Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
DOI 10.1007/s12205-010-0547-0
Structural Engineering
www.springer.com/12205
Abstract
The structural response of prisms of cross section 100100 mm and length of 500 mm constructed with reinforced fibrous concrete
and subjected to pure tensile loading has been presented in this contribution. The main focus was to study the effects of adding
different metallic fibers in mono and hybrid form in the conventionally reinforced concrete on the tension stiffening and strain
development. Two metallic fibers with different geometrical, mechanical and physical properties were investigated: amorphous
metallic straight fibers and carbon steel hooked-end fibers. A total of four concrete mixtures: control, single fiber and hybrid fiber
reinforced concretes were prepared. The fibers were investigated at content of 20 kg/m3 for single fiber reinforced concretes, and for
hybrid fiber reinforced concrete, at content of 40 kg/m3. Through studying load-deformation response of composites and strain
development in steel bar and concrete, it has been found that the metallic fibers improve tension stiffening effect and influence
significantly the strain development. The effect of two metallic fibers on tension stiffening was seen to be different at different
loading stages. On the other hand, when fibers were used in hybrid form, the behaviour of the composite was improved at all loading
stages in terms of tension stiffening and resistance to cracking.
Keywords: reinforced fibrous concrete, metallic fibers, cracking, tension stiffening, strain
1. Introduction
Since concrete is relatively weak and brittle in tension,
cracking is expected when tensile stress is induced in a member.
Cracking, in almost any case, is an inevitable characteristic of
reinforced concrete and their effects are multiple. Cracks can
affect the durability of structures by facilitating the corrosion
process in steel reinforcement. They can cause depreciation in
the appearance of concrete structures. They may also affect the
serviceability of water retaining structures by leakage of liquid
(ACI 224.2R-92; Christiansen and Nielsen, 2001).
When plain concrete is subjected to tension, the initiation and
growth of inherent micro-cracks reduce the load carrying area
and increases the stress concentration at critical crack tips,
causing the cracks to propagate further (Swaddiwudhipong and
Seow, 2006). Before cracking, the behaviour of concrete
component in tension is assumed to be linear up to its tensile
strength in the calculations of reinforced concrete behaviour and
after cracking it is assumed that it drops to zero indicating failure
*Ph.D. Scholar, Universit de Toulouse, UPS-INSA; LMDC (Laboratoire Matriaux et Durabilit des Constructions), F-31077 Toulouse Cedex 04,
France (Corresponding Author, E-mail: rhameed@insa-toulouse.fr)
**Associate Professor, Universit de Toulouse, UPS INSA, LMDC (Laboratoire Matriaux et Durabilit des Constructions), F-31077 Toulouse Cedex
04, France (E-mail: anaclet.turatsinze@insa-toulouse.fr)
***Associate Professor, Universit de Toulouse, UPS-INSA, LMDC (Laboratoire Matriaux et Durabilit des Constructions), F-31077 Toulouse Cedex 04,
France (E-mail: frederic.duprat@insa-toulouse.fr)
****Professor, Universit de Toulouse, UPS-INSA, LMDC (Laboratoire Matriaux et Durabilit des Constructions), F-31077 Toulouse Cedex 04, France
(E-mail: alain.sellier@insa-toulouse.fr)
547
2. Experimental Program
2.1 Concrete
Four different concrete mixes, one control and three mixes
containing metallic fibers were studied. The results of compressive strength tests performed on the four mixes showed that
the average compressive strength of plain and metallic fiber
reinforced concrete varied between 40 MPa and 45 MPa. For all
the concrete mixes, CEM I 52.5 R type cement has been used.
Local natural round sand with maximum particle size of 4 mm
was used. Round gravels with size range of 4-10 mm were used
as coarse aggregate. A Super-plasticizer has been used as an
admixture to improve the workability of the mix in the presence
of metallic fibers. Table 1 show the mix proportion of control
concrete.
Sand
(Kg/m3)
Gravel
(Kg/m3)
Water
(Kg/m3)
Super-Plasticizer
(Kg/m3)
322
872
967
193
1.61
Fiber Type
MF1
MF2
Dimension (mm)
Geometry
E, GPa
Tensile strength
(MPa)
Density
Cross Section
Straight
140
2000
7.2
Rectangular
0.5
Hooked-end
210
1200
7.8
Circular
amorphous metal
30
1.6
0.03
carbon steel
30
548
A Study on the Reinforced Fibrous Concrete Elements Subjected to Uniaxial Tensile Loading
Mixture
Type
RC-CONT
Control
RC-20MF1
RC-20MF2
Mono fiber
20
20
20
20
20
20
40
549
3. Experimental Observations
A Study on the Reinforced Fibrous Concrete Elements Subjected to Uniaxial Tensile Loading
Tension stiffening bond factor, was calculated for all compositions and presented in Fig. 10. Higher value of shows that
the member is more stiffened. It can be observed in Fig. 10 that
the fibers affect the tension carried by the composite since the
fibers contribute in carrying tension along with the steel bar at
the crack location. Among different type of fibers used in this
study, it was observed that before yielding of steel bar when
crack width is small, effect of MF1 fibers on tension stiffening is
more significant compared to MF2 fibers (Fig. 10). Although up
to yielding of steel bar, the effect of MF2 fibers when present
alone is less significant compared to MF1 fibers, but RC-40HyF
containing fibers in hybrid form exhibited maximum value of
compared to other composites.
Further increase of applied displacement resulted in yielding of
steel bar and crack opening was increased dramatically. The load
at yielding stage for all four composites is shown in Fig. 8, where
it is observed that RC-40HyF exhibited maximum yielding load;
this can be attributed to the increased tension stiffening in the
presence of metallic fibers in hybrid form. No effect on composite axial tensile load carrying capacity was observed in the
presence of MF2 fibers alone. After the yielding of steel bar, it
was noticed that the axial load capacity of RC-20MF1 start
decreasing and approaches to a value similar to RC-CONT. On
the contrary, axial tensile load capacity of composite containing
only MF2 fibers start increasing and becomes higher than the
values of both RC-20MF1 and RC-CONT; this showed the
effectiveness of MF2 fibers in restraining the macro cracks from
further opening and improving the response in term of ductility
and tensile strength after yielding of conventional reinforcement.
3.2 Local Strain Distribution in Steel
A number of observations regarding the strain distribution in
embedded steel bar prior and after the crack formation can be
made from the local strain recorded using strain gages pasted at
different section of steel bar as shown in Fig. 3.
Strain distribution at different section of embedded steel bar
versus axial load for the RC-CONT is shown in Fig. 11, where it
can be observed that stiffness increases with increase of distance
from the ends of specimen, this shows a gradual transfer of load
from the reinforcement to the concrete matrix and this is
551
The plot between local strains and axial load is shown in Fig. 13.
After cracking a severe increase in the strain value at sections in
the vicinity of the cracking plane was also observed. The
maximum increase in the strain value from 430 to 1220
was recorded at 308 mm. A temporary contraction in the bare
reinforcement due elastic unloading was also observed after
cracking. Fig. 14 shows strain values at mid section for all the
composites at different load levels, where it was observed
generally that for a given load level, resistance to deformation is
increased in the presence of MF1 fibers in comparison of
composite without fibers and composite containing only MF2
fibers.
In reinforced fibrous concrete containing only MF2 (RC20MF2), the first transverse cracking was occurred between
strain gages at 192 and 250 mm (Fig. 12). Drop in tensile load
and contraction in the bare reinforcement was also observed
similar to other composites. The plot between local strains in
embedded steel at different section and axial load is shown in
Fig. 15. A dramatic increase at section near the crack plane was
A Study on the Reinforced Fibrous Concrete Elements Subjected to Uniaxial Tensile Loading
th = -------------------------------
(1)
553
4. Discussion
Uniaxial tensile test were performed on reinforced fibrous
concrete composites and results have been analysed in term of
tension stiffening effect and strain development in steel bar and
concrete matrix in the presence of two metallic fibers in both
mono and hybrid forms. From the results obtained, the action of
two metallic fibers, whose geometrical and mechanical properties are different, can be explained as follows:
From SEM coupled with replica technique, Turatsinze and
Bascoul, (1996) found that the micro-cracking starts inside the
matrix before the occurrence peak load. At the time of initiation
of micro-cracks, MF1 fibers which are characterised as nonslipping fibers due to rough their surface and larger specific
surface area resulting in high bond strength with matrix, are
stretched and arrest the micro-cracking mechanism through
transferring the stress across the crack edges. By doing this,
micro-cracks formation is delayed resulting in high load carrying
capacity at first macro-crack. From the results obtained, it was
observed that the composites containing MF1 fibers exhibited
high values of first crack load compared to composite without
fibers (RC-CONT) and also offered more resistance to strain
development. Moreover, the propagation of micro-crack towards
the surface of concrete is also obstructed which significantly
influences the surface stiffness; this is evident from the results
obtained about the surface strain at different section in case of
composites containing MF1 fibers.
After the first crack, these fibers being fully stressed shared the
tension with the steel bar and the composite exhibits high tensile
load bearing capacity of cracked matrix, hence increasing the
554
A Study on the Reinforced Fibrous Concrete Elements Subjected to Uniaxial Tensile Loading
cracks are fully developed and MF1 fibers break, MF2 fibers
stop the further opening of micro crack near the concrete-steel
interface (Fig. 22). On the other hand, near the surface of
concrete, MF1 fibers restrain the micro crack formation. In this
way, both types of fibers affect the development and propagation
of crack through out the cross section of concrete matrix which is
not the case with composites containing single fiber; this results
in high tension carrying capacity at first crack which is evident
from the value of first crack load obtained with RC-40HyF
which was maximum of all the composites. Moreover, due to the
combined effect of two types of metallic fibers, RC-40HyF
offered high resistance to strain development both at the concretesteel interface and at concrete surface.
5. Conclusions
Resistance to cracking of reinforced concrete and reinforced
fibrous concrete containing two metallic fibers differing in their
mechanical, physical and geometrical properties have been investigated by performing test on prismatic specimens subjected
to pure tensile loading. The results of this study confirm the
findings of previous research work about the role of fiber
properties to control the cracking mechanism.
Among the type of metallic fibers used in this study; the use of
amorphous metallic fibers (designated as MF1 fibers) appears to
be highly effective in controlling micro-cracks. Given that these
fibers do not face the problem of corrosion when subjected to
aggressive environment and are very effective in controlling
micro-cracking, the reinforced concrete containing these fibers
may prove significantly useful as a material for water retaining
structures and sewerage pipes. Moreover, by the use of these
fibers, durability of the reinforced concrete structure may also
improve by arresting the micro cracks through which the water
penetrates and causes corrosion of the main reinforcement.
Carbon steel hooked-ended fibers (MF2) appears to be more
effective in arresting the macro-cracking which results in improved tensile strength and toughness of the composite after
yielding of steel bar.
The results obtained for the hybrid composite showed that
when these fibers are used in hybrid form, the composite exhibits
resistance to both micro and macro cracking mechanisms which
improves the global response in term of resistance to cracking,
tensile strength and toughness. Based on this observation, it can
be concluded that it is a good way to use these fibers in hybrid
form to improve behaviour of composite at all cracking stages
(micro cracking and macro cracking).
Future Research
In ongoing research program, different hybrid compositions of
these fibers are being tested in order to investigate the positive
synergetic effect between them and also to optimize the dosage
of fibers in hybrid form.
Fig. 22. Crack Development in Axial Tensioned Member
Vol. 14, No. 4 / July 2010
555
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Higher Education Commission of Pakistan for the financial support for this experimental
study.
References
Abrishami, H. H. and Mitchell, D. (1997). Influence of steel fibers on
tension stiffening. ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 94, No. 6, pp. 769182.
ACI 224.2R-92 (1997). Cracking of concrete members in direct tension.
Bischoff, P. H. (2003). Tension stiffening and cracking of steel fiberreinforced concrete. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, Vol.
15, No. 2, pp. 174-182.
Banthia, N. and Nandakumar, N. (2003). Crack growth resistance of
hybrid fiber reinforced cement composites. Cement & Concrete
Composites, Vol. 25, No. 1, pp. 3-9.
Christiansen, M. B. and Nielsen, M. P. (2001). Plane stress tension
stiffening effects in reinforced concrete. Magazine of Concrete
Research, Vol. 53, No. 6, pp. 357-365.
Fields, K. and Bischoff, P. H. (2004). Tension stiffening and cracking
of high strength reinforced concrete tension members. ACI
Structural Journal, Vol. 101, No. 4, pp. 447-456.
Ficher, G. and Li Victor, C. (2002). Influence of matrix ductility on
tension-stiffening behaviour of steel reinforced Engineered Cemen-
556