Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
426
Jana Nagyov
number of alternative uses for public revenues, their governments have given
increasing attention to privatization as an innovative means of lowering costs
and improving the effectiveness of public programs.
Recent changes in the social climate encouraged increased voluntarism
in highly developed countries not yet the case in developing and transition
countries. Currently in Central Europe (Austria, Poland, the Czech Republic,
Germany, Slovakia and Hungary) dramatic changes in behavior can be seen.
For example, thousands of volunteers participated during the 2002 floods in
efforts to save lives and property, collect basic materials, clean, and raise and
distribute money to victims of the floods. It is likely that these events will
help to improve the situation of nonprofit organizations and the perception of
voluntarism in the future.
2. Current Situation
Most nonprofit managers agree that marketing has become essential for the
nonprofits that want to compete for money in a marketplace culture.
However, many studies1 reveal some alarming facts (Skloot, 1988). Only few
nonprofits have incorporated a comprehensive approach to marketing. While
many of them perform one or more marketing functions, few have embraced
a marketing approach to operations.
Marketing directors understand that marketing is more than a collection
of independent functions such as advertising or publications. They see these
tasks rather as pieces of a comprehensive approach. That approach, broken
down to its essence, is to find out what people want and then see that they get
it. This final step is missing in most nonprofits.
Other studies show that the reason most managers in marketing positions
perform only pieces of the whole strategic concept is that they lack marketing
background. They can, therefore, be put into the category of accidental
marketers. Especially in transition countries where the nonprofit sector is
very young and the demand for marketing managers in business is very high,
there are not so many prepared to serve in this typically lower paid sector.
Based on personal interviews in the Czech Republic and on other
international information sources, it could be argued that the marketing
manager if there is such a position in a particular nonprofit tends to be
recruited from different areas of society, mostly having background in
education, law, social work or fine arts, basically in humanities more than in
business. Such managers feel that they are there to help others, but what is
1
See www.danenet.org/snpo
427
missing are the strategic vision and tools to implement the nonprofits
strategic objectives and fulfill its mission successfully.
While a number of nonprofits have begun to add marketing functions
and the personnel to manage them, research strongly suggests that only a few
of them have adopted a comprehensive marketing approach to their
operations. A majority of those currently engaged in marketing came into
their jobs without formal training in marketing; they rate their knowledge
high in some marketing skills, low in others, but they demonstrate little
interest in learning what they do not yet know in such critical areas as
research or direct marketing. While low salary structures are a problem in
attracting top talent, a nonprofit leader who does not appreciate marketing as
a comprehensive process and is not fully committed to incorporating the
marketing approach into the organizations operating strategies may
represent even a larger problem.
The managerial practices of existing and future nonprofit managers can
be significantly improved, if they accept proper marketing philosophy,
develop a systematic approach to marketing problem-solving, and are able to
use the concepts and techniques proven in the forprofit sector.
Translated into practice, an organization adopting a marketing approach
would be driven by a four-step process:
Do research to learn what the market wants, what it needs, and what
it thinks of the organization and its competition;
Design the organizations offerings (products and services
considering factors such as hours, locations, pricing, customer
service, and sustainable quality) to meet the needs or desires of the
market, as determined by the research;
Communicate the organizations offerings through advertising,
publicity, publications, personal contacts, or special events
(highlighting the benefits that research indicates are key to the
market);
Evaluate the success of the communication, learn how the market
responds to the offerings now, and determine whether to redesign.
With the above-mentioned steps as the basis, the remainder of the chapter
will review the marketing approach and develop further the four-step
concept.
3. Marketing Strategy
The marketing strategy should be an integral part of an organizations
strategic plan, which defines the organizations vision, mission and long-term
428
Jana Nagyov
objectives (see Annex 1). The first step to success is to develop a marketing
mindset among managers and personnel, concentrating on a customeroriented philosophy. This means that everyone must understand that the
customer/clients needs and desires truly determine the success of the
nonprofit organization in the long run.
Customer needs and desires can be identified through research only.
Based on the research findings, the market should be segmented, i.e., divided
into smaller parts with similarities, to be served more effectively. Having
segmented the market, competition coming from widely diverse sources
could be easily identified. Learning about competitors offerings helps to
position the nonprofit activity more precisely by locating gaps in the market.
The next step should be identification of strengths and weaknesses in order to
anticipate how likely is the organizations success in the activity.
The success of the whole nonprofit sector is strongly related to the
macroenvironment (political, economic, socio-cultural and technological) of
the society and to the preparedness of people to help others (as a part of the
culture). Therefore continuous monitoring of the macroenvironment, which
influences the nonprofit sector even more and faster than it does the forprofit
sector, is an indispensable part of marketing research.
Having collected important information about the needs and desires of
potential clients, competitors and the macroenvironment, the first draft of a
marketing plan could be written. A marketing plan starts with the definition
of a marketing mission and strategic objectives, which are derived from the
organizations business plan. The next steps should be determination of the
marketing mix and then the design of an evaluation system (see Figure 1).
429
Analyze Organization
Mission
Objectives
Goals
Culture
Strengths
Weaknesses
Public
to be
served
Competition
Socio-cultural
Political
Economic
Technological
Target markets
Competitive position
Marketing mix
Design
organization
and systems
Set specific
tactics
Determine
performance
benchmarks
Implement strategy
Assess performance
430
Jana Nagyov
Input Publics
Management
Board
Actors
Staff
Internal Publics
Ticket offices
Tourist
information
centers
Travel agences
Marketing firms
Intermediary Publics
Theater
subscribers
Current audience
General public
Publicists
Consuming Publics
431
trends are significant for charities; technological trends for libraries; sociocultural trends for theaters, cinemas, zoos, and recreational services. Every
nonprofit organization should define the main indicators that are crucial for
its current and potential activities and monitor them regularly. Any changes
in the macroenvironment must be signaled, analyzed and used for decisionmaking.
2
3
BCG portfolio matrix uses categories of Question marks, Stars, Cows and Dogs to represent
different strategies based on analysis of the market growth and market share.
McKinsey/GE matrix analyzes the market attractiveness and market strength of a company.
432
Jana Nagyov
Modified
New
Markets
1. Market penetration
Intensify activities, attract
new unemployed to enter
programs
2. Service modification
Distance courses
Evening courses
Short courses
3. Service innovation
E-learning
New specialization
Existing
4. Geographical expansion
New areas of the city
5. Modification for
dispersed markets
Program offered in bigger
villages
Distance courses with tutor
on the spot
6. Geographical
innovation
Geographical
7. New markets
Offer education to
employed individuals
Offer education to
companies
9. Total innovation
New concept of
bachelor studies
New
433
which means that they provide as much service as they can as long as
their resources just cover their costs.
Partial cost recovery means that the organizations operate with a
permanent deficit every year. Public transport companies offering
services in rural areas in the Czech Republic can serve as a good
example.
Budget maximization means that the success and competitiveness of
the nonprofit depend only on the resources the management is able to
attract. In many cases the organization has money but not successful
programs.
Producer satisfaction means concentration on the organizations own
wants and desires. There are many examples of organizations that are
basically self-serving and oriented towards maximizing their own
interests (McKnight, 1977).
434
Jana Nagyov
435
436
Jana Nagyov
Fundraising
Fundraising is a very specific activity existing only in the nonprofit sector.
The basic concept for approaching donors should be very similar to looking
at the consumer/client market. Marketing orientation, data analyses, and
other marketing principles should be easily applied.
The organization must analyze its own position in the marketplace
(position in relation to other competing nonprofit organizations), concentrate
on those donor sources whose interests are best matched to its own
(segmenting, targeting), and design its solicitation programs (offering marketing mix) to supply the necessary satisfaction to each donor group
(results of need and desire analysis).5
4. Marketing Mix
Budgeting
As in a forprofit business, a nonprofit organization has to start by defining
the optimal level of marketing expenditures. There are many methods for
doing it, but setting the marketing budget is an activity specific to each
nonprofit. The task is even harder in the postcommunist transition countries
because the sector as such is still young, with almost no experience from the
past. In many cases, nonprofit organizations lack a stable position. The
demand for services vacillates according to the present situation during the
transition process.
What could be recommended not only in transition economies but
everywhere is the use of the objective-and-task method which is based on the
definition of marketing objectives, determination of tasks to be performed,
and estimation of the costs. All other methods are antiquated and grounded
on experiences accumulated in a relatively more stable environment.
See the chapter on Fundraising by Haibach and Kreuzer for more detailed information.
437
Offer
The nonprofit sector differs from the forprofit one mostly in the perception of
the offerings. Conventionally, offerings are divided into two categories:
products and services. A product is seen as a set of tangible and intangible
layers, and there are alternative definitions. A widely used concept by Kotler
and Andreansen (1991) defines three levels of product: core product, tangible
product and augmented product. The core product represents a core benefit.
The tangible product involves brand name, features, packaging, quality, and
styling. The augmented product entails also some element of service
installation, delivery and credit, warranty, and after-sale service. Pure service
is defined as intangible, inseparable from its producer, variable in its
characteristics, perishable, and dependent on the involvement of the customer
in its production.
On the nonprofit market there are offerings combining product and
service in one. The complexity of the offerings could be linked with
industrial offerings, which are in many cases very individual and serving
very specific demands. The tangible part of the offering is typically smaller
than the intangible. Lovelocks (1983; see Table 2) classical division of
services is useful for better understanding and practical use. All nonprofits
could use this table of types of services to start with organizing and perhaps
cleaning up their portfolio.
As noted previously, most nonprofit activities are totally or partially
services. Therefore, proper staff selection and training, as well as
establishment and maintenance of quality standards are critical.
438
Jana Nagyov
Done to people
(healthcare)
Subscriber (telephone
service)
Nonsubscriber (police
service)
7. Adjustability of supply
High (utilities)
Low (theater)
2. Tangibility
Intangible
(psychotherapy)
5. Extent of possible
customization
Continuing (telephone
service)
6. Stability of demand
Low fluctuation
(insurance)
9. Role of products versus
people
Mostly people
(haircutting)
Idea
genera
tion
Offer
develop
ment
Concept
development
and testing
Market
testing
Marketing
strategy
formulation
Commercialization
Business
analysis
Launch
See the chapter on Strategic Management by Dudo von Eckardstein and Ruth Somsa in this
volume.
439
Cost Management
Value for money is a very popular saying in the forprofit business
environment. It means literally that what someone pays for a benefit should
be no more than what it costs to produce or deliver. Consumer cost is not
only the price paid for goods or services, even in the forprofit sector. The
perception of cost is much broader, and price is only a part of it. An
individual perceives a cost as the sum of price and other costs he/she pays for
things, such as time, transport, distance, comfort, additional services,
personal attention by staff, etc. In different situations and with different
goods and services, the perception of proportions in cost varies. For example,
an individual coming down with a headache on a Sunday evening might be
willing to pay more for pills and go farther to find an emergency pharmacy
because of the urgency of his situation.
The perception of price, time and distance is different in case of an
emergency. This fact has to be stressed because many activities in the
nonprofit sector deal with urgent problems of individuals, communities, and
groups. Furthermore, many offerings are not paid for with money, although
many of them are.
All goods have a dual nature. A benefit on one side is a cost on the other.
This principle is the nature of exchange. As suggested previously,
matching would be a better term than exchange in the nonprofit sector. An
optimal cost management strategy from the marketers standpoint is one that
maximizes the number of matchings (or revenue) for a given cost to the
marketers. The marketer must begin by researching consumer perceptions of
the costs they must pay. Otherwise, crucial but subtle barriers affecting
particular client segments might be missed. For example, the elderly refuse
nursing home care because they would have to admit their age (price); they
are not prepared to pay for comfort because they feel that the price is too
high.
440
Jana Nagyov
(1)
(2)
where fixed costs are expected to be EUR 6000 and the variable costs
per participant are EUR 50.
441
From theory it is known that two additional basic equations are needed.
Total revenue (R) is equal to the price times quantity sold:
R = PQ
(3)
Total surplus (S) is the difference between total revenue and total cost:
S=RC
(4)
2.
(5)
442
3.
4.
5.
Jana Nagyov
443
The result is that the school must have 267 current students paying full
tuition in order to break even. If the school has no additional resources,
management must consider lowering fixed costs, or if the number of
students is higher than the school can manage with the current fixed
costs, increasing tuition.
As mentioned above, the formula could be modified to take into account
surplus. The result answers a crucial question: How many students are
needed to cover the costs and make a reasonable profit of EUR 10,000?
FC + S
400,000 + 10,000
BEP = ---------------; in this case BEP = ---------------------- = 273 students.
P-VC
2000 500
2.
444
3.
4.
Jana Nagyov
445
446
Jana Nagyov
Personal communication
Mass communication
Fast
Low
High
Relatively lower
High
Low
High
Moderate low
Two-way
High
Accurate
One-way
Low
Difficult
447
448
Jana Nagyov
Message
encoding
Message decoding
Noise
Receiver
Feedback
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
449
5. Marketing Control
The purpose of marketing evaluation and monitoring is to maximize the
probability that the organization will achieve its short- and long-run
objectives in the marketplace. Monitoring systems are an intrinsic part of the
planning process since they permit crucial and timely adjustments. The
monitoring system in a nonprofit organization can differ from that in a
forprofit one basically, it can be less rigid and complicated. However, it
must include the following steps:
1.
2.
3.
4.
450
Jana Nagyov
2.
3.
4.
451
The marketing tools used in nonprofit organizations, small and large ones,
are the same as those used by businesses. However, how those tools are used
differs because of the difference in the offerings (product and service, the
kind of market) and organizations (type, size).
It is important for nonprofit organizations to conduct market analyses
and to segment and target their markets, but marketing research is often
difficult, and there is usually not much secondary information available.
Nonprofit organizations should develop strategies regarding positioning,
branding (if relevant) and the offering mix. They often use marketing
communication tools, including public service advertisements. Their
channels of distribution are usually very short, going directly from provider
to consumer without using intermediaries. Finally, pricing strategies are often
different from those used by profit-oriented businesses because the objectives
are not the same.
Good marketing is integrated marketing. Two principles are important
when designing and implementing a marketing mix, i.e., interaction and
synergy. Marketing instruments have to be combined in such a way that the
organizations offering is consistently marketed. In other words, all
marketing instruments have to work in the same direction, and not conflict
452
Jana Nagyov
with each other. The second important principle is synergy. The instruments
in the marketing mix have to be designed in such a way that the effects of the
tools are mutually reinforcing.
Ultimately, for marketing to be most effective, it should be formally
integrated into a nonprofit institutions organizational structure through a
marketing committee, task forces, marketing specialist firms, marketing
consultants, a marketing director, or a marketing vice-president.
Suggested Readings
McLeish, B.J. (1995): Successful marketing Strategies For Nonprofit Organizations.
John Wiley&Sons
Drucker, P.F./De Pree, M./Buford, R. (1992): Managing the Non-Profit Organization:
Principles and Practices. HarperBusiness, Reprint Edition
Herron, D.B. (1996): Marketing Nonprofit Programs and Services: Proven and
Practical Strategies to Get More Customers. Members, and Donors. Jossey-Bass
Grobman, G.M. (2000): The Nonprofit Organizations Guide to E-Commerce. White
Hat Communications
Ratke, J.M. (1998): Strategic Communications for Nonprofit Organizations: Seven
Steps to Creating a Successful Plan. John Wiley&Sons, Boot&Disk Edition
References
Bennett, P.D. (1988): Dictionary of Marketing Terms. Chicago
Beracs, J./Bauer, A./Simon, J. (1996): Marketing for Expanding Europe. Proceedings
of the 25th EMAC Conference. Budapest
Cornwell, T./Maignan, I. (1998): An International Review of Sponsorship Research.
In: Journal of Advertising, 27(1)
De Pelsmacker, P./Geuens, M./van den Bergh, J. (2001): Marketing Communications.
In: Financial Times. Prentice Hall
Duncan, J./Everett, B. (1993): Client Perceptions of Integrated Marketing
Communication. In: Journal of Advertising Research, May/June, 30-9
Drucker, P. (1989): What Business Can Learn from Nonprofits. In: Harvard Business
Review, July-August
Drucker, P. (1990): Managing the Non-Profit Organization. Oxford
Engel, J./Warshaw, M./Kinnear, T. (1991): Promotional Strategy, Managing the
Marketing Communication Process. Homewood
European Commission (1996): Green Paper on Commercial Communication in the
Internal Market
Fombrun, C. (1996): Reputation: Realising Value from the Corporate Image. Harvard
453
Annex
Nonprofit Organization Business Plan
Every business plan should include:
454
Jana Nagyov
A table of contents
A summary of the plan, including:
o Vision and/or mission declaration
o Brief paragraph about the organization and its long-term
objectives
o Four-line description of the offering to be introduced
o Four-line description of the market
o Brief paragraph on production/preparation
o Paragraph on distribution, if needed
o Short paragraph on financial requirements
A description of the organization and new business with description
of:
o Organization
o New offerings
o Target consumer
o The consumers need for the offering
o Sales strategy
A description of the market for the new offering, including
information on the competition and cost/price comparisons between
competitors and the organization
A marketing plan that includes information on:
o Markets
o Customers
o Competitors
o Microenvironment
o Demography
o Economy
o Technology
o Government
o Culture
o How each of these areas affects the marketing of offerings
o Evaluation of potential problems
Financial plan, including:
o Sources and applications of cash and capital
o Equipment list
o Balance sheet
o Break-even analysis
o Cash flow estimates by month for the first year and by
quarter for the second and third year, with notes of
explanation for each of the estimates
o Projected income and expenses for the first three years,
with notes of explanation
o Historical financial reports for the organization, such as
455