Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Research
Relationship between periodontal disease and preterm low birth weight: systematic
review
Amare Teshome1,&, Asmare Yitayeh2
1
Department of Dentistry, School of Medicine, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Gondar, Ethiopia, 2Department of
Physiotherapy, School of Medicine, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Gondar, Ethiopia
&
Corresponding author: Amare Teshome, Department of Dentistry, School of Medicine, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of
Gondar, Ethiopia
Key words: Low birth weight, periodontal disease, Preterm birth, systematic review
Received: 27/12/2015 - Accepted: 19/06/2016 - Published: 12/07/2016
Abstract
Introduction: Periodontal disease is a neglected bacterial infection that causes destruction of the periodontium in pregnant women. Yet its impact
on the occurrence of adverse pregnancy outcomes has not systematically evaluated and there is no clear statement on the relationship between
periodontal disease and preterm low birth weight. The objective of this study was to summarize the evidence on the impact of periodontal disease
on preterm low birth weight. Methods: We searched the following data bases from January 2005 to December 2015: CINAHL (cumulative index to
nursing and allied health literature), MEDLINE, AMED, EMBASE (excerpta medica database), Cochrane library and Google scholar. Only case-control
studies with full text in English were eligible. Critical appraisal of the identified articles was done by two authors independently to provide the
possible relevance of the papers for inclusion in the review process. The selected Case control studies were critically appraised with 12 items
structured checklist adapted from national institute of health (NIH). Odds ratio (OR) or risk ratios (RR) were extracted from the selected studies.
The two reviewers who selected the appropriate studies also extracted the data and evaluated the risk of bias. Results: Of 229 articles, ten
studies with a total of 2423 participants with a mean age ranged from 13 to 49 years were met the inclusion criteria. The studies focused on
preterm birth, low birth weight and /or preterm low birth weight and periodontitis. Of the selected studies, 9 implied an association between
periodontal disease and increased risk of preterm birth, low birth weight and /or preterm low birth weight outcome (ORs ranging from 2.04 to
4.19) and only one study found no evidence of association. Conclusion: Periodontal disease may be one of the possible risk factor for preterm low
birth weight infant. However, more precise studies with randomized clinical trial with sufficient follow-up period must be done to confirm the
association.
Introduction
This
bacterial
infections
are
adhered
to
the
Methods
system
the
uninterrupted search for risk factors for preterm birth and LBW that
and LBW not only comes from its capacity to predict increased risk
library and Google scholar. The search terms used were gingivitis,
but it also reflects the mother's exposure to other risk factors such
as
and
is a significant risk factor for preterm low birth weight with odds
ratio of 7.9 [6]. Other similar study done by Hill (1998) found that
studies.
and
the
unfavourable
individual
families.
socio-economic
This
conditions,
necessitates
malnutrition
Results
periodontitis
and
Study type: Full text case control articles written in english which
definition
Operational
Search yield: The search from the databases and manual search
Discussion
follow-up period, and study year, smoking, and alcohol used. The
operational definition of periodontitis was extrapolated from the
be a risk factor for preterm birth and /or low birth weight in many
standard table. The two reviewers (AT, AY), who selected the
appropriate studies also extracted the data and evaluated the risk of
bias.
needs (CPITN), and bleeding index. The other possible factors that
preterm birth alone (PB) [28] low birth weight (LBW), or preterm
birth associated to low birth weight (PLBW) [29]. Even though, the
Conclusion
that
the
difference
in
operational
definition
and
of
immunoresponsiveness
pregnancy,
During
especially
disadvantaged
associated with increased risk of preterm birth and low birth weight
those
carried
out
in
economically
loss
and
depth).
Some
studies
defined
5.
Competing interests
Authors contributions
birth
weight.
Periodontol.
1996;67(10
Suppl):1103-
7.
Periodontology.
Scholar
8.
9.
city of Brazil, 1993. Rev Saude Publica. 1998/06//;32(3):20916. PubMed |Google Scholar
10. Hill GB. Preterm birth: Associations with genital and possibly
References
oral
microflora.
Ann
Periodontol.
1998;3(1):222-
Am
Dent
Assoc.
2006;137(supp):10S-
2.
disease
and
systemic
health.
randomized
controlled
trial.
Periodontol.
Periodontol.
12. Michalowicz BS, Hodges JS, DiAngelis AJ, Lupo VR, Novak MJ,
Ferguson JE ea. Treatment of periodontal disease and the risk
3.
4.
of
preterm
birth.
Engl
Med.
2006;355(18):1885-
Periodontol.
Scholar
study.
Contemp
Clin
Dent.
2011/04;2(2):88-
Int J Appl Basic Med Res. 2015/04/Jan- undefined;5(1):26. PubMed | Google Scholar
Int
Obstet
Gynaecol.
2006
Feb;113(2):135-
24. Kukkamalla
MA,
Thomas
BS,
PralhadKushtagi,
Kaur,
16. Vettore MV, Leal Md, Leo AT, da Silva AMM, Lamarca GA,
birthweight.
Dent
Res.
2008/01;87(1):73-
17. Davenport
ES,
Williams
CECS,
Sterne
JaC,
Murad
S,
Integrated
Research
in
Medicine.
2013
2013;4(2):82-
27. Mumghamba EGS, Manji KP. Maternal oral health status and
preterm low birth weight at Muhimbili National Hospital,
19. Cruz SSd, Costa MdCN, Gomes Filho IS, Vianna MIP, Santos
CT. Maternal periodontal disease as a factor associated with
Tanzania:
case-control
study.
BMC
Oral
Health.
low birth weight. Rev Saude Publica. 2005/10;39(5):7827. PubMed | Google Scholar
population-based
study.
Clin
Periodontol.
2005
Part
I:
Obstetric
outcome
restriction.
control
study.
Clin
Periodontol.
2005/08;32(8):886-
Ann
of
prematurity
Periodontol.
and
growth
2001/12;6(1):164-
outcomes.
Community
Dent
Oral
Epidemiol.
NO
Criterias
Article
Article 2
Article 3
Article 4
Article 5
article 6
article 7
Article 8
Article 9
Article 10
1
1
clearly
stated
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
study
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
size
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Ye
No
No
Yes
cases
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
and
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
differentiated cases
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
objective
2
defined
population
Sample
justification
Homogenous
and controls
inclusion
exclusion criteria
from controls
7
Random selection
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
concurrent controls
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Baseline assessment
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
10
measures
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
yes
of
exposure
11
assessor blindness
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
12
Controlled
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
yes
Yes
11
10
10
10
10
12
confounding factors
Total
Author/publication
Country
year
Sample size
Definition
Periodontitis
of
Confounders
Outcomes
controlled
OR/RR(95%
Conclusion
CI)
Ahmed Haerian
Iran
Case =44
CPTIN
Yes
Control=44
Mothers of LBW
Periodontitis
infants (p=0.042),
and
deep
for LBW
95%
Periodontal disease
1.32-3.48),
is a possible risk
more
is
pockets
(p=0.0006,
Cruza et al.
2005
Brazil
[19]
Case =102
CAL>4mmat least
Control =200
four teeth
Yes
OR=2.15;
CI:
Senegal
Case=129
CAL 3 mm in at
yes
OR = 4 [2.3 - 5.7]
Periodontitis
was
Control =258
significantly
PD 4 mm
Brazil
[21]
Case=76
Control=75
Yes
Periodontitis
1.17; 10.36
considered a risk
mm,
Mannem
and
India
Chaval,2011 [22]
Case=52
CAL3 in at least
Control=52
four teeth
was
Odds ratio=137.5
Periodontal disease
,p<0.0001
could
be
risk
Argentina
Case=53
bleeding index of
AOR=4.19;
95%
Control=79
0-3index
periodontal pocket
depth
bleeding index
involved
AOR=5.14;
birth
0.018for
95%
are
risk
Author/publication
Country
year
Grandi et al , 2010
Argentina
[23]
Sample
Definition
size
periodontitis
of
Confounding
Outcomes
factors
OR/RR(95%CI)
Case=53
bleeding index of 0-
Control=79
periodontal pocket
depth
involved
Pocket depth
Conclusion
0.018for
bleedingindex
are
risk
birth
Kukkamal
et
al
India
2014 [24]
Case=100
PPD4mm
Yes
Control=100
60%=7-9mm
(p<0.001).
(x 92.8,
p<0.001).
There
was
significant
co-
relation
between
Periodontitis
and
Jordan
2009 [25]
Case =148
Control=438
>3 mm
Yes
The
severity
periodontal
1.59, 2.61)
diseases appeared
to
extent
of
be
associated
with
odds
and
increased
of
PLBW
delivery
Smitha.K, et al, 2013
India
[26]
Case=50
CAL>3mm
Yes
Control=50
periodontitis
is
significantly
associated
with
PTLBW
Mumghamba
Manji, 2007 [27]
and
Tanzania
Case= 150
Control
223
PPD>4mm
=
bleeding
or
30%
examined surface.
0f
Not listed.
No
significant
association
found
was
between
Periodontitis
and
preterm birth
10