Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Executive Summary
This report aims to advise Forever 21 (F21), an in-demand American Fashion
retailer on a supply chain management (SCM) and customer relationship
management (CRM) cloud-based solution. The Chief Information Officer (CIO)
of F21 is interested in updating the current SCM and CRM systems in response to
their customers changing demands. The report adheres to the CIOs key
priorities which are as follows:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
2|Page
Table of Contents
Executive Summary ................................................................................................... 3
Introduction .................................................................................................................. 5
Pros and cons of cloud-based SCM and CRM solutions compared to
their on-site counterparts ...................................................................................... 5
Improvement of customer satisfaction and retention ................................ 6
Main ethics, security and privacy issues ........................................................... 9
Recommendations................................................................................................... 10
Conclusion .................................................................................................................. 13
Overview ..................................................................................................................... 14
References .................................................................................................................. 15
3|Page
Introduction
Forever 21(F21) is an international fashion company with department stores
targeted towards young female adults with sophisticated fashion sense and everchanging preferences. The purpose of this report is to advise F21 on adopting
cloud-based solutions to upgrade their existing SCM and CRM systems, to
efficiently and effectively meet customer demands in order achieve the aims of
F21s chief information officer(refer to Appendix A for these aims).
This report will examine the cloud-computing solution and begins with a
comparison of the advantages and disadvantages of cloud computing compared
to traditional onsite counterparts. Secondly, the report will examine how cloudbased SCM and CRM can achieve organisational F21s goal and aims (refer to
Appendix A). Thirdly, the security, ethics, and privacy issues of cloud-based SCM
and CRM solutions will be explored, where suggestions will also be provided to
combat these. Finally, a scoring model for both SCM and CRM solutions will be
discussed to determine the best of breed cloud solution, that best suits F21s
needs.
retail business, since this method enables F21 to manage the manufacturers
inventory levels, based on pre-established service levels. To make VMI possible
the manufacturer allows the supplier to monitor stock levels and ongoing sales
data. A cloud-based SCM solution will allow F21 to send real-time sales data with
their suppliers who maintain inventory based on pre-established agreements,
compared to sending out manual requests for additional items as needed (JDA,
2015). With a cloud-based SCM that employs VMI, F21 can take advantage of the
savings costs, minimise stock out situations. Additionally, the supplier will also
benefit from this model due to data sharing, accurate forecasts, the reduction in
ordering errors and prioritising shipment of goods (Oracle, 2006). Ultimately,
these benefits will not only improve the efficiency and effectiveness of F21s
supply networks but simultaneously keep customers pleased, giving them
minimal reason to become disloyal.
Supply chain planning (SCP) can assist F21 in creating an effective and efficient
supply network that promotes customer satisfaction and retention. There are
several components to SCP which are outlined in the table below.
Demand planning and forecasting
Distribution planning
Inventory and safety stock planning
tailor their product mix to satisfy customer needs (Ku, 2010). This can be
achieved by adopting a cloud-based CRM, which is architecture to incorporate
operational, analytical and collaborative CRM.
Cloud-based CRM solutions have an operational component which can ensure
F21 is able to provide personalised and highly competent customer service
(Khodakarami, et.al). Since marketing, sales and support staff work on different
aspects of the operational CRM, a cloud-based solution will allow information to
be shared about F21s interaction with the customer, irrespective of where it
occurred within the business. This allows for an enhanced CRM Delivery
Processes since successful campaign management will generate leads for F21.
Additionally, effective sales management will soon convert these leads into
potential customers and then through service management, F21 will be able to
take on a personal approach to provide ongoing support to the customer through
face-to-face and online marketing mechanisms. Finally, F21s complaints
management will improve significantly, ensuring customer satisfaction by
directly addressing customer complaints and implementing a structured followup process. In doing so, F21 will widen, deepen and lengthen their customerbase as well as heighten the level of information available, which can be used to
modify F21s product mix to meet their consumers demands.
In addition, analytical approach can also be applied to examine customer
behaviour and perceptions in order to derive the optimal product mix that will
satisfy and retain F21s customers. It should be noted that cloud-based CRM
solutions enable marketing campaigns to easily shift from a mass approach to an
individual level (Kracklauer et al. 2004). This allows for F21 to cater to their
customers specific needs, thus ensuring F21s customer retention and
satisfaction is enhanced. CRM analytical tools will allow F21 to analyse not only
their customer acquisition retention, product mix and product usage levels but
market prices, quality and demands too. This can best be achieved through
developing a loyalty program which is linked to the cloud-based CRM or by
monitoring customers online sales accounts.
Moreover, collaborative CRM can be utilised to satisfy and keep customers, as
well as identify their needs to develop F21s product mix. F21 could ensure the
entire business has access to and is able to share information on the cloud-based
CRM solution. This allows for the quality of information to strengthen and can be
used to determine the different products their consumers are interested in
purchasing. This component fosters customer communication and collaboration
with the company to allow for a streamlined customer service approach, to
better serve and retain consumers (Khodakarami and Chan, 2011). This
collaboration results in a shift of focus onto the customer, a reduction in
communication barriers and an increase in information integration. As a result
the best product mix can be devised, to ensure F21s customers are served
efficiently and effectively.
If F21 leverages on cloud-based SCM and CRM solutions, they must be aware of
the ethical, security and privacy issues that may arise.
Ethics
Cloud-based solutions can give rise to ethical dilemmas; however Stephenson
(2010) believes the benefits will outweigh the concerns. Cloud computing allows
F21 to participate in networking advances whereby they are able to copy data
from various locations, accessing personal data remotely. Additionally, they can
partake in data analysis advances where F21 can abuse customer data to develop
profiles of individual behaviour. This can cause consumers to become frustrated
and unfaithful, therefore, F21 must ensure they act in an ethical manner to
protect their public presence and maintain the effectiveness of their operations.
However, due to the rapid development of cloud computing there is a time-lag
between the issues that arise and legislations to enforce what is right; hence F21
is forced to apply ethical principles to guide their decision making and ensure
they are acting in an ethical manner.
Security and Privacy issues
The main security and privacy problems of cloud-computing are outlines below:
Insider User Attacks:
Customers could use the solution to access their data, however they could
possibly assist external attackers to acquire additional information in
order to execute complex Internet-based attacks
Cloud provider controls data and thus could lose it or sell it for money
Sub-contractor of cloud computing firm., firm assisting in operation of
software, has access to data and thus is in a good position to make an
attack
External Attacks:
Remote software and hardware can attack cloud infrastructures and
applications such as a denial of service attack whereby attackers attempt
to intercept user access to cloud vendors services.
Social engineering can occur to manipulate cloud customers to provide
information by creating fake identities to gain trust as well as determine
staff roles within F21 to assist in planning an attack.
Central, transnational Information storage:
Cloud-based solutions store information centrally, therefore providing
attackers with data-rich targets whereby all of F21s information could be
accessed in a single attack
Storage of data across many legal territories means that one provider is
subject to diverse laws thus the customers local privacy and security laws
may differ to the storage facilities local territory laws (Kshetri, 2013).
To combat the above mentioned issues, F21 is advised to take the following
privacy and security measures of the vendors that F21 into account when
selecting a vendor.
Table 1.1: Important Privacy and Security measures of cloud computing
8|Page
Encryption
Geographic Redundancy
Backups
Identity Management
mechanism(IMD) from
vendor and client
(Newton, 2010)
Recommendation
Vendor-Managed Inventory
10 | P a g e
geographic location (Kracklauer, et al. 2009). Hence, NetSuite has been identified
as the best of breed which can improve F21s sale performance, productivity
and encourage collaboration between departments.
CRM Support Processes
Moreover, F21 needs a CRM that can provide market research and loyalty
management. Infusion Soft is quite basic in this offering, since this solution will
track the visitors on F21s website and automatically insert customer
information into the system. On the other hand, NetSuite provides excellent
tracking of customer interactions and tracking leads for greater targeting and
customer segmentation (Purch, 2015). This can help F21 optimise their
marketing activities, through the in depth data analysis of customers. They can
use this data to send more tailored communications to customers, based on their
individual needs. This leads to a more relevant interaction with customers, and
ultimately greater sales outcomes. Similarly to SalesForce, NetSuite allows users
to send emails straight from the cloud-based CRM (Beasty, 2007). If F21 adopts
NetSuite which has differentiated itself from other vendors, it will not only
attract new customers but strengthen its existing relationships with customers.
CRM Analysis Processes
Additionally, F21 needs a best of breed CRM that can master lead management,
customer profiling and feedback management, to gain new customers and retain
and satisfy them too. Infusion Soft assign scores to customers to determine how
likely these customers will become loyal (Purch, 2015). Similarly, SalesForce will
allow F21 to closely track each individual customer and tailor marketing
campaigns, in an attempt to entice them to make purchases (SalesForce, 2015).
However, since the retail industry has numerous competitors globally, F21
should seek a CRM that caters for a mass marketing approach. NetSuites cloudbased CRM allows for automated mass updates of leads and locations, allowing
managers to tailor these based on geographic location, which can be vital in
strengthening F21s online customer base (Edwards, 2007).
Conclusion
Hence, F21 is recommended that they adopt a cloud-based SCM solution with
Oracle and a cloud-based CRM solution with NetSuite. This is because our
scoring model shows that Oracle and NetSuite have developed mechanisms that
are highly technical, compared to other vendors and simultaneously address the
CIOs goals and objectives. This is based on our analysis of the scoring model. In
addition, F21 should have a deep understand of the advantages and
disadvantages related to a cloud-based SCM and CRM compared to their on-site
equivalents, recognise how cloud-based SCM and CRM can be adopted to
improve customer satisfaction and retention and be wary of the potential ethical,
security and privacy issues they may come across when implementing a cloudbased SCM and CRM.
12 | P a g e
References
Arnesen, S., C.P.A., 2013, Is a cloud ERP solution right for you? Strategic
Finance, vol. 94, no. 8, pp.45-50.
Beasty, C. 2007, Head to Head: NetSuite and Salesforce.com, Information Today,
Inc, Medford.
Edwards, J 2007, Inside CRM, USA, viewed 26 May 2015, <
http://www.insidecrm.com/articles/crm-blog/get-it-togetherwithcollaborative-crm-53559>
Forslund, H. 2010, "ERP systems' capabilities for supply chain performance
management", Industrial Management & Data Systems, vol. 110, no. 3, pp. 351367.
Hardy, Q 2014, NetSuite: Enterprise Software Still Follows a Manufacturing
Model, The New York Times, USA, viewed 28 May 2015
<http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/05/13/netsuite-enterprise-software-stillfollows-a-manufacturing-model/?ref=topics&_r=0>.
IBM Corporation 2013, CRM in the cloud: what you need to know, New York
JDA, 2015, JDA Vendor Managed Replenishment viewed 26 May 2015
<http://www.jda.com/view/scm-brochure/jda-vendor-managedreplenishment/>
Kandukuri.B.R and Rakshit.A 2009, Cloud Security Issues, paper presented at
the 2009 IEEE international Conference on Services Computing, pp. 517-520
Khodakarami, F. & Chan, Y. 2011, "Evaluating the Success of Customer
Relationship Management (CRM) Systems", Academic Conferences International
Limited, Reading, 04, pp. 253.
Kshetri, N. 2013, Privacy and security issues in cloud computing: The role of
institutions and institutional evolution, Telecommunications Policy, vol. 37,
no.4, pp. 372-386.
Kracklauer, A. H., Mills, D. Q., & Seifert, D. 2004. Collaborative customer
relationship management: taking CRM to the next level, Springer.
Ku, E.C.S. 2010, "The impact of customer relationship management through
implementation of information systems", Total Quality Management & Business
Excellence, vol. 21, no. 11, pp. 1085.
14 | P a g e
Yurong, X., Yen, D.C., Binshan, L., Chou, D.C. 2002, Adopting customer
relationship management technology, Industrial Management & Data Systems,
vol. 102, no. 8, pp. 442-452.
Purch 2015. Top 10 Reviews, viewed 23 May 2015,
<http://crm-software-review.toptenreviews.com/netsuite-review.html>.
SalesForce 2015, What is CRM?, USA, viewed 28 May 2015,
https://www.salesforce.com/au/crm/
16 | P a g e