Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to report on the findings of a small project funded by the
Teacher Training Agency and Oracle through the MirandaNet project, set up to
investigate the factors which have contributed to the continuing use of ICT by
experienced ICT and ICT teachers in their teaching. Evidence has been collected
through a literature search, teacher questionnaires, teachers' reports and interviews. The
factors which were found to be most important to these teachers in their teaching were:
making the lessons more interesting, easier, more fun for them and their pupils, more
diverse, more motivating for the pupils and more enjoyable. Additional more personal
factors were improving presentation of materials, allowing greater access to computers
for personal use, giving more power to the teacher in the school, giving the teacher
more prestige, making the teachers' administration more efficient and providing
professional support through the Internet.
1 Introduction
This research project was set up to investigate the factors which motivate teachers to use
ICT and to sustain their use of ICT in teaching. The aim of the project was to use the
factors identified to inform the professional development requirements of practising
teachers to enable them to use ICT appropriately in their teaching. The idea from the
project came from the experience of two projects, MirandaNet, directed by Christina
Preston, and the ICT and Motivation project, conducted by Margaret Cox to investigate
the effects of ICT on the motivation of pupils. More details about the project is reported
in Cox, Preston and Cox (1999).
The purpose of this paper is to present the findings of the literature review conducted
by the project and the research results relating to the uptake of ICT in teaching obtained
from a range of data collected through a survey of ICT and ICT teachers, records of
MirandaNET members' uses of ICT.
therefore not desirable. There is a genuine fear amongst many teachers about ICT and
scepticism of its value to their pupils
2.6 Inadequate resources
Even if the above problems are overcome there is often a difficulty for teachers who
have had some training to be able to use ICT because there are insufficient ICT resources
in the school or there is not enough time to review then and plan lessons incorporating
their use.
In spite of the problems listed above and many others, some positive things have been
learnt from previous experiences of different initiatives and training programmes.
Where schools have had the backing of the head teacher and there is a long term policy
for the school to integrate ICT into the teaching then they have been successful in
gradually developing the use of ICT in different areas.
Projects in which individual teachers have been given portable computers to develop
their own personal ICT skills have shown that teachers then start to use them in their
teaching as well. (NCET, 1994)
Teachers who have gone on longer courses, spread over a year have had the time to
practice in between sessions back in schools and have had the time to assimilate enough
expertise and knowledge to be able to continue to use them within their curriculum.
(Cox, Rhodes & Hall, 1988).
More recently, studies of teachers who belong to an Internet network of supporting
teachers, such as the MirandaNet, have shown that the support enables them to use
them in their teaching even if few other teachers in the school are doing so (Preston,
1999).
Lessons from the past have shown us that there are effective as well as ineffective
strategies for providing professional development for teachers which will lead to their
successful integration of ICT in their teaching. The next section discusses some of the
specific skills which teachers need to have to make the best use of ICT in the classroom
further in relation to teachers' ICT use we have used Ajzen's theories of attitudes and
behaviour (Ajzen, 1988) and Weiner's review of motivation (Weiner, 1990), discussed
more fully in the other BERA conference paper on motivation (Cox, Preston, and Cox,
1999). For the purpose of this paper we have considered a wider range of supporting or
preventing factors, relating these to the theory of Davis, Bagozzi and Warshaw (1989),
discussed below.
Davis, Bagozzi and Warshaw (1989) developed a theory of 'action relating to reasons'
(Technology acceptance model) based on the work of Fishbein and Ajzen (in Davis et al,
1989) to investigate the reasons why some people use computers and their attitudes
towards them. Their model, shown in Figure 1, links the perceived usefulness and ease
of use with attitude towards using ICT and actual use (system use). They tested this
model with 107 adult users, who had been using a managerial system for 14 weeks.
They found that people's computer use was predicted by their intentions to use it and
that perceived usefulness was also strongly linked to these intentions.
requirements in England and Wales of the Teacher Training Agency's ICT skills of
new teachers;
the new national opportunities fund for the training of teachers in the UK;
the changes in society with the rapid growth in the uses of the Internet and ICT in
general;
school policies on using ICT;
opinions of colleagues;
responsibilities of the teacher;
pressure from parents and pupils;
the influence of the local education authority.
Although these have been identified as very important by a number of research studies,
in leading teachers to understand the need for change and to question their professional
practice, discussed earlier, only a few could be investigated within the scope of this
project. The main focus of our research is on how teachers perceive ICT's contribution to
teaching and learning, and whether this is in conflict with their pedagogical and
epistemological beliefs. These factors come within Davis et al's perceived usefulness and
perceived ease of use components.
3.2 Perceived ease of use
From previous studies there are a number of factors which have been identified which
relate to the perceived ease of use of ICT, which in our case is for experienced practising
ICT/IT users. The Impact project (Watson, 1993) and other studies identified a wide
range of skills and competencies which teachers felt they needed in order to find ICT
easy to use. Some of these are given in Table 1 below.
Table 1 - Positive and negative factors influencing perceived ease of use
Positive factors
Negative factors
ownership of a computer
Negative factors
is not enjoyable
is counter-productive due to
insufficient technical resources
4 The Study
Informal research by the MirandaNet project began in 1992 with the collection of the
reports from the MirandaNet members. This was followed by the commissioned study
which began in May 1998. The research is now in the final stage of analysis and
reporting. For a more detailed description of all the research objectives, see Cox, Preston
and Cox (1999).
The focus of this paper is on the investigation into the factors which contributed to the
perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use discussed in section 2. The project
methodology is discussed briefly below. A more detailed description is given in the
paper on motivation (Cox, Preston and Cox, 1999).
4.1 Research methodology
In order to investigate the factors which influence the uptake of ICT, a range of methods
were used to collect evidence from practising teachers.
Stage 1 Literature Search and Examination of MirandaNet Data
Stage 1 involved:
the analysis of a range of paper based and electronically based evidence collected
from members of MirandaNet since 1992.
Number
of items
Personal information
16
Personal use of
computers
24
Use of computers in
school/institution
23
33
48
Professional
development
25
Professional association
information
25
provided
203
5 Results
Results relevant to this paper, focusing on the teachers' perceived ease of use and
perceived usefulness are presented here in three subsections. The first consists of the
variables describing the sample. The second subsection presents the results relevant to
factors associated with perceived ease of use. The third consists of the relevant factors
about perceived usefulness. The data from the questionnaire has been analysed using
SPSS and EXCEL Further results about specific factors regarding the motivation of
teachers are discussed in Cox, Preston and Cox (1999). The interpretation of the uptake
of ICT results are discussed in Section 6.
5.1 Description of the questionnaire sample
Questionnaires were returned by 82 educators, 60.7% of the total of 135 questionnaires
that were sent. Table 4 and Figure 2 show the proportion of male and female
respondents and the distribution of ages respectively.
Table 4 - Biological sex of the respondents
Sex
Number
Percent
male
44
61.1
female
28
38.9
The mean age of the respondents was 42 years, which shows that, for our sample of
experienced ICT users, the majority were in the middle aged bracket. This is contrary to
some previous research findings reported in the literature that ICT is mostly conducted
by newly qualified and younger teachers, although since many of the secondary school
respondents held senior positions in their own departments, i.e. as IT/ICT co-ordinator,
it is not unexpected that they would have several years' teaching experience already and
therefore be older than the majority of newly qualified teachers.
% of
responses
% of cases
load software
74
16.2
97.4
format disks
65
14.2
85.5
virus checking
59
12.9
77.6
file management
72
15.8
94.7
69
15.1
90.8
60
13.1
78.9
58
12.7
76.3
Task
Only three people did not have access to a computer at home with over 75% having
Email at home, shown in Figure 7 below.
Similar data were collected from a range of factors relating to the personal
use of ICT, indicating that the large majority of the teachers perceived that they had no
difficulties with using software and hardware and that they were confident in using ICT
for their personal requirements.
Administrative use
Teachers were asked a range of questions about using ICT for correspondence, timetabling, preparing worksheets, pupils records and assessing pupils. The majority of the
respondents use ICT for many of this tasks with little evidence of any difficulties in this
use. Most of the respondents agreed that it made their administration more efficient
Teaching use
A list of all the questions relating to the teachers' opinions about how easy it was to use
ICT in the classroom are provided in Appendix A. The results are also correlated with
each other and with the teachers' extent of ICT use. These results show that many of the
factors reported in previous studies as deterring teachers from using ICT and given in
Table 1, were not found to be prominent amongst our sample of experienced ICT and IT
teachers. Some of these results are given in more detail below.
Figure 8 - Responses relating to the extent to which using ICT makes it difficult to
control the class
Figure 8 shows that the majority of the sample disagreed that using ICT in a lessons
made the class more difficult to control. Similar findings were obtained for other ease of
use factors, with less agreement in some cases:
ICT makes the lesson more difficult for me - majority disagreed
ICT makes preparing the lessons more difficult - majority disagreed, but with a
significant minority agreeing;
Hardware and software problems often disrupt lessons - majority agreed;
Using ICT in teaching is expensive - majority agreed.
There were specific aspects still perceived as inadequate, for example Figure 9 shows
that over 65% of the respondents would like more ICT resources for their teaching.
Figure 10- Responses relating to the extent to which IT was considered to make
lessons more interesting
Figure 11- Responses relating to the extent to which using IT in teaching was
considered to be unenjoyable
The responses to other perceived usefulness factors include:
makes lessons more fun - 75% agreed
lesson more diverse - 95% agreed
improves presentation of materials 95% agreed
and for negative factors:
makes lessons more difficult 65% disagreed
reduces pupils' motivation 70% disagreed
impairs pupils learning 95% disagreed
Figure 12- Responses relating to the extent to which using IT in teaching enhances
their career prospects
Data were also collected about the teachers' perceptions relating to other benefits of
using ICT. Figure 12 above shows that s significant minority of respondents believed
that using ICT enhanced their career prospects.
Additional factors included:
ICT gives me more power in school
About 1/3 said they agreed/strongly agreed with this, although further analysis of this
result is needed since many of the respondents were already heads of departments or
deputy heads of schools
ICT gives me more prestige
Again a substantial minority agreed with this
Using ICT in teaching has given me more confidence using computers
most agreed.
Using ICT in teaching has given me greater awareness of its uses
again many agreed.
Substantial data was collected about the effects of previous training and the types of
training the teachers had experienced. We also collected data on the teachers' plans for
extending their uses of ICT to the national grid for learning, as shown in Figure 13, and
the value of the Internet for a range of supporting uses of ICT in their teaching, an
example of which is given in Figure 14. Figures 13 and 14 show that even though the
teachers in the sample were already using ICT extensively in their teaching and still
wished for further resources, they still intended to make further uses of ICT in the
future.
Figure 13- Responses relating to the extent to which teachers plan to use the NGFL in
the future for their teaching
Figure 14 Responses relating to the extent to which teachers value the Internet for
discussing teaching ideas
It seems foolish to attempt to work on ICT development in isolation when with a little
communication, ideas can be shared, discussed and refined
(Design and Technology and co-ordinator of staff ICT training)
6 Conclusions
The review of the previous literature has revealed a range of issues relating to the
uptake of ICT in teaching, including specific factors to do with teachers' perceptions
about the value and use of ICT in their teaching. Davis, Bagozzi and Warshaw's model
shows that ease of use and perceived usefulness can have a positive influence on
teachers' use of ICT. Our results have shown that the teachers who are already regular
users of ICT have confidence in using ICT, perceive it to be useful for their personal
work and for their teaching and plan to extend their use further in the future.
The factors which were found to be most important to these teachers in their teaching
were: making the lessons more interesting, easier, more fun for them and their pupils,
more diverse, more motivating for the pupils and more enjoyable. Additional more
personal factors were improving presentation of materials, allowing greater access to
computers for personal use, giving more power to the teacher in the school, giving the
teacher more prestige, making the teachers' administration more efficient and providing
professional support through the Internet.
These findings have implications for training other teachers to become regular users
since as was discussed in section 2, many of the professional development courses focus
on teachers acquiring basic IT skills. Our research has shown that the perceived
usefulness factors are probably equally important to teachers, therefore professional
courses should increase the training of teachers in the pedagogical issues if teachers are
to be convinced of the value of using ICT in their teaching.
Acknowledgements
The project team would like to acknowledge the support for this study from the Teacher
Training Agency, who funded most of the work, Oracle who funded the focus group
and other meetings, conference presentations and teachers' on-line communications,
MirandaNet who initiated the project and whose members provided valuable
information about their uses of Information and Communications Technologies,
Underwood, J. (1997). Breaking the cycle of ignorance: information technology and the
professional development of teachers. in Passey, D. & Samways, B. (Eds.) Information
Technology. supporting change through teacher education. Chapman & Hall. pp 155 160.
Watson, D.M. (Ed.) (1993) IMPACT - An evaluation of the IMPACT of the Information
Technology on Children's Achievements in Primary and Secondary Schools. King's College
London
Weiner, B (1990) The History of Motivational Research. Journal of Educational Psychology
Vol. 82. (4) 616-627
Woodrow, J. (1990) Locus of Control and student teacher computer attitudes. Computers
Educ. Vol. 14. No. 4 pp 421-432
This document was added to the Education-line database on 13 January 2000