Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
LANDESMUSEUMS FR
VORGESCHICHTE HALLE
I S B N 978 - 3 - 9 4 4 5 07-2 9 - 3
I S S N 18 6 7- 4 4 0 2
12/II
12/II
2015
Tagungen des
Landesmuseums fr Vorgeschichte Halle
Band 12/II|2015
Tagungen des
Landesmuseums fr Vorgeschichte Halle
Band 12/II|2015
landesmuseum fr vorgeschichte
herausgegeben von
Harald Meller,
Helge Wolfgang Arz,
Reinhard Jung und
Roberto Risch
Halle (Saale)
2o15
isbn 978-3-9445o7-29-3
issn 1867-44o2
Redaktion
Redaktion und bersetzung
der englischen Texte
Organisation und Korrespondenz
Technische Bearbeitung
Markus C. Blaich, Konstanze Geppert, Kathrin Legler, Anne Reinholdt, Manuela Schwarz,
Anna Swieder, David Tucker, Melina Wieler
Sandy Hmmerle Galway (Irland), Isabel Aitken Peebles (Schottland), David Tucker
Konstanze Geppert, Anne Reinholdt
Thomas Blankenburg, Anne Reinholdt, Nora Seelnder
Sektionstrenner Gestaltung: Thomas Blankenburg, Nora Seelnder;
S.33 Photograph Brooklyn Museum, Charles Edwin Wilbour Fund, 39.1. Creative
Commens-BY; S.95 Eberhard-Karls-Universitt Tbingen; S.333 UAB-ASOME;
S.481 R.Kolev (National Museum of History, Sofia), Dr. M.Hristov (National Museum
of History, Sofia); S.669 J.Liptk, Mnchen; S.8o3 Aberdeen University Museum,
National Museums of Scotland, Dr. A.Sheridan (National Museums of Scotland)
Umschlag Malte Westphalen, Nora Seelnder
Fr den Inhalt der Arbeiten sind die Autoren eigenverantwortlich.
Inhalt/Contents
Band I
What is an event?
35 Harvey Weiss
The 4.2ka BP climatic event in west and central Anatolia: combining palaeo-climatic proxies
and archaeological data
97 Hermann Genz
Beware of environmental determinism: the transition from the Early to the Middle Bronze Age
on the Lebanese coast and the 4.2ka BP event
The Aegean before and after c. 22ooBC between Europe and Asia: trade as a prime mover
of cultural change
Archaeological and environmental impact of the 4.2 ka cal BP event in the central and eastern
Mediterranean
The transition between the Copper and Bronze Ages in southern Italy and Sicily
283 Giovanni Leonardi, Michele Cupit, Marco Baioni, Cristina Longhi, and Nicoletta Martinelli
Northern Italy around 22oocal BC. From Copper to Early Bronze Age: Continuity and/or
discontinuity?
The late 3rd millenium BC in pollen diagrams along a south-north transect from the Near East
to northern Central Europe
335 Laurent Carozza, Jean-Franois Berger, Cyril Marcigny, and Albane Burens
Society and environment in Southern France from the 3rd millennium BC to the beginning of
the 2nd millennium BC: 22ooBC as a tipping point?
365 Vicente Lull, Rafael Mic, Cristina Rihuete Herrada, and Roberto Risch
Transition and conflict at the end of the 3rd millennium BC in south Iberia
Social change in the late 3rd millennium BC in Portugal: the twilight of enclosures
429 Germn Delibes de Castro, Francisco Javier Abarquero Moras, Manuel Crespo Dez,
Marcos Garca Garca, Elisa Guerra Doce, Jos Antonio Lpez Sez, Sebastin Prez Daz,
and Jos Antonio Rodrguez Marcos
The archaeological and palynological record of the Northern Plateau of Spain during the
second half of the 3rd millennium BC
449 Martin Klling, Vicente Lull, Rafael Mic, Cristina Rihuete Herrada, and Roberto Risch
461 Mara Weinelt, Christian Schwab, Jutta Kneisel, and Martin Hinz
Climate and societal change in the western Mediterranean area around 4.2ka BP
Band II
Sektion Mittel- und Osteuropa/
Section Central and Eastern Europe
New evidence for funeral and ritual activity in the northern part of the Balkan Peninsula:
a case study from Southern Bulgaria in the second half of the 3rd millennium BC to the first
half of the 2nd millennium BC
503 Klra Pusztain Fischl, Viktria Kiss, Gabriella Kulcsr, and Vajk Szevernyi
525 Mirosaw Furmanek, Agata Hauszko, Maksym Mackiewicz, and Bartosz Myslecki
New data for research on the Bell Beaker Culture in Upper Silesia, Poland
Living on the North European Plain around 22ooBC: between continuity and change
561 Franois Bertemes and Volker Heyd
22ooBC Innovation or Evolution? The genesis of the Danubian Early Bronze Age
Winter climate and weather conditions during the Little-Ice-Age-like cooling events of the
Holocene: implications for the spread of Neolithisation?
Extreme climate events identified by wood-anatomical features for the Main Valley (Southern
Germany) A case study for 3ooo2oooBC
Settlement dynamics and land use between the Hegau and the western Lake Constance region,
Germany, during the second half of the 3rd millennium BC
617 Philipp W. Stockhammer, Ken Massy, Corina Knipper, Ronny Friedrich, Bernd Kromer,
Susanne Lindauer, Jelena Radosavljevic, Ernst Pernicka und Johannes Krause
Kontinuitt und Wandel vom Endneolithikum zur frhen Bronzezeit in der Region Augsburg
Evidence for climate change between 22ooBC and 216oBC derived from subfossil bog and
riverine trees from Germany
Crisis what crisis? Innovation: different approaches to climatic change around 22ooBC
Sektion Mitteldeutschland/
Section Central Germany
Das 3.Jt. v.Chr. zwischen Saale und Unstrut Kulturelle Vernderungen im Spiegel
der Radiokohlenstoffdatierung
Why we should not ignore the mid-24th century BC when discussing the 22oo2oooBC climate
anomaly
Anhang/Appendix
Ergebnistabelle/Table of results
Zusammenfassung
Summary
Introduction
The period between 23ooBC and 21ooBC represents a time
of change in many areas of the Old World, and this is also
true for the Carpathian Basin, and for Hungary in partic
ular. This crucial transition has been described in a number
of different ways.
It was an important turning point of Hungarian Bronze
Age archaeology when, in connection with an international
travelling exhibition of the material of Bronze Age tell settle
ments in the Great Hungarian Plain, a summary of the new
research results was attempted (Meier-Arendt 1992). Though
the exhibition catalogue showed only glimpses of the rich
material of Bronze Age tell settlements, it became a hand
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
504
K L R A P U S Z TA I N F I S C H L , V I K T R I A K I S S , G A B R I E L L A K U L C S R , A N D V A J K S Z E V E R N Y I
Absolute
Bulgaria
dates (BC)
Central
Hungary
Europe
Reinecke Bz
Abb.1ab a Der Anfang der Bronzezeit in Sdost- und Mitteleuropa; b bersicht der spten
kupferzeitlichen, frh- und mittelbronzezeit
lichen Chronologie sowie der Kulturen/
Gruppen in Ungarn.
A1
2200/2100
EBA III
2300
Reinecke Bz
EBA 2
A0
2600/2500
EBA 1
EBA II
Eneolithic
Transitional
period
2900/2800
Late
Late Copper
EBA I
Neolithic
Age
3500/3400
cal BC
Central
Europe
Hungary
1500/1450
RB B
MBA 3
MBA 2
RB A2
Western Hungary
Eastern Hungary
Vatya
FzesabonyGyulavarsnd/
Otomani
Hatvan
Maros
Kisapostag
Gta-Wieselburg I
Late Nagyrv
Kisapostag
Late Nagyrv
Hatvan
Nyrsg/Szaniszl
Otomani I
Maros
Late Somogyvr/Proto
Kisapostag
Bell Beaker
Late Mak
Proto and Early
Nagyrv
Late Mak
Nyrsg
Early Nagyrv
Early Maros
Late Vuedol/Early
Somogyvr-Vinkovci
Mak
Mak
Yamnaya
Vuedol, Kostolac
Late Baden
Vuedol
Late Baden,
Kostolac
Late Baden,
Yamnaya, Early
Mak
Baden
Baden
Baden
Pre-Yamnaya
Encrusted Pottery
Gta-Wieselburg II
MBA 1
2000/1900
RB A1
EBA 3
2200/2100
2300/2200
RB A0
EBA 2
Somogyvr-Vinkovci
2500/2400
2900/2800
Eneolithic
Late
Copper
Age
EBA 1
Late
Copper
Age
3500/3400
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
O L D A N D N E W N A R R AT I V E S F O R H U N G A R Y A R O U N D 2 2 0 0 B C
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
505
K L R A P U S Z TA I N F I S C H L , V I K T R I A K I S S , G A B R I E L L A K U L C S R , A N D V A J K S Z E V E R N Y I
arp
er n C
No
Austria
Slovakia
Mtra
To
k
kk
B
rth
N
ea
ste
Ukraine
aj
st
hwe
N or t
ns
athia
Tis
rn
Ca
rp
za
at
hia
ns
Gu
tin
n
ai
Pl
n
ia
ar
g
1
un 2 Srrt
tH
a
e
Krs
Gr
Hungary
Apuseni
Mountains
Maros
Romania
Croatia
s
thian
arpa
Slovenia
er n C
East
bia
nu
a
d
ns
Tra
Danub
506
Drava
Serbia
hians
arpat
C
n
r
e
South
Sava
Fig.2ab a 1 The Danube River region; 2 eastern Hungary the Tisza and Maros River regions; 3 western Hungary/Transdanubia; b Bronze Age sites
ment ioned in the text: : settlement, burial, hoard; n tell settlement.
Abb.2ab a 1 Die Donauregion; 2 Ostungarn Theiss- und Marosgebiet; 3 Westungarn/Transdanubien. b Die im Text erwhnten bronzezeitlichen Fundstellen. Siedlung, Bestattung, Hortfund; n Tellsiedlung.
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
O L D A N D N E W N A R R AT I V E S F O R H U N G A R Y A R O U N D 2 2 0 0 B C
28
45
21
10 16
12
14
11
43
34 13
3538
18
17
5 15
9
25
2
46
3
4
29
33
19
40
41
42
20
7
6
1
27
22 24
39
44
23
32
26
31
30
100 km
1 Bakonszeg-Kdrdomb 8 Bonyhd
2 Balatonakali
9 Blcske-Vrsgyr
3 Balatonkeresztr-Rti 10 Budakalsz-Csajerszke
11 Budapest-Albertfalva
dl
4 Balatonszd-Temeti- 12 Budapest-Bksmegyer
dl
13 Budapest-Csepel 5 Baracs-Bottynsnc
Hollandi t
6 Berettyjfalu-Herply 14 Domony
7 Berettyjfalu-Nagy 15 DunafldvrBcs-dl
Klvriahegy
b
16 Dunakeszi-Szkesdl 25 Mnfcsanak-Szles 17 Dunajvros-Duna-dl
fldek
18 Ercsi-Sina-telep
26 Mokrin
19 Fajsz
27 Nagyrv-Zsidhalom
20 Gborjn-Csapszkpart 28 Nin Myla
29 Ordacsehi-Cserefld
21 Herndkak
22 Kiskundorozsma 30 Ostrikovac
Hosszht-halom
31 Patulele
23 Kiszombor
32 Pecica/Pcska
24 Klrafalva-Hajdova
33 Pcs-Nagyrpd
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
507
508
K L R A P U S Z TA I N F I S C H L , V I K T R I A K I S S , G A B R I E L L A K U L C S R , A N D V A J K S Z E V E R N Y I
Proto Aunjetitz
Bell Beaker
N
Nitra
Bell Beaker
Late Mak
Nyirsg
Late Mak
Early Nagyrv
Early Nagyrv
Somogyvr-Vinkovci
Early Maros
Somogyvr-Vinkovci
100 km
been published from the site of Berettyjfalu-Nagy-Bcsdl, co. Hajd-Bihar (Hungary; Dani/Kisjuhsz 2o13), two
from cremation graves and two from settlement features.
Their combined date is 255o 246o calBC (Kulcsr/Szever
nyi 2o13). The earliest AMS radiocarbon date for Hatvantype material is known from Velince, okr. Rimavsk
Sobota (Slovakia), in the northern Carpathian Basin, and
dates its formation to 219o 2o4o calBC (Grsdorf etal.
2oo4). The early Hatvan phase can be dated in the light of
its connections, for example with the Late Nyrsg, Sza
niszl (Dani 2oo5), and Late Nagyrv groups, and a few new
radiocarbon dates, to c. 22oo 19ooBC at the earliest.
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
O L D A N D N E W N A R R AT I V E S F O R H U N G A R Y A R O U N D 2 2 0 0 B C
netice
N
Nitra
Late Nyirsg
Gta-Wieselburg
Hatvan
Kisapostag
Stanislau
Nagyrv
Nagyrv
Early Otomani
Nagyrv
Kisapostag
Maros
Early Vatin
100 km
509
2200/2100 BC
K L R A P U S Z TA I N F I S C H L , V I K T R I A K I S S , G A B R I E L L A K U L C S R , A N D V A J K S Z E V E R N Y I
Kisapostag
Gta/
Wieselburg
Nagyrv
Hatvan
Early Nagyrv
Late Mak
Maros
L. Nyrsg/
Sanislau
2300/2200 BC
510
Somogyvr
Bell Beaker
Early Maros
Nyrsg
Fig.5 Selected typical ceramic finds from the Carpathian Basin/Hungary around 23oo/22ooBC and 22oo/21ooBC.
Abb.5 Eine Auswahl typischer Keramikfunde aus dem Karpatenbecken/Ungarn um 23oo/22oo v.Chr. und 22oo/21oo v.Chr.
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
O L D A N D N E W N A R R AT I V E S F O R H U N G A R Y A R O U N D 2 2 0 0 B C
OxCal v4.2.4 Bronk Ramsey (2013); r:5 IntCal13 atmospheric curve (Reimer et al. 2013)
Sequence Szigetszentmikls
Boundary start
R_Date Grave 49
R_Date Grave 50
4500
4000
3500
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
OxCal v4.2.4 Bronk Ramsey (2013); r:5 IntCal13 atmospheric curve (Reimer et al. 2013)
Sequence Bksmegyer
Boundary start
Boundary end
3500
3000
2500
2000
1500
Fig.6ab Bayesian analysis of radiocarbon dates from Bell Beaker cemeteries in Hungary: a Szigetszentmikls-Fels rge-hegyi dl; b BudapestBksmegyer (see Appendix 1 for data).
Abb.6ab Bayessche Statistik von 14 C-Daten aus glockenbecherzeitlichen Grberfeldern in Ungarn: a Szigetszentmikls-Fels rge-hegyi dl; b Budapest-Bksmegyer (Daten siehe Appendix 1).
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
511
512
K L R A P U S Z TA I N F I S C H L , V I K T R I A K I S S , G A B R I E L L A K U L C S R , A N D V A J K S Z E V E R N Y I
OxCal v4.2.4 Bronk Ramsey (2013); r:5 IntCal13 atmospheric curve (Reimer et al. 2013)
Sequence Mokrin
Boundary start
Phase Mokrin 2
R_Date Grave 208
R_Date Grave 52
Phase Mokrin 3
Boundary end
4000
3500
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
OxCal v4.2.4 Bronk Ramsey (2013); r:5 IntCal13 atmospheric curve (Reimer et al. 2013)
Sequence Kiskundorozsma-Hosszht-halom
Boundary start
R_Date Grave 55
R_Date Grave 66
R_Date Grave 15
Boundary end
4000
3500
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
Fig.7ab Bayesian analysis of radiocarbon dates from EBA 3 cemeteries in Hungary: a Mokrin; b Kiskundorozsma-Hosszht-halom (see Appendix 1
for data).
Abb.7ab Bayessche Statistik von 14 C-Daten aus Grberfeldern der Frhbronzezeit 3 in Ungarn: a Mokrin; b Kiskundorozsma-Hosszht-halom (Daten
siehe Appendix 1).
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
O L D A N D N E W N A R R AT I V E S F O R H U N G A R Y A R O U N D 2 2 0 0 B C
Fig.8ab a Climatic zones of the Carpathian Basin: 1 oceanic climatic effect; 2 forest-steppe climatic zone; 3 sub-Carpathian climatic zone; 4 transi
tional climatic zone; 5 relative frequency of sub-Mediterranean climatic effect. b Vegetation zones of the Carpathian Basin: 1 Pannonian forest steppe
region; 2 sub-Mediterranean oak forest region; 3 mixed zone between the sub-Mediterranean and central European forest regions; 4 Balkan oak forest
region; 5 Central European oak forest region; 6 beech and coniferous forest; 7 distribution of silver lime (Tilia tomentosa).
Abb.8ab a Klimazonen des Karpatenbeckens: 1 Meeresklimaeffekt; 2 Wald-Steppen-Klimazone; 3 subkarpatische Klimazone; 4 klimat ische bergangszone; 5 relativ hufiges Auftreten des submediterranen Klimaeffekts. b Vegetationszonen des Karpatenbeckens: 1 pannonische Wald-Steppenlandschaft;
2 submediterraner Eichenwald; 3 gemischte Zone mit submediterranen und mitteleuropischen Waldregionen; 4 balkanischer Eichenwald; 5 mitteleuropischer Eichenwald; 6 Buchen- und Nadelwald; 7 Verbreitung der Silber-Linde (Tilia tomentosa).
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
513
514
K L R A P U S Z TA I N F I S C H L , V I K T R I A K I S S , G A B R I E L L A K U L C S R , A N D V A J K S Z E V E R N Y I
LCA
EBA I
EBA II
2200 BC
EBA III
MBA I
distribution area of tells. While such a hierarchical arrange stroyed, after the ruins are levelled a new house is built
ment is possible in the central part of the country, along the exactly in its place, and so the dwelling place of the
Danube and the Middle Tisza Rivers (e.g. Earle/Kristiansen ancestors remains continuous (Chapman 1997; Chapman
2o1o; Szevernyi/Kulcsr 2o12), it does not seem to be valid 1999; Szevernyi 2o13). This metaphorical relationship with
for the Upper Tisza River region or the Hernd River valley, the past, which the tells represent and which becomes
where tells are not surrounded by less special sites (Fischl/ important in the ideology of the communities of the region
Kienlin 2o13). In Transdanubia, west of the distribution of at the period under discussion, is as important to the study
tells, similar socio-economic processes can perhaps be ob- of tell formation as their role in the development of social
served, starting from the EBA phase3 characterised by processes.
Kisapostag style material. We can observe some settlement
concentration and the fortification of certain sites, but
perhaps because of the different environmental circum Economy
stances tells are not formed (Kiss 2o12).
The formation of tells, however, is also the result of the Metallurgy
conscious decisions of their communities. The rebuilding of
the settlements, one above the other, was regulated by social Early Bronze Age copper shaft-hole axes are characteristic
rules and rituals connected to them. The dwelling mounds for the period between the Final Copper Age and the Early
created this way may have been the three-dimensional Bronze Age, shortly after 25ooBC14. This axe type is evi
manifestations of the identity of the communities that lived dence not only for the spread of a new type of metal weapon
there, significant places of cultural and collective memory or tool, but also of a technological innovation. The relative
(Raczky etal. 2o11; Raczky/Sebk 2o14). A similar type of abundance of Early Bronze Age moulds in the region is cer
settlement signalisation was the circular ditch, which also tainly noteworthy and reflects a flourishing local metal
lurgy. One of the regions most interesting find assemblages
appeared in Transdanubia.
With regard to the formation of tell settlements, experi was unearthed at ll, co. Pest (Hungary), where a cache of
ments indicate that the most convincing explanation for moulds for casting flat chisels and shaft-hole axes came to
the burning of the houses is that they were burnt inten light (Kvri/Patay 2oo5). The radiocarbon date from here is
tionally, probably for ritual reasons (Bankoff/Winter 1979; fairly late (234o 213ocalBC) in comparison with the typo
Gheorghiu 2oo7; Gheorghiu 2oo8). The suggestion is that logical dating (Mak style, EBA2a). This indicates that such
this intentional burning may have connected to the life typologically early (Kozarac/Dunakmld) axes were proba
cycle of those living in the house. During intentional house bly produced even in the last third of the 3rd millenniumBC
burning, through the transformative medium of fire, the (Fig.9).
house is transformed into an ancestral place. It becomes a
From around 25ooBC until somewhere between 23ooBC
source of social and ideological value, which can be ex- and 22ooBC, in the formative Early Bronze Age or Reinecke
ploited later on. This act at the same time ensures the clo Ao phase, the artefacts (e.g. daggers; see Fig.8) of a new type
sure of a cycle, causing discontinuity, and the opening of a of metallurgy started to spread, possibly mostly through the
new cycle, creating continuity. Although the house is de- Bell Beaker network (Bertemes/Heyd 2oo2; EBA phase2 in
14 Hansen 2oo9; Hansen 2o1o; Dani 2o13;
Szevernyi 2o13a.
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
O L D A N D N E W N A R R AT I V E S F O R H U N G A R Y A R O U N D 2 2 0 0 B C
Subsistence economy
Despite recent advances, our knowledge of Early Bronze
Age subsistence practices and their changes through time
remains rather sketchy. With regard to plant cultivation, we
have few analyses from EBA23 sites. At Pcs-Nagyrpd,
co. Baranya (Hungary), einkorn (Triticum monococcum),
emmer (Triticum dicoccum), and compact wheat (Triticum
spp.) dominated, complemented by six-rowed barley (Hor
deum vulgare), lentil (Lens culinaris) and pea (Pisum sativum; Hartynyi etal. 1968, 18; Gyulai 2o1o, 93). Slightly
more data is available from Bell Beaker settlements. Buda
pest-Csepel-Hollandi t (Hungary) yielded mostly sixrowed barley and emmer, while at SzigetszentmiklsVzmvek, co. Pest (Hungary) six-rowed barley, emmer, and
millet (Panicum miliaceum) were attested. The settlement of
Budapest-Albertfalva was sampled more systematically.
Here einkorn dominated, followed by emmer and barley,
and some pulses: pea and horse beans (Macrotyloma uni
florum; Gyulai 2o1o, 93f.).
Very few EBA3 sites have analysed botanical remains,
and in many cases these are tell settlements, where material
from Early Bronze Age and Middle Bronze Age layers was
not always treated separately, and the archaeological con
texts also remain largely unpublished. At Baracs-Bottyn
snc, co. Fejr (Hungary; also known as DunafldvrMacskalyuk; see Szevernyi/Kulcsr 2o12, 3o8f.), the
botanical remains from layers radiocarbon-dated to the
Early Bronze Age are dominated by barley (approximately
8o.oo%), followed by einkorn and lentil (Hartynyi etal.
1968, 13; Hartynyi/Novki 1975, 26). At Tszeg-Laposha
lom, co. Jsz-Nagykun-Szolnok (Hungary), emmer, einkorn,
and barley were attested among cereals, and a fairly large
amount of fine-leaf vetch (Vicia tenuifolia Roth.) was also
found (Hartynyi etal. 1968, 22f.). This seems to indicate
that there was no major difference in the most important
domestic plants exploited during EBA2 and 3.
With regard to animal husbandry, the most interesting
feature of the EBA2 period is the significant number of
horse bones on sites in the Budapest area, which is perhaps
an indication that the Great Hungarian Plain was a second
ary centre of horse domestication during this period. The
proportion of horses in animal bone samples from other
areas is much lower (Bknyi 1978; Bknyi 1992).
The bone material from tell settlements poses the same
chronological problems as the botanical remains. A notable
exception is the material from Szzhalombatta-Fldvr, co.
Pest (Hungary), where systematic sampling took place and
preliminary results are available. Between 24ooBC (or pos
sibly 23ooBC) and 2oooBC, cattle dominate, followed by
sheep/goats and pigs. By 2oooBC, however, animal exploi
tation strategies seem to have changed: both the animal
ratios and the kill-off patterns change, indicating the increasing use of secondary products. Sheep dominate and
are slaughtered at a later age, showing the importance of
515
516
K L R A P U S Z TA I N F I S C H L , V I K T R I A K I S S , G A B R I E L L A K U L C S R , A N D V A J K S Z E V E R N Y I
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
O L D A N D N E W N A R R AT I V E S F O R H U N G A R Y A R O U N D 2 2 0 0 B C
are evident, like the disappearance of Bell Beaker material, tinuous, uninterrupted development of societies in the area,
but continuity can indeed be observed between EBA2 and lasting until the end of the Middle Bronze Age. As prime
3 materials. Settlement patterns do seem to change, as evi movers of change we identify a certain degree of climatic
denced by the appearance of tells, but the earliest tells may melioration, surplus production, demographic growth,
actually predate 22ooBC by a century. Tin bronzes start to increasing social differentiation, and new forms of cultural
appear sporadically before 22ooBC, but their number in- memory and of relationship with the past. The processes
creases after that date and they become widespread after that started here laid the foundations for Middle Bronze
2oooBC this also appears to be a fairly continuous devel Age developments, in which even greater population con
opment. With regard to subsistence, plant cultivation does centration and a hierarchy observed in settlements and
not show any clear break, but there are changes in animal cemeteries culminated in the flourishing material culture
husbandry: the significance of horse breeding decreases in of the Koszider period around 16ooBC.
EBA3, but the use of secondary products really seems to
take off. Large communal cemeteries start with the Bell
Beaker period and some even continue into the EBA3, Acknowledgements
while others are newly founded in this phase. Rich burials
become rarer during EBA3, and the deposition of metal This paper was supported by the Hungarian Scientific Rework in hoards also shows a hiatus.
search Fund (OTKA Project 1o8597) and by the J.Bolyai
To sum up, the transition from Early Bronze Age2 to 3 in Research Scholarship of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.
the Carpathian Basin represents the starting point of a con
Bibliography
Ailincai 2oo 9
S.C.Ailincai, A new Bronze Age axe dis
covered in Northern Dobrudja. Peuce N. S. 7,
2oo9, 4956.
Bcsmegi/Smegi 2oo5
G.Bcsmegi/P.Smegi, Hhalom-Templom
domb bronzkori tell geoarchaeolgiai vizs
glata (Hhalom-Templomdomb: Geoarchaeo
logical investigations of a Bronze Age
tell). Commun. Arch. Hungariae 2oo5,
167176.
Bndi 1966
G.Bndi, The Cemetery of Ercsi-Sinatelep. The
Situation of the SzigetszentmiklsKisapostag
Group of the Nagyrv Culture in the History of
the Early Bronze Age in North-Eastern Trans
danubia. Alba Regia 67, 19651966 (1966)
1125.
Bndi 1982
G.Bndi, Die terminologischen und relativ
chronologischen Probleme der frhen und
mittleren Bronzezeit in Westungarn. In:
A.Aspes (ed.), Il passaggio dal Neolitico allet
del Bronzo nellEuropa Centrale e nella regione Alpina. Problemi cronologici e termino
logici. Atti del X Simposio Internazionale sulla
fine del Neolitico e gli inizi dellet del Bronzo
in Europa. Lazise-Verona 812 aprile 198o.
(Verona 1982) 165181.
Bankoff/Winter 1979
A.Bankoff/F.Winter, A House-burning in Ser
bia. Archaeology 32,5, 1979, 814.
Bende/Lrinczy 2oo2
L.Bende/G.Lrinczy, Kora bronzkori temet
s telepls a kiskundorozsmai Hosszhthalmon (Ein Grberfeld und eine Siedlung aus
der Frhbronzezeit auf dem Hosszht-Hgel
in Kiskundorozsma). Mra Ferenc Mz. vk.
Stud. Arch. 8, 2oo2, 771o7.
Bertemes/Heyd 2oo2
F.Bertemes/V.Heyd, Der bergang Kupfer
zeit/Frhbronzezeit am Nordwestrand des
Karpatenbeckens kulturgeschichtliche und
palometallurgische Betrachtungen. In:
M.Bartelheim/E.Pernicka/R.Krause (eds.),
Die Anfnge der Metallurgie in der Alten
Welt. Euroseminar Freiberg/Sachsen, 18.
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
Czene 2oo 8
A.Czene, Harangednyek Budakalszon (Bell
Beakers at Budakalsz). In: K.Ottomnyi (ed.),
Kpek a mltbl. Az elmlt vek satsaibl
Pest megyben (Szentendre 2oo8) 3233.
Dani 2oo1
J.Dani, A Krpt-medence K-i rsznek kul
turlis s kronolgiai krdsei a kora bronzkor
idszakban (Cultural and Chronological
Questions Concerning the N-E Part of the
Carpathian Basin in the Early Bronze Age). In:
J.Dani/Zs.Hajd/Gy.E.Nagy/L.Selmeczi (eds.),
M (Momos) I. Fiatal skoros Kutatk I.
sszejvetelnek konferenciaktete, Debrecen
1997, november 1o 13 (Debrecen 2oo1)
129161.
Dani 2oo5
J.Dani, A Fels-Tisza-vidk kora bronzkora a
tell-kultrkat megelz idszakban (The
Early Bronze Age of the Upper Tisza region
before the emergence of tell cultures). Unpub.
Diss. Univ. Budapest (Budapest 2oo5).
Dani 2o13
J.Dani, The Significance of Metallurgy at the
Beginning of the Third Millennium BC in the
Carpathian Basin. In: V.Heyd/G.Kulcsr/
V.Szevernyi (eds.), Transitions to the Bronze
Age. Interregional Interaction and SocioCultural Change in the Third Millennium BC
Carpathian Basin and Neighbouring Regions
(Budapest 2o13) 2o3231.
Dani/Fischl 2oo 9
J.Dani/K.P.Fischl, A Beretty-vidk kzps
bronzkori telljei. Topogrfiai megkzelts
(Die mittelbronzezeitlichen Tellsiedlungen
des Beretty-Gebiets. Eine topographische
bersicht). Tisicum 19, 2oo9, 1o3118.
Dani/Kisjuhsz 2o13
J.Dani/V.Kisjuhsz, Bestattungen der MakKultur in Berettyjfalu, Nagy-Bcs-dl. In:
A.Anders/G.Kulcsr/G.Kalla/V.Kiss/
G.V.Szab (eds.), Moments in Time. Papers
Presented to Pl Raczky on His 6oth Birthday.
srgszeti Tanulmnyok/Prehist. Stud. I
(Budapest 2o13) 671692.
Darczi 2o12
T.-T.Darczi, Environmental Changes in the
517
518
K L R A P U S Z TA I N F I S C H L , V I K T R I A K I S S , G A B R I E L L A K U L C S R , A N D V A J K S Z E V E R N Y I
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
O L D A N D N E W N A R R AT I V E S F O R H U N G A R Y A R O U N D 2 2 0 0 B C
gli inizi dellet del Bronzo in Europa. LaziseVerona 812 aprile 198o. Museo Civico di
Storia Naturale (Verona 1982) 139152.
Kalicz-Schreiber 1994
R.Kalicz-Schreiber, Siedlungsfunde und ein
Brandgrab der frhbronzezeitlichen MakKultur in Budapest. Zalai Mzeum 5 (1994)
3959.
Kalicz-Schreiber 1995
R.Kalicz-Schreiber, Bronzkori urnatemet
Szigetszentmikls hatrban (Das bronzezeit
liche Urnengrberfeld von Szigetszentmikls).
Rckevei Mz. Fzetek 2 (Rckeve 1995).
Kalicz-Schreiber 2oo1
R.Kalicz-Schreiber, Vernderungen der
Besiedlungsdichte in der Umgebung von
Budapest whrend des 3.Jahrtausends v.Chr.
(Changes in settlement density in the Buda
pest area during the 3rd millennium BC). In:
A.Lippert/M.Schultz/S.Shennan/M.TeschlerNicola (eds.), Mensch und Umwelt whrend
des Neolithikums und der Frhbronzezeit in
Mitteleuropa. Internat. Arch. 2 (Rahden/
Westf. 2oo1) 16517o.
Kalicz-Schreiber/Kalicz 1997
R.Kalicz-Schreiber/N.Kalicz, Die Somogyvr
Vinkovci-Kultur und die Glockenbecher in
Ungarn. In: B.Fritsch/M.Maute/I.Matuschik/
J.Mller/C.Wolf (eds.), Tradition und Innova
tion. Prhistorische Archologie als histori
sche Wissenschaft. Festschrift fr Christian
Strahm. Internat. Arch. Studia honoraria 3
(Espelkamp 1997) 325347.
Kienlin 2o12
T.L.Kienlin, Patterns of Change, or: Percep
tions Deceived? Comments on the Interpre
tation of Late Neolithic and Bronze Age Tell
Settlement in the Carpathian Basin. In:
T.L.Kienlin/A.Zimmermann (eds.), Beyond
Elites. Alternatives to Hierarchical Systems in
Modelling Social Formations 1, International
Conference at the Ruhr-Universitt Bochum,
Germany, October 2224, 2oo9. Univforsch.
Prhist. Arch. 215 (Bonn 2o12) 25131o.
Kiss 2oo 9
V.Kiss, The Life Cycle of Middle Bronze Age
Bronze Artefacts from the Western Part of the
Carpathian Basin. In: T.Kienlin/B.Roberts
(eds.), Metals and Societies. Studies in honour
of Barbara S. Ottaway. Univforsch. Prhist.
Arch. 169 (Bonn 2oo9) 328335.
Kiss 2o12
V.Kiss, Middle Bronze Age Encrusted Pottery
in western Hungary. Varia Arch. Hungarica 27
(Budapest 2o12).
Kiss etal. forthcoming
V.Kiss/Sz.Fbin/T.Hajdu/K.Khler/
M.Molnr/G.Szab, Contributions to the rela
tive and absolute chronology of the Early and
Middle Bronze Age in western Hungary based
on radiocarbon dating of human bones.
7th international scientific colloquium Bronze
Age Chronologies in the Carpathian Basin.
International conference in Trgu Mures, 24
October 2o14 (Trgu Mures, forthcoming).
Kordos 1987
L.Kordos, Climatic and ecological changes in
Hungary during the last 15,ooo years. In:
M.Pcsi/L.Kordos (eds.), Holocene environ
ment in Hungary. Akadmiai Kiad (Budapest
1987) 1124.
Kovcs 1982
T.Kovcs, Die terminologischen und chrono
logischen Probleme der frhen und mittleren
Bronzezeit in Ostungarn. In: A.Aspes (ed.),
Il passaggio dal Neolitico allet del Bronzo
nellEuropa Centrale e nella regione Alpina.
Problemi cronologici e terminologici. Atti del
X Simposio Internazionale sulla fine del Neo
litico e gli inizi dellet del Bronzo in Europa.
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
519
520
K L R A P U S Z TA I N F I S C H L , V I K T R I A K I S S , G A B R I E L L A K U L C S R , A N D V A J K S Z E V E R N Y I
Maran 1998
J.Maran, Kulturwandel auf dem griechischen
Festland und den Kykladen im spten 3.Jahr
tausend v. Chr. Univforsch. Prhist. Arch. 53
(Bonn 1998).
Mth 1988
M.S.Mth, Bronze Age Tells in the Beretty
Valley. In: T.Kovcs/I.Stanczik (eds.), Bronze
Age Tell Settlements on the Great Hungarian
Plain 1. Inventaria Praehist. Hungariae 1
(Budapest 1988) 27122.
Medzihradszky etal. 2oo 9
Z.Medzihradszky/L.Fkh/B.Berzsnyi/
K.T.Bir/Zs.E.Kovcs/B.Bradk/.Svingor,
Environmental reconstruction of VrsMriaasszonysziget, a multi-period archaeo
logical site in SW Hungary. In: J.-F.Moreau/
R.Auger/J.Chabot/A.Herzog (eds.), Procee
dings Actes ISA 2oo6, 36th International Sym
posium on Archeometry 26 May 2oo6,
Quebec City, Canada. Cahiers darchologie
du CLAT (Centre interuniversitaire d'tudes
sur les Lettres, les Arts et les Traditions) 25,
Sr. archomtrie (Qubec) 7, 2oo9,
2125.
Meier-Arendt 1992
W.Meier-Arendt (ed.), Bronzezeit in Ungarn.
Forschungen in Tell-Siedlungen an Donau
und Thei (Frankfurt on the Main 1992).
Melis 2o13
E.Melis, Data on Early Bronze Age Apparel on
the Basis of a Cremation Grave Excavated at
Mnfcsanak-Szles-fldek. Hungarian Arch.,
(e-journal) 2o13,
<http://www.hungarianarchaeology.hu/
wp-content/uploads/2o13/1o/eng_Melis_
13O.pdf> (o2.o7.2o15).
Merkl 2o1o
M.B.Merkl, Bell Beaker Metallurgy and the
Emergence of Fahlore-copper use in Central
Europe. Interdisciplinaria Arch. 1,12, 2o1o,
1927, <http://iansa.eu/papers/
IANSA-2o1o - o1- o2-merkl.pdf> (18.o8.2o15).
Merkl 2o11
M.B.Merkl, Bell Beaker Copper Use in Central
Europe: A Distinctive Tradition? BAR Inter
nat. Ser. 2267 (Oxford 2o11).
Mozsolics 1967
A.Mozsolics, Bronzefunde des Karpaten
beckens. Depotfundhorizonte von Hajdsm
son und Kosziderpadls (Budapest 1967).
Ndor etal. 2oo7
A.Ndor/E.Tham-Bozs/.Magyari/
E.Babinszki, Fluvial responses to tectonics
and climate change during the Late Weichse
lian in the eastern part of the Pannonian Basin
(Hungary). Sedimentary Geol. 2o2, 2oo7,
174192.
Nmeti/Molnr 2oo2
J.Nmeti/Zs.Molnr, A tell-telepek elterjedse
a Nagykrolyi-sksgon s az r vlgyben
(Verbreitung der Tellsiedlungen in der Ebene
von Nagykrolyi und im r-Tal). Scientia
Kiad (Kolozsvr 2oo2).
Nmeti/Molnr 2oo7
J.Nmeti/Zs.Molnr, A tell-telepek fejldse s
vge a Nagykrolyi-sksgon s az r vlgy
ben (Entwicklung der Tellsiedlungen und
deren Ende in der Ebene von Nagykrolyi und
im r-Tal). Scientia Kiad (Kolozsvr 2oo7).
Nmeti/Molnr 2o12
J.Nmeti/Zs.Molnr, Bronzkori hatalmi kz
pontok szaknyugat Erdlyben. A NagykrolyBobld-tell (Bronzezeitliche Machtzentren in
Nordwest-Siebenbrgen: der Tell von CareiBobld). Monogr. Szegedi Tudomnyegyetem
Rgszeti Tanszkrl 1 (Szeged 2o12).
Olexa/Novek 2o13
L.Olexa/T.Novek, Pohrebisko zo starej
doby bronzovej v Ninej Myli. Katalg I
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
O L D A N D N E W N A R R AT I V E S F O R H U N G A R Y A R O U N D 2 2 0 0 B C
In: A.Anders/G.Kulcsr/G.Kalla/V.Kiss/
G.V.Szab (eds.), Moments in Time. Papers
Presented to Pl Raczky on His 6oth Birthday.
srgszeti Tanulmnyok. Prehist. Stud. 1
(Budapest 2o13) 661669.
Szevernyi/Kulcsr 2o12
V.Szevernyi/G.Kulcsr, Middle Bronze Age
Settlement and Society in Central Hungary.
In: M.Jaeger/J.Czebreszuk/K.P.Fischl (eds.),
Enclosed Space Open Society. Contact and
Exchange in the Context of Bronze Age For
tified Settlements in Central Europe. Stud.
Arch. Ostmitteleuropa 9 (Pozna, Bonn 2o12)
287351.
Torma 1978
I.Torma, A balatonakali bronzkori sr (Das
bronzezeitliche Grab in Balatonakali).
Veszprm Megyei Mz. Kzl. 13, 1978, 1524.
Vicze 2o11
M.Vicze, Bronze Age Cemetery at
Dunajvros-Duna-dl. Diss. Pann. Ser. 4,1
(Budapest 2o11).
Vretemark 2o1o
M.Vretemark, Subsistence Strategies. In:
T.Earle/K.Kristiansen (eds.), Organizing
Bronze Age Societies. The Mediterranean,
Central Europe, and Scandinavia compared
(Cambridge 2o1o) 155184.
Wagner 2oo5
J.Wagner, Muster sozialer Differenzierung im
frhbronzezeitlichen Grberfeld von Mokrin/
Vojvodina. Mitt. Berliner Ges. Anthr. 26 (2oo5)
111146.
Zatyk etal. 2oo7
Cs.Zatyk/I.Juhsz/P.Smegi (eds.), Environ
mental Archaeology in Transdanubia. Varia
Arch. Hungarica 2o (Budapest 2oo7).
Source of figures
15 authors
6 based on Patay 2o13, 3o 9 Fig.19
7 a based on OShea 1992, 1oo;
Forenbaher 1993, 244; b based on
Bende/Lrinczy 2oo2, 87 Tab.1;
Fischl/Kulcsr 2o11, Fig.8 Tab.3
Appendix 1
authors
Addresses
Dr. Klra Pusztain Fischl
University of Miskolc
3515 Miskolc-Egyetemvros
Hungary
fklari@gmail.com
Dr. Viktria Kiss
Institute of Archaeology
Research Centre for the Humanities, Hungarian
Academy of Sciences
ri u. 49
1o14 Budapest
Hungary
kiss.viktoria@btk.mta.hu
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
Vajk Szevernyi
Institute of Archaeology
Hungarian Academy of Sciences
Research Centre for the Humanities
ri u. 49
1o14 Budapest
Hungary
szeverenyi.vajk@btk.mta.hu
521
522
K L R A P U S Z TA I N F I S C H L , V I K T R I A K I S S , G A B R I E L L A K U L C S R , A N D V A J K S Z E V E R N Y I
Appendix
Period
Site/feature
Sample
type
Conventional/AMS
Labcode
BP date
13 C (VPDB)
[]
Bell Beaker/Hungary
Bell Beaker
Szigetszentmikls-Felsorge-hegyi du
lo, grave 10
Human
bone
AMS
VERA-4748
392040
-17.60.7
Bell Beaker
Szigetszentmikls-Felsorge-hegyi du
lo, grave 49
Human
bone
AMS
VERA-4749
383040
-20.11.2
Bell Beaker
Szigetszentmikls-Felsorge-hegyi du
lo, grave 50
Human
bone
AMS
VERA-4750
377535
-20.30.6
Bell Beaker
Szigetszentmikls-Felsorge-hegyi du
lo, grave 367
Human
bone
AMS
VERA-4755
387540
-19.71.1
Bell Beaker
Szigetszentmikls-Felsorge-hegyi du
lo, grave 626
Human
bone
AMS
VERA-4757
384535
-21.41.4
Bell Beaker
Human
bone
AMS
DeA-2875
384536
Bell Beaker
Human
bone
AMS
DeA-2876
383135
Bell Beaker
Human
bone
AMS
DeA-2877
387433
Early Maros
Kiskundorozsma-Hosszhthalom, grave 56
Human
bone
deb-8073
375532
Early Maros
Kiskundorozsma-Hosszhthalom, grave 55
Human
bone
deb-8055
367847
Early Maros
Kiskundorozsma-Hosszhthalom, grave 66
Human
bone
deb-8095
362344
Early Maros
Kiskundorozsma-Hosszhthalom, grave 15
Human
bone
deb-8071
357451
Maros
Human
bone
GrN-14179
369030
Maros
Human
bone
GrN-14178
365530
Maros
Mokrin-grave 52 (phase 2,
Wagner 2005)
Human
bone
GrN-7977
365050
Maros
Human
bone
GrN-14180
365035
Maros
Human
bone
GrN-14181
359535
Maros
Human
bone
GrN-8809
350035
Maros/Hungary
Maros/Serbia
Appendix 1 Individual radiocarbon dates for the Early Bronze Age from Hungary and Serbia.
Appendix 1 Einzelne 14 C-Daten der frhen Bronzezeit in Ungarn und Serbien.
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
O L D A N D N E W N A R R AT I V E S F O R H U N G A R Y A R O U N D 2 2 0 0 B C
Cal BC
References
24722346 (68.2%)
25612290 (95.4%)
23892202 (68.2%)
24592148 (95.4%)
22782141 (68.2%)
23322043 (95.4%)
24552297 (68.2%)
24692209 (95.4%)
24292209 (68.2%)
24582204 (95.4%)
24302208 (68.2%)
24582204 (95.4%)
Kulcsr 2013a
23392205 (68.2%)
24582151 (95.4%)
Kulcsr 2013a
24542296 (68.2%)
24672211 (95.4%)
Kulcsr 2013a
22702062 (68.2%)
22862040 (95.4%)
Bende-Lo
rinczy 2002, 87, Tab.1;
Fischl-Kulcsr 2011, Tab.3
21371981 (68.2%)
22011937 (95.4%)
Bende-Lo
rinczy 2002, 87, Tab.1;
Fischl-Kulcsr 2011, Tab.3
20351919 (68.2%)
21341886 (95.4%)
Bende-Lo
rinczy 2002, 87, Tab.1;
Fischl-Kulcsr 2011, Tab.3
20211830 (68.2%)
21161758 (95.4%)
Bende-Lo
rinczy 2002, 87, Tab.1;
Fischl-Kulcsr 2011, Tab.3
21342033 (68.2%)
21961977 (95.4%)
21231972 (68.2%)
21361944 (95.4%)
21301946 (68.2%)
21921894 (95.4%)
21201956 (68.2%)
21371930 (95.4%)
20131902 (68.2%)
21131831 (95.4%)
18831771 (68.2%)
19191700 (95.4%)
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
523
nationaler Autorinnen und Autoren entsprechend, erscheinen viele Beitrge dieser Reihe in englischer Sprache mit
deutscher Zusammenfassung.
Mit dem bislang zuletzt erschienenen Tagungsband
konnten die Vortrge und Posterprsentationen des 6.Mittel
deutschen Archologentags Metalle der Macht Frhes
Gold und Silber in zahlreichen Artikeln renommierter Forscher verschiedenster Fachdisziplinen vorgelegt werden.
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015
TA G U N G E N D E S L A N D E S M U S E U M S F R V O R G E S C H I C H T E H A L L E B A N D 12 2 015