHEV

Similaroptimum
batterysizes
predictedforall
types
Electricrange
El t i
obviouslyaffected
Largevehicle
significantly
different

Howdoesthis
affectemissions?

((

Cost = f C H 2 .C E .C FF .(C Batt .C FC .C ICE )(


. BSize .FC Size ). CCO2 . f (EGen ) .( f (behaviour ). f (vehicle ))

ImperialCollegeLondon

Page47

Dependentvariable

Different vehicle type emissions


Differentvehicletype
Emissions

Worsefor
W
f
largervehicles
Notjusteffect
largerenergy
consumption
p

Economics

Favourssimilar
batterysize
(hollow
s mbols)
symbols)
Butlarger
vehiclemeans
lessmilescan
bedrivenas
electric
Increasinguse
ofrange
extender

Note:Thisisforsteamreformedmethaneand50%
Note:
This is for steam reformed methane and 50%
decarbonisedelectricity
ImperialCollegeLondon

Page48

Latest work
Latestwork

SubmittedtoEnergy&EnvironmentalScience

Policy Summary
PolicySummary
80
70

FCHEV is cheaper than FCEV and BEV


FCHEVischeaperthanFCEVandBEV
Batterysizesbetween515kWh
predictedindependentofvehiclesizeor
behaviour

Behaviouriscritical
Beha
io r is critical
ReducingCO2emissionsfrom
electricitygenerationiscrucial
Reducing CO2 emissions from
ReducingCO2emissionsfrom
hydrogenalsocrucial,butthereis
moretime,
Steamreformingmethaneisstill
commensurate with very ambitious
commensuratewithveryambitious
UKemissionsreductiontargetseven
in2030
Carbonpriceislikelytobeasmall
driver,otherpolicymeasures
required
Thefuturewillbeablendof
technologies

millio
onsales/year

60
50

BEVs

40

FCVs

30

PHEVs

20

HEVs

10

ICEVs

0
2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
Illustrationofapossibleuptakescenarioforelectricdrivevehicles,thatiscompatible
year
withmeetingtheIPCCs2050GHGemissionreductiontargets(adaptedfromtheIEA
BLUEMapscenario)
Long Distances
Heavy Vehicles

Hydrogen
& Fuel Cells

Mass Market
Plug-in-Hybrids

Battery
Electric

Sh t Distances
Short
Di t
Light Vehicles
Plug-in-Hybrids
Mass Market

Advanced
Biofuels

Note:Nottoscale

time

Long Distances
Heavy Vehicles

New Project FUTUREVehicles


NewProject
FUTURE Vehicles

3.5mfundingover4years,5Universities,fundedunderTSBLowCarbonVehicle
3
5 f di
4
5U i
iti f d d d TSB L C b V hi l
IntegratedDeliveryProgramme.OnepartnerisShanghaiAutomotiveIndustries
Corporation(SAIC)UKTechnicalCentre

Thank you for listening


Thankyouforlistening

ImperialCollegeLondon

Page52

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen