Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Materialism/Physicalism
Encephalic Injury (Phineas Gage)
Question 1:
Mind-Body Split
MIND
(thinking thing or substance, soul, spirit)
(res cogitans)
BODY
(physical thing, extended substance,
matter) (res extensa)
(Substance) Dualism
Dualism (L, dualis, duo, two): the view that
reality consists of two quite distinct
substances.
In philosophy of mind, the belief that the
mental and physical are deeply different in
kind: thus the mental is at least not identical
with the physical.
a ghost
mysteriously
ensconced in a
machine (Gilbert
Ryle, The Concept of
Mind (1949))
PHYSICAL EVENT
Hammer hits toe
MENTAL EVENT
Pain
CAUSAL RELATIONSHIP
Weeping
Sad thoughts
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KXojf4hYGQk
Neurons?
88
Imagine 2 scenarios:
A. Billiard ball miraculously starts to move?
B. Billiard ball miraculously comes to a halt?
Parallelism
The view that mental and physical phenomena
occur in parallel but that these simultaneities
never involve causal interactions.
Correlation but not causation.
Pre-established Harmony
A view originated by Leibniz
whereby
1. the mental and the material
comprise two different kinds of
substance
2. neither has any direct causal effect
on the other
3. the coincidence between mental
and material events is due to both
substances being created to act in
concert even though there is no
post-creation interaction between
the two.
Mind
Body
Occasionalism
A view popularized by Nicolas
Malebranche (1638-1715)
whereby:
1.
2.
3.
Materialism/Physicalism
The view that everything that actually exists is
material, or physical. Materialists are
philosophers who think that there exists in the
universe just one substance: matter. There is
no mind distinct from the body directing its
actions.
Scientific Evidence
Cheshire Cat
Its a friend of mine -a Cheshire Cat, said
Alice: allow me to
introduce it.
The Cat's head
began fading away the
moment he was gone,
and, by the time he
had come back with
the Dutchess, it had
entirely disappeared.
--Lewis Carroll, Alice in
Wonderland
MIND
Non-spatial
BODY
MIND
Non-spatial
BODY
Spatial
MIND
Non-spatial
Non-observable
BODY
Spatial
MIND
Non-spatial
Non-observable
BODY
Spatial
Observable
MIND
Non-spatial
Non-observable
Non-physical
BODY
Spatial
Observable
MIND
Non-spatial
Non-observable
Non-physical
BODY
Spatial
Observable
Physical
MIND
Non-spatial
Non-observable
Non-physical
Private
BODY
Spatial
Observable
Physical
MIND
Non-spatial
Non-observable
Non-physical
Private
BODY
Spatial
Observable
Physical
Public
MIND
Non-spatial
Non-observable
Non-physical
Private
Free
BODY
Spatial
Observable
Physical
Public
MIND
Non-spatial
Non-observable
Non-physical
Private
Free
BODY
Spatial
Observable
Physical
Public
Determined