Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Send
Ask for Clarification
Answer this Question
Steve Budden
answered 11 months ago
1 More Comments
Fawzy Harraz Mar 31 Reply Like 1
Well said Mr. Budden; I couldn't agree more. FEED is part of the
wider bundle of efforts that make the FEL which is a mandate for
successful value-based asset development. The more questions
Perfect, Fawzy.
Manuel Carniglia Apr 5 Reply Like
I certainly agree
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
5
Daniel Savard
answered 11 months ago
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
2
The answers given are basically correct, but a simpler high level
answer is that FEL is a business process and FEED is an
engineering process. Of course there is some engineering content
in the FEL process. Also FEL starts early and many projects die
before FEED if the early stages of FEL process do not show
promise. Also in my experience FEL is primarily an internal
company process, while FEED usually involves major outside
engineering work under the direction of the oil company.
Peter Noble
answered 11 months ago
Hessam Moussavi Apr 5 Reply Like
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
1
Arman Dyussembayev
answered 11 months ago
Arman Dyussembayev Mar 31 Reply Like
Great answers.
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
1
Alan Davies
answered 11 months ago
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
1
Send
E
Jeff Barker answered 1+ year ago
All 4 items you have listed are key FEED deliverables. FEED
consists of taking the design into a model, producing P&IDs,
MTOs, layouts, isometrics, etc to a level of engineering solid
enough to develop a cost estimate generally within +/- 15%, and
a level 3 schedule. All these deliverables makeup the FEED
package. Depending on the type of project, commissioning,
integration, and interface management, and project execution
plans should be well advanced. The full investment decision can
then either be approved or unapproved by the owners and
partners. A risk assessment should also be prepared during the
FEED stage.
Jeff Barker
answered 1+ year ago
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
3
Christopher All the items you list should be done during FEED and
much more. AS you and most know, FEED is the last gate in most
organizations' "gate" process to approve final design and
construction of a project. So the key deliverable from FEED is a
precise project definitions with several other key items including
strategy, execution planning, EHS, risk planning, etc., etc. Some
organizations, from a topsides perspective, often have rough
Mike Cooley
answered 1+ year ago
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
3
Fawzy Harraz
answered one year ago
Claudio Costa Jun 22 Reply Like
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
2
Patrick Campbell
answered 1+ year ago
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
1
Steve Swanstrom
answered 1+ year ago
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
1
Ashish Bandyopadhyay
answered 9 months ago
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
1
And don't forget about another key FEED deliverable that drives
detailed engineering design - Material Selection Diagrams (MSD).
Process data on hydrocarbon constituents, poisons, pH, pressure,
temperature, etc., weight constraints, external environment and
other info is used to select the materials of construction for piping
and fixed/rotating equipment. The MSDs are used to provide
material selection and corrosion allowance details in piping specs
and on equipment data sheets. On the ExxonMobil Hebron
topsides project, extensive use of duplex/super duplex stainless
steels and Titanium was a bit of an overkill from a corrosion
standpoint, but a huge factor in weight reduction.
Joel Sprague
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
0
We all know that The FEED is basic engineering which comes after
the Conceptual design or Feasibility study. The FEED design
Send
Ask for Clarification
Answer this Question
George Wild
answered 3 months ago
Ysmael Suarez Dec 14 Reply Like
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
0
The scope drives the number of man hours, the man hours drive
the cost (for FEED the main driver is Engineering man hours).
However as already said, there are too many variables to quote
an average...
Gary Palmer
answered 3 months ago
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
0
NOUMAN HAQ
answered 3 months ago
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
0
Dean Knowles
answered 3 months ago
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
0
Plants are probably different, but the question was about field
development.
Gustavo Adolfo Klein Dec 15 Reply Like
Submit
Ctrl+Enter to submit
0
David a Roberts
David Roberts
answered 3 months ago
Fawzy Harraz Dec 15 Reply Like