Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
This T/TAC William and Mary Considerations Packet starts out with a brief
review of research supporting the inclusion of writing to enhance reading comprehension,
and goes on to highlight a specific instructional strategy, R.A.R.E. (Restate the question;
Answer the question; Reasons given; and Examples from the text). Using the R.A.R.E.
strategy, students at both the elementary and secondary levels learn how to respond
accurately in writing to specific comprehension questions in all content areas. The packet
also describes how to develop questions that teach and assess comprehension in all the
purposes for reading.
this approach, teachers craft questions that elicit specific responses related to the material
read.
There are multiple benefits to answering comprehension questions in writing
including:
Students demonstrate the degree of their understanding of what has been read
based on the content of their answers.
Written responses give students the opportunity to use key vocabulary from the
text to increase vocabulary development (T/TAC Considerations: A Word
About Vocabulary, 2001).
Students learn to reference the text in order to retrieve examples as support for
statements and opinions.
Students learn, review, and apply spelling, capitalization, and punctuation rules.
The skill can be taught to a variety of learners at both the elementary and
secondary instructional levels across all academic areas.
Recall details
Sequence events
Inferential Comprehension
Critical
Analysis
Identify authors
point of view
Distinguish between
fact and opinion
Distinguish between
fact and fantasy
Relate to personal
experience
Compare/contrast
Make value
judgments
Draw conclusions
Identify bias
Paraphrase
Judge
adequacy/worth
Summarize
~ When the author used the expression .. in the story, it had a double
meaning. Explain each meaning. (Inferences: Literary Experience)
~ Explain how your knowledge has changed or remained the same based on the
information you read. Use examples from the text to support your ideas.
(Compare/Contrast: Information)
Considerations: Unlocking Reading Comprehension: Writing Is the Key
T/TAC W&M
Updated 6/19/14
~ What information did the author have to know before writing the directions for this
activity? List at least three things he had to know. (Draw Conclusions: Perform a
Task)
Critical Analysis
~ Do you think the author chose the best title for this poem? Explain why or why not
using specific information from the poem. (Literary Experience)
~ What did the author do to present the information in a clear way? Support your
answer with specific examples from the text. (Information)
~ Are the directions clear enough? Explain why or why not giving examples from the
directions. (Perform a Task)
(Adapted from HCPSS, 1997)
Create meaningful questions. Ask yourself: Is this more than a simple recall
question? Is the question about something meaningful in the text? Can the
student support it with examples from the text?
Dont ask too many questions about the same subject matter.
Consider varying the format of your questions. Not all responses have to be in
sentence form. Consider charts, lists, drawings, and labels as possible responses.
Write the response yourself to see if the question can be answered according to
the established criteria.
Consider the instructional levels represented within your class. Ask yourself:
Should all of the students answer all of the questions? Do some of the students
require modified criteria for responses (e.g., graphic, framed sentences, or
sentence starter)?
Mnemonic Examples
My
Very
Educated
Mother
Just
Served
Us
Nine
Pizzas
= Mars
= Venus
= Earth
= Mercury
= Jupiter
= Saturn
= Uranus
= Neptune
= Pluto
Please
Excuse
My
Dear
Aunt
Sally
=
=
=
=
=
=
Parenthesis
Exponents
Multiplication
Division
Addition
Subtraction
Reasons given
Looking back into the text, the student finds and paraphrases the reason why the
character changed.
Student Response: The character changed because he became aware of slaverys
horrors.
FRAME
An appropriate audience for this article is ___________________. I think this
because ______________________________, and ________________________.
SENTENCE STARTER
An appropriate audience for this article is ___________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________.
HIGHLIGHTED QUESTION
is
Who might be an appropriate audience for this article
Explain why.
1. Provide the students with a familiar reading passage in one of the purposes for
reading.
2. Make sure the reading passage should be at the appropriate instructional reading
level for the students.
3. Have the students listen to the passage being read to them as they read along.
4. Instruct the students to answer in writing a predetermined number of
comprehension questions at each of the levels of comprehension.
5. Score the results using the rubric (see below).
6. At regular intervals, administer this instructional assessment to measure growth
and guide instruction (Rosenfield & Gravois, 1996; T/TAC Considerations:
Instructional Assessment, 2002).
0
1
No response
Response reflects only two elements of R.A.R.E. and includes only parts of the
criteria of the assignment (e.g., restatement and answer and one requirement of
the criteria*).
Response reflects three elements of R.A.R.E. and follows the criteria* of the
assignment.
Response reflects the four elements of R.A.R.E. and follows the criteria* of the
assignment.
Response reflects only one element of R.A.R.E. and does not follow the
criteria* of the assignment (e.g., restatement only).
*Criteria The criteria of the assignment can be designed to reflect ongoing instruction
in grammar, sentence structure, key vocabulary, or transition words, for example.
A TARGET RESPONSE
1
21
3
4
A TARGET RESPONSE can be visually displayed in the classroom along with the
rubric. It is an effective tool when modeling or critiquing student responses. In addition,
students are able to refer to a displayed rubric when participating in a peer evaluation
activity or self-monitoring.
Language Arts
Mastery of R.A.R.E. is not only beneficial when used within the purposes of
reading, but also across the purposes for writing (expository, narrative, and persuasive),
thus, the format of R.A.R.E. generalizes readily to the formula for a well-developed
paragraph: topic sentence, supportive details, and a closing sentence. The transition from
answering a comprehension question in writing to writing a paragraph is logical to the
student. The basic components of a well-developed written response to a comprehension
question and a well-developed paragraph are similar. Keeping in mind the mnemonic
R.A.R.E. and the purposes of writing, consider the organizer for an expository paragraph
provided below.
Considerations: Unlocking Reading Comprehension: Writing Is the Key
T/TAC W&M
Updated 6/19/14
__________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________
Concluding sentence:
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
Social Studies/History
Incorporating R.A.R.E. into social studies and history units reaps a variety of
benefits for the learner as well as the teacher. Specifically, R.A.R.E. challenges students
to think critically. Depending on the level of questioning, a student can make
comparisons, infer cause and effect, or make judgments. To provide support for the
answer given, the student learns to reference the text, paraphrase from the text, and refer
to class notes and organizers for supportive information. The student then synthesizes the
information into sentences to complete the response. Such a process teaches valuable
research skills. For the teacher, the finished product provides an authentic assessment of
students understanding of the unit. Also, the criteria can be instructionally matched to
be adapted to all instructional levels.
Considerations: Unlocking Reading Comprehension: Writing Is the Key
T/TAC W&M
Updated 6/19/14
10
Example Grade 3
Different Regions, Different Resources
Region
Natural
Resources
Products
Capital
Resources
Human
Resources
Deserts
Rainforests
Criteria:
Use R.A.R.E. to answer the following question
Use the R.A.R.E. organizer to help organize your ideas
Use the answers you wrote in the chart to support your answer
Use complete sentences
Use C.U.P.S. (capitalization, usage, punctuation, & spelling)
R estate
A nswer the question
R easons given
E xamples from the text
How are the resources of the desert and the rainforest different? Support your answer
with three examples from the Different Regions, Different Resources chart above.
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
(Adapted from HCPSS, 1997)
11
R.A.R.E. Organizer
Answer the following question using R.A.R.E. Use the R.A.R.E. organizer to help you
answer the questions. Copy your complete answer in final form on the assignment
worksheet. Staple your R.A.R.E. organizer to the final copy of your question.
How are the resources of the desert and the rainforest different?
Restate the question here:
12
Science
13
Mathematics
In the past decade, the delivery of mathematics instruction has been under
scrutiny due to the mediocre performance of U.S. students on international assessments
(cited in Maccini & Gagnon, 2002) according to researchers McLaughlin, Shepard, and
ODay. In response, educators, parents, administrators, and the National Council of
Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) have developed a rigorous set of standards that
address the critical components of teaching mathematics. Included in these standards is a
requirement to teach students to communicate their understanding of mathematic
concepts and applications (NCTM, 2000). This standard infers that students must
demonstrate the ability to communicate orally or in writing a firm understanding of
applied mathematical theory.
The NCTM is now calling for a different approach to teaching mathematics.
Traditionally, mathematics instruction has been skill- and formula-based with a
secondary focus on application of theory or problem solving. Specifically, the charge of
the NCTM is to make use of instructional tools that provide a formula for communicating
solutions to mathematics application problems. The mnemonic R.A.R.E. serves as one
strategy to foster these skills.
The benefits of using R.A.R.E. in mathematics are numerous and include:
The mnemonic provides the student with a formula for a written response thereby
generating critical thinking skills to solve problems. For example, to solve word
problems students must recall the operations needed to calculate the problem.
While doing so, students demonstrate a cause-and-effect relationship.
When required to write their thought process, students explain why they chose
specific operations and how those operations resolve problems.
14
Computers
received
10
15
Mr. Reid is the technology teacher at Jones Elementary School. He is setting up the
new computer lab. Mr. Reid is keeping a table to show how many computers he
receives for six days. If he continues to receive computers according to the pattern
on his table, how many new computers will he receive on day 6?
Identify the key vocabulary:
________________________________________________________________________
What problem-solving strategy did you use?
_______________________________________________________________________
CRITERIA:
Use R.A.R.E. to write the answer to the word problem you just solved
R estate the question
A nswer the question
R eason
E xample of pattern
Use complete sentences
Use C.U.P.S. (capitalization, usage, punctuation, & spelling)
Restate: Mr. Reid will receive
Answer: 30 new computers by the Day 6
Reason: He receives 5 computers each day
Example: Day1 he received 5 computers. On Day 2 he received 5 more computers
Completed response:
Mr. Reid will receive 30 new computers in 6 days for Jones Elementary Schools new
computer lab. The reason being he is receiving 5 new computers each day for 6 days.
For example, on Day 1 he received 5 new computers. On Day 2 he received 5 more new
computers, which equals 10 new computers. On Day 3 he received 5 more new
computers to equal 15. By Day 6 with the pattern of adding 5 more computers each
day, he will have a total of 30 new computers for the lab.
Day 1
0+5=5
Day 4
15 + 5 = 20
Example:
Day 2
5 + 5 = 10
Day 5
20 + 5 = 25
Day 3
10 + 5 = 15
Day 6
25 + 5 = 30
15
50
Bob
Sue
X + 10
CRITERIA:
Using R.A.R.E., write the answer to the word problem you just solved
R estate the question
A nswer the problem
R eason for answer
E xample of equation
Use complete sentences
Use C.U.P.S. (capitalization, usage, punctuation, & spelling)
Use the completed equation for your example
(Adapted from Jitendra, 2002)
16
X + (X + 10) = 50
2X + 10 = 50
-10 -10
0 40
2X = 40
2
2
X = 20
Check: 20 + (20 + 10) = 50
Conclusion
Reading comprehension is a critical skill for all students in all academic content
areas. Teachers must be deliberate, analytical, strategic, sensitive, and creative in their
quest to teach reading comprehension. Linking reading and writing for improved
comprehension provides a valuable experience for internalizing learning (Fountas &
Pinnell, 1996). The mnemonic strategy R.A.R.E. challenges students at both the primary
and secondary instructional levels to construct meaning through reading and writing. It
facilitates explicit instruction and serves as an authentic, multidisciplinary assessment for
all students, especially those with memory difficulties that interfere with their ability to
comprehend.
17
References
Forness, S. R. (2001). Special education and related services: What have we learned from
meta-analysis? Exceptionality, 9, 185197.
Fountas, I. C., & Pinnell, G. S. (1996). Guided reading: Good first teaching for all
children. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
Harvey, S., & Goudvis, A. (2000). Strategies that work: Teaching comprehension to
enhance understanding. York, ME: Stenhouse Publishers.
Howard County (MD) Public School System. (1997). Offices of Language Arts, Science,
& Social Studies Curriculum. Ellicott City, MD: Language Arts, Science, &
Social Studies Curricula Writing Teams.
Jitendra, A. (2002). Teaching students math problem-solving through graphic
representations. Teaching Exceptional Children, 34, 3438.
Lyon, G. R. (1998). The NICHD research program in reading development, reading
disorders and reading instruction: A summary of research findings, keys to successful
learning: A national summit on research in learning disabilities. Washington, DC:
National Institute of Child Health and Human Development. (ERIC Document
Reproduction Service No. ED430 366)
Maccini, P., & Gagnon, J.C. (2002). Perceptions and application of NCTM standards by
special and general education teachers. Exceptional Children, 68, 325344.
Mastropieri, M. A., & Scruggs, T.E. (1999). Teaching students ways to remember:
Strategies for learning mnemonically. Cambridge, MA: Brookline.
National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (2000). Principles and standards for
school mathematics. Retrieved July 25, 2003, from
http://standards.nctm.org/document/chapter1/comm.htm.
National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (2000). Report of the
national reading panel: Teaching children to read: Findings and determinations of the
national reading panel by topic areas. Retrieved July 11, 2003, from
http://nichd.nih.gov/publications/nrp/findings.htm
Paulsen, G. (1998). Soldiers heart. New York: Random House.
Rosenblatt, L. (1991). Literature S.O.S. Language Arts, 68, 444448.
Rosenfield, S.A., & Gravois, T.A. (1996). Instructional consultation teams:
Collaborating for change. New York: Guilford Press.
Considerations: Unlocking Reading Comprehension: Writing Is the Key
T/TAC W&M
Updated 6/19/14
18
Salvia J., & Hughes C. (1990). Curriculum-based assessment: Testing what is taught.
New York: Macmillan Publishing Company.
Additional Resources
The following Considerations Packets are available through the T/TAC website at
http://education.wm.edu/centers/ttac/index.php
The following resources are available for loan through the T/TAC Library. Visit the
T/TAC website at http://education.wm.edu/centers/ttac/index.php for a complete listing
of materials. Select the Library link on the home page and enter your selection.
Title
Best Practices in Literary
Instruction
Teaching Our Children to
Read: Components of an
Effective Comprehension
Reading Program
Reading with Meaning:
Teaching Comprehension in
the Primary Grades
The Fluent Reader
Reading to Learn in the
Content Areas
When Kids Cant Read
What Teachers Can Do
Author
Gambrell, L., Morrow L,
Neuman, S. B., & Pressley, M.
Honig, B.
Call letters
CRD 139
TT153
Miller, D
CRD 205
Rasinski, T.V.
Richardson, J.S., Morgan, R.F.,
and Fleener, C.
Beers, K.
CRD 247
CRD 255
CRD 256
19