Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Exchanges: Regulation,
Development and Products
Akhilesh Awasthy
Director (Market Operations)
In this presentation
Fundamentals of Electricity Market
Evolution of Power Exchanges
Regulations for Power Exchange
Products at IEX
Future Products
Fundamentals of
Electricity Market
(Non storable)
Imbalances
Because of
complications in
Production &
Delivery systems,
mismatches will
always exist in supply
& consumption as
against contracted
Power. System
Operator manages
these imbalances
Laws of Physics
Interdependencies
Speed of Light
Congestion
Management
Ancillary
Services
Scheduling &
Dispatch
This commodity
Travels as per laws
of physics which are
unique to itself. We cant
Tell electricity where
to go or not to overload
a route/line. One
transaction of electricity
can affect any or all
other transactions for
delivery.
Production &
Consumption of
electricity is
dependent on
ancillary services
which make the
transmission system
Work, such as
Operating Reserves,
Reactive Power, etc.
SO Schedules Contracts
in advance and mingles
energy in real-time by
Dispatching Generation
to meet demend
as
privatization and liberalization seen as necessary to overcome organizational
inertia, and to attract private investment to serve rapidly growing demand arising
from economic expansion
through
separation of the public good embodied in the infrastructure network, such as
electricity or gas transmission and rail lines, from the associated commodity or
service
Vertical
or
Wholesale or Retail
Pool
or
Exchange
Single
or
Multiple
Auction
or
Continuous
Uniform
or
Pay-as-bid
Implicit
or
Explicit
Bilateral/Exchange Model
Generator
Generator
Central
Market
Bilateral
Contracts
Discom/
Consumer
Centralised Dispatch
Bilateral
Contracts
Power
Exchange
Discom/
Consumer
Decentralised Dispatch
Exchange
Charact
eristics
Pros
Cons
Coordination problems
Consolidated Overview
Participation
Market Offerings
Nord Pool
PJM
AEMO
IEX
Voluntary
DA spot, hour-ahead,
forward, futures, options
DAM, TAM
Double Sided
Double Sided
Double Sided
Double Sided
Closed, Open
Auction &
Continuous
--
Not available
Real-time /
Balancing market
Counter trade
Balancing Market
Purchase of ancillary
services & reserve
capacity
UI charge for
deviations
Pricing Rule
Zonal Pricing
Nodal Pricing
Zonal Pricing
Zonal Pricing
Pricing Type
Ex-ante
Ex-post
Ex-post
Ex-ante
Risk
Management
Forwards, futures,
options
Bilateral OTC
Congestion
Management
Area splitting
Security constrained
economic dispatch
Area splitting
Transmission
Losses
Included in LMP
To be purchased by
generators
To be purchased
by participants
Bidding Type
Adjustment
Market
Evolution of Power
Exchanges
Generation
Vertically
Integrated State
Electricity
Boards (SEB)
Transmission
Distribution
Consumer
Consumer
Consumer
Introducing Competition
Electricity Market
Production
Function
Transportation
Function
Generation
Transmission
Distribution
Merchant
Function
Wholesaling (Supply)
Retailing (Demand)
Natural Monopolies
System operator
Open Access
Imbalance
Settlement
Mechanism
Trading
Autonomous
Regulator
Power Exchange?
Organised Marketplace
Handles
Bidding
Delivery
Money
Risks
Delivery
On-line
Voluntary
National
Automated
Standardized
Contracts
Central
Counterparty
Spot
Intra-Day
Day-ahead
Forward
Weeks
Power Exchange
facilitates
Price Transparency
Risk Management
Standardized Contract
Offers law of One Price
An automatic interface.
Clearing & settlement of deals
Security by being a safe counterpart
Information disemination among the participants
TRADING
BROADCAS
T
CLEARING
DELIVERY
SETTLEMENT
POWER EXCHANGE
Easy Access
Anonymous
Transparent
Reliable
Secure
LIQUIDITY
Price
References
23
24
Open Access means The non discriminatory provision for the use
of transmission lines or distribution system by any licensee or consumer
or a person engaged in generation in accordance with the regulations
specified by the appropriate commission
OTC
PPAs
91%
OTC
Bilateral
<1%
TWh
Upto 25 Years
Medium Term
3 months 3 years
Short Term
9%
10 %
FY10
FY11
Total Generation
11 %
11%
11 %
FY12
FY13
FY14
Short Term
ST Share (%)
9%
FY15
OTC
Bilateral
+
EXCHANGE
Weekly
Daily
Day Ahead
Intraday
4%
3%
100%
28
25
21
19
16
24
31
29
38
51
51
53
50
FY11
OTC(ST)
FY12
Exchange
80%
26
28
60%
16
33
FY10
40%
20%
0%
FY13
FY14
DSM (Balancing)
TWh
Intraday - 3 months
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
FY15
10%
Balancing Market
Real Time
DSM
Frequency
linked
2%
22%
3%
1%
11%
13%
15%
Aug'10
53%
165 GW
2%
0%
9%
Coal
Gas
Diesel
Dec'15
61%
276 GW
Nuclear
Hydro
Ren'
Products at IEX
Day-Ahead
Market
Term-Ahead
Market
10-12 am bidding
Each 15-min block , 0.1 MW min NOC required
since June,08
since Sep,09
Intra-Day
Renewable Energy
Certificates
since Feb,11
Certificates
Continuous
IEX at a glance
ELECTRICITY
Day Ahead Market (DAM)
Day Ahead
Market
1. Intra-day
Contracts
2. Day Ahead
Contingency
3. Daily
Contracts
4. Weekly
Contracts
REC Market
Delivery
Next day
1400-2400 Hrs
same day
Next day
Auction Type
Closed
Auction
Continuous
Trading
Continuous
Trading
Continuous
Trading
Open Auction
Closed
Auction
Contract Unit
15 minute
Hourly
Hourly
Block of Hours
Block of Hours
1 Cert
3400+ Participants
3000+ Industries
300+ Generators
40.0
30.0
7.3
5.2
20.0
3.6
3.5
FY11
FY12
3.5
2.8
FY13
FY14
3.5
10.0
0.0
FY09
FY10
Volume(TWh)
MCP (Rs/kWh)
FY15
Bid Matching
Open/Closed
Auction
Continuous
Trading
[1/2]
Bidding
- Double sided Closed Auction
Order Types:
15-min block or Portfolio Orders
Min 15 Min
Different Price-Quantity Pairs
Partial Execution Possible
Block Orders
Relational Block Bid
Any 15-min block or series of 15-min blocks during the same day
Customized block bid allowed
Order Characteristics
SLDC Clearance should be 0.1 MW (Subject to state regulations issued by
concerned SLDC)
Minimum Order quantity cannot be less than 0.1 MW
Minimum volume step: 0.1 MW
Minimum price step: Rs 1 per MWh ( 0.1p/kWh)
[2/2]
Trading Availability
Every Calendar Day
Delivery Point
Periphery of Regional Transmission System in which the gridconnected entity, is located
12 Bid Areas
20
Portfolio B, MW
60
Portfolio C, MW
40
SUM, Purchase
SUM, Sell
Net transaction
1.1
2.1
2.5
3.1
20
20
20
10
60
50
40
40
40
40
20
-40
-60
-80
-81
-120
120 100
80
80
70
60
60
50
40
-40
-60
-80
-81
-120
80
20
-20
-21
-80
0
120 100
80
4.1
5.0
20
0
40
20
20
-120
40
20
20
-120
-100
-100
Purchase
250
5
Sell
200
4
Price ($/MWh)
Rs./kWh
Price (Rs./MWh)
3
150
2.5
100
2
50
1
0
-150
Volume (MW)
-100
-50
0
MW balance
50
100
150
Open Auction
Continuous Trading
Price-time priority based continuous matching
The highest Buy order & lowest Sell order gets the priority
If the prices are same then priority is given to the time of the order received.
Voluntary
REC Denomination
1 REC = 1 MWh
Validity
Categories
Trading Platform
Banking/Borrowing
Not Allowed
Single transfer only , repeated trade of the same certificate is not
possible
Transfer Type
Solar RECs
Price Guarantee
Future Products
PX
SPOT
2004
2008
PX
Forward
Contracts
Transmission &
Generation
Capacity
Market
Ancillary
Market
2009
2003
2001
Way
Forward
Derivatives
(Futures)
Short-Term
Intraday - 3 months
Balancing Market
Real Time
Unscheduled Interchange/DSM
Ancillary Services
Demand Response
Transmission Licensee
Exchanges
Demand Response
Demand-side response may prove as a appreciation to power
management in supply deficit situation like ours
Derivative Products:
Electricity Derivative (hedge) products allow managing the risk
associated with purchasing electricity off the spot (wholesale) market.
Hedge contracts can shield your expected electricity costs from
unpredictable shifts in the spot market.
PAT
Perform Achieve and Trade (PAT)
A market based mechanism to enhance cost
effectiveness of improvements in energy efficiency in
energy-intensive large industries and facilities, through
certification of energy savings that could be traded
ESCerts Mechanism
Start
2012
Compliance
Mandatory
Obligated Entities
Target
6.6 Mtoe for1st cycle, allocated on SEC basis for each plant
Mechanism
Banking
Denomination of ESCert
1 toe
Issuance
Cycle span
Market Place
Trading Regulator
CERC
POSOCO
Penalty
Designated Consumers
Industry Sector
Aluminum
7500
10
Cement
30000
85
Chlor-Alkali
12000
22
Fertilizer
30000
29
30000
31
30000
144
30000
67
Textiles
3000
90
Total
Accounts for about 165 mtoe of energy consumption annually
1st Cycle target of 6.686 mtoe (TPPs target share is 3.2 mtoe)
*Railways not included
478
Instrument Types
Price Quotation
Price tick
Price Limits
Volume tick
Minimum Order volume limit:
Transaction Fee
Matching
Trading Cycle
ESCert
Cycle
1 year
3 years
Life of Cert
Target
Unit
1MWh equivalent
Renewable Attribute
1 Toe
Energy Conserved
Buyers
Designated Consumers
falling short of Target
Sellers
Designated Consumers
surpassing Target
Banking
No
Yes (1 Cycle)
Multiple Trading
---
Floor Price
Yes
No
Forbearance Price
Yes
No
Regulator
Penalty
SERCs
SERCs
Non-Solar: Rs 1,500/MWh)
Non-Solar: Rs 3,300/MWh)