Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: To examine time trends in disparities in lowincome childrens health insurance coverage and access to
care by family immigration status.
METHODS: We used data from the National Survey of Childrens Health in 2003 to 20112012, including 83,612 children
aged 0 to 17 years with family incomes <200% of the federal
poverty level. We examined 3 immigration status categories:
citizen children with nonimmigrant parents; citizen children
with immigrant parents; and immigrant children. We used
multivariable regression analyses to obtain adjusted trends in
health insurance coverage and access to care.
RESULTS: All low-income children experienced gains in
health insurance coverage and access to care from 2003 to
20112012, regardless of family immigration status. Relative
to citizen children with nonimmigrant parents, citizen children
with immigrant parents had a 5 percentage point greater increase in health insurance coverage (P .06), a 9 percentage
point greater increase in having a personal doctor or nurse (P
WHATS NEW
JARLENSKI ET AL
METHODS
DATA AND STUDY POPULATION
We obtained data from of the National Survey of Childrens Health (NSCH) in all available years: 2003, 2007,
and 20112012.1719 The NSCH collects data about
childrens health; health insurance coverage; access to
and quality of care; and family, neighborhood, and social
context.20,21 The NSCH is a cross-sectional, nationally
representative telephone survey of US families who have
children ages 0 to 17 at the time of the survey. The surveys
included land-line telephone interviews only in 2003 and
2007, and a cellular telephone component was added in
20112012. In addition to English, the NSCH is administered in Spanish, Mandarin, Cantonese, Vietnamese, or
Korean (71% of the population speaking a language other
than English at home uses 1 of those 5 languages22). On
behalf of a randomly sampled child in the family, a parent
or guardian reports information about health and health
care of the sampled child and other family members.
Response rates were 55.3% in 2003,21 46.7% in 2007,20
and 38.2% in 20112012.23 Each year of the NSCH data
set includes final survey weights that adjust the survey responses to reflect the noninstitutionalized population of
children ages 0 to 17 in each state and the District of
Columbia. NSCH data collection procedures are standardized across years, and many questionnaire items remain the
same, so that multi-year analyses can be performed. We
combined data from the 3 waves of the survey together
ACADEMIC PEDIATRICS
ACADEMIC PEDIATRICS
RESULTS
Weighted descriptive characteristics of our study sample
across all years, stratified by family immigrant status, are
shown in the Table. Large and statistically significant disparities exist on all measures of health insurance coverage
and access to care. Although 91.4% of citizen children with
nonimmigrant parents had health insurance coverage at the
time of the survey, 86.0% of citizen children with immigrant parents had coverage, and only 53.8% of immigrant
children had coverage (P < .001). Similarly, 85.7% of citizen children with nonimmigrant parents had a personal
doctor or nurse, relative to 81.3% of citizen children with
immigrant parents and 57.9% of immigrant children (P
< .001). Generally, citizen children with immigrant parents
and immigrant children had worse health status than citizen
children with nonimmigrant parents. Citizen children with
immigrant parents and immigrant children were more
likely to live with both biological parents in the home,
and had parents with lower educational attainment, relative
to citizen children with nonimmigrant parents.
HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE
Results from multivariable regression models show that,
over the study period of 9 years, all low-income children
experienced increases in the predicted probability of having health insurance coverage, regardless of family immigration status (Fig. 1). Disparities between citizen
children with immigrant parents and citizen children with
nonimmigrant parents in having health insurance coverage
at the time of the survey decreased from 2003 to 2007 and
from 2007 to 20112012. Large and significant immigration disparities between immigrant children and citizen
children persisted, however.
From 2003 to 20112012, citizen children with immigrant parents had a 7.9 percentage point increase in the
probability of having any health insurance coverage, and
immigrant children had a 13.3 percentage point increase
in the predicted probability of having any health insurance
coverage, compared to a 2.9 percentage point increase
among citizen children with nonimmigrant parents
(Fig. 1A). Relative to citizen children with nonimmigrant
parents, the increase in health insurance coverage,
comparing 20112012 to 2003, was greater among citizen
children with an immigrant parent (P .06). Citizen children had far higher predicted probabilities of being
enrolled in Medicaid/CHIP insurance coverage in all survey years, relative to immigrant children (Fig. 1B). The
JARLENSKI ET AL
ACADEMIC PEDIATRICS
Table. Weighted Descriptive Characteristics of Children in Low-Income Families by Immigration Status, National Survey of Childrens Health,
2003, 2007, and 20112012
Characteristic
Weighted N
Unweighted N
Health insurance coverage, %
Any health insurance
Medicaid/CHIP
Continuous coverage
Access to care, %
Personal doctor or nurse
Preventive care use
No unmet medical need
Demographics and health status
Mean age
Race, %
White
Black
Other/multiple races
Hispanic ethnicity
Health status, %
Excellent
Very good
Good
Fair
Poor
Family characteristics
Family structure, %
Biological parents
Biological and stepparents
Single mother
Other
Language not English, %
Parental employmentk, %
Parental education, %
Less than high school
High school diploma
More than high school
Citizen Children,
Nonimmigrant Parents
56,545,315
65,208
Citizen Children,
Immigrant Parent
20,752,644
14,586
Immigrant Children
5,021,063
3,818
P*
91.4
60.9
82.1
86.0
65.8
76.0
53.8
34.8
45.3
<.001
<.001
<.001
85.7
82.2
86.9
81.3
79.8
87.8
57.9
63.3
77.8
<.001
<.001
<.001
8.3
7.2
11.2
<.001
60.9
28.5
10.6
11.6
63.0
9.1
27.9
79.1
61.3
11.1
27.5
76.2
<.001
54.1
27.3
14.3
3.4
0.6
39.1
23.1
29.1
8.0
0.8
34.2
22.2
32.2
10.8
0.6
<.001
41.7
10.5
39.4
8.5
2.0
77.0
71.6
5.8
20.8
1.8
73.1
74.7
65.4
9.4
20.9
4.3
83.5
73.1
<.001
14.2
41.3
44.5
46.4
30.0
23.6
44.5
25.9
30.0
<.001
<.001
<.001
.005
ACADEMIC PEDIATRICS
Figure 1. Predicted probabilities of health insurance coverage among low-income children by family immigration status, 2003, 2007, and
20112012. (A) Health insurance coverage. (B) Medicaid/CHIP coverage. (C) Continuous health insurance coverage. Low-income is defined
as family income <200% of the federal poverty level. Predicted probabilities are from multivariable logistic regression controlling for childrens
age, sex, race, ethnicity, health status, family structure, family language, parents employment and education, and state of residence.
DISCUSSION
All low-income children, regardless of family immigration status, experienced gains in health insurance coverage
and access to care from 2003 to 20112012 in this analysis
of a large, nationally representative data set. Additionally,
we observed that disparities lessened between citizen children with immigrant parents and citizen children with
nonimmigrant parents in having any health insurance
coverage, having a personal doctor or nurse, and having
no unmet health need. Although disparities lessened over
time between immigrant children and citizen children
JARLENSKI ET AL
ACADEMIC PEDIATRICS
Figure 2. Predicted probabilities of access to care among low-income children by family immigration status, 2003, 2007, and 20112012. (A)
Personal doctor or nurse. (B) Any preventive care use. (C) No unmet health need. Low-income is defined as family income <200% of the
federal poverty level. Predicted probabilities are from multivariable logistic regression controlling for childrens age, sex, race, ethnicity, health
status, family structure, family language, parents employment and education, and state of residence.
ACADEMIC PEDIATRICS
LIMITATIONS
Our study should be interpreted in light of several limitations. First, the NSCH is a population-based telephone survey and therefore subject to nonresponse bias. However,
the analytic data set incorporates survey weights to reduce
this nonresponse bias.20,21 Second, nonresponse could be
greater among immigrant families due to language and
cultural barriers. Additionally, surveys were conducted via
landline telephone numbers only in 2003 and 2007 and a
cellular phone component was added in 20112012.
Nonresponse could conceivably be greater in immigrant
populations who may not have landlines. If such
differential nonresponse bias occurred and was correlated
with worse insurance and access to care, our results might
overestimate the reduction in immigration-related disparities. Also, it is unknown whether nonresponse bias changed
by family immigration status over time. Nonresponse due
specifically to language barriers is minimized as the NSCH
is professionally translated into 5 different languages spoken
by immigrant populations in the United States.20,21,23 Third,
all measures are based on self-report of a parent or guardian
on behalf of a child, meaning that some measurement error is
inevitable. It is unknown whether this error might systematically differ by immigration status. Fourth, we are unable to
distinguish childrens or their parents legal status in the data,
so we are unable to make any conclusions about children or
parents who are undocumented immigrants. Finally, we are
unable to determine whether parents had access to
employer-sponsored health insurance, which could affect
health insurance coverage and access to care for children.
CONCLUSIONS
Although all children in low-income families experienced gains in health insurance coverage and access to
care from 2003 to 20112012, large disparities related to
family immigration status persisted. Given that the ACA
excludes many low-income immigrants from Medicaid/
CHIP or subsidized insurance, policy efforts are needed
to ensure that children in low-income immigrant families
are able to access health insurance and health care.
SUPPLEMENTARY DATA
Supplementary data related to this article can be found at
10.1016/j.acap.2015.07.008.
REFERENCES
1. Harringon M, Smith K, Trenholm C, et al. CHIPRA mandated evaluation of the Childrens Health Insurance Program: final findings.
2014. Report submitted to the Office of the Assistant Secretary for
Planning and Evaluation. Available at: http://medicaid.gov/chip/
downloads/chip_report_congress-2014.pdf.
Accessed
August
8, 2015.
2. Selden TM, Hudson JL. Access to care and utilization among children: estimating the effects of public and private coverage. Med
Care. 2006;44(5 suppl):I19I26.
3. Howell EM, Kenney GM. The impact of the Medicaid/CHIP expansions on children: a synthesis of the evidence. Med Care Res Rev.
2012;69:372396.
JARLENSKI ET AL
ACADEMIC PEDIATRICS
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
Resource Center for Child and Adolescent Health, Child and Adolescent Health Measurement Initiative; 2007.
Blumberg SJ, Foster EB, Frasier AM, et al. Design and operation of
the National Survey of Childrens Health, 2007. Vital Health Stat 1.
2012;1149.
Blumberg SJ, Olson L, Frankel MR, et al. Design and operation of the
National Survey of Childrens Health, 2003. Vital Health Stat 1.
2005;1131.
Ryan C. Language use in the United States: 2011. American Community Survey Reports, 2011. Available at: https://www.census.gov/
prod/2013pubs/acs-22.pdf. Accessed May 20, 2015.
National Center for Health Statistics. Frequently asked questions:
20112012 National Survey of Childrens Health 2013; ftp://ftp.
cdc.gov/pub/Health_Statistics/NCHS/slaits/nsch_2011_2012/01_Fre
quently_asked_questions/NSCH_2011_2012_FAQs.pdf. Accessed
October 1, 2014.
Cohen Ross D, Cox L. Preserving Recent Progress on Health
Coverage of Children and Families. 2003. Available at: http://kff.
org/medicaid/report/preserving-recent-progress-for-health-coverageof/. Accessed August 19, 2015.
Cohen Ross D, Cox L, Marks C. Resuming the Path to Health
Coverage for Children and Parents. 2006. Available at:http://kff.
org/medicaid/poll-finding/resuming-the-path-to-health-coverage-for/.
Accessed August 19, 2015.
Heberlein M, Brooks T, Guyer J, et al. Holding Steady, Looking
Ahead: Annual Findings of a 50-State Survey of Eligibility Rules,
Enrollment and Renewal Proecdures, and Cost-Sharing Practices in
Medicaid and CHIP. Available at: http://kff.org/health-reform/
report/holding-steady-looking-ahead-annual-findings-of/; 2011.
Accessed August 19, 2015.
White IR, Royston P, Wood AM. Multiple imputation using chained
equations: issues and guidance for practice. Stat Med. 2011;30:377399.
Little RJA, Rubin DB. Statistical Analysis With Missing Data. 2nd ed.
Hoboken, NJ: Wiley; 2002.
Saloner B, Koyawala N, Kenney GM. Coverage for low-income
immigrant children increased 24.5 percent in states that expanded
CHIPRA eligibility. Health Aff (Millwood). 2014;33:832839.
Seiber EE. Which states enroll their Medicaid-eligible, citizen children with immigrant parents? Health Serv Res. 2013;48(2 pt 1):
519538.
Ku L. Improving health insurance and access to care for children in
immigrant families. Ambul Pediatr. 2007;7:412420.
BeLue R, Miranda PY, Elewonibi BR, et al. The association of generation status and health insurance among US children. Pediatrics.
2014;134:307314.
Rhodes SD, Mann L, Siman FM, et al. The impact of local immigration enforcement policies on the health of immigrant Hispanics/
Latinos in the United States. Am J Public Health. 2015;105:329337.
Kenney GM, Haley JM, Anderson N, et al. Children eligible for
Medicaid or CHIP: who remains uninsured, and why? Acad Pediatr.
2015;15(3 suppl):S36S43.
Doty MM, Blumenthal D, Collins SR. The Affordable Care Act and
health insurance for Latinos. JAMA. 2014;312:17351736.
California Legislative Information System. Senate Bill 4: health care
coverage: immigration status. Available at: https://leginfo.legislature.
ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id201520160SB4;
2015.
Accessed July 10, 2015.
Flores G, Walker C, Lin H, et al. A successful program for training
parent mentors to provide assistance with obtaining health insurance
for uninsured children. Acad Pediatr. 2015;15:275281.